I also get "But all the big US tech companies do it too.."
Frankly I would much rather that all my private data/whatever go to the hands of the NSA and/or CSE, GCHQ than the Ministry of State Security in Beijing.
At least I have a moderate level of confidence in my actual free speech rights, civil rights and legal rights in the US and Canadian legal systems.
Every domestic Chinese company with "cloud" based whatever is legally obligated to set up a database replication export to the MSS. With active engineering cooperation to make it work correctly.
If the thought of stalking my social graph, whereabouts and interests didn't outright creep me out, I would be more comfortable with something Chinese than American.
I am not a person of interest to China - even if I do have anti-CCP sentiments, I have zero influence on them so it's not worth their time nor resources to enact extrajudicial punishment on me. Xi doesn't give a shit what some random schmuck in a Western country thinks about him. I'd have to be very influential for them to give a shit about me, at which point I'd have many reasons not to use social media (whether American or Chinese) anyway.
I would be more of a person of interest to my local government (which - as most Western governments - are a puppet to America) because if anything, I have at least some influence/leverage on them in the form of voting and generally being involved in the local community/industry, and they would need much less resources to punish/intimidate me if they so desire.
First, please do not read anything that follows as me accepting TikTok in any way, shape, or fashion.
As a non-Chinese citizen, what exactly can the MSS do to you with all of that data? I would be much more concerned with the gov't that had authority over me having that data. I'm guessing a Chinese citizen doesn't care one wit about what the NSA/GCHQ/etc knows about them either.
- Use compromising info about you to provide China IP from your employer, and/or betray your country
- Use compromising info about a family member to force you to provide China IP from your employer, and/or betray your country
- Use compromising info about you to force a family member to provide China IP from their employer, and/or betray their country
- Use info about you to force your employer to fire you in case you have held anti-China views
- Use info about you, if you've held anti-China views, to prohibit companies from getting into contract with your company
- .... and the list goes on and on. Just expand your imagination a little bit, it's not too hard.
CCP can’t do that.
Surveillance by police that have jurisdiction over you is more dangerous than those who do not.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-01-19/china-operations-to-f...
“But the CIA” is not “discuss[ing] it further” either. I’d be happy to discuss it properly. But reddit-like pithy stuff like this is not that.
Oh and China just assaulted and kidnapped protesters in the UK. Like, within the last couple of hours.
China just assaulted and kidnapped HK protesters in the UK.
However, they can absolutely use the threat of disclosure of sensitive information to blackmail or otherwise coerce someone. The threat (real or perceived) many times is worse than the reality.
I’d say they each have the capability to cause harm, but the incentives/motivations/safeguards that might drive (or inhibit) them to do so are drastically different.
This is just as much a problem in the US.
The PRC has a bit different motivations/incentives and theirs are not aligned with a perceived U.S. national security interest.
Whether you and I agree with the US national security apparatus's mission, in my opinion, it is at least more oriented towards safeguarding/promoting the US’ self-interest.
That’s not to say I agree with all of its actions, just trying to explain what I mean when I say there is difference in motivations and incentives.
> Nothing happens, don't get arrested, don't go to prison. (Obviously, you can't do something stupid like 3 percenters/proud boys and make overt death threats, or actively coordinate real world attacks/actions like the Jan. 6th attack on the capitol)
> Go criticize Xi Jinping and the CCP and the Chinese government in a location where you're subject to domestic Chinese law
> Go to prison camp.
Same for Assange.
Retaliation for protected expression happens all the time in the USA.
They can they just don’t need to. They can just disappear you. There’s documented evidence of the Chinese gov torturing, defiling, political dissidents but you’re worried about parallel construction from the NSA.
As a reminder, for parallel construction to work you need to have actually done something illegal, which the NSA then backtracks to build a case against you. For the Chinese gov to throw you into an unmarked van and press you into slave labor all they need is to tell someone to do it.
These aren’t even close to the same.
You are incorrect.
It's crazy to see americans so affraid of China when you do everything people complain of China doing.
I will never claim that the United States or its government is blameless, but this claim is so over-the-top I don't even know where to start.
If you'd please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules when posting here, we'd appreciate it.
I have a thousand times more confidence that I can engage in political activity, speech, investigation/journalistic related activity or religious activity in my personal and professional life, and not go to prison for it, in the US/Canadian constitutions and legal systems.
If your Cambodian/Colombian/Panamanian sure, do everything you can to ensure the US gov doesn’t get access to your data if you fear we’ll help your gov kill and imprison you at will, (if that’s even really a thing) but here in the US, it’s not a concern and you’re acting like it’s the same.
We had enormous protests in 2020, aside from those who actually committed real crimes very few people were arrested. Additionally none of them were turned into political prisoners who had to do slave labor.
Tiktok has better content, the fyp learns what you like and so it surprises and delights. I think american social media has been overly focused on the top 1% of content producers and advertisers, so the consumer experience has languished at their expense.
TT is really a consumer-first design, and users get visibility even without followers - it actually connects people so it feels a lot less like shouting into the void. It's cool to find a good post from a stranger that nobody has liked or commented on yet - liking that feels impactful to that person. American social media pretty much only shows you stuff from who you follow or advertisers, so any interaction you have is easy to get lost in the noise.
(Also, for whatever reason, I see a lot less angry shouting on TT, whereas twitter feels increasingly like the 2 minutes of hate from 1984)
The ease of posting leads to the content being much less polished: instagram feels like my friends are doing PR to convince the people they know that they are cool/beautiful/successful sometimes - just feels fake and distant to me.
Through TT I've found a bunch of people with the same interests and sense of humor as me, and I enjoy getting little glimpses into their lives and vice versa.
I think some amount of the 'tiktok is evil' meme is propaganda rooted in sinophobia, tech company PR counterprogramming, and american quasi-journalist influencers fearing their platforms are dissolving. About 2/3 of the criticism I've read seems hypocritical (based on industry standards) and alarmist, so it makes me more skeptical of the remaining 1/3.
Facebook and google being cozy with the feds that have power over me scares me a lot more than the CCP - who can do little to impact me directly.
There is an oddly specific reason for this: just about everything that might be controversial is likely filtered away into bubbles.
People will spell gay as gae, use accent marks and spaces, all sorts of things because not doing so will kill your upload pretty much. Tiktok will remove users from being featured if they look abnormal or ugly or low quality, afaik.
Also, not sure how attractiveness correlates to tone.
P.S: I am not saying they are sufficient.
But if you want something to worry about as an individual, consider China's increasing global reach and whether the CCP could at any point use their massive reach to systematically make life less pleasant for you if you express views contrary to the party's.
I won't use it and have no interest in it. It just seems like another noisy app filled with misinformation but also poses a real risk at a geopolitical scale. But on the other hand, I get why people just want to connect with other humans and see a skateboarding dog.
2. They push you to engage with that content, leaving comments and sending messages.
3. They have the capability to make you watch content that they know you'll like with the express goal of getting you to react to it.
4. TikTok videos are often recorded in personal spaces, giving insight into individuals' lives and leaking personal information (partners, children, pets, etc.).
5. The app itself can collect information about you and your device, including any information it may have access to you through overly-broad permission collection.
2+3. Why should I worry that a company is serving me stuff I actually like in hopes I'll interact with it? Isn't that the social contract of digital advertising, except TT is actually delivering?
4+5. That's just table stakes for the industry.
"Table stakes" and "a tool for surveillance" are not at all mutually exclusive. Which is all the more reason to be concerned about Mudge's suggestions that foreign bad actors were employed at Twitter. Make no mistake: social media is a tool that can be used for malicious purposes.
I get annoyed with the "but facebook does it too" argument as well. I don't really like throwing around the "foreign country disinformation campaign" accusations, but whenever tiktok comes up on this site it's hard to imagine regular people saying some of the things that are said about why it's "no less trustworthy" than american social media companies.
Even with this article, people will respond with "well, they probably weren't surveilling me because I don't have anything to hide." And then I show them the story about the cops that used social media to track a woman who went across state lines to get an abortion, and they get really mad.
Monitors are horizontal. Televisions are horizontal. People's EYES are horizontal. All of those garbage tiktok videos are vertical.
No. Under no circumstance - NO.
smartphones are vertical
Also if a video is showing a single person (standup comedy?) vertical can show them closer, as people (mostly) are vertical.
But yes, for a full movie, where you have horizontal camera movement, a vertical screen gives too little orientation for following the movement.
In painting and photography horizontal and vertical coexist for millenia. Based on the motive and purpose.
In my experience (sometimes depending on how it's stated but not always) people see these kinds of comments as a commentary on _them_ specifically. It often doesn't matter what your intention is, they just feel somewhat defensive/challenged, like you're accusing them of poor judgement. So they blow the comment off or even push back to make themselves feel better about their decision.
I understand this comment could be seen as pretentious but I sincerely understand why someone would feel defensive. It's very easy to see it as commentary on their judgment and values, especially in a country like the US that is so focused on being individualistic/protecting individual rights. Most people don't want to be accused of not caring about their privacy. It makes them feel shallow and talked down to, once again, regardless of intent.
The cat is out of the box. It must be resolved through a cat exterminator at the highest levels of Gov, forcing Apple and Google to delist this stuff.
Even the best and highly educated citizenry is not immune to this; let alone the rest of USA and the west. Micro actions from individuals wouldn’t be sufficient. No harm meant to cats or any of our furry friends.
If you are, the CCP kidnaps them to take them home for putting a toe out of line.
And by you and I participating in the CCP’s surveillance apparatus, we make it easier for them to pounce on those who are trying to steer clear of the CCP, sadly, the ones who the CCP likes to kidnap and bring home to torture.
It is the one app that I would never allow near one of my devices. Yet, whenever I mention the threat anywhere or to anybody, I get "you are too paranoid" or "but Facebook does it too". Most of the time I just get ignored / downvoted.
Am I missing something? Does the app really have enough redeeming features to warrant the risk of using it?