News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alien Truth by bmitc on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @08:43AM (#33246305)
> The truths of mathematics would be the same, because they're true by definition. Ditto for the truths of physics

These are pretty strong statements for which there’s no arguments provided for but serve as assumptions for the rest of the article. I don’t think there’s consensus among mathematicians, philosophers, cognitive scientist, or biologists on this.

Mathematics is most definitely a human endeavor, and so we can’t really make claims about its existence in the universe independent of humans. I think alien analogs to mathematics are unlikely to match ours. If we are lucky, I think it could be the case that the various structures could be similar, but the likelihood the implementations resemble each other are slim. It’s even a stretch to assume the structures would relate. Even humans do not fully agree on mathematics. There is no “one” mathematics because mathematics is the human exploration of idealized objects using a variety of human logical systems.

And then there’s the possibility that our mathematics and overall perception of reality is shaped by our biology in far deeper ways than we imagine and currently understand.

Re:Alien Truth by LocalH on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:08AM (#33246545)
> Mathematics is most definitely a human endeavor, and so we can’t really make claims about its existence in the universe independent of humans.

I think the idea is that math is not created by humans, but documented by humans. Sure, the specific terminology may be our invention, but there are basic mathematical properties that seem (from our perspective) like they should be universal. For example, whatever names a being has for the numbers 1 and 2, if you take that 1 and add 1 more, you must get 2 (or the "local equivalent") as the result.

My guess is that, if what we call math isn't truly universal, it's probably at least universally true within the realm of physical life, and there's likely some massive causal chain from the root properties of physics itself to the mathematical properties that we call "math". When it comes to raw, untethered "consciousness" (or whatever one would prefer to call it), this may not hold true even in the slightest.

Yes, this comment steps slightly outside what could ever be determined purely by the scientific method at the end. I feel it is useful to do so in discussion, even when that cannot directly enter into research. There are some truths to the larger universe that I don't think the scientific method will ever truly be able to uncover, just due to it's rigor. Some aspects of the universe are just simply not falsifiable, but they're still worthy of discussion with an open mind.

Re:Alien Truth by dTal on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @10:40AM (#33247925)
There is most certainly a massive causal chain between physics and what humans call "math", because everything humans do is determined by the laws of physics. The causal chain leads through millions of years of evolution and tens of thousands of years of culture. "The numbers 1 and 2" are a complex web of analogies that have not actually been demonstrated to "exist" outside of our minds, so evidence that alien mathematicians would have words for them is much weaker than our intuition would suggest. The question that must be answered is "Given the constraint of precisely modelling the world in a useful way, to what extent are all rule-based systems isomorphic?"

Responding to your second point, I'm afraid I can't agree with you that unfalsifiable propositions are "useful" discussion contributions - especially not with an "open mind". The only criterion on which such propositions can be judged is whether they are fun to believe, and that is a very dangerous muscle to flex.

Re:Alien Truth by dagw on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:15AM (#33246621)
I think alien analogs to mathematics are unlikely to match ours.

Almost certainly not, but they're probably isomorphic. And either way if we show them our axioms they will be able to validate our mathematics and vice versa.

The truths of mathematics are of the form 'if A then B'. Even if they don't start at A or even accept A as true, but will should still get B if they assume A.

Re:Alien Truth by Koshkin on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @01:21PM (#33250848)
> they're probably isomorphic

That's a strong statement. I'd probably talk about homomorphism.

Re:Alien Truth by naasking on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:01AM (#33246474)
> I think alien analogs to mathematics are unlikely to match ours.

So aliens won't be able to count? They won't have a concept of zero? They won't have a concept of 1=successor(0)? I find this very, very hard to believe, and a lot of mathematics follows from the structure of the natural numbers.

If you accept evolution by natural selection is a universal law, then I think it naturally follows that ability to count must evolve. After all, it's pretty important to know whether there are 0, 1, or many predators/food/prey/enemies.

Re:Alien Truth by bmitc on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:12AM (#33246581)
I think this is one argument that leads to the idea that the structures could be relatable, if a being could count. But who knows? Our mathematics relies strongly on the logical and axiomatic systems used. Things can get weird real quick with small tweaks to these systems, so it doesn’t seem like a stretch that whatever mathematical analogs aliens may possess may be wildly different. And there’s a lot of developments that our perception of reality is shaped by our biology in ways we barely understand.

There are intelligent beings on Earth that don’t seem to even have analogs to human mathematics, at least that are apparent to us. We can barely communicate with a small subset of animals and plants on Earth. So I am just inherently skeptical of claims that alien thinking will bear any resemblance to human thinking.

Re:Alien Truth by naasking on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:19AM (#33246679)
> Our mathematics relies strongly on the logical and axiomatic systems used.

Yes and no. You don't need more structure than 0 and 1 to describe literally any form of information, and we're using machines right now that use such an encoding. The idea that any organism of sufficient complexity to have any kind of math won't have any notion of 0 and 1 is very implausible.

That said, we certainly won't have the same syntactic descriptions of most structures, but they will certainly be relatable via isomorphisms.

> We can barely communicate with a small subset of animals and plants on Earth. So I am just inherently skeptical that claims that alien thinking will bear any resemblance to human thinking.

But what does that have to do with math? Math isn't about how thinking works, it's about how structures are related to each other. Structures and their relations don't depend on how one thinks. As above, how such structures are described/encoded probably depends on how one thinks (aliens maybe won't use pencil and paper), but the structure being described will be the same and so there will necessarily exist some kind of isomorphism between their "syntax" and ours, as syntax is a projection of the structure.

Even plants have observable behaviour showing a distinction between 0 and 1: they observably move towards the sun when it's shining, and don't move when it's not. This isn't knowledge of "math", but simply to demonstrate that structure is everywhere and life simply must develop some intrinsic understanding of it.

Re:Alien Truth by bmitc on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:25AM (#33246738)
What do you mean by “no”? Computers and information theory most definitely rely on logical and axiomatic systems, and particular ones at that.

Mathematics is also shaped by our thinking, which was my point. I think it’s a strong claim that aliens would even have a “mathematics”.

Re:Alien Truth by naasking on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:40AM (#33246957)
> What do you mean by “no”? Computers and information theory most definitely rely on logical and axiomatic systems, and particular ones at that.

I mean "no" to your implicit assertion that such basic logical and axiomatic systems would not evolve in any alien species capable of mathematics. Any such alien will distinguish true and false, will have AND, OR and NOT connectives, and will understand a form of implication (it's inherent to causality). That's all you need to build an understanding of most of our formal systems.

Yes the particular expression of our information theory and computer science depends on specific syntactic choices which implies a surface dissimilarity, but the underlying structure will be the same even when expressed in alien math.

For instance, an alien species might evolve in an environment in which hyperbolic geometry is more natural (say a species large enough that they can sense gravity directly), and so they develop that geometry first. This will have an isomorphism to our formal model of hyperbolic geometry, and we can then explain Euclidean geometry to them from there.

Edit: > Mathematics is also shaped by our thinking, which was my point.

Yes, but ultimately irrelevant. This drives the pace of mathematical discovery, and what kinds of mathematical formulae, but this is ultimately irrelevant to the fundamentals which underpin this all, which is what this really comes down to.

Re:Alien Truth by illogical_spock on Saturday October 22, 2022 @03:57PM (#33301596)
> Any such alien will distinguish true and false, will have AND, OR and NOT connectives, and will understand a form of implication (it's inherent to causality).

Implication doesn't have anything to do with causality and in fact the concept of implication in mathematical logic is broken. See: the paradoxes of material implication:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradoxes_of_material_implicat...

To simplify, F -> T (true if false) is a true implication so, for example, I can say that "I am the pope therefore it rained yesterday" and, if it rained yesterday, then the implication is true even though I am not the pope. There has been endless grumbling among philosophers and mathematicians because of this kind of paradox but it is an inevitable result of the axiomatic definition of implication by means of a truth table, and there's no way to correct it without also changing the truth tables of disjunction and negation (because A OR NOT B is equivalent to NOT B THEREFORE A, i.e. because of the way disjunction and negation work, false implies true; you will have to work through this on your own and hit your head on your desk very hard, many times, just as I did when I first realised what a mess this is).

In other words, either we accept human axioms of logic, and we have paradoxes of implication, or we don't have paradoxes of implication but then we don't accept human axioms of logic. An alien civilisation may well choose to not accept any axioms of logic that lead to paradoxes of material implication, so they won't have human axioms of logic and, if their formal system is sound, they won't have human logic, and therefore, no human mathematics.

In other words, no, aliens will not necessarily have the same mathematics as humans.

Re:Alien Truth by naasking on Saturday November 05, 2022 @11:27AM (#33482364)
> Implication doesn't have anything to do with causality and in fact the concept of implication in mathematical logic is broken

I disagree, it's seems very obvious that if-then connectives are a crude causal description. Yes, the crude form is problematic because it's crude.

Re:Alien Truth by mjan22640 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @03:06AM (#33258676)
>Math isn't about how thinking works, it's about how structures are related to each other. Structures and their relations don't depend on how one thinks.

All the things you see around you are an outcome your brain processing. That applies to any structures that you abstract from that as well. Math is an exploration of how the brain does that.

Re:Alien Truth by Koshkin on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:12AM (#33246585)
Counting implies the ability to perceive the discrete, but such discreteness may not be obvious to a shapeless creature living in a liquid or a gaseous substance.
Re:Alien Truth by dagw on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:19AM (#33246668)
Most mathematical concepts are far from obvious to humans (lots of people seem to struggle with the continuum hypothesis for example), yet we can still work with them no problem. So even if this shapeless intelligent creature didn't start with discrete mathematics, they'd probably invent it eventually.
Re:Alien Truth by naasking on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:45AM (#33247035)
> Counting implies the ability to perceive the discrete, but such discreteness may not be obvious to a shapeless creature living in a liquid or a gaseous substance.

Is a shapeless creature even logically coherent? Intelligence needed for math requires making distinctions, and distinctions imply structure, and structure is logically incompatible with true "shapelessness".

Re:Alien Truth by caleb-allen on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:29PM (#33249963)
> Is a shapeless creature even logically coherent?

Do you see how your argument is self-defeating?

According to logic that humans have developed, there is such thing as a "shape". But Western philosophers have pondered the innateness of a "shape" or an "object" from very early on (Plato, through Leibniz, beyond).

"Shape" and "logic" are both human constructs articulating "structure", another human construct.

A shapeless creature doesn't need to be "logically coherent" to exhibit intelligence; logic, truth, and structure are features that have emerged from human intelligence. I wouldn't accept the argument that an entity must exhibit the same features to qualify as intelligent simply because humans have.

Re:Alien Truth by naasking on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:46PM (#33250264)
> According to logic that humans have developed, there is such thing as a "shape"

There is such a thing as "structure", of which "shape" is an instance, yes.

> "Shape" and "logic" are both human constructs articulating "structure", another human construct.

Structure is not a human concept. We have particular conceptions of structure, but structure exists, period. 0 != 1, they have different structure. This is indisputable.

> A shapeless creature doesn't need to be "logically coherent" to exhibit intelligence

If you think that reality does not have to be logically coherent, or that that does not necessarily imply that any creatures within reality have to have a logically coherent description consistent with coherent natural laws, then you're talking about a fantasy world of your imagination and I don't think there's anything further to discuss.

Re:Alien Truth by criddell on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:57AM (#33247223)
If we can conceive of shapeless blobs living in a liquid then surely they can conceive of being like us.
Re:Alien Truth by RxVd on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:16AM (#33246636)
>They won't have a concept of zero? They won't have a concept of 1=successor(0)? I find this very, very hard to believe

Most of the world did mathematics for a long time without zero (I hope you know that most number systems like Roman didn't have zero till that eventually came from India, and we evolved to have the current number system). Who knows what direction different number systems might have taken if they didn't come in contact with zero.

Re:Alien Truth by naasking on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:27AM (#33246773)
That's mostly irrelevant. The naturals starting from 1 are isomorphic to the naturals starting at 0, which is why math didn't need zero for so long.
Re:Alien Truth by Koshkin on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:00AM (#33248279)
Not if you take into account the special properties of 0. (Generally speaking, a structure that admits a neutral element with respect to addition is not isomorphic to one that does not.)
Re:Alien Truth by naasking on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:18PM (#33249765)
You are correct, hence why I initially said it's mostly irrelevant. I should have qualified the claim about isomorphism as well. Still, quite a bit of math maps 1:1 without zero, so you can build a common understanding even if they don't have zero.

I also don't think any alien species with which we will communicate will not understand zero. It just seems impossible. Before philosophers came up with zero in formal models, everyone intuitively understood the concept. Every animals knows when they have no food vs. when they have some food. Humans in ancient civilizations also couldn't just take something without paying.

Re:Alien Truth by RxVd on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:13AM (#33248497)
How is it irrelevant to this discussion? Parent proposed that aliens will have zero by posing that question. I gave an example from our own earth indicating intelligent life can manage without zero.
Re:Alien Truth by naasking on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:48AM (#33249214)
> I gave an example from our own earth indicating intelligent life can manage without zero.

Firstly, I disagree that humanity managed without zero. Literally everyone had an intuitive understanding of zero, they just didn't have it in their formal systems that were being studied by philosophers. For instance, try walking walking up to a vendor in Ancient Greece and just taking something without paying.

Secondly, it's largely irrelevant because a lot of math with zero can be mapped to math without zero with no loss of information, so even if aliens used math without zero there would be no trouble communicating as there would still be an understandable formal correspondence.

Re:Alien Truth by authpor on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @10:33AM (#33247804)
> So aliens won't be able to count?

they will see all the numbers in a line and (maybe through something resembling geometric reasoning) just know what the total is without having to slice up the line and count the slices.

Re:Alien Truth by bena on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @10:35AM (#33247847)
Hacker News, the place where you will get told that we are definitely going to invent spacecraft that will be able to traverse the galaxy by solving the light speed issue, the gravity issue, and the radiation issue (among others) but that when we meet extraterrestrial lifeforms, they won't know how to fucking count.

Sorry. That's the one. That's the one that broke me. Jeremy Bearimy

Re:Alien Truth by bmitc on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:06PM (#33249547)
I don't believe we'll solve those issues anytime soon. But for aliens counting, which I think is itself arguable, it is not really under debate here. There's a vast gap between counting and what mathematics is and encapsulates.
Re:Alien Truth by naasking on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:51PM (#33250353)
> But for aliens counting, which I think is itself arguable

I honestly can't imagine how you can reach this conclusion with any rigour. Do you agree that aliens will need to consume some energy source to stay alive, which we will call "food"? Do you agree that an understanding of "there's no food in my environment", "there's some food in my environment", and "there's lots of food in my environment" would be selected for? I certainly hope so, so at the very least they will understand the differences between zero, non-zero and "many".

The only way this wouldn't happen is if the environment is so rich in abundance that there is never any absence of food. But this is impossible, because even single-celled life by necessity will reproduce to consume all available resources until it reaches an equilibrium matching the rate of food production. So any intelligent species will necessarily evolve in an environment of scarcity where zero and non-zero will be implicitly understood.

Since intelligent life will necessarily evolve in scarcity, quantifying the amount of food is a useful trait that would be selected for. This is why we've now proven that numerous "non-intelligent" animals can count, including salamanders, chicks, mosquitofish, honeybees and more. Intelligent life needs to understand where they are, what they have and what they will need in the future. This involves quantifying, aka counting, no way to escape it.

> There's a vast gap between counting and what mathematics is and encapsulates.

Yes, but you posited intelligent aliens that have their own math. The conclusion that they would not understand zero and repeated application of a construction over zero to build non-zero quantities is impossible. It is the very root of building a theoretical structure of any kind, so if they have math of any kind, they have some kind of counting system that will have an isomorphism to ours.

Re:Alien Truth by bena on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @02:23PM (#33251744)
But you believe we will eventually.

And you believe that aliens that can count is something that is "arguable".

You're the dot.

Re:Alien Truth by zhynn on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:15AM (#33248542)
What if aliens have no notion of discrete numbers, what if everything is probabilistic analog math? What about an organism that can see/focus/sense multiple things simultaneously, and a single "thing" is a set. What about a creature whose primary sensing organ is diffuse molecules (smell/taste) instead of sight and use light (instead of meat tentacles) to interact with matter. How might an organism that touches matter with laser fingers and smells the consequences count differently? I wouldn't have the first idea, honestly.

There could be an entirely different paradigm to "counting" and consequently to the fundamentals of maths.

The math that we invented is influenced by our biology and capacity to sense our environment. Our brains and how those brains work with our sense organs. This pattern is likely universal (all life will have methods of sensing their environment and interacting with it), but the methods might be very different.

Re:Alien Truth by naasking on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:53AM (#33249320)
I'm sure you can imagine any kind of alien, but that doesn't make your imagined alien logically coherent or physically realizable and consistent with the theory of evolution by natural selection. Do you agree that these are real, physical constraints that any imagined alien species must satisfy?

If not, then you have to explain how an alien species might develop that is not subject to physical constraints and evolution by natural selection.

If so, then you must agree that any alien must be able to distinguish two scenarios, "I sense some food here" and "I sense no food here". The basic binary distinction is inescapable, and this is the foundation of true/false, 0 and 1, etc.

Re:Alien Truth by jarpadat on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @02:05PM (#33251514)
Consider an alien which subsists on photons, which is a form of life that exists today. We know from heseinberg that the sensing of this food "here" or "there" is nonphysical. Presumably our creature's civilization would require no heisenberg to discover what anyone can see from their own photosensor.

Rather it is the concept of objects remaining in a single place that would require some real mathematical innovation to a creature with no experience of such an idea. And so this distinction of entirely separate logical states, far from being basic or inescapable, is our very human invention. It is useful for creatures like us, who perceive things in one place when they are not really so, who do their computing with sand in a region where it's bountiful, and who encode abstractions as software because doing so in dedicated hardware is more costly.

While it is certainly possible that all intelligent life would have these constraints, there is no particular reason to expect it. What we can expect is that humans will expect others to be too much like ourselves; it's a well-known cognitive defect in our species.

Re:Alien Truth by naasking on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @02:39PM (#33251937)
> Consider an alien which subsists on photons, which is a form of life that exists today.

Plants don't just subsist on photons, there are many other ingredients.

> We know from heseinberg that the sensing of this food "here" or "there" is nonphysical.

I don't what this means. How do you "non-physically" sense photons?

> Rather it is the concept of objects remaining in a single place that would require some real mathematical innovation to a creature with no experience of such an idea. And so this distinction of entirely separate logical states, far from being basic or inescapable, is our very human invention.

Assuming you're talking about some alien made of bosons that aren't subject to the Pauli exclusion principle, you'll note that bosons still interact with fermions in which that principle does apply, so I don't think your argument follows. I admit I don't really understand your premises though so I have no idea what you really meant.

Re:Alien Truth by IIAOPSW on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @07:33PM (#33255519)
>What if aliens have no notion of discrete numbers, what if everything is probabilistic analog math?

0 and 1 are both valid probabilities.

>What about an organism that can see/focus/sense multiple things simultaneously, and a single "thing" is a set.

Its possible, using sets only containing other sets (or possibly the empty set), to construct the integers.

>There could be an entirely different paradigm to "counting" and consequently to the fundamentals of maths.

Systems of mathematical expressions are just like coding languages. The choice is arbitrary, one can always emulate the job of another. Just like how I did with your chosen examples, in principle one can always hack the integers out of whatever system you give me (or hack whatever system out if integers).

Re:Alien Truth by dbsmith83 on Thursday October 20, 2022 @11:53AM (#33276563)
> what if everything is probabilistic analog math?

you said every thing which implies discreteness. Also, probabilities are probabilities of an event (read: something discrete) happening

Re:Alien Truth by geomark on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:44AM (#33249128)
What if aliens did not perceive distinct objects, but rather that everything observable is part of a greater whole? Would they need counting numbers?
Re:Alien Truth by vecter on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:34PM (#33250071)
Counting numbers are such a basic foundational aspect of all life that it's hard to imagine any "intelligent" being not understanding the concepts of 1, 2, 3, etc.
Re:Alien Truth by naasking on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:55AM (#33249352)
You will have to explain how this property might be selected for by evolution by natural selection before I can even understand what you're suggesting.
Re:Alien Truth by rendall on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:32AM (#33246843)
> there’s the possibility that our mathematics and overall perception of reality is shaped by our biology in far deeper ways than we imagine and currently understand.

Almost certainly true. We as evolved creatures do not perceive objective reality, but only enough reality as to enable our ancestors to survive our very niche environment (niche relative to the entirety of the universe). Our science and mathematics model only our perceptions of reality, and not reality itself.

It is folly to assume that an alien, evolved along an entirely different set of initial conditions, would share our perceptions of reality. Our mathematics, modeling as it does our perceptions, serves human needs and perceptions only.

Re:Alien Truth by pattt on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:31AM (#33246838)
Fully agreed, the way I'd approach this would be that the said mathematical proofs about certain truths "by definition" rely on human logic as the main building block and substrate. Logic is a human basis of agreeing which seems necessary evolutionary. Counting and separating observable objects turned out to be quite necessary for survival as well. Hence this statement seems to imply that aliens would need to have a corresponding logic reasoning system and observational abilities. If that was the case perhaps there would be a strong inclination to believe that the isomorphic reasoning would be deduced.
Re:Alien Truth by mr_mitm on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:15AM (#33246624)
> Even humans do not fully agree on mathematics. There is no “one” mathematics because mathematics is the human exploration of idealized objects using a variety of human logical systems.

Maybe not in its entirety, but I find it hard to imagine that any civilization as advanced as ours (let's say a civilization that manages to harness nuclear fission, just to set a baseline) will not come up with concepts such as prime numbers, real number, complex numbers, calculus, etc. If they do that, they will inevitably find the same structures we found using function theory. They will know about differential equations and prove similar theorems about them as we did. And the Pythagorean theorem is a universal truth that holds everywhere.

Re:Alien Truth by lostmsu on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @10:37AM (#33247875)
In that list prime numbers might not be a thing.
Re:Alien Truth by lmkg on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:06AM (#33248372)
> real number, complex numbers, calculus, etc

Some humans believe that the prominence of real numbers is a historical accident. It seems quite plausible to me that a human society, much less an alien one, would go down a mathematical evolutionary path based on the constructable numbers and the computable numbers.

Regardless of whether we eventually find the same structures, there are things that we might consider basic which they find esoteric and vice-versa.

Heaven forbid we encounter an alien civilization that discovered an O(log n) algorithm for integer factorization before they invented steam power.

Re:Alien Truth by bmitc on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:20PM (#33249802)
> Some humans believe that the prominence of real numbers is a historical accident.

That is a great point. The continuum is contentious and pretty highly debated philosophically.

I also encourage people interested in that to also learn about smooth infinitesimal analysis. Just a small tweak in the underlying logic and model yields unique mathematics and questions established assumptions.

Re:Alien Truth by dbsmith83 on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:30AM (#33246820)
> Mathematics is most definitely a human endeavor, and so we can’t really make claims about its existence in the universe independent of humans.

Can you give an example of a mathematical concept which could be different?

I believe that math is universal. We may use models to understand it (infinity, perfect circles, etc.), but the underlying mathematical truth is independent of humans. The same is true for science. There are physical laws which we look to discover. We use models in science to understand them, but the models are not the same as the underlying truth

Re:Alien Truth by rendall on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:40AM (#33246946)
> I believe that math is universal. We may use models to understand it (infinity, perfect circles, etc.), but the underlying mathematical truth is independent of humans.

Humans (probably) perceive and understand a slim subset of reality. We have an illusion of universalism of our perceptions because we perceive nothing outside of them. Also, we are the dominant species of the planet, which gives us a reason to believe that our perceptions are "more accurate" than, say, a bat's.

Personally, I don't think an alien's perceptions and understanding would contradict our own, but if it's given that our perceptions are a subset of reality, then an alien's understanding might include elements of reality that we literally cannot perceive or even understand.

Re:Alien Truth by dagw on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:56AM (#33247194)
All of this is arguments for why our understanding of science and the nature of the universe might differ. It can also explain how our mathematics might evolve very differently and we will have made different mathematical discoveries and do math in very different ways (all of which I agree are very likely). However it doesn't explain how an alien race will look at one of our mathematical proofs that we have proven True and be able to prove that it is False.
Re:Alien Truth by rendall on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:25PM (#33249890)
> However it doesn't explain how an alien race will look at one of our mathematical proofs that we have proven True and be able to prove that it is False.

Where is this coming from? Is this relevant to what I wrote?

Re:Alien Truth by dagw on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @04:03PM (#33253065)
If both their math and our math agree on what statements are true and false then both our maths are functionally the same.
Re:Alien Truth by rendall on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:34AM (#33261191)
Well, sure, because the term "math" already presupposes a lot. There are two possibilities, here:

1) Math describes reality, so human math and alien math are the same thing, just different perspectives of reality and so, ultimately compatible.

2) Math is a language that humans use to describe their perceptions of reality to other humans. Perception is not reality, but a kind of isomorphism or pared-down heuristic, driven as it is by the evolutionary imperative to streamline for survival. Therefore a language that appears to be universal will only make sense to entities that employ the same perceptual framework for understanding, which is to say, human beings.

I agree that something that is "true" in human math will not be directly "false" in an alien math. 2+2 really does equal 4. The question is whether 2+2=4 is relevant or even understandable to an alien.

Re:Alien Truth by DontchaKnowit on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @10:03AM (#33247290)
But see I don't think think what your saying contradicts the above post. If our subset intersects with the alien subset of perception, then we both will have a perception of an underlying truth, and we could conceivably understand the alien models and vice versa because they address the same subject.
Re:Alien Truth by rendall on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:44PM (#33250227)
UP said that mathematics is universal. I believe it models only our perception and understanding, which are informed by our biological, evolutionary imperatives.

Reality itself is beyond us. All that we have at our disposal are our perceptions, which is what we are modeling when we "do math". Mathematics is not universal, it's a language that we use to communicate what we perceive to other humans.

It's speculative, whether an alien species, with a perceptual and cognitive system evolved entirely elsewhere under other pressures, would have an understanding that intersects with our subset of reality. I personally think it's unlikely. What that would mean is that we wouldn't be able to communicate, never mind trade technology and mathematical ideas.

Re:Alien Truth by dbsmith83 on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @02:04PM (#33251500)
> It's speculative, whether an alien species, with a perceptual and cognitive system evolved entirely elsewhere under other pressures, would have an understanding that intersects with our subset of reality. I personally think it's unlikely. What that would mean is that we wouldn't be able to communicate, never mind trade technology and mathematical ideas.

I mean, maybe, but this is conveniently unprovable, much like the flying spaghetti monster, since you are saying we could not communicate because our slices of reality don't intersect. I disagree and think that most likely we would live in a reality that was largely the same, but I guess we'll never know!

Re:Alien Truth by rendall on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @09:29AM (#33261831)
> this is conveniently unprovable

Perhaps. I was responding to the assertion that Mathematics exist independently of biology or perception of reality which is at least as unprovable

Re:Alien Truth by Koshkin on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:06AM (#33248366)
> I believe that math is universal

The only thing that is "universal" is Nature itself. Mathematics, on the other hand, is a reflection of Nature in the human mind; or, put differently, it's Nature's language we humans are capable of understanding. It is therefore conceivable that other creatures, far removed from us, could "hear" a language that is just as far removed from ours.

Re:Alien Truth by agent008t on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:18AM (#33246663)
The statement that "the truths of mathematics would be the same, because they are true by definition" is correct. Mathematics exist independently of biology or perception of reality. It is just a collection of arbitrary abstract definitions and what follows from them. The alien species may come up with different base definitions that they find more useful or interesting. But they would derive the same conclusions as we would if they were starting from the same definitions and applying the same abstract rules.
Re:Alien Truth by bmitc on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:29AM (#33246808)
> Mathematics exist independently of biology or perception of reality.

Is there a “proof” of that? How could a proof exist? You’d probably win several awards if you had one.

> It is just a collection of arbitrary abstract definitions and what follows from them.

… created by humans.

Re:Alien Truth by dagw on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:52AM (#33247129)
Is there a “proof” of that?

It's how we define the concept "mathematics". If a result was dependant on "biology or perception of reality" or anything else outside its defining axioms, it wouldn't be mathematics.

Re:Alien Truth by bmitc on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:01PM (#33249470)
I'm sorry, but I just disagree that that's how mathematics is defined and that it doesn't depend on our biology and perception, because we are making those definitions.

A book I might recommend and that I'm going through at the moment is Where Mathematics Comes From: How the Embodied Mind Brings Mathematics Into Being by George Lakoff and Rafael Nunez. The origin and meaning of mathematics is strongly influenced by cognitive sciene, and thus biology. I've been downvoted, but this is not a totally novel or off the rails idea. It is basically accepted in robotics that embodied cognition is how you get a robot to understand and perceive its environment. Where do you think that idea came from?

Re:Alien Truth by dagw on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @03:12AM (#33258720)
A book I might recommend and that I'm going through at the moment is Where Mathematics Comes From: How the Embodied Mind Brings Mathematics Into Being

I haven't read that book, but I did just read the wikipedia page for it, for what it's worth. Based on that I feel it's more that they're arguing that the path we've taken and the metaphors we've used while exploring our way to our current understanding of mathematics is based on our biology. Our biology has greatly affected the order we've discovered things and how we understand those thing and how we actually 'do' math day to day, and all that I agree with. It's also very likely that aliens will have taken a very different path and have very different metaphors and proofs for understanding and doing their version of what we call mathematics. Because of this it might very well be very difficult for us to initially understand each others mathematics.

Indeed looking through human history our philosophical understanding of mathematics fundamentally 'is' has changed many times. Yet mathematical truth's we've found along the way have always remained constant (barring errors in calculation or reasoning) even as our understanding of mathematics has changed.

I believe that once we gotten passed all that both us and the aliens will find that, at the core, we both agree on what is "mathematically" true.

I will however also concede that some of the arguments in this thread has made me slightly less sure than I was before, so that is something I guess.

Re:Alien Truth by rendall on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:51AM (#33247126)
> Mathematics exist independently of biology or perception of reality.

Even the concept of "number" itself is almost certainly an artifact of perception that enabled our ancestors to survive our niche, planetary environment, and not an inherent feature of objective reality.

Aliens, evolved to survive in another environment entirely with a different set of initial conditions, almost certainly would not have the same, nor even any, understanding of "number".

Would we consider such aliens a civilization or some kind of insensate "process"?

Re:Alien Truth by DontchaKnowit on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:57AM (#33247205)
Um no.

I'm so over this deconstructionist "reality is your perception" line.

Numbers are a thing. In fact they're one of the most basic observable things about the universe. And the concept if a number holds up all the way down to the quantum level. I.e. space and time are discrete and therefore space and time can both be COUNTED. Counting is literally one of the most basic and early achievements of human cognition and were gonna act like we just made it up?

Absolute silliness.

Re:Alien Truth by bmitc on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:15PM (#33249691)
> I'm so over this deconstructionist "reality is your perception" line.

What makes you completely reject that? I don't think it has as much to do with deconstructionism as it does embodied cognition. We keep learning more and more about how biology and physiology and evolutionary pressures affect and inform cognition and thus perception. I was recently reading about how there have been scientific studies that seem to suggest that certain animals seem to experience time differently that we do. So you could say "time is a thing", but yet, it appears that it is not the same thing across lifeforms. There are animals that sense gravitational and electromagnetic fields, something we cannot do. Would it make sense to them to say "all beings can read these fields because we do"?

I think the problem is that it is all too easy to fall into the trap in thinking that alien lifeforms would be like us. There's a multitude of evidence of that here on Earth in the variety of life, despite even coming from the same origin.

Re:Alien Truth by rendall on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:22PM (#33249842)
This is a great rebuttal, and gestures towards what I was getting at. Thanks.
Re:Alien Truth by Koshkin on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @01:18PM (#33250808)
> There are animals that sense gravitational and electromagnetic fields, something we cannot do.

That actually proves the fact that reality is not simply someone's perception. (We humans do not perceive these fields, and so it took scientific advances for us to discover them as part of the objective reality.)

Re:Alien Truth by DontchaKnowit on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @08:52PM (#33338327)
Yes, thank you. This line of reasoning is so painfully flawed and in a lot of cases outright dangerous or unhealthy.

There is an objective reality that exists beyond our perceptions. But our perceptions are based on that objective reality to some extent. We're not just making shit up. That doesn't make any sense.

Re:Alien Truth by rendall on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:21PM (#33249812)
> "reality is your perception"

You literally imagined what I meant so vividly that you made up a quote.

Try responding to what I actually wrote, and if it's unclear, asking with some humility.

I'm not even sure what your objection is, exactly. Nothing you wrote contradicts what I wrote.

Re:Alien Truth by caleb-allen on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:33PM (#33250056)
> I'm so over this deconstructionist "reality is your perception" line.

Kant would have a field day with this statement

Re:Alien Truth by slibhb on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:32AM (#33246851)
While it's true that there's no consensus on this topic, that doesn't imply that people can't make claims one way or the other. In fact, the claims that the essay makes (Platonism) are very commonly made.
Re:Alien Truth by adrianN on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @08:59AM (#33246450)
I'm pretty sure that any sufficiently advanced species that does any kind of mechanical engineering will have maths that is homomorphic to analysis.
Re:Alien Truth by exitb on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @08:59AM (#33246458)
Isn't the basic math largely driven by attempts to understand and quantify the world around us? In such case, it depends on more universal concepts like distance, time, speed, acceleration etc. Concepts which I would imagine to be familiar to any intelligent being that takes a physical form. I can't imagine an alien wondering about a period of a pendulum and arriving at an answer that's really different from ours.
Re:Alien Truth by p0pcult on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:25PM (#33249884)
Re:Alien Truth by tambourine_man on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @08:52AM (#33246380)
Yeah, lots of strong baseless assumptions in the first paragraph made me stop reading.
Re:Alien Truth by cloogshicer on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @08:50AM (#33246372)
Fully agreed.

These beliefs you quoted from the article, which unfortunately most people don't even recognize as beliefs, form the basis of the dominant religion of the western world (scientism).

The worrying thing is that the majority of people who believe in this religion don't even realize they are believers.

Re:Alien Truth by gregmac on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:36AM (#33246903)
Science doesn't have "facts" or "truths". It is based on falsifiability: for a theory or hypothesis to be considered scientific it must be able to be tested and conceivably proven false.

This is the key difference from religion, which has no such "falsifiability" equivalent.

The closest thing to "beliefs" is probably an individual following which of several competing theories is most likely correct -- but there's always the underlying basis that any of them might have evidence showing they're incorrect at any time, and one's view should adjust as a result.

Often this comes in the form of deferring to other people or a consensus view, which could be construed as "faith" but is different: If you asked me how the universe exists, I'd say the big bang theory is the best answer we have, but I don't understand enough about the underlying science to explain why nor can my brain comprehend the reality of it. I have no loyalty or allegiance to this view, though; I could be swayed to another theory if the big bang is ever proven false or if a better theory arises.

Further reading: https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2015/11/why-scie...

Re:Alien Truth by bmitc on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:02AM (#33246480)
If I am not mistaken, this is similar to what Feyerabend seemed to be on about.

https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/cross-check/was-philoso...

Re:Alien Truth by simonh on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @10:10AM (#33247394)
The thing that differentiates science from religion is repeatability. With religion everyone has their own opinion, people out of contact with each other come up with radically different religious beliefs and there is no way to bridge between those beliefs. If we forgot everything we know about religion, in a thousand years we might rediscover religion again but they'd be entirely different religions from what we have now.

With science it doesn't matter who does a given experiment, anyone else doing the same experiment will get the same results. There's no scope for disagreement about verifiable scientific facts. Just do the experiment and find out. If we forgot everything we know about science, in a thousand years if we rediscovered science, very quickly we'd rediscover all the exact same facts about the world again.

Re:Alien Truth by pfortuny on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:49AM (#33247089)
I guess he was thinking of arithmetic.

In any case, any model which includes infinity (and Peano arithmetic already does) is pure convention and unconsciously assumes a lot of things.

Finitary induction may make sense as something "universal". Further than that, we are making things up as we go (and I am a professional mathematician). The fact that they work to solve real problems does not make them more real.

Re:Alien Truth by illogical_spock on Saturday October 22, 2022 @08:49PM (#33303534)
More to the point, our mathematics work to solve real problems up to a certain point. For instance our mathematics have not yet been able to identify polynomial-time solutions to problems in the class NP and it's possible that this is exactly because our mathematics are inadequate to express such solutions, if such solutions do exist (and Donald Knuth, for example, believes they do). In which case we'll never know whether P = NP (or we will, but it won't be any use, similar to what Knuth, again, suggests).

It is a tautology that the famous incompleteness results in mathematics and computer science are the result of the axioms of arithmetic used to derive them. Would Gödel be able to derive his incompleteness result without Peano's axiomatisation of arithmetic? Not really. Arithmetic is axiomatic and our axioms of it are arbitrary and ad hoc. Because they're axioms. Who says aliens would come up with the same ones?

There are huge assumptions made in this thread that only indicate the brief time that the contributors have given to thinking about all this stuff. If you think about it for a couple of minutes, sure, it all feels very natural. Zero, infinity, division, mathematical logic, set theory, etc. But if you think about it a bit more, and then do a bit more than think, and go read about it, it's obvious that those are just the ideas that we chose to go with, not the only ones that exist, and certainly not the only ones proposed by mathematicians, logicians, computer scientists and philosophers over the years. For instance, Hilbert was a finitarian, division doesn't work with zero, zero doesn't work with division, dividing an infinity multiplies it, material implication leads to counter-intuitiveness paradoxes, set theory with only the membership relation leads to paradoxes, etc etc etc. Mathematics is full of unnatural holes that need constant patching up, and there is nothing to say that it is in any way, shape or form "real", let alone universal as so many people in this thread seem to be saying.

Re:Alien Truth by p0pcult on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @10:11AM (#33247409)
I also take issue with the author's assumptions. Consider the case of AIs trained to identify new variables in a system of pendulums:

https://cosmosmagazine.com/technology/artificial-intelligenc...

Different truths that describe the same system.

Re:Alien Truth by authpor on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @10:32AM (#33247787)
but mathematics is founded upon logic, which isn't not somethign typical mathematicians encounter in their formal education.

computer science, on the other hand, is somewhere in between math and logic (IMO).

alas, logic is philosophy... which is on a 'higher' academic rung up the ivory tower of european centered civlization (at least from my perspective in a outer-tier/colony of the academic (sub)institution)

Re:Alien Truth by sovande on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @10:51AM (#33248135)
Somethings in mathematics are constant, both here and on alpha centauri, like the circumference of a circle divide by its diameter is Π or the hypotenuse squared is the sum of each leg squared in a right triangle etc.
Re:Alien Truth by lmkg on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:02AM (#33248302)
But neither of those facts are true in non-Euclidean geometries like Spherical Geometry or Hyperbolic Geometry. The jury is still out on whether the universe is flat or has some sort of curvature. Meanwhile spherical geometry is fundamentally useful because we live on a sphere, not on a plane, and it is more accurate at modeling the 2-D space that we navigate in.

My point being, assumptions get baked-in to systems in surprising ways. Even something seemingly-objective like math. Especially when you're using it as the basis for communication, then what counts as "basic" or "fundamental" or "standard" reflects a perspective, not a fundamental truth.

It's likely their mathematical systems would eventually reach the same conclusions as ours, but the prominence or significance of fields or results (like circles and triangles) might be radically different. Even though we view those components as absolutely fundamental, it's possible an equivalent system could be built from different primitives.

Re:Alien Truth by carapace on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:18AM (#33248605)
I think mathematics could be defined as that part of philosophy which is self-evident and universal. The value of Pi isn't contingent?

Aliens may have different biochemistry, but it would be made from the same chemical elements as ours. Likewise their formal systems may be wildly different from ours, but they will still be based on form (even implication is ultimately a very simple formal structure. Math doesn't even require causality as a prerequisite!)

Last but not least. many people (Kurt Gödel among them) believe that mathematical thought is actually perception of real phenomenon in a "higher" plane of reality, which, if true, seems to me to imply that alien mathematicians would be perceiving the same phenomenon as humans, literally. In this view, the "truths of mathematics" are literally the same "objects" for them and for us.

Re:Alien Truth by rewgs on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @04:35PM (#33253514)
> There is no “one” mathematics because mathematics is the human exploration of idealized objects using a variety of human logical systems.

But isn't the whole point to to do our best to bypass human-centric systems of understanding, and arrive at the "core truth" of the matter? Whether that's possible is another matter, but even if it's not possible, surely it's something that can be theoretically approached, and I would wager is precisely what PG means by "one mathematics."

> And then there’s the possibility that our mathematics and overall perception of reality is shaped by our biology in far deeper ways than we imagine and currently understand.

Yes, but also no. Consider some first principles:

-We have every reason to believe that any and all life would not live forever, or if the life in question is "intelligent" (a nebulous/human-centric term, for sure) would at the very least conceive of other things not lasting forever (such as stars, or even the universe itself [or, if you want to be really generous, "this current iteration of the universe"]). -Therefore we can reasonably assume that all "intelligent" life in the universe would understand the concept of scarcity (either via finite lifespans/time, food/energy sources, both, or something else), non-infinity. I'd go so far as to say that any life form that doesn't understand its own mortality or other such limits should be not be considered "intelligent," at least for the reasons of this discussion. -Therefore we can reasonably assume that said intelligent life would somehow conceptualize a binary state (you're either alive or you're not, you either have access to an energy source or you don't, etc), and consequently would somehow or another understand the concept of "zero," "nothing," etc, as well as its opposite, "something." And from there, would necessarily discern the differences between two states of "somethings" (the state of "something" that is "one" is different than the state of "something" that is "two").

I know I'm using a lot of loaded terms here -- "reasonably," "assume," "discerning" -- but just like we look for life by looking for the markers of life that we know were necessary for Earth (carbon, water, etc), we can look for intelligence that exhibits the properties that we understand it to have. We need some sort of frame of reference, after all, if we are to do anything other than simply flail. If that frame of reference is to be proven wrong, that's wonderful, but until that's the case, I don't think it's unreasonable to assume that the universe's "primitives" would be perceived in any truly, truly different way such that the species' interpretation would cause humans to rethink our own understanding of the universe's "primitives" from the ground up.

After all, conceiving a difference between hydrogen and helium requires being able to tell the difference between one and two (electrons, as well as separate elements themselves). And considering we have every reason to believe that those make up the majority of the mass in the universe, any "intelligent" life (there's that human-centric term again) can be expected to somehow conceptualize that difference, and thus, do something like counting, and thus, approach the same primitives of mathematics that we do. The approach might be different, but what they're approaching -- the very fabric of reality, hopefully as objectively as possible -- must be assumed to be the same (again, that is, until we're given compelling evidence to believe otherwise).

That said, I've never studied the philosophy of mathematics, so I could be talking out of my ass here, this is just the reasoning of a layman after all. If anyone reads this and goes "no you're way off base," I'd love to hear it!