If not, then you have to explain how an alien species might develop that is not subject to physical constraints and evolution by natural selection.
If so, then you must agree that any alien must be able to distinguish two scenarios, "I sense some food here" and "I sense no food here". The basic binary distinction is inescapable, and this is the foundation of true/false, 0 and 1, etc.
Rather it is the concept of objects remaining in a single place that would require some real mathematical innovation to a creature with no experience of such an idea. And so this distinction of entirely separate logical states, far from being basic or inescapable, is our very human invention. It is useful for creatures like us, who perceive things in one place when they are not really so, who do their computing with sand in a region where it's bountiful, and who encode abstractions as software because doing so in dedicated hardware is more costly.
While it is certainly possible that all intelligent life would have these constraints, there is no particular reason to expect it. What we can expect is that humans will expect others to be too much like ourselves; it's a well-known cognitive defect in our species.
Plants don't just subsist on photons, there are many other ingredients.
> We know from heseinberg that the sensing of this food "here" or "there" is nonphysical.
I don't what this means. How do you "non-physically" sense photons?
> Rather it is the concept of objects remaining in a single place that would require some real mathematical innovation to a creature with no experience of such an idea. And so this distinction of entirely separate logical states, far from being basic or inescapable, is our very human invention.
Assuming you're talking about some alien made of bosons that aren't subject to the Pauli exclusion principle, you'll note that bosons still interact with fermions in which that principle does apply, so I don't think your argument follows. I admit I don't really understand your premises though so I have no idea what you really meant.
0 and 1 are both valid probabilities.
>What about an organism that can see/focus/sense multiple things simultaneously, and a single "thing" is a set.
Its possible, using sets only containing other sets (or possibly the empty set), to construct the integers.
>There could be an entirely different paradigm to "counting" and consequently to the fundamentals of maths.
Systems of mathematical expressions are just like coding languages. The choice is arbitrary, one can always emulate the job of another. Just like how I did with your chosen examples, in principle one can always hack the integers out of whatever system you give me (or hack whatever system out if integers).
There could be an entirely different paradigm to "counting" and consequently to the fundamentals of maths.
The math that we invented is influenced by our biology and capacity to sense our environment. Our brains and how those brains work with our sense organs. This pattern is likely universal (all life will have methods of sensing their environment and interacting with it), but the methods might be very different.