News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alien Truth by DontchaKnowit on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @10:03AM (#33247290)
But see I don't think think what your saying contradicts the above post. If our subset intersects with the alien subset of perception, then we both will have a perception of an underlying truth, and we could conceivably understand the alien models and vice versa because they address the same subject.
Re:Alien Truth by rendall on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:44PM (#33250227)
UP said that mathematics is universal. I believe it models only our perception and understanding, which are informed by our biological, evolutionary imperatives.

Reality itself is beyond us. All that we have at our disposal are our perceptions, which is what we are modeling when we "do math". Mathematics is not universal, it's a language that we use to communicate what we perceive to other humans.

It's speculative, whether an alien species, with a perceptual and cognitive system evolved entirely elsewhere under other pressures, would have an understanding that intersects with our subset of reality. I personally think it's unlikely. What that would mean is that we wouldn't be able to communicate, never mind trade technology and mathematical ideas.

Re:Alien Truth by dbsmith83 on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @02:04PM (#33251500)
> It's speculative, whether an alien species, with a perceptual and cognitive system evolved entirely elsewhere under other pressures, would have an understanding that intersects with our subset of reality. I personally think it's unlikely. What that would mean is that we wouldn't be able to communicate, never mind trade technology and mathematical ideas.

I mean, maybe, but this is conveniently unprovable, much like the flying spaghetti monster, since you are saying we could not communicate because our slices of reality don't intersect. I disagree and think that most likely we would live in a reality that was largely the same, but I guess we'll never know!

Re:Alien Truth by rendall on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @09:29AM (#33261831)
> this is conveniently unprovable

Perhaps. I was responding to the assertion that Mathematics exist independently of biology or perception of reality which is at least as unprovable