News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alien Truth by dagw on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:56AM (#33247194)
All of this is arguments for why our understanding of science and the nature of the universe might differ. It can also explain how our mathematics might evolve very differently and we will have made different mathematical discoveries and do math in very different ways (all of which I agree are very likely). However it doesn't explain how an alien race will look at one of our mathematical proofs that we have proven True and be able to prove that it is False.
Re:Alien Truth by rendall on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:25PM (#33249890)
> However it doesn't explain how an alien race will look at one of our mathematical proofs that we have proven True and be able to prove that it is False.

Where is this coming from? Is this relevant to what I wrote?

Re:Alien Truth by dagw on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @04:03PM (#33253065)
If both their math and our math agree on what statements are true and false then both our maths are functionally the same.
Re:Alien Truth by rendall on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:34AM (#33261191)
Well, sure, because the term "math" already presupposes a lot. There are two possibilities, here:

1) Math describes reality, so human math and alien math are the same thing, just different perspectives of reality and so, ultimately compatible.

2) Math is a language that humans use to describe their perceptions of reality to other humans. Perception is not reality, but a kind of isomorphism or pared-down heuristic, driven as it is by the evolutionary imperative to streamline for survival. Therefore a language that appears to be universal will only make sense to entities that employ the same perceptual framework for understanding, which is to say, human beings.

I agree that something that is "true" in human math will not be directly "false" in an alien math. 2+2 really does equal 4. The question is whether 2+2=4 is relevant or even understandable to an alien.