Yes. Spending $1k (probably a lot less if you're buying a thousand devices at once) is almost insignificant when it comes to kitting out staff to do their job as well as possible. If you can make someone you're paying $100,000/year just 1% more productive then it's already paid for itself. Plus it's a perk "top of the line VR headset for every employee" keeps people onside (I'm reluctant to say 'happy'; that would be too much).
If the company I work for decided to get all the staff VR headsets for meetings I'd be really cool with that. If we switched to Teams though, that might undo the happy vibes..
I would imagine... really distracting.
VR is goofy, and it'll continue to be goofy. Like... ok so you have an avatar. Are a cartoon? That's a bad start. Are they maybe an unreal meta human that looks like you? Different than you? Like you, but poorly done? Ok whatever let's assume the rendering is fine.
What are you doing in this virtual meeting? Are you standing? Because that would be very weird for a business meeting. Presumably you're sitting irl because this is work, so maybe your avatar is sitting... Do they have a table in the virtual room? Because a meeting with no table is a bit odd for a business setting. But if you're in VR, you probably don't have a table in front of you irl. Or at least not the same table that's virtually in front of you. What does your body language track? What if Carol starts lagging and her avatar starts jerking around? What if your facial tracking gets something wrong and you just have a weird look on your face? Or more realistically your facial tracking is just a pretty simplistic thing that vacillates between neutral and smiling and you need to convey negative emotions?
In snow crash, the thing that made the metaverse work was very strong facial expression mimicry. It's not a terrible argument, but we don't have that. We have fake expressive facial mimicry that looks emotive but isn't actually that nuanced to your own face.
VR Chat for business just seems like a preposterous idea. Especially for older folks.
What this usually means is that startups and 'cool' companies adopt it, and then companies run by older people adopt it because they cargo cult anything successful. That could be enough to drive it to the mainstream. It's worked for lots of other tech and ideas (websites, mobile apps, nosql, agile, etc).
It struck me as goofy at first but I think they had it right, actually. You can join a call like that from almost anywhere. Don't need to dig out a laptop, let alone VR garbage. Airport, walking down the street on the way to another meeting, in the car on speakerphone (like, probably don't do this, but of course tons of people do), whatever, it all works. No "do I have the service they want installed? Is it updated?" No other crap popping up and making noise or distracting you. And phone number plus code had fewer problems than meeting invites for all the hip services.
Maybe not having VR will end up being one of those things that signals either low or high status. I can't imagine C-suite types fucking around with VR except for big all-hands announcements or whatever.
Lowest common denominator applies for critical attendees.
And then you have people with different degree of reluctance, which you have to encourage and train (see the recent post about Facebook/Meta pushing their managers to enforce VR meetings ...
I see this repeated again and again but where are the studies? I totally fail to see how putting a VR headset would make the corporate world more productive.
I'm not a luddite: for example I can clearly see why AR, when I drive my car, can be convenient (say with navigational aids) or can provide safety features. I see the use cases that'd benefit many people.
But a VR headset making people in the corporate world more productive? I mean: it may be the case but it remains to be seen.
Heck, I don't even know: are people supposed to do VR meetings seeing 3D avatars kinda looking like the other persons in the meeting? For I don't see how you could see the real person correctly, knowing that it'll have a VR headset on its head (so it cannot filmed by any camera correctly).
How are facial expressions going to be represented in the VR meetings?
Someone will smile and you'll instead see a 3D model smiling? I'd say if that's the case the chance that there's a productivity gain has to be weighted with the chance that it could also be the biggest flop in the history of flops...
I believe there's work on getting cameras inside the headsets for expressions and gaze-tracking.
I think that's due to a mixture of productivity and employee pain hardly being measurable, and whoever decides the budget for those things is not an actual computer poweruser. I wouldn't see it being much different for VR devices. Unless maybe the head of IT in a company is hyped about that stuff.
Zuck read too much cyberpunk as a kid. The Metaverse is lifted straight out of Snow Crash, they didn't even change the name [0]
Don't underestimate the story telling value of people characters in a virtual space. Consider how much better The Matrix is while they're actually in it.
Anything that could be an email, or a presentation, sure. But if you have to trust what other people in the room are saying, then this won't work.
It's early days, but having very accurate face and hand tracking will be the next big step
I think PCs has merit and could be very useful in some spaces like development, exploring new productivity (with good keyboards) or maybe even prototyping architectural designs etc, but these are too niche for whatever Gates is trying here… for his billion dollar bet to succeed nearly everyone would have to be using his PC product.
- It needs to be light enough to wear 8 hours a day and not disconnect too much from reality, like with XR/AR.
- Input devices matter a great deal and writing on a keyboard - while in the field - will pose a problem, same goes with mouse input devices. The current controllers are too large and slow for productive input.
I have not followed research in this area, but I'm sure that some very smart people are trying to figure out the ideal virtual keyboard for VR.
And I miss them, every time I use those computers. The Keyboard (and mouse, even if the Vi people will probably want to lynch me for that) is still the most efficient input device. That might eventually change through some UI revolution, but all we have so far are UIs with fewer features in exchange for making touch usage slightly easier.
And has only existed for last 70 years of human history. I doubt it'll stick with us.
Remember, it wasn't networked, and the I/O was limited to a crappy matrix printer at best. There was practically no software, and most professionals and managers didn't know how to type since that was a secretary's task.
Also the comparison to early computers a little weird. VR isn't a platform that can scale out to to handle billions of e-commerce transactions or solve computational biology problems. Apples to oranges.
- You're able to visibly instruct and teach physical objects without being physically on-site.
Now apply that to professions like cooking, teaching, repairs, art, entertainment, music, industrial etc.
When I played various games with a wider range of input options, there was a noticeable latency, and the virtual environment did not fully capture my real or intended motions very well.
I think there are possibilities for VR in certain fields, but when it comes to arts and sciences like cooking and music, there are some aspects of the physical world that, to be captured in a compelling and useful way, will require significant progress or significant modification to extant VR hardware and software.
In cooking, there is a tangible, tactile difference in using a cleaver versus a pairing knife, and there is a tangible, tactile difference between cutting a head of kale, versus a large tuna. Likewise, there is a tangible, tactile component to interacting with instruments, and a large part of learning an instrument is developing not just the muscle memory of interacting with it, but developing the fine muscles involved as well.
In both cases, the learning requires the use of the specific instrument, and there is a genuine limitation in practical learning when the medium of instruction and the instrument of instruction is generalized to a set of what are essentially game controllers.
It seems to me the virtualization of physical interactions, without proper and necessary modifications to hardware and software, will leave VR bereft of the instructive capability it is relying on in order to be useful in this business/enterprise context in which it would like to be considered.
I can imagine that VR in general has some applications that are valuable, but this particular article is about the potential of replacing normal voice and video calls with avatars in a virtual conference room.
> these are too niche for whatever Gates is trying here… for his billion dollar bet to succeed nearly everyone would have to be using his PC product.
I don’t think Microsoft / Gates had a “billion dollar bet” that’s comparable to what Zuckerberg is doing with VR and the metaverse.
Meta sells ads on a social network and is using money from that business to subsidize the development of VR applications on the theory that someday meta might make lots of money from VR.
Microsoft sold software for personal computers, made a lot of money doing it, and used that money to fund the development of more software for personal computers. At no point in this early history was there a billion dollar bet.
Xbox?
There are many other professions besides programming.
But in reality, it was just unpleasant to use. I just didn't like having something strapped to my face. Ultimately, 3 monitors provided an adequately immersive experience for learning without the hassle/discomfort of having a headset on. Honestly, it was kind of better anyway.
I suspect that what people will quickly find is that although a VR meeting might in certain respects have theoretical advantages, its just not better enough (or maybe even better at all) to overcome the hassle. I don't want to go into a meeting room and strap on a headset, especially not the headset everyone else has been strapping on for the last month. Comparing zoom to a headset, I'd take zoom.
This has already been deployed in industrial complexes like Volvo/SAAB for teaching engineers in car manufacturing.
But I'll concede that you'll looking at an uphill battle. It's not intuitive to a lot of people what the benefits are until you've experienced it.
https://www.computerworld.com/article/3562374/mac-adoption-i...
https://www.computerworld.com/article/3604601/macs-reach-23-...
And apparently all of the fortune 500
https://appleinsider.com/articles/19/11/12/100-of-fortune-50...
Your model of "just fancy tech companies and startups" is maybe a bit outdated.
It's really not. More permit them now or have some departments or (perhaps acquired) sub-units that use them. Your average office drone and old-corp IT person or developer is still issued a Windows machine, and probably a low-end one.
[EDIT] Broader point remains either way: issuing $3.5k laptops/desktops is very very far from the norm.
Not sure what you want to happen here but I guess we agree to disagree and move on.
I did read them, they're just not very relevant.
[EDIT]
Incidentally, I never even claimed this:
> Your model of "just fancy tech companies and startups" is maybe a bit outdated.
I claimed that those are the only sorts of companies where one can be pretty sure most workers aren't seeing and using lots of mostly-cheap Windows machines. Which is a very different claim from those being the only places that use Macs at all, or are even the only ones that mostly use Macs.
I wrote:
> Including lots of developers—just not the ones at fancy tech companies or startups.
I.e. I'm saying that almost no fancy tech companies or startups are likely to push cheap Windows laptops on their developers, which explains how some people might come to think that organizations in general are generous with equipment dollars for their workers and are sensitive to the costs in lost productivity of issuing shitty devices. This is not the case, even for software developers, in much of the economy outside that bubble.
I work at a very large company that's probably counted here (because the number of Apple devices in the company is not 0), and almost everyone is only supplied with a mid-range Windows laptop, and a cheap Android phone.
VR has applications, but mainstream consumer use is not one of them.
I suspect and predict the killer app is simply greater bandwidth and bigger screens for ordinary video calls. Some marketer will find the right angle and moment to proclaim "telepresence is here!" and the mainstream ambitions of VR will evaporate. All interest will go to "half rooms" where the "other half" of the room is someone else's telepresence half room. On demand, of course.
Gaming will always have some type of VR hardware - that's too compelling not to try. However, beyond gaming the ordinary person does not really need 360 degree immersion for anything unless they are learning something complex and VR is used in the profession they are learning about.
I enjoy looking at friends and loved ones, looking out the window occasionally, taking notes, drinking coffee without a headset in the way, not having a sweaty face or being nauseated.
AR maybe, VR for hours ? No thanks
Today I'm coding by my window, with the sun shining outside - some birdsong audible from the trees in the yard. One of my kids just came home from school, and we chatted for a couple minutes. I had a few (too many) meetings today, but they were all video-calls and for some of the time I could carry on with a current task.
I think the receptiveness of the HN crowd overestimates the utility of this technology. It would probably be used to enslave underlings into being 'present' at the virtual office without pee-breaks for 10-hours every day.
PS: I see everyone else in this thread questioning the idea that we should sit in a virtual-reality world with goggles strapped to our faces all day is getting downvoted. I think people outside the tech-nerd bubble would probably disagree.
I’m coding by the windows with the blinds down, sometimes birds, or worse, church bells (actually, mostly the damn bells) annoy me. I guess it’s nice when my wife pops in, but I could still interrupt my VR session for that.
Not saying I’m in any way into VR, I don’t really see the point yet, but I wanted to give a different POV ;)
This still sounds so bad.
Also, some may enjoy to work from beach in Bali or Swiss mountains.
People take drugs to achieve this level of focus
But remember that a single Telepresence room can cost $60k - $600k, plus an ongoing subscription for networking + management, without the capacity or flexibility of a virtual room. Every meeting room in my office has one.
This is touched on in the article, but remember theres a difference between how individuals and corporations spend money, especially if it can lead to [percieved?] gains in productivity/team cohesion.
https://www.nojitter.com/telepresence-beautiful-and-expensiv...
I'd love if the company sent me just a headset that I put on and I'm "at work".
Performing select activities around design, prototyping etc? Yes, but it's a small market. IMHO FB is betting too much on a pipe dream, considering nobody thinks "hey let's get my enterprise productivity apps from Facebook". Hard, hard sell.
they built sports cars for rich people too before the cheap ones
meta is building toys for people with money, until they get to streamline their manufacturing for the cheap ones
Probably Xbox Work 360^3 would help.
[1] https://www.google.com/amp/s/boingboing.net/2018/05/23/epic-...
I think VR has merit and could be very useful in some spaces like gaming, exploring new worlds (with good graphics) or maybe even prototyping architectural designs etc, but these are too niche for whatever Zuck is trying here… for his billion dollar bet to succeed nearly everyone would have to be using his VR product.