News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Meta Meets Microsoft by robertlagrant on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @09:38AM (#33176792)
Hah yes. 7 people on low-res webcams and one with a 4k Master Chief avatar.
Re:Meta Meets Microsoft by spywaregorilla on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @09:44AM (#33176868)
Or the alternative even. I work in consulting. What would it be like if my team was geared up in VR and the client was not? What would it be like if the client was geared up and we were not?

I would imagine... really distracting.

Re:Meta Meets Microsoft by anonred on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @11:34AM (#33178517)
Isn’t that just the definition of network effect? Meta is clearly betting that at a certain critical mass not owning a VR headset in a professional environment will be like not owning a webcam.
Re:Meta Meets Microsoft by jonny_eh on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @12:20PM (#33179230)
How do I bet that they're wrong?
Re:Meta Meets Microsoft by weeblewobble on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @01:12PM (#33179994)
short $META?
Re:Meta Meets Microsoft by spywaregorilla on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @12:30PM (#33179369)
I think it will come across as unprofessional to join a meeting in vr personally. And triply so if not everyone, or everyone of a certain class is doing it.

VR is goofy, and it'll continue to be goofy. Like... ok so you have an avatar. Are a cartoon? That's a bad start. Are they maybe an unreal meta human that looks like you? Different than you? Like you, but poorly done? Ok whatever let's assume the rendering is fine.

What are you doing in this virtual meeting? Are you standing? Because that would be very weird for a business meeting. Presumably you're sitting irl because this is work, so maybe your avatar is sitting... Do they have a table in the virtual room? Because a meeting with no table is a bit odd for a business setting. But if you're in VR, you probably don't have a table in front of you irl. Or at least not the same table that's virtually in front of you. What does your body language track? What if Carol starts lagging and her avatar starts jerking around? What if your facial tracking gets something wrong and you just have a weird look on your face? Or more realistically your facial tracking is just a pretty simplistic thing that vacillates between neutral and smiling and you need to convey negative emotions?

In snow crash, the thing that made the metaverse work was very strong facial expression mimicry. It's not a terrible argument, but we don't have that. We have fake expressive facial mimicry that looks emotive but isn't actually that nuanced to your own face.

VR Chat for business just seems like a preposterous idea. Especially for older folks.

Re:Meta Meets Microsoft by cwalv on Thursday October 13, 2022 @01:50AM (#33187696)
Remote work in general seems like a preposterous idea many folks .. even after being forced to do it, they can't really wrap their head around how it works, or why some people like it
Re:Meta Meets Microsoft by onion2k on Thursday October 13, 2022 @02:53AM (#33188044)
VR Chat for business just seems like a preposterous idea. Especially for older folks.

What this usually means is that startups and 'cool' companies adopt it, and then companies run by older people adopt it because they cargo cult anything successful. That could be enough to drive it to the mainstream. It's worked for lots of other tech and ideas (websites, mobile apps, nosql, agile, etc).

Re:Meta Meets Microsoft by kortilla on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @12:35PM (#33179447)
That’s a pretty weak bet given that owning a webcam isn’t even expected for meetings between businesses.
Re:Meta Meets Microsoft by yamtaddle on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @12:44PM (#33179566)
A few years ago when video chat was, if you asked tech workers, already the norm for remote meetings, I know for a fact that at least one of the big three management consulting firms still strongly preferred call-an-actual-phone-number voice conferencing.

It struck me as goofy at first but I think they had it right, actually. You can join a call like that from almost anywhere. Don't need to dig out a laptop, let alone VR garbage. Airport, walking down the street on the way to another meeting, in the car on speakerphone (like, probably don't do this, but of course tons of people do), whatever, it all works. No "do I have the service they want installed? Is it updated?" No other crap popping up and making noise or distracting you. And phone number plus code had fewer problems than meeting invites for all the hip services.

Maybe not having VR will end up being one of those things that signals either low or high status. I can't imagine C-suite types fucking around with VR except for big all-hands announcements or whatever.

Re:Meta Meets Microsoft by jayd16 on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @01:20PM (#33180092)
You mean like in real life where people can wear casual or dress clothes? Won't it just be that business cultural norms develop?
Re:Meta Meets Microsoft by spywaregorilla on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @01:30PM (#33180231)
I didn't mean geared up in goofy avatars. I meant rendering themselves in VR at all
Re:Meta Meets Microsoft by r00fus on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @01:54PM (#33180551)
More like real life where you're on screen share but your client is literally phoning it in (because they can't run webex/zoom or they're on the road).

Lowest common denominator applies for critical attendees.

Re:Meta Meets Microsoft by msmenardi on Thursday October 13, 2022 @04:32PM (#33196129)
I imagine the meeting would take place at a level of communication determined by the lowest common denominator. If the client can't do video, then everyone else does audio-only. If they can't do VR, then you all are stuck with a Zoom call.
Re:Meta Meets Microsoft by skizm on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @09:49AM (#33176941)
Wait. Now I want this.
Re:Meta Meets Microsoft by xen2xen1 on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @10:07AM (#33177183)
7 people on low-res webcams and one with a 4k avatar he was using with his wife the night before who's been out of town a lot..
Re:Meta Meets Microsoft by Tepix on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @10:46AM (#33177750)
With Zuck watching.