News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by kaushikc on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @04:18AM (#33160696)
Top 10 Countries with the highest rate of incarceration 2022

United States — 629

Rwanda — 580

Turkmenistan — 576

El Salvador — 564

Cuba — 510

Palau — 478

British Virgin Islands (U.K. territory) — 477

Thailand — 445

Panama — 423

Saint Kitts and Nevis — 423

https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/incarcera...

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by gerdesj on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @04:29AM (#33160766)
Those rates are per 100,000.

That page also notes this shocker but it also quotes itself as a source at one point, so is it a decent source (?):

"The United States leads the world in total number of people incarcerated, with more than 2 million prisoners nationwide ... This number is equivalent to roughly 25% of the world's total prison population and leads to an incarceration rate of 629 people per 100,000"

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by usednet on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @04:40AM (#33160841)
The crazy thing is that mass incarceration is relatively new in the US. Are Prisons Obsolete by Angela Davis was a real eye-opener for me.
Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by bitwize on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @06:24AM (#33161544)
Not even Angela Davis was totally opposed to prisons. She just thought they were for counterrevolutionaries rather than ordinary criminals.
Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by barry-cotter on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @07:09AM (#33161871)
> The crazy thing is that mass incarceration is relatively new in the US.

Indeed. Before the massive explosion in violence and disorder the US pioneered in the 60s the First World was substantially more peaceful. Less need for incarceration with much lower rates of crime.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by mmustapic on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @07:33AM (#33162067)
The higher incarceration rates were caused by the "war on drugs" during the 80s.
Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by barry-cotter on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @11:10AM (#33164280)
US murder rates doubled between 1960 and 1970.

https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/the-u-s-murder-rate-is-...

It took until 1980 for incarceration rates to start their upward climb. Ten years is a remarkably long time for a doubling of murder rates to take to show up in imprisonment.

https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/the-imprisoners-dilemma...

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by pessimizer on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @11:24AM (#33164458)
> It took until 1980 for incarceration rates to start their upward climb. Ten years is a remarkably long time for a doubling of murder rates to take to show up in imprisonment.

This is extremely dubious. The vast majority of people in prison are not there for murder. From a search, 15% of people in prison have a murder on their record. It's not TV.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by mcv on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @04:44AM (#33160859)
Wikipedia has slightly different numbers[0], with El Salvador instead of Rwanda at #2, but the fact remains that the US has the highest incarceration rate in the world. Though it seems to have gone down slightly; I recall that a few years ago it was over 700/100,000.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_incarcera...

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by whacko_quacko on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @04:47AM (#33160888)
Good catch! According to the word prison brief the ranking actually looks like this (incarcerated per 100 000):

El Salvador 605 Rwanda 580 Turkmenistan 576 American Samoa (USA) 538 Cuba 510 United States of America 505

I'd still consider this horrible, but making a point is no reason to use dodgy sources.

From: https://www.prisonstudies.org/highest-to-lowest/prison_popul...

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by TylerE on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @05:04AM (#33161000)
Might be a difference in how people in jail (vs prison) get counted?

Not sure if other systems have a similar distinction?

For non US people: Jail is run by the local (usually county) government and is for minor(ish) crimes like writing bad checks, failing to appear in court, DUIs, reckless driving, things like that.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by KingOfCoders on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @07:19AM (#33161939)
Thanks, didn't know (German), something new to learn each day. Would have used jail and prison interchangeably.
Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by Avshalom on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @09:13AM (#33162954)
More importantly jail is where people are held before they are sentenced/found guilty. They are also yes used for shorter sentences. But you can still be jailed for years before you ever see the inside of a courtroom.
Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by azalemeth on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @04:48AM (#33160891)
It's also worth noting that the rate per 100k people can artificially inflate the numbers for some of those on that list – e.g. the British Virgin Islands has a population of ~30k people and Saint Kitts ~47k, so both some degree of rounding and a large degree of Poissonian-like fluctuation are probably to be expected...
Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by tommiegannert on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @04:48AM (#33160892)
> so is it a decent source (?):

It's just stating that the source said 2M, which combined with the total population yields 629. Nothing wrong with drawing a simple conclusion from two sources. The sources for the prisoner numbers are clearly labeled at the bottom of the page:

https://www.prisonstudies.org/research-publications?shs_term...

https://www.prisonstudies.org/highest-to-lowest/prison-popul...

https://www.prisonpolicy.org/global/appendix_countries_2021....

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by tecleandor on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @04:52AM (#33160912)
Here they quote U.S. Bureau of Justice Statistics from 2020 with around 1.7M of prisoners. That's about 15% lower than that number, but still quite high.

https://www.prisonstudies.org/country/united-states-america

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by bismuthcrystal on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @05:06AM (#33161007)
This is always stated as something bad, but perhaps the US is a violent society and it is doing a good job at keeping the violent behind bars?

A similar argument can be made about health spending: if it's low then we are not doing enough, but if it's high then we are spending too much (i.e. we are inefficient), when in fact we might be allocating more capital to it because we value it more.

Glad to hear any thoughts about this.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by isolli on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @05:14AM (#33161056)
I think both points, while reasonable, are wrong.

If memory serves, the rise in incarceration rates can be traced back to the failed war on drugs, which incarcerated many non-violent (often black) offenders. There is also a tough-on-crime stance, in part due to the fact that US sheriffs and judges compete in local elections, leading to aberrations such as mandatory minimum sentencing.

As for health spending, a lot of the spending can be traced to inefficiencies, and predatory pricing by hospitals, drug companies, and medical device manufacturer. The lack of centralized information for insurance and payments (note that I don't blame insurers) also creates huge administrative costs.

Those are both complex topics, so I don't claim to have captured all aspects, and I may have some of the details wrong, but I would say it's a good first approximation.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by martopix on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @05:12AM (#33161044)
> perhaps the US is a violent society and it is doing a good job at keeping the violent behind bars?

The real question should be *why is the US "a violent society"? I think your post is a good example of what I think the problem in the USA is: the belief that the world is divided up in good guys and bad guys and you just need to lock up all the bad guys. But it's not like that. Violence, including incarceration, brings other violence. Poverty, inequality, ignorance, lack of health support for drug users, all bring violence. The US would definitely have enough money to turn deprived neighbourhoods into less deprived communities, which means less violence. But it doesn't do so for ideological reasons connected to this belief of good vs. bad.

Sorry if I used your comment as an example, I do not mean it as an attack. But do ask yourself, why is the US a violent society and not Switzerland?

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by nverno on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @05:35AM (#33161227)
> Poverty, inequality, ignorance, lack of health support for drug users, all bring violence.

This is certainly not generally true. There are many countries with much greater poverty, inequality, and ignorance (at least measured by education) than the US that have much less violent crime. I'd imagine having more drug users per capita has a significant effect on violent crime everywhere however.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by balls187 on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @10:59AM (#33164135)
Can you provide a source for assertion?

The violence is fueled by two things: income inequality and the prevalence of guns.

Any country with those two factors will have a problem with violence; the fact that the US is the most civilized country among that list (and likely sits atop that list) is what is so damning.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by dsfyu404ed on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @12:26PM (#33165352)
The largest single chunk of the violence is just the settling of drug industry business disputes. If the people doing the shooting had badges and got their paychecks on state letterhead most people here wouldn't blink twice.

Whereas you may lean on an expensive and complicated court system to send an employee of the state to apply violence (or threats thereof) to someone who had wronged you until they right their wrong people in the drug industry has no such luxury since their disputes will not he heard by a court. Likewise they must DIY it. That means home invasions, shootings, etc, etc.

Back before people in these lines of work shot at each other (have you ever tried doing a drive by on horseback with a 6 shooter, doesn't work very well) over these sorts of disputes people would round up friends and beat each other up or people would torch houses.

Bringing our massive illegal economy out of the shadows would clean up a huge fraction of the violence.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by nverno on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @05:55PM (#33169743)
> Can you provide a source for assertion?

I was thinking of Indonesia, only because I lived there for a while, but those are factors in nearly every country.

> The violence is fueled by two things: income inequality and the prevalence of guns.

I don't think either of these are what cause the violence (maybe they throw fuel on the fire as you're saying though). People can be just as violent without weapons, and just as greedy when they are on the top. They just become more dangerous with money, guns, and lawyers.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by armitron on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @05:27AM (#33161166)
Is Switzerland riddled with violent gangs? Is it bordered by failed narco-controlled states that continuously smuggle people and drugs into the country? Does it have big chunks of the population living in inner city crime-infested ghettos?

These are hard problems and can't be imagined away with "The US would definitely have enough money to turn deprived neighbourhoods into less deprived communities, which means less violence".

We saw what well-meaning but supremely naive ideologically-driven policies lead to, in SF and Chicago and Seattle and LA. If that's the world you want to live in, all the best (but it won't be long before you start running for the exit).

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by meigwilym on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @05:41AM (#33161257)
Would you mind sharing sources on what was done and what the (un?)intended consequences were in SF, Chicago, Seattle and LA?
Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by qlm on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @05:39AM (#33161245)
> We saw what well-meaning but supremely naive ideologically-driven policies lead to, in SF and Chicago and Seattle and LA.

Can you expand on this?

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by ch_sm on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @05:45AM (#33161275)
It’s interesting that you bring up theses specific questions. Ask yourself: why is the U.S. riddled with violent gangs? Why is it bordered by failed narco-controlled states? Why do large chunks live in inner city crime-infested ghettos (and why are there ghettos in the inner cities in the first place)? Many would argue that all these are home-made problems. Imprisoning the victims of this system can’t conceivably be the solution, and might in fact only make it worse (mass imprisonment has many bad societal effects).
Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by ClumsyPilot on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @05:57AM (#33161362)
Your government policy has turned your cities into crime infested ghettos. Even diverse and poor countries like India are managing to avoid this problem.

US doesn't have some magical and unique set of challenges, apart from political disfunction, that can't be found anywhere else in the world.

> We saw what well-meaning but supremely naive ideologically-driven policies lead to, in SF

I must have missed something - SF solved the housing crisis, everyone could get a an education and a decent job but crime remained?

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by swman on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @07:32AM (#33162055)
As someone who recently moved to SF downtown is a sh*thole. You see a bunch of high TC Uber/Etc bozos zipping down the road on their scooters avoiding the drugged out zombie who is yelling at people and being aggressive. Unfortunately there are hundreds more of these people, and I’ve been waiting at a red light where a guy just pulled out his liquid ejection port and started peeing on the sidewalk. I need to get on a scooter soon.

In the shadow of the salesforce tower and probably trillions of dollars of market cap, this is what we see? Wtf

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by cestith on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @01:10PM (#33165907)
Chicago, San Francisco, and LA are far from the most dangerous cities in the United States. Why are they your talking points?
Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by Ligma123 on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @05:51AM (#33161323)
>But do ask yourself, why is the US a violent society and not Switzerland?

Glad you asked. First of all who is committing the crimes, USA and Switzerland?

I don't know if there is publicly available data for Switzerland but for the USA there is:

https://crime-data-explorer.app.cloud.gov/pages/explorer/cri...

check the "All Violent Crime Offender vs. Victim Demographics" tables. The numbers are absolute values, so you'd need to calculate the per capita values.

>Poverty, inequality, ignorance, lack of health support for drug users, all bring violence. The US would definitely have enough money to turn deprived neighborhoods into less deprived communities, which means less violence.

Trying to reduce those issues has been ongoing policy in the last years. Yes they are important, but they are not the only factor.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by EdwardDiego on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @06:17AM (#33161504)
Well done on expressing your racism in a subtle manner. As opposed to the previous times you've expressed it like a brick through a window.
Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by parkingrift on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @07:04AM (#33161838)
The FBI is racist and fabricated these stats, as we all know.
Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by attemptone on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @07:23AM (#33161972)
The problem is not with stating the facts. Because facts and numbers have no meaning in themselves.

The problem comes from the things that you're supposedly implying. This isn't entirely your fault, because this line of thinking is brought up again and again. People know what someone is trying to say if someone just pulls up this kind of statistic. Your fault (if it's an honest mistake) is not being aware enough of the discussion around this topic and the lack of articulateness in your comment.

>The FBI is racist and fabricates stats

This, but unironically

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by EdwardDiego on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @07:15AM (#33161906)
If we're erecting dumb strawmen, let me erect one in the shape of the parent comment - African-Americans are over-represented in crime, because they're just like that. Quod erat dumbonstrandum.
Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by parkingrift on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @07:17AM (#33161929)
You do know that there are other demographics than race?
Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by EdwardDiego on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @07:21AM (#33161951)
All of which were mentioned by a grandparent comment, then quoted and commented on as being insufficient to understand "who" is committing crime, by the person I was replying to.

If you can't see what their gist was, well, that's a you thing.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by parkingrift on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @07:25AM (#33161989)
Nope. Grandparent comment asked why the US is a violent society. Absolute top comment on the chain is just outright incarceration numbers. No one asked anything about race until you came along.
Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by Jochim on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @10:02AM (#33163484)
Crime statistics split by demographic are commonly used as a dog whistle by racists. The people posting them typically aren't interested in discussing the reasons behind a particular demographic committing more crime beyond asserting that it's due to inherent traits.

That those statistics were posted as a dog whistle is backed up by the user's other posts.

On Portugal's African colonies:

> The only thing to apologize is to ourselves. We should haver never went there and left you in the stone age.

> All the infrastructure we left you weren't able to maintain, as it happened with 99% of the African countries.

> Total mystery why.

Casual quotation marks around youngsters:

> And now robbing stores is becoming rampant as we can all testify by the loads of videos of "youngsters" entering stores and taking what they want without anyone doing anything.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by EdwardDiego on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @07:57AM (#33175661)
There are none so blind as those that won't see.

I hope you're only playing dumb.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by teh64 on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @08:34AM (#33162583)
"The FBI is racist": ever heard of COINTELPRO? I think trying to undermine the civil rights movement (among others) could be classified as racist, do you not agree?

Also "FBI crime stats" is probably one of the loudest dog whistles, more like a fog horn at this point.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by samatman on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @07:25AM (#33161988)
Your aggressive and inappropriate accusation would be comical if it wasn't so disgusting.

You're the bad guy here. No two ways about it.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by piva00 on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @08:46AM (#33162692)
Ok. What exactly are you trying to imply? It's hard to draw conclusions from your gaps, it's pretty clear that you are saying that young African-American men commit more violent crimes per capita.

What should I draw from this though? That the USA has a violent history with slavery and segregation and those scars haven't been healed, that the government hasn't figured out a way to fix this historical issue?

Or should I draw some other conclusion that I prefer to not type out because it'd be too disgusting to even entertain it?

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by bm3719 on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @10:07AM (#33163543)
Probably the only safe thing to say with these facts in mind is that we haven't found a solution to this problem that both reduces the crime output of those likely to commit it, and also treads carefully across our collective sensitivities surrounding the topic.

Maybe that's an impossible task given those requirements. If it were easy, we'd probably have found the solution by now. We're pretty sensitive about numbers like that after all, to the point that I'm generally reluctant to quote them.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by Jochim on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @10:46AM (#33163969)
> Probably the only safe thing to say with these facts in mind is that we haven't found a solution to this problem that both reduces the crime output of those likely to commit it, and also treads carefully across our collective sensitivities surrounding the topic.

It's certainly the thing to say if you don't feel like actually changing anything.

The main reason behind the disparity in crime demographics become fairly apparent when you compare them to the statistics on poverty demographics. Research shows a correlation between poverty/income inequality and rate of violent crime. It follows that reducing the crime rate, regardless of demographic, is a matter of raising people out of poverty and reducing the level of societal inequality.

> If it were easy, we'd probably have found the solution by now.

Quite frankly, most countries haven't even tried looking for one. Most prison systems only put people through a process that only makes them more likely to reoffend. The insane thing about this is we know that some places are better but we make excuses and refuse to change.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by thanatos519 on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @09:01AM (#33162845)
> the belief that the world is divided up in good guys and bad guys and you just need to lock up all the bad guys.

Reminded me of this quote:

If only there were evil people somewhere insidiously committing evil deeds and it were necessary only to separate them from the rest of us and destroy them. But the line dividing good and evil cuts through the heart of every human being. And who is willing to destroy a piece of his own heart?

-- Alexander Solzhenitsyn

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by boring_twenties on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @01:49PM (#33166452)
OT but does anyone have this quote in what I presume is the original Russian?
Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by luplex on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @05:23AM (#33161124)
The US is probably more violent than other western countries, but I think the real problem are the much harsher sentences for comparable crimes (citation needed).

There's much more of a focus on punishment instead of reintegration. The legality of the death sentence is a clear violation of human rights, for example.

I haven't encountered evidence that would suggest that the US is better at preventing crime than others.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by donkeyd on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @05:42AM (#33161258)
> There's much more of a focus on punishment instead of reintegration.

Yup, this is a cultural thing. In the US, people (in general) want criminals to be punished, they don't put too much value in rehabilitation. It's very different from many European countries which is visible in sentencing.

> I haven't encountered evidence that would suggest that the US is better at preventing crime than others.

On the contrary, there's much more crime in the US than most western countries. Whether this has anything to do with punishment vs rehabilitation is impossible to say though. I personally think that lack of many social services is more to blame. Things like social security, public housing mixed with private, health care, workers rights, et cetera mean less people end up in criminality in the first place.

Recidivism rates unfortunately are extremely hard to compare due to the methods and sentencing being extremely different.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by hnbad on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @10:29AM (#33163788)
"There's more crime" is a meaingless claim unless you define what "crime" is and how you measure how much there is of it. Jaywalking is a crime in some countries. Does a country that criminalizes jaywalking have more crime than one that doesn't if it has any people jaywalking? How do you measure crime which is underreported or not enforced consistently?

If the US has a higher incarceration rate it's extremely likely that it has "more crime" because incarceration is supposed to be a punishment for doing crimes. The question is how the definition of those crimes compares to other countries. E.g. do you consider possession of cannabis a crime because it is illegal on a federal level? Former US President Bill Clinton used cannabis before it was legalized in any US state, so was that a crime?

For a real world case of this nebulous concept of "crime" as an opaque quantity consider immigration: even if they commit fewer violent crimes, it's still entirely possible for an immigrant to be more prone to crime simply because they are subject to additional legal requirements citizens aren't and failing to comply with any of them may qualify as a criminal offense. Just by their legal status they are able to commit an entire category of crimes others can't. Whether you think that is justified or not, they can literally be criminals for behaving exactly the same way as a non-criminal citizen would.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by _trampeltier on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @06:42AM (#33161677)
Also, I think after jail, you are not allowed to vote in most us states. Also to get a job after jail seems almost impossible in the us.
Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by sokoloff on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @07:28AM (#33162015)
Voting is conditioned on not being a convicted felon in some states.

https://www.ncsl.org/research/elections-and-campaigns/felon-...

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by int0x2e on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @07:23AM (#33161974)
You might be interested in listening/reading a recent Planet Money episode (https://www.npr.org/2022/09/22/1124477182/federal-judges-eco...), which explains how for ~20 years or so, many US federal court justices went to an exclusive, all expense paid economics bootcamp, taught by some of the most well known economics thinkers of the time. That sure sounds great in theory - why wouldn't you want to have judges to have a deeper understanding of economics when they can have impact on financial matters?

Well, as it turns out, some of the key ideas taught focused on the rational economic theory, and extrapolated from there to crime and punishment - e.g.: a criminal makes a cold economic calculation before commit each crime, taking into account the expected gain from this crime, the likelihood of getting caught, the expected punishment if caught, etc. - and therefor, if we make the "cost" higher, by opting for harsher prison sentences - crime will become less attractive and therefore happen less.

When the data is analyzed, justices that went through this program appear to hand out harsher sentences to offenders, and often rule in favor of corporations and against government agencies when compared to the control group. The effect is most evident for judges that used to learn more to the liberal side, which is surprising to me, but it definitely is interesting.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by lm28469 on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @06:27AM (#33161578)
> This is always stated as something bad, but perhaps the US is a violent society

Either they are overly violent or overly incarcerating people, both are "something bad"

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by ravel-bar-foo on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @07:02AM (#33161801)
The US also doesn't have mandatory inpatient mental health care (or at least this has been severely downsized since the 1970s). How much of the numbers can be explained by other countries have higher rates mental health care institutionalization, while the US has shifted most of these people to prisons?
Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by ravel-bar-foo on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @07:28AM (#33162012)
I found some numbers: according to Statistica, Europe has 275 mental health 'hospital admissions' per 100,000, whereas the Americas have 41.8. That could be entirely enough to explain the difference in prison populations, but of course one would need data on the length of the average mental health hospitalization. It also doesn't explain the comparison to other regions with lower incarceration and lower mental health treatment rates, which is pretty much the entire rest of the world.

Statistica: https://www.statista.com/statistics/452902/admission-rate-in...

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by lazyasciiart on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @07:51AM (#33162193)
The US also doesn’t have optional inpatient mental health care, for many people. There are simply no beds available, even for people who have been ordered there by a court.
Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by rippercushions on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @07:41AM (#33162126)
For comparison, number #2 on the list (Rwanda) had a genocide involving tens of thousands of people hacking each other to death with machetes, and 26,000 of their 43,000 prisoners were convicted of various crimes related to this genocide. They also like to imprison anybody even vaguely suspected of opposing the current government -- and they still have less people in prison than the US.
Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by pessimizer on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @11:17AM (#33164363)
> 26,000 of their 43,000 prisoners were convicted of various crimes related to this genocide.

This is a general charge in Rwanda, which is a dictatorship still run by the commander of the ethnic army that sparked the genocide by killing the president and massing at the border to invade. They recently imprisoned the guy Hotel Rwanda was about as a terrorist. And like you say, they're still less of a police state than the US.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by denton-scratch on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @09:23AM (#33163049)
> but perhaps the US is a violent society

Perhaps it is a violent society because of a deeply-ingrained fear of violence. Frightened people are more likely to assume a situation is threatening, and respond with violence. And imprisonment is a form of violence; nobody voluntarily takes themselves off to prison on judge's orders. The more likely you are to be imprisoned, the more likely you will risk a shoot-out with cops.

There seem to be a lot of people in the USA that take a strongly retributive attitude to justice: e.g. "Close the prisons, criminals should just be shot like mad dogs".

The purpose of a criminal justice system is to protect the public by enforcing the law, not to embody some moral posturing about the fruits of wickedness.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by pessimizer on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @11:09AM (#33164274)
> perhaps the US is a violent society and it is doing a good job at keeping the violent behind bars?

Most crime pays terribly, being a street drug dealer barely pays minimum wage and involves immense risk. Opportunities for some in the US are so bad that they choose terrible jobs (high risk, bad pay) at far higher rates than people do in other countries. Jobs that, in addition, come at a moral/reputational cost (your family is angry at you, other careers are closed off to you once you have a record.)

> perhaps the US is a violent society

What does this even mean? Of course it is a violent society. This is just a vague innuendo that this violence is impossible to fix and intrinsic to the US; it's just question-begging.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by kevingadd on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @12:14PM (#33165188)
The US is perhaps a "violent society" but our crime rates have been trending down over the last few decades, while spending on prisons has not trended down accordingly. We could be spending that money on valuable social programs.

See https://www.sentencingproject.org/criminal-justice-facts/ and https://www.sentencingproject.org/publications/u-s-prison-po... for some numbers - prison populations massively spiked over the course of a couple decades, but while crime rates have come down massively prison populations have not declined nearly as much.

Based on the number of people in US jails and prisons who are awaiting trial - not even convicted of a crime - or there for minor offenses due to policies like "three strikes", it's hard to argue that massive incarceration is actually what's making us safer.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by bena on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @12:15PM (#33165219)
We can compare spending to outcomes however. The US spends more money for worse overall outcomes than other countries.
Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by theautist on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @01:21PM (#33166048)
I have always thought that the US should lock less people and start handing less harsh sentences, but having lived in the bay area for almost 6 months, I came to the conclusion that the US should lock up even more people.

I understand that prisons don't necessarily fix the crime problem, but the thing we probably all agree on is that fixing crime is not something trivial at all, and until we know the exact causes of crime, and start to tackle them one by one, we need to do something immediate about crime because life here is frankly unbearable. Random shootings, shoplifting, assault, hate crimes, and muggings are all too common here.

I'm unable to even think about starting a family in this environment.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by noduerme on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @05:26AM (#33161151)
Russia doesn't publish its incarceration stats, apparently.

Also, would the millions of Uighurs in concentration camps in China be considered "incarcerated" or is this simply a definition left to non-autocratic democracies?

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by rags2riches on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @05:49AM (#33161308)
The Wagner PMC is recruiting cannon fodder for the war in Ukraine in Russian prisons. The Russian incarceration numbers may be improving drastically as we speak!
Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by trasz on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @05:59AM (#33161384)
Even Zenz and associated media don’t claim there are millions. And yes, even if you add them it still looks much better than US.
Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by areyousure on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @09:45AM (#33163288)
In case anyone is curious, one of the largest numbers claimed by Adrian Zenz is "1.8 million" in the following article: https://foreignpolicy.com/2020/07/01/china-documents-uighur-...

> Since 2017, up to 1.8 million Uighurs, Kazaks, and other Turkic minority groups in the northwestern Chinese region of Xinjiang have been swept up in what is probably the largest incarceration of an ethnoreligious minority since the Holocaust.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by trasz on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @11:13AM (#33164321)
Adding the right minority groups will give you however high number you need, but even he admits it’s not just Uighurs. And the result is still better than US incarceration ratios.

(Or course this about largest incarceration is bullshit too, but hey, he needs to be making money somehow, right?)

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by FriedrichN on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @06:13AM (#33161479)
One would think think detaining a million Uyghurs would equate to incarceration. I certainly do think so.

But on the other hand, if you need to compare yourself to countries such as China and Russia and have your defense be "well at least we don't have concentration camps", you know you have work to do. Maybe the US doesn't have the highest incarceration rate, be it per capita or absolute, but it does have the highest rate of incarceration of any modern 'free' society. And that is a shame.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by pfortuny on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @07:40AM (#33162118)
And, now that you mention it: Guantánamo is still a thing.
Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by thrwyoilarticle on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @06:40AM (#33161658)
'It's not as bad as genocide' is not a hugely convincing argument.
Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by noduerme on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @01:34PM (#33166247)
Oh, of course not, I'm just pointing out that none of those countries are even on the list; therefore, the list is meaningless.
Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by KingOfCoders on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @07:24AM (#33161984)
(I'm not pro genocide)

1M / 1.4B is increasing the incaceration rate by 70.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by dirtyid on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @10:57AM (#33164109)
> be considered "incarcerated"

Even accepting grossly inflated propaganda figures, ~2M were detained over multiple years, with the vast majority on short sentences (months). We're talking stat shifts of low 100,000s locked up for months spread over 5 years. It wouldn't have shifted PRC per capita internment figures to be comparable with the US.

Or that by all accounts mass internment phase is over, majority have been released, extra problematic elements that couldn't be fixed in a few months/years are removed from society with lifetime sentences. The TLDR is "mass internment" is a temporary tool in PRC for deradicalization initiatives with deadlines in mind, not permanent conditions supported by prison industrial complexes like in the US. XJ securitization was expensive, not profitable.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by pessimizer on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @11:35AM (#33164637)
There are only twelve million Uighurs on the planet, and the US murdered six million random Muslims as a response to a 9/11 planned and committed by Saudi nationals.

Also, there aren't millions of Uighurs in concentration camps in China. There were an enormous number of Uighurs rounded up, usually for dubious reasons, in a a ruthless Sinoization campaign meant to stop efforts (with terrorism and bombings) to create a breakaway republic. Notably, China nearly cloned the US's anti-Muslim anti-terrorism language in order to justify this dragnet. Since then, virtually everyone has been released and the program wound down. US nationalists will still be talking about it 50 years from now as an excuse for why we need to hurt Chinese people, as if the Uighur crackdown had the staying power of our indefinite prison in Guantanamo Bay.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by noduerme on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @01:50PM (#33166470)
>> need to hurt Chinese people

Excuse me? Calling out a dictatorship that's committing genocide has exactly nothing to do with American nationalism nor with "hurting" people of some ethnicity.

I'm also Jewish. Your statement is equivalent to saying Jews still talk about the Holocaust 50 years after it happened as a way to hurt German people. Or that Blacks talk about slavery as a way to hurt white people. These were groups that were victims of racial genocide and you're using the oldest cheap trick of holocaust revisionists to blame them for making some other racial group feel guilty...?

It was the communist party, the nazi party, the institution of slavery. Not the Chinese, the Germans, the whites. We call the truth out to try to prevent it from happening again. Racist propagandists and the peddlers of denial, who are also the ones to commit genocide, come up with the shallow excuse that the victims are racist.

Pretending that people talk about CCP concentration camps to "hurt Chinese people" is an explicit propaganda attempt to cover up or change the subject from an actual racial genocide committed by the Chinese government, by using an imaginary, nonexistent racist response from the west that makes "Chinese people" into the narrative's victims. Keep polishing that, one day it might sound as good as Putin's version about victimized Russians.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by gertrunde on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @05:35AM (#33161226)
I was surprised to see BVI & Saint Kitts on that list, although it seems like the figures are right, just a bit odd, with the way the rates are given as number of prisoners per 100k people. BVI - Prison population ~140-150, total population ~30k SK&N - Prison population ~200, total population ~50k
Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by viridian on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @07:04AM (#33161831)
The rest of the world used to be behind by at least a factor of 2. Bad as it is, things are actually much better than in 2010, where just over 1% (1,000 per 100,000) of the total population (1.3% of adults) were in prison.

This number is likely to continue to decrease, as sentences have gotten shorter over time, and those have a huge, huge lag time. Your average prosecutor has, for better or worse, liberalized significantly from 1980 to now, even when compared to the general public.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by swman on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @07:20AM (#33161949)
To be fair, and I say this as a brown immigrant, the USA has a lot of actual criminals. My perception after living here for many years is that people here resort to crime and violence way faster than people from my home country, and the poorest people here are probably much better off than the average middle class people there, all things considered (access to public schools, libraries, internet, 24/7 clean water and power, etc.)

Not saying that where I’m from doesn’t have its own set of issues, but the type and levels of crime here are just insane. We have our crazies and backwater types who do dumb stuff but you don’t hear about some random people who rob homes, then get in a highway shootout, before kidnapping someone in their car and going on a wild chase for 2 hours that ends in more gunshots. Or you go to the grocery store and get shot or punched over a few bucks.

People here seem to be okay with crazy Public drug abuse (SF), turning their head to petty theft (it’s part of living in the city! Wtf), or giving more attention to the perpetrators than victims.

Typical mentality in my circles: Who cares bro 450k TC coming through. #FIRE

So insane.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by KingOfCoders on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @07:21AM (#33161950)
One of the reasons (there are many others) US unemployment rates can't be compared to Europe.
Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by dncornholio on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @07:58AM (#33162260)
Why not? What's so special about US that you think it should be compared differently? In this case, I think numbers are numbers.
Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by KingOfCoders on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @08:26AM (#33175927)
If you put millions of people (higher percentage than countries in Europe e.G) into prison there are less people unemployed. That doesn't say something about your economy though, for which, beside GDP, the unemployement rate very often is a proxy.

The biggest other reason:

Unemployement rate in Europe is mostly calculated by the number of people getting benefits and looking for a job (roughly) (+ in Germany if they work less than 15h/week). The US calls a sample of housholds (some 10k) and asks if the people in the household actively look for jobs but don't have one. In that case they are counted as jobless.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by hooby on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @08:52AM (#33162742)
It's also interesting to compare that with other countries.

United States - 629

Canada - 104

Greenland - 126

Mexico - 166

Germany - 69

Russia - 325

Iceland - 33

Japan - 38

Norway - 49

China - 121

Vietnam - 128

England and Wales - 130

Australia - 160

Hungary - 169

Iran - 228

Lithuania - 216 (= highest of all EU countries)

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by bequanna on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @10:50AM (#33164015)
I see this cited very often, but what exactly should we take away from this? Just some general idea that "too many" people are in prison?

I think most people agree that low-level drug offenders shouldn't be filling our prisons.

But most people who live/work/frequent urban areas will have a steady stream of anecdotes about someone being mugged or otherwise experiencing violence, serious property crime, open drug, etc.

How can we reconcile the fact that we still encounter too many dangerous, antisocial people with the fact that we have high incarceration rates?

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by pessimizer on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @10:58AM (#33164121)
> what exactly should we take away from this? Just some general idea that "too many" people are in prison?

Yes. Same as when we compare what proportion of GDP we spend on health care and compare it to other countries with longer lifespans. We're supposed to take away the general idea that we are spending too much on too little healthcare. When we look at how much murder we have per capita and compare it to our number of prisoners per capita, we should take away the fact that we're getting too little murder reduction for too much imprisoning of people.

> How can we reconcile the fact that we still encounter too many dangerous, antisocial people with the fact that we have high incarceration rates?

We don't bother. If one's attempted solution of incarcerating poor people makes violence worse, the answer is obviously to incarcerate even more people.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by saila on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @12:19PM (#33165264)
I've lived in an urban area for the last ~25 years and I certainly don't have a "steady stream" of anecdotes of the type of crime you're describing.

On the other hand, there is a steady stream of news articles about street crime, which often seems to portray the situation as worse than it is.

People that comment under news headlines on Twitter, for example, sometimes seem completely detached from reality, thinking they'll be murdered in a Mad Max hellscape if they cross some imagined urban boundary (but many of these people have an ideological agenda, so it's not clear whether they actually believe this).

Of course, there are issues in the city, just like there is everywhere, including distracted drivers (my worst fear), domestic abuse, and so on. Street crime certainly does exist, and is worse in some areas for sure, but is it really the biggest threat to our everyday safety?

It's kind of like how my mom gets caught up worrying about gangs, and I always ask her if she's ever had an interaction with a gang member (the answer is always no). Sure, gangs exist and sometimes do bad things to uninvolved people, but if you compare, for example, domestic abuse or negligent car crashes, those are far more of a threat to most of us commenting here than gangs ever will be.

EDIT: And to the extent that the U.S. does have more crime/incarceration than other countries, I'd ask what we're doing wrong, or more neutrally, what's different about our approach? One major issue is that our prison system seems particularly ineffective at rehabilitation and reintegrating people into society, so recidivism is high.

Re:Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminal... by bequanna on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @01:45PM (#33166383)
> And to the extent that the U.S. does have more crime/incarceration than other countries, I'd ask what we're doing wrong, or more neutrally, what's different about our approach?

Why are you only considering our approach and not the differences in our citizens? Approaches don’t commit crimes, people do. What makes our _citizens_ different?