North America is in a pretty good place compared to the rest of the world when it comes to energy/food/labor demographics.
China is, unfortunately, a long way from the competent leadership of Hu Jintao and the other previous post-Mao leaders. Unlike the previous leaders (primarily selected on merit), who WANTED to prevent another Mao-like cult of personality, Xi is a deeply-insecure man whose rise was entirely built on family connections. He has fostered a cult of personality while simultaneously using the cover of anti-corruption stings to remove all of his CCP rivals, or anyone critical of him.
The result is a huge departure from the previously competent CCP decisions. The current CCP is carrying out foolish, self-destructive, and non-sensical policies that can only make sense in the context of local decision makers desperate to please Xi. Xi is the ultimate centralizer of all decisions, having knee-capped the previous CCP policies of pushing decision making to local officials as much as possible. It's a real nightmare, and has resulted in China having an image of a shining (although somewhat authoritarian) city on a hill to a weird techno-dystopia with people starving in their apartments under absurdly stupid "Zero Covid" lockdown policies because the CCP can't admit the SinoVax is a complete failure.
Without strong leadership, China might still be a pre-ondustrial/low-industrial poor region plagues by wars between small nations.
Countries like China and Cuba had to manufacture their own vaccines without the new mRNA process and it was less effective as a result but still better than nothing. Cuba even had to get permission from the US to import syringes to be able to administer the vaccine they manufactured. How is that defensible?
All of this without even saying that the CPC has an incredibly high approval rating (https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2020/07/long-term-sur...), even when the polling is done by outside entities and anonymized. It seems incredibly condescending to treat a billion+ humans as inept drones under the iron grip of a tyrant simply because they're geopolitical rivals.
Drones, no, but it's very instructive to look at what the elites of China do. Many who achieve success in China spend significant resources to have a foot out the door, because they know that success is fleeting, depending on remaining in favor of the CCP. Even Xi Jinping's daughter went to school in the US.
If the CCP is actually so benign and China is well run and a good place to be, why does that happen?
They could be targeting economic policy around the, say, 1.3 billion or so non-elites.
A few million at the top may see a net burden in "we have to be responsive to overall planning goals" and "we might have less raw economic opportunity", but maybe it's a choice the CCP is willing to make. At least on an aggregate, society-wide level, the quality-of-life metrics do seem to be pointing in the right direction.
I don't think "schooling in the US" is inherently a culpable thing. Premier American universities are globally very highly respected, and I could see value in "cross training" to make sure they're not missing any good ideas worth investigating.
I also would not extrapolate public opinion about the CCP based on polling, even if it's done by outside entities and anonymized. Any Chinese with an IQ higher than room temperature would know better than to speak out against the CCP in a western-designed poll. Xi Jinping is leading his country like Stalin...they have GULAGs for dissenters.
So, I don't disagree with you. I just think culturally, the Chinese are rightly reticent to express any antigovernmental sentiment, for good reason. Let's remember that the Chinese people have been occupied and oppressed by the Chinese Communist Party since the Chinese civil war. I pray for their liberation.
You really believe that? In that case I'm sure you also believe that no Uyghurs have been harmed as well.
91 percent of Chinese people have absolutely no say in their government based on statistics of membership in the CCP. Nobody is saying they are inept drones but they certainly get disappeared if they protest their government.
Look at USD FX rates. The US may be able to purchase resources and goods abroad at more favorable exchange, but who can afford to buy US exports as the USD rockets skyward? And what is the logical follow-on to unobtainable USD units of trade? Substitutes that China, for example, are more than delighted to support if it means they exert (even) more control over the global monetary system.
The USD is strong because people need to buy things from the US to begin with. That is, at best, a "nobody goes there it's too popular" kind of comment. The idea that you weaken your currency to increase exports is something you do to benefit from growth, like moving industry to China. But if something like an energy shortage or a fertilizer shortage start limiting your ability to produce things with that opportunity, you're just doubled down on a bad situation.
This isn't even a story on "reserve currency" status. This is just the US (and Canada) being in an incredible competitive situation. What do you do when there's a global food shortage and the US is the only country unhindered? You suck it up, buy those stupidly expensive US dollars, and import US food. And get screwed if you owe USD denominated debts while your currency goes down.
And if the US finds it's not at the right level, it can always just... spend more money. It's basically free. Everyone's getting hit with inflation because it's genuinely harder to make and ship things. Slapping on some excess money sloshing around to try and keep things going is dangerous.
You do this enough and your allies become collateral damage, the system begs for a change. Rest of the world starts to only base their trades in gold (or some other standard) and when faced with USD debt, change the debt amount through policy. US has to keep their (future) allies afloat either openly or with hidden support.
Odd but that Snowcrash reference seems oddly prescient given the rise of Uber, Instacart, GrubHub, etc. Not quite pizza delivery but similar genres.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7CmXz8Qd9yw
(I highly recommend Perun's channel for analysis of the Ukraine war)
Also, it's a bit hard to take seriously someone that says "so no jets, no F-35, no battleships". Sure it's a throwaway line but it seems like someone trying to communicate something serious wouldn't refer to literal battleships, which nobody in the world uses anymore. It's not something that Perun would say.
I used to work in the Pentagon, and while we never took Zeihan's talks without a grain of salt, directionally he tends to be very accurate. Nations like China which lack a culture of immigration have extremely predictable demographic booms and busts, and Zeihan is spot on with those. He also hits on the reality of how dependent most nations, especially China, are on imports that pass through oceanic shipping lanes they have no ability to control or secure without the US Navy.
There is no way for a cargo ship to arm itself against submarines.
The only way I see the landscape changing meaningfully in the direction you suggest (cargo ships going up against seafarers they are not able to defend themselves from) is if letters of marque were reinstated. At least one proposal has been floated -- and when we all stop laughing about it I grant that it might become a thing
Say, because Taiwan was being invaded?
And in the form of a blockade, of course.
There's a list here that would be a reasonable starting point for any further digging you might wish to do:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_airliner_shootdown_inc...
Korean air lines flight over Russia, us shooting down Iranian jet in the gulf, Russia shooting down Malaysian air over Ukraine, Iran shooting down a Ukrainian jet over itself.
I presume gp means Not swept under the rug in terms of information suppression, swept under the rug in terms of very little diplomatic fallout
I think there are a few other things that have lined up, like Sri Lanka collapse being a bellwether for his forecasts.
The last time someone mentioned this, they said he'd predicted they'd invade in 2014, which is after they'd invaded and annexed Crimea.
I found a talk form 2018 in which he said there are going to be 3 major bush wars of global import, Ukraine-Russia, Iran-Saudi Arabia, and China-Indian Ocean. So far Ukraine has panned out, he also predicted where the political parties are going right now in the US and why they seem so out of whack.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran%E2%80%93Saudi_Arabia_pr...
Source: https://books.google.com/books?id=vn-BAwAAQBAJ&printsec=fron...
EDIT: I had an incomplete copy paste on the link so I corrected it
Do agree with his broad thesis though. America is in a very good spot.
Energy and infrastructure are the venes of Europe which clocked and overstretched to the max. Something will need to give and it already begins by small bakeries closing and more to follow..
It wont end well. I don't believe we will have any growth in Europe for the next 3 years.
Who is going to invest in Europe if energy is literally unpredictable and expensive?
They only wanted gas as a switch off / switch on power source, you cant do that with nuclear.
Instead, people protested also against wind and solar and we switched to cheap gas from Russia.
Which the green parties didn't want at all..
^ even so it would probably take a couple of years to get methane generation going at scale.
This is all self-inflicted. You can't prevent people and countries from shooting themselves in the foot.
Tomorrow we might discover a new kind of math, requiring newly trained mathmeticians in a novel field.
Those mathmeticians will need admins, business services, places to work, food, etc.
Thus even the discovery of a few jobs has more jobs created than found.
Feeding one person is easy. Feeding 200 people with a mix of allergies is hard.
It's not clear that this thread is about. Jobs a weak approximation of utility creation + equalit of the distribution of that utility.
But I guess to answer the question, jobs, especially at the bottom are "enabled" more than anything. We want people to do simple tasks, but tech advancements make it efficient enough to actually pay people to do it. Like rideshare drivers, ignoring valid claims about vc money burning. Some new types of jobs might be created or discovered but most jobs changes are about determining whether its viable to pay something to do something you want to do. The idea to have them do it has always been there.
But you may be interested in knowing that models of labor markets are often based on matching models - you've got two groups (employers, employees) and everyobdy is trying to find {one,many} members of the other group that are a good match.
As I understand it, those are mainly concerned with reduction in labor costs.
Job discovery is a phrase used by Clayton Christensen to describe finding a job to be done. He uses it to describe finding a product to sell to people to perform some function in their lives - a job to be done by a product that you make. I'm using it as an alternative to the idea of "job creation" because I don't think that's real.
There is a certain political narrative about job creation and job creators. I tried to find support for it in academia and I could not.
I didn't want to put all this in my original question because then I would only get political replies.
---
About politics - Yes my question has some political motivation, but I am genuinely interested in the subject. My motivation is not to prove or disprove, but to learn. You don't have to believe that about me, but I do.
Where does your understanding derive from? Reducing macroeconomics to "reducing labor costs" is akin to reducing classical mechanics to "computing projectile trajectories". I don't know Christensen but I take it that he's a business school professor and I guess that was the target audience he was speaking to there.
You're not wrong that economics is a discipline that is not free from ideological biases, but I guess you're going a bit far in reducing the discipline to that. People still want to answer questions with data, like "what happens to unemployment (and exchange rates, and investment,...) if we raise interest rates?". Labor economics might ask more narrow questions like "what happens if we raise the minimum wage?". That's the sort of questions that economics deals with, not musing over the semantics of creation vs discovery.
Jobs are the same, when you create an organization there are countless ways to structure it and you will create different jobs depending on how you do things. Job creators are the people who create organizations, the better they do their job the more these organizations can do with less people so the more wealth there will be to share, so job creation is an extremely important job.
Your understanding of what economics is interested in is also incorrect. I guess business programs are concerned with reduction of labor costs. Economics is concerned with efficiently allocating scarce resources.
https://economics.mit.edu/files/7400
and Open Coursework page
https://ocw.mit.edu/courses/14-661-labor-economics-i-fall-20...
A labor matching model is better because it recognizes the need for a worker and a job opening, and for those to find each other.
Was "social media manager" created or discovered? How about (to take an older example) telex operator?
Many of the most successful free market economies embody the concept of "was born on third base and thinks he hit a triple."
The United States and Canada had relatively easy access to territorial expansion, which offered them huge amounts of fertile, temperate land and almost any natural resource needed. They also started with a high-immigrant and relatively educated population.
South Korea got to build their economy late enough to be relatively unburdened by legacy costs. They also had a Western world more than willing to ignore a series of presidents-for-life, domestic crackdowns, and incestuous government-industry relationships as long as they kept Kim Il-Sung up in the attic.
Even Singapore had the advantage of being ideally located for trade purposes.
With those benefits, was the free market necessary to unlock their success?
Conversely, if you dropped (say) the American Founders in 1917 Moscow or 1948 Peking, would they do any better?
> if you dropped (say) the American Founders in 1917 Moscow or 1948 Peking, would they do any better?
Absolutely. See Hong Kong, Japan & Germany after WW2, Chile does better when they go free market, does worse when they veer back left, etc. South American countries have vast resources, but little prosperity.
US immigration consisted of people in abject poverty, who arrived illiterate with nothing but a suitcase.
The success was astounding. We're talking child mortality being halved and poverty rates dropping off a cliff, in only a few years. Of course, US businesses did not like it very much and US imperialism shut it down in violent fashion, and Guatemala has been an unstable and violent place ever since, with a long string of brutal dictators.
What is "funny" in a deeply grim and sad sense is that this was at once socialism (i.e. means of production to the people who work, rather than a separation between those who work and those who own), but also very much the American Dream: a plot of land which was your own, for you to work, and where you own the fruits of your labour. You, not a king, not a robber baron, you. That's why the violent stampdown by the US is especially disgusting and hypocritical.
As for Chile, it had a democratically elected left-wing government. Even if Pinochet's economic policy turned out better (which it by most measures did not), NOTHING can justify a violent operation to overthrow that government, to the tune of tens of thousands of tortures and deaths, to implant one that pursues your favoured brand of economics.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32765771
> Mining a bunch of copper, helping your cronies get rich, and pumping up land prices is not a "miracle".
And that's from an ideologically aligned source.
> This record is less bad than Allende’s, but it’s far from what I’d call good, and it’s certainly nothing that anyone should call an economic “miracle”.
I really don't understand the romance with leftism, where the historical record of its implementations is pretty miserable.
Not to mention, the notion that the US was a free market at any point in its history is unequivocally false, and anyone who thinks a system that observes slavery qualifies as a free market should be embarrassed.
> anyone who thinks a system that observes slavery qualifies as a free market should be embarrassed.
I usually say "excluding the slave south". Nevertheless, let's compare the slave south with the free north. The free north economically buried the slave south, which was a major cause of the southern rebellion. They wanted to protect their economy from the depredations of free labor.
The south lost the war because the north buried them with arms and supplies and trains and everything needed in plentiful supply to destroy the southern barefoot armies.
A similar thing happened in both WW1 and WW2. The American free market decided the fate of Germany and Japan the day the US entered the war, because Germany and Japan simply were overwhelmed. The US supplied not only themselves, but supplied Britain, France, and Russia, and still buried Japan with overwhelming endless supplies of everything the military wanted.
The Japanese understood this (Hitler didn't), and tried to win WW2 with one stroke (Pearl Harbor). When that failed, they put everything on the line at Midway. The carriers were sunk, their best pilots were killed, the planes were lost, and Japan could not replace them, and everything went downhill for them from there. The US lost carriers and airplanes and just built lots more.
Hitler lost WW2 the day he declared war on the US, in probably the stupidest military move in history. You can't win against a free market country unless yours is free market, too.
They do seem to have a very planned part (looks like so from the other side of the world), that isn't internationally competitive. But simply claiming that their economy is planned is clearly wrong.
I didn't claim that. I was pointing out that the centrally planned part isn't working. China has a mixed economy.
Don’t these industries depend on inputs from around the world?
* Plenty of land
* Plenty of wood
* Plenty of sources of fresh water
* Pro-immigrantion policy could reducing construction costs
* Seemingly high rate of 'cottage' ownership which seems like a second home to me, which seems to indicate abundance?
* Remote working situation good
* Fiber can't be that hard to roll out to new places right next to roads plus Starlink exists
* People don't seem to mind the weather too much?
In US, these things seem less abundant as lots of our land is allocated already as opposed to just being crown land
1. There has been more demand for living in cities and less for rural areas
2. That demand has not been met with the same increases in housing supply, so prices rise
3. Low interest rates make housing an even more attractive investment, and throw gasoline on the fire
Land is generally not very valuable by itself, it is locations that are valuable (specifically desirable locations in growing cities). There are highly limited locations available in Canadian cities, particularly the desirable cities of Toronto and Vancouver.
Same with the Bay Area, NYC, Hong Kong, Singapore, Sydney, Auckland etc. Singapore does probably the best job of the above at keeping housing relatively affordable despite very limited locations.
I would start with questioning this assumption.
Also, based on their terrible choices of ISP and mobile networks, I would question this one too:
> Fiber can't be that hard to roll out to new places right next to roads plus Starlink exists
I purchased a home at the start of this mess with an 2.6%. Right now it's hovering around 6%. I would say I MASSIVELY lucked out.
Does Canada not fix the rate? I am confused -
You can also let your rate float with the market, which is called a variable rate mortgage.
The U.S. has been heavily subsiding mortgages since the great Depression, through programs such as FHA. Banks would not be willing to loan people money at such low rates over 30 years unless the government and taxpayers backed the loan.
It's not at all clear whether the policy actually helps ownership.
The mortgage market was very tightly regulated to really only permit the 30-year fixed-rate mortgages until 2002.
Anyone who has taken a five-minute look at the real estate market in any major US city can see those market distortions plain as day.
I have my doubts that the US will allow that to happen. The resource curse is real.
So in these times where rates go up, it makes Canadian homeowners suddenly have to pay more for their houses they're already living in.
In variable rate mortgages, the amount going to principal vs interest changes. The monthly payments remain constant.
I’m not an economist so I can’t tell you how far they can go with this. But they have an atypical margin for error correction re: interest rates / money creation.
Though I'll admit, I still found the stat that of 20% youth unemployment in China to be shockingly high. The idea that they're lowering their interest rates is also bonkers to think about. Their economy has been slow motion train wrecking for soooo long now. God help them if they get another covid flare up over the winter and and are stupid enough to do another lockdown.