News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by oxff on Thursday September 15, 2022 @06:21AM (#32849671)
In Europe they've probably gone down the past decade I'd say.
Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by onion2k on Thursday September 15, 2022 @06:58AM (#32849928)
In Europe they've probably gone down the past decade I'd say.

Outside of the technology hubs like London dev salaries have gone up significantly, largely due to developers being able to work remotely for companies in the technology hubs. I imagine that's a large part of what's exerting downward pressure on wages in those areas.

Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by IaacForHire on Thursday September 15, 2022 @07:13AM (#32850033)
Oof, European salaries are absurdly low. When I first left the USA I was thinking "OK I'll get a nice job in Amsterdam or Denmark" .. Then I saw the cost of living and the low salaries, and waved away that dream.
Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by atemerev on Thursday September 15, 2022 @07:28AM (#32850148)
Exactly. Here, a software engineer is mostly just another low middle class profession, not even the upper middle. US immigration is hard enough, otherwise half of European software engineers would have moved to the Valley already.

(And no, "cheap medicine" and "cheap education" do not exactly cover the difference, at least for software engineers).

Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by 2rsf on Thursday September 15, 2022 @07:46AM (#32850302)
I don't want to pen THIS discussion again, but... the difference is not that big especially if you calculate risk and family in. I live in Sweden with our "known" high taxes and as far as I can tell from conversations with friends and colleagues is that our QUALITY of life is not that different. Of course, YMMV especially if you were a big shot in a big shot place with no family to support, young and healthy.
Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by pembrook on Thursday September 15, 2022 @09:44AM (#32851827)
I don't want to offer the canned rebuttal to this either, but, the free healthcare and education don't make up for a salary potential that maxes out at 2-3X lower than what you could make in the US (especially combined with much lower taxes).

The fact is, the Nordics are de-facto the best place in the world to be below average. They're not a great value if your skills offer you above-average earning potential.

Sure, your QOL might be similar while working. But in the US, you can retire by 45 on a FAANG salary (even with a family!). That's virtually impossible on the entire continent of Europe as a salaryman.

Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by nmarinov on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:57AM (#32852990)
> Sure, your QOL might be similar while working. But in the US, you can retire by 45 on a FAANG salary (even with a family!). That's virtually impossible on the entire continent of Europe as a salaryman.

Common idea but in IT it's absolutely possible to retire by 30 in several EU countries. Bulgaria, Romania and it might take more time but you can add Poland and several more to that list. Sure it's not Western Europe but then again the US is not just SV.

Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by yardie on Thursday September 15, 2022 @07:32AM (#32850182)
Worked there as well and our son was constantly haranguing me about wanting to move back. Had to sit him down and explain what my compensation after taxes were and the cost of living compared to the US. He only remembers France as where his family and former schoolmates are.
Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by CalRobert on Thursday September 15, 2022 @09:43AM (#32851806)
:-( We're looking at NL specifically so our kids can have some freedom, ride their bikes and take public transport, and not be prisoners of suburbia. But the wages are pretty terrible; I've been working remote for US companies (set up my own consulting firm so invoicing is easy) and that's worked pretty well. We'll see if the recession kills it.
Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by yardie on Thursday September 15, 2022 @11:55AM (#32853946)
Possibly the opposite! The Euro drop in price has made it competitive for US companies to hire engineers in Europe. The only con is the difference in timezone. Central/South America still has that advantage.
Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by CalRobert on Thursday September 15, 2022 @04:05PM (#32857774)
Yeah, I just started a contract denominated in USD which has been nice. Time zones are kinda annoying.
Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by yrgulation on Thursday September 15, 2022 @07:50AM (#32850336)
Try east europe, pays better and lower taxes. Standard of living is improving and accommodation is way better. You have room for growth as well. At least that’s what i see among software engs in Romania. Net pay is lower but take home is better. Heard poland and bulgaria arent far off. Ukraine was also good before the war.
Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by 988747 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @09:54AM (#32851992)
In Poland you can make close to $100k per year (as a contractor, not employee), and only have like 18% tax rate on this (12% income tax plus social security payments). So you earn like $6-6.5k monthly after taxes, and all your living expenses are maybe $1.5k. You can save the rest towards your apartment/house (and you need $130-200k for that, or 3-5 years of saving).
Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by atraac on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:23AM (#32852511)
That's exactly what I'm doing right now except I get around 70-80k eur as a contractor. Take home as a single 20something guy is insane and allows you to buy a decent house for cash in 3-4 years near a major city.

The only thing most people outside don't talk about when it comes to Poland is our insanely terrible and corrupted government, lack of teachers, nurses, doctors, much higher inflation recently, regressing in women's rights, bad air quality in most big cities etc. Public healthcare is in so bad state that you need to go private anyway to get anything done. Also half of our society is still really religious, close minded and anti-west, it's slowly changing but Poland is still pretty hard place to live, f.e. for LGBT people. All those things are stopping me from actually commiting to staying in Poland, besides having my family I hate almost everything about this country.

Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by Melchori on Thursday September 15, 2022 @08:37AM (#32850861)
Ah come on...

You can get a good stable salary in Amsterdam and have a great life...

Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by IaacForHire on Thursday September 15, 2022 @09:29AM (#32851612)
I'm not sure about great. If I had family beyond my wife, sure I think Western Europe would be incredible.

Since I don't, I choose to live in a poor country instead of a Western European country. Bought a flat for $100k, spend about $1k per month, and when I am able to find work I put 90% of it into savings.

Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by Cryptonic on Thursday September 15, 2022 @07:27AM (#32850137)
Yes I also though about a move from Germany to the Netherlands but looks like Software is nothing they see worth of paying more than 60-70k€. Here in Germany I earn 110k€, but this is close to the max you can expect as Software Developer. Maybe 120-140k€ if you are a high value asset that bunkers critical knowledge (My company calls it subject matter expert - basically somebody who wrote critical, but unmaintainable code for a decade or more).
Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by oxff on Friday September 16, 2022 @12:03AM (#32861927)
I know many devs who abandoned the 'high quality of life' of Western Europe for higher pay elsewhere. It is really not all that glamorous to be a dev here.
Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by hiq on Thursday September 15, 2022 @09:48AM (#32851898)
> European salaries are absurdly low.

Counterexample: Zurich, Switzerland.

Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by 0x000xca0xfe on Thursday September 15, 2022 @07:07AM (#32849994)
Yup, just started as an embedded software developer for 50k€ in central Europe, same as most of my friends. It's basically the same as 10 years ago from what I've heard, but COL has increased A LOT since then.
Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by koevet on Thursday September 15, 2022 @06:54AM (#32849891)
Not sure about salaries for permanent positions, but contractor rates have definitively gone up in the last 10 years for me.
Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by tluyben2 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @08:43AM (#32850949)
They have been rising for the past 30 years for me, but indeed faster the past 10 years.
Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by that_guy_iain on Thursday September 15, 2022 @06:48AM (#32849846)
For me, it seems they're going up. 5-years ago, I would ask for 65,000€ in Berlin and that would be considered extremely high for my role now it seems 75,000€ is where the asking price is.
Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by IaacForHire on Thursday September 15, 2022 @07:15AM (#32850054)
So 3% per year, or just a little bitover inflation. Still, better than the US where we don't really get inflationary raises.
Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by rr888 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @09:23AM (#32851540)
London I think the glory days were late 90s and maybe 03-08. Esp when contractors were paying no tax. I think rates have gone up a little since then but cost of living has doubled or tripled.
Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by finikytou on Thursday September 15, 2022 @06:48AM (#32849851)
in pure Euro no they went up a bit but definitly lower than the cost of living increase. the problem is that in the past decade Europe welcomed Cyprus, Czech Republic,Estonia,Hungary,Latvia, Lithuania,Malta , Poland ,Slovakia,Slovenia,Bulgaria ,Romania, Croatia.

Most of those countries were below living standards/salaries of western europe while having for some of them a very strong education system. Romania for instance trains a lot of good devs/it ops. All this qualified workforce can work in any country of europe. Add to this qualified workforce from syria/turkey for germany, North Africa for france and you see that while European companies did not grow like the US one, the pool of talent they can grab is larger than ever. the cake became smaller and Europe did everything it could toblock ambitious tech companies to grow and use the stock market as a wealth tool. they don't even understand that they operate in a global market and that if they tax or limit growth in their own country then the companies will move out. Dublin and Amsterdam for instance became hubs for this reason.

There is also the perception in the old world that being a "Techie" is like being a white collar factory worker. Developers are definitly not considered as stars in Europe. Most of the engineers in europe that want to make money work for an american company.

Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by badpun on Thursday September 15, 2022 @07:00AM (#32849939)
> Most of the engineers in europe that want to make money work for an american company.

From my experience, most of engineers in Europe who want to make money work are contracting. Contracting money can be similar to what the FAANGs offer here (outside of Switzerland), but taxes are often lower and you don't have to debase yourself with multistage leetcode interviews and intracompany promotion games.

However, the US companies may start to up their game here salary-wise - I was recently contacted by a recruiter of a Tier 2 US tech company who said that the TC for a tech lead position in their branch in Poland is around 220k EUR. I hope this is a part of a larger trend.

Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by finikytou on Thursday September 15, 2022 @08:46AM (#32850983)
in many european countries tax will be 50% for contracting. to make 150k you need to make 300k... you cant take days-off,sick-days, might even need to make more for retirment match vs normal job... it is really not a good way to make money
Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by ChuckNorris89 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @01:00PM (#32855035)
>in many european countries tax will be 50% for contracting

This! Contracting is the way if your country of residence has low taxes for freelancers, but if its' the same or higher as a FTE then it sucks.

Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by walthamstow on Thursday September 15, 2022 @06:52AM (#32849873)
All the countries you mention apart from Bulgaria, Romania and Croatia were admitted in 2004, which is nearly 20 years ago now.
Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by finikytou on Thursday September 15, 2022 @08:50AM (#32851035)
it is europe. things go slow but once they are in motion... they first used those countries for lowering blue collar jobs (construction for instance) then white collar, the cloud/saas craze was an accelerator. the covid is one too.
Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by ChuckNorris89 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @07:45AM (#32850281)
The effects took time to manifest. Now they slowed down.
Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by yrgulation on Thursday September 15, 2022 @07:53AM (#32850361)
Have you considered moving to those countries for better pay? It sad to hear pay is so bad in germany, probably getting quality education in romania or turkey might help? At the end of the day you are also free to move in to any of these countries.
Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by finikytou on Thursday September 15, 2022 @08:57AM (#32851176)
you don't understand how economics work right? ask mexicans how happy they are to have high earning americans moving to mexico?

https://www.latimes.com/world-nation/story/2022-07-27/americ....

once you remove a country frontier, the market forces that are leashed to that country will be destroyed. radically transforming the country economy in ways that no one in this country but the 1% will benefit.

Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by yrgulation on Thursday September 15, 2022 @01:29PM (#32855481)
I think i understand. It’s a bit like removing borders destroyed car industries in a few countries, because germany could suddenly sell their cars and machinery import tax free. Radically transforming these industries in europe and america alike. Makes sense.
Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by ethbr0 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @07:45AM (#32850290)
Hasn't this been the Dutch playbook, since ~1600?

"Look at how much more freedom we give capital than the rest of Europe!" etc.

Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by oxff on Thursday September 15, 2022 @07:46AM (#32850293)
Yeah I was taking into account cost of living increases and inflation when I wrote it, it's quite grim to live in Western Europe on regular dev salary :D
Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by 2rsf on Thursday September 15, 2022 @07:51AM (#32850351)
> it's quite grim to live in Western Europe on regular dev salary

No it's not. We still earn above average and (very) generally life in Europe are not grim.

Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by finikytou on Thursday September 15, 2022 @08:48AM (#32851015)
it is not grim but getting a family-home with a dev salary is out of the picture for many western europeans. it wasn't the case one generation ago. american dev can definitly afford a house even in HCOL cities. for a similar job at AWS or Google you getting 550k+ in NYC vs 200k in London or Paris. just looking at real estate (which is number 1 cost) it is worth moving to NYC.

just to give you an idea: MIDTOWN next to bryant park 1 400 000k$ https://ibb.co/m4bPcXR

decent location in paris (definitely not top tier like next to Bryant park) 1 300 000 Euros https://ibb.co/kx8BXh2

why every time we say life became harder/more expensive we get comments saying its not that grim? this is how it starts. first steps are to reduce government benefits (retirement age further, unemployement benefits shorter,...-

Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by jltsiren on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:14AM (#32852360)
London and Paris are expensive, but they are not the norm. Home ownership is still affordable to dual-income middle-class families in Western Europe, and there are plenty of nice cities to choose from.

In many larger cities, central locations are ridiculously expensive. Once you get further away from the center, prices drop quickly. Because the society is less car-centric, location has a bigger impact on home prices than in the US.

Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by finikytou on Thursday September 15, 2022 @12:22PM (#32854324)
well city center or further in the city is 10kSQM in paris minimum that still puts the house into unaffordable territory with a european salary of ~80k for a senior dev. germany is a bit different because they have multiple job cities but take other countries. London vs other english cities job market will be night and day. Same for paris. You just don't get the same opportunities in smaller cities. Spain same. Portugal same. and the list goes on.
Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by jltsiren on Thursday September 15, 2022 @01:40PM (#32855668)
First, buying on a single salary is always difficult, because you are competing primarily against dual-income households.

Second, the problem seems to be chasing the hottest job markets. Those places are often unaffordable, because there is too much money floating around. They are good for people near the top, who can get very high compensation, as well as those near the bottom, who are happy to accept any job. People in the middle often find better deals in places with fewer opportunities and lower costs of living.

Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by Firmwarrior on Friday September 16, 2022 @12:36AM (#32862118)
Man, every time I think I'm doing well, it turns out I'm making way less than I could be.. I'm apparently getting a crappy deal making $300k TC in the Bay Area with 14 years of experience
Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by yrgulation on Thursday September 15, 2022 @01:33PM (#32855551)
How many properties do you own? Few people i know in east europe own at least a second home. One owns four flats and land. Do you own at least the home you live in or is it bank owned? Not being rude, just asking if the above average salary actually brings above average living, and not just a new iphone and macbook pro every 5-6 years. Does it allow for one to grow into more than just a wage earner?
Re:Ask HN: Have tech salaries been stagnant for the past dec... by finikytou on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @04:54AM (#32909291)
i totally agree with you and I didn't mean to sound like I was disrespecting eastern europe. If I was in my early 20s Id definitly consider moving to eastern europe and its a part of the world I enjoy personally travelling there for the culture and the nice cities.