Incentives.
The justification would be that sexual assault is a serious crime that goes underreported. If victims are afraid to come forward because they fear arrest for other, pettier offenses, then predators are even more likely to escape justice and commit more assaults.
Really, any offenses. We could imagine that there's some method for abusing a policy of disallowing use of a victim's evidence to prosecute that victim for unrelated crimes, but until it happens, it's reasonable to ignore that possibility.
Boudin was on life support pre recall at this point in history and found the SFPD dna evidence issue which was a questionable use case of that data at best.
The woman had been arrested on suspicion of a felony property crime, with police identifying her based on rape-kit evidence she gave as a victim, part of a giant San Francisco only dna data bank her data was in and she matched to.
Given how incredibly hard Boudin made it for what is left of the SFPD to prevent crime this is one of those 'everyone loses' current realities
Can you point out the evidence that Boudin instructed the SFPD to use DNA evidence in the investigation of retail theft? Like is there a memo from the DA saying “I, Chesa Boudin, instruct you to collect DNA evidence for retail thefts, and make sure to mash the rape victim database up with the criminal database!”
I have never seen a group so fervently pro-police on this site as the pro-SFPD group (and I do not mean the anti-Boudin group, I mean the group that is critical of anyone that doesn’t tow the “poor SFPD, we would live in a utopia if only they had unlimited power” line.)
edit: Typos
We all lose because rape kit dna shouldn't be in the pool of felon dna data, the police were being impeded by Boudin at every turn resulting in inappropriate policing methods to try and get a federal case through. The streets of San Francisco are no longer safe for anyone as a result of this fiasco with the SFPD understaffed and relunctant to do much for fear of being on the wrong side of criminal advocate activists legal challenges....
Your point is that the lack of evidence that Boudin was involved in this is the proof that this is his fault? Is there any scenario where anything SFPD does that’s shitty isn’t his fault?
Edit: When were the streets of San Francisco “safe” exactly? I wasn’t there during this horrible period between 2020 and 2022 but in 72 hours in SF a few years back:
-I saw people buying oxy from a guy in a tent, about ten feet from an occupied parked cop car
-About eight guys “running a train” (taking turns having penetrative sex) with a woman in an alley whilst they all smoked crack
-A woman taking a shit out of the window of a moving bus
-I was chased by a homeless man for five blocks because I only gave him a dollar and he kept demanding “more”
-I was forced to accept a dvd of truly depraved pornography at a bus stop
-I saw an adult shop openly selling cocaine
-Countless people shitting on the street
Does Chesa Boudin have a time machine? It sounds like I experienced exactly what the SFPD superfans say he caused.
Edit 2: This was during Garcon’s tenure.
There's surely a threshold at which they will gladly incriminate you. The paramedics just can't reasonably foresee where said line is other than knowing it's far beyond the typical illegal activity you find in that setting. Moreover, I'm sure you could imagine in the case of federal crimes (drug trafficking, terrorism, high profile national news stuff, etc) the feds having no qualms about threatening to drag the paramedics through an expensive prosecution if they don't narc.
What if you showed up with a bomb vest? Or showed up in a stolen military helicopter?
I’m not sure what the value is of these very obvious cases where common sense dictates that there is a plain and obvious limitation to this policy. The point is obviously to limit harm that people do to themselves and one another, not to function as some sort of philosophical thought experiment made concrete.
What is the purpose of this “what about”?
If the wording was something like "won't call the cops if you're way too fucking high" I'd find it more believable.
That’s exactly what they mean, and that is painfully obvious. I do not understand your point here. What exactly are you having difficulty believing? Do you think they intend to advertise that they provide blanket cover for every crime on earth?
I am having difficulty believing that anyone would actually believe that that is what’s intended by that statement. It is much more believable that a person would intentionally misinterpret that statement to make some sort of vague joke about language.
> HARM REDUCTION
> Medical staff will be available 24 hours a day to help in any situation, and they will not incriminate anyone. Do not hesitate to visit medical tents or reach out to any staff member or security member.
Did you really wonder if they meant "looking like a murderer is fine" or are you trolling?
I'm getting strong Godwin's Law vibes from your response, btw.
Pre-collecting DNA from everyone to use as evidence against them in future criminal investigations is way over the line when it comes to “is this behaviour totalitarian or fascist”.
Using DNA from a rape kit to identify someone in a crime is a clear violation of the 5th amendment.
Just because you can do something doesn’t mean you should.
The majority vote can be rallied through fear and propaganda into vesting ever greater authority in a centralized seat of power, with any opposition vilified as an existential threat.
The only way democracy survives is through a watchful and untrusting populace that constantly holds its government to account and seeks to limit its power and pervasive reach into the lives of the citizenry.
Freedom and liberty require at its core the ability to dissent. Dissent in turn requires privacy because dissent by its very nature will be suppressed by those in power.
I would theorize that mandatory en masse DNA cataloging is anathema to democracy because it inevitably is far too powerful a tool to suppress dissent.
The next logical step if you don’t think the 5th was violated is collecting DNA from everyone (eg: repurposing COVID swabs) so you can identify all the potential suspects from your sampled population while completely ignoring that someone from outside the sampled population could be the person you are looking for.
Being able to positively identify people is a reasonable function of a government, including democratic governments.
I think this is comparable to a key to your house that you gave to the police, because it was burglarized. They finished their investigations and hand the key back to you. What they did not tell you, is that they created a secret copy of your house keys and then five years later use it silently for searching through your house without a warrant.
Legislation appears to be doing the right thing here, my question is whether the police did their duty or not. Someone signed a consent form to put them in a database that tagged them as a match. That's not a police discretion thing, it's not clear to me that damages are appropriate.
Fortunately I'm not a judge, just some guy on the internet.
Magnitude of a crime can always be expanded to justify anything. We have plenty of things we could do to catch more criminals (even murderers!), but we don't. As an example, why not run a DNA check on any blood draws at the doctor's office? Sure it's an invasion of privacy, but what if it catches a murderer!
I get it. Here the argument is that the person approached law enforcement on their own, and thus opened themselves up to this. But this is incidental -- it happens to be that reporting this crime requires handing over DNA. But police could require everyone to do a blood draw when reporting any crime, right? I think most people would have a problem with that and think it is obviously an invasion of privacy. But OK, you can argue that the real problem there is that it is too tit-for-tat. How about instead every time you walk into a police station someone watches you and collects any hair that falls off of your head and runs it through the database? No coercion, no one can argue that they had to give their DNA in exchange for services. Still seems like it would still have a pretty negative effect on trust between people and police.
The only thing that makes this case "confusing" is that a bunch of different actors are bundled together. If the administration of a rape kit was 100% done by a doctor (as far as I know it is done by nurses but then handed over to police, currently?), and they could then trivially separate out the two genetic materials and hand over only that which didn't belong to the victim, then I think most people would find it distasteful for the police to demand both sets of DNA, right? Why do you need the other one (the doctor could confirm it belongs to the victim if that is the concern)? Just because it happens to be that the way we happen to administer this today makes it convenient to check both (and perhaps even easier than not checking both), does not in my mind introduce any sort of new ethical consideration. It still feels an awful lot like "well, if you want us to look at your crime, you have to be willing to have us check you for any crimes first".
The job of police is difficult, not as an accident of history because they didn't have the right technology when we wrote a lot of these laws, but because it's supposed to be difficult because we understand the value of what's lost if it isn't.
Can someone explain why it is considered as such, also with regard to forensics (if that makes any difference)? The original definition of privacy looks somewhat archaic in this case.
E.g.: someone follows you everywhere with a camera - it's privacy invasion. Some public camera films you accidentally at a specific place - it is not, though it's clearly you in the video. Seems like intent and focus are key here, and your image is not invasive by itself, but only if someone focuses on you. We leave DNA everywhere just like we leave images on every camera, but (to me) it's only privacy invasion if someone builds many fragments together or pauses to "look" into your business there. DNA itself is as private as your look - everyone can see it unless you actively counter it by physical means.
But the police didn't focus on her, they focused on evidence, just as if some camera filmed her in that house and they'd look at that footage, not at some drone footage tracing specifically her to see if her route maybe includes that house.
Storing DNA from previous encounters is ~ like storing your id photo (i.e. absolutely neutral info, lacking any context). Does this part invade privacy, maybe? But what's private here?
> It seems pretty clear to me that the victim should have the help of the police in apprehending the rapist, but should also be arrested for the bench warrant.
It seems to me that's a great decision if you don't want people to report murders because they have outstanding parking tickets.
Throwing any old DNA that comes into your hands into a huge database, with no prior expectation that the person whose DNA your searching is involved in a specific crime you're looking to compare them to but just to see if anything in there matches anything else in there, will turn up false positives with incredible regularity
https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2008/09/dna_matching_..., https://www.maa.org/external_archive/devlin/devlin_02_11.htm..., etc. DNA fishing expeditions are a terrible, terrible idea.
I remember being very troubled by a case from years ago about a cop who knocked on someone's door because neighbors had heard screaming. The resident and his girlfriend had been having loud sex, but agreed to let the cop verify no violence was taking place. During the visit the cop noticed some cannabis plants and the man was convicted of possession with intent to distribute.
My rule of thumb if I were rewriting the law would be that the inadvertently discovered crime must be as or more serious than that which is being reported/investigated. If a person is a victim of or an honest cooperator in the investigation of a serious crime, lesser offenses should be held in abeyance, although a warning of potential liability in future unrelated police contacts would be acceptable.
And anyway, what is a lesser offense? Drug trafficking are serious offenses if you go by maximum sentences.
Drug trafficking are serious offenses if you go by maximum sentences.
We should employ a more rational approach. I believe there's greater security in maximizing the payoff for cooperation rather than the punishment for prior defection.
My hope is that the cannabis would then be fruit of the poisoned tree and reaffirms my belief that you would never work with the cops to any degree.
I guess it would have turned on whether the cops' lingering suspicion was reasonable. Legally, this isn't so much weighing one point of view against another, as the LEO/state being able to construct a reasoned argument to justify the search - which is almost always possible.
For example, I recall a murder case where a guy was pulled over on the freeway in the small hours of the morning and turned out to have a dead body in the trunk. The defendant challenged the validity of the stop at appeal. The reason offered at trial for the stop was that a) there had been a string of auto burglaries in that area; b) it was dry but had rained earlier, and there were still water drops on the car - suggesting it had been parked a short time earlier; c) the freeway was almost empty but the vehicle as staying scrupulously at the speed limit. So the cop reason-ably suspected it could be a car thief and pulled the driver over to check. The court agreed.
They are subjected to the possibility of false positives or misleading true positives (it is their DNA but they didn't do the crime). These are low probability events but the population is fairly large and the number of suspect samples is also large and one images both will only grow in the future.
But I think the real problem is that it shows a certain lack of thoughtfulness when it comes to data use and governance. It doesn't seem like they considered themselves stewards of the most sensitive data possible from people who have suffered horribly. It's possible they weren't aware of the ethical quandary here or they didn't have the technological sophistication to develop a nuanced solution. Either case argues for more restriction in how the data are used while we as a society catch up to the implications of this evolving technology.
It needs to be placed in the category of evidence inadmissible in other crimes, because it's not there right now.
There's a reason that so called sanctuary cities are a good idea and it's because of thoughts like this. people avoiding reporting crimes to the police because they are fearful of being deported is exactly how more crime is perpetrated without fear of retribution on marginalized communities. If you are fearful of being arrested for a bench warrant over some parking ticket you couldn't pay for or some other matter... you will not seek help from the police.
A bench warrant is a court order. We have this famous law that says that no warrants shall issue but upon probable cause. If the court has done its job correctly, you only issue a warrant when you have justified suspicion of a crime.
Pulling someone's DNA from a database absent any other evidence of their involvement in a crime has no such judicial review failsafe.
So, yeah, this is different because one is just justice at work and the other is a really terrible fourth amendment violation.
IANAL, but I would presume this would be an illegal search and seizure and/or violate the protection against self-incrimination.
My understanding is that the cops would need a warrant to get DNA, and they need probable cause to get a warrant.
That is different than someone who has a bench warrant identifying themselves to police.
I share the common emotion that this is awful and shouldn't happen, but I have trouble justifying it intellectually.
Let's say, instead of DNA, it was an outstanding bench warrant. It seems pretty clear to me that the victim should have the help of the police in apprehending the rapist, but should also be arrested for the bench warrant. You might disagree, but there's no solving the problem of both needing the help of the police and being wanted for crimes. Waiting a day to serve the warrant, out of respect? Does that help?
This is different, yes, but how different? What changes to the database should be made here? Completely separate victim and suspect lists? It's burglary this time, what if it was homicide?
Not that you can separate victim and suspect when processing rape kit DNA! Eliminating common subsequences reduces the entropy and makes matches harder, we share a lot of SNPs in common.
My complete disgust that this happened remains, but this is one of the gnarliest ethical dilemmas I've seen.