Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her
by samatman on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @02:45PM
(#32828574)
That would be confusing yes. But you can't remove the victim's DNA from the offender's, without making it less likely to find a match. That question has an actual answer: you can't. It's literally a boolean thing: you have victim AND offender, if you XOR victim out, you lose some offender.
Legislation appears to be doing the right thing here, my question is whether the police did their duty or not. Someone signed a consent form to put them in a database that tagged them as a match. That's not a police discretion thing, it's not clear to me that damages are appropriate.
Fortunately I'm not a judge, just some guy on the internet.
Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her
by mirekrusin on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @03:15PM
(#32828975)
It's a bit of a drama with this house key and stuff, it's more like they took your picture when you were victim and later recognized you when you were offender and used address they saved back then to knock on your door.
Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her
by pessimizer on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @03:35PM
(#32829212)
Why would they take and hold pictures of the victims of crime?
Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her
by mirekrusin on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @01:52AM
(#32833726)
As part of standard case documentation procedure?
I think this is comparable to a key to your house that you gave to the police, because it was burglarized. They finished their investigations and hand the key back to you. What they did not tell you, is that they created a secret copy of your house keys and then five years later use it silently for searching through your house without a warrant.