News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by Majromax on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @01:43PM (#32827699)
> I share the common emotion that this is awful and shouldn't happen, but I have trouble justifying it intellectually.

Incentives.

The justification would be that sexual assault is a serious crime that goes underreported. If victims are afraid to come forward because they fear arrest for other, pettier offenses, then predators are even more likely to escape justice and commit more assaults.

Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by xapata on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @01:49PM (#32827812)
> pettier offenses

Really, any offenses. We could imagine that there's some method for abusing a policy of disallowing use of a victim's evidence to prosecute that victim for unrelated crimes, but until it happens, it's reasonable to ignore that possibility.

Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by listless on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @02:20PM (#32828257)
The most shocking thing in this article is that SF actually prosecuted a retail theft case and went so far as to get DNA? This is not the SF Fox News has been telling me about.
Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by olivermarks on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @02:33PM (#32828439)
It was arguably one of ex DA Boudin's stunts to make 'the system' look bad.

Boudin was on life support pre recall at this point in history and found the SFPD dna evidence issue which was a questionable use case of that data at best.

The woman had been arrested on suspicion of a felony property crime, with police identifying her based on rape-kit evidence she gave as a victim, part of a giant San Francisco only dna data bank her data was in and she matched to.

Given how incredibly hard Boudin made it for what is left of the SFPD to prevent crime this is one of those 'everyone loses' current realities

Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by braingenious on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @03:18PM (#32829022)
It’s fascinating how people will contort their brains to make every obviously shitty thing that SFPD does somehow the fault of their political boogeyman.

Can you point out the evidence that Boudin instructed the SFPD to use DNA evidence in the investigation of retail theft? Like is there a memo from the DA saying “I, Chesa Boudin, instruct you to collect DNA evidence for retail thefts, and make sure to mash the rape victim database up with the criminal database!”

I have never seen a group so fervently pro-police on this site as the pro-SFPD group (and I do not mean the anti-Boudin group, I mean the group that is critical of anyone that doesn’t tow the “poor SFPD, we would live in a utopia if only they had unlimited power” line.)

edit: Typos

Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by olivermarks on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @04:22PM (#32829722)
I was saying quite the opposite to 'Boudin instructed the SFPD to use DNA evidence in the investigation of retail theft'. What I actually attempted to say was the SFPD's questionable use of dna data was seized on by Boudin who was fighting for his political life at this point and amplified it as a weapon vs the SFPD.

We all lose because rape kit dna shouldn't be in the pool of felon dna data, the police were being impeded by Boudin at every turn resulting in inappropriate policing methods to try and get a federal case through. The streets of San Francisco are no longer safe for anyone as a result of this fiasco with the SFPD understaffed and relunctant to do much for fear of being on the wrong side of criminal advocate activists legal challenges....

Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by braingenious on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @04:31PM (#32829818)
> Boudin at every turn resulting in inappropriate policing methods to try and get a federal case through.

Your point is that the lack of evidence that Boudin was involved in this is the proof that this is his fault? Is there any scenario where anything SFPD does that’s shitty isn’t his fault?

Edit: When were the streets of San Francisco “safe” exactly? I wasn’t there during this horrible period between 2020 and 2022 but in 72 hours in SF a few years back:

-I saw people buying oxy from a guy in a tent, about ten feet from an occupied parked cop car

-About eight guys “running a train” (taking turns having penetrative sex) with a woman in an alley whilst they all smoked crack

-A woman taking a shit out of the window of a moving bus

-I was chased by a homeless man for five blocks because I only gave him a dollar and he kept demanding “more”

-I was forced to accept a dvd of truly depraved pornography at a bus stop

-I saw an adult shop openly selling cocaine

-Countless people shitting on the street

Does Chesa Boudin have a time machine? It sounds like I experienced exactly what the SFPD superfans say he caused.

Edit 2: This was during Garcon’s tenure.

Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by candiodari on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @04:01PM (#32829494)
Unless this is the police just grasping at straws to arrest someone and DNA evidence provided some link (no-one identified her at the scene), which is just wrong, the police knows it, but they have a connection and thus, maybe, a conviction ...
Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by s1artibartfast on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @08:38PM (#32831911)
That seems wild to me. What are the limitations to this and what is special about DNA. If someone makes a police report for rape and their ID comes back as wanted for murder, should the police look the other way as to not disincentivize rape reports?
Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by xapata on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @09:30PM (#32832262)
Perhaps so. Let's let that happen first, before we debate it. Oh, and there's nothing special about DNA in this respect. It just happens to be something collected during a rape investigation.
Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by Spivak on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @02:35PM (#32828455)
This is why if you've ever been to a music festival they make it absolutely explicitly clear that you can go to the on-site paramedics for anything and they won't incriminate you. Putting someone in a position where they have to weigh the risk of ODing verses a life-ruining jail sentence is how you end up with people dead.
Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by throwaway0a5e on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @03:51PM (#32829377)
>make it absolutely explicitly clear that you can go to the on-site paramedics for anything and they won't incriminate you.

There's surely a threshold at which they will gladly incriminate you. The paramedics just can't reasonably foresee where said line is other than knowing it's far beyond the typical illegal activity you find in that setting. Moreover, I'm sure you could imagine in the case of federal crimes (drug trafficking, terrorism, high profile national news stuff, etc) the feds having no qualms about threatening to drag the paramedics through an expensive prosecution if they don't narc.

Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by sidewndr46 on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @03:07PM (#32828852)
I've been to plenty of music festivals and never heard of this. Are you suggesting if I show up clutching a knife, bathed in human blood and covered in entrails that I'm not going to be incriminated for anything?
Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by braingenious on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @03:28PM (#32829127)
What if you showed up carrying a corpse with “I was murdered by the person carrying me” carved into their chest?

What if you showed up with a bomb vest? Or showed up in a stolen military helicopter?

I’m not sure what the value is of these very obvious cases where common sense dictates that there is a plain and obvious limitation to this policy. The point is obviously to limit harm that people do to themselves and one another, not to function as some sort of philosophical thought experiment made concrete.

What is the purpose of this “what about”?

Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by sidewndr46 on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @07:02AM (#32835479)
It's obviously meaningless, at least in the US. A private contract between two individuals in the US cannot abrogate the ability of a court to compel someone to testify in a criminal trial. When someone is put on the stand under oath, they're going to testify.

If the wording was something like "won't call the cops if you're way too fucking high" I'd find it more believable.

Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by braingenious on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @12:50PM (#32839822)
>If the wording was something like "won't call the cops if you're way too fucking high" I'd find it more believable.

That’s exactly what they mean, and that is painfully obvious. I do not understand your point here. What exactly are you having difficulty believing? Do you think they intend to advertise that they provide blanket cover for every crime on earth?

I am having difficulty believing that anyone would actually believe that that is what’s intended by that statement. It is much more believable that a person would intentionally misinterpret that statement to make some sort of vague joke about language.

Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by Spivak on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @03:46PM (#32829317)
Here let me just pick a festival that's happening soon https://www.lostlandsfestival.com/info/

> HARM REDUCTION

> Medical staff will be available 24 hours a day to help in any situation, and they will not incriminate anyone. Do not hesitate to visit medical tents or reach out to any staff member or security member.

Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by unethical_ban on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @03:25PM (#32829098)
Not literally anything. In the context of festivals, this probably means "illegal drug activities".

Did you really wonder if they meant "looking like a murderer is fine" or are you trolling?

Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by spoils19 on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @04:43PM (#32829952)
I think it's important to be clear and concise when discussing these things, otherwise people can easily get confused, like the poster. Keep in mind that some of us operate on rigidity and what may be obvious to you is not obvious to others.
Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by braingenious on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @08:40PM (#32831924)
By “us” do you mean that you also thought that this meant that medical tents at music festivals would provide cover for murder?
Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by pfdietz on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @02:31PM (#32828410)
You're right, that's a concern. The solution is to get everyone in the DNA database beforehand so there's no marginal cost of getting swabbed with a rape kit.
Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by zaroth on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @02:44PM (#32828552)
Totalitarianism is always a solution, it’s just also always the wrong solution.
Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by pfdietz on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @04:05PM (#32829559)
That's true, but it isn't relevant to the comment you are responding to.

I'm getting strong Godwin's Law vibes from your response, btw.

Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by manicdee on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @07:16PM (#32831358)
Godwin’s law doesn’t apply when talking about actual Nazis.

Pre-collecting DNA from everyone to use as evidence against them in future criminal investigations is way over the line when it comes to “is this behaviour totalitarian or fascist”.

Using DNA from a rape kit to identify someone in a crime is a clear violation of the 5th amendment.

Just because you can do something doesn’t mean you should.

Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by MichaelZuo on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @08:56PM (#32845633)
If the people vote for the government to collect everyone’s DNA at some future point in time, that’s just how a democracy works. Freedom and liberty includes the freedom and liberty to make poor decisions.
Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by zaroth on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @10:21PM (#32846239)
A democracy without the guardrails of a constitution can absolutely slip into totalitarianism thru entirely democratic means.

The majority vote can be rallied through fear and propaganda into vesting ever greater authority in a centralized seat of power, with any opposition vilified as an existential threat.

The only way democracy survives is through a watchful and untrusting populace that constantly holds its government to account and seeks to limit its power and pervasive reach into the lives of the citizenry.

Freedom and liberty require at its core the ability to dissent. Dissent in turn requires privacy because dissent by its very nature will be suppressed by those in power.

I would theorize that mandatory en masse DNA cataloging is anathema to democracy because it inevitably is far too powerful a tool to suppress dissent.

Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by MichaelZuo on Friday September 16, 2022 @09:50AM (#32866021)
The constitution can be almost arbitrarily amended, or even replaced almost entirely, if 3/4 of voters agree, or 3/4 of their representatives in a constitutional convention agrees... you do realize a specific portion of the U.S. constitution explicitly enumerates that possibility?
Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by manicdee on Saturday September 17, 2022 @10:58AM (#32878045)
If a population votes for the least worst government that doesn’t give that government permission to turn to autocracy slightly slower than the other option.
Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by MichaelZuo on Saturday September 17, 2022 @07:55PM (#32882873)
The government is given permission, presumably, for whatever the voters voted for.
Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by akudha on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @04:36PM (#32829878)
That is what the Kuwaiti government did, years ago. This might work for authoritarian governments, should not work in democracies
Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by AdrianB1 on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @10:45AM (#32837974)
It is a bad idea, but technically speaking it has nothing to do with democracy, they are orthogonal.
Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by pfdietz on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @05:11PM (#32830228)
Why shouldn't it work for democracies? In what sense is maintaining a DNA database incompatible with democracy?
Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by manicdee on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @07:22PM (#32831396)
Because using DNA collected from a victim of crime to prosecute them for a later crime is probably a violation of 5th amendment rights.

The next logical step if you don’t think the 5th was violated is collecting DNA from everyone (eg: repurposing COVID swabs) so you can identify all the potential suspects from your sampled population while completely ignoring that someone from outside the sampled population could be the person you are looking for.

Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by pfdietz on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @09:09PM (#32832102)
I don't see how this is unreasonable, when already we collect photographs (with ID cards). Or, more aptly, we already collect footprints of newborns, for purposes of identification. Collecting DNA for purposes of identification is almost the same thing.

Being able to positively identify people is a reasonable function of a government, including democratic governments.

Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by manicdee on Saturday September 17, 2022 @10:56AM (#32878028)
DNA testing is not positive identification.
Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her by s1artibartfast on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @08:40PM (#32831920)
The direct proposal was not to collect data from victims, but all innocent parties . no need for extrapolation.