Re:Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her
by ajross on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @02:17PM
(#32828227)
> Let's say, instead of DNA, it was an outstanding bench warrant.
A bench warrant is a court order. We have this famous law that says that no warrants shall issue but upon probable cause. If the court has done its job correctly, you only issue a warrant when you have justified suspicion of a crime.
Pulling someone's DNA from a database absent any other evidence of their involvement in a crime has no such judicial review failsafe.
So, yeah, this is different because one is just justice at work and the other is a really terrible fourth amendment violation.
A bench warrant is a court order. We have this famous law that says that no warrants shall issue but upon probable cause. If the court has done its job correctly, you only issue a warrant when you have justified suspicion of a crime.
Pulling someone's DNA from a database absent any other evidence of their involvement in a crime has no such judicial review failsafe.
So, yeah, this is different because one is just justice at work and the other is a really terrible fourth amendment violation.