News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by zamalek on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @10:39AM (#32824860)
Society is becoming a parody if itself. I understand that there are consequences of Mudge's information but, from a purely naive standpoint, having congress get involved over bots on a social network where people share 280 character messages is fucking bizarre.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by ryzvonusef on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @10:46AM (#32824957)
https://twitter.com/donie/status/1569695781631688704

> "It's not far fetched to say an employee inside the company could take over the accounts of all the Senators in this room," @dotMudge with a warning here on Captiol Hill. #Twitter

perhaps a valid reason?

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by bradleybuda on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:23AM (#32825502)
It's not far fetched to say a Senator's pilot could drop their airplane into the Delaware.

It's not far fetched to say a the line cook at a Senator's restaurant could poison their food.

It's not far fetched to say that a Senator's financial advisor could run off with their money.

It's not far fetched to say the teachers who instruct a Senator's kids could fill their heads with lies.

Humans have all sorts of ways to wreak destruction on one another but it mostly doesn't happen, and when it does, we have many, many systems in place to detect and punish. And we tend to scale the weight of these systems to the size of the perceived threat - that's why doctors and pilots are more burdened than bankers who are more burdened than cooks.

How likely is someone to actually take over these accounts (what's to gain)? How much damage would it do (not too much, people get hacked on Twitter all the time and that's baked in to the credulity of each tweet)? How likely is that employee to get caught (high), and how much punishment would they face (huge fines, possible jail time, unemployable in many industries for the rest of their lives).

Technical safeguards are not our only safeguards, especially for insider threats, which long predate the Internet. External hackers do dramatically change the calculus here (unlikely to get caught or punished) but that's not what's being alleged.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by pclmulqdq on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:46AM (#32825841)
Technical safeguards against insider threats do not actually protect you from insider threats - the fact that your behavior is logged and you will get fired and sued into oblivion works very well.

Technical safeguards against insider threats protect your insiders. They give your insiders cover in situations where they might be coerced to do things.

When I was at G, I likely could have read some data from cloud customers with some social engineering and the permissions I had. It would have taken hours to get the first byte, and I would have been fired within 10 minutes if I did without a good reason. The fact that it would have taken hours and some social engineering would let me plausibly tell the police (or the Chinese government or the mob or anyone else), "no, I don't have access to that data." Twitter's engineers didn't have that cover.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by MattPalmer1086 on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @02:26PM (#32828329)
I like your take on it providing cover for insiders against coercion. I hadn't considered that aspect before.

I'd slightly disagree that technical safeguards don't provide any protection against insider attacks. But yes, the deterrent effect of having a high chance of being caught is very effective.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by sangnoir on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @08:51PM (#32831984)
Weren't those controls added after some Googler stalked teenagers[1] via their chats for months? That event generated bad publicity in the press, and some years later, the same thing happened at Uber, with the euphemism "LoveOPS" being used, IIRC.

High-growth companies prefer to prioritize features and kick the access control can down the lane until they absolutely have to. Without looking at revenue and employee numbers, I suspect 2010 Google and 2016-ish Uber are comparable to current Twitter, IMO.

Edit: the Googler story is far worse that I remembered: he had unfettered access to underaged victims' mailboxes, chat logs, contacts and Voice accounts and used that information to taunt one victim, and unblocked himself from another victim who had blocked him on Gchat - Google only became aware of it when it was reported externally.

1. https://www.businessinsider.com/google-engineer-stalked-teen...

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by pclmulqdq on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @09:16PM (#32832156)
That incident inspired the alerts and the permissions checks. There were a few other incidents (not heinously bad if they were public, but potentially bad for G) that made them go all the way.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by bink on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @01:03PM (#32827062)
Not to defend Twitter because their lack of oversight and security controls around who can access what sounds completely inadequate and borderline criminal... but comparing any company to Google is unfair. Very, very few companies have the resources and experience that Google has dealing with these types of threats.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by michaelt on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:49AM (#32825885)
> It is not far fetched to say a Senator's pilot could drop their airplane into the Delaware.

Aviation has the state imposing licensing requirements, the state certifying which vehicles can take passengers, the state imposing technical requirements like transponders, the state investigating accidents, the state telling pilots when they can take off and land, the state searching passengers' luggage and sending them shuffling through scanners without their shoes, the state establishing no-fly lists, and the state wading into the industry and choosing winners and losers whenever it's geopolically convenient.

If you tell the senate you'd like the tech industry to be regulated no more heavily than the aviation industry we'd be in for a lot more regulation.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by bradleybuda on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @12:05PM (#32826129)
> [...] we tend to scale the weight of these systems to the size of the perceived threat - that's why doctors and pilots are more burdened than bankers who are more burdened than cooks
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by madeofpalk on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @12:06PM (#32826143)
> How likely is someone to actually take over these accounts? How much damage would it do?

We kind of have answers to these questions already:

- A rogue employee/contractor deactivated Trump's account back in 2017 https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/nov/03/experts-w...

- "130 high-profile Twitter accounts [including Apple, Barack Obama, Joe Biden, and Bill Gates] were compromised by outside parties to promote a bitcoin scam" using internal Twitter admin tools. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_Twitter_account_hijacking

The impact of both of these was basically zero.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by saltminer on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @12:59PM (#32826995)
There's also the fact that entire forums exist around selling accounts (or access to accounts). One such site, swapd.co, has a pinned post for Twitter "username claims" and "account recovery", among other things. This site has sold admin panel access that has been responsible for a lot of crypto scams [0] in the past.

Nobody's account is safe. Doesn't matter what 2FA methods you use, whether you're verified or not, how many followers you have, all it takes is a couple grand for someone else to take it over.

> The impact of both of these was basically zero.

Per the Wikipedia article you linked, the attackers got $110k in Bitcoin, which is not "basically zero" (even if the price of BTC has fallen since then).

[0]: https://www.web3isgoinggreat.com/?id=researcher-zachxbt-alle...

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by ohgodplsno on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @02:57PM (#32828728)
If taking over more than 100, extremely high profile accounts with millions upon millions of followers only nets you 100k and puts massive visibility on you, it's basically zero.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by aaaaaaaaata on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:39PM (#32833096)
And yet it's still happening.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by tschwimmer on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @12:50PM (#32826844)
Is it true that the impact of these incidents was zero? How much money did the bitcoin scam guys get?
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by codyb on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @10:49AM (#32824979)
They probably have a way to take over accounts to check bug reports.

We've had that at places I've worked. Where you'd be able to impersonate a user in order to see what was going on with their specific set of user data to corroborate their report and find a fix.

The question is... are the permissions locked down, is access audited and immutable, etc I think.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by bombcar on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @10:50AM (#32825004)
Yep, there's lots of software with "su for X" capabilities; it's much better than the normal method which is "ok tell me your password and I'll login as you and see what's up".
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by AndrewStephens on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @10:53AM (#32825053)
Well Duh! Of course a twitter employee could take over any account. Hopefully they have some internal safeguards in place but there are probably hundreds of people there that could take over an account if they wanted to, just as the owners of news.ycombinator.com could take over any account here.

You don't really own a Twitter (or Facebook, or ycombinator) account. Those services have an account on you. You update their account on you when you use their service to post (and they keep other information useful to their business on your account that you have no access to).

This is just the way social media works.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by michaelt on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:08AM (#32825283)
> Well Duh! Of course a twitter employee could take over any account.

Most companies the size of Twitter would have a lot more controls than that on random employees' write access to production.

If I want to assume a user's identity in my employer's production system I have to fill out a form justifying it, get my manager's approval for each account accessed, and my activity is subject to logging.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by madeofpalk on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @12:07PM (#32826165)
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by themaninthedark on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @12:21PM (#32826385)
Remember when an employee took down Trumps account? https://news.yahoo.com/rogue-twitter-employee-took-down-1419...

First it was "inadvertently deactivated due to human error by a Twitter employee." Then "Through our investigation we have learned that this was done by a Twitter customer support employee who did this on the employee’s last day."

It was kinda funny but you would expect that they would learn and improve from it.

Edit: Thank you siblings for showing that it has continued to happen. Obviously not lesson not learnt.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by encryptluks2 on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:52AM (#32825924)
So it can still be done, isn't that the original complaint?
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by armchairhacker on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @12:18PM (#32826349)
The point is that politicians shouldn’t be posting their important messages on Twitter, but an official government channel. This was discussed in 2016
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by Anon1096 on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:05AM (#32825238)
Was there an expectation of the opposite being true? You don't own a social media account. See all the people banned, shadowbanned, or who have had their @ handle or blue checkmarks taken from them. I thought it was accepted that the service provider can do whatever they want with a given account.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by zamalek on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:05AM (#32825250)
> perhaps a valid reason?

That's why I specifically said "from a naive standpoint." I'm not arguing against valid reasons, I'm pointing out how absurd the situation is.

From my comment:

> I understand that there are consequences of Mudge's information

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by capableweb on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @10:42AM (#32824900)
It's not about "bots on a social network", it's about misuse of peoples data in one of the worlds biggest social network.

Just as I tuned in, Mudge was talking about how Twitter repeatedly mismanaged peoples emails, citing that if they didn't sell emails, their competitors would get an unfair advantage.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by zhxshen on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @10:42AM (#32824904)
Are you even watching this? They're talking about foreign agents running amok on the inside (even after Twitter being notified by the FBI), lack of logging, mishandling of email addresses, etc, etc. Bots or no bots, all of that stuff is kind of a big deal.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @01:00PM (#32827005)
Given Twitter's centrality in the flow of information, it would be unreasonable to not expect foreign agents (along with extremists of every flavor, financial fraud artists, and who knows what else) to try to get inside.

The same is true of Facebook and Google.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by zhxshen on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @01:28PM (#32827468)
Foreign agents run amok before an FBI warning: sure, shit happens.

Foreign agents still running amok after an FBI warning: WTF?!

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by aaaaaaaaata on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:41PM (#32833100)
I'm not sure SoftBank/KSA is super concerned about "foreign agents" inside their company.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by zhxshen on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @06:48AM (#32835381)
apparently so
[dead]
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by zhxshen on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @03:11PM (#32828911)
Mudge isn't a politician, has an excellent reputation, and would probably be much happier if Twitter just had its shit together in the first place so he doesn't have to kick-off a whistlestop tour on the subpoena train. First stop: getting grilled for 2h40m by geriatric attorneys & faded beauty queens. In other words, I see no reason for him to lie about any of this.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by sangnoir on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @09:56PM (#32832401)
> I see no reason for him to lie about any of this

I don't know the guy or his circumstances,but as someone who's been aggrieved by a former employer/manager, I can think of at least one reason he may want to stir up a raucous.

It doesn't sound like he's lying, but nothing he's said sounds particularly egregious - relative to practices at other American tech companies and startups. The worst he could be accused of may be exaggeration or having standards that far exceed common practice.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by aaaaaaaaata on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:43PM (#32833109)
> I don't know the guy or his circumstances

Then I'm sorry, but your comment is malinformed.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by encryptluks2 on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @01:40AM (#32833674)
Based on what, your feelings? This is one of the most accurate authentic comments here.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by aaaaaaaaata on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @02:09AM (#32833796)
My feelings are:

1) this being common practice doesn't make it right

2) knowing someone's background, and deeply studying their historical writings, can provide a lot of color when evaluating someone's ethics, or any bias in their actions.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by sangnoir on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @12:44PM (#32839740)
> 1) this being common practice doesn't make it right

But that just makes Twitter normal - that doesn't deserve congressional hearings, or whistleblowing IMO. Doctor's only briefly talk to patients before moving on, and depend a lot on the file: I don't think that is right - but that's what the American standard of care seems to have settled on. If I were to sue a doctor for malpractice, alleging they'd have made a more accurate diagnosis by spending more time with me, a valid defense for them would be to show that they followed standard practice.

> 2) knowing someone's background, and deeply studying their historical writings, can provide a lot of color when evaluating someone's ethics, or any bias in their actions.

I learned from the New Yorker article that Mudge signed an 7- or 8-million dollar agreement with Twitter earlier this year that had a carve-out in its non-disparagement clause(s) for whistleblowing

That definitely "adds color"

[dead]
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by zhxshen on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @03:25PM (#32829093)
Comparing Mudge to a cop... Just Say No.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peiter_Zatko

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by encryptluks2 on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @03:46PM (#32829323)
Again, many similar people can build a positive public reputation but that doesn't mean they are immune from criticism or bad decision-making later in life. Epstein had a good reputation at one point. Larry Nasar had a good reputation at one point. Doesn't prevent people from doing bad things to further their own self-interests.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by aaaaaaaaata on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:44PM (#32833114)
> Epstein had a good reputation at one point.

With you? He never did with me.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by encryptluks2 on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @01:41AM (#32833681)
By former Presidents, CEOs, Prince's, etc. Glad you never got too close to him as there is no telling what kind of situation you'd end up in.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by colinmhayes on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @12:16PM (#32826317)
It's really not hard to find evidence of twitter security fuck ups. Multiple Saudi nationals have given up dissident information to the saudi government because of their access to twitter's internal geolocation tools. One of them fled the country after twitter told him the FBI was investigating him. Twitter practically forced everyone to give them their phone number and then leaked the numbers. The list goes on.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by encryptluks2 on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @02:10PM (#32828115)
Are you kidding me? The major credit bureaus have had just as many fuck ups. You don't see congress doing anything to fix it. There was a major utility shutdown due to security issues where they paid a ransom. Did you see Congress doing anything? This isn't exclusive to Twitter. Congress will use any situation to push their opportunistic rhetoric, and for them Twitter a social media company is more important to spread their propaganda than a credit bureau breach where everyone's personal data is compromised. What values does that show and teach, and why is that your talking point?
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by aaaaaaaaata on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:42PM (#32833104)
Who are you arguing for, and why?
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by encryptluks2 on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @02:00AM (#32833757)
I'm arguing for the people, who are you arguing for?
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by aaaaaaaaata on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @02:07AM (#32833783)
> and why

Anyway.

I feel I'm doing the same by promoting responsible disclosure of unethical treatment of people's data.

Did you even look at the guy's frigging Wikipedia page yet?! I just feel like we're talking past each other.

Reading through rest of thread...Is this a Musk-related thing for you?

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by encryptluks2 on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @05:37AM (#32834969)
> Did you even look at the guy's frigging Wikipedia page yet?!

Of course, but a Wikipedia page is not immune from bias nor does it provide unfettered credibility. I recall the same tactics and approaches being utilized in users pushing an agenda for Wikileaks, suggesting that they were basically perfect and incapable of doing any wrong and that Assange could do no harm. I don't give anyone a God-like status.

> Reading through rest of thread...Is this a Musk-related thing for you?

No, this is a personal experience kind of thing. I see this type of situation quite often where a topic will get people are riled up based on their political and personal biases and skew their critical-thinking ability to actually analyze the situation. If congress was actually concerned about people's data, they would have actually put forth efforts to enact some reasonable legislation that didn't just apply to whatever platform they feel the most censored on.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by aaaaaaaaata on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @08:11AM (#32836044)
Right, wrong, indifferent, Congress sits on ass until lobbyists pay them to move, or someone shames them into action.

So, again, following you — but I don't even know if I care in this instance because the enemy of my enemy (Twitter & any other entity acting trustworthy with people's data when knowing you're not worth the trust) is my friend.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by PKop on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @10:49AM (#32824988)
If you pretend a platform for mass media, journalism, and public discourse that certainly affects domestic and international politics is trivial, sure.

Just people huh? Not the Presidents, politicians, richest business men and high profile journalists right? To say nothing of all the other niche communities like finance and tech.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by esperent on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:04AM (#32825232)
> on a social network where people share 280 character messages is fucking bizarre. reply

Perhaps a less dismissive characterization of Twitter would help make it less bizarre?

It's a platform used by many leading public figures, including US presidents, to share information and the 280 character limit is a format that often leads to less filtered communication than you'd get in other mediums.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by SanjayMehta on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @10:52AM (#32825028)
Twitter is a propaganda network; whoever controls it, controls the narrative.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by thedorkknight on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:05AM (#32825248)
I don't disagree, but as a side note, "the narrative" always strikes me as a loaded word. It seems that generally when people use it, whatever they're referring to just so happens to be the "narrative" of the other side.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by SanjayMehta on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:08AM (#32825287)
True, but that's the way it's being used.

I can't think of a better word. Suggestions?

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by thedorkknight on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @12:09PM (#32826192)
It's more of the implied singularity of it that's problematic. There's no monolithic "narrative", there's a ton of "narratives", many of which are contradictory
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by nkozyra on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @10:53AM (#32825048)
How is that different than literally every other website or publication on earth?
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by illuminerdy on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @10:56AM (#32825109)
I think the scope and scale makes it different.

Social media has become extremely important to the free and open exchange of ideas between people.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by nkozyra on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @10:59AM (#32825145)
> I think the scope and scale makes it different.

Then what is the threshold wherein the natural inability to avoid bias becomes propaganda? Why is Twitter propaganda but not HN or my blog? When does it cross the line?

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by hackerlight on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:26AM (#32825537)
This is the binary bias[1].

You're trying to come up with hard distinctions and categories, when trying to do so is totally uninteresting and without any utility. I notice it's extremely common here on HN[2], perhaps because the job of an engineer involves working with categories, and something that's linguistically fuzzy is uncomfortable to them. I write more about this cognitive failing in the second half of my post here[3].

In short, there is no objective threshold wherein the natural inability to avoid bias becomes propaganda. And nor should we waste time on that point. Such a discussion is merely semantics around the definition of the word "propaganda". We should leave that to the people who compile dictionaries.

Such clouded thinking has created a blind spot here in this very thread, e.g. that someone can say something so ridiculous as "How is that different than literally every other website or publication on earth?" and not get downvoted, as if the practical difference between a social media platform with access to hundreds of millions of eyeballs on the one hand, and a small blog on the other, is not self-evident. Such an obvious difference can only not be self-evident to someone who is incapable of understanding that things can vary by degree instead of by category.

[1] https://www.psychologicalscience.org/news/releases/binary-bi...

[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32708833

[3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32674580

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by nkozyra on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @12:15PM (#32826297)
> Such an obvious difference can only not be self-evident to someone who is incapable of understanding that things can vary by degree instead of by category.

I'm sorry, but I'm asking how and why the number of people suddenly flips the switch to propaganda and all I'm seeing is a flippant dismissal from you.

It's my stance that it is not the number of people who see it that dictates that it's propaganda, and that the definition supplied fails to meet any real criteria for propaganda.

This isn't a binary bias, I'm not asking "is it or is it not?" I'm asking someone _why_ they think it's propaganda.

I find your response reductionist, and the appeal for downvotes snarky. I'll let citations of your own comments stand on its own merit.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by hackerlight on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @12:28PM (#32826487)
It was described as a propaganda network capable of controlling the narrative.

It is a matter of degree, but you keep insisting it's a matter of category.

If the CCP uses networks of bots to amplify pro-CCP stories and viewpoints on Twitter, then that's "different" (to answer your original question) in an extremely important way to if someone pushed those views on their own small blog. It's different because the scale and impact is different.

Also, both of those things belong, to some extent, to the category of "propaganda network capable of controlling the narrative". But one belongs to it more, and one is more of an issue, because the world isn't binary.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by nkozyra on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @12:39PM (#32826657)
> It was described as a propaganda network capable of controlling the narrative.

No, you added the second part. That could indeed bolster the argument, but it wasn't made in the initial claim.

If scope is the tipping point - which appears to be your argument here with regard to degree - recall my initial question was about the threshold. Which is conveniently what you're saying we should ignore because it's unimportant. So which is it?

I contend that one of the core tenets of "propaganda" is that there needs to be a deliberate and centralized. It's easy to call something propaganda but it's much harder to defend that claim.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by hackerlight on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @12:53PM (#32826904)
There is no tipping point. The premise of a tipping point means you're still thinking about category instead of degree.

Also, when we say degree, we don't mean the degree to which the definition fits. That's a boring discussion. We simply mean the degree to which it's a problem.

Twitter, to the extent that it's being used as a propaganda network by CCP bots, which it is, is a big problem for us.

A small blog being used for propaganda... not such a big problem.

That's the difference that you're missing. The scale and scope is different. Therefore the extent to which they're important is different.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by nkozyra on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @01:23PM (#32827381)
> There is no tipping point. The premise of a tipping point means you're still thinking about category instead of degree.

Quite the opposite. I've asked about degree the entire time. "Opinion" does not mean the same thing as "Propaganda," but the scale of the former could transform it into the latter.

What's the degree here? That's what I'm asking.

> That's a boring discussion.

This is dismissive. If you want to discuss things in good faith, please avoid language like this. You're refusing to engage with an aspect of my reply - and that's fine - but don't pretend my thought are meaningless or boring as a response.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by hackerlight on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @01:56PM (#32827930)
Of course opinion != propaganda. What is propaganda is a CCP bot network on Twitter.

I'm ending this convo here. It's become a tedious debate about semantics and nothing productive is being achieved.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by nkozyra on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @02:37PM (#32828470)
You entered a conversation and started calling my points boring and meaningless; I don't sense you were looking for productive conversation from the get-go.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by illuminerdy on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @12:22AM (#32833298)
It's impossible to set a definite standard for when a social media site or other website has become so crucial to the public square that it is set apart from general services.

You could use a multi-prong test like they do for determining whether an entity constitutes a monopoly.

Or you could use the old Justice Stewart's test for obscenity..."I know it when I see it."

But given what we've learned of late about the government influencing social media sites to censor citizens on their platforms, I don't think there's a legitimate argument that certain social media sites are not different from the general internet.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by thatguy0900 on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:30AM (#32825592)
I would say those things absolutely can be propoganda, but the government can only really enforce so much. Is it worth it for a gov employee to look at your blog for foreign government influence on elections? No. Twitter? Yes
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by encryptluks2 on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:57AM (#32826001)
Foreign election influencers absolutely may absolutely use popular blogs, especially when sharing information on other social media to recruit users into a certain personality trait.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by deltree7 on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @12:54PM (#32826922)
Sinclair broadcasting has a far broader reach and actually influences ideologies that you can draw a direct correlation to ideology and Sinclair broadcast viewers.

None of Twitter/FB/Youtube has that kind of correlation

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by SanjayMehta on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:07AM (#32825270)
Unlike publications and most other websites, Twitter is near real time.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by nkozyra on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:14AM (#32825380)
That's the differentiation between propaganda and not? Sorry, that doesn't make much sense to me.

Most of the "real time" aspect of Twitter is a reaction to something, often publications themselves.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by encryptluks2 on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:55AM (#32825976)
Same for news stations, Facebook, Instagram, reddit, etc. Any platform where people share information can be a propaganda network. Should we make it all state owned now?
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by themaninthedark on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @12:29PM (#32826507)
Who is saying Twitter needs to be state owned? People are saying they need to comply with rules and regulations that govern it. People are saying the maybe new rules and regulations need to be enacted.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by encryptluks2 on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @04:11PM (#32829609)
What rules and regulations? Congress isn't a court. There has been no discovery to show that they are not following rules and regulations.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by marcinzm on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @10:57AM (#32825125)
I'd hope congress pays some attention to anything which 80 million Americans use or interact with.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by TheRealDunkirk on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:09AM (#32825299)
I think you're missing the point entirely. The fact that the world has gone bonkers over this whole farce proves that Twitter is just as influential as the most jaded critic has suspected.

And then you stop and realize that the user numbers on Twitter are DWARFED by Facebook (and Instagram and TikTok), and you realize just how screwed we really are.

And all for the sake of making some people insanely rich, by flooding every aspect of our lives with advertising.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by thelock85 on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @01:42PM (#32827690)
> Society is becoming a parody of itself.

We've accepted emotional, mental, spiritual, and physical (to some extent) abstractions of ourselves as our true selves. And exchanged social cues for algorithms to manipulate our behaviors.

In the moments when you can break out of that abstraction the parody becomes so clear, and also terrifying. Like what are we actually building towards?

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by faeriechangling on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @09:04PM (#32832066)
I’ve been hearing people downplay the seriousness of things on the internet my entire life and I’m mostly surprised at this point that people think that taking twitter seriously is such a ridiculous notion.

If you instead say “international information system responsible for sending 500m messages daily including by senior govt/business officials has poor stewardship” I think it doesn’t seem so rediculous that senior government officials are so concerned. They all use Twitter, why wouldn’t they be concerned? You could easily cause militarily significant damage to a country with a good hack against twitter.

There was a very politically significant insurrection organized on twitter, this system has already been used to direct an angry mob in the general direction of these high level government officials who proceeded to attempt to break down barricades and assault them.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by RunSet on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:31AM (#32825612)
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by sc68cal on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @10:53AM (#32825041)
This is all being done so that Elon Musk can back out of his contract to buy Twitter
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by smt88 on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:02AM (#32825206)
I hate Musk, but who cares what the motivation is?

Shedding light on an (unfortunately very) influential company is good for the public.

Musk shouldn't get out of his deal, but whatever he does to reveal malpractice at Twitter is good for all of us.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by aaaaaaaaata on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:46PM (#32833122)
Or any/all large corps that hold extortion-level userdata on everybody, statistically speaking.