News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by SanjayMehta on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @10:52AM (#32825028)
Twitter is a propaganda network; whoever controls it, controls the narrative.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by thedorkknight on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:05AM (#32825248)
I don't disagree, but as a side note, "the narrative" always strikes me as a loaded word. It seems that generally when people use it, whatever they're referring to just so happens to be the "narrative" of the other side.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by SanjayMehta on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:08AM (#32825287)
True, but that's the way it's being used.

I can't think of a better word. Suggestions?

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by thedorkknight on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @12:09PM (#32826192)
It's more of the implied singularity of it that's problematic. There's no monolithic "narrative", there's a ton of "narratives", many of which are contradictory
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by nkozyra on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @10:53AM (#32825048)
How is that different than literally every other website or publication on earth?
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by illuminerdy on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @10:56AM (#32825109)
I think the scope and scale makes it different.

Social media has become extremely important to the free and open exchange of ideas between people.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by nkozyra on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @10:59AM (#32825145)
> I think the scope and scale makes it different.

Then what is the threshold wherein the natural inability to avoid bias becomes propaganda? Why is Twitter propaganda but not HN or my blog? When does it cross the line?

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by hackerlight on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:26AM (#32825537)
This is the binary bias[1].

You're trying to come up with hard distinctions and categories, when trying to do so is totally uninteresting and without any utility. I notice it's extremely common here on HN[2], perhaps because the job of an engineer involves working with categories, and something that's linguistically fuzzy is uncomfortable to them. I write more about this cognitive failing in the second half of my post here[3].

In short, there is no objective threshold wherein the natural inability to avoid bias becomes propaganda. And nor should we waste time on that point. Such a discussion is merely semantics around the definition of the word "propaganda". We should leave that to the people who compile dictionaries.

Such clouded thinking has created a blind spot here in this very thread, e.g. that someone can say something so ridiculous as "How is that different than literally every other website or publication on earth?" and not get downvoted, as if the practical difference between a social media platform with access to hundreds of millions of eyeballs on the one hand, and a small blog on the other, is not self-evident. Such an obvious difference can only not be self-evident to someone who is incapable of understanding that things can vary by degree instead of by category.

[1] https://www.psychologicalscience.org/news/releases/binary-bi...

[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32708833

[3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32674580

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by nkozyra on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @12:15PM (#32826297)
> Such an obvious difference can only not be self-evident to someone who is incapable of understanding that things can vary by degree instead of by category.

I'm sorry, but I'm asking how and why the number of people suddenly flips the switch to propaganda and all I'm seeing is a flippant dismissal from you.

It's my stance that it is not the number of people who see it that dictates that it's propaganda, and that the definition supplied fails to meet any real criteria for propaganda.

This isn't a binary bias, I'm not asking "is it or is it not?" I'm asking someone _why_ they think it's propaganda.

I find your response reductionist, and the appeal for downvotes snarky. I'll let citations of your own comments stand on its own merit.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by hackerlight on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @12:28PM (#32826487)
It was described as a propaganda network capable of controlling the narrative.

It is a matter of degree, but you keep insisting it's a matter of category.

If the CCP uses networks of bots to amplify pro-CCP stories and viewpoints on Twitter, then that's "different" (to answer your original question) in an extremely important way to if someone pushed those views on their own small blog. It's different because the scale and impact is different.

Also, both of those things belong, to some extent, to the category of "propaganda network capable of controlling the narrative". But one belongs to it more, and one is more of an issue, because the world isn't binary.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by nkozyra on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @12:39PM (#32826657)
> It was described as a propaganda network capable of controlling the narrative.

No, you added the second part. That could indeed bolster the argument, but it wasn't made in the initial claim.

If scope is the tipping point - which appears to be your argument here with regard to degree - recall my initial question was about the threshold. Which is conveniently what you're saying we should ignore because it's unimportant. So which is it?

I contend that one of the core tenets of "propaganda" is that there needs to be a deliberate and centralized. It's easy to call something propaganda but it's much harder to defend that claim.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by hackerlight on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @12:53PM (#32826904)
There is no tipping point. The premise of a tipping point means you're still thinking about category instead of degree.

Also, when we say degree, we don't mean the degree to which the definition fits. That's a boring discussion. We simply mean the degree to which it's a problem.

Twitter, to the extent that it's being used as a propaganda network by CCP bots, which it is, is a big problem for us.

A small blog being used for propaganda... not such a big problem.

That's the difference that you're missing. The scale and scope is different. Therefore the extent to which they're important is different.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by nkozyra on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @01:23PM (#32827381)
> There is no tipping point. The premise of a tipping point means you're still thinking about category instead of degree.

Quite the opposite. I've asked about degree the entire time. "Opinion" does not mean the same thing as "Propaganda," but the scale of the former could transform it into the latter.

What's the degree here? That's what I'm asking.

> That's a boring discussion.

This is dismissive. If you want to discuss things in good faith, please avoid language like this. You're refusing to engage with an aspect of my reply - and that's fine - but don't pretend my thought are meaningless or boring as a response.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by hackerlight on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @01:56PM (#32827930)
Of course opinion != propaganda. What is propaganda is a CCP bot network on Twitter.

I'm ending this convo here. It's become a tedious debate about semantics and nothing productive is being achieved.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by nkozyra on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @02:37PM (#32828470)
You entered a conversation and started calling my points boring and meaningless; I don't sense you were looking for productive conversation from the get-go.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by illuminerdy on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @12:22AM (#32833298)
It's impossible to set a definite standard for when a social media site or other website has become so crucial to the public square that it is set apart from general services.

You could use a multi-prong test like they do for determining whether an entity constitutes a monopoly.

Or you could use the old Justice Stewart's test for obscenity..."I know it when I see it."

But given what we've learned of late about the government influencing social media sites to censor citizens on their platforms, I don't think there's a legitimate argument that certain social media sites are not different from the general internet.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by thatguy0900 on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:30AM (#32825592)
I would say those things absolutely can be propoganda, but the government can only really enforce so much. Is it worth it for a gov employee to look at your blog for foreign government influence on elections? No. Twitter? Yes
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by encryptluks2 on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:57AM (#32826001)
Foreign election influencers absolutely may absolutely use popular blogs, especially when sharing information on other social media to recruit users into a certain personality trait.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by deltree7 on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @12:54PM (#32826922)
Sinclair broadcasting has a far broader reach and actually influences ideologies that you can draw a direct correlation to ideology and Sinclair broadcast viewers.

None of Twitter/FB/Youtube has that kind of correlation

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by SanjayMehta on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:07AM (#32825270)
Unlike publications and most other websites, Twitter is near real time.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by nkozyra on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:14AM (#32825380)
That's the differentiation between propaganda and not? Sorry, that doesn't make much sense to me.

Most of the "real time" aspect of Twitter is a reaction to something, often publications themselves.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by encryptluks2 on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:55AM (#32825976)
Same for news stations, Facebook, Instagram, reddit, etc. Any platform where people share information can be a propaganda network. Should we make it all state owned now?
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by themaninthedark on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @12:29PM (#32826507)
Who is saying Twitter needs to be state owned? People are saying they need to comply with rules and regulations that govern it. People are saying the maybe new rules and regulations need to be enacted.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by encryptluks2 on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @04:11PM (#32829609)
What rules and regulations? Congress isn't a court. There has been no discovery to show that they are not following rules and regulations.