News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by londons_explore on Sunday September 11, 2022 @03:20AM (#32797525)
I'd really like to see 'forever' domain registration.

Pay your fee once, and the domain stays active forever.

The cost of running the servers for a top level domain are really small, and probably going down with time, so it should be possible for the domain registrar to keep operations going with just a trickle of new registrations.

As a compromise, perhaps you could charge a nominal fee for domain name ownership transfers.

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by masukomi on Sunday September 11, 2022 @08:56AM (#32799234)
I believe that the owners of a custom TLD (like amazon's .pay) have to pay ICANN every year to keep that TLD alive. I believe it's over $100k annually.

as such, a forever registration would have to be a quasi-pyramid scheme where the initial users keep their domains only so long as there are more new users coming in each year than existed in all the past years combined (or something similar depending on charges).

also, what good is a forever domain when it doesn't also have forever hosting? You die, the domain continues on forever, your hosting provider stops hosting and now no-one else can ever use that domain. Kind-of a jerk move in the end.

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by quintushoratius on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:09AM (#32799739)
> You die, the domain continues on forever, your hosting provider stops hosting and now no-one else can ever use that domain.

So not that different than today. You stop paying for your domain and squatters make sure no one can ever register that domain, for a reasonable fee, ever again.

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by lalopalota on Sunday September 11, 2022 @11:10AM (#32800254)
but they are using it. for some definition of "using".
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by ctxc on Sunday September 11, 2022 @11:28AM (#32800447)
That's...worse. Isn't "using" it to make sure it's unused till you get paid worse than it not being used right now but open to being usefully used by someone who intends to fully use it in the future?
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by est31 on Sunday September 11, 2022 @11:14AM (#32800297)
> as such, a forever registration would have to be a quasi-pyramid scheme where the initial users keep their domains only so long as there are more new users coming in each year than existed in all the past years combined

It doesn't have to be a pyramid scheme. The registrar can also invest the money, and use the interest as revenue. So instead of paying 40 USD annually you pay 1000 USD for the initial registration. 4% interest of that would be 40 USD.

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by powersnail on Sunday September 11, 2022 @11:31AM (#32800472)
What happens if the investment fucks up, and the registrar goes broke? Where does the domain buyer get the next renewal for free?
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by saulpw on Sunday September 11, 2022 @12:12PM (#32800856)
insurance
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by syrrim on Sunday September 11, 2022 @12:34PM (#32801047)
If they took your fee then invested it in some reliable asset, they could theoretically continue to earn an annuity on it indefinitely, which they could use to pay ICANN's fee, any server fees, etc. A hosting company could do the same.
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by arinlen on Sunday September 11, 2022 @03:38AM (#32797592)
> Pay your fee once, and the domain stays active forever.

Beyond domain squatters, who would benefit from that?

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by londons_explore on Sunday September 11, 2022 @03:47AM (#32797627)
It's part of the solution for a zero maintenance web presence.

It means I could maybe publish my memoirs and family tree and have it still available in 500 years.

It also makes web domains like other property - you don't purchase a nice watch and then expect it to be reassigned to someone else if you don't pay your annual watch renewals.

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by Arainach on Sunday September 11, 2022 @03:55AM (#32797669)
I do expect my property to be reassigned if I don't pay my property taxes. Eternal ownership allows those who had power and money in the past to continue to have that power indefinitely, and is very detrimental to society.
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by omgwtfbyobbq on Sunday September 11, 2022 @04:07AM (#32797737)
That should be minimized as long as a limited number of domains per person (excluding legal entities) are allowed in a limited number of tlds.

Your property is both relatively scarce, limited, and requires significant service compared to random domains on some random tld.

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by quintushoratius on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:12AM (#32799768)
Domains may not experience scarcity per se, but desirableness quickly falls of as the strings get more random.

Everyone would love to have a three- or four-letter domain but, like land, they're not making new characters for the ASCII alphabet.

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by omgwtfbyobbq on Sunday September 11, 2022 @05:08PM (#32803284)
We could restrict those too. Any desirable length, words, numbers, etc, could just be treated like normal domains.
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by nly on Sunday September 11, 2022 @07:15AM (#32798662)
If property prices always go up, in theory you could just finance the property to pay the taxes indefinitely
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by ekianjo on Sunday September 11, 2022 @09:16AM (#32799369)
bad analogy. in effect you never own a TLD so its not a tax on ownership.
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by arinlen on Sunday September 11, 2022 @04:15AM (#32797778)
> It means I could maybe publish my memoirs and family tree and have it still available in 500 years.

This usecase makes no sense at all. If you plan to have a server going after you're no longer able to maintain a server, your only option is to pay someone to manage your infrastructure and/or services. Once you're paying some company to manage your infrastructures, managing domains becomes a subitem in your invoice.

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by hfsh on Sunday September 11, 2022 @05:45AM (#32798266)
You don't expect the watch to hang around forever, either. You'll lose it, sell it, or it will break. We don't want a future with indestructible watches littering the streets.
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by jefftk on Sunday September 11, 2022 @06:50AM (#32798549)
It could be "foo.tld2022", with YYYY registrable only in that year. Won't get in the way of future folks.
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by dane-pgp on Sunday September 11, 2022 @01:36PM (#32801569)
For memorials, it could be as uniform as firstname.lastname.disambiguation.birthyear.deathyear with the requirement that each person could only register one domain under the birthyear.deathyear root.

To get around the problem of a numeric TLD, I suggest using Roman numerals (and telling Myanmar it has to go back to using .bu).

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by lalopalota on Sunday September 11, 2022 @11:13AM (#32800283)
that also implies forever hosting of content, not just the domain.
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by doodlesdev on Sunday September 11, 2022 @12:04PM (#32800782)
Solvable through IPFS. When it comes to the domain, an onion v3 domain or unstoppable domains are good bets, although I really don't expect _any_ of our current computer infrastructure to exist within 500 years.
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by tialaramex on Sunday September 11, 2022 @08:46AM (#32799181)
> It means I could maybe publish my memoirs and family tree and have it still available in 500 years.

While I'm sure this would be great for your ego, it makes no actual sense. Very few documents from so long ago are available, not because it was somehow miraculously impossible to preserve documents but because overwhelmingly people don't give a shit.

You are demanding that future people should give a shit, and they aren't going to oblige.

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by andrepd on Sunday September 11, 2022 @09:15AM (#32799353)
?? Writing down your memoirs is "demanding other people give a shit"? What an odd way to view things.

I for one love to read historical documents and primary sources. I'm glad some people in ancient times had the foresight to record a bit of their lives in the hope that future generations might find it interesting.

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by rhodorhoades on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:26AM (#32799882)
Do you have any good memoirs you’d recommend?

I’ve always found personal accounts and memoirs to be the best kind of writing. You get to read beneath the surface between the person they were, the person they wanted to be and the worldly circumstances they found themselves in.

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by quintushoratius on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:23AM (#32799856)
Permanent hosting costs money, so you are in effect demanding that future folks give a shit about you.

You always have the option of committing your memoirs to stone, absorbing the long-term cost up front yourself.

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by hotpotamus on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:43AM (#32800004)
Do the math (I'm a bit lazy and not that great at it) to think about how many ancestors you have from 500 years ago (I know enough about math to know it's an exponential function), and then think about how long it would take to read all of their memoirs and you begin to realize the problem.

Of course, go far back enough (I'm not sure if 500 years is enough) and mathematically speaking, the number of your ancestors will exceed the population of the world, which shows some other issues that you run into.

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by hotpotamus on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:39AM (#32799978)
The Carnegie Corporation might disagree with this somewhat, though I suppose it's only been acting as a dead hand of its founder for a touch over a century now, not the five that GP is going for.
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by grumbel on Sunday September 11, 2022 @04:19AM (#32797787)
Require the domain name to be a UUID or include the date or something else that makes it unsquattable. The domain being actually forever is far more important than it being pretty. Most people will use a search engine for lookup anyway, but it's the forever domain name that is a first step in preventing links from getting broken.

That said, this is not something I expect to happen in the regular Web, this seems to be a job for IPFS, blockchain or whatever. With plain HTTP, even if you have your forever domain, you'd still have the issue that the webserver it is pointing to can change, break or just disappear.

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by bombcar on Sunday September 11, 2022 @05:16AM (#32798120)
You’ve described an onion domain basically.
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by arinlen on Sunday September 11, 2022 @04:23AM (#32797809)
> Require the domain name to be a UUID or include the date or something else that makes it unsquattable.

What's the benefit of a UUID over a raw IP address?

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by IYasha on Sunday September 11, 2022 @06:52AM (#32798560)
IP addressess change. In my practice not-so-small hosting provides made a few changes in last 10 years.
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by bzxcvbn on Sunday September 11, 2022 @11:18AM (#32800341)
Do you also expect to get a forever DNS server that will host your zone without ever getting paid?
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by xigoi on Sunday September 11, 2022 @05:54AM (#32798313)
You can change the hosting for the website.
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by kube-system on Sunday September 11, 2022 @04:28AM (#32797837)
Certificates?
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by arinlen on Sunday September 11, 2022 @05:29AM (#32798183)
> Certificates?

Not a technical requirement. Subject alternative name (SAN) certificates support IP addresses.

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by tialaramex on Sunday September 11, 2022 @07:17AM (#32798675)
More clearly, "SAN certificates" aren't a thing. Since PKIX all certificates in the Web PKI were required to have the Internet's names on them as SANs. For several years now, web browsers only look at the SANs to make decisions. The Common Name from the X.500 system is only there for humans to look at, and for legacy software which still thinks that's a good idea decades after we explained why it isn't. Ideally we'd one day get rid of it (wastes bytes on the wire), but I won't hold my breath.

Unlike the Common Name, which is arbitrary human text (so e.g. " oops.example" is a valid name despite that space at the start, as are "c-programming.example\0\0\0" and "Ł0Ł.example") the SANs are defined so that it's harder to screw up and a machine can reliably just bit-for-bit compare the data. There are two main kinds: IpAddress SANs are defined for the IPv4 or IPv6 address just as bits, you can't express 200.300.400.500 as an IpAddress, whereas that's a (stupid but) valid Common Name; DnsName SANs are defined using a restricted character set and as specifically the ASCII LDH DNS hostname subset, which makes it much less tempting to try to incorrectly write a Unicode name here, what's actually required is the ASCII LDH name, ie Punycode.

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by forgotpwd16 on Sunday September 11, 2022 @05:14AM (#32798106)
As those domains will be expensive compared to common ones since it's expected you'll be paying the equivalent of a number of renewal years, squatting will be a much more expensive business to do.
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by CodesInChaos on Sunday September 11, 2022 @03:51AM (#32797648)
I don't see how squatters would benefit more from that than other people registering domains. If anything I'd expect them to prefer a recurring fee over a high upfront fee.
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by arinlen on Sunday September 11, 2022 @04:09AM (#32797746)
> I don't see how squatters would benefit more from that than other people registering domains.

Registering a domain is not an issue to anyone.

Some domain name registrars even offer multi-year subscription plans for those who don't want to bother with the 5minute work it takes to extend a subscription, and send out warnings months in advance to renew subscriptions.

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by jwilk on Sunday September 11, 2022 @04:50AM (#32797970)
Which registrars offer that?
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by arinlen on Sunday September 11, 2022 @05:34AM (#32798211)
> Which registrars offer that?

I expect all of them, and I'd be very surprised if any domain name registrar didn't offered this feature.

For example, both Namecheap and GoDaddy allow customers to extend domain registrations up to 10 years in one go.

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by tzs on Sunday September 11, 2022 @11:12AM (#32800276)
If anyone is curious as to why it is 10 years nearly everywhere, that limit comes from ICANN.

Network Solutions does offer a 100 year plan (and used to offer a 1000 year plan, but I just checked and that one is gone) but the way the implement is by registering for 10 years and then every year for the next 90 years adding a year.

You only really have the domain registered for 10 years, and you are betting the Network Solutions will still be around for 90 more years, and Network Solutions is betting that the price they have to pay for domains in that TLD will not have gone up so much that the total cost of all those extensions is more than what they earned by having your initial large [1] upfront payment invested for 100 years.

My recommendation: register your domain for 10 years. Don't turn on auto-renewal. Add an annual "Check my domain registration" item to your calendar. When that items come up each year either (1) add another year to your domain, or (2) check to see if it is near expiration and add years.

[1] $1600 for 100 years of a random .com.

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by jwilk on Monday September 12, 2022 @09:13AM (#32809621)
The 100 year plan is for $999: https://www.networksolutions.com/domain-name-registration/po...

Do you remember how much the 1000 year plan costed?

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by tzs on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @11:09AM (#32838332)
No, and I can't find anything on it so it is possible that I misremembered. I definitely remember that they had a plan that was longer than the ICANN maximum and another plan that was way longer than that one, but it may have been 20 years and 100 years rather than 100 years and 1000 years.
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by MerelyMortal on Sunday September 11, 2022 @08:33AM (#32799116)
Limit it to one per real person (not oganization etc)
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by saargrin on Sunday September 11, 2022 @05:20AM (#32798142)
i would like to have a permanent email for example .. a service for which i now pay godaddy though they dont actually do anything other than DNS
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by nottorp on Sunday September 11, 2022 @03:04PM (#32802318)
> Pay your fee once, and the domain stays active forever.

We had that for the .ro TLD. What happened was that a lot of useful domain names got acquired by random entities and sat there unused. And i don't mean "you can have this domain for $5K" unused, properly unused.

They switched to a yearly fee model (about 1/5 of what the forever fee was, plus credit if you paid the forever fee in the past 5 years) and that seems to have cleaned up the space a bit.

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by tzs on Sunday September 11, 2022 @11:58AM (#32800732)
I don't think that would work well with the existing TLDs, where domain names often have meaning other than as just a domain name, and there is often more than one person or organization that would want that specific name.

Maybe make a new TLD specifically for infinitely lasting names, say .permanent, and make all top level names under that be 128 bit numbers in some text format randomly generated when you register the domain such as hex or base64. E.g., f560618f355b0ddf560456d41d635e3d.permanent or 9WBhjzVbDd9WBFbUHWNePQ==.permanent.

With those names it doesn't matter that they get locked up forever with the initial registrant.

> As a compromise, perhaps you could charge a nominal fee for domain name ownership transfers.

When the name is generated also generate a public/private key pair and associate the public key with the name at the top level servers. Someone is considered to own the domain if they can prove that they have the corresponding private key.

The top level would allow someone who has the private key to ask for a new key pair to be generated to replace the current one.

Want to transfer ownership? Give the new owner the private key and they can use it to do a key change.

This should allow making the top level service entirely automated and cheap to run.

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by larsiusprime on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:53AM (#32800090)
That’s what unstoppable domains supposedly offers, or so I’ve heard.

Vitalik Buterin wrote an interesting analysis about how to allocate scarce domains, contrasting unstoppable’s approach with recurring demand based fees:

https://progressandpoverty.substack.com/p/should-there-be-de...

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by CydeWeys on Sunday September 11, 2022 @11:15AM (#32800310)
Those aren't real domain names though, as they aren't reachable from normal DNS servers. >99.9% of people cannot use these.
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by larsiusprime on Sunday September 11, 2022 @03:28PM (#32802504)
Yeah, I’m fairly skeptical of crypto stuff myself. Do read vitalik’s article though, it has a lot of applications for domain allocation and isn’t dependent on crypto at all.
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by jameshart on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:25PM (#32805355)
Forever is, as Prince once pointed out, a mighty long time.

Requiring periodic renewal ensures that the entity that is responsible for the domain is still alive, and still wants it. Allowing an entity to register a domain forever creates the possibility of zombie domains, registered forever through a registrar who has long since gone bust, by a registrant who long ago lost their password... but the registry is obliged to still maintain the last state of that domain's NS records forever.

Nobody would be able to initiate a transfer; nobody would be able to buy the domain off the owner... the resource would be permanently dead.

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by geysersam on Sunday September 11, 2022 @04:53AM (#32797979)
Yes please, that'd be amazing. However, it would be good to have some kind of system to weed out unused domains for other uses. Otherwise I imagine we'd have lots of occupied but abandoned domain names.
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by ValentineC on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:34AM (#32799946)
I've thought about this too, and it should somewhat be possible to set up some form of long-lived association, with day-to-day management outsourced to professional service providers.

The one-time cost for a domain should be substantial, with the capital put into long-term investments like index funds, which are then used to pay domain renewal (and maybe static webhosting) costs year after year.

If people can set up trust funds for their families and estates, I don't see why it's not possible to do a niche "trust fund" for websites.

Happy to have someone steal my idea. :)

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by CydeWeys on Sunday September 11, 2022 @11:15AM (#32800307)
We looked into it, but it's essentially impossible under current ICANN rules, which require that domain registrations have an integer number of years of validity of 1 to 10.
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by RedShift1 on Sunday September 11, 2022 @03:29AM (#32797552)
What happens when you die?
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by noisy_boy on Sunday September 11, 2022 @03:41AM (#32797605)
One can start with "forever" being, say, 125 years (Wikipedia says that the longest lived person recorded was slightly over 120). So domain expiry date=current date+125-current age. When human beings routinely start living longer than that, it can be revised.
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by ngcc_hk on Sunday September 11, 2022 @03:54AM (#32797664)
Well like graveyard sone just want to leave a stone there forever next to the church. It is sometimes good read. And each of our existence is unique even if may not be “important” to all or any. Still …

Forever is good. Especially if you know it is forever than you say thing that you want to say forever.

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by edent on Sunday September 11, 2022 @04:04AM (#32797727)
Most graveyards don't work like that - at least not in my part of the world. Graves are regularly re-used and stones are moved.

We can't expect the dead to continue to exert pressure over the living.

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by IceWreck on Monday September 12, 2022 @03:29AM (#32807142)
But the thing is I want my stuff to stay up long after I die. Kind of like my gravestone on the internet where I can choose what to put.

I dont care if it eventually gets lost amongst the huge amount of content but I still want my stuff to be out there.

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by vntok on Sunday September 11, 2022 @03:43AM (#32797615)
What happens when you die before reaching 125 years old?
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by noisy_boy on Sunday September 11, 2022 @04:59AM (#32798011)
Doesn't matter; the domain is "forever". Because if you want to expire it upon death, none of these assumptions/calculations are needed - put that in the clause and done (enforcement is another thing though).
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by politelemon on Sunday September 11, 2022 @03:44AM (#32797616)
I'd say nothing, it continues to stay in my name and cannot be registered by anyone else, ever. The domain hosting service may disappear, and that's fine too.
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by colordrops on Sunday September 11, 2022 @01:45PM (#32801641)
This is one application where blockchain tech could actually solved a real world problem. There are workable DNS systems tied to the Blockchain, which would allow for permanent unassailable domains with no central authority to take it away. Widespread adoption is of course the main issue.
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by smileybarry on Sunday September 11, 2022 @07:57AM (#32798877)
It would have to be regulated to some degree to prevent extreme squatting, e.g.: one domain per ID would be a good start. Maybe one that isn’t a trademark too? Sort of paving the way for a name/pseudonym domain to be registered this way.
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by forgotpwd16 on Sunday September 11, 2022 @05:11AM (#32798082)
This reminds me, Epik markets a 'forever' domain registration. Not what you're asking though as they just renew a domain perpetually so depends on domain operator remaining active (as well as Epik itself).
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by generalizations on Sunday September 11, 2022 @08:58AM (#32799244)
Put it on ipfs. Long as someone cares, it'll stay up there.
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by kevincox on Sunday September 11, 2022 @09:16AM (#32799362)
Not really if you want mutability.

IPNS "records" have a TTL so you need someone with the key actively re-publishing them. I guess in theory you could publish for a very long time but you risk issues of someone maliciously re-sharing an older record that hasn't expired.

I guess once you die you can hope that someone has recorded the last version so you can "move" from IPNS to a regular CID. But IDK how much I would want to rely on that for long-term legacy especially if the TTL on your IPNS record is shirt. Although I guess IPNS records are small enough that it would be fairly easy to set up a service that recorded all published IPNS records. Maybe publish it as a merkle tree so it is infeasible to tamper with old records.

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by generalizations on Sunday September 11, 2022 @01:14PM (#32801387)
If this is a 500 year old legacy, I don't think mutability is a criteria. Seems it's more a question of if anyone's going to care enough to host it.
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by kevincox on Sunday September 11, 2022 @01:20PM (#32801431)
I meant that you likely want mutability while you live. Then an archive once you die.
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by octoberfranklin on Sunday September 11, 2022 @07:08AM (#32798625)
Yeah, and I'd like to have a driver's license that will never expire.

But neither of these things will ever happen, for approximately the same reason.

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by UncleEntity on Sunday September 11, 2022 @11:11AM (#32800269)
In Arizona driver’s licenses are good until you’re 65 which effectively, if you’re a particularly bad driver and die in a horrific crash between 16 and 65, never expires.
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by IYasha on Sunday September 11, 2022 @04:56AM (#32797988)
OpenNIC