News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by WalterBright on Friday September 09, 2022 @01:52PM (#32782593)
The right way to reduce CO2 emissions is to simply tax the carbon content of fuels as they are sold from the refinery. Increase the tax until the usage goes down.

Simple, effective, efficient, and boring. And hard to virtue signal one's way out of.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by thehappypm on Friday September 09, 2022 @01:55PM (#32782642)
Unfortunately this doesn’t really work in a democracy. It’s just going to end up being too unpopular. The next president is just going to run on “I will cancel the carbon credits!” And then win the election in a landslide and cancel them.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by DennisP on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:15PM (#32782918)
One option is fee-and-dividend, which pays all the revenue back out to the population, equal amount per capita.

You still have an incentive to reduce emissions, because your dividend is the same regardless and you can reduce your fees. And since most people's net emissions are less than average, most people come out ahead.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by Aunche on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:05PM (#32783520)
At the end of the day, any sort of tax is going to generate a dead weight loss. The amount of money that gets distributed to you with a carbon dividend inevitably is going to be less than your additional tax burden or the consumer surplus from the goods and services you otherwise would have bought without the tax. Of course, you make very good arguments about why the dead weight loss is absolutely dwarfed by the negative externalities of fossil fuel emissions. Even if you don't consider climate change, air pollution is a contributor of over 100,000 deaths in America alone. However, this point is moot if people aren't willing to act on those externalities.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by ericd on Friday September 09, 2022 @09:45PM (#32786896)
A given person will not inevitably get back less than their tax burden, people on average will get back less, but I'm pretty sure the median person will get back more. People who eg. fly a lot will get back less, those who live relatively modest lives will get back a good bit more. The wealthy will disproportionately bear the brunt of a carbon tax, because they tend to live much more energy-intensive lives than the median person.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by Aunche on Saturday September 10, 2022 @02:07AM (#32788245)
Emissions scales very sublinearly with wealth. Someone who is 1000x richer than average isn't going to live in 1000 houses, eat 1000x more beef, or drive 1000 cars simultaneously. This means that they're in a much better position to simply eat the cost of a carbon tax while the poor and middle class will actually have to make the sacrifices to reduce emissions. Even if they're technically be ahead monetarily, they'd feel worse off because they have to organize carpools, turn down the thermostat in the winter, etc.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by DennisP on Saturday September 10, 2022 @06:34AM (#32789380)
It's true that someone rich won't be especially bothered by fee-and-dividend, even though they're paying out more than they're getting back. It won't be an effective tool for reducing the emissions of rich people.

It's also true that a person with lower-than-average emissions will pay out less than they get back. They'll have a strong incentive to reduce emissions, but even if they don't reduce emissions they'll be better off than before. These people will be the majority.

The people who might feel worse off are those who emit a bit more than average without being rich. They'll need to modify their behaviors if they want to come out ahead. Of course that's part of the whole point.

A lot of people might actually be ok with changing their behaviors, if they know everybody's doing it so it will actually make a difference. Right now we have this public goods situation where the outcome is going to be the same regardless of what you personally do. Dealing with public goods situations is the main reason for taxes in general; it's hard to fund roads with voluntary donations, so most people are ok with paying taxes for roads.

The other benefit of fee-and-dividend is that it makes low-carbon energy sources more competitive. It's not just about getting people to carpool or whatever, it's about getting fossil fuels off the grid and the roads, because they just can't compete.

Of course if that works, the end result might be higher prices that don't get reflected in the dividend. But we don't end up in a apocalyptic nightmare, so there's that.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by imtringued on Saturday September 10, 2022 @07:16AM (#32789600)
Rich people easily produce 100 tons of CO2 emissions or more per person. If they eat the cost of a carbon tax with a carbon dividend that is effectively a donation to less wealthy people.

Wealthy people own businesses and those businesses have a strong incentive to reduce emissions, when they do, they end up reducing the tax burden on their consumers.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by ericd on Saturday September 10, 2022 @09:50AM (#32790626)
You’re not wrong about the sublinearity, though someone maintaining a $20M mansion on 20 acres is going to use many times the energy maintaining it, especially when you consider the materials used for maintenance.

The average person wouldn’t have to organize carpools, though it’d certainly be incentivized - at least at the beginning, I’m assuming most wouldn’t, so not doing that, you’d still be a net recipient of tax money. But part of the whole point is that we can’t continue living exactly the same way, if we don’t want to destroy ourselves, and especially our children.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by throwawaylinux on Saturday September 10, 2022 @08:41PM (#32795819)
Well, are you trying to disincentivize CO2 emissions or just tax the rich more?
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by Schroedingersat on Friday September 09, 2022 @08:56PM (#32786633)
> At the end of the day, any sort of tax is going to generate a dead weight loss.

You say that like it's not the goal.

Yes. People will do fewer polluting things. That's the point.

The harms from the externalities vastly dwarf any total economic reduction.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by imtringued on Saturday September 10, 2022 @07:13AM (#32789586)
>At the end of the day, any sort of tax is going to generate a dead weight loss

The entire point of a pigovian tax is to create a deadweight loss proportional to the harm an externality causes.

>The amount of money that gets distributed to you with a carbon dividend inevitably is going to be less than your additional tax burden or the consumer surplus from the goods and services you otherwise would have bought without the tax

As I already said, the difference between what you pay in and get out is an incentive to make you cease the activity that produces the harmful externality.

>Of course, you make very good arguments about why the dead weight loss is absolutely dwarfed by the negative externalities of fossil fuel emissions.

That is how a pigovian tax is supposed to work.

>Even if you don't consider climate change, air pollution is a contributor of over 100,000 deaths in America alone. However, this point is moot if people aren't willing to act on those externalities.

This is irrelevant, lots of countries have adopted carbon taxes. The benefits are obvious, less bureaucracy for businesses, more money to poor people, less shaming for a lack of personal action, mitigating climate change, less corruption and wasteful spending.

The alternative to carbon taxes isn't no carbon taxes, the alternative is more micromanagement by the government which is more likely to result in even bigger deadweight losses which are unlikely to be proportional to the amount of negative externalities that are being avoided.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by adonovan on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:45PM (#32783300)
I've been telling people how great this idea is for years, because it's simple for organizations to plan around as it gradually ratchets up, easy to administer, and sort of progressive in the sense that the poor benefit more (relatively) than the rich.

But this year the penny finally dropped for me how demoralizingly futile it is to make rational carbon policy in the US by talking about its merits. The success of the Inflation Reduction Act ($370bn for climate) was entirely due to a cunning political hack: not taxing individuals (only corporations) and reducing the deficit at the same time (by staffing the IRS to enforce existing tax collection laws), so that it could be acceptable to the holdout conservative Democrats.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by nwj on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:47PM (#32783319)
I think I've heard this option called a Pigovian tax before. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pigovian_tax.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by mr_toad on Saturday September 10, 2022 @03:12AM (#32788558)
A Pigovian tax, set correctly, will actually remove the deadweight loss caused by a negative externality. However, it is very difficult in practice to measure the negative externalities of something like sea level rise, especially when the effect could be centuries in the future.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by imtringued on Saturday September 10, 2022 @07:35AM (#32789704)
A perfect pigovian tax is rarely necessary. Just 10% of the ideal rate is already sufficient in a lot of cases simply because of the fact that a lot of harmful activites are free and not tracked.

Let's say there is a wood stove that increases cooking efficiency by 2x, this means a lot less trees have to be cut down for cooking. However to a person for whom trees are free, they aren't going to buy a better stove just to save on emissions, they will only start once they run out of trees which is when it is already too late. By charging a fee per tree, even if it is a token amount, people will start calculating and weighing whether cutting down more trees or less trees and buying the stove is the better option. Once they have made the initial investment they may even tell their neighbours about it. A single person changing their mind, can change the minds of everyone.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by rtkwe on Friday September 09, 2022 @05:14PM (#32784997)
Net over a year that's all well and good but the extra wait for that dividend payment to come in will be rough for a lot of people.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by DennisP on Friday September 09, 2022 @05:48PM (#32785310)
Dividends don't have to go out annually. Estimated taxes would come in quarterly, and it wouldn't be hard for the government to pay out as frequently as social security checks. Each period, adjust payments to make up for discrepancies in the last period.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by thehappypm on Friday September 09, 2022 @09:03PM (#32786670)
This system rewards people for others emitting carbon, no? Doesnt that create an incentive for people to want more emissions?
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by kitkat_new on Friday September 09, 2022 @09:43PM (#32786884)
as a company I want other companies to have non competitive prices, so yes.

But why would anyone voluntarily follow that? It's not like money is generated out of nothing.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by oliwary on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:01PM (#32783473)
What about introducing a variable environmental toll at the border? It could be based on the environmental rules of the exporting country and the expected emissions of the production and transport of the good.

Ideally, this would have the following effects:

* Make local manufacturing more competitive - introducing only local regulations gives companies a big incentive to produce in less stringently regulated areas. Correcting this could bring back manufacturing and be politically popular.

* Give companies an incentive to develop sustainable processes.

* Give companies an incentive to lobby other governments to introduce more stringent rules.

* Align cost of goods with actual externalities, motivating people to buy more sustainable products.

* The toll revenue could be used to improve carbon saving initiatives, such as public transport and sequestration.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by landemva on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:45PM (#32783988)
Putting America on economic parity with manufacturing polluters like China and Mexico is reasonable. The environmental tariffs would be helpful to stop companies from green-washing by manufacturing the iGadgets in polluting countries.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by WalterBright on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:30PM (#32783119)
We already tax everything else, including fuel.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by thehappypm on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:36PM (#32783883)
And those taxes are extremely unpopular! And for a carbon tax to work the tax would need to be punitive.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by colinmhayes on Friday September 09, 2022 @04:08PM (#32784242)
It might feel punitive, but the entire point of pigouvian taxes is that people were taking advantage of not having to pay for externalities. Not having the tax is punitive to the people who are consuming less than the average energy.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by mr_toad on Saturday September 10, 2022 @03:15AM (#32788569)
Unfortunately the people who consume the least energy often have the least political power.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by WalterBright on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:50PM (#32784056)
All taxes are unpopular, unless they mostly or completely fall on other people.

That hasn't stopped taxes in a democracy.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by imtringued on Saturday September 10, 2022 @07:38AM (#32789720)
If we had more unpopular taxes we could have less taxes (quantity and revenue) overall.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by tgsovlerkhgsel on Saturday September 10, 2022 @02:19AM (#32788317)
That's why you take the revenue from the tax and distribute it across the population. The slight rise in prices is less noticeable than the check/deposit you get every month/year.

And the next president will lose the election in a landslide for ending the free money.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by hedora on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:00PM (#32782714)
Taxing at the refinery (or even well head) seems reasonable, but it might be difficult to set up the tariffs properly.

Instead, they could tax gasoline at $1/gallon (and do similar things for other greenhouse gas sources, such as coal, meat and concrete), and use the resulting funds for carbon capture.

If you want a progressive tax, tax new cars at $2 * 200,000 miles / EPA combined miles per gallon. This will instantly make all new cars carbon neutral or negative at the tailpipe. Similarly, you could also tax embodied carbon on all new goods.

The $1/gallon of gas computation works like this:

Burning a gallon of gas produces 20lbs of CO2. (The O2 in the CO2 comes from the atmosphere, explaining why the CO2 weighs more than the gasoline.)

A ton is 2000 lbs, so 100 gallons of gas emits a ton of CO2.

Atmospheric carbon capture looks like it will cost roughly $100 / ton at scale, or $1/gallon of gasoline.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by WalterBright on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:30PM (#32783102)
It's so much easier to just tax it at the production site, because such production is pretty concentrated in a handful of sites.

Taxing the C also properly accounts for different fuels having different energy per C atom.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by knodi123 on Friday September 09, 2022 @11:51PM (#32787635)
> Instead, they could tax gasoline at $1/gallon (and do similar things for other greenhouse gas sources, such as coal, meat and concrete), and use the resulting funds for carbon capture.

But you know there's only one political party in america willing to spend money to help preserve the environment. And there's another party in america that actively works against any environmental policy for purely culture-war reasons. And if party A raises the price of gasoline, then party A gets immediately voted out and party B will find a way to push even harder in the opposite direction.

We need a way to offset carbon that is politics-neutral. And I'm afraid gasoline prices are front-and-center as a political arena these days.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by gremlinsinc on Friday September 09, 2022 @04:28PM (#32784496)
How do you do this, without hurting people with 'clunkers' who need said 'clunker' to get to work or the market (because they live in a food desert), and can't really afford to upgrade to greener living because cost of living takes their whole paycheck, and they'd be homeless if they can't afford gas or their car breaks down unless they just started living out of their car?

I'm hesitant to think taxing gas at the pump makes any sense, I think maybe taxing diesel though could be a better thing because diesel is used more commercially by big rigs, which is a tax on commercial industries rather than consumers. Jet Fuel and such should have a very high tax, because that's something most people don't use, and isn't really a 'necessity'. Fuel at ports should also be taxed, and I think ports/airports should be under some global climate action 'congress' or something that ensures equal taxation and carbon offsets globally are being applied.

Though, if we were to use all the tax revenue or at least maybe 50% for UBI to say anyone with < 100k annual salary, I think it wouldn't matter if we taxed everything more evenly including gas at the pump, in fact that'd probably encourage more support for taxing carbon offsets since much of it goes to taxpayers as cash in their pocket.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by notatoad on Friday September 09, 2022 @07:39PM (#32786180)
In canada our carbon tax gets charged on fuel purchases and returned to taxpayers based on income level. If your income is below the threshold, you get the same rebate regardless of if you drive a 30-year-old pickup truck or a bicycle.

seems fair without rewarding the people who drive clunkers.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by njarboe on Friday September 09, 2022 @05:05PM (#32784908)
Return all of the CO2 tax to the people. Everyone gets a check for the same amount each quarter.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by hedora on Sunday September 11, 2022 @11:37PM (#32805807)
The sentence starting with "if you want a progressive tax" addresses this.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by WalterBright on Friday September 09, 2022 @04:35PM (#32784597)
We already tax gas at the pump.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by imtringued on Saturday September 10, 2022 @07:40AM (#32789731)
A Hyundai i10 is very cheap and it consumes very little gasoline.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by renewiltord on Friday September 09, 2022 @01:55PM (#32782634)
I agree so hard. But it's like Georgism. There's a clear path forward in economic theory, but the truth is that there is a divergence between Stated and Revealed Preferences. The former say "We are worried about Anthropogenic Climate Change". The latter say "We will fire you if you act like we care about Anthropogenic Climate Change to the extent that it causes discomfort".

This is, in many ways, the ideal for most people. One can say "Climate Change is really important" while blaming "The Corporations" for what they're doing and simultaneously blaming the President for "raising the price of gas".

That way you can appear virtuous while not sacrificing anything.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by WalterBright on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:34PM (#32783160)
The vast bulk of climate policy appears to be virtue signalling. Like EV cars having "zero emissions", never mind the coal power plants needed to charge the batteries.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by renewiltord on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:43PM (#32783276)
California's electricity mix made EVs pretty good (especially with timed charging) but I believe you are right in general. A classic example is environmentalists who want sprawl over dense cities.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by WalterBright on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:48PM (#32783325)
Another example is blocking permits for natural gas pipelines. This has resulted in increased coal plant usage.

Coal emits twice the CO2 per energy than natural gas does.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by imtringued on Saturday September 10, 2022 @07:56AM (#32789842)
It also means throttling renewables because coal plants are usually less responsive and flexible.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by colinmhayes on Friday September 09, 2022 @04:14PM (#32784330)
Even coal power plants release less carbon per mile driven than ICE cars.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by wizofaus on Friday September 09, 2022 @04:20PM (#32784393)
Even for brown Coal? And accounting for embedded emissions etc.?
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by WalterBright on Friday September 09, 2022 @04:40PM (#32784633)
Less, but not much less.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by opportune on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:46PM (#32784003)
I agree completely. It is much easier to directly capture the externalities at the most centralized and traceable point (production/refining, and importing) than to have a decentralized system of varying standards and shadiness. If you tax carbon at the source there is no nuance and it’s much harder to cheat.

The problem does become partly a tragedy of the commons though. If eg China doesn’t tax carbon at all internally, then we’d need to figure out how to appropriately tax the emissions of imported finished goods so as not to incentivize them to release CO2 as a competitive advantage. Even if we do that, they may still trade with another country that doesn’t tax imported goods either. One benefit for carbon offsets is they can in theory be used to incentivize cross-border emissions reductions without requiring the poorer countries to sacrifice anything.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by colinmhayes on Friday September 09, 2022 @04:04PM (#32784201)
Right, the biggest problem with a carbon tax is that it would lead to industries that are heavily reliant on energy to move to defecting countries. Do we really want North korea to become the epicenter of crypto mining?
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by WalterBright on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:49PM (#32784037)
We're already implementing ineffective green policies that put the US at a competitive disadvantage. At least C taxing would be effective.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by ZeroGravitas on Friday September 09, 2022 @05:35PM (#32785206)
The US has several carbon fees/taxes.

https://carbonpricingdashboard.worldbank.org/map_data

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by asiachick on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:05PM (#32782782)
Yes, and put millions of people out of work so they can starve and live in tents

I'm not saying your wrong, only that raising the price of fuel raises the price of everything else. Fuel prices go up, shipping prices go up, shipping prices go up, product prices go up, product prices go up, less people can afford to life. Company expenses go up, company looks for ways to cut expenses, often by lowering employment, etc...

VS coming up with cleaner and cheaper ways to fuel things, then everything goes in the other direction. Cheaper fuel = cheaper shipping = cheaper products = more poor people can eat. Companies make more money they can hire more people, etc...

I know that's easier said than done, just pointing out raising the price of fuel is not a simple solution beacuse it has extreme consequences.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by endominus on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:24PM (#32783035)
I'm always wary of just-so stories. It's easy to pull them in any direction one wants. Cheaper fuel -> lower prices -> greater consumption -> more reliance on extraction of limited resources -> less ability to move off those resources/find alternatives without destroying the global economy -> disaster when we hit "peak whatever." The pandemic has shown how fragile the global economy has become due to the massive network of linkages that have grown between what could be relatively self-sufficient countries. A ship crashing in single canal sent commodity prices worldwide through the roof for months!

There was a comic I read a while back during the 2008 financial crisis, describing the banking sector as a group of wizards building a massive tower in a town. Eventually, it grows too large, wobbling and nearing collapse. The wizards beg the townspeople for help. The townspeople say this is the natural consequence of their actions, but the wizards counter that should their tower fall, it is large enough to do significant damage to the town as well. Thus galvanized, the town gathers together and shores up the foundations of the tower, securing it. At which point the wizards promptly go back to making it even taller and grander, because no one ever learns a lesson.

People are extremely averse to direct negative consequences of actions, but are much more nonchalant about indirect negative consequences, especially of inaction (see; the trolley problem). There is always hope of a miracle cure. That is the thrust of your argument; strong action now may fix the issue, but cause widespread suffering in the short term. Whereas the status quo is a slowly boiling pot, and perhaps someone will find a way to turn off the heat while we languish here, but more likely someone won't and waiting will lead to an even worse economic outcome when global supply chains are disrupted even more forcefully than by a simple tax hike.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by WalterBright on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:34PM (#32783169)
We tax everything else without wrecking the economy.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by asiachick on Sunday September 11, 2022 @03:23PM (#32802461)
I didn't say taxes would wreck the economy. I said it would affect the poor. The cost will be passed on to the consumer. I can afford that cost but lots of poor can't

You can easily find tons of articles about how inflation hurts the poor most. A carbon tax has the exact same effect as inflation as it raises the price of everything. Vs say an progressive income tax.

https://www.npr.org/2022/05/11/1097966775/inflation-poor-inc...

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by thinkcontext on Friday September 09, 2022 @04:11PM (#32784274)
Europe has a carbon price and it hasn't wrecked their economy. They of course have other energy related problems but those aren't related to their carbon price.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by SamReidHughes on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:10PM (#32782854)
There are a ton of taxes and fees that could be reduced because they're replaced by the revenue. Sales taxes and payroll taxes, for starters.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by imtringued on Saturday September 10, 2022 @07:58AM (#32789859)
People live in tents because land is too expensive and local homeowners prevent affordable housing construction.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by DesiLurker on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:47PM (#32784015)
Agreed though it me be difficult to make it acceptable to masses, especially poorer folks who may be push towards voting red and effectively nullifying such change in short order. It may be more palatable to make it revenue neutral and give the money back as refund based on income.

Another way to think about it is the right price of carbon is (in steady state) is the cost to remove the equivalant amount of carbon if we dont want to worsen the situation. So a small portion of this revenue (carbon-tax) could be directed towards subsidizing properly vetted carbon removal techs. of course this number will be high initially so we'll have to taper in the change but it will also give chance for better public acceptance and maturity for carbon removal tech.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by refurb on Saturday September 10, 2022 @12:49AM (#32787873)
It is the most simple and direct way, but look at what happened when energy prices went up this summer? A bunch of governments jumped in with special payments to offset the higher prices.

I don't think there is the political will to jack up carbon costs and force consumers to decide between paying or just using less.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by criddell on Friday September 09, 2022 @01:54PM (#32782628)
How do you sell that to voters?
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by TheCoelacanth on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:14PM (#32782899)
Give all of the proceeds from the tax back to the people. Effectively, instead of all carbon-emitters paying the government, make it so that high-carbon-emitting people have to pay the low-carbon-emitting people.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by it_citizen on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:16PM (#32782928)
And it reduces inequalities given that the 20% richest pollute way more than the 80% poorest.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by kelnos on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:26PM (#32783745)
Does it, though? For example, I would expect lower-income folks to be more likely to have older, less-fuel-efficient cars.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by bumby on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:57PM (#32784116)
It does according to some studies.

"The trend is clear: Emissions generally rise with wealth...The richest 1%—... earning $109,000 a year—are by far the fastest-growing source of emissions."[1]

And at least according to that article, it's not due to international disparities in wealth.

"people’s emissions within countries now overwhelms the country-to-country disparities."

[1]https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2022-wealth-carbon-emissi...

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by lkbm on Friday September 09, 2022 @04:02PM (#32784176)
They also fly less, have smaller cars/apartments, buy cars less frequently, and buy less stuff in general.

I think air flight is typically my largest source of CO2 emissions, and certainly will be this year.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by ericd on Friday September 09, 2022 @09:50PM (#32786918)
They don't fly cross country or internationally multiple times a year, a large fraction of people making 6+ figures do, and that generally swamps a clunker's usage. Also, all the carbon that goes into making new cars they buy, all the Amazon crap, and climate controlling huge houses.

Let alone moving around a building-sized yacht, building and maintaining mega mansions, or flying a private jet in the super-rich circles.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by Schroedingersat on Friday September 09, 2022 @09:33PM (#32786830)
So then they can car pool or catch the train for two months and pay for a better car with the extra freedom afforded by the emissions dividend which then costs them less in maintenance too.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by Aunche on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:37PM (#32783893)
Unfortunately, consumption taxes are always regressive, and a carbon tax would be no different. Even if you happened to receive more from a carbon dividend than you would pay in carbon taxes, you would "pay" for it by having to sacrifice goods and services that you otherwise would have consumed. I do support a carbon tax, but I think it's important to be realistic about its effects if we want it to be politically sustainable.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by TheCoelacanth on Friday September 09, 2022 @05:34PM (#32785201)
Only if you are currently emitting more than the post-tax average emission. If you are already below average, you can emit the same amount and get paid.

Poor people are generally emitting well below the average currently. They take fewer flights, have smaller houses and buy less stuff in general. With current levels of emissions, they would be getting paid without reducing emissions at all.

Eventually after the rest of society reduces emissions, they might have to reduce emissions, but that would only be after the rest of society sacrifices much more consumption.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by Aunche on Friday September 09, 2022 @06:24PM (#32785627)
>Only if you are currently emitting more than the post-tax average emission. If you are already below average, you can emit the same amount and get paid.

You need to consider the downstream effects of the tax. The oil can only get taxed once, but the effects are compounded throughout the entire economy. For example, truck drivers would see dramatically increased expenses. For examples, truck drivers would have to pass on the cost of the fuel to transport freight. Meanwhile, other drivers will be forced to quit, which reduces our total freight throughput, which makes shipping even more expensive.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by Schroedingersat on Friday September 09, 2022 @09:31PM (#32786815)
This is a description of the system working. Both outcomes are cheaper for the customer.

Either the customer pays the retailer who pays the truck driver with the exact money the truck driver paid, or the customer does something cheaper and there is more money to go around because the customer is not paying for all the harms trucking does (including their kid's asthma bills and several dollars per gallon in road upkeep).

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by lozenge on Saturday September 10, 2022 @04:10AM (#32788815)
Drivers would quit? Why wouldn't they raise their prices? Truck transport is an irreplaceable step in every company's sale of goods to another person or company. Well, a couple might be able to switch to trains, but they'd be the minority.

The only way demand for freight transport would go down is by reducing inefficient dead space in product packaging - ie exactly the type of efficiency improvement we would want from a tax.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by Schroedingersat on Friday September 09, 2022 @09:26PM (#32786768)
Those are weasel words.

If the money in is proportional to carbon, and the money out gets distributed perfectly evenly by population then the net result is progressive.

The only way that can not be true is if emissions scale up faster than income scales down or if we listen to people citing fake concern for the poor to enact a means testing program that redirects 90% of the money to serco and other cronies for enforcement.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by Aunche on Saturday September 10, 2022 @02:39AM (#32788398)
>If the money in is proportional to carbon, and the money out gets distributed perfectly evenly by population then the net result is progressive.

Monetarily, sure, but in practice the effect would feel regressive because income scales more faster than emissions. Someone who is 1000x richer than average isn't going to live in 1000 houses, eat 1000x more beef, or drive 1000 cars simultaneously. This means that they're in a much better position to simply eat the cost of a carbon tax while the poor and middle class will actually have to make the sacrifices to reduce emissions by carpooling, turning the heat down in winter, etc.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by Schroedingersat on Saturday September 10, 2022 @06:35AM (#32789387)
The rich person will also receive a much smaller portion of their income in the rebate (and then pay 1000x the poor person for their flights and to fuel their yacht, and 100x to cool their house with glass walls and run their pool, etc etc).

The tax is mildly regressive and the rebate is extremely progressive. The poor person who makes all those lifestyle changes in response to the tax is much better off than they were as the upper bound on their contribution sans rebate is less than what they were paying to begin with.

So stop your fake concern for the poor who would have more options, and more spare cash.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by Aunche on Saturday September 10, 2022 @10:26AM (#32790952)
>So stop your fake concern for the poor who would have more options, and more spare cash.

They would have fewer options. They already have the choice to reduce to emissions without a carbon tax, and now they have financial pressure to go down that path.

And no, it's not "fake concern". As I've said many times, I'm pro carbon tax. I'm explaining the real economic factors that make the carbon tax politically infeasible. All it takes is a particularly cold month in the north, where people are far more reliant natural gas heating, for the pro-carbon tax camp to completely burn all their political capital for the next hundred years.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by Schroedingersat on Saturday September 10, 2022 @06:22PM (#32795029)
You're lying though.

If you have $200 in your pocket for heating and natural gas heating costs $190 (because you have an equal share if the rebate but a smaller than equal share of the tax burden), you're far better off than if you have $100 in your pocket and it costs $100. If there are other options that cost $150, you now have the freedom to choose them when previously your only choice was gas.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by TheCoelacanth on Saturday September 10, 2022 @04:50PM (#32794482)
So rich people give a bunch of money to poor people, but that's regressive because the rich people don't notice it very much?

The poor don't have to sacrifice anything unless the average carbon emissions drop to below what the poor are currently consuming. Until that happens, the poor can continue to emit whatever they currently do and get paid for the fact that they don't consume more.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by imtringued on Saturday September 10, 2022 @07:45AM (#32789775)
As I already said, the rich own businesses and those businesses won't sit still and pay carbon taxes if they can avoid them.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by thinkcontext on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:58PM (#32784127)
You could scale the refund according to income.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by colinmhayes on Friday September 09, 2022 @04:11PM (#32784282)
Problem is that the people who consume less than the average amount of carbon are generally located in cities and therefore already support liberal policies. You need to convince the conservative leaning suburbs, which are the hardest hit by a revenue neutral carbon tax because they have high incomes and don't live in high density areas.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by ericd on Friday September 09, 2022 @09:54PM (#32786936)
It would incentivize local manufacturing by making it much more costly to use a globally-spanning supply chain. That would increase blue collar worker leverage. It's got a lot going for it, politically. The rich would experience quite a lot of inflation on travel and energy-intensive luxury goods, though, which wouldn't be offset for them.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by it_citizen on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:12PM (#32782874)
Just like Canada did. By redistributing the tax revenue. Look up Carbon fee with dividends.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by WalterBright on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:31PM (#32783129)
Use the monies to correspondingly reduce the sales tax.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by landemva on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:48PM (#32784031)
Eliminate personal income tax.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by WalterBright on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:52PM (#32784063)
The sales tax taxes everyone, so everyone would get a benefit from the carbon tax.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by landemva on Friday September 09, 2022 @04:03PM (#32784185)
Does compliance with personal income tax not apply to certain people? Even poor W-2 people have to sign and mail a yearly form to get over-withheld payroll deductions refunded.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by WalterBright on Friday September 09, 2022 @04:38PM (#32784619)
Something like 40% of Americans pay no income tax.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by landemva on Friday September 09, 2022 @11:31PM (#32787505)
What % don't file federal income tax form each year?
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by criddell on Friday September 09, 2022 @05:00PM (#32784847)
And in the five states with no sales tax?
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by imtringued on Saturday September 10, 2022 @07:49AM (#32789793)
I agree, but only if property tax is replaced by a land value tax.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by hedora on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:02PM (#32782744)
Be honest about how said voters' houses are going to be worthless when Phoenix runs out of water, California burns down, and Miami/NYC/New Orleans are under water.

Also, be honest about how we're rapidly barreling toward the end of economic growth because the weather keeps destroying industrial and agricultural production.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by WalterBright on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:32PM (#32783139)
The only way Phoenix will run out of water is if the government does not allow the price of water to be the free market price.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by wizofaus on Friday September 09, 2022 @04:25PM (#32784456)
What exactly is the "free market price" for water? Are you suggesting reticulated water supply for a city should be achieved via competing free enterprises? Is there anywhere in the world where that's worked well?
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by WalterBright on Friday September 09, 2022 @04:39PM (#32784625)
The free market price is the price set by Supply & Demand.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by wizofaus on Friday September 09, 2022 @04:48PM (#32784716)
That's a non-answer unless customers can meaningfully choose where/how to obtain their regular water supply and how much to pay for it. I'm genuinely curious if that's true in any modern cities.

Edit: Santiago in Chile seems to be close to such a case. Interestingly, 70% of the population want to see a return to public ownership of water rights. And it's pretty hard to find evidence having private ownership of water rights is helping ensure long term supply for all.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by WalterBright on Friday September 09, 2022 @07:37PM (#32786167)
Has public ownership shown it's better?
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by wizofaus on Friday September 09, 2022 @07:59PM (#32786316)
There's far too few data points to make a meaningful comparison - but water supply has been a public good since Assyrian times. I was only objecting to your claim that if the price of water was somehow established via the free market it would magically ensure it never ran out.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by WalterBright on Saturday September 10, 2022 @01:30AM (#32788067)
Supply&Demand can indeed appear to work like magic.

Increasing the price causes demand to drop. Increasing it so the demand matches the supply means no shortage.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by wizofaus on Saturday September 10, 2022 @01:57AM (#32788206)
How someone clearly intelligent enough to design parts at Boeing can parrot statements like that does my head in. I'm not an economist at all, but I have at least a passing familiarity with elasticity of demand (which is pretty damn low for water, given it's a basic biological need with zero satisfactory substitutes, and that the excess use of brings little immediate gratification). If you want to claim higher prices for water guarantee that free enterprise will always invest what's necessary to ensure its availability I'd like to see the evidence for it.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by nickpp on Saturday September 10, 2022 @06:42AM (#32789418)
The fact that you are so nonchalantly dismissing the statement of someone like Walter should make you take a long hard look at yourself, your beliefs and your though processes.

Water usage is just as elastic as any other consumption behavior. Heck, I halved mine this year by simply selectively letting parts of my yard dry up in this hot summer. And enterprises can pass increased prices on to the final product.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by wizofaus on Saturday September 10, 2022 @07:22AM (#32789639)
No, it's simply not - most items we consume are not biological needs and do have reasonable substitutes. Obviously there's scope for many of us to reduce our water usage, and I don't doubt increasing the price is one way of achieving that. But if you want to claim that a free market for water will guarantee there's always sufficient supply for a given population, then it's fair to ask for evidence.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by WalterBright on Saturday September 10, 2022 @12:26PM (#32792050)
Some years ago, there was a drought in Seattle. The government instituted a lawn watering ban to cope with it.

Some rich people didn't want their lawns to go brown, so an entrepreneur rented some tanker trucks, filled them up outside the region, drove back to Seattle, and watered their lawns.

This caused a hue and cry about how unfair this was, and another ordinance was passed to make it illegal to truck water in.

However, it is exactly what you asked for - an example of the free market delivering when the price is high enough.

As for biological needs, I recommend reading "Empire of the Summer Moon" about how the Comanche were able able to survive in the desert. This included killing their horses and drinking the contents of their stomachs as an example of how far they would go to get water.

Besides, biological drinking water is only a tiny, tiny fraction of human water consumption.

Another example, when there are natural disasters, entrepreneurs would truck in bottled water and gasoline and sell it (until the government put a stop to that, too).

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by lozenge on Saturday September 10, 2022 @04:21AM (#32788855)
"Look, your business is going bankrupt because it's now too expensive to water your crops compared to the price they would fetch if sold, but that doesn't mean there's a water shortage! You just can't afford it!"
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by nickpp on Saturday September 10, 2022 @06:52AM (#32789471)
Enterprises have to cope with price increases all the time. My friends building houses have seen the price for iron multiplying over the year, but construction still goes on.

Some businesses die but the others adapt and find solutions. It’s where human creativity and innovation shines. An expensive item is a great motivator to find alternatives.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by wizofaus on Saturday September 10, 2022 @07:27AM (#32789663)
And without water, some people die but the others...wash less and let their gardens and crops die? What sort of alternative do you think expensive water would be a great motivator for us to find?
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by nickpp on Sunday September 11, 2022 @07:09AM (#32798633)
And without food, some people die but it was the free markets who brought us this incredible array of cheaper and cheaper options while planned economies couldn't keep their citizens from starving.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by wizofaus on Sunday September 11, 2022 @07:21AM (#32798693)
"Food" is a vastly broader category of possible substitutable commodities than water is. And it's a stretch to claim it's entirely the work of free markets that ensures our food supply - agriculture is pretty heavily subsidised in most modern economies. I'm quite willing to accept that we would see some more innovative ways of supplying water to cities if there was less public control over it. I also agree that water should be more expensive in places that it's hard to supply to (which should help discourage too many people from living there) - but no government is going to let its voters die of thirst, and is just as strongly motivated to maintain supply as competing private enterprises might be.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by WalterBright on Saturday September 10, 2022 @12:27PM (#32792056)
Desalination plants, for example.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by wizofaus on Saturday September 10, 2022 @08:32PM (#32795762)
We have those in Australia. Free enterprise had nothing to do with it, in fact it would have been a terrible investment (and yes, it was a a questionable use of taxpayer money, at least so far). But that you could supply a city the size and distance from the ocean of Phoenix with affordable constant supply of water with desalination plants seems a stretch.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by MichaelCollins on Friday September 09, 2022 @05:52PM (#32785356)
If they drain the aquifers and a bad drought hits for long enough, they'll run out of affordable water.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by imtringued on Saturday September 10, 2022 @07:51AM (#32789805)
It would be more appropriate to say that Phoenix will run out of water if the price of water is too low.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by baggy_trough on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:05PM (#32782794)
The voters will cast a judgement about whether that is hysterical nonsense or not.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by nathanaldensr on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:05PM (#32782795)
Sorry, but most people don't believe that or you. Try reading sources outside your bubble.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by it_citizen on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:19PM (#32782967)
Reputable sources explaining that climate change won't destroy trillions of dollar of assets and GDP? Seems like I am in that bubble too. Could you lay them down please?
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by aydyn on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:13PM (#32783600)
Reputable sources say that "California will burn down" and "NYC will be under water"? Extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof.

Unless OP is just using hyperbole to make a point, in which case maybe they shouldn't.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by hedora on Sunday September 11, 2022 @11:35PM (#32805798)
Search for New York City flood walls.

You must have heard about the fires in California in the last few years, right? Look up what's happened to air quality on the west coast from the smoke.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by kelnos on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:29PM (#32783783)
True or false, reputable sources or not, there are still plenty of people in the US -- enough to affect the outcomes of elections, at least -- who just do not and will not believe it.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by akira2501 on Saturday September 10, 2022 @02:14AM (#32788285)
In the USA. Or, China?
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by yongjik on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:32PM (#32783136)
28% of Americans flat out oppose America becoming carbon neutral by 2050 [1], and that's before we even ask them how much they're willing to pay. Only 31% supports phasing out fossil fuels completely.

I don't think "virtue signaling" (or its lack) is the problem.

[1] https://www.pewresearch.org/science/2022/03/01/americans-lar...

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by david422 on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:38PM (#32783221)
But why don't they want to phase it out? There could be some other reasons like:

  1. a job tied to fossil fuels
  2. concerns that energy prices will go up without fossil fuels
  3. lack of alternatives for things like trucks etc.
And/or change is scary and 28% probably just don't want to change.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by MichaelCollins on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:27PM (#32783755)

    4. Religious beliefs.
    5. Trolling the libs.
    6. Belief that carbon taxation is a scheme to impoverish their nation for social justice.
    7. Belief that global warming will be good for their community.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by natch on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:24PM (#32783032)
Naive in the extreme. See other comments about democracy. Also, see history about revolts.

The best way is to make the alternatives to anything you want to get rid of overwhelmingly more attractive to decision making entities (people, companies, etc.), who will then choose with their free will. Not easy to do, but some are working on it.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by notatoad on Friday September 09, 2022 @07:35PM (#32786152)
as they are extracted from the earth. the refining process has non-trivial carbon emissions, and that should be captured in any carbon tax schemes.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by bosswipe on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:56PM (#32784109)
But the politics suck so it'll never happen.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by ars on Friday September 09, 2022 @04:18PM (#32784374)
It's is not simple at all to tax fuel at the source!!

You have completely forgotten about import/export. If you tax only American fuel, then American exports become very expensive, while imports become cheap.

Guess what happens next?

Setting up a tax scheme for fuel that taking into account import/export is incredibly complicated, your system is probably the most complex solution there is!

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by ZeroGravitas on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:26PM (#32783743)
This is effectively the corporations carbon taxing themselves, because they know a carbon tax is the sensible answer, but politics is holding it up in certain regions.

Just like the US car manufacturers don't really want Democrats and Repbulicans raising and lowering emissions standards every four years, big corps (other than coal producers maybe) don't really want the carbon tax to go up and down on a political whim. This is basically them setting aside the carbon tax money, and applying the carbon tax pressure to themselves internally, so they end up in the same place as a carbon tax would lead them.

As with a pure cabon tax, in many ways it doesn't matter what the money is spent on. As long as there is a financial disincentive for people to burn carbon when there's an alternative, it all kind of works out.