News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by TheCoelacanth on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:14PM (#32782899)
Give all of the proceeds from the tax back to the people. Effectively, instead of all carbon-emitters paying the government, make it so that high-carbon-emitting people have to pay the low-carbon-emitting people.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by it_citizen on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:16PM (#32782928)
And it reduces inequalities given that the 20% richest pollute way more than the 80% poorest.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by kelnos on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:26PM (#32783745)
Does it, though? For example, I would expect lower-income folks to be more likely to have older, less-fuel-efficient cars.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by bumby on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:57PM (#32784116)
It does according to some studies.

"The trend is clear: Emissions generally rise with wealth...The richest 1%—... earning $109,000 a year—are by far the fastest-growing source of emissions."[1]

And at least according to that article, it's not due to international disparities in wealth.

"people’s emissions within countries now overwhelms the country-to-country disparities."

[1]https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2022-wealth-carbon-emissi...

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by lkbm on Friday September 09, 2022 @04:02PM (#32784176)
They also fly less, have smaller cars/apartments, buy cars less frequently, and buy less stuff in general.

I think air flight is typically my largest source of CO2 emissions, and certainly will be this year.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by ericd on Friday September 09, 2022 @09:50PM (#32786918)
They don't fly cross country or internationally multiple times a year, a large fraction of people making 6+ figures do, and that generally swamps a clunker's usage. Also, all the carbon that goes into making new cars they buy, all the Amazon crap, and climate controlling huge houses.

Let alone moving around a building-sized yacht, building and maintaining mega mansions, or flying a private jet in the super-rich circles.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by Schroedingersat on Friday September 09, 2022 @09:33PM (#32786830)
So then they can car pool or catch the train for two months and pay for a better car with the extra freedom afforded by the emissions dividend which then costs them less in maintenance too.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by Aunche on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:37PM (#32783893)
Unfortunately, consumption taxes are always regressive, and a carbon tax would be no different. Even if you happened to receive more from a carbon dividend than you would pay in carbon taxes, you would "pay" for it by having to sacrifice goods and services that you otherwise would have consumed. I do support a carbon tax, but I think it's important to be realistic about its effects if we want it to be politically sustainable.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by TheCoelacanth on Friday September 09, 2022 @05:34PM (#32785201)
Only if you are currently emitting more than the post-tax average emission. If you are already below average, you can emit the same amount and get paid.

Poor people are generally emitting well below the average currently. They take fewer flights, have smaller houses and buy less stuff in general. With current levels of emissions, they would be getting paid without reducing emissions at all.

Eventually after the rest of society reduces emissions, they might have to reduce emissions, but that would only be after the rest of society sacrifices much more consumption.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by Aunche on Friday September 09, 2022 @06:24PM (#32785627)
>Only if you are currently emitting more than the post-tax average emission. If you are already below average, you can emit the same amount and get paid.

You need to consider the downstream effects of the tax. The oil can only get taxed once, but the effects are compounded throughout the entire economy. For example, truck drivers would see dramatically increased expenses. For examples, truck drivers would have to pass on the cost of the fuel to transport freight. Meanwhile, other drivers will be forced to quit, which reduces our total freight throughput, which makes shipping even more expensive.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by Schroedingersat on Friday September 09, 2022 @09:31PM (#32786815)
This is a description of the system working. Both outcomes are cheaper for the customer.

Either the customer pays the retailer who pays the truck driver with the exact money the truck driver paid, or the customer does something cheaper and there is more money to go around because the customer is not paying for all the harms trucking does (including their kid's asthma bills and several dollars per gallon in road upkeep).

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by lozenge on Saturday September 10, 2022 @04:10AM (#32788815)
Drivers would quit? Why wouldn't they raise their prices? Truck transport is an irreplaceable step in every company's sale of goods to another person or company. Well, a couple might be able to switch to trains, but they'd be the minority.

The only way demand for freight transport would go down is by reducing inefficient dead space in product packaging - ie exactly the type of efficiency improvement we would want from a tax.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by Schroedingersat on Friday September 09, 2022 @09:26PM (#32786768)
Those are weasel words.

If the money in is proportional to carbon, and the money out gets distributed perfectly evenly by population then the net result is progressive.

The only way that can not be true is if emissions scale up faster than income scales down or if we listen to people citing fake concern for the poor to enact a means testing program that redirects 90% of the money to serco and other cronies for enforcement.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by Aunche on Saturday September 10, 2022 @02:39AM (#32788398)
>If the money in is proportional to carbon, and the money out gets distributed perfectly evenly by population then the net result is progressive.

Monetarily, sure, but in practice the effect would feel regressive because income scales more faster than emissions. Someone who is 1000x richer than average isn't going to live in 1000 houses, eat 1000x more beef, or drive 1000 cars simultaneously. This means that they're in a much better position to simply eat the cost of a carbon tax while the poor and middle class will actually have to make the sacrifices to reduce emissions by carpooling, turning the heat down in winter, etc.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by Schroedingersat on Saturday September 10, 2022 @06:35AM (#32789387)
The rich person will also receive a much smaller portion of their income in the rebate (and then pay 1000x the poor person for their flights and to fuel their yacht, and 100x to cool their house with glass walls and run their pool, etc etc).

The tax is mildly regressive and the rebate is extremely progressive. The poor person who makes all those lifestyle changes in response to the tax is much better off than they were as the upper bound on their contribution sans rebate is less than what they were paying to begin with.

So stop your fake concern for the poor who would have more options, and more spare cash.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by Aunche on Saturday September 10, 2022 @10:26AM (#32790952)
>So stop your fake concern for the poor who would have more options, and more spare cash.

They would have fewer options. They already have the choice to reduce to emissions without a carbon tax, and now they have financial pressure to go down that path.

And no, it's not "fake concern". As I've said many times, I'm pro carbon tax. I'm explaining the real economic factors that make the carbon tax politically infeasible. All it takes is a particularly cold month in the north, where people are far more reliant natural gas heating, for the pro-carbon tax camp to completely burn all their political capital for the next hundred years.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by Schroedingersat on Saturday September 10, 2022 @06:22PM (#32795029)
You're lying though.

If you have $200 in your pocket for heating and natural gas heating costs $190 (because you have an equal share if the rebate but a smaller than equal share of the tax burden), you're far better off than if you have $100 in your pocket and it costs $100. If there are other options that cost $150, you now have the freedom to choose them when previously your only choice was gas.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by TheCoelacanth on Saturday September 10, 2022 @04:50PM (#32794482)
So rich people give a bunch of money to poor people, but that's regressive because the rich people don't notice it very much?

The poor don't have to sacrifice anything unless the average carbon emissions drop to below what the poor are currently consuming. Until that happens, the poor can continue to emit whatever they currently do and get paid for the fact that they don't consume more.

Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by imtringued on Saturday September 10, 2022 @07:45AM (#32789775)
As I already said, the rich own businesses and those businesses won't sit still and pay carbon taxes if they can avoid them.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by thinkcontext on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:58PM (#32784127)
You could scale the refund according to income.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by colinmhayes on Friday September 09, 2022 @04:11PM (#32784282)
Problem is that the people who consume less than the average amount of carbon are generally located in cities and therefore already support liberal policies. You need to convince the conservative leaning suburbs, which are the hardest hit by a revenue neutral carbon tax because they have high incomes and don't live in high density areas.
Re:Companies are buying large numbers of carbon offsets that... by ericd on Friday September 09, 2022 @09:54PM (#32786936)
It would incentivize local manufacturing by making it much more costly to use a globally-spanning supply chain. That would increase blue collar worker leverage. It's got a lot going for it, politically. The rich would experience quite a lot of inflation on travel and energy-intensive luxury goods, though, which wouldn't be offset for them.