Taxing the C also properly accounts for different fuels having different energy per C atom.
But you know there's only one political party in america willing to spend money to help preserve the environment. And there's another party in america that actively works against any environmental policy for purely culture-war reasons. And if party A raises the price of gasoline, then party A gets immediately voted out and party B will find a way to push even harder in the opposite direction.
We need a way to offset carbon that is politics-neutral. And I'm afraid gasoline prices are front-and-center as a political arena these days.
I'm hesitant to think taxing gas at the pump makes any sense, I think maybe taxing diesel though could be a better thing because diesel is used more commercially by big rigs, which is a tax on commercial industries rather than consumers. Jet Fuel and such should have a very high tax, because that's something most people don't use, and isn't really a 'necessity'. Fuel at ports should also be taxed, and I think ports/airports should be under some global climate action 'congress' or something that ensures equal taxation and carbon offsets globally are being applied.
Though, if we were to use all the tax revenue or at least maybe 50% for UBI to say anyone with < 100k annual salary, I think it wouldn't matter if we taxed everything more evenly including gas at the pump, in fact that'd probably encourage more support for taxing carbon offsets since much of it goes to taxpayers as cash in their pocket.
seems fair without rewarding the people who drive clunkers.
Instead, they could tax gasoline at $1/gallon (and do similar things for other greenhouse gas sources, such as coal, meat and concrete), and use the resulting funds for carbon capture.
If you want a progressive tax, tax new cars at $2 * 200,000 miles / EPA combined miles per gallon. This will instantly make all new cars carbon neutral or negative at the tailpipe. Similarly, you could also tax embodied carbon on all new goods.
The $1/gallon of gas computation works like this:
Burning a gallon of gas produces 20lbs of CO2. (The O2 in the CO2 comes from the atmosphere, explaining why the CO2 weighs more than the gasoline.)
A ton is 2000 lbs, so 100 gallons of gas emits a ton of CO2.
Atmospheric carbon capture looks like it will cost roughly $100 / ton at scale, or $1/gallon of gasoline.