Also, competition law seems to be way too simple. We should have at least 10 similar-sized competitors in this field, yet we are stuck with this duopoly.
So App Store is a monopoly on Apple devices, and on Android based devices there's plenty of choice ranging from bad for privacy (Play store) to fully FOSS-only (F-droid).
On iOS, if you don't publish the app on App Store, 0% of your users will be able to install it, because there is simply no alternative.
For us (well, atleast me), getting an apk from github is not a problem, also not clicking three times to update the app... "normal users" usually don't do this, and some even get scared at the scary messages on phones, warning users about "alternative sources" and "play protect" and other stuff.
I'm not really arguing that this is a great solution for everyone (or that sideloading should magically mean that Android isn't being noncompetitive), just pointing out that even insufficient solutions can really make a really big difference for some people.
I want the sideloading and updating experience on Android to be better, and there are some very real frustrations that come from that -- including that there are great apps like NewPipe that I can't really recommend to everyone I know because of the complexity of installing them. But in contrast, I don't think I could even use iPhone myself because these apps are so essential to me, so I'm grateful that at least I have a phone where it's possible for me to jump through these hoops.
To your point though and in regards to the person you were replying to, you're right that none of that changes anything about whether Play Store has what is essentially a monopoly over other Android storefronts. I would love to live in a world where I could recommend NewPipe to people without feeling like I also need to borrow their phone and sit down with them and help them install it.
----
> For us (well, atleast me), getting an apk from github is not a problem
Pro tip which you might already be aware of, but F-Droid supports custom repositories, and the NewPipe team maintains their own repository that gets immediate updates. Installing NewPipe from F-Droid directly isn't something I would recommend because the app needs to be updated so frequently and F-Droid is slow to pull in those changes. But if you use their custom upstream repo, you can still have F-Droid manage the updates/installation while getting basically direct updates from the Github repo.
This would of course be better if Android allowed the F-Droid store to auto-update apps, but...
I vaguely remember hearing that at some point Android was going to allow this, but then I haven't heard anything since and my version of F-Droid still requires manually clicking an install button, so I'm not sure if Google ever actually followed through.
Did some more digging and it looks like F-Droid just hasn't been updated yet to take advantage of it for eligible apps (https://gitlab.com/fdroid/fdroidclient/-/issues/2316).
99% of app users get an app by clicking on a link that was sent/recommended to them.
So more accurate to say "100% of users will never find your app on a store if it's not directly on a store."
I work on health/social service apps for state and local municipalities. The conversation about putting them on the stores ends when we explain that the stores don't allow such apps. Which is a blessing in disguise ans PWAs are far superior in most every way.
Most people just look at the "trending" stuff in the main playstore window, or search the store with general keywords (eg "menstrual calendar"), and try the first few hits.
Apple simply banned them. That’s why I cannot equivocate Apple and Google’s market dominance, Apple is just so much more obscene and over the top, Google at least has some more shame.
Epic sued Google too. They're going to trial in January 2023.
But then they weaponize inconvenience. You can run the app, but if you want Google Play, they stick you with their terms. SafetyNet blah blah. If you don't, the bank owns the copyright on the bank app so third party devs can't give ordinary users a convenient legal way to install it.
So third party alternatives get friction on purpose and can't gain users. And without users people don't develop native apps.
Compare what it would take to get iOS apps to run on a Linux phone.
Blackberry, Jolla and several other Linux + Android attempts have proven that being easy isn't enough.
You can, of course, access your bank from a browser.
For now. Do you think the W3C would resist if banks tried to standardise a way for sites to determine if you are running with Secure Boot enabled? This would be part of a system to prevent browsers from spoofing their user agent string / version number.
They ignored the protests of those opposed to DRM, and I can't imagine there being as much objection to banks trying to protect users from browser vulnerabilities and kernel-level keyloggers.
Of course some Free Software advocates would again "cry wolf", predicting that banks would start to block requests from "unapproved" OSes, but those claims would be dismissed as scaremongering, right up until it started happening (and the wolf started eating their sheep).
Linux on phones isn't even at "good enough," let alone compelling.
Its interesting because you can really see how we end up with dictators in politics. Doesn't need to be a coup, people voluntarily give it up for small conveniences.
Alternatively, it's not that important and as such the market being a "fiefdom" is irrelevant. In which case suggesting people switch to alternatives is also irrelevant because it simply doesn't matter.
I'm not sure what you're trying to say here. Even if you think that the status quo is problematic, I don't think that suggesting that consumers switch to something that is terrible is a pragmatic solution.
And yeah, Meta sucks.
Apple can decide to throw all that investment down the drain.
But I don’t see any negative consequences of passing a law saying a platform must provide a reason with documentation if a paying user is banned. There also must be an independent review board that is answerable to the board of directors. But not the CEO.
On the other hand, it came out in the Epic case that there is “no duty to deal”. Meaning you can’t force a company to do business with anyone as long as it isn’t for a protected reason.
The government can’t and shouldn’t force a company to do business with someone as in the Walmart case. Would you want the government to force a health or drug store to sell cigarettes?
Health/drug stores are not a monopoly (or a duopoly if you count google, but still a monopoly for apple users).
If you could get apps for iDevices on "every street corner", one of them not selling apps from that specific developer wouldn't matter either.
No one would sign a lease that said "we can kick you out at any time," but that's what developers are agreeing to with Apple.
It would require Apple to more selective up front about who they chose to do business with, but I think that would be a good thing, because it would give developers more stability once they were "in."
That's a bizarre argument. You could argue similarly against speed limits, because next the government will force you to drive in reverse or something.
Accepting payment makes some obligations more real. As a free user you accept whatever tos apple throws at you and that's it. As a paying customer you buy a service, with many protections that includes. (depending on your country)
A faulty product that simply doesn't work can totally be resolved with "fully refunded, they're not our customer anymore".
For example in Australia ACCC says that sure, you're entitled to a refund as one of the options when a product/service fails. But that doesn't stop you from being able to claim damages or losses even if you're fully refunded. https://www.accc.gov.au/consumers/consumer-rights-guarantees...
Actually I'd love to see the result of involving ACCC in this situation if someone in Oz gets terminated. They can be very detailed in their analysis if they're interested.
Also, paying for the right to develop on Apple platforms is hardly a service.
> You hereby appoint Apple and Apple Subsidiaries (collectively “Apple”) as: (i) Your agent for the marketing and delivery of the Licensed Applications to End-Users
Apple is providing devs a service.
>ACCC rules apply to products and services.
Over here in Europe consumer protection laws generally do not apply to contracts between businesses. i.e. A photographer buying a camera for their business use would not necessarily be covered.
Bringing stolen goods back and arranging them as they were before would often be a sufficient defense against a theft charge, as an intention to permanently deprive the owner of the item is often a necessary element of the crime. This would presumably also reduce your burglary charge to trespass.
https://vistacriminallaw.com/borrowing-theft/
https://www.floridacriminaljustice.com/blog/2017/08/theft-is...
In fact, a few of my indie developer friends have gotten their monthly App Store payments held up by Apple while Apple investigates so-called "unusual activity" (which turned out to be nothing).
I'm not really sure how that's relevant here, we're discussing hypothetical regulation that scarface74 is proposing.
>In fact, a few of my indie developer friends have gotten their monthly App Store payments held up by Apple while Apple investigates so-called "unusual activity" (which turned out to be nothing).
This is likely unavoidable as Apple is subject to a number of AML regulations.
Never in my life has my bank withheld a payment. And I've never had a job paycheck held back because of "suspicious activity".
> Amex puts people in “financial review” and locks your account
Amex doesn't pay you; you pay Amex.
I'm talking about companies refusing to pay what they already owe you. App Store payments to developers are for app sales that are already long completed, and Apple has already taken the money from App Store customers.
Either your bank is particularly lenient or your transactions are particularly boring. Most paychecks definitely fall into the "particularly boring" category.
OTOH App store transactions are a relatively big money laundering risk, you are receiving payments from large amounts of different people.
To a longtime indie developer???
We're not talking about huge sums of money here. One month's income for a little indie App Store developer. More or less (probably less) the amount of a software engineer's monthly paycheck.
And what's Apple's "evidence" for money laundering in these cases anyway? It always turns out to be nothing, and payments are eventually restored, but the developer is deprived of cash flow for a month or several with no explanation ever.
Anyway, for developer accounts that Apple terminates (again without explanation), I believe that Apple simply confiscates the money and never pays what it owes to the developer.
>And what's Apple's "evidence" for money laundering in these cases anyway? It always turns out to be nothing, and payments are eventually restored
Unfortunately, they're by law not allowed to discuss these things.
>Anyway, for developer accounts that Apple terminates (again without explanation), I believe that Apple simply confiscates the money and never pays what it owes to the developer.
Unlikely.
If the bank thinks you are laundering money, there are going to be investigation.
I once unknowingly deposited a fake money order in my checking account. I was naive and I fell for the old “we need to pay for three months rent with this money order and can you refund the difference”.
Before I even called the bank once it dawned on me that it was probably fraudulent, the bank had already put a hold on my account.
If Apple think you are working in a company that is under sanctions, they are going to verify that you aren’t.
What do you mean exactly by "deposit"? These are automatic deposits from Apple or from an employer.
A ton of people make >$120K a year and receive >$10K in payments per month. It's not unusual at all.
> I once unknowingly deposited a fake money order in my checking account.
How is this relevant? There are no fake money orders here.
> If Apple think you are working in a company that is under sanctions
Again, how is this relevant to longtime indie devs?
Whether it’s unusual is subject to a Risk Assessment. NACHA happily sells Risk Assessment Workbooks to your bank’s Compliance Department [1].
[1]: https://www.nacha.org/products/ach-risk-assessment-workbook
Edit: Here's the intro to article 22:
> The data subject shall have the right not to be subject to a decision based solely on automated processing, including profiling, which produces legal effects concerning him or her or similarly significantly affects him or her.
That’s why for people who have issues with security, they can also add their redress number to flights
> The data subject shall have the right not to be subject to a decision based solely on automated processing, including profiling, which produces legal effects concerning him or her or similarly significantly affects him or her.
Ha, wow. "I do not like regulation, until it affects me, then I love it."
> Imagine having a potato farm, being able to sell potatos only to walmart, and walmart baning you from selling via them...
What you are talking about here is the dream of Libertarians.
It’s a very Libertarian stance that give consumers the power to make informed decisions.
Notice I did not say that the government should have oversight on the process that private companies are allowed to ban users. I said the independent review board should be answerable to the board of directors not the CEO.
What is your standard for judging where transparency should be legally required or not?
If Apple is going to buy Netflix they may buy it and shut it down. Or at least not let it on the Apple platform. That might be important to know if I’m going to dedicate myself to the ecosystem.
“When it affects my profit!”
If you're banned from a nightclub, it sucks.. but there are many, many other nightclubs (unless you live in a place small enough to have only one... then it sucks too).
If you're banned from apple, you basically have only google play left, and considering that most people specifically develop for one platform or another, it's usually not just losing half your customer base, but sometimes losing all of it.
Imagine having a potato farm, being able to sell potatos only to walmart, and walmart baning you from selling via them...