News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by amelius on Sunday September 04, 2022 @09:00AM (#32712559)
I feel that the App Store is really a monopoly since the Play Store is something else (it uses your personal data to sell ads, something I want to stay far away from).

Also, competition law seems to be way too simple. We should have at least 10 similar-sized competitors in this field, yet we are stuck with this duopoly.

Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by nicoburns on Sunday September 04, 2022 @10:13AM (#32713239)
Most of the ill effects of monopolies also occur in duopolies, so it's really besides the point whether it's a monopoly or not. What it clearly isn't is a competitive market.
Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by ajsnigrutin on Sunday September 04, 2022 @01:22PM (#32715364)
Yep, and even here it's not an "independent" duopoly (basically walmart and target in the same city) but switching from one to another means buying a new device, sometimes for $1k+, and your whole ecosystem.... if we're talking about developers here, also learning a new programming language and doing all the work again.
Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by saurik on Sunday September 04, 2022 @03:27PM (#32716779)
Yeah, these are really independent markets, in the same way that a store can be a monopoly even if it is only a monopoly "West of the Mississippi" with another not-actually-competing store in the East (which might or might not be a monopoly there; in the case of mobile app markets it is, and the result is really two monopolies, not one duopoly).
Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by sofixa on Sunday September 04, 2022 @09:43AM (#32712954)
Play Store has local alternatives because Android allows third party stores.

So App Store is a monopoly on Apple devices, and on Android based devices there's plenty of choice ranging from bad for privacy (Play store) to fully FOSS-only (F-droid).

Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by ajsnigrutin on Sunday September 04, 2022 @09:47AM (#32713007)
Let's be fair... 99% of your users will never find your app if it's not directly on the play store.
Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by capableweb on Sunday September 04, 2022 @09:49AM (#32713035)
Probably true, but at least it's an option.

On iOS, if you don't publish the app on App Store, 0% of your users will be able to install it, because there is simply no alternative.

Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by least on Sunday September 04, 2022 @11:03AM (#32713821)
Two workarounds that I've seen apps that don't meet app store guidelines are altstore [1] and TestFlight, which I guess doesn't have the same rigorous oversight that the app store does? The latter still does require the developer to have an Apple Developer account, though.

[1] https://altstore.io/

Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by danShumway on Sunday September 04, 2022 @10:24AM (#32713377)
This is absolutely true, but at the same time I am still extremely grateful that I can have applications like NewPipe that otherwise would be practically impossible to build/distribute. Not to say that there isn't room for improvement.
Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by ajsnigrutin on Sunday September 04, 2022 @01:25PM (#32715403)
Newpipe has a pretty specific userbase,... if it was on top of the "trending" apps in play store, there would be a lot more users... since it's not, it's just people like you, me, and a bunch of other nerds using it, while "normal people" just wait through the ads, because they're unaware that alternatives exist.

For us (well, atleast me), getting an apk from github is not a problem, also not clicking three times to update the app... "normal users" usually don't do this, and some even get scared at the scary messages on phones, warning users about "alternative sources" and "play protect" and other stuff.

Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by danShumway on Sunday September 04, 2022 @02:57PM (#32716451)
Definitely, the UI to sideloading is a real problem. But Youtube would be unusable for me on Android without NewPipe, it helps so much.

I'm not really arguing that this is a great solution for everyone (or that sideloading should magically mean that Android isn't being noncompetitive), just pointing out that even insufficient solutions can really make a really big difference for some people.

I want the sideloading and updating experience on Android to be better, and there are some very real frustrations that come from that -- including that there are great apps like NewPipe that I can't really recommend to everyone I know because of the complexity of installing them. But in contrast, I don't think I could even use iPhone myself because these apps are so essential to me, so I'm grateful that at least I have a phone where it's possible for me to jump through these hoops.

To your point though and in regards to the person you were replying to, you're right that none of that changes anything about whether Play Store has what is essentially a monopoly over other Android storefronts. I would love to live in a world where I could recommend NewPipe to people without feeling like I also need to borrow their phone and sit down with them and help them install it.

----

> For us (well, atleast me), getting an apk from github is not a problem

Pro tip which you might already be aware of, but F-Droid supports custom repositories, and the NewPipe team maintains their own repository that gets immediate updates. Installing NewPipe from F-Droid directly isn't something I would recommend because the app needs to be updated so frequently and F-Droid is slow to pull in those changes. But if you use their custom upstream repo, you can still have F-Droid manage the updates/installation while getting basically direct updates from the Github repo.

This would of course be better if Android allowed the F-Droid store to auto-update apps, but...

I vaguely remember hearing that at some point Android was going to allow this, but then I haven't heard anything since and my version of F-Droid still requires manually clicking an install button, so I'm not sure if Google ever actually followed through.

Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by lern_too_spel on Monday September 05, 2022 @12:27AM (#32720513)
Non-system app stores can already update apps automatically since Android 12. https://developer.android.com/reference/android/Manifest.per...
Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by danShumway on Monday September 05, 2022 @10:01AM (#32724367)
Awesome, that's good to hear.

Did some more digging and it looks like F-Droid just hasn't been updated yet to take advantage of it for eligible apps (https://gitlab.com/fdroid/fdroidclient/-/issues/2316).

Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by intrasight on Sunday September 04, 2022 @10:50AM (#32713670)
> Let's be fair... 99% of your users will never find your app if it's not directly on the play store.

99% of app users get an app by clicking on a link that was sent/recommended to them.

So more accurate to say "100% of users will never find your app on a store if it's not directly on a store."

I work on health/social service apps for state and local municipalities. The conversation about putting them on the stores ends when we explain that the stores don't allow such apps. Which is a blessing in disguise ans PWAs are far superior in most every way.

Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by ajsnigrutin on Sunday September 04, 2022 @01:24PM (#32715388)
That's maybe us ners, who google stuff and follow recommendations.

Most people just look at the "trending" stuff in the main playstore window, or search the store with general keywords (eg "menstrual calendar"), and try the first few hits.

Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by faeriechangling on Sunday September 04, 2022 @03:28PM (#32716783)
Never stopped Fortnite or Epic Games from selling their own game on their own terms on android profitably and successfully.

Apple simply banned them. That’s why I cannot equivocate Apple and Google’s market dominance, Apple is just so much more obscene and over the top, Google at least has some more shame.

Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by lapcat on Sunday September 04, 2022 @04:32PM (#32717413)
> Never stopped Fortnite or Epic Games from selling their own game on their own terms on android profitably and successfully.

Epic sued Google too. They're going to trial in January 2023.

Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by that_guy_iain on Sunday September 04, 2022 @09:44AM (#32712974)
The problem is no one wants to invest into making an mobile OS that OEMs will use. Nearly every alt mobile OS I've seen feels like it's coupled to the hardware and meant to be unique or super privacy focused which is a turn off for OEMs. OEMs have already been burnt by creating their own OS so none of them are getting in the mix. Microsoft screwed up too badly to come back. And Blackberry just staginated.
Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by fezfight on Sunday September 04, 2022 @09:56AM (#32713094)
Pinephone uses Linux. Pretty straight forward.
Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by amelius on Sunday September 04, 2022 @10:33AM (#32713487)
The one thing Linux seems to lack is good tried and tested sandboxing of untrusted applications. And of course an ecosystem of developers (e.g. why I can't run my bank app on Linux).
Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by AnthonyMouse on Sunday September 04, 2022 @11:15AM (#32713951)
The traditional way to bootstrap this is to support existing apps. Which in theory for Android is easy -- getting Android apps to run on Linux is what they already do.

But then they weaponize inconvenience. You can run the app, but if you want Google Play, they stick you with their terms. SafetyNet blah blah. If you don't, the bank owns the copyright on the bank app so third party devs can't give ordinary users a convenient legal way to install it.

So third party alternatives get friction on purpose and can't gain users. And without users people don't develop native apps.

Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by pjmlp on Sunday September 04, 2022 @11:53AM (#32714321)
Android apps have no notion Linux even exists, it isn't exposed to userspace as public API.
Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by AnthonyMouse on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:09PM (#32714504)
The Android runtime has a notion that Linux exists and in fact runs on Linux. It doesn't take something like Wine to do it.

Compare what it would take to get iOS apps to run on a Linux phone.

Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by pjmlp on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:18PM (#32714610)
Indeed, and someday might be using Zirkon instead of Linux.

Blackberry, Jolla and several other Linux + Android attempts have proven that being easy isn't enough.

Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by fezfight on Sunday September 04, 2022 @11:25AM (#32714035)
As usual, the answer to 'why not Linux' is market share. Linux has numerous ways to sandbox applications. What it doesn't have is an advertising campaign promoting it on the desktop/phones. So it has a small number of users in those areas. Which means companies that dont care about freedom won't support it. And thus: banking programs dont run on the pinephone yet.

You can, of course, access your bank from a browser.

Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by dane-pgp on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:07PM (#32714482)
> You can, of course, access your bank from a browser.

For now. Do you think the W3C would resist if banks tried to standardise a way for sites to determine if you are running with Secure Boot enabled? This would be part of a system to prevent browsers from spoofing their user agent string / version number.

They ignored the protests of those opposed to DRM, and I can't imagine there being as much objection to banks trying to protect users from browser vulnerabilities and kernel-level keyloggers.

Of course some Free Software advocates would again "cry wolf", predicting that banks would start to block requests from "unapproved" OSes, but those claims would be dismissed as scaremongering, right up until it started happening (and the wolf started eating their sheep).

Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by fezfight on Sunday September 04, 2022 @01:27PM (#32715427)
I even think MBNA recently started blocking Firefox. It's a dark time for us all.
Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by least on Sunday September 04, 2022 @11:10AM (#32713889)
It's a pretty straight forward path to market suicide.
Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by fezfight on Sunday September 04, 2022 @11:33AM (#32714111)
There's no inherent reason, just market effects. It's a positive feedback loop. If you want to be rid of Apple and Google, support Linux. More support will lead to adoption, and thus a bigger market. Or you can continue to genuflect to Apple, thanking them as they lock down and prevent any opportunity to compete with them. It's our collective choice.
Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by least on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:01PM (#32714404)
The impetus isn't really on consumers to use half baked products in hopes that it'll improve over time. It's on developers of alternatives to make it at the minimum good enough, but more so actually compelling to use the product. Firefox is losing market share every day. I'd say it's probably "good enough" to be a viable alternative for people that are looking for an alternative but not compelling enough to convince anyone to switch to it. They're fighting against momentum.

Linux on phones isn't even at "good enough," let alone compelling.

Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by fezfight on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:10PM (#32714509)
Yeah, it's going to take folks to think about what they want from the future, instead of just right now. Free market or fiefdom. Doesn't have to be Linux, but it's pretty clear walled gardens == fiefdoms.

Its interesting because you can really see how we end up with dictators in politics. Doesn't need to be a coup, people voluntarily give it up for small conveniences.

Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by least on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:32PM (#32714780)
If a phone is important enough that you think that it's critical that people consider using alternatives for the sake of the future, then those alternatives need to consider why they're that critical and ensure that they are meeting those needs.

Alternatively, it's not that important and as such the market being a "fiefdom" is irrelevant. In which case suggesting people switch to alternatives is also irrelevant because it simply doesn't matter.

Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by fezfight on Sunday September 04, 2022 @01:32PM (#32715482)
Forgive me, I'm not sure what youre trying to say. The relevant reason not to have fiefdoms is demonstrated by the article, is it not? The king can unilaterally destroy you or your business at a whim.
Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by least on Sunday September 04, 2022 @03:31PM (#32716817)
That's the intrinsic risk of your business depending on other business' platforms. We're witnessing the effects of this currently with Meta's revenue being heavily impacted by Apple's privacy initiatives on their platform.

I'm not sure what you're trying to say here. Even if you think that the status quo is problematic, I don't think that suggesting that consumers switch to something that is terrible is a pragmatic solution.

Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by fezfight on Sunday September 04, 2022 @03:57PM (#32717083)
I see. My point is it's a choice we all make everyday. How else can we do it? We can choose to live free, or as serfs. I acknowledge that you disagree.

And yeah, Meta sucks.

Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by cowtools on Sunday September 04, 2022 @11:30AM (#32714077)
The linux-phone ecosystem seems to be doing alright just by porting applications from the rest of the ecosystem. It's a lot more usable than it was a year ago.
Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by badpun on Monday September 05, 2022 @08:30AM (#32723537)
Interestingly, there are huge number of monopolies like that on the consumer side too. Let's say you're a big fan of Marvel - then, you have to pay Marvel prices for tickets and merch, as they have a monopoly on Marvel universe IP. Same for Magic:the Gathering - for millions of fans of the game, there is no substitute, so they begrudgingly pay whatever Hasbro commands them.
Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by daydream on Monday September 05, 2022 @08:55AM (#32723773)
Those cases don’t fit the standard definition of a monopoly. A monopoly is “a situation where there is a single seller in the market” (OECD). In both those cases many alternatives exist using a reasonable market definition. Just because a company has pricing power doesn’t mean it’s a monopoly.
Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by lern_too_spel on Monday September 05, 2022 @12:23AM (#32720476)
The App Store also uses your personal data to sell ads. The difference is the Play Store isn't the only game in town on the devices that have it.