News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by lapcat on Sunday September 04, 2022 @09:03AM (#32712586)
There's no evidence that Apple is refunding banned developer accounts, either for the yearly developer fee or for unpaid App Store sales.

In fact, a few of my indie developer friends have gotten their monthly App Store payments held up by Apple while Apple investigates so-called "unusual activity" (which turned out to be nothing).

Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by prvit on Sunday September 04, 2022 @09:22AM (#32712763)
>There's no evidence that Apple is refunding banned developer accounts, either for the yearly developer fee or for unpaid App Store sales.

I'm not really sure how that's relevant here, we're discussing hypothetical regulation that scarface74 is proposing.

>In fact, a few of my indie developer friends have gotten their monthly App Store payments held up by Apple while Apple investigates so-called "unusual activity" (which turned out to be nothing).

This is likely unavoidable as Apple is subject to a number of AML regulations.

Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by scarface74 on Sunday September 04, 2022 @10:36AM (#32713524)
Every company that deals with payments does that. Banks, PayPal and I’m sure the various places like UpWork. You routinely hear that Amex puts people in “financial review” and locks your account out because of “suspicious activity”
Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by lapcat on Sunday September 04, 2022 @10:41AM (#32713566)
> Every company that deals with payments does that. Banks,

Never in my life has my bank withheld a payment. And I've never had a job paycheck held back because of "suspicious activity".

> Amex puts people in “financial review” and locks your account

Amex doesn't pay you; you pay Amex.

I'm talking about companies refusing to pay what they already owe you. App Store payments to developers are for app sales that are already long completed, and Apple has already taken the money from App Store customers.

Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by prvit on Sunday September 04, 2022 @10:44AM (#32713608)
>Never in my life has my bank withheld a payment. And I've never had a job paycheck held back because of "suspicious activity".

Either your bank is particularly lenient or your transactions are particularly boring. Most paychecks definitely fall into the "particularly boring" category.

OTOH App store transactions are a relatively big money laundering risk, you are receiving payments from large amounts of different people.

Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by lapcat on Sunday September 04, 2022 @10:49AM (#32713658)
> OTOH App store transactions are a relatively big money laundering risk

To a longtime indie developer???

We're not talking about huge sums of money here. One month's income for a little indie App Store developer. More or less (probably less) the amount of a software engineer's monthly paycheck.

And what's Apple's "evidence" for money laundering in these cases anyway? It always turns out to be nothing, and payments are eventually restored, but the developer is deprived of cash flow for a month or several with no explanation ever.

Anyway, for developer accounts that Apple terminates (again without explanation), I believe that Apple simply confiscates the money and never pays what it owes to the developer.

Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by prvit on Sunday September 04, 2022 @10:59AM (#32713773)
This is unfortunately it goes. Nothing Apple specific.

>And what's Apple's "evidence" for money laundering in these cases anyway? It always turns out to be nothing, and payments are eventually restored

Unfortunately, they're by law not allowed to discuss these things.

>Anyway, for developer accounts that Apple terminates (again without explanation), I believe that Apple simply confiscates the money and never pays what it owes to the developer.

Unlikely.

Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by ungamed on Sunday September 04, 2022 @11:31AM (#32714094)
You'd think so, but you'd be wrong.
Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by scarface74 on Sunday September 04, 2022 @11:05AM (#32713837)
I can guarantee you that if you start depositing large payments over $10K that your bank is going to report it - it’s required by the law.

If the bank thinks you are laundering money, there are going to be investigation.

I once unknowingly deposited a fake money order in my checking account. I was naive and I fell for the old “we need to pay for three months rent with this money order and can you refund the difference”.

Before I even called the bank once it dawned on me that it was probably fraudulent, the bank had already put a hold on my account.

If Apple think you are working in a company that is under sanctions, they are going to verify that you aren’t.

Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by lapcat on Sunday September 04, 2022 @11:13AM (#32713919)
> I can guarantee you that if you start depositing large payments over $10K that your bank is going to report it - it’s required by the law.

What do you mean exactly by "deposit"? These are automatic deposits from Apple or from an employer.

A ton of people make >$120K a year and receive >$10K in payments per month. It's not unusual at all.

> I once unknowingly deposited a fake money order in my checking account.

How is this relevant? There are no fake money orders here.

> If Apple think you are working in a company that is under sanctions

Again, how is this relevant to longtime indie devs?

Re:Apple can terminate developer account without a reason by... by peyton on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:28PM (#32714736)
> A ton of people make >$120K a year and receive >$10K in payments per month. It's not unusual at all.

Whether it’s unusual is subject to a Risk Assessment. NACHA happily sells Risk Assessment Workbooks to your bank’s Compliance Department [1].

[1]: https://www.nacha.org/products/ach-risk-assessment-workbook