News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by ffwszgf on Saturday September 03, 2022 @06:32PM (#32706808)
Cloudflare can do whatever it wants but I wish they were honest about it.

The claim that there has been some “dangerous escalation” in the past 2 weeks is nonsense. If anything the owner has been monitoring the thread more proactively and making sure people follow the law. This is included not allowing the creation of new accounts and reminding everyone that their data will be turned over to the authorities should it be requested.

The only thing that picked up steam in the last two weeks is the campaign to drop Cloudflare and the media attention on the situation. That’s why they caved in. It got big enough to reach Bloomberg/wsj/congress. Just be honest about it.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by altcognito on Saturday September 03, 2022 @06:47PM (#32707014)
> The claim that there has been some “dangerous escalation” in the past 2 weeks is nonsense.

I don’t believe you have the same information as cloudflare and assuming good faith I believe them when they say there are legitimate threats to body and person.

They have a responsibility to their investors to insure that their brand isn’t used to coordinate violence.

Dont just shrug your shoulders while a small group invites violence because “that’s just too bad” We all have a responsibility to discern what is valuable speech and what is corrosive. Mentally ill people exist, and they are more than happy to use these forums, and they are often used in these forums as tools.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by jyrkesh on Saturday September 03, 2022 @06:56PM (#32707155)
> I don’t believe you have the same information as cloudflare and assuming good faith I believe them when they say there are legitimate threats to body and person.

I don't believe that Cloudflare gathered the same volume of info that many others have about KF. OP's point is that behavior as bad or worse than what's been going on (yes, including super detailed doxxing, swatting, death threats, and the like) have all been going on for YEARS on KF, and Cloudflare paid no mind until a larger campaign got going.

Full disclosure: I'm actually disappointed that they made the decision to cut them off. Not because I'm pro-KF at ALL, it is absolutely abhorrent. But I do tend to peruse extremist circles on both sides to understand the radicalism a little better, and generally think that keeping these folks relegated to unseen areas is net-negative.

But to the original point, I think it's disingenuous to suggest that this decision wasn't primarily catalyzed by the PR calculus of more people being in the "shut it down" camp than the "leave it up" camp (which makes sense to me, as soon as the spotlight is cast, most people are going to say it's disgusting and should be taken down).

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by ineedasername on Saturday September 03, 2022 @08:13PM (#32708039)
>Cloudflare paid no mind until a larger campaign got going.

You seem to think that is a criticism but it’s actually a pretty good description of how things should work: a problem got enough attention to rise to their notice and they dealt with it. I see no fault in cloudflare setting a high bar on this, for generally not paying attention to content unless it’s serious enough to really grab their attention.

The fact that there are other problems of various severity elsewhere doesn’t change that. The fact that not all targets have as large of a public voice to avoid harassment and potential violence is a tragedy, not a mark against cloudflare.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by jyrkesh on Saturday September 03, 2022 @09:05PM (#32708539)
Left some more comments on this down-thread, but I really meant it neutrally. I don't know if I agree with you that it's how things SHOULD work, but it certainly is how they DO work.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by ineedasername on Sunday September 04, 2022 @11:05AM (#32713838)
> SHOULD

How could things work any differently? A problem cannot be addressed until it rises to their attention. I don’t think there can be any dispute in that.

There are diffent ways this can happen, but that just shifts the argument to how they should structure their organization to facilitate those different ways. Do they prefer an open reporting system? Do they actively monitor and look for problems? Do they decide to be so hands off that only problems that rise to their attention organically, outside of formal structure, are the ones they deal with?

Once we recognize that, the discussion shifts to what sort of problems, when brought to their attention, they decide to address or decide to take no action.

Now we can have a conversation about that, so let’s do a thought experiment:

You own a small business, let’s say bespoke software. It’s small enough that the nature of the work means you talk to every potential customer before beginning a project. A customer comes to you with a very interesting and intellectually challenging project. You like this kind of work, it’s your favorite type of project. But then in the conversation the customer says “I’m going to use this software in part to facilitate personal harassment that is borderline illegal. It will make targets miserable and they will have little ability to do anything about it.”

Do you still take that job? If you answer “no” then your value system is inconsistent unless it entails the belief that Cloudflare should act as it did.

After that, all we’re arguing about are cloudflare’s motives: Money, PR, etc. You might argue that cloudflare does a bad job at this. Or lacks the ability to scale that decision in all cases. But your value system still says that if their is someone at cloudflare aware of the problem that has the power to say “NO” as you would then they should do so.

You can criticize cynical motives or incompetent and spotty enforcement but you can’t criticize them for those cases when they actually say “no”.

If you would say “yes” then we can amicably part ways in this discussion. We would have discussed things in a way where we have positively engaged in a discourse about our beliefs to the point that I will know enough about yours to know that we disagree on such a fundamental level that the productive discussion we had to get to this point has run it’s course. We are unlikely to get further, probably just repeating and restating things in different ways.

But if you have a no then you really have to examine why you feel cloudflare should not do the same. How you can, absent those secondary issues of motive and scale, make a logically consistent argument that individual people at cloudflare with the same power of “no” should behave any differently.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by nemothekid on Saturday September 03, 2022 @07:25PM (#32707522)
>I think it's disingenuous to suggest that this decision wasn't primarily catalyzed by the PR calculus

You seem be taking a very uncharitable view of CF here. Why isn't "the PR around blocking Kiwifarms made Kiwifarms posters more agitated until they did something that CF couldn't take lying down" an option? That's perfectly consistent with recent events and what CF posted in their blog (and frankly, more likely).

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by AbrahamParangi on Saturday September 03, 2022 @08:16PM (#32708065)
You should, as a general rule, never take a charitable view of the actions of businesses. If you start with the most machiavellian interpretation possible you will be more right than wrong. Not that you will be always right, but absent special information it is the presumptive default.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by saltminer on Saturday September 03, 2022 @10:15PM (#32709079)
I was actually monitoring the Keffals threads to laugh at the salt on display. It was hilarious at times, then you'd run into stuff like people determining what restaurants she was likely to be at so they could detonate a bomb and kill her. It's such a brazen display that, even if it was a joke, I don't think the first amendment would be an acceptable defense if your door got busted down over it.

CF should have kicked them off long ago, but when they say "Escalating threats", they're really underselling it IMO. KF already tried to murder Keffals via swatting, so I have a very hard time believing the "it's only for teh lulz" crowd.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by ahtihn on Sunday September 04, 2022 @04:47AM (#32711130)
> KF already tried to murder Keffals via swatting

While that is obviously the intent, the fact that "swatting" even works is serious failure of law enforcement and I don't understand how the public still accepts it after all this time.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by staindk on Sunday September 04, 2022 @07:22AM (#32711879)
Isn't "swatting" just the practice of calling 911 and saying e.g. "I'm at [streamer's neighbour's address] and there were gunshots fired at my neighbour's house! Please send armed police!"?

I don't think there's a simple way to stop swatting, though if a streamer/someone else who is a likely swatting target phones ahead of time and asks to be put on a "likely to get swatted, please disregard suspicious calls" list then the police should honour that list (AFAIK there is something like this but it often doesn't help).

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by lupire on Saturday September 03, 2022 @08:21PM (#32708117)
There are two businesses here, CF and KF. In a dispute, the benefit of the doubt goes to one of them. And it's clear which is more trustworthy.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by AbrahamParangi on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:03AM (#32709706)
To be clear, nothing I say is any sort of endorsement of Kiwifarms. Cloudflare is a business so it’s Machiavellian. Kiwifarms is… I don’t even know what Kiwifarms is. Something worse.

But you shouldn’t trust (meaning the way you’d trust a person you know) any business. Especially not well run businesses! They’re not people— and the better run they are, the more Machiavellian.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by jyrkesh on Saturday September 03, 2022 @09:04PM (#32708526)
I totally understand that reading, and I completely agree with you that it's consistent with their business goals and operating principles. I was just calling it out to the (admittedly minority) of folks in these comments that seem to view them as some sort of moral savior who's making these calls for the good of society.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by dogecoinbase on Saturday September 03, 2022 @08:02PM (#32707923)
CF no longer deserves the benefit of the doubt. See e.g. https://news.ycombinator.com/reply?id=32705613
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by andsoitis on Saturday September 03, 2022 @07:41PM (#32707702)
> But I do tend to peruse extremist circles on both sides to understand the radicalism a little better, and generally think that keeping these folks relegated to unseen areas is net-negative.

Why net-negative? If it is accessible online (and it must be, otherwise how do they communicate?) then one can still peruse, have a pulse on it.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by password4321 on Saturday September 03, 2022 @08:06PM (#32707966)
> one can still peruse, have a pulse on it

Not without an invite to the private Discord / Google doc / telegram group / whatever.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by jyrkesh on Saturday September 03, 2022 @08:49PM (#32708395)
Yeah, this is basically what I meant. Even Discords on TG groups that are "public" but still require your identity to attached and therefore "doxxable" in some respect are still off the radar in the sense that they're not included in research datasets.

I sometimes wonder if online and violently oriented extremism is indeed on the rise, or even completely mainstream at this point. Or if it's actually a very small, isolated problem that gets amplified and magnified through the clickbait media cycle. Or anywhere in between (like e.g. the common claim that these ideas are laundered into the mainstream, potentially with some amount of watering down, dogwhistling, or code switching that obfuscates the source).

At this point, I really think very few people, if anyone, even know the order of magnitude of the problem. Certainly, there's been some academic studies done on the topic, but most of them focus on fully public content on e.g. Twitter or TikTok, as opposed to the "dark circles" like KF, TG groups, and Discords.

There are also technically public boards that are somehow blocklisted on more mainstream social media that exist in a sort of grey area. I probably can't post any of them here without the risk of getting this comment moderated, but many of them were formed in the wake of exoduses from banned subreddits, and then popularized by advertising on those subreddits in the small window between getting quarantined or admin-moderated and getting banned.

Idk, this comment wasn't very cohesive, even after some edits, but yes, there's a big difference between a public subreddit and a semi-public Discord server in terms of monitoring certain kinds of speech. And I think most people here at least somewhat buy into the legitimacy of the Streisand Effect, and I think a lot of this is just that but with nastier people.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by philistine on Saturday September 03, 2022 @08:13PM (#32708041)
That's exactly a problem with theses sites; they are horrible and yet can slowly recruit people because companies still provide them with services that allow them to stay public.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by derefr on Saturday September 03, 2022 @08:19PM (#32708099)
Such groups can splinter endlessly into unidentifiable new subgroups. How do you stop those? What is your imagined end-game here — making freedom of association default-deny?
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by anigbrowl on Saturday September 03, 2022 @09:09PM (#32708567)
Depends on motivation level.

Extremist types do have a tradeoff between security and visibility because they need to grow the size and/or quality of their network or watch it shrink due to boredom or demotivation. conversely people who monitor extremism want o limit its growth, but not so aggressively that extremists significantly up their game and monitors have to start researching infrastructure from scratch.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by ajross on Saturday September 03, 2022 @08:29PM (#32708196)
> I do tend to peruse extremist circles on both sides to understand the radicalism a little better,

Genuinely curious about what "extremist circles" you're perusing on the left that seem to fit into this category? Most of the big protest leaders in the various groups have always been and remain on twitter. Your text clearly implies there's some kind of secret conclave that the rest of us are missing, which is... not at all my experience.

What sites/communities/whatever are you talking about here?

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by jyrkesh on Saturday September 03, 2022 @08:40PM (#32708293)
I'll quote myself from this comment where I explain a little more about my social media habits in that space. I think you're right that a ton of them are on Twitter, I'd add Reddit, and also say I've never dared try and dip into the shitstorm of private Discord channels: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32156760

> ...far left filter bubbles--with calls for violence, personal attacks, doxxing, and all the rest of it--absolutely exist on Twitter and Reddit (among other places, I'm sure). In particular, just pop over to subs like /r/GenZedong, /r/COMPLETEANARCHY, /r/Anarchism, /r/AnarchismZ, /r/196, /r/2624, /r/JusticeReturned, or many many others.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by ajross on Saturday September 03, 2022 @08:45PM (#32708341)
> calls for violence, personal attacks, doxxing [...] exist on Twitter and Reddit

You're going to need to cite them better then. I mean, I read some of those subs. They're out there, sure, but they're absolutely not doing what you claim they are, and (like all subreddits that want to stay up) ban those who do. I'm sure you can find a single comment here and there, but no, there's no coordinated SWATing on reddit, that's ridiculous.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by AllegedAlec on Sunday September 04, 2022 @03:18AM (#32710680)
> You're going to need to cite them better then.

There's this person on twitter who regularly calls for doxxing and actual harassment by seending stuff to people's employers and family. I can't remember how to pronounce their name though. Kuhffuls? Kheffils? Shoot, I just can't recall...

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by ajross on Sunday September 04, 2022 @09:28AM (#32712817)
Maybe link some of her tweets? I see this point being made repeatedly as essentially an argument of faith, but in fact Keffals simply does not engage in the kind of targetted harrassment that KiwiFarms does. There is, I think, exactly one tweet someone found where she said "I hope they get doxxed" or whatever.

And... OK, that's intemperate! She absolutely shouldn't have said it. She should probably take it down (maybe she has?). Twitter would have been very justified in issuing a warning over it (maybe they did?).

But... sorry, that's as far as that kind of thing goes. It's not remotely the same thing as calling in a bomb threat, or providing a forum for volunteers to post home addresses, or SWATing people, or even doing a pizza flood. It's not, and you know that.

But because so many people here have "picked a side"[1], you all find yourselves in this insane position of having to defend places like KiwiFarms because they're "on your side". And the only way that works morally if is "the other side" is just as bad. But... it's not. It's just not.

[1] On trans rights, which is the crazy thing. Everyone on that site was seriously willing to go to jail just... to prevent having to let people be who they want to be? That's the mind-bending thing to me, personally. You can't just... let them be?

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by AllegedAlec on Sunday September 04, 2022 @09:59AM (#32713119)
> But... sorry, that's as far as that kind of thing goes.

Not really. Among others you can find tweets saying shit like "no bad tactics, just bad targets". Keffals also rejoiced in taking away people's sources of income in the past, amongst others that of a streamer named Destiny. I also recall her being giddy about trying to get someone's nursing license removed, but I can't find an archived version of that.

> It's not remotely the same thing as calling in a bomb threat,

One person on a forum did. The post was removed as soon as it was seen by a mod, which was within 30 minutes. It was from an account that never posted otherwise. That's suspect.

> or providing a forum for volunteers to post home addresses,

Sleuthing and finding someone's address isn't in itself illegal.

> or SWATing people, or even doing a pizza flood. It's not, and you know that.

These are, and they explicitly say to not do any of that shit. When people do this or say they'll do it they get banned.

> you all find yourselves in this insane position of having to defend places like KiwiFarms because they're "on your side".

I defend them because while I think they're on or over the borderline of what is morally acceptable, that I find how they use their free speech to be objectionable doesn't mean I think it should be taken away from them. These people find joy, for whatever perverse reason, in finding out details about the weirdest e-celebs and sharing those details. I think it's not a good thing generally, but doing that is very much within the limits of free speech.

I do not agree with them from an ideological perspective, nore do I understand why they like doing what they do. However, I will defend their right to do so, because free speech is free speech, even when I disagree with it.

> You can't just... let them be?

It's very quickly becoming obvious that you haven't looked into the history of these terminally online mad-people. Some keywords would be 'DIY bathtub HRT' and 'Catboy ranch', in this particular case, though on the other hand, for your sanity I would suggest not to.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by ajross on Sunday September 04, 2022 @10:36AM (#32713520)
> One person on a forum did. The post was removed as soon as it was seen by a mod, which was within 30 minutes.

This seems revisionist to me. There was a whole thread dedicated to identifying every Belfast restaurant that serves Poutine because Keffals said something to that effect. People were talking about or implying bomb threats everywhere in that thread. I definitely saw it, but obviously I can't link it because CloudFlare.

It's just not true that KF engaged in serious moderation. If they had, they wouldn't be a community engaged in targetted harrassment, and they are very clearly a community engaged in targetted harrassment.

And to repeat: you seem really engaged in finding a way to make them not, or make their enemies just as bad. When... maybe you could just not defend them? If you want to make a 100% principled argument for Free Speech, go right ahead. But don't nod to the idea of moderation like you are here and then pretend that it works when it doesn't.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by AllegedAlec on Sunday September 04, 2022 @10:43AM (#32713593)
You know... I was typing up a reply to this, but I don't think we're gonna agree.

I don't buy the narrative of "they do targetted harrassment as a community" because I haven't seen evidence of it except for the alleged victims saying so. There is no evidence either way, so I am gonna say that Kiwifarms isn't guilty of that. That's not to say I don't think people weren't swatted using info gathered there, but that's not the same thing as harrassment, because there is no proof that members of that community did so by urging of the community.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by ajross on Sunday September 04, 2022 @05:40PM (#32717952)
> I haven't seen evidence of it except for the alleged victims saying so

CloudFlare says so too. Wikipedia has a whole "harassment" section in their page on them: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kiwi_Farms

I mean, you're obviously free to believe what you want to, but it's not like there's a general lack of evidence here. You just don't want it to be true, which was sort of my point upthread: KiwiFarms is, in a real sense, "on your side", so you're not willing to condemnn their clearly bad acts. And that's upsetting.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by AllegedAlec on Monday September 05, 2022 @01:34AM (#32720912)
> Wikipedia has a whole "harassment" section in their page on them: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kiwi_Farms

The sources for that section are news articles about the alleged victims saying so. To me that's not credible evidence.

> KiwiFarms is, in a real sense, "on your side", so you're not willing to condemnn their clearly bad acts. And that's upsetting.

Well, I did also say that I do not find their use of free speech palatable, but that I do think it should be allowed. I don't get the general dislike that they have for people like DSP, which you could handily ignore without any real consequences. In those famous words: "the internet's not real, just close your eyes lmao".

Now, if they do indeed do targetted harrassment then it's different. However, from the look-see I gave a few of the threads, which I wouldn't recommend if you value your soul, it's all discussion and information gathering. None of it was calls for harrassment or threats, veiled or otherwise.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by RavingGoat on Sunday September 04, 2022 @06:38PM (#32718425)
You are completely clueless. Kiwifarms revels in harassing people to the point of suicide.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by jyrkesh on Saturday September 03, 2022 @09:02PM (#32708511)
I was really hoping I wouldn't get this kind of response because I'm really not trying to be combative or make any kind of point about the relative volume of calls for violence on different sides of the political spectrum. And I have no interest in screencapping a zillion messages over years of having been an internet degenerate to try and prove to you that some non-zero amount of it exists, via a tit-for-tat conversation on what's fake, what's an isolated instance, what's a false equivalence blah blah blah. It's tiresome, and I've watched it play out more times than is probably good for my mental health.

Plus, none of it is relevant anyway because there are so many people poisoning the well with fake personas that are misrepresenting their political enemies for more "evidence" that their group is in the right.

(Ugh, this is bringing to mind a Reddit rabbithole where some person claimed to be ex-AHS-ingroup, and that AHS people were posting CP under fake conservative accounts on conservative boards, and then AHS people claimed that this person was never in the AHS Discords, or that they didn't exist, or the screenshots were fake, and that ACTUALLY it was conservatives posting CP under fake leftist accounts on leftist boards, and OMG HOW DO THESE PEOPLE SPEND EVEN MORE TIME ON THE INTERNET THAN ME I NEED TO STEP BACK FROM THE COMPUTER. And no, I didn't walk away feeling like I had any idea what had actually happened.)

In any case, it's my belief that all ingroups have people within them that aren't operating under their purported values (religion, politics, public servants, etc.). I also believe that the people who have the most power to effect change are the people willing to call out those within their own ingroups who are violating their group's purported principles. E.g. cops gotta call out cops, men gotta call out men, Israelis gotta call out Israelis and Palestinians gotta call out Palestinians. And yes, leftists gotta call out leftists.

I ALSO think that we need more coalition between groups with overlap on certain high-value beliefs and initiatives, and that it's easier to form that unity when people aren't using bad faith arguments to defend the more toxic members of their ingroup.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by ajross on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:03AM (#32709708)
> And I have no interest in screencapping a zillion messages over years of having been an internet degenerate to try and prove to you that some non-zero amount of it exists, via a tit-for-tat conversation on what's fake, what's an isolated instance, what's a false equivalence blah blah blah. It's tiresome

But... you brought it up. We're here discussing KiwiFarms, a site with a long and documented history of violent behavior and extremist rhetoric. And you invoked the idea of "extremism on both sides" as part of an argument for something about censorship. And the clear truth is that there is simply not a similar kind of discourse going on on the left. There isn't.

It's a bunch of hippies being mad about social justice, and occasionally pining for someone to seize the means of production. That's not SWATing, it's not doxxing, it's not harrassment. It's just not.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by jyrkesh on Sunday September 04, 2022 @03:42AM (#32710789)
>> But I do tend to peruse extremist circles on both sides to understand the radicalism a little better

> Genuinely curious about what "extremist circles" you're perusing on the left that seem to fit into this category?

>> ...far left filter bubbles--with calls for violence, personal attacks, doxxing, and all the rest of it

...

> But... you brought it up

Did I? It seemed like a minor throwaway aside as part of an argument I was making that didn't need the "both sides" part to be true that you said you were "genuinely curious" about.

I maybe did a poor job of elaborating that I've personally witnessed a non-trivial amount of people claiming to be from all corners of the political sphere who engaged in internet speech that most of us would find unacceptable, including violent rhetoric. Hell, I just saw a whole Twitter thread full of (maybe/maybe not) leftists on whether or not it was okay to counter-SWAT to some KF people (because ALLEGEDLY some were trying to organize it).

Of course, there's no way I'm going to be able to pull it up now, it was in the infinite scroll, and there's a good chance it's been deleted or moderated by now. Am I going to become some full-time forensic screencapper of all these things? No, I'm just doing it half for fun and to half to try and understand the mindset of people that I actually deal with in real life. Which, by the way, I have close personal friends who have said stuff like what I'm describing out loud in the past, with varying levels of irony. I don't think they're bad people for it, they're just...passionate.

Plus, screencaps would be worthless...I mean, at this point we're all trading AI-generated Dall-E stuff, even photos are basically worthless at this point. (I ALSO just saw a bunch of "insignia" CLEARLY photoshopped onto a rally photographs, and I'd bet good money your first guess was wrong on which way it went. Except it was also totally working, with both sides taking the bait, Photoshop callout was hidden in "Load more tweets".)

Oooh, but now that I think about it, you should check out r/StormfrontorSJW. That one's a good ol' time.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by concordDance on Sunday September 04, 2022 @01:31AM (#32710124)
> And the clear truth is that there is simply not a similar kind of discourse going on on the left. There isn't.

I have personally seen more left wing calls for violence against their politcal opponents than right wing ones. By a factor of about four.

As far as I can tell your assertion is baseless.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by palmetieri2000 on Sunday September 04, 2022 @02:25AM (#32710386)
And your anecdotes are worthless.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by jyrkesh on Sunday September 04, 2022 @04:05AM (#32710916)
Proving the negative is impossible. The internet is too vast. Proving that it exists is effectively impossible, because there's always bar-moving on

But between the volume of what I've seen myself, and the high likelihood of SOME crazies existing in almost any kind of group that exists (not just politics, but companies, churches, courts, etc.).

Now is there a literal leftist equivalent of Kiwifarms out there doing exactly the same stuff? I genuinely have no idea, I'm not making that claim. It certainly helps, though, that people on the left are a LOT more technically inclined, and probably smarter in general, on average. They're all on Signal or Discord.

Again, I'm NOT right-wing, or defending KF. I'm just saying that violent rhetoric on the internet isn't an "us vs. them" problem.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by ajross on Sunday September 04, 2022 @08:45AM (#32712435)
> Proving that it exists is effectively impossible

An existence proof is a thing, I'm not following your point. It seems like it's pretty easy to prove that KiwiFarms, in this particular case, engaged in targetted harrassment and has for quite some time. QED, right?

The point upthread is just asking for where your equivalent existence proof is for these left wing groups engaging in similar hateful activity. And you're not finding it. And I for one think that might be a good opportunity to revisit your priors about the kind of "extremism" that exists on the left, vs what you believe must be the case.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by paulmd on Saturday September 03, 2022 @11:19PM (#32709465)
r/196 is more or less a general-purpose meme discord and about the spiciest thing I’ve seen is people dumping on landlords.

cannot recall ever seeing anyone doxxed on r/196 ever ever. Someone just got mad they got downvoted for trying to brigade conservative opinions onto a bunch of 20y/o’s.

edit: the one thing that is absolutely true is that they aggressively enforce the civility rules... not a great place to go and have a "civil discussion" about whether LGBTQ groups have a right to exist. And I'm betting that's what happened, lol.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by pelagicAustral on Saturday September 03, 2022 @10:51PM (#32709292)
Leftypol anyone?
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by rejectfinite on Saturday September 03, 2022 @07:37PM (#32707669)
>I don’t believe you have the same information as cloudflare and assuming good faith I believe them when they say there are legitimate threats to body and person.

There are "legitimate threats to body and person." on every chat platform everyday. Yet they are still operating.

Could this offending content not be reported to moderators and admins?

Edit: Just flag and downvote me with no reply, good discussion. This site is turning into facebook/reddit.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by andywood on Saturday September 03, 2022 @09:40PM (#32708824)
I have the same information, unless CF pays someone to lurk the Farms more than I do. Unlikely. This is a pretext plain and simple. Prince is full of it. There was one fedpost and it was taken down. It happens. There's no machine learning algo scanning new comments to see if they sound like plausible threats.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by abigail95 on Saturday September 03, 2022 @09:25PM (#32708716)
Having never read Kiwifarms I don't know whether the threats are real or not.

But it's not like the person/s they are targeting, or their plans are secret

CF is making a specific claim that law enforcement is too slow against the escalting risk.

Why would this be true?

Kiwifarms seems like a big problem but it's a small fish in the total criminal pool.

It's not like a Kiwifarms post goes up and a bomb goes off 5 minutes later. If the police can send a swat team anywhere in the US within 2 hours for a hoax, I'm certain the same resource exists for actual threats.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by asah on Saturday September 03, 2022 @09:50PM (#32708901)
We can't know, because Cloudflare provided no evidence (e.g. redacted examples) to justify their decision.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by dmix on Saturday September 03, 2022 @06:55PM (#32707138)
Then they should provide at least some basic details. Trusting them to be honest is silly. This sort of thing needs transparency.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by wyager on Saturday September 03, 2022 @06:54PM (#32707133)
> I don’t believe you have the same information as cloudflare

Yes he does - the activity of KF posters is public.

The amount of bullshitting going on here is insane. People are just making things up wholesale.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by altcognito on Saturday September 03, 2022 @07:33PM (#32707615)
Cloudflare has probably more than one person now involved in monitoring with realtime tools what is being done on their network.

This doesn't take a lot of intuition to think that they have a better idea than a random person on the internet.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by lupire on Saturday September 03, 2022 @08:26PM (#32708163)
CF provided domain DDOS protection, not serving, for KF. So content/hosting isn't part of service CF were providing.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by rejectfinite on Saturday September 03, 2022 @07:56PM (#32707854)
The posts are public on a public forum. You dont need an account. Like Twitter! :)

>realtime tools what is being done on their network.

That inspects every post? That sees some hidden forums for ultra doxxing and crime?

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by ineedasername on Saturday September 03, 2022 @08:21PM (#32708112)
I don’t know where posts are coming from when I see them online. We can only guess at the specifics (which will hopefully be released when there’s time for an after-action report) but presumably cloudflare may be able to see ip addresses and have some idea of location. If someone posts “I’m coming to kill you” a dozen times but the ip is in Europe and doesn’t appear to be a VPN then that’s less cause for concern than the same posts made by someone with a residential ISP ip that’s half an hour away from the target.

Of course that may not at all resemble what happened, but you are incorrect to believe the cloudflare doesn’t have a privileged position that allows them more information.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by Karunamon on Saturday September 03, 2022 @07:40PM (#32707692)
When the topic under discussion are the contents of a publicly available website, unless you think that Cloudflare has some kind of tooling scanning for specific terms on the CDN origin (why?), no, I am pretty confident in saying they do not have any additional information. This is not some arcane matter of network management, this is the public contents of a public website that anyone can verify.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by bombcar on Sunday September 04, 2022 @01:51AM (#32710221)
The additional information would be “the board is getting pissed and you need to fix this now”.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by Handytinge on Sunday September 11, 2022 @06:31AM (#32798470)
> We all have a responsibility to discern what is valuable speech and what is corrosive.

That's not the internet I signed up for, and I don't agree with or support it. Very sad state of affairs.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by istinetz on Sunday September 04, 2022 @06:17AM (#32711560)
>Mentally ill people exist, and they are more than happy to use these forums, and they are often used in these forums as tools.

I can say literally the exact same thing about twitter. This is extremely high bar you're setting for this one site, that you're not following for literally any other social media.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by ahiknsr on Saturday September 03, 2022 @07:18PM (#32707434)
> The claim that there has been some “dangerous escalation” in the past 2 weeks is nonsense.

I believe the final push for Cloudflare to drop them was this forum thread where users were organizing a bomb threat & armed confrontation against several members of the Drop Kiwi Farms campaign.

(copied from https://www.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/x56mot/cloudfla...)

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by Cyberdog on Saturday September 03, 2022 @08:47PM (#32708370)
Interesting how that screenshot on Keffals' Twitter feed crops out the number of downvotes that post would have received, as well as the replies from other posters calling that poster a fed and a glowie.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by matheusmoreira on Saturday September 03, 2022 @11:39PM (#32709580)
Yeah, it's a meme as old as the forums themselves. It's hilarious that this one post that everyone immediately saw through was the one that made Cloudflare react.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by dart200 on Saturday September 03, 2022 @07:29PM (#32707574)
one screenshot by someone crying wolf as much as possible proves exactly nothing.

the post was deleted within a few mins, so extremely sus. violent threats are posted on all major websites, idk why this one is so exceptional.

doesn't even look real, smells entirely like bait. or someone trying to get KF taken down.

[dead]
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by viridian on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:00AM (#32709693)
What's more likely:

That this user has compromised the backend of HN via some exploit in order to make a couple of posts?

or

They are the type of person who regularly deletes their old posts?

Because I see the latter on reddit, twitter, etc, all the time, while the former has serious security implications for every user on HN.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by Akronymus on Sunday September 04, 2022 @06:15AM (#32711551)
Or someone simply not feeling like commenting for a long time.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by google234123 on Saturday September 03, 2022 @07:30PM (#32707583)
To be fair, if the opponents of KF were willing to illegally ddos the site then it’s not a stretch to say they wouldn’t be willing to do a false flag.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by lupire on Saturday September 03, 2022 @08:28PM (#32708183)
DDOS and murder (SWATting is use of deadly force, so is attempting murder) are not interchangable crimes.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by _-david-_ on Sunday September 04, 2022 @01:58AM (#32710264)
The post you are responding to is insinuating that if a group is willing to commit one crime (DDOS) they may be willing to do another crime / questionable act like make a bomb threat post to frame KF.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by JYellensFuckboy on Saturday September 03, 2022 @07:32PM (#32707605)
Am I missing something? The linked source contradicts that comment. The source only links one post by one user - a horrible attempt at a joke by my reading - and it was removed.

Is there more?

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by pixl97 on Saturday September 03, 2022 @07:57PM (#32707861)
>a horrible attempt at a joke by my reading

No. Just no.

"We should just blow everyone up, lol, j/k" < This is fascism in practice. This is the behavior that leads to violence.

>Never believe that anti-Semites are completely unaware of the absurdity of their replies. They know that their remarks are frivolous, open to challenge. But they are amusing themselves, for it is their adversary who is obliged to use words responsibly, since he believes in words. The anti-Semites have the right to play. They even like to play with discourse for, by giving ridiculous reasons, they discredit the seriousness of their interlocutors. They delight in acting in bad faith, since they seek not to persuade by sound argument but to intimidate and disconcert. If you press them too closely, they will abruptly fall silent, loftily indicating by some phrase that the time for argument is past. --Sartre

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by dvzk on Saturday September 03, 2022 @09:05PM (#32708542)
Just say that you want Kiwifarms deleted from the internet. There is nothing tenuous or uncertain about that stance, if you own it openly. Hiding behind concern over a false and un-serious threat is a coward's strategy.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by pixl97 on Saturday September 03, 2022 @09:46PM (#32708878)
I honestly know nothing about the site, somehow before today I've missed the place existed. I can see in past history HN history it's been quite a contentious site.

If sites are making threats of violence against others, and it is not being moderated, even fascists 'I'm just kidding' behaviors, I'm perfectly fine banning them, I'm not hiding behind anything, this is my stated position.

You're just falling into a typical libertarian trap, a common failing on sites like HN. That is the "All voices should be heard, even those calling for violence and intimidation of others", it's just very suspect because the groups that tend to espouse that tend to do so say it from a position of privilege and are not the ones having acts of violence carried out against them.

Violence should not, and ultimately cannot be tolerated.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by cornel_io on Saturday September 03, 2022 @11:47PM (#32709630)
I know nothing here, but it sounds from other posts like it is being moderated very aggressively, and posts like these survive for mere minutes.

Violence absolutely should not be tolerated. But it's going to show up briefly on every site, and that's just reality. What's different about KF is that hate is allowed, and people are suspicious that the real reason it's being targeted is for allowing hate, not violence.

I'm sure that's true, and I don't super hate that this shitty site is getting its just desserts, but pretending that this is a "we need to protect life" decision rather than a "we are agreeing with people who want this speech silenced" decision is pretty shady.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by dvzk on Saturday September 03, 2022 @11:10PM (#32709413)
No, I do think Kiwifarms should have been prosecuted and unhosted, for failing to curtail frequent mass harassment threads against ordinary and mentally ill individuals, which led to real-world harm. I'm just not going to defend deplatforming by quoting downvoted and deleted jests from a few users who could also be anti-KF astroturfers.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by slothsarecool on Saturday September 03, 2022 @06:55PM (#32707149)
Just adding some light to the escalations; there were bomb and shoot threats over the last few days. The userbase on the site upped the tone of their "jokes"/threats after the last blog post and thats what caused the final suspension.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by stepupmakeup on Saturday September 03, 2022 @07:17PM (#32707421)
I don't know what happened prior to today, but earlier today there was a bomb threat which was apparently removed by the site's moderators within minutes, but it hit Twitter anyway. The fact that this isn't mentioned anywhere by the people currently leading the "campaign" already proves there's an agenda.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by syrrim on Saturday September 03, 2022 @07:20PM (#32707460)
People have always posted (usually fake) threats in kiwifarms threads. They have always been removed promptly. The same is true of basically every large website on the internet. When cloudflare made their post saying they wouldn't remove kiwifarms, the site already had that reputation.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by rejectfinite on Saturday September 03, 2022 @07:40PM (#32707693)
There are "bomb and shoot threats over the last few days" on FB, Messenger, Telegram, Signal, CoD/CS lobbies etc everyday. Like Kiwifarms the content is removed when reported. What is the issue?
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by _vvaw on Saturday September 03, 2022 @07:20PM (#32707455)
There absolutely were not, and this is a gross exaggeration. One user made a clearly satirical comment about posting IRA soldiers with bombs at every cafe in the Ulster area. This was screenshotted by Keffals and posted to Twitter as a serious threat. Everyone else posting in the thread understand it was an extremely dumb joke. The post was removed by the KF owner within minutes. If that is why the site went down, I’ll be amazed and disappointed.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by _vvaw on Sunday September 04, 2022 @10:11AM (#32713225)
Update: I am amazed and disappointed.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by mpyne on Saturday September 03, 2022 @07:26PM (#32707534)
I think the point is that this isn't even KF's first go at the bomb threat thing. They've organized bomb threats, swatting, stalking vulnerable people at hotel rooms they've fled to, and worse things besides... and CF was always OK with. Always.

Until now.

When KF forced CF into a choice between protecting KF and protecting the victims of KF, CF chose KF, repeatedly.

Until now.

I'm glad CF has made the right choice, finally. But it clearly is not going to come from within, it's going to have to come from continued public awareness.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by philippejara on Saturday September 03, 2022 @07:46PM (#32707755)
Is there any proof, at all, of any swatting, being organized there? seems to be a question that eludes people.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by mpyne on Saturday September 03, 2022 @09:11PM (#32708598)
On the off-chance that this is a serious question and not gaslighting, start with this investigative journalist's thread: https://twitter.com/oneunderscore__/status/15657972205318144...

This isn't recent either, the same reporter wrote on the site back in 2016: https://www.thedailybeast.com/trump-trolls-cheer-trans-woman... (linked to from his Twitter thread).

I personally witnessed Near's live-tweeted descent into despair, culminating in their suicide (https://twitter.com/eevee/status/1409230358977998851?lang=en, https://twitter.com/near_koukai/status/1408986839743037448), all driven by KF.

As Near described it:

> But Kiwi Farms has made the harassment orders of magnitude worse. It's escalated from attacking me for being autistic, to attacking and doxing my friends, and trying to suicide bait another, just to get a reaction from me. I lost one of my best friends to this. I feel responsible

The behavior from just the Daily Beast story alone exceeds the harm caused by things like spamming, for which CloudFlare does ban email users. CloudFlare even runs a dedicated service that "crawls the Internet to stop phishing, Business Email Compromise (BEC), and email supply chain attacks at the earliest stages of the attack" [1].

One could only wonder how magical the Internet would be if CloudFlare could stop doxxing and account hijacking attacks at their earliest stages! Or... you know, at least not facilitate those attacks coming from within their own network. Because once this all crosses into harassment, stalking, doxxing and mass online bullying, it stops being about "speech" and starts being about facilitating and organizing criminal activity.

[1] https://www.cloudflare.com/products/zero-trust/email-securit...

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by philippejara on Saturday September 03, 2022 @10:19PM (#32709106)
Ok, the investigative journalist's thread shows literally no proof or even evidence that kiwi farms was involved in the swatting, and the man with the note apparently posted it on /pol/(?) so not even kiwi farms was on that one. Neither of the other two links said anything about swatting.

I'm serious here, and genuinely trying to understand this underlying consensus that the one to blame for it is that website, but I just don't see it.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by mpyne on Saturday September 03, 2022 @11:08PM (#32709392)
If Keffals's own personal statement wasn't enough, this press article https://lfpress.com/news/local-news/swatted-toronto-man-caug... confirms her address and her father's were posted to Kiwifarms immediately prior to them being swatted.

Also, KF's admin directly mentioned that those on the site are using it for swatting (see https://www.sinseer.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/FaveAhKVE..., taken from a page posted by a different victim of KF-sourced harassment).

> the man with the note apparently posted it on /pol/(?) so not even kiwi farms was on that one

You mean the note literally saying "KiwiFarms all Troons"?? https://twitter.com/oneunderscore__/status/15658039736716369...

Where they uploaded the first pic is hardly the issue, that KiwiFarms was organizing the online harassment campaign, including doxxing and swatting, is the issue.

And I couldn't help but notice you seemed to miss Near's tweet. Do you think they were unclear as to the source of their misery?

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by philippejara on Saturday September 03, 2022 @11:43PM (#32709598)
No, her personal statement isn't enough, how could she know who did it? I'm sure in the heat of the moment someone going thru something like that would make assumptions and galvanize their position somewhat, it's completely understandable, but it's hardly evidence. Also the article doesn't say anything about the timeframe between her dox being posted and the incident.

The admin explicitly saying for people to stop "encouraging SWAT pranks" when speaking apparently(?) about two other elements is a bit closer but still quite weak, its an open forum from what I gathered so far surely there would be archives or some screenshot or something for said "pranks" towards the streamer being discussed right? especially if there is mention of him actually having to deal with the FBI in previous times.

I didn't overlook the tweets, I just couldn't find a single mention of swatting there.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by mlyle on Saturday September 03, 2022 @11:56PM (#32709673)
Yes, the evidence for a causal link in swatting is weaker, but evidence exists: discussion of swatting on the site, proximal links in time between people being doxxed and being swatted, etc.

And then we have screenshots of them figuring out her hotel room immediately after the swatting and engaging in harassment.

There's plenty of evidence for the site being used to coordinate unlawful harassment, and moderate evidence for them being used in highly dangerous harassment (e.g. swatting).

I think you're engaging in motivated reasoning. It's like if someone is known through extensive evidence to have assaulted others 100x, and there's moderate quality evidence they murdered someone-- arguing that they shouldn't be in jail because you personally don't find the murder evidence convincing enough. OK, um, we disagree about the murder thing, but what about all the other crimes?

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by philippejara on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:19AM (#32709782)
Gonna be quite direct:

>discussion of swatting on the site, proximal links in time between people being doxxed and being swatted, etc.

what is this proximal link? and if that link is something like 3 days or a week or something, on an open forum, i'm not sure it's that relevant, literally anyone can watch the website without participating for what I understand.

>And then we have screenshots of them figuring out her hotel room immediately after the swatting and engaging in harassment.

I saw the bedsheet investigation, but what harrassment did they engage in? the situation where the orders happenned was in a second hotel, and after a big of digging it wasn't even kiwifarms that got the dox on that one, it was Vile on doxbin[0], and he also admitted to being the one making the orders.

> There's plenty of evidence for the site being used to coordinate unlawful harassment, and moderate evidence for them being used in highly dangerous harassment (e.g. swatting).

what is the evidence for this unlawful harassment, and what is the moderate evidence for the swatting? if all you have is what was posted above for the swatting then we'll agree to disagree, which is fine, what is however the plenty of evidence for the former? And no, that twitter thread really doesn't cut it afaic.

> I think you're engaging in motivated reasoning. It's like if someone is known through extensive evidence to have assaulted others 100x, and there's moderate quality evidence they murdered someone-- arguing that they shouldn't be in jail because you personally don't find the murder evidence convincing enough. OK, um, we disagree about the murder thing, but what about all the other crimes?

Well, here's the thing, I know little about kiwifarms in particular and everyone is saying that there is extensive evidence of other crimes, articles are being written saying that they were the one responsible for swatting people and a thousand other things, and the citation/source rabbit hole just leads to a dead end, or ends up circular, so yes i'm going to have my doubts and at least want to see some of this extensive documented harassment trove, archiving things on the internet is but a couple clicks away.

I'll leave the thread for today for it is getting too late, have a good one.

[0]: https://doxbin.org/upload/Keffals

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by Covzire on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:50AM (#32709945)
Hate crime hoaxes are off the charts. "moderate evidence" isn't close to sufficient for anything anymore on the web.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by mlyle on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:58AM (#32709992)
At the very least:

- Moderators on KF felt the need to address the topic of swatting.

- People dox'd on KF were definitely swatted-- the missing evidence is to what degree the actual swatting was coordinated on KF. It's relatively indisputable that KF was in the causal chain.

- Harassment occurred, coordinated on KF to someone immediately after relocating from a swatting.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by charcircuit on Saturday September 03, 2022 @10:16PM (#32709087)
You sidestepped the question. He asked for proof.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by krainboltgreene on Saturday September 03, 2022 @08:32PM (#32708220)
No one is answering you because it's obvious to even the most intermediate observer where this work is coming from.

The only reason anyone would give KF the benefit of the doubt is because they willfully are ignoring the activity going on in KF.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by betwixthewires on Saturday September 03, 2022 @09:38PM (#32708815)
What about to people like me, who have only ever heard of kiwi farms in passing, who don't really know anything substantial about any of this stuff and want to know more? Is it obvious to us? I'd like to see what everyone's talking about when they talk about this site, and if they're right, without actually going there. Can you help me out with that?
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by krainboltgreene on Sunday September 04, 2022 @01:22PM (#32715371)
You want me to google news articles for you?
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by betwixthewires on Sunday September 04, 2022 @04:20PM (#32717283)
No, just show me that what you're saying is true.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by krainboltgreene on Sunday September 04, 2022 @10:49PM (#32719959)
You've had a day and a half to google it.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by betwixthewires on Monday September 05, 2022 @03:18AM (#32721455)
I did google it, still nothing but more people telling me to google it.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by Cyberdog on Saturday September 03, 2022 @08:48PM (#32708381)
So the lack of evidence of wrongdoing is evidence of wrongdoing. Got it. That will certainly fly in court.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by krainboltgreene on Sunday September 04, 2022 @01:22PM (#32715365)
What court? What lack of evidence? Are you even on this earth right now?
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by Cyberdog on Sunday September 04, 2022 @01:37PM (#32715540)
> What court?

A hypothetical court. I was just using it as an example of how the argument wouldn't hold muster in situations where it would really need to.

> What lack of evidence?

You posted this:

> No one is answering you because it's obvious to even the most intermediate observer where this work is coming from.

Again, "well, it's just obvious, dude" is not evidence. It's similar to a "god of the gaps" argument. If there's evidence Kiwi Farms did it, then Kiwi Farms did it, and if there's not evidence that Kiwi Farms did it, then Kiwi Farms still did it. That makes no sense.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by krainboltgreene on Sunday September 04, 2022 @02:22PM (#32716060)
> I was just using it as an example of how the argument wouldn't hold muster in situations where it would really need to.

I love when non-lawyers think they have any idea on what holds muster in the court of law.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by philippejara on Saturday September 03, 2022 @08:56PM (#32708443)
So there isn't then?
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by e2le on Saturday September 03, 2022 @08:55PM (#32708432)
I do wish people would archive these pages to dissuade any doubt of wrongdoing.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by _dain_ on Saturday September 03, 2022 @07:31PM (#32707587)
>They've organized bomb threats, swatting, stalking vulnerable people at hotel rooms they've fled to, and worse things besides

all of these things are against site rules, users who do them are banned (and mercilessly mocked).

the MTG swatting was so obviously a false flag, whoever did it said "YES I AM FROM KIWIFARMS AND THIS IS MY EXACT USERNAME", there was no actual discussion of a swatting attempt in the thread prior to that; nobody would just straight up admit who they were while committing a crime like that, especially after null repeatedly said he hands over people's info to law enforcement if they post illegal shit.

remember, the site is currently being DDoSed, which is a crime. people want it gone. so is it that impossible that the DDoSers would also do other illegal crap (like swatting) and blame it on KF to get their way?

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by smcl on Saturday September 03, 2022 @07:51PM (#32707802)
Oh shit maybe we're all wrong then! Can I ask, then, what is the purpose of the site, if it's not to co-ordinate the harrassment of individuals by sharing their personal information?
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by rejectfinite on Saturday September 03, 2022 @07:59PM (#32707889)
>what is the purpose of the site

It is a forum.

Should sites have to have a "purpose" and does this need to be vetted by some authority or the hosting provider?

What is the "purpose" of Twitter, Facebook, Telegram, Signal, 4chan or Discord?

>by sharing their personal information

I mostly saw public Twitter screenshots being reposted. I swear some people dont seem to understand that Twitter is public and not all DMs.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by smcl on Saturday September 03, 2022 @08:04PM (#32707936)
Ok have fun doing whatever it is you do that isn’t doxing on your forum when it’s back online (after the doxing and the threats took it offline) I guess.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by rejectfinite on Saturday September 03, 2022 @08:27PM (#32708174)
I dont have an account there... My HN is also not some driveby throwaway. You are putting words in my mouth now because you are out of arguments. This is a discussion forum.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by artificial on Saturday September 03, 2022 @09:37PM (#32708803)
Regarding the "purpose" argument. Authoritarianism is on the rise. What are you, some kind of wrongthinker? :)
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by HideousKojima on Saturday September 03, 2022 @09:36PM (#32708787)
The purpose is to document the bizarre (and oftentimes outright creepy and/or illegal) behavior of the terminally online. You know, stuff like helping your friend sell his bathtub brewed hormones to minors without their parents finding out. Or running a Discord server called Catboy Ranch that has several minors on it, and you send them personalized collars that declare them your property. Just ordinary, innocent stuff that is no one else's business, clearly.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by bobsmooth on Saturday September 03, 2022 @07:54PM (#32707832)
To laugh at silly people online.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by HereIGoAgain on Monday September 05, 2022 @01:01AM (#32720726)
What are you talking about exactly? As far as I've been able to find, they don't even have a history of harassment, let alone something illegal, not as a forum/community. As we saw with this "threat" here.. it was reported and deleted as soon as the mods saw it and the user perma banned.. Just like every other attempt by a "member" to post something illegal or interact with someone off site.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by _dain_ on Saturday September 03, 2022 @07:29PM (#32707570)
these were obviously (stupidly poor taste) jokes, and they were removed as soon as the site admin was made aware. death threats are against the rules of the site. what exactly makes this so urgent that KF has to be blasted off the internet?
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by dmix on Saturday September 03, 2022 @06:54PM (#32707123)
100% they are trying to have their cake and eat it too. First you pretend you care about free speech for a week and gesticulate in public. Then you come up with some extraordinary circumstance so it doesn’t seem like it’s the new normal.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by crazytalk on Saturday September 03, 2022 @06:57PM (#32707177)
Heavily reminiscent of Reddit caving in on /r/jailbait following exposure in the WSJ. Actually not heavily reminiscent, identical
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by frickenhamster on Saturday September 03, 2022 @08:59PM (#32708480)
After hearing about the drama and reading kf's pov, I can definitely understand why the people ddosing kf want it down. The stuff they do is illegal and absolutely vile but overlooked by the people in power because it suits their politics. It scares me as a prospective parent.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by charcircuit on Saturday September 03, 2022 @10:21PM (#32709124)
>The stuff they do is illegal

The content on the Kiwi Farms is legal.

Edit: Disregard this as I misinterpreted what I quoted.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by frickenhamster on Saturday September 03, 2022 @10:31PM (#32709187)
I was referring the the stuff the people who want kf down were doying, ie selling homemade hormones to underaged children.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by matheusmoreira on Saturday September 03, 2022 @11:51PM (#32709646)
> selling homemade hormones to underaged children

What is this? Who is doing this and why?

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by iaml on Sunday September 04, 2022 @06:11AM (#32711536)
This happens because a lot of times trans people find themselves in the position where they realize they are trans but can’t do anything about it because they were born in a country that doesn’t offer the qualified help to them (at all or in timely fashion). Sometimes it has to do with their parents refusing to hear what’s on their mind. That’s when “trans diy” options come to light and they helped many a trans people previously. The thin line where this kind of behavior might turn into something less innocent might not be immediately obvious, especially when phrased in a way that is supposed to elicit emotional response.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by fatherzine on Sunday September 04, 2022 @08:03AM (#32712145)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primum_non_nocere "first, do no harm"

"Non-maleficence, which is derived from the maxim, is one of the principal precepts of bioethics that all students in healthcare are taught in school and is a fundamental principle throughout the world. Another way to state it is that, "given an existing problem, it may be better not to do something, or even to DO NOTHING, THAN TO RISK CAUSING MORE HARM THAN GOOD." It reminds healthcare personnel to consider the possible harm that any intervention might do. It is invoked when debating the use of an intervention that carries an obvious risk of harm but a less certain chance of benefit."

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by iaml on Sunday September 04, 2022 @09:15AM (#32712705)
You seem to be of opinion that this is a simple situation with clear cut options one of which is always safe while the other can bring harm. That is not the case, as usual with problems that cause so much discussion on the internet. If the trans person is not able to get necessary treatment (which is well documented by medical professionals) it’s very likely they will experience depression and they may even suffer harm as a result. How can you evaluate that doing nothing in this situation may indeed bring less harm than another option? That is usually a decision that needs to be made by a medical professional, but what if that’s not possible? What if the doctors aren’t trained to deal with situations like this and would still bring harm by their choices?
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by matheusmoreira on Sunday September 04, 2022 @10:12AM (#32713232)
So the trans activist solution is to sell sexual hormones to prepubescent children? Is this real? I'm having trouble believing this shit.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by Deathcrow on Sunday September 04, 2022 @10:52AM (#32713699)
>Is this real? I'm having trouble believing this shit.

Yes it's real and if you think making and distributing homemade hormones to children is vile and dangerous, you're apparently a transphobe nowadays.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by iaml on Sunday September 04, 2022 @10:41AM (#32713569)
You have trouble believing that trans people, whose problems are ignored by most population, choose to help people experiencing the same problem, that they know may lead to suicide if untreated, when nobody else does? How is it surprising? The only proper solution to this problem is to give all trans people equal and quick access to properly trained medical professionals who can treat them correct way, and that’s not happening.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by matheusmoreira on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:03PM (#32714431)
Belief has nothing to do with it, gender dysphoria is an established medical diagnosis. The question is: why are these transgender people recommending and selling drugs to children? Do you seriously think this is okay?

Here's the published criteria for such a recommendation:

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK532313/

> Persistent and well-documented gender dysphoria

> Capacity to consent for the treatment

> Mental or medical underlying issues are in control

The gender dysphoria must be persistent. How is it possible to determine that without long term observation? The patient needs to consent after being informed of and understanding the risks. Can a child understand and consent to this?

It's absolutely insane that people think it's okay to just ignore all this and sell hormones to children. This is not help, this is drug dealing. Whoever is doing this is exposing children to significant risks.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by iaml on Sunday September 04, 2022 @01:19PM (#32715330)
Hormones are not specifically targeted to young people, and all the trans dyi resources I’ve seen have a ton of disclaimers and aren’t exactly easy to find and use. It is a last option for people who have no other choice, and it is regarded as such in community. To go this route you need to do actual math, do the blood work and read about this a lot. Do I think it should be available for children? In a perfect world - no, as children have access to medical professionals and puberty blockers. In this one, where an opinion of 17.999 year old may be completely discarded by parents who are 100% sure they know their child better then the child themselves? Where people can be told their appointment is in two years? Where the doctor can be a bigot and discard valid concerns? And not having this option at all may lead to many suicides? Yeah, I think this option may be justified. How many years would you consider to be permanent enough for you? Are you claiming that all parents are correct all the time?
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by matheusmoreira on Sunday September 04, 2022 @10:00AM (#32713135)
That is absolutely insane. I don't care what the gender politics situation is. These hormones have significant risks associated with their use and are not things that can be sold to children.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by hifumin on Sunday September 04, 2022 @10:46AM (#32713623)
You do know that there are plenty of faceless grey market hormone sellers that'll sell hormones to literally anyone who sends them cryptocurrency and maybe sometimes a bank transfer? "Trans activists" with large followings aren't the ones doing that.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by matheusmoreira on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:14PM (#32714543)
Yes, that's illegal drug dealing. No way around that. However, that's not what was described to me in response to my original question.

What is this supposed to mean?

> That’s when “trans diy” options come to light and they helped many a trans people previously.

> trans people [...] choose to help people experiencing the same problem

Did I misinterpret this? Because it seriously sounds like there are trans people out there selling these "DIY trans" drugs. If they're knowingly selling to children in an attempt to help them as previously claimed, I'm sorry but that's extremely fucked up.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by _-david-_ on Sunday September 04, 2022 @02:02AM (#32710286)
It is trans people / trans activists. They want children who think they are trans (despite 60-80% of children growing out of it) to use hormones.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by ttybird2 on Sunday September 04, 2022 @03:09AM (#32710632)
Is there a source for the "60-80%" figure?
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by _-david-_ on Sunday September 04, 2022 @11:38AM (#32714176)
There are a couple different studies which is why I put the range. Here are a couple

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18981931/

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23702447/

Some older studies from the 80s and 90s that are even higher (well into the 90%), but they may not be the best representation of the modern trans situation.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by honkler on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:18AM (#32709779)
>what is this?

Selling homemade hormones to underaged children

>who is doing it?

Mentally ill people

>and why?

Mental illness

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by scythe on Saturday September 03, 2022 @06:52PM (#32707088)
They didn't say that there was "dangerous escalation" in the past two weeks. They said that there was a pressure campaign over the last two weeks, and they also said that they didn't want to comply with this campaign.

They, crucially, said that there was dangerous escalation over the past 48 hours, i.e., since Thursday. Given that most of us have jobs, we might not have noticed. But what changed in 48 hours that led Cloudflare to contact law enforcement?

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by derefr on Saturday September 03, 2022 @08:22PM (#32708132)
Cloudflare didn't say that they contacted law enforcement in the last 48 hours; they said that they've been in contact with law enforcement for weeks and law enforcement hasn't acted (i.e. to give them a court order to shut the thing down.)
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by convery on Saturday September 03, 2022 @07:04PM (#32707276)
> But what changed in 48 hours that led Cloudflare to contact law enforcement?

Several hit-pieces in the media? Saw nothing out of the ordinary in the thread about Keffals a couple hours ago.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by zerocrates on Saturday September 03, 2022 @07:23PM (#32707492)
I don't know what else has been there, but this seems like it would qualify, no?

https://twitter.com/keffals/status/1566153033586810885

I understand that it's since been deleted.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by convery on Saturday September 03, 2022 @07:34PM (#32707633)
Maybe, but people shitposting about blowing up half a city just to annoy a streamer doesn't really sound like the kind of threat that would make a company do a 180 on their position..
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by rejectfinite on Saturday September 03, 2022 @08:03PM (#32707930)
It was deleted as it is against the rules of the site? The strawman of "damage control" seems like a retrofit by Keffals.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by happyopossum on Saturday September 03, 2022 @08:04PM (#32707940)
Err, how would that qualify as a legitimate threat?
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by lookalike74 on Saturday September 03, 2022 @07:03PM (#32707256)
Thank you for this comment. The only possible negative here is "Kiwifarms itself will most likely find other infrastructure that allows them to come back online." Cloudflare supposedly being "concerned that our action may only fan the flames of this emergency" is disingenuous at best.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by hackerlight on Sunday September 04, 2022 @05:55AM (#32711467)
> The claim that there has been some “dangerous escalation” in the past 2 weeks is nonsense

How do you know?

And to be specific, the claim was "targeted threats have escalated over the last 48 hours to the point that we believe there is an unprecedented emergency and immediate threat to human life".

[dead]
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by Grue3 on Saturday September 03, 2022 @08:29PM (#32708197)
There is at least one CF customer who was doxxed by Kiwifarms after expressing displeasure with Cloudflare's initial decision. CF CEO (eastdakota) blocked this customer when he complained about it [1] So much for free speech + great customer service!

[1] https://twitter.com/GossiTheDog/status/1565629001862873088

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by skissane on Saturday September 03, 2022 @08:45PM (#32708348)
> CF CEO (eastdakota) blocked this customer when he complained about it

GossiTheDog was publicly attacking a deceased former employee of Cloudflare (Jaime Cochran), and eastdakota was offended: https://twitter.com/eastdakota/status/1565575185159204864

I'm pretty sure that's the reason why eastdakota blocked GossiTheDog – not because he was complaining about being doxxed by Kiwifarms

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by wahnfrieden on Saturday September 03, 2022 @09:50PM (#32708904)
You got the name wrong. And the attack was against the GNAA "i'm a nazi" president and online shock-racist employed at Cloudflare at that time, nothing to do with their later death which is none of our business. It was also to remind that Weev claims there is a different GNAA-adjacent sympathizer employed at Cloudflare who is a personal ally to Stormfront.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by skissane on Saturday September 03, 2022 @10:19PM (#32709107)
Cochran is the person that both GossiTheDog and eastdakota were talking about. (I'm not sure about the Jaime vs Jamie spelling – my impression is "Jaime" is what she preferred at the time of her death, so I'm going to go with that – as to why eastdakota and the screen-shotted NBC News story spelled it "Jamie", I don't know – maybe just typos or autocorrect.)

My point was that the person I was replying to was either misinformed or disingenuous about eastdakota's reasons for blocking GossiTheDog. I don't see the relevance of the rest of what you are saying to my point.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by wahnfrieden on Saturday September 03, 2022 @10:27PM (#32709158)
The rest is context for readers on who's being defended by the ceo and rest
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by skissane on Saturday September 03, 2022 @11:00PM (#32709347)
I think if you used to work with someone, and now they are dead – being upset at people publicly attacking them, when they aren't around to defend themselves, is a very understandable human reaction. eastdakota's reaction here is very human.
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by wahnfrieden on Saturday September 03, 2022 @11:16PM (#32709447)
They weren't attacked, Cf was attacked for employing them and their allies. Cf has a habit of financially supporting actual far-right activists such as Westboro Church, besides this. They are under watch.

more context on the employee at the time - https://twitter.com/Slendy5127/status/1565764927498903552

edit because reply is broken: they donated money to Westboro aka GODHATESFAGS[.]COM

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by skissane on Saturday September 03, 2022 @11:42PM (#32709595)
> They weren't attacked, Cf was attacked for employing them

That sentence is illogical. Attacking X's employer for employing X is an attack on X – it is saying that X is unworthy of being employed

> Cf has a habit of financially supporting actual far-right activists such as Westboro Church

You make it sound like they donated money to WBC. From what I understand, at one point they accepted them as a paying customer. WBC is an atrocious organisation, but a business having them as a customer isn't "financial support" – do you apply the same standard to the many other businesses who undoubtedly have WBC and/or its leaders and members among their customers? Who is their cell carrier? What supermarket do they shop at? Which airline do they fly?

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by _-david-_ on Sunday September 04, 2022 @02:06AM (#32710304)
> they donated money to Westboro aka GODHATESFAGS[.]COM

Do you have any proof of this?

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by rejectfinite on Saturday September 03, 2022 @08:01PM (#32707905)
>KF probably started doxxing and threatening CF employees/other customers

Source: It came to me in a dream

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by _vvaw on Saturday September 03, 2022 @07:24PM (#32707508)
> KF started doxxing and threatening CF employees, as well as their other customers.

First I’ve heard, and I’ve followed this story closely. Do you have a source?

Sounds about as likely as KF SWATing a Republican Congresswoman and calling the police to say “it was us, Kiwi Farms” in the middle of this conflict over hosting, which is exactly what was claimed in that case.

Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by paulmd on Saturday September 03, 2022 @07:41PM (#32707701)
CF's statement says "imminent and emergency threat to human life". What do you think that means that it didn't mean 48 hours ago?
Re:Blocking Kiwifarms by _vvaw on Saturday September 03, 2022 @07:45PM (#32707746)
OK, so you made up the “doxing and threatening of CF employees” based on that nonspecific phrase. Got it.