Yes, in many jurisdictions, including the US, canceling your credit card does not change your obligation to pay. (Imagine buying a $10,000 physical product and the seller forgets to charge until the day after delivery, and you've canceled the card. You're not getting out of that.)
However, there is substantial friction in the American legal system. Of course, if they can find you, they will send a threatening form letter from a lawyer. If you're not experienced with the legal system, this seems scary. But: big whoop.
It costs $5k-20k to fully pursue a contractual claim. Nobody does this for small consumer purchases. (They will send you to collections, if they know your identity, though. But if they don't have good ID, they can't even attach to your credit score.)
Nobody is going to send a subpoena for your $15/mo subscription on a dead credit card.
These concerns are all frivolous and irrelevant for 99% of consumer purchases that charge in the tens of dollars per month.
In the American legal system, it is important to distinguish between what is possible versus what is practical. And exploit that difference whenever you can.
And you'd be surprised how some services continue to charge you (and give you the service) if your card stops working. I've had it happen several times when cards expire (due to messy post office service, it's a mess to renew here, plus I often forget to actively go and personally get the new one in time).
no thank you. I'd rather live in a world where we try to make it better not race to the bottom
Don't be naive about it, you have to be brave. There's always a chance someone betrays you, but it's a risk worth taking.
They're the ones exploiting our "contractual obligation" to keep paying them despite no longer wanting the service. They deserve absolutely everything that happens as a result of their abuse. We won't apologize.
Canceling a credit card or charging back a charge for a prepaid service you aren't using is not immoral or evil by any stretch of any real moral code.
But of course no merchant is going to go through the effort and expense to do all this, unless you owe them a decent chunk of change. A couple months of a $15/mo subscription likely doesn't clear that bar.
If privacy.com doxed their users for some random company, that would ruin the whole purpose of their service...
Unknown. Do you have some evidence of that?
It doesn't guarantee the vendor will win a final judgement but no court is going to prevent them from tracking you down.
evidence for that, please?
There are numerous advantages to a privacy.com number besides cancellation:
* you're sure that your real credit card will not leak out when (not if) they get hacked.
* You get notified every time the card is charged (or declined).
* You can set dollar limits so they can't pile on other charges.
* You have a complete record of all the charges on that card. You know that no other vendor can use it.
So refusing a privacy.com card, if they can even do it, would be a consumer-unfriendly act.
Also, this sounds like a great opportunity for privacy.com to have a lucrative side business of bulk-selling the real customer data to collections agencies - or maybe just open up a collections agency themselves. How much do you trust them?
So? As long as this doesn't happen, it's still practical.
Might as well say "this would stop working if credit services cease following a societal collapse". Sure, but it's not an actual issue for the foreseeable future.
If a large percentage of customers did this, then there would be pressure on legislators to crack down on it, but the compromise to emerge would be that online services ALSO have to make it as easy to cancel as it was to join.
The entity charging you would need to report your missing payments to a credit agency. And to do that generally they need your social security number.
For the most part, you can be reasonable sure that unless you gave them your social security number they will not show up on your credit report.
No, it’s the same here. If you signed up with fake credentials with the intention of breaching the contract, it could be fraud.
Q: So, Mr. Defendant, when you signed up for this service, did you intend to pay?
A: Yes
Q: And did you pay?
A: Yes
Q: But eventually you cancelled the credit card?
A: Yes
Q: And why did you do that?
A: I was tired of the service, and they made it almost impossible to cancel.
At that point, the prosecution drops the case.
But hey, if you want to keep paying for a shitty service you don't want anymore because you can't jump through all their hoops... well, you do you.
Q: But eventually you cancelled the credit card?
A: Yes.
Q: Despite your contractual obligation to pay?
A: yes, but they made it impossible to can...
Judge: You must only answer the question.
And no, the judge is not going to say "you must only answer the question" if you answer that way; "when did you stop beating your wife?" doesn't actually work in a court of law.
Regardless, even if you did have a contractual obligation to pay, but found it impossible to cancel (assuming you're allowed to cancel without penalty), you could pretty safely answer "Yes" to that last question, and then your own lawyer would then expose the whole impossible-to-cancel situation when it's their turn to question you. Court of law isn't this "haha, gotcha!" thing.
If there's an issue about whether a question is admissible, the lawyers argue it. If the judge decides it is, they just say "Overruled; answer the question."
That's why your lawyer will tell you to look at them before answering.
Q: But eventually you cancelled the credit card?
A: Yes.
Q: Despite your contractual obligation to pay?
Defense counsel: Objection, your honor. Leading the witness.
Judge: sustained
Want to try again?
You're right about one thing, though; it's much briefer. All the lawyer says is "Objection. Leading." They do it so much that they don't waste words like on TV.
Contracts can be unconscionable or otherwise illegal.
So in at least some civil cases, one side can request a jury trial. I'm not sure in which ones.
Agreed, someone would have to be egregious to attract prosecutorial attention. But for a civil judgement, using a temporary card with a fake name that is cancelled without notice (particularly if a discount was offered up front in exchange for commitment) is going to weigh in the plaintiff's favor. That, in turn, factors into e.g. credit agencies when considering taking such items off a report after the debt collector who bought it begins collections.
TL; DR This is a fine strategy. But try to cancel using the service's means. If they force you through loopholes, fire off an email and carry on. None of this is legal advice. But it does seem like the courteous thing to do.
I didn't see anything about EU compliance in the relevant news (and it was relatively big news for such a quotidian change). Possibly the number of people with useless gym etc. memberships after corona was the last straw - these were often 2-3y autorenewing contracts, for fairly large amounts.
My strategy: Fire off an email to whatever billing email is on there, say "I will not be renewing this insurance", and cancel the direct debit. They will try to charge, send a couple letters, and it's all safe to ignore because I've stated my intent to cancel in time.
https://www.internations.org/about-internations/
see the reviews complaining about them
https://www.reviews.io/company-reviews/store/internations-or...
Looking at their site, privacy.com doesn't seem to handle 3DSecure or any other DSP2 level of authentication. Has anyone recently succeeded making payments with that in the EU ?
Of course if you give your actual credit card number/CVV etc. but with a fake name it will get refused by your issuer.
Works great and you can set a date for it to lock itself after to block charges, they even suggest it as a use case for stopping trials from charging you, etc. It generates a card per website and you can replace it as many times as you want all for free.
Anyone else using this awesome service?
I will continue to do this for businesses that wanna try evil subscription cancellations.
However, they make good care to know the real identity of they buyer, so you'll (mostly) be aware you're getting into that hot water.
I can’t classify this one. Kinda sounds like an IRC wire fraud joke that some kid actually tried.
I stopped pirating stuff as soon as they would sell it to me, but it was because downloading music was a full-time job and I had stuff to do
I am curious if the card #s I can get directly from Citi might work but haven't tested it out. Those are a pain to generate compared to privacy.com though.
I know they can detect that you're on a VPN; at least, one of the popular ones. I'm not sure about obscure VPN services.
Would you know if it works with credit cards not from the US?
How does it deal with transactions in other currencies?
Now when you "subscribe" to WhizBang online, go to Privacy and create a special credit card just for WhizBang. Give WhizBang a fake name and address as well, and don't use your "regular" email. Create some spares on ProtonMail or some other low-friction service.
When WhizBang goes to verify your credit card, your fake name & address are not checked. You can give them whatever you want.
Your purchase will appear on your regular credit card records. If you want Privacy to use a fake seller, you have to pay for that.
When you want to cancel WhizBang, you just close their credit card. They will get a Decline when they go to charge it, and they'll eventually cancel you. You can go through their official cancellation process, if you want to.
This works. It's what I do.