News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by Aromasin on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:18PM (#32402718)
I'm still convinced by Intel's and Pat's XPU strategy. Having a well rounded portfolio of CPUs, GPUs, SoCs, and FPGAs that all work flawlessly, alongside a comprehensive software environment to make cross-platform development easier (their OneAPI stack) is a dream for any OEM/ODM; provided it works.

Their issue at the moment isn't strategy. It's execution. Axing their GPU division would only hurt their current plan, and do nothing to fix the the systematic problem that they're missing deadline's and shipping incomplete products. From the outside looking in, it seems like there's some fat that needs trimming and people aren't pulling their weight. If they can scale back to efficient team and org sizes, cut the side projects, and focus on excellent software and hardware validation, I can see them pulling this off and Pat being lauded as a hero.

Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by PaulHoule on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:20PM (#32402762)
People I know who develop high performance systems are so indifferent to OpenCL it's hard for me to picture what could make people develop for OpenCL.

There is such a long term history of failure here that somebody has to make a very strong case that the next time is going to be different and I've never seen anyone at Intel try that or even recognize that history of failure.

Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by bubblethink on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @07:39PM (#32406089)
With all accelerators, GPUs, FPGAs etc., the solution to me seems pretty simple. Give it away. Like literally give them away like usb sticks in a parking lot. All these companies and startups work on raising massive rounds and focus on enterprise sales and deals with national labs etc., while the average joe has nothing to tinker with. Everybody who mattered had a cheap GPU, and a cheap x86 system before that. That's what drives adoption.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by rasz on Wednesday August 10, 2022 @06:52PM (#32419446)
Intel tried that in its own way. Galileo/Edison Quark based products, lasted 2 years and was pure shit. They entered Arduino hobby embedded world with microcontroller like x86 without dedicated fast IO (it could do something like 1KHz max) and no support/documentation. Intel version of giving it away was pricing slightly below? competition with similar spec (400MHz) while targeting 8bit 16MHz market :-)

Nowadays only Chinese seem to be able to give it away to grow market share. $1 Espressif is a good example, Govin $7 GW1N-1 fpga devboards. Raspberry <$1 RP2040 is one western exception I could come up with.

Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by PaulHoule on Wednesday August 10, 2022 @10:34AM (#32412673)
There are FPGA dev kits that are fairly affordable. It's probably still cheaper to get a breadboard and a bag of 54xx chips if you want to learn digital logic but I'd say the problem for hobby FPGAs is that the developer tools are poor and the FPGA vendors keep the bitstream format secret so there is no competition to produce better developer's tools.

I was also going to mention some dev boards NVIDIA had come out in the last few years that were affordable (I think) but they are all out of stock now and the ones you can get are $2000+ now.

Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by jiggawatts on Wednesday August 10, 2022 @07:26AM (#32410216)
Back in the early 2000s you just had to put your email into a developers' sign-up list and tiny startups nobody had ever heard of like NVIDIA would ship you a GPU nearly a full year before it was available to mainstream customers. Fun times...
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by Miraste on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:37PM (#32403057)
It's unfortunate, but the reality is it would take an act of god to unseat CUDA at this point.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by bobajeff on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @04:09PM (#32403557)
That or they could just open their GPU cores to direct programming instead of locking it behind some API.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by amluto on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @04:12PM (#32403592)
This depends on the degree to which the underlying hardware remains compatible across generations. nVidia can sell monster GPU systems today to run 5-year-old CUDA code faster without any recompilation or other mandatory engineering work. I don’t know whether this is possible with direct hardware access.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by PaulHoule on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @04:23PM (#32403745)
Intel's OneAPI (rebranded OpenCL) can allegedly do this.

It also claims to do this across radically different architectures like FPGA and all I can say to that is "I find that very hard to believe"

Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by buildbot on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @05:56PM (#32404909)
Yeah it is in practice not really true. Maybe after hacking the code you can watch it compile for _days_ and then perform probably worse than a GPU without extreme tuning, which removes the point anyway.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by pjmlp on Wednesday August 10, 2022 @02:12AM (#32408316)
Rebranded SYCL, if it was rebranded OpenCL, it wouldn't even be worth a 2nd look.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by greenknight on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @11:51PM (#32407665)
Depends... sometimes its built specifically to kernels.

One common instance is, blender's Cycles renderer. Every time there is a new NVIDIA GPU. It needs to be recompiled to support it. Sometimes that also requires a new CUDA version to be able to do it. CUDA versions over the years have deprecated different operations and what not.

Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by wmf on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @04:15PM (#32403627)
That's a "did you just tell me to go fuck myself?" solution. It didn't work for AMD and it won't work for anyone else. Developing a CUDA-to-GPU compiler and runtime stack is an immense amount of work and customers or "the community" can't afford it.

Although for completeness I'll note that Intel's GPU architecture is documented: https://01.org/linuxgraphics/documentation/hardware-specific...

Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by VHRanger on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @06:45PM (#32405543)
Vulkan compute might, over time, take root.

The fact that a similar API can be used for training on servers, inference from laptops to phones, is an appealing proposition

Best part: most devices have decent vulkan drivers. Unlike openCL.

Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by pjmlp on Wednesday August 10, 2022 @02:13AM (#32408323)
Only on Khronos dreams, its experience is even worse than OpenCL.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by nicoburns on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @04:22PM (#32403735)
Could Intel just implement CUDA support? That would certainly be a huge task, but Intel aren’t have the resources for that.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by Aromasin on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @06:14PM (#32405148)
Intel doesn't implement CUDA, but they're working on a CUDA to DPC++ (their parallel programming language) migration tool to make the jump less painful. I've tested some of the NVIDIA samples with it and it seems to do the vast majority of the grunt work, but there are still some sections where refactoring is required. You can find it in the OneAPI base toolkit.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by paulmd on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @04:44PM (#32404033)
The GPU Ocelot project did exactly that at one point. It's probably a legal minefield for an organized corporate entity though.

https://gpuocelot.gatech.edu/

Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by TomVDB on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @06:00PM (#32404958)
One of the big attractions of CUDA is not just the core (programming, API, compiler, development tool) but also the libraries (cuDNN, FFT, cuSignal, … It’s a very long list). These libraries are usually not open source, and can thus not be recompiled even if you have core CUDA support.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by doppioandante on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @07:12PM (#32405838)
There is ZLUDA, based on oneAPI if I recall correctly: https://github.com/vosen/ZLUDA
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by tambourine_man on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @05:56PM (#32404910)
Unless someone beats them in the hardware front. GPUs that are 30-50% faster (or just as fast but 30-50% cheaper).

I could see Apple and AMD, working with TSMCs latest node, stepping up to the challenge.

Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by ceeplusplus on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @06:13PM (#32405134)
No way 30-50% is enough. You need 2x at least, if not more. There is a deep rooted ecosystem of CUDA apps. You would need to have at least 2-3 generations of 2x lead to get people to switch.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by rowanG077 on Wednesday August 10, 2022 @06:48AM (#32409992)
For me it's like watching a slowly unfolding car crash. Opencl for all it's flaws is the only compute API that is open, yeah oke Vulkan compute exist as well. All of them using proprietary CUDA has already bitten them in the ass many times. Yet there is nothing beeing done to remove CUDA from the stack at all. Quite the opposite in fact.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by pinewurst on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @04:18PM (#32403668)
And could care even less about “oneAPI”(tm).
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by khitchdee on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:22PM (#32402787)
Execution is about engineers. Intel can't retain their engineers. Without good engineers you can't compete. So you downsize and try compete only on one thing -- better x86. Pat Gs return as CEO does help with engineer retention though.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by ChuckNorris89 on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:37PM (#32403066)
>Execution is about engineers.

Meh, not really. Google has some of the best engineers in the world yet they fail at nearly everything that isn't related to search, android, ads and e-mail.

Even Jensen Huang said that it's more about vision and not all about execution. He said in the early days of Nvidia all of their competitors at the time had engineers good enough to execute, yet only they had the winning vision that enabled them to make and sell exactly what the market wanted, nothing more, nothing less.

Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by time0ut on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @05:16PM (#32404438)
My impression is that most of Google’s failures are strategic. Stadia, for example, has been executed very well in the technical sense. It just doesn’t make a lot of sense strategically. I feel every failure I can think of fits this mold of great technology solving the wrong problem or held back from solving the right problem.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by senttoschool on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @11:59PM (#32407716)
Google is very engineering led. From my experience working with software developers, and as a software developer myself, they're really bad at the business aspect of things. They're too idealistic and not practical.

That and their culture of "move fast, fail fast" means they pull the rug just as fast as they lay it out.

Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by etempleton on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @11:53PM (#32407677)
Google’s pricing model didn’t even make sense. Pay for a subscription and then buy the games that will forever be locked on the Stadia service? Why would anyone want to do that. Microsoft was just rolling out Gamepass, why would you not do that in the cloud?
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by random314 on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:53PM (#32403344)
> everything that isn't related to search, android, ads and e-mail.

And YouTube.

No wonder they are 10X as valuable as Intel

Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by t-3 on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @10:21PM (#32407210)
YouTube was bought due to the failure of Google Video. They couldn't compete, so they acquired.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by nl on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @11:01PM (#32407442)
But that was a failure of marketing and strategy (specifically YT decided to take on copyright claims, Google Video didn't try), not execution.

It was Google engineering that allowed YT to scale.

Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by random314 on Wednesday August 10, 2022 @01:09AM (#32408021)
Not really. Google video would take 24 hours to make an uploaded video available, whereas YouTube made it available right away.

Google video engineering wasn't up to snuff and management decided to move fast and just acquire YouTube.

Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by ChuckNorris89 on Wednesday August 10, 2022 @03:27AM (#32408768)
>Google video engineering wasn't up to snuff

So hiring the best 1337-coders in the world didn't automatically give them the best product? Shocking.

Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by random314 on Wednesday August 10, 2022 @03:03PM (#32416919)
If you look at the details, I would lay the blame on Ghemawat and Jeff Dean and their insistence on using C++ for everything. Nobody could argue against them, even VPs.

When YouTube joined Google, their engineers were shocked to find that Google engineers were writing 1000s of lines of server side C++ code, that could be accomplished in 100s of lines of python code. Which explained why YouTube was able to move a lot faster and pump out features, while Google video was struggling to keep up.

It was not the leetcode engineers, but Dean and Ghemawat insisting on C++ only on the server. Its still true today. Go might be making inroads now.

Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by GoOnThenDoTell on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @11:20PM (#32407538)
They acquired Android too
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by nl on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @10:59PM (#32407434)
>> Execution is about engineers.

> Meh, not really. Google has some of the best engineers in the world yet they fail at nearly everything that isn't related to search, android, ads and e-mail.

Seems to me that Google didn't fail to execute in other things they tried. The products worked fine, but they didn't have a market.

That's not failure of execution, it's failure of strategy.

Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by khitchdee on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:39PM (#32403099)
Google used to be search only. Now they have Android. That's pretty good.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by pinewurst on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @04:20PM (#32403701)
Android is still basically ads - in that it’s another source of info fodder for their ad machine along with search.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by throwawaylinux on Wednesday August 10, 2022 @12:54AM (#32407977)
Google didn't have Android because they had a good engineering team who created it though. They have Android because they had executives with vision who bought Android Inc., and because they had the subsequent humility and vision to override what the engineers had initially developed resteered the project in the wake of the iPhone.

I've noticed it's very hard for a lot of technical people to give credit to executives, marketing, finance, or anyone else when it comes to the success of a technical product, but very easy for them to assign blame to those groups. Whereas those latter groups often seem to be the first to credit engineers with successful products, and willing to share blame for failures.

Maybe it's because I'm in the technical group so I hear insider gossip and rantings, and the other groups project an overly generous facade, but unfortunately sometimes it doesn't feel like it. Ask a sample of nerds about failed projects near to their hearts. DEC, Sun, Boeing, whatever Google chat app they liked, the failed company or project they worked on, etc. 9 times out of 10 you'll hear rantings about greedy management, incompetent finance, the idiots in marketing, etc. who wantonly desecrated the Mona Lisas and Sistine Chapels of Engineering.

Many engineers are very good at taking a problem given to them by their company or one they've dreamed up and optimizing the hell out of it. Very few are capable of identifying problems that will be valued by others, and coming up with approaches to solving them in ways that are cost competitive and marketable. Very few people at all can do that well because it requires a measure of creativity and multi disciplinary vision, but at least executives are supposed to be thinking about these things so they have a chance.

Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by ChuckNorris89 on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:46PM (#32403215)
And how many other dozens of products did Google build then kill off due to failure? Similar to Intel.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by khitchdee on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:50PM (#32403297)
Intel does not have a number 2. They only own x86. They have failed to diversify.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by __d on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @05:17PM (#32404457)
They have _tried_ to diversify:

They have competitive NICs, although they don't seem to be maintaining the lead there they once had.

They bought competitive network switches. These have largely languished, in part because they sat on the IP and then targeted it at weird niches.

They bought Altera. I feel like it had lost some momentum vs. Xilinx, but with AMD acquiring the latter, it's probably going to end up a wash.

The AI chips are kinda too early to tell, but at least they're playing the game.

Overall, I think they have squandered the massive advantage they had in CPUs for the last 3 decades.

Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by touisteur on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @06:50PM (#32405598)
Oh yeah I'm waiting for their 200G NICs while NVIDIA is ramping up connectx 7 with 400G on PCIe5...

The low end AI chips are a mess. Myriad-X can be used only through openvino, and they've been closing details about the internals... Keembay is... Years late?

Is there anything coming out of Intel these days?

And what happened to nervana systems, became plaidml then disappeared after bought by Intel? Maxas was really great and now, crickets.

Even profiling tools, which they used to be on top of, don't seem to work well on Linux w/ the TigerLake gpu. It's so painful to debug and program, they might as well have not put it in...

Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by khitchdee on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @09:18PM (#32406840)
> Overall, I think ...

That's a reflection of their company culture. They're a bit stiff.

Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by ChuckNorris89 on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:59PM (#32403418)
>Intel does not have a number 2

Yeah they do, Intel has the FPGA division they bought from Altera. That's a huge business on its own.

And my point still stands: having great engineers is not enough for great execution. You need great leadership with a vision a-la Steve Jobs or Jensen Huang.

Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by tambourine_man on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @05:58PM (#32404934)
And that’s what, 15 years old?
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @06:45PM (#32405544)
The degree of market penetration that Android has maintained for that 15 years is a pretty impressive feat, both strategically and technically.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by R0b0t1 on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @04:23PM (#32403755)
Necessary but not sufficient is the phrase.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by djmips on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @09:51PM (#32407042)
Self aggrandizing I feel. Vision is helpful but Nvidia still had better engineers than the rest.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by abudabi123 on Wednesday August 10, 2022 @07:38AM (#32410296)
The sweetspot secret sauce is for leadership to superposition the talent's output in the product. I don't know if ever Microsoft's ecosystem did this. While watching Google's acquired Deepmind defeat China's Go-champ I was playing with everything top of the line from Microsoft's ecosystem and the whole was less than the individual parts in quality, design, etc, put together. Apple has at times achieved this while under Steve Jobs. Steve Jobs's vision was decades and decades ahead of the curve if you go through his interviews. You get this sixth sense is in Elon Musk.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by alfalfasprout on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @06:39PM (#32405477)
It's a bit of everything but yeah, what I've seen is basically that Intel has a combination of absolutely insane talent working on some really hard problems and a lot of mediocre talent that they churn through.

And the reality is that yeah, with their comp for engineers so abysmally bad why would anyone really go there? Especially when it's not like they're getting great WLB.

Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by khitchdee on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @08:43PM (#32406590)
Their stock options are not worth anything now. It's no longer a great place to work. Because they do not show you the money.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by PaulHoule on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:28PM (#32402915)
For the last 20 years there have always been stories in the press about how Intel is laying off 10,000 engineers. It never struck me as a very psychologically safe place to work.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @06:46PM (#32405561)
IIRC, they had (maybe still have?) a policy of laying off the bottom 5%. Every year. For a company that size, it's a lot of engineers.

But yes, that probably does not make it a psychologically safe place to work...

Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by PaulHoule on Wednesday August 10, 2022 @10:27AM (#32412560)
It's a dangerous policy because the one person who never gets laid off is the narcissist who is good at managing people's impressions of them.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by tlb on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @08:08PM (#32406339)
Part of strategy is knowing what your organization is capable of, and not burning time and money trying to do something you can't execute effectively.

I mean, "make the fastest CPUs and GPUs and charge a premium" would be a great strategy if they could deliver. But in a world where they're struggling to keep up on the CPU side, pouring resources into GPUs could lose them both markets.

Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by ncmncm on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @08:30PM (#32406504)
But they need a decent-ish GPU to integrate on their CPU dies.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by Dalewyn on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @08:45PM (#32406607)
Do they?

I can't remember the last time I sincerely used an integrated GPU, Intel or AMD, since they're too weak for my purposes. I only ever use them as a Lowest Common Denominator failsafe when troubleshooting.

And for use cases (not necessarily mine) where low-end GPUs make sense, it's not like Nvidia and AMD don't sell bottom of the barrel GPUs that you (or OEMs) can buy for a Franklin each or something.

Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by nyanpasu64 on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @10:51PM (#32407388)
Integrated GPUs with shader support (Intel HD graphics, not GMA) are fine for web browsing and programming work, which is what I spend most of my time on. In laptops with switchable graphics, sticking with integrated graphics can save power consumption. And additionally they're not anywhere near as scalped/overpriced as discrete gaming GPUs, or as horrible value as low-end GPUs (I suspect some of the price comes from the cost of a display adapter and media decoder/encoder). Though integrated graphics are subpar for gaming or compute for sure.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by ac29 on Wednesday August 10, 2022 @11:17AM (#32413402)
Intel is the number 1 GPU vendor by volume. Integrated GPUs are good enough for the majority of PC users these days.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by ncmncm on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @09:41PM (#32406989)
Laptops and netbooks.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by Dalewyn on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @09:56PM (#32407070)
There is nothing stopping them from using discrete GPUs on the lower end. Don't tell me they don't have the physical space for another chip on the mobo either, because they do.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by ncmncm on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @11:15PM (#32407508)
It just costs more. Netbooks are pretty price-sensitive, tablets moreso.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by klelatti on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:30PM (#32402947)
You may well be right but if each of the individual components of that portfolio is worse than the competition then it will be an uphill struggle.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by khitchdee on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:54PM (#32403365)
XPU is too generic a term and harmful looking at it from a business perspective.
Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by AceJohnny2 on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @06:33PM (#32405406)
> provided it works

Ay, there's the rub!

Re:Will Intel's AXG division survive Pat Gelsinger’s axe? by mugivarra69 on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:26PM (#32402873)
isnt that amd rn