This is the perpetual moral hazard that we constantly see at all big tech firms. These firms promised fantastical profit margins, but only on the condition of scaling at very low cost. What doesn't scale at very low cost? Customer service. That's why you're all so awful at it.
And don't come back with your satisfaction metrics from customers you haven't screwed. Your job is to do right by the customers who aren't convenient for you. Just like it's an insurance company's job to pay out to the tiny minority of claimants. It doesn't matter one bit if the company has a great web site or API that everyone loves. The true moral nature of your company is revealed by how you treat the customers who need you to do right by them.
I don't see how you can assume bad faith on the user. Have you ever dealt with corporations? If so, you would know that they often lie and downplay things that make them look bad.
I feel it is only fair to point out that Stripe might be a dirty rotten liar, too.
This is not something the business sells, and a huge chargeback risk
https://www.reddit.com/r/smallbusiness/comments/wa1zob/dont_...
I read a few of their comments their complain seems to be about the $3000 and needing to wait 120 days to get it.
They also say you can't call, but at least for me I'm able to call Stripe here: https://support.stripe.com/?contact=true
Second, I posit that having even one (confirmed) suspicious or fraudulent transaction increases the likelihood of having others.
> I used Stripe for about a year to run a small cell phone store in Denver, CO area. [1]
> We sold a cheap van in the company name. [2]
Yeah, that explains how they arrived in Stripe jail.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32261868#32264335
[2] https://www.reddit.com/r/smallbusiness/comments/wa1zob/comme...
I don't think you're disagreeing with patio11 here. To wit:
> Sometimes situations which result in external complaints are the result of a process failure, and *in those cases we try to fix the instant case and improve processes in the future*.
I read that as: they prioritize satisfying the immediate, dissatisfied customer first and address process improvement second, which is exactly the priority that you're suggesting. Especially combined with patio11's other suggestion of personally contacting the upper management of the company.
Your customer service strategy is really "go to a small internet forum that only some startup nerds know about and find my email address"?
It's a shame because a good customer support interaction can create a serious evangelist (hard to quantify but extremely valuable). Maybe Stripe knows this because they put a lot of effort into appeasing the HN community (many developers/entrepreneurs who make processor purchasing decisions). I wish they'd apply this attitude to all their customers.
We offer (human-powered, somewhat obviously?) support via a variety of methods 24/7; time for us to reply to email is generally a few minutes. Could we do this better? Yes, and I hope we continue doing it better; if anyone ever has an interaction where we don't meet the bar please flag to us.
I don't know whether it's a chatbot spitting out replies based on keyword matching, or whether it's a human with a "responses per hour" performance target which doesn't give them time to read the emails they're replying to, but either way it's very different from the "talking to a human" experience I'm used to from daily life.
(And it's not a case of a correct process coming to a result I don't enjoy, except in a very narrow sense. "I understand your request and the answer is no" would be an improvement over what I often get)
Then, when the account didn't auto-renew because they didn't have any card on file, their canned response switched to "create a new Platinum account" (with much worse benefits).
I requested that this be the same grandfathered type of Platinum account that I lost.
Their canned response was that I should create a new Platinum account.
I said okay, but I want the same benefits I lost.
Their canned response was that I should create a new Platinum account.
I created a new Platinum account. It had much worse benefits.
Approximately one week later, I was permanently banned from Tinder for violating community standards without explanation (after having been a nice member of the community for the past year on Platinum and continuing to be one).
Wow, one reply in and we're already seeing open contempt for this type of troublesome customer. What nerve, expecting a payment processor to promptly process payments and make funds accessible to the account holder.
This reply is going to look monumentally bad if the customer ends up being right about how they were treated.
And will you say the opposite when the opposite is true? Other comments mention facts about how the OP tried to do something outside of normal and the response is expected for "abnormal" behavior on an account.
Anger against companies is one thing... but will you defend them when it turns out the company is in the right or is this only a one sided comment?
The statement that he never talked to a human could be true at the point in time when he first made the claim in his reddit post.
While I understand you can't comment on the specifics of this case, can you speak generally about whether or not disabling the phone/chat support buttons is a part of some standard process?
Sometimes, a financial institution might only be able, due to staffing or other considerations, to deal with you asynchronously in writing, perhaps from e.g. a group of professionals who are not as numerous as front-line user operations.
Are you just trying to say "we're so short staffed, there's no one to answer your messages, let alone your calls?"
But that kind of phrasing leaves a big gap.
Do they offer it during some hours? Which hours? Or do they offer it never?
There's a big difference between "call and chat are only extended beyond business hours for certain issues" and "call and chat are only ever for certain issues".
The response here could mean either.
The small company I was working for got card tested (scammers use hundreds of stolen cards to see if they work). I called customer support and talked with a human on a Friday night at 8pm for 15 minutes about our options. 2-3 days later, I chatted with someone from the fraud team.
I was surprised by the high touch service even though didn't have a lot of volume (new account w/ less than $10k of transactions).
You've build up an incredible amount of kudos with your comments and blog posts over the last decade+ here and are willing to burn it for a corporation in a moment? Earning trust takes a long time, losing trust only takes the blink of an eye.
If it was just bad communication about what this specific business uses the card for, it seems like that should be resolvable without waiting out the chargeback period.
Using a merchant account for a purpose which you haven't disclosed to the processor -- like a cell phone store selling a truck -- is a violation of the merchant agreement, and is often grounds for account closure.
1. Is selling trucks against the terms in general?
2. This is a cell phone store selling a cell phone store truck. It's part of the business, not something unrelated.
If they had thought of it, they probably would have made trucks or no trucks a part of the processing agreement up front. They thought it was a reasonable use, and it might have even been a reasonable use! So why can't this be resolved any sooner or with better communication?
Probably not, but I can't rule it out. It's certainly an unusual thing to accept a credit card payment for, and the fact that vehicles are titled property may complicate matters.
> 2. This is a cell phone store selling a cell phone store truck. It's part of the business, not something unrelated.
No, it isn't. The business of a cell phone store is, generally speaking, going to be selling cell phones and cell phone accessories, and its merchant account will have been obtained with the understanding that it would only be used for charges related to those products. It isn't in the business of selling cash registers or furniture or trucks, even if it may happen to possess those things as a business; if it wants to sell those things, it needs to accept payment through some other means.
> its merchant account will have been obtained with the understanding
> if it wants to sell those things, it needs to accept payment through some other means
So it's not part of the general business, but it is the business doing the sale, and such a thing was not part of the merchant account negotiation.
...I don't see a single thing you actually disagree with me over?
> time for us to reply to email is generally a few minutes
These two assertions are conflicting. A few minutes is not nearly enough time for a human to understand and address a support request. So like most companies, it sounds like Stripe is actually running automated support behind a fleshy humanesque interface. Don't delude yourselves into thinking that this counts as "human-powered" support.
I've also wasted hours of my life on hold with customer service "people" who, in the best case, take 5 minutes to hear my situation, 15 minutes to check into it, 5 more minutes to apparently not do the thing they said they were going to do, and 0 seconds to forget about all these details after hanging up, meaning I had to go through the same pattern all again the next call. Even in the cases where I've directed reps to look at previous tickets for history, half the time they still can't find it.
I'm sure that there are many people that use support instead of clicking around to the right option on the website, even though that seems abhorrent waste of time to anyone with half a clue. But companies optimizing for this are doing a disservice to everyone that is only using higher touch methods because they're trying to solve uncommon situations.
I can believe that "modern" support only takes a few minutes per the request, because each individual request is itself just a cog in the larger machine. When I spend an hour on the phone, bounced back and forth between 3-4 departments, how long was each of those conversations? Like so many things these days, the problem is with the overall constructive behavior rather than the myopic metrics that have been over optimized.
And don't get me started on those useless freeform voice prompts. Don't make the customer distill their problem down into a curt description, because once again, they're likely calling with a weird problem. Just give me the numeric options that mirror your business structure and I'll pick the most appropriate one, thank you.
Many, many, many people do not do that. Ask any retail business what the #1 and #2 calls are and the answer is always #1: "Are you open right now?" and #2: "What are your hours?". I suspect a big chunk of Stripe's email requests are similarly trivial - "where can I see my $whatever report", "can I take amex?", "how much will I pay for a $.95 transaction", etc. that a competent support person can answer in their sleep. Now if we're getting into complicated technical issues, I'm sure those should be taking more time.
I share your disdain for those "just say what your issue is", although the trick to that is usually to say "cancel" and get immediately transferred to someone who will be expected to keep your business.
>We don't comment publicly on individual customers. This is an important part of customer privacy and we're serious about it.
But then you heavily imply that the user ("Many people who say...") is a liar? Bad look.
What does "human-powered support" even mean? Is this weasel speak for a chatbot or do you mean actual people replying to support claims?
But maybe the cost of this model is hidden from the consumer, and I'd rather pay a bit to have reliability and fairness. I don't know how much I'd have to pay, but I'm willing to guess it's palatable, or at least in the neighbourhood. If we are being tricked by these hidden costs, it's better (if you can) to move on, there are people trying to compete even if it's a difficult industry to break into. Try not to get locked in. If I were running a small business, I'd definitely be discounting crypto payments and putting the extra work into handling whatever regulatory complications arise, vs yelling at the walls that are the infinitely scaling tech companies
Is there a reason you can't get ARN/STAN refund codes via the Stripe API?
I have never been able to get an answer to that.
The issue is Card payments and the networks they use. Doesn't matter if lightning settles transactions instantly if the customer wants to pay with Visa and Visa allows funds claw back for ~180 days.
Normally a stores merchant account is kept open, so if a transaction is charged back a month later (and the bank and visa aggree with the chargeback) the money can be recovered from future sales. If the stores merchant account is closed because of "reasons" the payment provider can either use the funds the store has yet to cash out from the the payment provider as "insurance" against chargebacks until the deadline passes (at which case its safe to cash out) or start invoicing the store you just told to GTFO as a merchant to try and get the money back and then go recovery paths which is much more a nightmare for payment providers.
I'm not saying I agree with the polices, just that I understand why they are in place, the payment providers are just covering their own asses at the end of the day.
My question is about "what if".
Would there be downsides?
If the upsides outweigh the downsides, LN could slowly find its way into retail. Maybe by starting with some special use cases where speed, low fees, privacy or immutability are especially important.
Customers with outstanding orders are often on the bottom of the list of creditors who get paid back when a company goes bust and even the companies themselves will often say in their final messages to customers to speak to their card company and issue a charge back for outstanding orders.
The vendor needs to factor in the costs induced by Stripe. That's 3% fee plus the danger of your account being frozen. How much is that? Maybe another 1%?
So if the "price" to use Stripe is 4%, the vendor could offer their customers the same products for 2% less if they pay via lightning - and share the savings with their customers.
Sounds like a good deal. I have bought something with my CC hundreds of times and never ever did a chargeback.
On top of it, as a customer, I find credit cards annoying and scary. To get one, I have to get it physically delivered to my snail mail box. And everytime I pull that thing out, someone could photograph or memorize the numbers on it and cause me trouble.
There's nothing more annoying than trying to pay for your meal via a payment method they don't accept -- a common one these days is cash, many restaurants just don't accept it around here anymore, with no signage. So, for businesses, it isn't just a matter "willing to pay for it" but also customer expectations and not having to pay for "employee downtime" (such as employees having to explain why they don't accept that payment method) and "lost inventory" (such as a table being held while someone travels somewhere to retrieve a different payment method).
> the vendor could offer their customers the same products for 2% less if they pay via lightning
They can do this already by switching to a different payment provider that isn't "turn-key via API." There are many payment providers that only cost a small percentage over the interchange rate which varies between 1.5% and 3%, IIRC, depending on the type of card. You have to deal with sending transactions via FTP and all kinds of shenanigans ... but this is why you pay Stripe a flat rate, right?
> and share the savings with their customers.
I LOL'd. That never happens. Ever. Also, 2% isn't going to make a noticeable difference to practically anyone.
> I have bought something with my CC hundreds of times and never ever did a chargeback.
And that one time you do, you'll be incredibly thankful to get the money back that was spent on a container of shoes in a country you've never been to. True story.
> everytime I pull that thing out, someone could photograph or memorize the numbers on it and cause me trouble.
You can use tap-to-pay in a reasonably advanced area. My card never comes out of my wallet. Ever. I just hold my wallet up to the sensor and it is done.
> I have to get it physically delivered to my snail mail box.
Same here in the UK, however the cards are not delievered "activated", so you have to verify account details to enable to the card so prevents against thieft of the card in the mail (as even if it was stolen from the mail and activated, you will quickly contact the card issuer to say "Hey, where my card?" at which point the issuer will cancel the card and cancel any trasactions made on the card)
> everytime I pull that thing out, someone could photograph or memorize the numbers on it and cause me trouble.
Same could happen with Debit cards too, however the card number alone is useless without the EMV chip for in store transactions here in the UK (Mastercard are even phasing out the magnetic stripe completely[0] - My accounts are set to refuse magnetic stripe transactions unless I enable them via the banks app) and online transactions offer lower fee's if you validate the 3 digits on the back of the card and the address of the card holder, so most online stores will have for all 3 pieces of info (card number, the CVV, and the card holders address) before accepting the transaction. Making it harder to commit the fraud.
My cards (which I recently had replaced as I misplaced my wallet, guess i'm not as responsible as I thought I was) all now have the card number on the back of the card (makes it hard to photograph the card number as the chip and number are onn opposite sides, so when you insert/tap the card into a reader the number is not facing you or anyone standing next to/behind you.
Most of my cards support Apple Pay (The exception is my PayPal Business card which doesn't whoever I don't carry that card with me anyway) So most of the time I'm not getting my cards out of my wallet when I'm purchasing items in store (Prob the reason I misplaced my wallet, Its prob in the house SOMEWHERE...). But granted Apple Pay/Google Pay are not as widely used as the plastic cards shipped from the card issuers are.
Replacing my cards was a piece of cake for me, granted I use more "modern banks" than the high street banks of old, so when I reported my cards as lost my bank issued me a temporary card to my phone so I could still do purchases while I waited for my new card to arrive (Not all banks do this, and the temp card had a max spend limit on it until my new card arrived).
And on top of that the credit card has greater consumer protections than debit cards anyway if something were to happen.
[0]: https://www.mastercard.com/news/perspectives/2021/magnetic-s...
EDIT: I forgot to say. Just because Credit cards have greater protections than Debit cards, that doesn't mean that debits cards have no protection at all.
Also, disputing charges is a whole separate protocol for lightning that hasn't yet been considered. Or more accurately, is railed against as 'code is law' and 'not your keys not your crypto'
So for all the fees you 'save,' lightning nets a significantly below 0.
[Edit] Upwork is big enough to make their own gateway - the idea that they haven't is negligent.
FedNow also replaces ACH debit origination and its Good Funds Period with a Request to Pay architecture that IMO is far safer and has fewer edge cases and lacks the hilarious infinite loop in ACH debit exception handling.
So, yeah, good question, sorry you're being downvoted.
Bit of an understatement, right?
They are waiting for your answers, it is a public matter as per your clients repeated requests, it affects more people, money is involved, we are all waiting for your resolution and future mitigation actions. Or rebuttal ofcourse.
So much to unpack here but this is extremely patronizing ("we're not wrong, you just didn't like what we did). "process operating correctly" refers to holding a merchant's money with no reason communicated, and no way for them to get in touch with the company?
We are looking into things.
As someone who ran businesses for a long time myself, it would be very alarming to me if customers felt they were being ignored while repeatedly talking to people who work for us. If that ever happens, please bring in literally anyone at Stripe, inclusive of other Patrick. Our email addresses are often available through a quick search of HN; mine is (predictably) [email protected] if you need it.
We don't comment publicly on individual customers. This is an important part of customer privacy and we're serious about it.
Sometimes situations which result in external complaints are the result of a process failure, and in those cases we try to fix the instant case and improve processes in the future.
Sometimes they are the result of a process operating correctly but coming to a result which someone did not enjoy. The record available to the process is often more detailed than the record available to the public Internet, and may include extremely relevant context.