There is a worrying return to authoritarianism everywhere. People forget that none of their rights would have been won if there wasn’t any wiggle room in the system, for people to do illegal things before they get accepted as legal, like smoking pot, being gay, being pro-democracy, etc.
You are literally removing people's functional access to food, water, and shelter.
going after financing was surprisingly efficient, but not giving them the convenient out of "sure continue protesting without the trucks" was dumb.
I think we can agree that it left us with 3 things: a dangerous precedent, a reminder to everyone that a centralized, cashless society has downsides, and a protest that ended after a week instead of being dragged on for months.
Police not doing their job. Yep, and Ottawa did not want to rock that boat too much. (I can imagine they had some initial guess as how quickly they will give up, so it could be that that's why the police was lenient with them. But who knows.)
While from a power and monopoly on violence perspective going after finances is very similar to using other means to get people to do this or that, but it sets a very bad precedent. Even if it's the easier way compared to doing the hard work of separating the truckers from their trucks one by one, and removing the trucks.
But hey, that rhetoric came directly from the the only government in the western hemisphere to have suspended constitutional rights (and because of a protest) since probably World War 2... So it's not exactly surprising.
(There was also this obsession to call them terrorists, again textbook dehumanizing/discrediting tactics. And for the record, I'm not a pro truckers and voted for trudeau twice. Yet the way the government dealt with the situation was literally disgusting.)
We went from calling them conservative grandma killers (at least that was somewhat related to their claims), to nazis, to terrorists and finally foreign backed insurrectionists. In 2 weeks. Let's hope the public opinion doesn't ever turn against Muslims as much too then, because now I have a glimpse of just how irrelevant any of my rights would suddenly be.
Agreed. Though the difference with the Canadian Truckers vs all other protests was that it was ongoing 24/7 and they were advertising for donations with the promise of continuing the protest.
Sure the government could have done nothing and let them do their thing but the voter backlash against them would have grown to include not only the people protesting but the people affected by the protests. So the government used all the tools in the toolbox to stop it including propaganda. It's kind of wild though to think that the rest of the country or world can essentially extend their political influence to an issue in a geographical area where they have no "skin in the game".
Personally I think it was stupid of the truckers to block key trade routes. Did they not realise that politicians receive donations both officially and non officially (revolving door) from wealthy people who own businesses? Why not just announce an ongoing strike? My guess would be they didn't have the numbers or they weren't willing to make a financial sacrifice for their cause.
Yes, the wealthy can afford to find ways to cheat on everything. But all segments of society are dodging taxes.
As a middle-class salaried employee, your income is taxed down to the last decimal place. But if you work in the trades, or anything else where many transactions are handled in cash, then tax evasion is _rampant_. And you know who is usually party to that? The tradespeople AND the relatively wealthier folks giving them envelopes of cash in exchange for a "discount" because the transaction isn't reported.
Will those stop? Probably not. But at least in larger sums it should make people afraid of dodging their tax burden.
I don't understand how making middle/poor class pay more taxes spares the rich from taxes.
Only consumption and wealth should be taxed. Wealthy people tend to consume more anyways. For some goods & services (energy consumption for example) a progressive tax rate might be appropriate, with tax exception for people who consume the least (as poor tend to do).
Luxury goods and services (private planes and yachts, luxury car brands, etcetera should also have a higher than normal tax rate, since for wealthy people the barrier to buy would still be low and poor or middleclass people can’t afford such goods and services anyway.
A system without income tax could also result in very simple tax reporting for most people, an additional benefit.
In practice, consumption taxes are extremely regressive.
Firstly, because people who earn less necessarily have to spend a much higher proportion of their income to stay afloat.
Secondly, because higher earners tend to spend their money on categories that are typically exempted (like healthcare, education, investments, political activism, real estate) -- and things that are out of the easy reach of taxation, like international travel.
Consumption tax is also logistically quite expensive, because it requires every business to continually and constantly maintain records on all sales and returns; the recording for payslips is comparatively trivial. Three compliance burden is magnified by incredibly complex rules which often require teams of experts to evaluate, exactly because of the kinds of "luxury" carve outs you're already identifying seem warranted.
Income tax reporting does not need to be hard for most people. The top 1% of earners cover almost 40% of revenue; the bottom 50% cover only 3%. We don't need to make everyone file and pay income taxes each year; we could do just fine with only 1/10th of Americans filling. The pain of income tax is just a contrivance in the name of "fairness" to make regular people hate the tax process and support policies that would significantly alleviate the well-offs tax burden. Policies like exchanging income tax for sales tax.
This is usually not possible. In Denmark you are taxed the same whether you receive your payment in stock or money. When you receive stock, you are taxed on the value of the stock at receive time -- obviously this is awful for receiving grants in a startup where the paper value is high, the stock is iliquid and the risk is substantial.
I think where the rich really benefits are the equity line of credit (ELOCs), where they effectively move money around without generating taxable events -- usually for very small interest payments.
The real benefit to the rich is capital gains rates are significantly lower than income tax rates in many places, so anyone who is paid via capital gains pays significantly less tax. The income tax over 150,000 in the UK is 45% plus 3% for national insurance, and capital gains is a flat 20% for someone on that income level.
Make the charity fully controlled by the family and it's a great way to protect ones wealth. Most of the income can be spend on stock purchases and perhaps <1% of the yearly profit can be spend on the actual charity, while another big part of the profits can be used to provide secure income for family members and friend working for the charity. Also, it's a way to avoid inheritance tax and to prevent someone running off with part of the wealth after a divorce.
Taxing income is in my opinion both unethical and rich people can avoid tax on most of their income anyways if they put in a little effort.
Income which you need to tax. So you just jumped through another hoop before having to pay income tax.
They would pay more consumption tax but pay less percentage wise, because wealthy people save more than poor people.
Raising consumption taxes will be regressive because poor people spend all their money on food, heating and other consumption.
Taxing property perhaps would work. Or inheritance taxes. Big resistance on those for obvious reasons.
Currently there is no reason for them to be conscious about that when every moment of my life incurs a taxable response not to mention their response to me even forgetting to pay amounts as paltry as $1000 is utterly excessive.
Funny the amount of effort they put into that yet how much effort is being put into keeping spending in check.
Someones got to consume less. Everyone thinks it should be the other guy. Wealthy have power so they are always shifting the burden to the middle class and the poor.
That much always seemed obvious to me at the federal level. For state/municipal governments there's at least some argument they do actually rely on the revenue, as they can't just go ahead and print/issue more money as needed.
It is as simple as that. "Less pressure" on the Government is a joke. The more it has, the more it wants.
If you give your power away, they take it, and want more. Power 101.
The money will be spent on things like public Media and public education to make propaganda for the Government. And on making the people in power mega rich, just like in China, Russia, Cuba, Venezuela or Argentina.
Or perhaps, more cynically, for lower taxes overall.
The rich then get tax cuts for themselves that aren't applicable to regular people (like most all of us). Example of something we should address - bezos and musk get loans on their vast stock holdings. The loans aren't taxable. If their holdings slowly get higher in value, they never have to sell their stock to get that value (or they have so much they never get a margin call). They can pass on those stocks to their heirs which can reset the price. I wish we all had a billion in stock and we could get a few tens of millions in loans to live off of, never triggering a capital gains tax.
Another example is wealth taxes, which would be something along the line of Steve Ballmer has to pay 1/2 % of his wealth over 100 million or something every year. But what if he doesn't have ready available cash for that, people say, it's hard to value things. Somehow we could do it. And we never think about it, but everyone who owns a house has to pay a wealth tax every year! We normal people pay wealth taxes, the really rich should probably have to do it too. All the same arguments about changing values and not have ready money from an expensive asset applies to every home own in america who pays property tax.
I acknowledge that there are valid privacy grounds to oppose the move to cashless/less-cash. I just don't accept the argument that it should be easier for middle-class plumbers to not declare their income.
My military? The one that hasn't maintained a defensive posture since 1946? The one that, instead of defending me, goes out of its way to murder civilians in sovereign nations? The one that engages in not-congressionally-declared wars on completely fabricated pretexts? You raise this as a good thing?
Utilities: I don't know where you live, but where I live, private electric utility companies pay for their own infrastructure, or, where there is a public utility, they are paid by bonds secured by future water/sewer fees, not taxes.
Roads, fine, I have no problem with these, but again, they are paid largely by use and gasoline taxes, not income tax.
Furthermore: sales and use taxes are great, and I fully support them. Even luxury taxes are fine - you want to stick it to the rich, go for it, set a 60% sales tax on Maseratis and such. Income tax, however, is an absolute tyranny. Disincentivizing value creation is literally the worst idea in modern governance. In a world of 400+ PPM CO2, disincentivizing consumption is what we need the most.
You can easily make the argument that tax evasion is morally right, since much of our tax money goes to a military that destabilizes "unfriendly" governments around the world and spills as much blood as needed to maintain our globalist economy.
Now, it basically affects everyone - the current threshold is in the between minimum wage and average wage, closer to minimum, with exceptions for effectively 5-year-or-older-common-cars and a couple more things. In a couple of years, the threshold would likely be lower than minimum wage (either by rule change, or by inflation that would bring minimum wage above current threshold), and at that point, the threshold would be "money you can give your kids to buy to stuff for themselves at the store, and not much more".
Slow boil, works great on populations.
I wonder if the exception is easily abused. "Here's a 1980's beater and a suitcase which does not contain cocaine, that'll be 30 thousand dollars please!".
The Indian government is not trying to ban cash. Demonetization replaced old currency notes with new ones and the total cash in circulation increased after demonetization played out.
In India, only the salaried class fully pays their taxes. Businesses which deal in cash don't and anything that makes tax evasion difficult is a Good Thing⟨™⟩.
However, once you move out of the big cities and into the small towns, cash still rules.
You see rich people have to use banks. Because over certain sums, using cash just becomes way too dangerous. So they use banks which means the banks report to the government and the government gets their taxes. But rich people also often influence the government (or even outright run it). And they hate paying taxes. So they want to shift some of the taxation burden on to the middle class and the poor. But poor people often use cash and sometimes skim on taxes. I am sure this happens with some of the more adventurous middle class too. For smaller sums cash is perfectly manageable.
Thus, the government becomes very concerned and does everything it can to "help" the poor move to more modern electronic payments.