News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by mr-ron on Saturday July 02, 2022 @02:20PM (#31961143)
Tangent related to this. I had an old yahoo mail address from late 90s till mid 00s before I switched to gmail. Lots of family / high school / college / early professional emails were there.

The other month I logged in to view them as I do every so often and yahoo had purged the entire archive. Like 20MB worth of emails gone.

Apparently they have a policy if you do not log in in a year of time they will delete everything with no way to recover.

I can’t imagine the decision making to put this policy in nor could I ever imagine using yahoo email again for any purpose whatsoever.

Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by reid on Saturday July 02, 2022 @03:14PM (#31961514)
Full disclosure: I work on Yahoo Mail, but I’m not speaking for my employer.

Yes, this can happen after 12 months of inactivity for free accounts. Policy: https://help.yahoo.com/kb/SLN2018.html

For context, Gmail has a policy which allows for deletion after 2 years of inactivity: https://www.google.com/gmail/about/policy/

I’m sorry the service didn’t meet your expectation, but for others here who are curious, there are some options for keeping email storage active! These days there are paid Yahoo Mail accounts available which retain email for as long as you have the subscription active. (Or you can log in once a year with a free account.)

You can also use a IMAP app to save a local archive of all of your email. This works for all accounts, even free ones! More: https://help.yahoo.com/kb/SLN5033.html

Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by iforgotpassword on Saturday July 02, 2022 @04:12PM (#31961941)
What totally enraged me about this is that the policy was apparently introduced long after I created my account. At some point when I switched to Gmail, I set up yahoo to forward to it. This worked for years. Then this policy kicked in and from one day to the other, the Yahoo account was deleted. No warning was sent to the Gmail address beforehand. There wasn't much going on on the Yahoo account anyways, so I only noticed it much later. I have an old YouTube account that I signed up to with that yahoo address that I can't access anymore, and not do the recovery process because email.

Easy, just recreate that Yahoo account right? Wrong, to suck even more, yahoo now only offers new Email accounts on their .com domain. Mine wasn't on the .com domain. But existing accounts on the other domains still work fine, so they need to keep up that infra anyways.

Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by geoduck14 on Saturday July 02, 2022 @05:44PM (#31962748)
>Full disclosure: I work on Yahoo Mail, but I’m not speaking for my employer.

I've worked for large corporations before, and I have had training g that explicitly told me not to "go on social media, disclose my affiliation, and then run text support".

I'm not going to tell you how to post on HN - cause I love hearing true tech stories, but you might consider caution

Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by PyWoody on Saturday July 02, 2022 @06:40PM (#31963127)
One of the things that makes HN special is getting frontline insights like what OP gave. Almost any thread with a major issue/outage will have such a comment. Most of the time, it will come directly from a CTO/CEO.
Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by robin_reala on Saturday July 02, 2022 @05:56PM (#31962824)
I work for a large corp and I’ve explicitly OKed it with the social media team that it’s OK for me to engage with customer complaints online to get them resolved if necessary. There are a few guidelines, but they’re easy to meet.
Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by cratermoon on Saturday July 02, 2022 @06:41PM (#31963141)
In my experience, this cuts two ways. Some companies hire what about to PR flacks to respond to complaints with bland, vague apologies and company hype. The good companies have real support people tasked specifically with engaging on social media to help users fix issues, especially common ones. As you might expect, I tend to prefer to do business with the latter, and I suspect I'm not alone.
Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by enlyth on Saturday July 02, 2022 @03:27PM (#31961610)
Gmail definitely does not enact this policy. Me and a friend managed to log into a shared gmail account recently we had from high school, to which no one logged in for more than a decade.
Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by londons_explore on Saturday July 02, 2022 @06:07PM (#31962885)
To my knowledge gmail has never purged unused accounts.

It would be a security nightmare to let anyone else register and reuse an email address anyway. So the only benefit is saving a little disk space.

But disk space for highly compressible text that will probably never be accessed is super cheap.

Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by londons_explore on Sunday July 03, 2022 @04:14AM (#31966043)
If costs got too much, they could easily take all very old emails and archive them - for example onto tape and cut down to one or even no online replicas.

Then add a button that says "Some emails and attachments older than 1 year are archived. Click here to retrieve them (takes 24 hours)"

Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by eastbound on Saturday July 02, 2022 @05:59PM (#31962844)
If someone had IMAP and sync with their mobile enabled, would it count as a login?
Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by dehrmann on Saturday July 02, 2022 @09:19PM (#31964163)
Unrelated question, but since you work on Yahoo Mail...

What's its association with AT&T? My parents have an old AT&T email they want to keep after leaving AT&T. AT&T claims it's possible (which I find shocking), but it's not really clear who actually runs the account. I think it was originally sold as AT&T/Yahoo, so was it Yahoo mail under the hood? Is that still the case?

Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by reid on Saturday July 02, 2022 @10:31PM (#31964525)
I don’t know the policy for email account retention for AT&T Internet email, so I can’t speak to anything about it…

But for your last two questions: Yes, it’s Yahoo Mail under the hood! That is still the case. Yahoo provides email hosting services for AT&T Internet users under a contract between Yahoo and AT&T.

However, all customer support for AT&T Yahoo Mail is handled by AT&T, so the best resource for help for those accounts would be AT&T customer service or their help site: https://www.att.com/support/topic/email-support/

Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by zymhan on Sunday July 03, 2022 @12:31AM (#31965081)
Any chance it's from the SBC/Yahoo days?
Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by netsharc on Saturday July 02, 2022 @08:49PM (#31963988)
Heck, I login daily (my Yahoo Mail is my "this online shop needs an email address" address) and a few years ago I checked, it's lost my emails before the year 2000. (Yeah I got the address when Yahoo started offering them, because I thought it'd be cool to have an @yahoo.com address...). Of course back then I actually had real emails, from high school friends and family members, which are all gone now. Great job your team is doing!
Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by jrimbault on Saturday July 02, 2022 @03:19PM (#31961548)
Just this afternoon I was with my father looking for a way to backup all of his emails on his yahoo account.

I was looking "naïvely" for the button to request all of his personal data. I didn't find one and there's probably one somewhere I'm guessing.

I resigned myself to set up Outlook on his computer and make a manual backup.

Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by idorosen on Saturday July 02, 2022 @03:31PM (#31961652)
I use getmail (similar to fetchmail) to routinely archive (i.e., sync without deleting + reindex) all of my emails from various free accounts, just in case. It can save to mbox, Maildir, mh, and other formats that are easy to import to any MUA/LDA. This is worth doing for all e-mail, and I have a patch to make it support OAuth. I don’t think it supports JMAP, but it’s great for IMAP, Gmail, and Yahoo mail and deduplicates messages by ID and content, etc. while preserving tags/mailboxes (if saved as Maildir). I highly recommend running something like that in a cron job somewhere once a week to sync locally with some sanity checks (e.g., did it save any new messages? did the folder grow? Etc.)

I also use it to save Spam/Junk folders, which then comes in very handy to train my local spam classifier for my self-hosted mail servers with lots of data. (Over 3TB of spam saved so far and about 20GB of ham.)

Gmail’s spam filter has had a higher false positive rate than usual for me lately, so I have a little report emailed to me once a week of likely ham in my gmail spam box, which has found at least 3 messages per week that I missed.

Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by davchana on Saturday July 02, 2022 @03:37PM (#31961699)
I use a mix of google email labels, apps script, spreadsheet & drive folder to download every email (older than 15 days, so that I have enough time to delete it) as .eml files in Google drive folder, which by turn downloads it to my local disk.

The spreadsheet keeps log of each msg in a thread.

Labels marks the downloaded emails.

Apps script run on a trigger & does the heavy lifting of actually downloading the .eml.

Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by reid on Saturday July 02, 2022 @03:29PM (#31961628)
Yes, I believe a local IMAP backup is the way to go.
Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by RF_Savage on Sunday July 03, 2022 @06:32AM (#31966621)
Huh, this would explain why some of my gmail redirects have seemingly died.
Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by sethammons on Saturday July 02, 2022 @02:23PM (#31961163)
You can't imagine paying for storage of things that appear to not be used when you are giving it away free?
Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by interestica on Saturday July 02, 2022 @02:24PM (#31961174)
How are they giving it away for free?
Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by melvinram on Saturday July 02, 2022 @02:33PM (#31961241)
When they don't charge money for it and you're not using it (so no views for ads), they aren't getting paid and it's costing them storage money. How is it hard to see that they are giving it away for free?
Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by Firmwarrior on Saturday July 02, 2022 @03:00PM (#31961427)
Because if they didn't treat their customers like crap, they might still theoretically have had customers at some point in the future
Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by bombcar on Saturday July 02, 2022 @03:23PM (#31961580)
Someone who doesn’t login and doesn’t pay is not much of a customer.
Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by cratermoon on Saturday July 02, 2022 @06:43PM (#31963149)
Someone who uses an ad-supported service for free is not a customer.
Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by katzgrau on Saturday July 02, 2022 @02:36PM (#31961276)
Yeah well when `df` tells you the disk is at 100%, gotta start somewhere
Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by aasasd on Saturday July 02, 2022 @08:04PM (#31963696)
Feels weird to be one of those patronizing old farts, but: Thunderbird has nearly all of my emails since mid-2000s, including accounts that are dead for years.
Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by Jaruzel on Sunday July 03, 2022 @01:31PM (#31969373)
Same here, glad I'm not alone in this. When I explain to people I can search 25 years of personal email via my current inbox, they just look at me like I'm making it up.

When I switched to a personal Exchange server about 15 years ago, I copied over all previous emails from a collection of legacy accounts, and then more recently I migrated the whole lot up to Exchange Online.

I also converted and migrated in old mail messages from a DEC VMS system I used to be a SysAdmin on.

Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by distances on Sunday July 03, 2022 @10:41AM (#31968040)
I just have all my emails since 1997 in my current email account. Every time I've changed providers, I've copied the old emails over to the new one as they've all had some POP3 functionality for import.

I do still have my first email account from 1997 too, but it was an early free email service that got acquired by Yahoo so I was hit by this same Yahoo deletion policy at some point. Which didn't really matter as I had everything copied over to the next one anyway.

Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by dmd on Saturday July 02, 2022 @08:47PM (#31963963)
Same but my archive goes back to 1988, including some I carried over from Fidonet.
Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by tyrfing on Saturday July 02, 2022 @03:43PM (#31961739)
Microsoft has had a similar policy, although they entirely delete the account instead. Same for smaller companies like GMX.

Definitely a contributor to sticking with Gmail.

Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by deorder on Saturday July 02, 2022 @07:17PM (#31963397)
The same thing happened to me and I'm still sick of it. I lost a lot of emails from the beginning of my career. I found out when I finally got around to backing up my old stuff. There are still a lot of emails that I wish I still had. I know it is / was a free service, but still.
Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by allenu on Sunday July 03, 2022 @02:37AM (#31965612)
I also used yahoo mail during that same period and am disappointed to see all my emails gone as well. I can understand the reasoning, but man, what a blast from the past it would to see what college-aged me was emailing 20 odd years ago.

I think the last time I checked on this email was nearly 10 years ago and by that point, it was 99.9% spam, so pretty much worthless for day to day use.

Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by rybosome on Saturday July 02, 2022 @03:19PM (#31961543)
I discovered that recently as well and was very disappointed. I understand why this happened from Yahoo’s perspective, but it sucks nonetheless.
Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by dm319 on Saturday July 02, 2022 @02:40PM (#31961298)
I remember this was standard back in the day, and I think the time period was even shorter. Think it happened to me on Hotmail at 3 months.
Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by jpalomaki on Sunday July 03, 2022 @02:59AM (#31965689)
Looking from a different perspective, this kind of account expiration is good for data security. Just think how many dormant Yahoo accounts there would be, forgotten by the owner and with weak and leaked passwords. Likely in many cases users themselves could not even remember passwords, making it impossible for them to remove the data.
Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by criddell on Saturday July 02, 2022 @03:05PM (#31961457)
I surprised you could even log in. I thought Yahoo was going to start recycling email addresses (which seems like a terrible idea).
Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by plasma_beam on Saturday July 02, 2022 @02:39PM (#31961289)
Same here, though I still login from time to time, mostly because my apple id is still tied to the account. My emails are still there too.
Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by registeredcorn on Saturday July 02, 2022 @11:50PM (#31964888)
What amount of time do you think would be more appropriate before inactivity would lead to deletion of data?
Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by 83457 on Saturday July 02, 2022 @07:50PM (#31963614)
Same happened to me with Hotmail. Sucks.
Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by alar44 on Saturday July 02, 2022 @04:51PM (#31962266)
You don't store important information in free email services.
Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by NavinF on Saturday July 02, 2022 @09:33PM (#31964227)
...he says while fully knowing that the majority of humans store important information in free email services.
Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by alar44 on Sunday July 03, 2022 @08:08AM (#31967092)
That's not my problem.
Re:Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002) by unixbane on Saturday July 02, 2022 @03:47PM (#31961764)
Wow we should all use only Google because they are the only good and trustworthy email provider. Why do we even need email at all? There should just be a simplified protocol or webapp that stores everything on Google and manages all your authentication tokens for every website you use.

</sarcasm> yup that was the end game for email as we knew already 20 years ago