News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It's worse than you think by akersten on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @02:30AM (#31917105)
Any life philosophy that helps one get through the day in a positive way is good. I do have a nit to pick with part of this one. It leans on the idea that "everyone is winging it all the time" and links to a Guardian opinion(?) piece where they pull quote from people who can't read a clock or tie their shoes. I think that's both not the right level of assumed incompetence that the author wanted to convey, but also reinforcement of a comforting excuse for failing to flourish. There is such a thing as expertise, and it (almost) always takes a lot of work to achieve it. So it both denigrates those who have worked hard to be competent in their field and gives aspirationals an out that potentially stunts their growth.

I agree that the mantra applies in some circumstances, like casual social interaction (although I'm sure there are subject matter experts in that realm too who could out-chat any of us), but applying it to your career and goals seems self-defeating to me.

But again, we are all different and different motivations work on each of us. Just my unsolicited opinion.

Re:It's worse than you think by ryandvm on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @09:21AM (#31919727)
After the last decade, I now believe the "everyone is winging it all the time" theory more than ever.

I used to think people in power really had their shit together (CEOs, judges, doctors, politicians, etc.) but it turns out that it's just regular dumbasses everywhere.

Hell, just look at the testimony from the January 6th hearings. These people were running the most powerful organization in human history and they were absolutely batshit stupid. Crazy yes, but also just plain stupid. Totally incapable of assembling a coherent worldview.

Sure there are experts, but they became experts by focusing their energies on their discipline. They don't have time for political machinations. The people _running_ everything are by and large just bullshitting their way to the top.

Re:It's worse than you think by syl_sau on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @11:15AM (#31921358)
I'm not sure what you're referring to with the Jan 6th hearings (I don't really follow US news), but in my opinion it's certainly the case that politics, media and administration are the privileged domains for which the phrase "everyone is winging it all the time" makes the most sense. It's infuriating but I gather it's unlikely to be true for most other things in life which require, as the parent comment pointed out, actual expertise.

When I think of all my models, whether directors, writers, painters or engineers, they've always struck me as especially smart, and this feeling seems to always correlate with how humble they are and how old the interview I am watching is. I guess they mostly talk about the thing they do for a living. Also, I've noticed a decrease in global intelligence, and that probably makes people look much more stupid in comparison.

In fact, I don't believe expertise makes you brilliant on all fronts -- arguably, it may signify the exact opposite. Take an artist, e.g. an actor or a painter, that is someone who spends most of their time learning their own specific craft, why should we listen to their takes on things unrelated to their activities more than the average person? It makes no sense, but sometimes we hear musicians, actors, etc. give their undue opinions on various matters. And so we stumble upon the fact that they have, like most of us, no clue on most things in life, just like us. And that's okay I guess.

Re:It's worse than you think by ipiz0618 on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @11:21AM (#31921449)
Reminds me of the brilliant Ricky Gervais quote:

"So if you do win an award tonight, don’t use it as a platform to make a political speech. You’re in no position to lecture the public about anything. You know nothing about the real world. Most of you spent less time in school than Greta Thunberg."

Re:It's worse than you think by dumpsterlid on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @03:41PM (#31924810)
"Also, I've noticed a decrease in global intelligence, and that probably makes people look much more stupid in comparison."

Serious citation needed here??

Re:It's worse than you think by spacechild1 on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @03:34PM (#31924723)
> why should we listen to their takes on things unrelated to their activities more than the average person?

Also applies to HN :-)

Re:It's worse than you think by brnt on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @07:20PM (#31926953)
> The people _running_ everything are by and large just bullshitting their way to the top.

There were never on the stand. All you've seen are footsoldiers, and one way of organizing an army is to design it for dumb soldiers. Read Dark Money by Jane Mayer to get an idea of the kind of people who're running that show.

Re:It's worse than you think by perilunar on Thursday June 30, 2022 @11:50AM (#31934242)
As Bertrand Russell said:

"The trouble with the world is that the stupid are cocksure and the intelligent are full of doubt."

The worse is that other stupid people see confidence as a signal of competence (and give confident people power), when it's actually a negative signal. Truly smart people are usually pretty humble.

Re:It's worse than you think by oifjsidjf on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @11:35AM (#31921646)
True. As long as a person has a few very specific tendencies, or perhaps a lack of certain resistances/indoctrinations/beliefs he can push forward much more than the average person and thus he can become a CEO etc... and still be fallible, but he will also succeed merely due to the state of his mind.
Re:It's worse than you think by hgomersall on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @03:21AM (#31917386)
To quote Greg LeMond: it never gets easier, you just get faster. As someone who arguably has accumulated expertise, I still feel like I'm winging it a lot. The difference is I'm now winging it at the boundaries of the state of the art. It certainly doesn't feel easier to be here than where I was 20 years ago (though I do feel to be in a better place). There's always much more expertise I need!
Re:It's worse than you think by kryogen1c on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @07:28AM (#31918731)
> it never gets easier, you just get faster. As someone who arguably has accumulated expertise, I still feel like I'm winging it a lot.

Yes, I believe the gp has missed the point of the article.

The lesson from "your to-do list isn't difficult, it's impossible" is not nihilism. The point is not that no one is good at anything so why bother; the point is that the feeling of overwhelm, dread, and depression from an impossible- seeming to-do list is rooted in false assumptions. Your to-do list doesn't seem impossibly long, it IS impossibly long! You are born with a to-do list and you will die with a to-do list - but that's OK. We're all in the same boat.

Another helpful way to think about this is a math analogy. Your knowledge is a circle or sphere that has your literal area of expertise. The more your learn, the larger it gets - but you also gain more contact with the unknown.

That is the lesson. Imposter syndrome demystified. Only a fool feels in complete control. One simply does what one can.

Re:It's worse than you think by fallous on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @10:39AM (#31920791)
Over the years I've learned to be suspicious of simple solutions to difficult problems and those who assert such solutions. When trying to convey that healthy skepticism to others I tend to use the phrase "beware those who express the certainty that can only be born out of ignorance or a swindle."

The analogy I use to explain how the acquisition of knowledge leads to humility is akin to climbing. You start in a ditch and can only see a single mountain that you must ascend to be knowledgeable. Once you reach the peak of that mountain you are greeted with an entire new range of mountains that would remain hidden from you without the benefit of your newfound perspective. You may also safely assume that beyond each of those mountains lies yet another set of partially or completely obscured mountain ranges.

As Socrates said, "if I am wise it is only in that I know what I do not know."

Re:It's worse than you think by toss1 on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @10:31AM (#31920653)
>> One simply does what one can.

Exactly.

Long ago, I built a task management app for myself and my company. After using it for a while, I looked at the overview and found that I had something like 768 hours of Urgent and High priority tasks due in the next two weeks. There are only 336 hours total in two weeks (nevermind sleeping, eating, traveling, etc...). Moreover, this was not atypical of the list of things on my plate, it was just that now it had been collected as actual data.

No amount of working faster, trimming, delegating, etc. was going to get this done. The realization is that things WILL slip, even so much that some never get done. The goal is just to keep the critical things from slipping so much that you are taken out of the game. Also recognize that this is OK, and don't beatup myself or others about it (and that beating on myself or others only distracts and prevents the tasks from getting done). Just get on with what you can get on with.

Re:It's worse than you think by razzimatazz on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @03:48AM (#31917519)
You prompted me to think of fitness - as someone who has accumulated fitness I still feel like I am suffering a lot when I run, and I can take that suffering as a bit like winging it. The difference is I am suffering/winging it at a decent pace, I'm accustomed to what suffering/winging it feels like and know that I don't need to give up, I believe I can push on.

And indeed there is always more fitness that I need.

Re:It's worse than you think by mcbrit on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @05:25AM (#31917995)
Running is not training. Running is a stimulus; training is the response of the body to the stimulus. You want to come up with an ideal set of stimuli to create an efficient training response.

Outside of a goal race, you shouldn't suffer when you run, especially 'a lot'. You are tearing down muscles and training energy systems that are inefficient.

Slow down. Walk. Fragment runs into multiple runs. Run doubles. You'll get faster, faster. Add volume at your new, sane pace and new, sane volume up to 40-60 miles/week.

Once you've achieved the slow end of 'adult fast', say sub-20m/40m/90m for 5k/10k/half, you can revisit suffering during training. You still probably shouldn't.

Of course if you want/like to suffer or can only run 4 times a week at peak heat during a Georgia summer then all of this is out the window.

Re:It's worse than you think by vibrolax on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @09:11AM (#31919606)
Everything fell into place for me as a runner after I joined an adult running club whose coach used Jack Daniels "Running Formula" as the basis for setting each member's training intensities and durations. It largely removed the ability/willingness to suffer as a factor in reaching one's fitness potential.
Re:It's worse than you think by mythrwy on Thursday June 30, 2022 @01:12PM (#31935514)
Jack Daniels Running Formula sounds interesting maybe I could do that! (unless it's a different Jack Daniels).
Re:It's worse than you think by k__ on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @06:54AM (#31918512)
Interesting.

I'm not much into sport, but I had the impression that training was above the goal.

Like, you try to get into a situation that is harder than reality, so when you finally do the actual thing, it will be easier.

Re:It's worse than you think by derbOac on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @08:46AM (#31919401)
It's complicated. What you suggest is true, but how you get to that point is different. The parent is also emphasizing high volume low intensity training which is part of many routines; high intensity interval training is another.

Often the strategy is to adopt both, until you gradually converge on some target (pace over distance). Where that target is is a different issue.

Re:It's worse than you think by hgomersall on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @04:45AM (#31917800)
I'll add another relevant point that I think is attributable to Bradley Wiggins, but I can't find it now: [on time trials] You should always be asking yourself if you can keep going at this pace, and if the answer is anything other than "I don't know" you've already lost.
Re:It's worse than you think by totetsu on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @05:20AM (#31917968)
Yes! and how much you come to resent chasing the idiot you who kept going at that pace and set your last pb.
Re:It's worse than you think by ip26 on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @04:04PM (#31925076)
Only if you keep pushing speed. At a given speed, the fitter you get the better you feel at that speed.

Plus, fresh of the couch everything hurts. Some fit person's lungs might be burning, their legs might feel heavy, but the not-fit person has three different cramps, blisters, achy feet, shoulder pain, toe pain, neck pain, lung pain... that gets better fairly quickly with training.

I feel the whole "it never hurts less you just get faster" viewpoint is demoralizing & misleading, which doesn't help when people are struggling to stay fit.

Re:It's worse than you think by SilasX on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @08:25AM (#31919180)
I see it as a case of the Availability Heuristic[1] striking hard.

Say you make 100 decisions in a day, and your expertise yields an obvious, high-quality answer in 98 of them. When you think back to that day, the remaining 2 (which didn’t so yield) will dominate your memory of what happened.

In that case, it will feel like all you did was make non-rigorous, poorly-grounded guesses … but that impression is wrong.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Availability_heuristic

Re:It's worse than you think by jonplackett on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @04:43AM (#31917793)
This is a great point well explained. The more you know the more you feel able to wing. And the more chance your winging has of coming off.

Einstein probably felt like he was winging it with General Relativity, until he wasn’t.

Re:It's worse than you think by k__ on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @06:57AM (#31918523)
Good point.

High-tech feeling like magic is something that comes to mind.

When I try new ideas, I sometimes get the feeling they have merit in a way I can't explain. So, when people ask my why I'm working on X or Y, I can't really give them satisfying answers.

Re:It's worse than you think by Taylor_OD on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @10:53AM (#31920996)
Yeah getting "good" at a lot of things is just having been in the situation once or twice so you are less stressed. It doesnt mean you made the right decision the first time or even that you will make the right decision this time. Just that you can react faster than the first time.
Re:It's worse than you think by Ma8ee on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @02:57AM (#31917266)
Of course there is something like expertise. But the really accomplished experts are winging it most of us all, because they are at the frontiers of human knowledge, trying things that no one has tried before, stepping where no one has stepped before. So what else can they do than wing it.

And regarding the possibility that someone becomes an accomplished expert in a field and then never tries anything new? It must be exceedingly rare. If you don't have the temperament to always try new things, you rarely become a true expert. And a true expert that can't try new things rapidly becomes bored to death.

Re:It's worse than you think by nonrandomstring on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @03:39AM (#31917467)
And there's no innovation without that ability to push boundaries, feel on the edge, and occasionally screw things up. Who dares, wins. All pioneers are 'imposters', out of time and place, or alone behind enemy lines, until they look back one day and see others following and realise they're a leader.
Re:It's worse than you think by larsnystrom on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @06:00AM (#31918196)
I think the author was just trying to be nice to the reader. The worst case scenario when suffering from impostor syndrome is not that everyone is winging it all the time, but rather that you are in fact not very good at what you're doing, you may never become good at it and the people around you know that already. But I think the main point of the article still stands: Accept that you're not good at something, stop worrying about it and try the best you can anyway. Usually, after doing that for a while, you end up actually becoming good at it.
Re:It's worse than you think by twelve40 on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @07:10AM (#31918614)
haha yes i read something similar between the lines : ) the author presented a very charitable version of this.
Re:It's worse than you think by herbertl on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @02:37AM (#31917148)
Your final sentence really resonates. I think for some people, a note of pessimism is such a relief and freeing (e.g., "Oh thank goodness, I'd never have been able to meet that deadline anyway. Now let me get started on it"), but for others, that same note of pessimism causes inaction ("Why would I bother trying if it's impossible?! Not even worth getting started")
Re:It's worse than you think by bjackman on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @09:57AM (#31920152)
I think both are true: there _is_ such a thing as expertise and it's worth making huge sacrifices to develop it.

But you cannot be an expert in every aspect of an endeavour that you are involved in. You have to be winging it in some regard.

A very common example is being an expert programmer who must turn their hand to project planning or politics or UX design in order to translate their engineering excellence into actual success. You can become an expert in each of those things too, but there's always another field of challenge around the corner.

It's worthwhile to become great at each of those things as they arise but you have to escape from the longing to never be bad at anything again.

Edit: after more pondering, I don't actually think there are any project planning experts. I've never seen it done successfully, _even_ when you take this article's advice and admit that various aspects of planning (like time estimation) are hopeless. So I guess the hopelessness is fractal in some places.

Re:It's worse than you think by verisimi on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @04:38AM (#31917762)
The insight provided is summed up at the end, here:

> In short: we can't ever get free from the limited and vulnerable and uncertain situation in which we find ourselves. But when you grasp that you'll never get free from it, that's when you're finally free in it – free to focus on the hard things, instead of the impossible ones, and to give this somewhat preposterous business of being a human everything you've got.

You say:

> but applying it to your career and goals seems self-defeating to me

What about applying the insight to the concept of 'a career' itself? Ie not as something to make your career better, as if that is the obvious only answer.

Many take it for granted that career/money/etc is what life is about... but is it?

If time is over as quickly as that (as the author says) is the 'best' use of one's time spent in a career? Is 'a career and all that' a distraction from getting a better understanding of existence and one's place in it? Or from following one's heart and allowing oneself to be guided by what one uncovers within as 'right', as opposed to whatever external metrics are provided and might not (ultimately) be in your favour?

Re:It's worse than you think by davedx on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @03:29AM (#31917425)
I agree with you. However "seems self-defeating to me" I think is kind of the point of his essay: instead of letting your deficiencies defeat you, accept them then throw yourself at improving yourself with that acceptance behind you.
Re:It's worse than you think by __t__ on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @02:40AM (#31917171)
I agree that expertise is a thing, but its my belief that often this expertise is acquired by "winging it" or doing something without really having a clear path of how to do said thing. This is what I got from that line, at least