Land reform was one element. The other, despite the article's unqualified praise of "open up your economy to foreign investment and trade", is trade restrictions and various forms of state meddling to support local industries. I don't need to point out how difficult China makes it for foreign firms to operate in their local market. Per James Galbraith:
" ... none of the world's most successful trading regions, including Japan, Korea, Taiwan, and now mainland China, reached their current status by adopting neoliberal trading rules." - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparative_advantage#Criticis...
Sometimes you simply can't compete with another country with really devalued currency and very low wages
and you know, sweatshops. people opted to work in one because it was better than trying to make it in whatever rural village farming rice and hope.
the problem is not the economics, but the politics. the elites who got filthy rich on this don't want to move to the next stage.
So it isn't so much "as a rule" as "as a rule when the government has been refulatorily captured."
In fact I think you will find that most industries that are built only happen through lots of government "interference." Silicon Valley is an excellent example of this, as the early customers were all defense industry largesse. And without those extremely rich customers with very extreme technological needs, development of Silicon Valley would have stalled, or perhaps not happened at all.
The examples of those successful Asian countries implies that the tradeoff is well worth it.
Why does exporting come with the expectation of providing employment to countries who could not build competent industries. I am not anti-immigration, I am an immigrant myself, just trying to understand your argument.
I think economic immigration has nothing to do with trade imbalance, and all to do with quality of life. As an example, India may be exporting more to Greece, but there are many Indians who would rather live in Greece, and none in the other direction.
And the examples of many, many countries which used "industrial policy" to implement awful ideas like import substitution (i.e. "developing" towards autarchy, not increased trade openness and market discipline) can imply the opposite.
I'm not sure that this is correct, the theoretical argument for supporting infant industries is quite old and well known by now. The main remaining question is an empirical one, of whether you think that industrial policy as it's actually practiced in the real world is generally worthwhile. Those who advocate against government meddling argue that it mostly isn't.
Frontline: Coming From Japan [The Fall Of The US Television Industry] (1992) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aesJTsZqm6c
https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/opinions/1990/09/30/j...
"JAPAN AND THE BIG SQUEEZE September 30, 1990. HOW DID Japan destroy the American television industry? The secret history of that strategy reveals how Japanese manufacturers and the Japanese government first created an anti-competitive cartel ..."
"Japan's raid on the American market dates back to 1956, when the largest Japanese manufacturers formed the Home Electronic Appliance Market Stabilization Council, an illegal production cartel. The intent of the cartel was to monopolize the domestic market for television receivers, radios and other home electric products and to exclude foreign imports. Once their home market was secure, they would launch a drive against the far richer American market."
https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/ct-xpm-1987-04-23-870131...
"TARIFFS WON`T AFFECT MOST JAPANESE TV SETS Apr 23, 1987 The new tariffs on Japanese color televisions will have little or no effect on the U.S. market, because most sets are exempt."
I'm no absolutist, each country has to balance a whole host of local conditions and needs. They also need to build a consensus. However the fact is they liberalised trade and investment, and that's what brought success. There were preconditions to being able to do that, but it's still a fact.
But I suspect we agree - different trade policies are needed for different stages of development. Fledgling industries need protection, while mature industries want to expand into foreign markets.
Where conflict arises is when mature industries want to expand into developing markets, crushing any local competition. Sometimes this is mutually beneficial (not every country can have leading edge semiconductor fabs), other times it is not (nobody needs McDonald's to feed their country), but those industries will still lobby for trade deals for market access, and use neoliberal trade theory to justify it as mutually beneficial.
A couple counter-arguments to that:
According to Milton Friedman, after Japan was forced by Western powers to remove trade restrictions and drastically lower tariffs in the late 1800s, it prospered, contrary to what the mercantilist theories of the time predicted:
https://youtu.be/CWgNe8v6KFc?t=322
Also, there is much evidence dispelling the mythologized account of MITI's role in the expansion of the Japanese economy specifically:
https://www.econlib.org/library/Enc1/JapanandtheMythofMITI.h...
The article notes much more foundational properties of the 50s/60s Japanese economy, like a smaller portion of private sector output being taxed to support the public sector, as more likely causes of its growth:
>>"The fact that the tax burden is unusually low by the standards of other developed countries may alone be a significant factor in the explanation of the high rate of private saving and investment in Japan." From 1951 to 1970, while Japan's real GNP was growing at an average of 9 percent per year, total national and local taxes (excluding social security) fell from 22.4 percent of national income to 18.9 percent. This left more money for people to save and invest. Compare Japan's situation with the United States, where the proportion rose from 28.5 percent to 31.3 percent. Interestingly, Japan's two decades of greatest postwar growth were also its decades of lowest taxes. During the seventies, as Japan's taxes rose to 22.8 percent of national income in 1980, real GNP growth declined to only 4.8 percent. Higher taxes weren't the only reason for this deteriorating performance, of course; oil price increases also contributed.
This graph demonstrates how much lower social welfare spending used to be in Japan:
https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/social-spending-oecd-long...
and? what's the counterfactual? what would have happened otherwise?
trading is important, but politics is the critical factor. trading provides the inflow of wealth, if it gets allocated in a way that inequality just keeps rising, then the beneficiaries will eventually capture the state and then revert/regress to whatever anti-competitive shit they will think of to enrich themselves.
the problem with neoliberal policies is that they are not enforced, and what we got on a global scale is libertarian idgaf-ism. WTO members should have loudly levied serious tariffs on China (and others) who don't reciprocate the various policies required for doing business as foreigners.
Singapore showcases this very well. The ethnic Chinese and the Indians are very much focused on pursuing education for their children, even back in the early colonial days and that has led to great success for that portion of the population. The Malays however, have a more idyllic bent in their cultural preferences and that has led to a more impoverished life overall in their population.
Maybe it’s because the early Chinese and Indians were imported by the British and brought with them the stereotypical immigrant work ethic while the Malays were indigenous and didn’t have the same kind of drive.
Without a solid economy you just end up with like 30% unemployment rate where a large percentage of those unemployed hold higher degrees (masters and PhDs).
I don't think education alone is enough for the path to richness in a nation. Tunisia is still stuck with an inability to re-innovate and free its economy, and resolve its corruption issues. I don't think centralized government is the answer either (neither is industry as some comments suggested; Tunisia could have jumped directly from an agricultural to an information economy, but so many things went wrong).
Maybe it's the Mediterranean? There is hardly any Mediterranean country that had economic success in that same time-frame.
> you just end up with like 30% unemployment rate where a large percentage of those unemployed hold higher degrees (masters and PhDs).
The other question is how valuable really are these degrees? I don't recall Tunisian universities being particularly sought after.
Network effects: Tunisia is quite close to Europe.
Visa Access: It's limited but still https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tunisian_diaspora vs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overseas_Chinese. Relative to population size, Tunisians moved more overseas.
Geographically close to Europe but I bet Europeans/Americans do not feel that way. Again due to various factors.
VISA: For Asians there is one advantage - they have some established characteristics - like hardworking, reputation in IT etc. Again not to say others do not have it but when people talk about IT guy/girl they refer to Indians or Asians - NOT Tunisians.
This “land distribution” point reminds me of a paper they claimed Spain fell behind other colonial powers like England and France because the resource they exploited was precious metals that allowed a few to get rich, but didn’t allow a middle class to grow.
Make me think of whether big tech does the same thing (if they can find a way to automate enough they can hire few people and few engineers)
In many western countries each of these industries has undergone massive monopolization, which in my opinion has driven not only wealth inequality but knowledge inequality--there are now many millions of people who couldn't actually set "the system" up if the oversight vanished because they don't have any real ownership of its components.
Taiwan and the "Land to the Tiller" Program by John C. Médaille
https://cooperative-individualism.org/medaille-john_taiwan-a...
I think it would be economically better, though politically impossible, if India experienced a great deal of farmland consolidation. How is a guy that only farms 1.2 hectares supposed to increase his income? Buy a farm truck or tractor? Increase efficiency? He's stuck doing everything by hand and making $1000 a year.
Sure, there might be some truth to the statement that an average US farmer is more efficient than an Indian farmer. But, the reason that an average India farmer is only doing 1.2 hectares compared to the US farmers is not that Indian farmers are inefficient at farming, it's just that there are at least two orders of magnitude more farmers in India (and that's their livelihood) compared to the US.
edit:formatting
Also the most profitable farms aren’t the largest ones, which are often dedicated to growing common grain like wheat and rice, and sugarcane. These crops would be bought by the government at prefixed prices. And the assured income again leads to a lot of fighting and influence mongering, and ironically much smaller takes for the average competing farmer.
Quite unexpectedly, the highest profits are made by farmers who manage to get smart financing and grow niche crops like fruits, some vegetables, flowers, organic, cash crops etc. The highes profits in India are always made by people who carefully avoid government and activist attention, assistance, benevolence, interference.
Wealth* that is not doing anything has no effect on the economy. Suppose I had $100 trillion in cash (or art, or other useless commodity) in a vault somewhere, and never spend a dime of it. How is it impeding the economy? If I didn't tell you about it, you wouldn't even know it existed.
It's only when I start spending it, to redirect labor per my wishes, that I start affecting the economy. If I spend it all on yachts, that will cause a lot of labor and materials to go to yachts that won't contribute anything to the economy once built, instead of going to something more productive.
*Using "wealth" to mean fiat money, or art, or anything that has no productive use. E.g. if the wealth was instead in the form of idle farmland, that would be used to grow food if owned by someone else, then yes, that would be impeding the economy. So one must distinguish between wealth with inherent value, and wealth that only has value because people are willing to pay for it.
Actually that would result in a manufacturing industry. The problem is that if you wanted to buy a Yacht in say south Africa you wouldn't manufacture it in South Africa despite the mass unemployment problem.
but it does exist and is "missing" from the economy (i.e. other peoples pockets)
No, but people constantly shout "money printing" when the money supply goes up even though it could be as a result of people producing more physical capital.
Imagine producing more physical capital and being told you don't deserve liquidity in proportion to the capital/value you produced. That is the problem with a fixed supply currency system like the gold standard.
Why is it a problem to keep the money supply fixed? Imagine a theoretical economy where 100% of the money is in the hand of a single person. Even though the rest of the economy is able to produce and barter, it would be far more efficient to use liquidity i.e money to facilitate the division of labor. That one guy with all the money is effectively blocking the public infrastructure we call money. Transactions that ought to happen don't happen. Money doesn't fulfill its function as a medium of exchange. Therefore it is only appropriate to tax people in proportion to the damage they cause to the economy by excessive patience and holding excessive amounts of liquidity. It like an illegal parking fee intended to keep the streets free.
The amount of production is not impacted much by how how many bushels of wheat, or days of labor of the average worker, we value the Mona Lisa. Art can be wealth, but not all wealth is a factor of production. Labor, land, capital are all factors of production that influence how much stuff is made.
Making sure that everybody has enough to survive, enough to thrive, and enough to be creative and innovate or achieve what they want should be the goal. Distribution not only of wealth, but perhaps as importantly, distribution of responsibility and authority so that people can make the best possible decisions for themselves. Redistributing away from the accumulation of power/wealth into too few hands is very important for that.
Slumlord properties have the same theoretical problem as land, in that concentrated ownership can act as an incentive towards bad management; there's not much economy of scale when it comes to managing rental properties, so policy should incent dispersed ownership instead.
You can't be incentivised to create art when you will never realize that incentive. And unlike music record labels, it's not like you are giving someone else your earnings in exchange for editing and technical help and marketing.
Art was a bad example, though, since it's mostly just used as a tax dodge. The real problem is rent seeking.
Brings up the point that some countries with similar land reforms (e.g. Mexico) didn't achieve the same result, but generally casts a favorable view of the book.
This is an interesting view. how did they avoid being punished for this?
Zimbabwe tried redistributing farms but it turned out horribly for them.
Would be interested In understanding how Zimbabwe attempt was different to these countries.
Here in South Africa land reforms is a politically charged issue. Due to apartheid we have a deeply unequal society, where productive farm land is concentrated in primarily in a few hands. Split along racial lines.
I recall meeting some labourers on a farm here in the western cape. They worked on a farm that had been “claimed” by colonisers who arrived in the 1800’s, and then handed down in families.
Where as this labourer ancestors has been in that area for generations before the colonisers got there.
It actually didn't. It tries to buy out land but then noticed that it ran out of money. After that they hired thugs to get white farmers off their farms. They didn't give the new black farmers any method of financing their business which led to failed farms. Finally they gave the land to political allies who don't farm at all.
A simple land value tax would have prevented this nonsense.
Zimbabwe redistributed the land without the necessary infrastucture or know-how to till the land and produce output.
Therein was the whole failure.
The keyword here is "idle". An "idle" landlord is unproductive and unlikely to riot. What happened in Zimbabwe is a power grab. It's usually the leaders taking a nice pie, and sharing the rest with the (in this case black) poor population. This destroys whatever little wealth the country had.
Recent history of Zimbabwe: <http://imgur.com/a/VdQdD>
Although more capital, in theory, can just easily be made - if the incentives are not in place - it appears to have the same problems as getting past the agricultural stage.
So it seems like a parallel to me why advanced economies might stagnate.
How to keep capital 1) maximally productive, rather than rent seeking, and 2) keep capital from fleeing, are all about what incentive structures the government sets up. And for every single industrial country, government policy has been key to growing infant industries into functional, independent, adult economies.
At every stage of economic development, the rules seem to change for of which policies enable or maximize economic growth. (I fear the US is starting to flub it now, but they may still save themselves!!)
Yes. That's a good book.
It's not "land reform", though. It's agricultural modernization. Farming needed to be mechanized to free up labor for manufacturing. The "Asian tigers" had far too many people tied up inefficiently growing rice. Then they could start exporting.
Most poor countries are past that point now, though. Today's poor countries have too many people in cities. And everybody can't be a net exporter.
The book's theory is that success starts by first focusing on productivity of agricultural land, to maximize output, not profit. To accomplish that, you need lots of farmers who are motivated to maximize output, which means land distribution so that farmers are working for themselves, rather than as laborers where the landowner takes all. Once there is a broad base of farmers, and the country has food sovereignty, limited import funds can't be drained away just to make sure everyone is fed. And once there's a broad farming base, that is accumulating savings, that means that 1) banks can start making loans for the beginning of industry, and 2) there's a strong farmer consumer base that can be customers of this early industry.
Countries like Japan, Taiwan, and South Korea that practiced land reform to wrench land away from idle landlords and distribute it widely, have had this success. And countries that feigned it, like the Philippines, have struggled in comparison.
Land really is different from capital, there's a finite amount of it, whereas more capital can always be made. Redistributing hoarded land should be a primary function of government, or at least a government that wants to grow the economy, rather than grow wealth inequality.