News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How do poor countries get rich? by lern_too_spel on Sunday June 26, 2022 @11:33AM (#31884893)
The biggest impediment to growth is idle wealth. Wealth tied up in art is not doing anything and should be taxed arbitrarily high at inheritance. The same with slumlords' properties. Taxes on productive income can then be reduced by the same amount to encourage growth.
Re:How do poor countries get rich? by car_analogy on Sunday June 26, 2022 @12:53PM (#31885577)
> Wealth tied up in art is not doing anything

Wealth* that is not doing anything has no effect on the economy. Suppose I had $100 trillion in cash (or art, or other useless commodity) in a vault somewhere, and never spend a dime of it. How is it impeding the economy? If I didn't tell you about it, you wouldn't even know it existed.

It's only when I start spending it, to redirect labor per my wishes, that I start affecting the economy. If I spend it all on yachts, that will cause a lot of labor and materials to go to yachts that won't contribute anything to the economy once built, instead of going to something more productive.

*Using "wealth" to mean fiat money, or art, or anything that has no productive use. E.g. if the wealth was instead in the form of idle farmland, that would be used to grow food if owned by someone else, then yes, that would be impeding the economy. So one must distinguish between wealth with inherent value, and wealth that only has value because people are willing to pay for it.

Re:How do poor countries get rich? by imtringued on Sunday June 26, 2022 @03:31PM (#31887154)
>If I spend it all on yachts, that will cause a lot of labor and materials to go to yachts that won't contribute anything to the economy once built, instead of going to something more productivity

Actually that would result in a manufacturing industry. The problem is that if you wanted to buy a Yacht in say south Africa you wouldn't manufacture it in South Africa despite the mass unemployment problem.

Re:How do poor countries get rich? by hansel_der on Sunday June 26, 2022 @01:30PM (#31885943)
> If I didn't tell you about it, you wouldn't even know it existed

but it does exist and is "missing" from the economy (i.e. other peoples pockets)

Re:How do poor countries get rich? by car_analogy on Sunday June 26, 2022 @01:46PM (#31886092)
If you add a zero to the end of every bill in circulation, there will be 10x more money, but people won't be any better off.
Re:How do poor countries get rich? by makomk on Sunday June 26, 2022 @02:01PM (#31886246)
Not really. There is not some fixed amount of money in existence and certainly not some fixed amount of wealth. Governments and banks create money as necessary to facilitate the actual economy in producing actual stuff, and as for wealth, well... When the price that some artist's works trade at goes up, such that the value of the ones sitting in some billionaire's vault is now higher, that extra wealth clearly doesn't come from anywhere at all. It simply springs into existence from nowhere, and will spring out of existence just as easily if private ownership of art becomes effectively impossible. What is a limiting factor in the real economy's ability to make people better off is its capacity to produce actual goods and services for them to buy, and that capacity is not used in any way by wealth sitting around doing nothing.
Re:How do poor countries get rich? by imtringued on Sunday June 26, 2022 @03:39PM (#31887222)
>There is not some fixed amount of money in existence

No, but people constantly shout "money printing" when the money supply goes up even though it could be as a result of people producing more physical capital.

Imagine producing more physical capital and being told you don't deserve liquidity in proportion to the capital/value you produced. That is the problem with a fixed supply currency system like the gold standard.

Why is it a problem to keep the money supply fixed? Imagine a theoretical economy where 100% of the money is in the hand of a single person. Even though the rest of the economy is able to produce and barter, it would be far more efficient to use liquidity i.e money to facilitate the division of labor. That one guy with all the money is effectively blocking the public infrastructure we call money. Transactions that ought to happen don't happen. Money doesn't fulfill its function as a medium of exchange. Therefore it is only appropriate to tax people in proportion to the damage they cause to the economy by excessive patience and holding excessive amounts of liquidity. It like an illegal parking fee intended to keep the streets free.

Re:How do poor countries get rich? by makomk on Monday June 27, 2022 @09:09AM (#31894064)
The thing is that during the last two years, governments have systematically shut down the actual productive parts of the economy that make stuff to fight Covid and tried to fill in the gap produced by printing and handing out money instead. This does not work.
Re:How do poor countries get rich? by epistasis on Sunday June 26, 2022 @01:56PM (#31886198)
I'm not sure I agree with this. There's two key parts to wealth: producing enough stuff to make life easy for people, and distributing that to many many people tether than hoarding it for a few.

The amount of production is not impacted much by how how many bushels of wheat, or days of labor of the average worker, we value the Mona Lisa. Art can be wealth, but not all wealth is a factor of production. Labor, land, capital are all factors of production that influence how much stuff is made.

Making sure that everybody has enough to survive, enough to thrive, and enough to be creative and innovate or achieve what they want should be the goal. Distribution not only of wealth, but perhaps as importantly, distribution of responsibility and authority so that people can make the best possible decisions for themselves. Redistributing away from the accumulation of power/wealth into too few hands is very important for that.

Re:How do poor countries get rich? by missedthecue on Sunday June 26, 2022 @01:38PM (#31886017)
I really need you to explain to me what "tied up" means. If I buy a $100 million dollar piece of art, that $100m doesn't disappear into the ether, it goes to the person who sold me the piece, who can then spend that on whatever they want.
Re:How do poor countries get rich? by wronglyprepaid on Sunday June 26, 2022 @11:45AM (#31885009)
Can you cite anything to back your claim here? Why is idle wealth more of an impediment than policies that discourage investment? What does idle wealth even mean, how do you measure it? Why would anyone with wealth want it to sit idle?
Re:How do poor countries get rich? by bombcar on Sunday June 26, 2022 @12:06PM (#31885172)
An no matter how many times you sell the Mona Lisa to pay the Mona Lisa tax, it still wouldn’t drop in value. So all art would have to be owned by the government or non-profits, which can easily be abused by the rich to hold “their” art tax-free.
Re:How do poor countries get rich? by zozbot234 on Sunday June 26, 2022 @12:32PM (#31885385)
There's a fallacy here. The bottom-line economic effect of having a lot of "wealth tied up in art" is incenting the preservation and/or creation of highly valued art. You can't even meaningfully take that wealth away in the aggregate, because it's pure paper wealth; it's a side effect of how much we happen to value some objects.

Slumlord properties have the same theoretical problem as land, in that concentrated ownership can act as an incentive towards bad management; there's not much economy of scale when it comes to managing rental properties, so policy should incent dispersed ownership instead.

Re:How do poor countries get rich? by vkou on Sunday June 26, 2022 @12:36PM (#31885426)
Not when the price of art never reaches it's creator, and only goes stratospheric through speculation and back-and-forth trades long after his death.

You can't be incentivised to create art when you will never realize that incentive. And unlike music record labels, it's not like you are giving someone else your earnings in exchange for editing and technical help and marketing.

Art was a bad example, though, since it's mostly just used as a tax dodge. The real problem is rent seeking.