Sometimes you simply can't compete with another country with really devalued currency and very low wages
and you know, sweatshops. people opted to work in one because it was better than trying to make it in whatever rural village farming rice and hope.
the problem is not the economics, but the politics. the elites who got filthy rich on this don't want to move to the next stage.
So it isn't so much "as a rule" as "as a rule when the government has been refulatorily captured."
In fact I think you will find that most industries that are built only happen through lots of government "interference." Silicon Valley is an excellent example of this, as the early customers were all defense industry largesse. And without those extremely rich customers with very extreme technological needs, development of Silicon Valley would have stalled, or perhaps not happened at all.
The examples of those successful Asian countries implies that the tradeoff is well worth it.
Why does exporting come with the expectation of providing employment to countries who could not build competent industries. I am not anti-immigration, I am an immigrant myself, just trying to understand your argument.
I think economic immigration has nothing to do with trade imbalance, and all to do with quality of life. As an example, India may be exporting more to Greece, but there are many Indians who would rather live in Greece, and none in the other direction.
And the examples of many, many countries which used "industrial policy" to implement awful ideas like import substitution (i.e. "developing" towards autarchy, not increased trade openness and market discipline) can imply the opposite.
I'm not sure that this is correct, the theoretical argument for supporting infant industries is quite old and well known by now. The main remaining question is an empirical one, of whether you think that industrial policy as it's actually practiced in the real world is generally worthwhile. Those who advocate against government meddling argue that it mostly isn't.
Frontline: Coming From Japan [The Fall Of The US Television Industry] (1992) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aesJTsZqm6c
https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/opinions/1990/09/30/j...
"JAPAN AND THE BIG SQUEEZE September 30, 1990. HOW DID Japan destroy the American television industry? The secret history of that strategy reveals how Japanese manufacturers and the Japanese government first created an anti-competitive cartel ..."
"Japan's raid on the American market dates back to 1956, when the largest Japanese manufacturers formed the Home Electronic Appliance Market Stabilization Council, an illegal production cartel. The intent of the cartel was to monopolize the domestic market for television receivers, radios and other home electric products and to exclude foreign imports. Once their home market was secure, they would launch a drive against the far richer American market."
https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/ct-xpm-1987-04-23-870131...
"TARIFFS WON`T AFFECT MOST JAPANESE TV SETS Apr 23, 1987 The new tariffs on Japanese color televisions will have little or no effect on the U.S. market, because most sets are exempt."
I'm no absolutist, each country has to balance a whole host of local conditions and needs. They also need to build a consensus. However the fact is they liberalised trade and investment, and that's what brought success. There were preconditions to being able to do that, but it's still a fact.
But I suspect we agree - different trade policies are needed for different stages of development. Fledgling industries need protection, while mature industries want to expand into foreign markets.
Where conflict arises is when mature industries want to expand into developing markets, crushing any local competition. Sometimes this is mutually beneficial (not every country can have leading edge semiconductor fabs), other times it is not (nobody needs McDonald's to feed their country), but those industries will still lobby for trade deals for market access, and use neoliberal trade theory to justify it as mutually beneficial.
A couple counter-arguments to that:
According to Milton Friedman, after Japan was forced by Western powers to remove trade restrictions and drastically lower tariffs in the late 1800s, it prospered, contrary to what the mercantilist theories of the time predicted:
https://youtu.be/CWgNe8v6KFc?t=322
Also, there is much evidence dispelling the mythologized account of MITI's role in the expansion of the Japanese economy specifically:
https://www.econlib.org/library/Enc1/JapanandtheMythofMITI.h...
The article notes much more foundational properties of the 50s/60s Japanese economy, like a smaller portion of private sector output being taxed to support the public sector, as more likely causes of its growth:
>>"The fact that the tax burden is unusually low by the standards of other developed countries may alone be a significant factor in the explanation of the high rate of private saving and investment in Japan." From 1951 to 1970, while Japan's real GNP was growing at an average of 9 percent per year, total national and local taxes (excluding social security) fell from 22.4 percent of national income to 18.9 percent. This left more money for people to save and invest. Compare Japan's situation with the United States, where the proportion rose from 28.5 percent to 31.3 percent. Interestingly, Japan's two decades of greatest postwar growth were also its decades of lowest taxes. During the seventies, as Japan's taxes rose to 22.8 percent of national income in 1980, real GNP growth declined to only 4.8 percent. Higher taxes weren't the only reason for this deteriorating performance, of course; oil price increases also contributed.
This graph demonstrates how much lower social welfare spending used to be in Japan:
https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/social-spending-oecd-long...
and? what's the counterfactual? what would have happened otherwise?
trading is important, but politics is the critical factor. trading provides the inflow of wealth, if it gets allocated in a way that inequality just keeps rising, then the beneficiaries will eventually capture the state and then revert/regress to whatever anti-competitive shit they will think of to enrich themselves.
the problem with neoliberal policies is that they are not enforced, and what we got on a global scale is libertarian idgaf-ism. WTO members should have loudly levied serious tariffs on China (and others) who don't reciprocate the various policies required for doing business as foreigners.
Land reform was one element. The other, despite the article's unqualified praise of "open up your economy to foreign investment and trade", is trade restrictions and various forms of state meddling to support local industries. I don't need to point out how difficult China makes it for foreign firms to operate in their local market. Per James Galbraith:
" ... none of the world's most successful trading regions, including Japan, Korea, Taiwan, and now mainland China, reached their current status by adopting neoliberal trading rules." - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparative_advantage#Criticis...