News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by jeroenhd on Saturday June 18, 2022 @11:14AM (#31790547)
What I think is something people easily overlook with Patreon and similar platforms is that it's quite hard to make a decent profit on $1 or $5 transactions that most of Patreon's income seems to come from.

They're definitely overcharging for more profit, but your margins won't be much lower if you handle payment yourself. Your 3% bank cut to receive money doesn't always work because often there's a minimum fee per transaction.

I know most iDeal (Dutch payment provider) transaction costs are 25 cents. It's a flat fee, so buying a €2000 TV will still leave you with 25 cents of fees, which is great for big stores, but when you use them do donate a single euro, the transaction fees are a whole quarter of the donation.

Tons of tiny transactions is a pretty terrible way to receive money. It's not "give up >15%" terrible, especially if your patrons tend to donate more, but Patreon needs to spread costs over all creators to make small content creators worth the effort.

Having a look at Donorbox, the same issue becomes clear: the cost for receiving payment in .NL is only 1.4%… and a €0,25 payment processor fee. These low processing fees are also only applicable to registered non profits in the NL which the author most definitely isn't. Even with the extra cheap rates and a non profit the fees to the lowest tier (±€3) add up to nearly 10% on a platform that's built around minimising costs for non profit organisations. There is the ability to use bank transfers for real cheap, but that's always a possibility anyway. One thing this site does seem to offer is the ability to offload all the site's cost onto the person who donates rather than subtract it afterwards, but that's just raising the donation price to compensate, not really a decrease in cost.

Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by oefrha on Saturday June 18, 2022 @02:01PM (#31792204)
Patreon charges a 5%-12% platform fee on top of any payment processing fee. They’re not footing the bill of 25c or whatever flat fee per transaction, as you seem to imply. They’re not spreading costs.

Whether you’re donating $1000 or $1, Patreon is getting their 8% (or 5%, or 12%).

Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by thayne on Saturday June 18, 2022 @11:51AM (#31790966)
The solution for this is to have the donation system pool transactions together. Instead of a single transaction for each creator you donate to, you make a payment into a pool that you can then allocate funds from to various recipients. And instead of individual payments to recipients, you send a single lump sum once a month (or if perhaps less frequently if donations are sparse).
Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by vzqx on Saturday June 18, 2022 @12:24PM (#31791296)
This is how Patreon already works - they pool both incoming and outgoing donations for the month into a single transaction to reduce fees. But there are a bunch of donors who only donate $1-$3 a month to a single creator, and these incoming transactions don't benefit from pooling.
Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by Dylan16807 on Saturday June 18, 2022 @03:22PM (#31792911)
This is how Patreon works when you're lucky.

They keep degrading the pooling and/or threatening to remove it entirely.

Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by armchairhacker on Saturday June 18, 2022 @02:00PM (#31792198)
You pool the transactions over a longer period. The donor initially gets charged $10, but if they cancel early they will get refunded. Then after a few months they get charged another $10 and so on.

It has drawbacks, like if the person doesn’t have $10 or they complain that they’re being charged. But a) is unlikely since most people who are that poor aren’t donating money, and b) is hopefully unlikely if you make it very clear how the payment system works and that they can get refunded if they cancel early.

Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by wmf on Saturday June 18, 2022 @01:38PM (#31791993)
I guess the next step would be to have a monthly minimum of $10 or more. You could still split it as 10 $1 donations but at least fees would be reasonable.
Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by CJefferson on Saturday June 18, 2022 @02:32PM (#31792478)
I suspect patreon's hope is you onboard people with one small monthly payment, then that person will over time add more which lets them then make a useful profit on you.
Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by BurningFrog on Saturday June 18, 2022 @12:27PM (#31791326)
You can "pool" individuals over time.

That is, instead of $3/month you do, say, $9/quarter.

Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by Nowado on Saturday June 18, 2022 @12:33PM (#31791388)
Which is going to lower conversion. Significantly.

Whole reason why any service is paid monthly is because it's just makes more money over customer lifetime.

Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by smachiz on Saturday June 18, 2022 @12:48PM (#31791546)
it's not really going to change the lifetime value of a customer, I bet, once they're onboarded. But it will absolutely lower conversion.

People do month to month because they don't know if they'll find value in it, it's totally no commitment.

Asking to think if I'll still like this creator in 3 months requires actual thought... and $9 feels like money whereas $3 just doesn't.

Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by escapecharacter on Saturday June 18, 2022 @11:54AM (#31790995)
Gonna start a PAC for me and my friends’ horny fan art commissions
Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by vinni2 on Saturday June 18, 2022 @12:22PM (#31791286)
how would that happen? credit card providers would need to pool transactions not the patreon?
Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by mtlynch on Saturday June 18, 2022 @12:31PM (#31791362)
I think what they mean is that if I'm making $1/month contributions to 20 different creators, and they're all on the same platform, I can pool that into a single transaction with a single $0.50 fee, meaning that fees eat only 2.5% of my donations.

If I were donating to creators on different platforms, it would be 20 transactions, each with a fee of around $0.30, so fees would eat 30% of my donations.

Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by amelius on Saturday June 18, 2022 @01:00PM (#31791666)
This is how banks should work.
Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by Nextgrid on Saturday June 18, 2022 @11:37AM (#31790812)
On the other hand, Patreon bills supporters as one lump sum and then pays out as a lump sum as well - that should at least offset the flat per-transaction fee, if there is any.
Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by echelon on Saturday June 18, 2022 @11:54AM (#31791005)
They should have a system to charge in bulk up front that you can then use to support creators. Similar to how Reddit allows purchase of hundreds of thousands of coins at once.

Sell "Patreon Tokens". 100 for $100 at a one to one exchange rate. You can then spend in stores (one time redemptions) or subscribe to creators.

Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by harles on Saturday June 18, 2022 @11:42AM (#31790861)
On the billing side, I’d guess it’s unlikely to help. I’ve never paid more than $6/mo total on Patreon and I’d expect this is typical.
Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by Cerium on Saturday June 18, 2022 @11:47AM (#31790925)
Mine is about $20 a month, a couple $5, a couple $1 per episode, one $3.5.
Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by egypturnash on Saturday June 18, 2022 @01:11PM (#31791765)
They keep on proposing stuff that will break this. Usually it is claimed to be an attempt to solve the problem of someone supporting a creator who uses Patreon to create a paywall, snagging everything they can, and cancelling before the monthly charge ever hits.

Which is a problem but their proposed solutions always seem to involve things like "now everyone pays on the anniversary of when they started supporting a creator" which just completely fucks up the original value proposition of "we merge lots of little transactions into one decent-sized one", as well as fucking things up for people like me who are just using Patreon as a tip jar for stuff they release publicly. Letting individual creators decide this will work for them and opt into it is never mentioned as an option, so Patreon gets to hear a loud, sustained scream from creators who are normally quiet, and walk it back a week later.

Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by weberer on Saturday June 18, 2022 @12:36PM (#31791416)
This is something crypto was supposed to fix. And maybe smaller coins did, but transaction costs for BTC and ETH are even higher.
Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by latchkey on Saturday June 18, 2022 @01:05PM (#31791705)
There is more to 'crypto' than just BTC/ETH. Quite a few of the larger L2 chains have fraction of a penny fees and transactions go through in seconds. They are actually perfect for smaller transactions. We just need more people to build on top of them and make real products like this in order to get more adoption.
Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by emptysongglass on Saturday June 18, 2022 @01:28PM (#31791918)
Lightning BTC is absurdly cheap and very fast.
Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by elif on Saturday June 18, 2022 @07:05PM (#31794613)
You can use a smart contract with a side-chain for fee-less transactions from donators -> creators, and only have to pay a single transaction fee every time a donator or creator adds or withdraws funds.

so each donator would have ~$0.75 fee every month, regardless of how many creators they support. or whales could just fill their account for the quarter/year for $0.75 if they so chose.

and each creator would only have a $0.75 fee every time they decided to withdraw.

just build $0.01 into the contract and its a profitable system.

Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by polski-g on Saturday June 18, 2022 @02:10PM (#31792290)
Iota is a way better technology for this sort of thing.
Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by sumy23 on Saturday June 18, 2022 @12:52PM (#31791579)
I ran a micro-payments platform and our solution was to have users store money in their "wallets" that they could spend on any content with minimum amounts for wallet additions. Unsurprisingly, people don't like spending more money :)
Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by latchkey on Saturday June 18, 2022 @01:07PM (#31791724)
Depends on the platform I think. I built the one for Kink (NSFW porn) and it did quite well. The stored 'money' was called, Kinks that we held database entries for. People would just buy blocks of $10+ of these tokens (this was long before blockchain) and refresh them as they spent them.
Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by monkeybutton on Saturday June 18, 2022 @01:23PM (#31791874)
How well did that go with how anti-adult industry the banking industry is?
Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by latchkey on Saturday June 18, 2022 @02:07PM (#31792256)
It was a pain in the ass. The porn industry developed 3rd party systems that would swap between merchant accounts on a whim. When people would put their credit card in, on the back end, it would try multiple accounts until it found one that would take the card and it was all integrated with a whole referral system [1] called NATS that was really sketchy software. It has been many years for me and seeing that they are still in business is kind of crazy really.

[1] https://toomuchmedia.com/

Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by generalizations on Saturday June 18, 2022 @01:41PM (#31792021)
I looked into this a while back with PayPal, when I was researching a business that would depend on massive quantities of $1 transactions. At the time (dunno if they still do), PayPal had a separate type of account you could sign up for with a different fee structure for transactions of that magnitude. It was pretty good.
Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by PaulDavisThe1st on Saturday June 18, 2022 @06:53PM (#31794534)
ardour.org makes the majority of its income (approx US$200k/yr) via a PayPal micropayment account. Most of our transactions are < US$12, the crossover point where the standard and micropayment fees are the same (higher amounts are better with standard fees). On a US$1 transaction (we do thousands of these every month) we save 23c per transaction.

The one downside is that if PayPal ever stops offering this, the revenue model for ardour.org will have to change, since there are really no viable alternatives.

Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by sorenjan on Saturday June 18, 2022 @11:32AM (#31790754)
I think this is one of the problems flattr tries to solve. instead of multiple micro transactions you make one larger transaction each month to flattr, who then divides it up to all the creators you want to support. I don't know how Patreon does it, if they make one charge for each creator you support I guess the transactions fees can become a large part of the total amount.

https://flattr.com/

Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by DoctorOW on Saturday June 18, 2022 @11:49AM (#31790942)
All patreon customers are also only charged once per month no matter how many creators they support. The main difference being that since Patreon has people pledge specific dollar amounts instead of trying to figure it out month-to-month like Flattr the average Patreon customer has much fewer creators.
Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by Pakdef on Saturday June 18, 2022 @11:35AM (#31790787)
> What I think is something people easily overlook with Patreon and similar platforms is that it's quite hard to make a decent profit on $1 or $5 transactions that most of Patreon's income seems to come from.

It's not hard with many cryptos that have basically no fees

Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by arinlen on Saturday June 18, 2022 @12:48PM (#31791537)
> What I think is something people easily overlook with Patreon and similar platforms is that it's quite hard to make a decent profit on $1 or $5 transactions that most of Patreon's income seems to come from.

Nothing forces Patreon to take a cut for each and every donation, let alone such a hefty fee. Plenty of micropayment services charge instead a fee for transactions into and out of their system, and internal transactions don't incur any cost or transaction fee.

If Patreon insists in taking a hefty cut from each and every donation, that's a problem caused by their business model.

Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by Sebb767 on Saturday June 18, 2022 @01:26PM (#31791902)
> Nothing forces Patreon to take a cut for each and every donation, let alone such a hefty fee.

Payment processors do. Donorbox [0], which the author switched to, states their pricing. For 1$, you'll pay ~32p (Stripe)/ ~51p (PayPal) for the payment processor, so 32%-51%. For 5$, you'll pay ~40p (Stripe) or 59p (PayPal), so still 8%-12%.

This is without Patreon/Donorbox having made a single dollar yet, but they do need to pay people to set up payment, their platform and support. Also, they want to make profit, since they're not a charity, after all.

[0] https://donorbox.org/pricing

Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by Dylan16807 on Saturday June 18, 2022 @03:27PM (#31792962)
Paypal lets you do micropayment charges for 5 cents plus 5%, and I've seen other services claim to have similar numbers.
Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by mgkimsal on Sunday June 19, 2022 @02:49PM (#31802164)
Years ago I ran a service with multiple charge points, and had 2 PayPal accounts. When the payment was under... ~$5, I'd use the micropayment account, and fallback to the 'regular' account for prices over that. I realized I was in some violation of terms with PP, but was never caught. I wasn't doing quite enough transactions to probably hit their radar, and my chargebacks were non-existent, so I was probably lucky.
Re:Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets by scollet on Sunday June 19, 2022 @03:46AM (#31797175)
Why does it matter