"Early contributions to the tale include the medieval courtly romance Perceforest (published in 1528).[4] In this tale, a princess named Zellandine falls in love with a man named Troylus. Her father sends him to perform tasks to prove himself worthy of her, and while he is gone, Zellandine falls into an enchanted sleep. Troylus finds her and rapes her in her sleep; when their child is born, the child draws from her finger the flax that caused her sleep. She realizes from the ring Troylus left her that he was the father, and Troylus later returns to marry her.[5]"
Guy was high on some drugs when he wrote this sh%t. Talk about messed up.
They exposed children to the idea that the chaotic world is outside your ability to control, but you must live in it and navigate it to the extent you can nonetheless. This will not always end well for you, despite your best efforts.
In contrast, the message of modern fairy tales is that life has challenges, but they can all be overcome. If you are noble, persistent and hard working, you can achieve anything. Characters nearly always end up royalty or some variation of happily ever after.
0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pinocchio#Fictional_character_...
1: https://slate.com/culture/2011/10/carlo-collodi-s-pinocchio-...
The part of the movie where all of the boys on Pleasure Island begin to turn into donkeys always freaked me out as a kid.
https://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/customer-reviews/R1JOT49B5OUAL0/...
Even the opening of the review is... something:
> To be honest, I struggled with this book. I found the main character incredibly frustrating. He almost always did the wrong thing. I mean, almost ALWAYS. Well, people sometimes do (including me!), but what he does is also almost always incredibly stupid. Well, again, people do stupid things (including me!), and the main character is, after all, a puppet who is only moments old at the beginning of the book, so how is he to know better? Fair question, but still, I found the book hard work. He just did not seem to learn from his mistakes.
>> 0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pinocchio#Fictional_character_...:
> Pinocchio's bad behavior, rather than being charming or endearing, is meant to serve as a warning.
That reminds me something I read about "Inuit parenting." They live in a dangerous and difficult environment, so they'd tell kids all kinds of scary stories designed to get them to do the correct thing before they could understood the actual danger.
It's just about life, explained through metaphors from somebody who had lived it a bit to some who may have lived it less, and could benefit from a few warnings.
Collodi was also a gambler: one night he lost an especially large amount of money, then happened to meet a friend, who commissioned him a literary work so as to help with the payment of his debts. "Le Avventure di Pinocchio" was in a way born out of deeds, to warn against deeds.
Like the suggestion that "Bambi" is a parable, it has been also suggested that Brer Rabbit represents the slave of the Antebellum South surviving against the toothed and clawed Brer Fox and Brer Bear only by his wits (though in fact Brer Wolf meets his own end at the hands of Brer Rabbit's "wit" ... or boiling water in his specific case).
That's the variant I got told in my childhood (1980s West Germany). It always amuses me that these simple facts seem to be cruel and horrific to Americans.
Also, "Hänsel and Gretel" is a tale about parental abandonment, stranger danger, cannibalism, and burning old women alive, then forgiving said parental abandonment (but only after the kids bring back treasure).
And "Red Riding Hood" is essentially about sexual child abuse.
Or both, where vipers were boiled, and new vipers were constantly being added to bite, then turn into boiling viper soup themselves.
IDK about plot hole, I assume the both method will get the job done. But, I do question the efficiency and practicality.
"Ring around the Rosie... and we all fall down" (refers to the Great Plague of London in 1665)
"Rockabye baby in the treetops" (eventually sent crashing to the ground by storm winds).
Killing depictions, mild sexual jokes... as nothing.
Well, if we're thinking about the moral messages of some of these old tales, I've always thought Requiem could be a good movie to show tweens+ as a cautionary against drug abuse. If Disney threw in an evil witch selling smack, a few catchy songs, a handful of dead parents, and a handsome prince to kiss Harry's arm back to life then I bet they'd have... well, maybe not a hit. But it would be something, and I'd watch it.
Those two, along with Kids (1995) could definitely be used as cautionary tales for t(w)eenagers.
what (imo) would make requiem for a dream really effective is that it shows the transition from the "honeymoon phase" of drug use to the "consequences phase" really well. I think this is the part that teenagers really don't understand (or at least I didn't). when you're starting out, it can seem like a lot of the anti-drug messaging is just fear mongering (and it is, to an extent). but most people that age don't yet have the perspective to distinguish between harmless fun and a slow motion crisis.
trainspotting is also great, and a bit more realistic than requiem for a dream. but if I had to pick one of the two to show to teens, I'd probably pick the former.
Disney/Hollywood version is always Cinderella, and German that closely adheres to the original is called Aschenputtel. The same goes for Snowwhite and Schneewitchen, Sleeping Beauty and Dornröschen.
There's even a counter example. The 2010 film Tangled is called Rapunzel like the original fairy tale in German.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snow_White_and_the_Huntsman
The Disney version of Cinderella is based on Charles Perraults version, which is significantly different. An Perrault is older than Grimm, although both are based on older traditions.
There’s a theory that Hansel and Grettel represents a cultural memory of a time of famine where children were abandoned, left to starve.
I think they all used to live in a very different reality, with people dying at an earlier age and much more often then they do now. Also infant mortality was much much higher in the olden days; it was a scary time, altogether.
The olden days didn't have the luxury of clean water, antibiotics and food plenty. These are quite recent inventions...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qQrqhdU99Ws
Also the father commands his son 'you must get up'; he acts like a commander.
Most original material Disney adapted was bleakier and more grisly than the adaptation.
Most of the tales collected by brothers Grimm would today be horror stories. (Did you know that Cinderella's evil stepsisters had their toes and heels cut off so they could fit in the slippers? Or that the ravens pecked their eyes as punishment? Or that Maleficent ends up in a boiling cauldron full of vipers?)
I bet Disney would be able to adapt even something like "Requiem for a Dream" into a happy hero-coming-of-age story.
You lose a lot if the only version of these classics you've seen (or read, or heard) is Disney's sweet & shiny simulacra.