Tesla says that the car should be in sight during the whole summon procedure precisely so things like this don’t happen.
https://www.tesla.com/ownersmanual/model3/en_us/GUID-6B9A1AE...
“You must maintain a clear line of sight between you and Model 3 and closely monitor the vehicle and its surroundings at all times.”
“Smart Summon is a BETA feature. You must continually monitor the vehicle and its surroundings and stay prepared to take immediate action at any time. It is the driver's responsibility to use Smart Summon safely, responsibly, and as intended.”
I’m surprised that this was not a slam dunk for your insurance company.
(I'm sure the engineers at Tesla are just as dissatisfied about the state of things, but Musk is relentless. I'm glad I chose not to work there)
> “In the U.S., things are legal by default, and in Europe, they are illegal by default,” Musk said last month during the opening of Tesla's factory near Berlin. “We have to get approval beforehand, whereas in the U.S., you can kind of do it on your own cognizance, more or less.”
This sums it up. Elon is gambling the entire autonomous industry on the hopes that these crashes never go too viral. That it's never a slow news week when FSD happens to drive like a blind teenager and cremate the driver and murder innocent bystanders.
If this ever happens it's the end of autonomous driving. The regulation will be so punitive and the hoops so plentiful that it will be over, for everyone.
I'm so glad autonomous cars are a scam, because the price its proponents want to impose on everyone else to make it a reality (legally enforced non-ownership of a car you bought, even further expansion of the road network and even greater sprawl, a privately owned panopticon, banning other road users, even proposals for mandatory self driving car beacons on pedestrians, and guarantee there'd be a 'premium subscription' down the line to go anywhere other than a major chain for dinner) is far too great.
"Have your car come to you while you deal with a fussy child."
This is Tesla to a tee. What marketing promises, the fine print take away.
Musk is eccentric sure, but at the end of the day the two companies are building emmission-free vehicles and trying to make humanity an interplanetary species. Both of these are pretty worth-while goals, imho.
I would love to see a CEO who doesn't have flaws.
This is like hearing people talking about how it's worth-while to give money to the church in the hope to secure themselves heaven.
Tesla and SpaceX are not young companies, they have been around for 20 years now. Quality of life provided to the American consumer in this timeframe? Zero, zip, none.
In the same timeframe Google became ubiquitous, Microsoft put a PC on every desk and Amazon became the way we shop.
The stark contrast between the presence of Tesla and Musk in the financial press (or every press he can summon really) and the absence of products in the real world is all an educated person needs to characterize this individual and the scheme he engineered.
You haven’t heard of Starlink or the Model S? I can drive 120 electric miles to my country cabin, where there is no cell service and wired broadband tops out at about 32 kilobit per second USR modems, and I can open a RDC connections to my CNC machines, play low latency games, blow things up with det cord and cast boosters. It’s pretty cool, man.
> the absence of products in the real world
Again, you haven’t heard of Space-X or Tesla? They make some very successful and widely used products. No marketing department - I guess that’s why this is all new to you?
Widely used by who exactly? Go Karts for rich people and rockets? What's the quality of life for the broad population in that?
People ranging from NYC Billionaire's Row all the way to Subsaharn Africa use Google Search every day, Android, Microsoft Windows too, likewise Facebook and Youtube.
Your message only evidences how bubbles of wealth manage to isolate wealthy individuals from regular people problems.
Read my handle, I have nothing against toys for rich people, what I am against is pretending they are anymore than toys for rich people. Google is ubiquitous in our lives, so are Microsoft, Coca-Cola, Exxon, Shell, Walmart, Facebook, Berkshire etc.
Yet the social and market consensus is that Tesla is more important than all the above companies even though it's not ubiquitous, frankly speaking Tesla is the opposite of that.
Like Porsche, Ferrari, McLaren, Corvette... they produce toys for rich people. Badly assembled and badly refined I should add.
> NASA users Space X to launch their people to the ISS, they're singlehandedly reviving space aeronautics.
And what's the quality of life improvement for the American consumer in that whole ordeal? I can pinpoint exactly where and how Google makes my life easier, same for Exxon, Facebook, Microsoft etc.
Watching the rocket go up and land on its butt is at best a form of entertainment for rich people who are too depressed by the daily routine and are too scared to try drugs or too proud to go to therapy.
To reiterate in order to include non tech companies Walmart sold 600B dollars worth of products, Amazon 400B.
Berkshire has 800B worth of premiums under management. These are real life being impacted with straight injections of quality of life.
The Boring company is about subsurface construction on Mars.
Fully automated factories are about manufacturing on mars (and in orbit).
Electric cars, self-driving technolgy and hyperloop are about transportation on mars.
Solar City and batteries are about the power grid on mars.
SpaceX is about getting to mars.
Their insurance says "driver wasn't driving, not covered." Meaning the Tesla owner is still to blame, but you need sue them directly; meaning your insurance needs to sue them directly.
Ugh, why do they insist on this weird corporate speak?
As a society, we have not figured out who is liable in cases like this -- the owner or the car company that engineered the AI.
For the most part none of this is novel to the law.
So long as the owner didn’t do anything negligent themselves, then it seems a strong claim of product liability (defective product). It seems there is very little chance of contributory negligence of the owner with this function, unlike crashes in self-drive mode, where the driver was supposed to pay attention and maintain their hands on the wheel, but turns out they were sleeping or in the backseat live streaming.
I do think there should be legislation adopted to protect the victims by giving them a statutory private right of action against both the owner and the car manufacturer to hold them jointly and severally liable for any accident involving self driving vehicles, then in practice the owner/manufacturer (i.e. their insurance companies) to sort out liability.
Assuming that's the case, I would argue that this specific sort of accident is squarely in the domain of the user.
Not even mentioning the explicit warnings to keep line of sight when you use smart summon, as well as the fact that summon is automatically limited to only within 20 meters of the car.
You may say multitasking is hard or impossible but we humans manage to approximate it anyways because it’s necessary for life. For example, if you are the parent of two fussy children in a busy parking lot, you better know how to multitask or one of those kids will escape your sight!
"The person in the driver's seat is only there for legal reasons"
from the 5+ year old marketing video still featured on https://www.tesla.com/autopilot
Asking not because I don't believe it, but because the only results I get on google by searching for that quote are your comments on HN from this year in multiple threads that include it.
If the Tesla website indeed says it (which I am yet to find), I would write it off as just future-promise-marketing. You can call it misleading in that case, which would be fair.
At the end of the day, that's not how it currently works, and you have to hold the button for the car to move during summon, and you gotta be within 20 meter radius. As soon as you let the button go, the car stops. This isn't me just saying based on what internet says, this is what I have observed myself and what the car manual says[0] (both the online and the print version, in multiple spots).
0. https://www.tesla.com/ownersmanual/model3/en_us/GUID-6B9A1AE...
It's interesting how Google narrows your world view.
> If the Tesla website indeed says it (which I am yet to find)
Here you go:
https://www.tesla.com/blog/introducing-software-version-10-0
> I would write it off as just future-promise-marketing
No, it's just lies and advertising.
Now, here, maybe the user could have prevented the car accident by letting go of the button. But, what if the user had faith (however misplaced) that the car was going to avoid the collision until it was too late to let go? Or what if the user had suffered a stroke at that particular moment and couldn’t let go? It’s an interesting thought experiment.
Some things, like the decision to trigger a weapon in an act of war may be something societies want to have humans, and only humans make the ultimate call. That is, there is a desire for a human-in-the-loop.
On the other end of the spectrum are decisions we want to take out of the human hands because we think automation is more reliable and better for our society.
And then there are the unintended consequences. Looking back the past 10 years, it's arguable that the 'share' and 'retweet' features of social media that gives the power of virality to ordinary people have had a profound effect on our society and culture, both for good and for bad (and for many cases where we can't even agree on what's good or bad).
I argue that, while some of this is not novel to the law, I don't necessarily think that those precedents cover all of the changes tech has wrought to how we live and govern ourselves.
If my car is parked in a parking lot, and someone rams my car so that it rolls and hits another car, I am liable. This is why parking breaks are important
I don't understand why self driving cars would be any different. I am liable to make sure I am using my car properly. Even if it has fancy tech.
Relying on images only requires you to perfectly identify every object in the scene in order to infer its bounding box. And that's an issue like we see here where you don't expect to see private jets near a Tesla and so it may not be modelled.
With LiDAR, Radar etc. at least they know "something" is there even if they don't know what is.
https://www.theverge.com/2021/5/24/22451404/tesla-luminar-li...
https://www.patentforecast.com/2021/07/22/lidar-competition-...
https://www.patentforecast.com/2021/09/02/waymo-is-driving-l...
Fwiw, the best use of summon is simply getting out of a tight parking spot (e.g., some residential garages).
Expecting it to be a valet is ambitious in its current state.
So which is the definitive statement?
That said, some of the Tesla marketing, like in the example you provided, is very far off the mark. I really wish they wouldn’t do that, since it makes people question the other things marketed about the car that are (more or less) accurate.
Fwiw, the summon feature is a nice, minor convenience. I would even say that it is well-implemented for simple use cases. That said, the existing feature does not match the dreams that Tesla is currently selling (imho).
I bet it'd work great on Mars, though. Not a whole lot of airplanes there, now or in the foreseeable future.
I find disturbing how the car just keep going... This is not a sensor issue.
Tesla stops when it sense a imminent collision even if you have your foot on the pedal.
But, based on the incident, it seems to rely on the cameras and radars. Not on engine performance data.
Smart summon does have wild raccoon energy. In this case, you need to be within ~200 feet and the car uses its GPS location to plot a path to you. It will back out and turn around obstacles. But it goes kind of fast. Uncomfortably fast. I had my car whip around a turn and nearly hit a parked car. I don't think I've ever seen it work well. Or at least it has always ended with me letting go of the phone kill switch. Which again, takes around a full second to stop the car.
Like someone else commented, this is a very different system than "full self driving" (16 year-old that just got their license energy), which is also a different thing than "Autopilot" (works great on highways).
I thought the official dogma was that when self-driving cars were in "auto-mode" the manufacturers would be the parties held responsible/liable and pay for any damages cause by their systems.
See my response here:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31129075
tl;dr — Tesla states the driver is responsible when using this feature.
WTF, I'm against self-driving cars now. Glad you're all right.
In the linked case, the car's windshield hit the prodruding tail of the jet, which was maybe 1.5m above the tarmac. I'd be more willing to believe that this is an edge case of the sensors (they aren't tuned for overhangs, and I've heard of people scraping garage doors for presumably similar reasons). But... a motorcycle, really? Are you absolutely sure it was on summon?
Likewise I don't understand why you were dealing with the other driver's insurance company anyway. This is what you pay your own insurer for; making you whole without having to do the work yourself is literally what you pay them for.
That's shocking. What does that have to do with liability? Hypothentically if my car's brakes failed while my car was parked, my insurance should cover any damages.
i once had to file a claim after a tesla on summon backed out of its parking space and directly over my motorcycle, crushing it against a barrier wall with such unrelenting force it pushed the cylinder head covers into the gas tank. this claim was a real tit spanner because the owners cut-rate insurance company flat-out refused to cover it since the driver wasnt in the car. it took nearly a year of subrogation but mercifully they settled.