News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by lucasyvas on Sunday March 20, 2022 @07:53PM (#30748115)
These problems tend to work themselves out naturally - when you purposefully damage your user experience, you lose the early tech adopters that originally drove your product growth. They instead flock to a competitor that leaves you holding your bag of a shitty product.

There are a few companies flirting with this dangerous line right now and it opens them up completely for disruption, which is the opposite of what they want.

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by tcmart14 on Sunday March 20, 2022 @08:44PM (#30748628)
I don't think pleasing tech adopters is what help windows at this point. Maybe 20 year ago, sure. Today, most consumers of Windows that are not business/enterprise, are probably doing it more so because that was the defacto OS for them when they were in grade school, and it has been the defacto OS on most computers sub $1K. We are seeing some market shift to chrome OS and there is probably a good future where Chrome OS displaces Windows massively. If it does, it won't be because of tech adopters and such. It will be because Chrome OS is what is gaining popularity for kids in school and they will grow up being used to.

Edit: Defacto above meaning, when I go into best buy, that is what is pre-loaded. Or I go to walmart, that is what comes on the computer.

Edit: 'there is probably a good future where Chrome OS' typo or poor wording. Meant to say something along the lines of, 'there is probably a good chance that a Chrome OS future happens'

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by Espressosaurus on Sunday March 20, 2022 @08:52PM (#30748702)
If you think Chrome OS is going to save you, you haven't been paying attention to Google for the past 10 years.
Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by tcmart14 on Sunday March 20, 2022 @08:56PM (#30748738)
I didn't say it was going to save me. I do think I had a type that said 'good future.' I meant to put something along the lines of 'good probability of a future.' Chrome OS is going to be another user hostile environment for sure. But the point is, Chrome OS has a good shot at displacing windows not because it is better or less user hostile, but because it is putting cheap machines in the hands of kids who will one day, grow up, and enter the workforce and lead the workforce later on.
Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by userbinator on Sunday March 20, 2022 @10:19PM (#30749333)
Chrome OS has a good shot at displacing windows not because it is better or less user hostile, but because it is putting cheap machines in the hands of kids who will one day, grow up, and enter the workforce and lead the workforce later on.

That's even worse, because as the saying goes, those who never had freedom (or ownership, for that matter) won't miss it.

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by seanp2k2 on Sunday March 20, 2022 @10:56PM (#30749638)
Fear not; they'll deprecate Chrome OS and Stadia in the next few years and add it to https://killedbygoogle.com/ , which I see has just added AngularJS recently. Google Cloud Print stuck out there too, since we had a big thing about rolling that out at work just a few years ago as the future solution for all our printing needs.
Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by tcmart14 on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:24AM (#30750599)
Google does kill off a lot of products, but I wouldn't hold my breath on Chrome OS. It is paying off for them in the education space. They have an OS that ships on cheap computers that work well enough for students. Gets them in the google ecosystem and the mind set of Chrome OS is what a computer should be. Not to mention contracts in place with school systems that probably nets them easy money.

https://www.thurrott.com/mobile/chrome-os/chromebook/228534/....

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by tcmart14 on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:21AM (#30750588)
What is worst or better is not what matters in this instance. This is a matter of the reality of what will probably lead to the adoption of an OS. Would I be happy with Chrome OS displacing Windows? No. Am I happy with Windows having the market share it does? No. But what I want doesn't matter in adoption. What matters is, Chrome OS has a strategy that will probably work. And that strategy doesn't involve tech influences getting excited over the product, it is simply getting it in kid's hand so they think Chrome OS is how a computer should be. Regardless if that is true. That is why Linux adoption for the common user sucks, their first experience was probably Windows, so in their mind, Windows is how a computer should be.
Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by hulitu on Monday March 21, 2022 @04:49AM (#30751776)
Purchasing decision are made by business executives. I use windows because i am forced by my employer.
Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by tcmart14 on Monday March 21, 2022 @05:47AM (#30752110)
> kids who will one day, grow up, and enter the workforce and lead the workforce later on

I noticed chromebook getting big in the education space and really getting into the hands of kids 7 years so. Your business executives I assume are old enough to pre-date chromebook's big debut in eductaion? They likewise are probably most familiar with Windows and that is why they hand it down as the required bit of software? or probably a sweet business contract, that also plays a factor.

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by gryn on Monday March 21, 2022 @06:13AM (#30752276)
you can do like I do, use window for nothing beside virtual box in which there's your real everyday OS.
Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by lordnacho on Sunday March 20, 2022 @07:59PM (#30748171)
I wish this was true, but there are a heck of a lot of office workers who have grown up with Windows and can never be trained to use anything else.

You'll get a lot of resistance and rationalisation about why they don't think Linux or BSD or whatever isn't as good, and that the training time is better used to just work.

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by jasonjayr on Monday March 21, 2022 @12:05AM (#30750118)
My kid just graduated high school last year.

She would tell me stories about how impressed her peers were with seeing her do something as basic as copy and paste, and navigating files + folders.

There is a generation of kids that have only ever grown up on tablets + the web, so; the desktop + office app market + ecosystem is ripe for disruption.

Maybe it's done right this time, and not married to a single browser version(ha) or platform runtime.

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by brimble on Monday March 21, 2022 @12:13PM (#30755809)
> She would tell me stories about how impressed her peers were with seeing her do something as basic as copy and paste, and navigating files + folders.

> There is a generation of kids that have only ever grown up on tablets + the web, so; the desktop + office app market + ecosystem is ripe for disruption.

I'm not aware of any generation for which being comfortable with those things hasn't put one in, at least (I'm being very conservative), the top 20% of computer literacy. Most people are bad at just using a computer—given how long it's been a problem, there's either a lot of essential complexity there that cannot be mitigated or avoided to improve usability, or we as an industry have just done a terrible job designing desktop operating systems for regular people. I don't think tablets et c. have much to do with it.

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by userbinator on Sunday March 20, 2022 @08:20PM (#30748372)
who have grown up with Windows and can never be trained to use anything else.

When Windows itself is changing so much that it hardly resembles what it used to be, there's going to be a lot of relearning anyway.

On the other hand, you can make Linux look like any version of Windows if you really wanted to.

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by spaetzleesser on Sunday March 20, 2022 @08:27PM (#30748439)
If you want Linux to compete, you need spreadsheet software as good as Excel and a word processor that's 100% compatible with Word. I tried to use LibreOffice for a while but Calc ins't there yet and I had tons of formatting problems when I sent documents to Words users. After dealing with this for a while you just give up and start using Office again.
Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by Lev1a on Sunday March 20, 2022 @10:51PM (#30749596)
> you need spreadsheet software as good as Excel and a word processor that's 100% compatible with Word

IIRC I read an anecdote a few years back that if MS ever lost the code to their office products they couldn't re-implement it 100% compatible again since they don't completely abide by any standards like the Open Document Format.

I will always continue to harbor hatred for MSs Office products since when I had to write a big piece of homework for 9th grade in school (a "Facharbeit", kinda like a mini Bachelor's thesis as an intro to scientific writing) I then had to transfer the file from my computer via USB drive to my fathers' PC to print it out. Naive as i was, I didn't think to double-check the formatting after the transfer since it was the same software on the same version on the same OS etc. Ended getting a "1 (very good)" for content but the formatting grade was so bad it dragged the combined mark down to a "3 (satisfactory)". Since then I'll only print documents after converting to pdf and double-checking everything is ok and will never voluntarily use an MS Office product ever again.

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by nicoburns on Sunday March 20, 2022 @09:11PM (#30748861)
It’s a shame Office went to the continually updated subscription model. Older versions of office ran excellently under wine.
Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by jart on Sunday March 20, 2022 @09:01PM (#30748783)
I don't want to pull back the curtain too much or tramp on everyone's hopes, but Linux can't compete with Microsoft because of UEFI. The PCs being sold today only allow Microsoft's software to run. In order to distribute a Linux distro, you have to ask Microsoft to give you a shim where they've signed your private key, so that you can share your own signed kernel builds with others. Therefore you can't publish a Linux desktop for consumers without being in league with the adversary.
Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by Shared404 on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:26PM (#30749865)
I believe many UEFI implementations allow you to replace the secure boot keys with your own.

I've not done it personally as most of my machines I just disable Secure Boot, but it's an option if you know about it and buy carefully.

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by jart on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:54PM (#30750044)
That's why I was used the word consumers. Rolling your own crypto will let you work around the requirement of asking Microsoft for permission to install our own operating system. But it limits the audience for your work to the technical class.
Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by Shared404 on Monday March 21, 2022 @12:07AM (#30750126)
/me removes foot from mouth

I see what you mean now, I screwed up reading your first comment.

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by jart on Monday March 21, 2022 @03:03AM (#30751074)
I think this is the first time someone has ever reacted non-negatively towards me online after I brought up the subject. UEFI has good PR and I think people refuse to believe the implications of what happened. It would be like having Google officially be the only CA for HTTPS certificates and then removing HTTP from Chrome. That's basically what the security community did with PCs.
Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by Shared404 on Monday March 21, 2022 @12:32PM (#30756100)
That surprises me. Much better in my opinion to listen then to assume I know better - especially because I'm familiar with your work.

Even though Secure Boot can be disabled on most hardware afaict [0] that's still a step consumers won't take so the point still stands easily. Especially with the amount of "you will break everything and kick a a puppy" that manufacturers throw in there to disuade anyone who manages to get to the menu.

[0] worked at a repair ahop until 1.5ish weeks ago, have disabled SB on a lot of hardware.

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by seanp2k2 on Sunday March 20, 2022 @10:59PM (#30749675)
Source? I've installed Ubuntu on half a dozen newish UEFI computers, some of which came with OEM Windows, over the past few years with no trouble https://wiki.ubuntu.com/UEFI/SecureBoot
Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by ohyeshedid on Monday March 21, 2022 @03:12AM (#30751129)
The source is in your own link. Also note, the person you replied to went on to emphasize 'consumer' in a followup comment, which I think makes the point much more salient.

[1]: "On Ubuntu, all pre-built binaries intended to be loaded as part of the boot process, with the exception of the initrd image, are signed by Canonical's UEFI certificate, which itself is implicitly trusted by being embedded in the shim loader, itself signed by Microsoft.

On architectures or systems where pre-loaded signing certificates from Microsoft are not available or loaded in firmware, users may replace the existing signatures on shim or grub and load them as they wish, verifying against their own certificates imported in the system's firmware."

[1] https://wiki.ubuntu.com/UEFI/SecureBoot#How_UEFI_Secure_Boot...

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by sgjohnson on Sunday March 20, 2022 @10:43PM (#30749528)
Is there a source for this?

And also, can’t you just disable Secure Boot?

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by wolpoli on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:53PM (#30750041)
There's WPS Office that runs on Windows, MacOS, and Linux. The user interface has a level of polish that rivals Microsoft Office. Sadly, I didn't have a chance to explore if it is seamless to move a file between MS Office and WPS Office.
Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by TheOtherHobbes on Sunday March 20, 2022 @08:44PM (#30748624)
It's not about cosmetic similarities.

Linux would kill it if it made it trivially easy to run Windows inside a sanitised and privatised container or VM that prevented telemetry and all the other nonsense.

I suspect a lot of people would accept a modest performance hit if that were possible.

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by creakingstairs on Sunday March 20, 2022 @08:29PM (#30748458)
That’s true but the new generation have grown up with (for better or worse) web/apps. Once they are the main workforce, they will be much less reluctant to switch to whatever OS.
Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by lucasyvas on Sunday March 20, 2022 @08:00PM (#30748190)
You're not wrong, but office users should be locked to a browser in 2022 anyway. What do they need Windows for? They can all use a web browser.

Microsoft has done an amazing job convincing the office world they need Windows, when they don't need a single feature that it provides in 99% of cases.

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by Pasorrijer on Sunday March 20, 2022 @08:03PM (#30748217)
As an officer worker, there are many many things I do that cannot be done in a web browser. File comparison tools, macros and complex excel queries, hard applications for both new and legacy critical programs...

Can this be done on Linux? Frequently. Can it be done in a web browser? Rarely effectively and often not at all.

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by syntheweave on Sunday March 20, 2022 @09:15PM (#30748885)
I can vouch for personal experience with macros and Linux, since I made my return to it this month. It's not ideal yet, but it's workable, and there's a generational transition taking place while moving from x11 to Wayland, since the two have different notions of input, so you have to wander through some compatibility stuff to find your way.

This is annoying, but already much better than the Windows story, because you can customize things right down to the kernel level and generally get the result you're looking for in a pretty direct fashion. I now have it set up so that it detects the model of keyboard I plugged in and redirects specific models to specific macro layers - a seemingly obvious two-keyboards use case that can be a serious hassle on Windows without resorting to a hardware solution.

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by oblio on Monday March 21, 2022 @03:09AM (#30751100)
They were talking about Excel macros, not sure if you're talking about the same kind of macros.
Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by lucasyvas on Sunday March 20, 2022 @08:10PM (#30748268)
That's fair - I would still be curious to know what percentage of office workers run Windows that don't actually need to.
Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by 3np on Sunday March 20, 2022 @08:29PM (#30748456)
Isn't Excel feature-complete in the browser now, macros and all?

https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-365

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by sjy on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:44PM (#30749976)
VBA macros aren't supported. Last time I checked even conditional formatting wasn't supported, although I see now it was added in January 2022 [1]. Even so, as with many other features, the web UI is different and more limited. Links to documents stored locally or on an SMB share don't work. Scrolling through thousands of rows is laggy. Generally, Excel Online is useless for the complex spreadsheets used in large enterprises, which themselves are often workarounds for the limitations of the web apps the enterprise is supposed to run on.

[1]: https://techcommunity.microsoft.com/t5/excel-blog/new-condit...

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by Pasorrijer on Sunday March 20, 2022 @08:47PM (#30748655)
In theory, yes.

However Excel Online breaks down quickly with large file sizes, loses formatting and struggles mightily with complex macros.

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by zo1 on Monday March 21, 2022 @03:26AM (#30751235)
Just wait till they start running those "native" programs in a VM on a server and streaming the UI to you in a browser for interaction.
Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by hulitu on Monday March 21, 2022 @05:16AM (#30751922)
Last i heard they experimented with windows running in the cloud and the user having just a kind of thin client. It is hilarious that 20 years after SUN's "The network is the computer" and some years after freedesktop's initiatives "wayland", "X is obsolete" "X on network sucks", Microsoft is coming doing just this.
Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by hackerfromthefu on Sunday March 20, 2022 @08:21PM (#30748377)
I'd have to say that, today, all of those can be done in the browser except Excel.

File comparison, hard applications, legacy code, can be compiled to WASM and run quite well in the browser. The pieces are in place to do it, they just need polishing and tuning to make it ubiquitous. Even Excel could be compiled like this but again MS wants to own you and pin you over a barrel while extracting everything they can from you, so Excel won't be available. But many/most Spreadsheets can be done in Libreoffice, or code or no/low code alternatives.

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by the_snooze on Sunday March 20, 2022 @08:37PM (#30748554)
>File comparison, hard applications, legacy code, can be compiled to WASM and run quite well in the browser.

Not when you're working on proprietary/confidential/classified information.

>But many/most Spreadsheets can be done in Libreoffice, or code or no/low code alternatives.

Not when you're working on spreadsheets that you need to send to organizations that heavily rely on MS Office.

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by apetresc on Monday March 21, 2022 @12:45AM (#30750396)
> Not when you're working on proprietary/confidential/classified information.

Why not? The WASM approach the OP is suggesting works entirely locally, the web is simply pushing client code to your browser.

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by hulitu on Monday March 21, 2022 @05:06AM (#30751864)
> Why not? The WASM approach the OP is suggesting works entirely locally, the web is simply pushing client code to your browser

Because "the web is simply pushing client code to your browser". Untrusted code. Which may violate the confidentiality of you document. I still don't get it why companies which deal with "confidential information" are very happy to put those documents in the cloud. But ... it is their data and they decide what to do with it.

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by apetresc on Tuesday March 22, 2022 @03:47PM (#30770594)
I think you're still misunderstanding. The documents don't need to be "in the cloud", the WASM in your browser can operate on them locally.

Is the WASM "untrusted"? Sure, I guess, all code you haven't written yourself is "untrusted" by default. Why would a native application shipped via CD or download be any more "trusted"?

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by raxxorrax on Monday March 21, 2022 @06:41AM (#30752433)
You lose most of the advantages of running a software in your browser though.
Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by hackerfromthefu on Monday March 21, 2022 @09:33AM (#30753912)
Can you explain what you're thinking?
Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by GekkePrutser on Sunday March 20, 2022 @10:05PM (#30749229)
OneNote is still a pig in the browser. Every day it has to reload and loses track of all the folders in the notebook so I have to reload them all again.

Oh and it's soooo slow :(

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by mamcx on Sunday March 20, 2022 @09:32PM (#30749000)
Beware what you ask for: Browsers are becoming an OS, and ARE far more abusive with users.

And that browser more likely is owned by oogle...

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by Al-Khwarizmi on Monday March 21, 2022 @04:39AM (#30751713)
Not sure if with "should" you are talking about some kind of ideal world. But in 2022 in the real world, this cannot be done. Online Word is a joke. I would like to use it (because I hate MS Office, so if I could go without having it installed and taking room in my HD and start menu, it would be great) but it's unusable even for my quite basic needs. A sister comment talks about advanced stuff like Excel macros, etc.; but even very basic functionality is not available.

For example: right now, it's impossible to edit a document online with Track Changes without showing all the changes (which makes documents practically unreadable). And you don't even have pages online, documents are shown with a continuous layout where it's difficult to know where pages start and end.

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by hulitu on Monday March 21, 2022 @05:00AM (#30751837)
MS Office in browser is like Teams: terrible. Aparently MS decided to rewrite the UI for the browser app and even they acknoledge that is not working (do you want to open in desktop app ?)
Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by aksss on Monday March 21, 2022 @03:21AM (#30751198)
I think you’re projecting, and severely unfamiliar with the software.
Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by skoskie on Sunday March 20, 2022 @08:54PM (#30748717)
Add MacOS to the list. The continued crippling of the OS for power users keeps pushing us toward the iOS experience, and it’s killing me. I can’t see details of my own log files for privacy reasons. The new Finder design is just awful and accomplished nothing for all the change. Now I learn I can’t make hardlinks for directories on APFS. The list goes on.
Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by GekkePrutser on Sunday March 20, 2022 @10:00PM (#30749199)
Yes, I moved away too. So much dumbing down, so many things changed just for the sake of it. And of course no settings to revert it. Eventually it was just too annoying to upgrade.

A lot of it is security hardening but the problem is I have to give all control to Apple. There is no way for me to change anything in the read only OS part without the whole rigmarole of booting into recovery mode and blessing my changes with every update. There should be a way I can sign my own changes. It's the Apple way or the highway. And I'm running into more and more issues when the Apple way is just not good enough for me.

I'm really so happy with having options again with KDE. No more opinionated software for me.

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by raxxorrax on Monday March 21, 2022 @06:45AM (#30752458)
They have long understood that security is always an argument to throw into the pot to justify their changes. Boot malware isn't really a widely spread problem in 22 and MS still pushes TPM 2.0. It is probably less about user security than control about users and machines.
Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by scarface74 on Monday March 21, 2022 @08:31AM (#30753295)
This is what can happen when you turn off SIP on the Mac. You can’t trust developers to not be careless and/or malignant.

https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2019/09/no-it...

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by digisign on Monday March 21, 2022 @12:52PM (#30756448)
Poor security design. App installers should definitely be sandboxed, "sip" or not. Preventing the local admin from making any changes due to lack of that, is fixing the wrong problem. Or perhaps not in a granular enough way.
Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by scarface74 on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:38PM (#30757229)
So it’s “poor security design” when a user with root access specifically disables the security and bad things happen?
Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by digisign on Monday March 21, 2022 @02:20PM (#30757736)
Yes, useful and destructive/fatal configuration should be separated.

If you have to remove a load-bearing pillar to install a light-switch, the design is poor, to say the least.

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by scarface74 on Monday March 21, 2022 @02:45PM (#30758075)
There are two separate levels

- root access - doesn’t disable SIP

- Disabling SIP requires you to go through many contortions.

People didn’t need to disable SIP to install Chrome. They were doing it for other reasons.

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by digisign on Tuesday March 22, 2022 @12:03PM (#30767741)
Yes, and those reasons are why I mentioned poor design.

This morning I was reminded, my work Mac has a dozen daemons trying to contact things I don't want, such as icloud, itunes, google, etc. A fraction of these are ostensibly useful, but I had to resort to Little Snitch to block them because the OS is read-only, i.e. insanity.

Even the user-hostile mess of Windows allows me to turn off the worse services... although even that is dwindling.

Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by scarface74 on Wednesday March 23, 2022 @08:26PM (#30785223)
The OS is not “read only” if you go through contortions. But if you can write anything to the OS, so can anything you run
Re:Windows needs a change in priorities by astrange on Monday March 21, 2022 @02:01AM (#30750781)
You can’t make hardlinks to directories on any other file system either.