News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by newaccount74 on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:13AM (#30743281)
Bitcoin is the critical pillar that enabled the commoditization of the ransomware industry. It's a whole field that likely wouldn't exist if it wasn't for pseudonymous digital currencies.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by PaulHoule on Sunday March 20, 2022 @08:30AM (#30742105)
It’s a great way to separate gullible people from their money and that is always in demand.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by Bilal_io on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:08AM (#30743231)
OP asked about Blockchain, not Cryptocurrencies specifically. It's important to know the difference before shitting on Cryptocurrencies, which as a matter of fact provide a lot of value to many people around the world.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by hocuspocus on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:31AM (#30743472)
Blockchain technology itself is a great way to extract money from gullible people. I have friends who raised 8 digits from clueless VCs, to build solutions to problems that wouldn't exist without blockchains.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by knorker on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:55AM (#30743719)
Are there blockchain solutions that are not apparent scams?

NFTs are not cryptocurrencies, but I assume the parent comment was also calling them a scam? (well, they didn't use the word scam, but it looks implied)

There are also other "solutions" on top of blockchains, but I keep reading about them only from people who have a vested interest in getting more people to take part, in order to increase their own net worth. Which sounds like a pyramid scheme to me.

But to kinda contradict myself: Yes, there are blockchain things that are not pyramid schemes or other scams. But they also don't provide any other value. Whether they are scams or not depends on if you think the people pushing it actually believe in what they're saying.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by Naijoko on Sunday March 20, 2022 @12:17PM (#30743944)
NFT´s are more or less the same as cryptocurrency. Same stuff under the hood but different name and application ... but more or less exactly the same... otherwise of the name..and how they are sold

NFTs are storing links to pictures

Coins are storing the state of the ledger.

Exatly same technology

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by knorker on Monday March 21, 2022 @06:18AM (#30752297)
Yeah. A lot of them are cryptocurrencies if you squint.

NFTs are… well they added the concept of nonfungibility. It's interesting, albeit currently without useful applications.

But take "blockchain land registry". The blockchain will be a pointer to a physical house, or piece of land. In that way it's pretty much exactly NFTs, but I would not say they are exactly cryptocurrency.

So if cryptocurrency, NFT, and land registry are A B and C, then I would say that B and C "are the same", but A and C "are not", but A&B as you say sure are very similar.

Note that I'm not saying blockchain land registry makes any sense what so ever. Because it doesn't. A block chain will never decide who owns land, because courts and government does, backed by the power of the police.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by phyalow on Sunday March 20, 2022 @10:38AM (#30742971)
- Synthetic Stocks (that trade 24 hours a day)

- Decentralised Money Markets (including forward rate curves), biggest analogue to this is the emergence of a nascent eurodollar market in the 50's

- Trustless Borrowing and Lending

- Evasion of sanctions and capital controls (N.B. this is not necessarily negative)

- Allow decentralised autonomous organisations (D.A.O's) to manage treasury assets (e.g. are a key part of coordination)

- Allow me to self custody my wealth outside a traditional institution and outside of inflationary govt. backed currencies

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by RC_ITR on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:21AM (#30743344)
Synthetic stocks have arbitrage discounts/premiums that shouldn’t exist.

Decentralized markets often cause the liquidity provider to lost value from “impermanent loss”

The capital controls thing is a fairy tale. When was the last time someone accepted a ruble in exchange for any major crypto currency? If someone can but BTC with a dollar, why don’t they just evade the control with their dollars?

Major cryptos are all down 20%+ from their peak. That’s wild inflation.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by phyalow on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:52AM (#30743681)
>Synthetic stocks have arbitrage discounts/premiums that shouldn’t exist.

Why is this a bad thing? It only implies that there are information inefficiencies. A discount/premium represents a oppurtunity to capture it and make money, remind me again why this is a bad thing? ADR's/GDR's are a very similar thing (well actually inferior in some respects) in traditional finance and have a tremendous product market fit.

>Major cryptos are all down 20%+ from their peak. That’s wild inflation.

Uh, you and I must have a different definition of inflation. I dont think taking price delta is a useful thing. Conversely I could argue that if you moved the point of comparison back 18 months, the dollar has markedly declined vs. crypto (which is a fact), obviously this is cherry picking, hence why price discussions arent useful.

Capital controls are not a fairy tale for a large group (see: billions) of people. Crypto has found a use case in Venezuela, China, Turkey, Lebanon and Argentina amongst others. As a point of clarification you cant evade controls with dollars in financial systems that neccessitate holding said dollars in bank accounts, with the very same banks that are controlled by regulators who enforce those capital controls, frankly that is nonsensical. If you are implying bags of USD hidden under beds is suitable, then good luck with that.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by RC_ITR on Monday March 21, 2022 @05:32PM (#30759982)
>remind me again why this is a bad thing?

It's kind of wild to me that crypto has caused some people be to pro arbitrage. Arbitrage is the most inefficient form economic rent because it is a tax on producers of value (a group that largely gets ignored in the crypto-verse) that goes directly to speculators.

>Uh, you and I must have a different definition of inflation.

Yeah, my definition if inflation is a year over year comparison oh how much a basket of goods and services cost relative to a currency. What's yours?

>Crypto has found a use case in Venezuela, China, Turkey, Lebanon and Argentina amongst others.

Which currency and where are the transactions? Are Venezuelans buying BTC with bolivars? If so who is selling their BTC for Bolivars? Are they transacting day-to-day in a currency I'm not aware of?

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by phyalow on Monday March 21, 2022 @08:11PM (#30761391)
>>It's kind of wild to me that crypto has caused some people be to pro arbitrage. Arbitrage is the most inefficient form economic rent because it is a tax on producers of value (a group that largely gets ignored in the crypto-verse) that goes directly to speculators.

Arbitrage is a neutral activity, I dont see any universe where it could be seen to be a tax on producers of value (whatever that means), it is simply market participants correcting informational inefficiencies and providing liquidity.

>>Yeah, my definition if inflation is a year over year comparison oh how much a basket of goods and services cost relative to a currency. What's yours?

Reread my previous response to your reply on this point, on why this is not at all useful.

>>Which currency and where are the transactions? Are Venezuelans buying BTC with bolivars? If so who is selling their BTC for Bolivars? Are they transacting day-to-day in a currency I'm not aware of?

https://www.ft.com/content/02194361-a5b9-4bf0-9147-f36ba7759...

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by RC_ITR on Monday March 21, 2022 @09:34PM (#30761880)
>it is simply market participants correcting informational inefficiencies and providing liquidity.

You are describing the process of eliminating arbitrage. What synthetic stocks have is arbitrage. Is that distinction not clear to you?

>why this is not at all useful.

So a pizza slice cost 0.0002 BTC last year and now costs .0003 BTC and that's not meaningful to you? Just because someone said the word 'non-inflationary' doesn't mean Bitcoin is immune from the factors that cause inflation (supply and demand of a currency vs. supply and demand of goods and services - note that fixing currency supply is only 25% of that equation).

>the FT article

"While Turks have long chosen to protect themselves against lira volatility by keeping their savings in dollars or euros, data suggest that some of them are turning to “stablecoins”, which are pegged to hard currencies or other assets and act as a bridge between digital coins and national currencies."

So the use case of crypto is making it so Turks can hold USDC (bought with USD) instead of just holding USD? Cool.

EDIT: Just to be clear on my last point here, unless people are willing to sell their tokens for Lira, then Lira holders can't buy the tokens. If there is a large market of people willing to sell tokens for Lira, then the Lira can't be that bad of a currency or somebody is lying somewhere. Just because it's crypto doesn't mean you don't have to thinks about the two sides of the transaction - contrary to popular crypto belief, value isn't generated arbitrarily from the ether.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by inter_netuser on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:26AM (#30743390)
>Synthetic stocks have arbitrage discounts/premiums that shouldn’t exist.

So somebody is making mad money from arbitraging them?

>Decentralized markets often cause the liquidity provider to lost value from “impermanent loss”

Someone's loss is someone's gain.

>The capital controls thing is a fairy tale. When was the last time someone accepted a ruble in exchange for any major crypto currency? If someone can but BTC with a dollar, why don’t they just evade the control with their dollars?

Please try sending money from China to the outside and report back.

>Major cryptos are all down 20%+ from their peak. That’s wild inflation.

You can do other things with assets than "buy and pray".

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by RC_ITR on Monday March 21, 2022 @05:36PM (#30760021)
> So somebody is making mad money from arbitraging them?

Literally the opposite, b/c if they were, the arbitrage gaps would close! That's how arb. works!

>Someone's loss is someone's gain.

Sure, if your argument is that crypto's main use case is tricking retail into being fleeced by institutions, then I agree with you.

>Please try sending money from China to the outside and report back.

You mean the country that will send you to jail for 10 years for transacting in crypto?

>You can do other things with assets than "buy and pray"

Uhhh is this a currency or a security we are talking about?

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by Naijoko on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:58AM (#30743747)
>Please try sending money from China to the outside and report back.

Bank transfere works... or alipay .. or western union... I dont get the problem. But I get the money from chinese customer.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by phyalow on Sunday March 20, 2022 @12:15PM (#30743926)
Chinese individuals have a $50,000 USD annual limit on buying foreign exchange/or placing foreign wires. You can read up all about it on the State Administration for Foreign Exchange (SAFE) a.k.a. the Chinese capital control regulator's website e.g. https://www.safe.gov.cn/en/2017/1230/1391.html

Chinese corporations must too also observe strict limits on foreign exchange transfers (although the limits are a little higher).

Foreign investors in China have ongoing and substantial difficulty repatriating money/earnings and have previously had to rely on pools of capital known as "QFII" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qualified_Foreign_Institutiona... , things have improved somewhat in recent years, but it would only take a minor unexpected decline/appreciation in the CNYUSD or CNH/CNY spread for things to tighten back up.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by Naijoko on Sunday March 20, 2022 @12:20PM (#30743975)
ok thank you I didnt know that. I got regular money from china so I asumed it wasnt that difficult
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by AlchemistCamp on Sunday March 20, 2022 @01:32PM (#30744641)
When I left China, banks only let me convert 500 USD worth of RMB per day of my savings. This was money that I'd earned legally in China and already paid taxes on. I didn't realize this restriction until after I'd already bought plane tickets and was preparing to leave.

I literally could not get my money out in time.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by kikowi on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:28AM (#30743413)
I have been working with a few Russian and Belarusian software engineers on Upwork and I now pay them in cryptocurrencies, because Upwork (and other websites) banned their profiles and they can't receive my payments.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by jacknews on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:45AM (#30743623)
You're using it to evade sanctions?
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by IshKebab on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:59AM (#30743759)
Yeah the only real use for Bitcoin is to do illegal stuff. If what you're doing is legal than there are way easier methods.

There are occasional grey areas (e.g. Wikileaks donations) but that's the truth 99% of the time.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by kreetx on Tuesday March 22, 2022 @03:40PM (#30770508)
Many just invest ("hodl") in bitcoin, is that inside the 1%?
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by Brian_K_White on Sunday March 20, 2022 @12:01PM (#30743778)
It is an answer to the question, and for every sanction you consider valid, there is one you don't, and so the tool to get around them, and the act of getting around them, is not damning.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by jacknews on Sunday March 20, 2022 @12:37PM (#30744148)
I'm not questioning the tool, but this use of it.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by Brian_K_White on Sunday March 20, 2022 @01:33PM (#30744660)
And I'm saying there is nothing automatically damning about either the tool or it's use or it's use for that purpose.

I guess I have to spell it out: It obviously depends on the sanction, who is declaring it against who, and why, and even on a variety of individual details case by case.

If you would question helping Russia, instead of generally "getting around sanctions", that would be more valid, but really even that is too simplistic.

You don't have to actually have a family member in Russia yourself to imagine that there are probably countless circumstances where you would not criticize someone for getting around any policy.

Or maybe your particular ethics says that you still couldn't even help a family member because ultimately it would come at the cost of some Ukraninian family that you can't justify helping to kill. That would be a defensible stance and I wouldn't call you a bad person for it, but it's not the only valid ethical stance, and you likewise don't have much right to criticise anyone else for deciding that they have their reaons for getting around a sanction.

The short answer to your question was really just "Yes." with no apology or defense needed.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by jacknews on Sunday March 20, 2022 @07:39PM (#30747999)
You don't have to spell anything, it's quite clear you mean 'government is an ass, it's rules are not for me, and crypto gives the me the tool I need to ignore them'.

In some cases, you might even be right.

There are doubtless some valid reasons to 'work around' these particular sanctions, but IMHO paying your Russian devs to keep developing your website or whatever, which appears to be the case here, is perhaps not one of them.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by yucky on Sunday March 20, 2022 @03:57PM (#30746040)
Yes, much like the Underground Railroad was a tool used to get around property laws that the government used to enforce turning slaves back into their owners.

Governments have a long history of doing the wrong things, and trying to starve the populations of countries acting against our interests, is one of many examples. If Bitcoin can be used to help feed the innocent, you've actually turned me into a crypto-convert.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by yucky on Sunday March 20, 2022 @04:00PM (#30746066)
Sanctions is a fancy word for "starving the innocent women and children who live in countries not aligned with our interests".

You want to take out Putin, take him out. Don't try to harm innocent people just because they had the misfortune of being born in a country that we no longer find economically useful.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by jacknews on Sunday March 20, 2022 @08:00PM (#30748178)
People need to choose their own governments (sometimes force may be required), and not let foreign powers, however seemingly well-meaning, install them, depose them, etc.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by jacknews on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:29AM (#30743438)
Lots of people are using it, so yes it has a use, and while people keep using it (even if it's not the best way to achieve their goal), it will continue to have a use, and the skeptics (I number myself as one) should just get used to it.

One definite potential use-case is FX settlement, which currently goes through an obscure (and expensive) bank-owned coop-type institution (CLS bank). I think other inter-bank and central bank uses might also make sense.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by mirceal on Sunday March 20, 2022 @10:53AM (#30743103)
- accepting payments when visa/mastercard/your bank decide your business is not allowed to exist anymore - sending money anywhere in the world in minutes for minimal fees - keeping your privacy when you’re paying online
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by multjoy on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:21AM (#30743347)
Blockchain isn't private. It is anonymous, but the whole point is that it isn't private.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by MattPalmer1086 on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:33AM (#30743495)
It's not even anonymous, it's pseudonymous.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by mirceal on Friday March 25, 2022 @03:31PM (#30806207)
can someone prevent you from transacting on the blockchain if they don't like your face? how exactly do they know who you are? (i get it's not private as in untraceable but it's way better than the centralized system we have now)
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by rvz on Sunday March 20, 2022 @09:03AM (#30742284)
So something like ENS [0] is not a use-case? Here's a product that is using it: [1][2]

[0] https://ens.domains/

[1] https://www.skiff.org/

[2] https://www.skiff.org/updates/skiff-ens

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by biztos on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:47AM (#30743646)
Off-topic a bit, but I actually registered a name on ENS recently and now I can’t stop thinking how weird it is that the registrations are time limited, considering “blockchain” and all that.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by DennisP on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:54AM (#30743714)
ENS was purposely designed that way. A smart contract can implement whatever rules you like.

It doesn't seem like a great idea to me for name registrations to be perpetual, but a name service on Ethereum could certainly work that way.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by biztos on Sunday March 20, 2022 @10:38PM (#30749483)
Yes, I assumed it was not done by mistake.

The funny thing (to me anyway) is that a big part of the culture seems to be how absolute "ownership" is -- at least around NFTs -- and how this is decentralized, but with ENS it's a rental just like a .COM (but with something like 1000% processing fees) and it's more centralized than DNS.

I wanted to try out the .ETH name and I'm fine with them doing whatever they want with the contract, I just find it amusing.

Unstoppable seems a lot closer to the overall ethos: https://unstoppabledomains.com

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by gumby on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:30AM (#30743455)
I have never seen a defi example that didn’t ignore Coase.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by perardi on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:27AM (#30743409)
Frankly, it’s kind of hard to pitch blockchain if you’re at all honest with your stakeholders.

“So, we want to recreate databases, except vastly slower, far less energy-efficient, and way harder to use.”

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by indigochill on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:34AM (#30743511)
Now, I am a blockchain skeptic, but this is only half the story. Some unique traits of blockchains:

1. They're immutable (this is as I understand even unique as compared to git, which also uses Merkle trees)

2. They use distributed replicas (as opposed to distributed partitions).

3. Maybe some other stuff that's slipping my mind at the moment.

The multi-billion dollar question is in which use cases those traits are actually useful. So far we're progressively ruling things out as we watch distributed blockchain products simply gravitate back towards centralization.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by Naijoko on Sunday March 20, 2022 @12:07PM (#30743838)
>1. They're immutable (this is as I understand even unique as compared to git, which also uses Merkle trees)

Blockchain is not Bitcoin or crypto somehow. Crypto is blockchain + proof of work and some p2p. Blockchain is more or less the fancy word for immutable merkle tree. The idea to have a tree or chain of hashes based ond the previus one existed before bitcoin. And proof of work existed also before. It was used to prevent spam in emails. But didnt have sucess.

The glorius idea of nakamoto was to put it all together.. it was a good idea and worth a try but now we know its mostly worthless unsless you are a criminal or some fringe use case that shouldnt exist in Democratic and humanistic conditions

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by thagerty on Sunday March 20, 2022 @07:45AM (#30741858)
Don't kid yourself. Anything the feds think is important enough to start regulating should be taken seriously.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by tonetheman on Sunday March 20, 2022 @08:08AM (#30741982)
translation: NOPE
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by mescaline on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:23AM (#30743368)
Authentication and payment for online content (micro-payments), or services which process information (such as AI based summarization of content).

Put an NGINX proxy in front of content or an API and then wire it up to Lightning. Requests can be done without site authentication and the site still gets paid for the content or service.

This would finally implement 402s: https://www.w3.org/Protocols/rfc2616/rfc2616-sec10.html#sec1...

418 I'm a teapot

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by conorcleary on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:29AM (#30743432)
Oh, get your head out of the sand. It doesn't take much searching online to find many valid use cases for the basics of blockchain verification.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by biztos on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:42AM (#30743595)
I haven’t actually shipped anything but I’m working on a couple blockchain related artworks, and I occasionally talk to other artists who are active in the art part of the NFT world, as opposed to the “financial instrument dressed as a monkey” part.

Two things seem to be an emerging, er, consensus:

1. Having the blockchain part (the NFT for instance) actually have some real relationship to the art is much more interesting than just having pointers to artworks that are fine without it.

2. The exciting thing is that people can go and do what they like with the NFTs (etc) without your permission. This applies to non-art too I think: nothing is stopping you from making Mutant Ape Yacht Mashup.

So, I contend that “decentralized user interaction with artworks via a system the artist doesn’t control” is a use for blockchain, though I admit it’s a pretty fringe one.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by hash872 on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:21AM (#30743345)
As a longtime crypto & blockchain skeptic- I have to be fair and note that, according to this FT article, HSBC and Wells Fargo are using (non-crypto) blockchain specifically to settle currency trades. And this is apparently past the testing or experimentation stage, this is live implementation.

I don't really understand how it works (if you have a fat finger error, is it reversible?) or why it's better than a simple relational database, but apparently this is a use case

https://www.ft.com/content/1a4dcaf5-2b4b-4f0b-8c58-a8fa173f2... https://archive.is/qs8Cg (archive.is link to bypass the paywall)

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by AlchemistCamp on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:02AM (#30743176)
A century ago when people were fleeing war zones or religious hatred, the difficulty of the rest of their life often depended upon whether or not they had any gold (which was often confiscated) or a Swiss bank account.

In a similar situation today, a mnemonic phrase for a crypto account serves a similar purpose.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by pimlottc on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:20AM (#30743337)
That sounds good, is there evidence this is actually happening?
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by inter_netuser on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:26AM (#30743394)
ukraine?
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by pimlottc on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:36AM (#30743527)
Are they using bitcoin substantially?
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by xeromal on Sunday March 20, 2022 @01:46PM (#30744822)
I saw an article in passing that Ukraine was offering 500,000USD in crypto for every soldier that surrendered with a jet or tank, but my memory fails me.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by inter_netuser on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:43AM (#30743604)
idk, it recieved 100 mil in relief funds, raised in like two weeks from regular avg people, from around the world?

is that substantial? Seems rather unprecedented.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by timeon on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:21AM (#30743343)
I wonder if most people fleeing Ukraine now do actually use crypto.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by hocuspocus on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:27AM (#30743405)
Why would they? It's Russia that is under sanctions and where banks are limiting currency exchange.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by AlchemistCamp on Sunday March 20, 2022 @01:24PM (#30744559)
The Ukrainian government has certainly made moves to make that easier. This is from 5 days ago: https://twitter.com/mintsyfra/status/1504112103954735112

Translation:

> Ukraine has legalized the cryptosector - @ZelenskyyUa profile Law.

> Now foreign and Ukrainian cryptocurrencies will operate legally in Ukraine and banks will open accounts for crypto companies. This is another important step towards the development of the virtual assets market in Ukraine.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by Naijoko on Sunday March 20, 2022 @12:03PM (#30743798)
Why should they use crypto? Dont they have credit cards. The Value of the currency didnt drop and the Banks will hopefully be backed by the EU or somesorts. Their money is still good.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by AlchemistCamp on Sunday March 20, 2022 @01:38PM (#30744729)
You can't blame people for doubting their ability to make withdrawals from a bank that may be reduced to rubble before they've found their next home.

Some also may not feel as comfortable as you do about gambling their entire future on the generosity of "the EU or somesorts". The generosity is real, but having some

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by EverywhereTrip on Sunday March 20, 2022 @04:25PM (#30746263)
PodPing is a podcasting notification system that replaces constantly polling individual RSS feeds. It is based on the Hive blockchain.

You can see podcasts updated in real time at https://podping.watch/

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by ArtTimeInvestor on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:26AM (#30743392)
Orbis is a decentralized alternative to Twitter:

https://orbis.club/

All data is stored on blockchains, so in contrast to the old social networks, your post history, likes and comments can not be taken away from you.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by indigochill on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:28AM (#30743419)
Mastodon proved years ago that you don't need a blockchain to decentralize Twitter (which I don't mean as a dis on Orbis, but merely a rebuttal to the suggestion that a blockchain is necessary for this use case).
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by ArtTimeInvestor on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:30AM (#30743440)
Is Mastodon really decentralized? If you use YourName@SomeMastodonSite and SomeMastodonSite deplatforms you - how do you keep your posts, likes, comments and contacts?
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by indigochill on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:49AM (#30743656)
> Is Mastodon really decentralized?

Yes. There is no central Mastodon server. Anyone can run a host and federate with other hosts at will.

> If you use YourName@SomeMastodonSite and SomeMastodonSite deplatforms you - how do you keep your posts, likes, comments and contacts?

The Mastodon interface makes it easy to export/import your information so that you can copy it over to a new host - if you worry you might get deplatformed and get cut off without warning, you can do a periodic local backup to be safe: https://docs.joinmastodon.org/user/moving/

The export includes your posts, but that document does say "Mastodon currently does not support importing toots or media due to technical limitations, but your archive can be viewed by any software that understands how to parse ActivityPub documents." I'd be curious what those technical limitations are. Presumably you could write a script to re-post the archived posts since it's just stored in ActivityPub JSON.

Edit to add: The most sure-fire way to avoid deplatforming is to run or pay for your own host. Other hosts may decide not to federate with you, but you'll at least be guaranteed a platform for those who do decide to engage with it.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by ArtTimeInvestor on Sunday March 20, 2022 @12:15PM (#30743923)
Export/import does not let you "keep" posts, comments, likes and contacts. Everybody can copy everything. When SomeMastodonSite no longer states that you posted something at a certain date, user2 liked it on a certain date and user3 commented on it on a certain date, all that info is lost. Just copying it does not help. Everyone could copy anything and claim it is "real". You also lose your identity when you get deplatformed from SomeMastodonSite.

That is the benefit of decentralized solutions. Your identity and history can not be deleted or changed by a single actor.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by indigochill on Sunday March 20, 2022 @01:16PM (#30744489)
A fair point regarding exporting/importing, though again, self-hosting is the real answer if you're concerned about deplatforming in that context.

> That is the benefit of decentralized solutions. Your identity and history can not be deleted or changed by a single actor.

Yes, in consensus systems, but how much this is a benefit is an open question. Perhaps you find yourself in a situation where you actually do want to modify/delete your identity and/or history (cleaning up a drunk post, for instance?) and now it's technically impossible. In this case, having it stored somewhere mutable by a trusted host gives you the ability to make that change. On the other hand, maybe (the rhetorical) you are okay with these being immutable because it's more honest about what really happened and doesn't let people artificially clean up after themselves. I think an argument could be made for both approaches depending on what someone wants from their decentralized Twitter clone.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by ArtTimeInvestor on Sunday March 20, 2022 @02:02PM (#30744988)
Is self-hosting really a solution? On a self-hosted instance, how do you prove to people that you are displaying the truth? That you really wrote that great prediction last year and not yesterday? That some popular person liked your post? That your post got 10000 likes and not just 3? That it really was Paul Graham who commented on it?

And if you lose your domain, you lose your identity. There are horror stories out there, where businesses are destroyed because incompetent registrars gave the domain away. Again, you would need a decentralized solution like ENS to prevent that.

There are decentralized solutions which allow the author of a piece of data to update or delete it. It is just a matter of incentives. When the protocol has a way for the author to update or delete content, that just means storing the old version of the content is not incentivised anymore.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by mariusor on Sunday March 20, 2022 @05:20PM (#30746761)
> On a self-hosted instance, how do you prove to people [...]

Generally the ActivityPub protocol disseminates a user's actions to a number of other users. On Mastodon specifically all users mentioned in a post will receive copies. Activities generated by users on other servers can be double checked against their own servers for validity, I think there's very few things that you can game when you're running your own instance without people being able to verify based on what these other instances have received.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by azeirah on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:29AM (#30743433)
Mastodon provides immutability? Huh
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by indigochill on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:36AM (#30743524)
Twitter isn't immutable.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by rvz on Sunday March 20, 2022 @04:11PM (#30746155)
Generally, this is the limit on where using 'blockchains' doesn't make sense here.

Especially for a social network where everything is immutable and you cannot edit or even truly 'delete' anything and it is all public. Thus opens the gate to abuse. [0] Even if you try to 'hide' it, it is still on the public blockchain permanently and forever.

[0] https://blog.mollywhite.net/abuse-on-the-blockchain-lecture/

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by netfortius on Sunday March 20, 2022 @06:00PM (#30747123)
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by slibhb on Sunday March 20, 2022 @12:04PM (#30743800)
Sending money overseas (remittances). Companies that offer this service take a cut, most of which can be avoided with a blockchain currency (buy blockchain currency, send it to someone else, they sell it for fiat).
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by recvonline on Sunday March 20, 2022 @08:37AM (#30742149)
Why do people still think Blockchain has to be a consumer product?

“Nobody has come up with a use case”.

How about DeFi? I think that’s a pretty big use case! Besides, who cares? Either use it (DeFi, donations, salary etc) or don’t.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by doopy1 on Sunday March 20, 2022 @10:43AM (#30743007)
Lot's of people shit on NFTs, but they are certainly a use case.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by Naijoko on Sunday March 20, 2022 @12:24PM (#30744022)
you are aware that a NFT is only a stored link to a picture on a server? Why would that have any use ever?
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by doopy1 on Sunday March 20, 2022 @12:28PM (#30744059)
They are except when they're not. Plenty of NFTs are on-chain. Also, if nothing else, they've provided a lot of creatives an opportunity to get compensated for their work. The "art" NFT eco-system is very much akin to a patreon of sorts. I don't see how that's a bad thing.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by Naijoko on Sunday March 20, 2022 @12:48PM (#30744245)
ok didnt know that. But honstly I blindly asume that the capacity/cost ratio is still way higher compared to a non Blockchain system with same conditions. Thats generaly the problem. There are many solutions for a problem but there isnt a problem where blockchain and crypto are the best solution. They are mostly on the worse side of solutions....
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by SteveNuts on Sunday March 20, 2022 @12:05PM (#30743813)
But how?
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by Naijoko on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:59AM (#30743764)
Buying drugs online is one of the first use cases and one with the longest use.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by pcthrowaway on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:43AM (#30743606)
People here seem to like IPFS
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by tim333 on Sunday March 20, 2022 @12:35PM (#30744134)
IPFS doesn't really use a blockchain. It's more like bittorrent which predates the bitcoin blockchain.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by newacc9 on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:32AM (#30743481)
Find a true Scotsman, they'll give you a valid answer
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by ashwagary on Sunday March 20, 2022 @09:44AM (#30742540)
Decentralized exchanges with no counterparty risk that require no user info.

Most people coming from the traditional finance world understand the value of this.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by jqpabc123 on Sunday March 20, 2022 @09:58AM (#30742628)
Decentralized exchanges with no oversight or accountability and the ability to "mint" an endless supply of their own crypto and influence it's price.

Most people coming from the traditional finance world understand the de-value in this.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by phyalow on Sunday March 20, 2022 @10:52AM (#30743089)
Uh, no.

If you are sophisticated (or even just have a functioning brain instead of a void between your ears) you can easily:

1) Avoid assets that are inflationary, by conducting your own due diligance, or even better inspect the code of the smart contract to determine if minting is even possible.

2) No oversight is a feature not a bug. Nobody forces you to trade, but knowing the rules of the game are unalterable is ultimately the best arbiter of active capital allocation decisions. Did you follow the story of the LME and Nickel futures over the last fortnight? That market is now bust and the LME's reputation is (rightly) in tatters.

3) Having worked as a trader at a blue chip investment bank and then at a hedge fund for many years I am almost positive despite the present clunkiness and inefficency of some AMM based DeFi exchanges, this model is the future of exchange. CLOB's are manipulated just as much (if not more) than DeFi/CEX OB's.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by jqpabc123 on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:20AM (#30743339)
If you are sophisticated (or even just have a functioning brain instead of a void between your ears) you can easily see that the largest exchange is minting it's own crypto. And amazingly, it remains pegged regardless of how much they mint.

This is being used in more than half of all crypto trades and can easily be used to influence crypto prices across the board.

There is really nothing "free" about a market where the market makers are also active players with an unlimited supply of funds. And without a "free market", most everything else is irrelevant.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by phyalow on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:34AM (#30743502)
I lost you when you jumped from talking about decentralized exchanges "minting" to centralized exchanges and pretended they were the same thing.

For your info an example of a decentralized exchange is "Uniswap" which operates onchain and does not (in most circumstances) custody your assets or even have humans in the loop. A centralised exchange is Binance, which largely operates fully off chain and custodies your assets.

Lastly I dont think anyone is pretending the space is not without risks - its a "caveat emptor" environment in its purest form. USDT isnt the only game in town by a mile & congruently Jump/Jane Street/Hudson River/other U.S. regulated actors have no problem acting as a credit counterparty with USDT so due diligence must check out to some degree of satisfaction (indeed I hold my own reservations).

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by jqpabc123 on Sunday March 20, 2022 @01:29PM (#30744617)
I lost you when you jumped from talking about decentralized exchanges "minting" to centralized exchanges and pretended they were the same thing.

Decentralized exchanges simply follow the centralized exchange market. It is the only available, practical way for anyone to set prices.

What the centralized exchanges do affects the entire market by sheer force of their trading volume.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by pcthrowaway on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:43AM (#30743597)
If you're talking about Tether/USDT (which is a massive fraud by all appearances), that isn't an exchange.

Decentralized exchanges can't just mint more tokens, unless they deployed the token for that contract with an allowance for them to mint it.

AKA, the largest decentralized exchange, Uniswap, does have a Uniswap token. But they can't just mint it whenever/however they want, the contract (which anyone can audit) doesn't allow it

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by inter_netuser on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:38AM (#30743547)
what exchange is minting its own crypto? can you describe the scenario in more detail?
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by ashwagary on Sunday March 20, 2022 @05:00PM (#30746575)
I think the minting tangent is a silly one. The underlying tech can be used to trade shares in public companies (TSLA, AAPL, NVDA, etc) in the future as an example if you wish.

What is being traded is less interesting than the fact that it can be traded 24/7, cheaply, globally, transparently, pseudoanonymously, settle instantly, and with no counterparty risk.

Nothing like this has ever been achieved in human history, any other observations are a distraction.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by Brian_K_White on Sunday March 20, 2022 @01:11PM (#30744452)
As long as we're speaking for most people... most people coming from any world understand that's a problem in the same way that any useful tool is.

Saws are not useful because they can cut your hand off? Fire is not useful because it can burn your house down?

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by jqpabc123 on Sunday March 20, 2022 @01:33PM (#30744658)
Most people understand that without regulation, any market quickly degenerates into fraud and extortion.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by Brian_K_White on Sunday March 20, 2022 @01:47PM (#30744834)
The question was about an information handling tool, not a market.

But as to markets, for every valid critique you can present against decentralized and/or anonymous markets, there is an equally valid critique to be made against centralized & controlled markets.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by iszomer on Sunday March 20, 2022 @10:26AM (#30742860)
Especially for those whom don't understand borders and their implications.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by Naijoko on Sunday March 20, 2022 @12:37PM (#30744151)
here I quote from wikipedia

>>A hash chain is similar to a blockchain, as they both utilize a cryptographic hash function for creating a link between two nodes. However, a blockchain (as used by Bitcoin and related systems) is generally intended to support distributed consensus around a public ledger (data), and incorporates a set of rules for encapsulation of data and associated data permissions.

So a Blockchain is only a configuration of a hashchain. So we have to make clear that blockchain is only a fancy name and nothing realy special. There are a shitload of different setups of hashchains and they mostly have no fancy name, as far as I know. Everyone with the skill can make whatever with hashchains and call it whatever.. Trianglechain.... NextgenQuantumsuperchain...ChainChain... whatever... So if the basic question is, do hashchains have real use cases? Most certainly. But I am to lazy to google.

Or does the configuration of a hashchain called blockhcain does have a real use. Atm Crypto but as far as I know some banks and supply chains and IBM tried to find problems for blockchains, but failed. Even if highly controverse, the german goverment wants to put things like the passport, diplomas and drivers licence on the blockchain. I think somehow IBM is involved. But is more or less that they want to try to sell that shit. But its not p2p whatever, only a Databank that is a blockchain.. at the end it will be a better database. Maybe a hashchain. Btw it did allready fail for the vaccines passport. They wanted to but that into 5 blockchains. At the end it was a central database, maybe a merkle tree or similar.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hash_chain

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by darkteflon on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:25AM (#30743377)
Ukraine has received between USD50-100m in crypto donations since the start of the war and there isn’t a damn thing Putin can do about it.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by hocuspocus on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:33AM (#30743493)
What can Putin do about donations in USD, EUR, UAH, ... ?
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by darkteflon on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:43AM (#30743599)
Depends what happens next, doesn’t it.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone come up with a use for blockchain yet? by hocuspocus on Sunday March 20, 2022 @01:18PM (#30744501)
I mean yes, Putin can nuke the Fed and the ECB, but I'm not sure how Bitcoin would help in this case.

Or Putin could try to seize the Ukrainian national bank, but unless Russia can annex the entire country, that's a bit futile.

There are many ways to send money to Ukraine and Ukrainians and Bitcoin seems like the least practical one, on both ends.