News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Accused of cheating, marathon runner Frank Meza's life fe... by Reubend on Thursday March 10, 2022 @01:15AM (#30623724)
It's terrible that people were harassing this man, and that those communities formed a mob mentality against him. But I don't feel particularly sorry for him; he cheated, denied it, threatened to sue people, and then eventually took his own life after his reputation was ruined.

Perhaps if he had stopped competing after the first blog post exposing him, things would have de-escalated. Instead, he doubled down on his lies, and made things worse for himself.

Re:Accused of cheating, marathon runner Frank Meza's life fe... by probably_wrong on Thursday March 10, 2022 @02:20AM (#30624020)
I do feel sorry for him, and I think you are being too forgiving to the trolls here.

This was not a mere "ruined reputation", but rather a persistent, coordinated mobbing assault big enough that not even a professional PR firm could do anything.

Did he cheat? Likely yes. Did he deserve being banned from marathons? Sounds like it. But did he deserve "the pressure, attention, emailing, even trolling" that he got? No, he did not.

If I were in his position, I would have also tried to sue.

Re:Accused of cheating, marathon runner Frank Meza's life fe... by krisoft on Thursday March 10, 2022 @06:08AM (#30625607)
> But did he deserve "the pressure, attention, emailing, even trolling" that he got?

What made his conduct outrageous is how he was clinging to his side. He could have just said: “yup, you got me. I had a rough day and made a bad decision.” They would have disqualified his result, maybe banned him in the future races and nothing more would have come from it.

You can’t keep maintaining the unmaintainable and expect people to loose interest. He liked the prestige while he was on the good side of it, and when he turned out to be a cheater he wanted suddenly none of the attention.

You said that a professional PR firm couldn’t help him. Sure enough, turns out it is very hard to rebuild a house while it is actively burning and the owner is pouring more gasoline on it every so often.

Re:Accused of cheating, marathon runner Frank Meza's life fe... by throwaway6734 on Thursday March 10, 2022 @06:52AM (#30625900)
People that break the social contract and then try to gaslight the rest of society when discovered instead of admitting their actions are some of the lowest kinds of people.

They corrode social trust.

I have no sympathy for this person, they're a snake.

Re:Accused of cheating, marathon runner Frank Meza's life fe... by simonh on Thursday March 10, 2022 @07:12AM (#30626035)
People are more complicated than that. It sounds like he was an incredibly generous and loving person, there were queues of people saying how much he had helped them.

That in no way justifies what he did, at all, but it's not the case that he was an unremitting lowlife. It's a real conundrum, that otherwise wonderful people can sometimes do terrible things.

Re:Accused of cheating, marathon runner Frank Meza's life fe... by RickJWagner on Thursday March 10, 2022 @08:22PM (#30635022)
You're right.

In related news, Jussie Smollett was sentenced to jail today for faking a race/sex orientation hate crime. (He also claimed the imaginary attackers were politically motivated.)

Many expected him to escape jail time, but he did not. The judge cited Smollett's refusal to accept responsibility (and the resulting harm to society) in making the decision to mandate jail time.

Re:Accused of cheating, marathon runner Frank Meza's life fe... by Fricken on Thursday March 10, 2022 @06:58AM (#30625939)
I agree with your premise, but there are so many bigger fish to fry than some rando who cheated on a marathon.
Re:Accused of cheating, marathon runner Frank Meza's life fe... by ungamed on Thursday March 10, 2022 @07:02AM (#30625962)
Where do you draw the line for the fish ?
Re:Accused of cheating, marathon runner Frank Meza's life fe... by smcl on Thursday March 10, 2022 @07:59AM (#30626398)
Presumably some point before harassing a man to the point where he commits suicide. I don't think anyone has ever answered "where do you draw the line?" the the satisfaction of anyone who has asked the question. It is unanswerable.
Re:Accused of cheating, marathon runner Frank Meza's life fe... by pc86 on Thursday March 10, 2022 @10:16AM (#30627822)
> I don't think anyone has ever answered "where do you draw the line?" the the satisfaction of anyone who has asked the question.

Absolutely. It's a lazy, disingenuous way to just try to shut down discussion.

Re:Accused of cheating, marathon runner Frank Meza's life fe... by ungamed on Friday March 11, 2022 @09:44AM (#30640501)
Ah cool, so we're not drawing lines.

If you really practice this in life, you're going to be taken advantage of.

You're right, discussing it is just stupid. My mistake.

Re:Accused of cheating, marathon runner Frank Meza's life fe... by rightbyte on Thursday March 10, 2022 @07:58AM (#30626394)
Well away from games for my part atleast.
Re:Accused of cheating, marathon runner Frank Meza's life fe... by trhway on Thursday March 10, 2022 @09:16AM (#30627114)
>But did he deserve "the pressure, attention, emailing, even trolling" that he got? No, he did not.

cheating like this denies other participants fruits of their hard labor of many years, just flushes all their effort down the drain. Compare that to just having "the pressure, attention, emailing, even trolling".

Re:Accused of cheating, marathon runner Frank Meza's life fe... by isitmadeofglass on Friday March 11, 2022 @08:34AM (#30639643)
> big enough that not even a professional PR firm could do anything.

What an odd take. Just because throwing money at something doesn’t make it go away does not mean it’s a “big attack” or even that people calling him out are in any way in the wrong. As OP stated the big problem seems to be that he persistently tried to regain his old good reputation instead of accepting defeat. When a cheater wants to continue cheating, it doesn’t matter how much money he throws at PR firms, it’s still fair to call out his cheating.

Re:Accused of cheating, marathon runner Frank Meza's life fe... by asojfdowgh on Thursday March 10, 2022 @05:24AM (#30625285)
trolls can't stay there for long

"Journalists" being paid to get every last bit of scrap on a person, sometimes even going through people's rubbish, breaking laws that protect citizens too, are far more nasty

Re:Accused of cheating, marathon runner Frank Meza's life fe... by ben_w on Thursday March 10, 2022 @05:56AM (#30625525)
Some people can and do make vigilanteism into their identity. I know two cases where people have had their employment affected in some way as result of one or more vigilantes trying to punish or blackmail them respectively.

If you want to call that trolling, I guess you could. The word has changed a lot since I first encountered it over two decades ago.

Re:Accused of cheating, marathon runner Frank Meza's life fe... by ceejayoz on Thursday March 10, 2022 @07:22AM (#30626112)
> trolls can't stay there for long

Trolls can keep it up forever. It’s a labor of love for them, a hobby. I know folks who’ve had multi-year trolls and at least one that escalated to in-person stalking.

Re:Accused of cheating, marathon runner Frank Meza's life fe... by bo1024 on Thursday March 10, 2022 @02:10AM (#30623955)
By all accounts (including a friend of mine) he was a wonderful person, mentor, coach, etc. back in the day. It sounds like maybe he developed some mental issues that eventually led to both the cheating and suicide.
Re:Accused of cheating, marathon runner Frank Meza's life fe... by rectang on Thursday March 10, 2022 @06:09AM (#30625623)
There are lots of cheaters (and worse) out there with "wonderful" reputations.

I feel sorry for Meza — even when self-inflicted, pain is pain — but I'm glad he didn't get away with it. I wish that our world did not reward cheating so regularly and handsomely, and I wish Meza had not chosen to cheat.

Re:Accused of cheating, marathon runner Frank Meza's life fe... by dfxm12 on Thursday March 10, 2022 @08:47AM (#30626808)
Instead, he doubled down on his lies, and made things worse for himself.

I don't know how anyone who has lived through the baseball PED scandal thinks doubling down helps. Bonds & Clemens fought tooth and nail against allegations. They'll never get into the hall of fame. Compare this to someone like David Ortiz, who got voted into Cooperstown this year. Ortiz didn't even really apologize. He just didn't double down.

I feel like this happens with other celebrity scandals, too, where the people who don't publicly argue stuff like this seem to have their public image less tarnished, if at all.

Re:Accused of cheating, marathon runner Frank Meza's life fe... by antihero on Thursday March 10, 2022 @07:49AM (#30626315)
If anything from reading this article it feels like the running and marathon communities are hugely self-righteous and have a colossally overblown sense of self-importance.

It's just a fucking race mate, this man teaches people and heals people - if you run a marathon, it should be about your own sense of achievement, why care so much about what some other person has done?

Re:Accused of cheating, marathon runner Frank Meza's life fe... by peteradio on Thursday March 10, 2022 @09:15AM (#30627100)
This isn't some guy who is faking his way into the middle of the pack, he was accepting record times. How can a community maintain fraudulent high water marks?
Re:Accused of cheating, marathon runner Frank Meza's life fe... by greedo on Thursday March 10, 2022 @09:25AM (#30627220)
That's why I never got much into my finishing position in a race. All I cared about was running a PB if possible. I knew that no matter how hard I trained, how well I built up to a healthy diet, that someone out there was better than me. Or trained harder, had a better pair of shoes, or better coaching. Or had a rabbit to help them stay on pace.

But people have an unhealthy competitive urge. I saw the same thing when I played basketball. Pickup games where people took things way too seriously, like the outcome of the game meant they'd get a call from an NBA scout, when most of the players were juco level at most.

Re:Accused of cheating, marathon runner Frank Meza's life fe... by trhway on Thursday March 10, 2022 @02:11PM (#30631098)
>this man teaches people and heals people

with his systematic cheating and refusal to accept the reality and take the responsibility magically confined only to marathons ... The guy was an executive and moral integrity isn't that execs are known for. Cheating, outright denying of proven facts, legal threats and hiring PR company - that is a typical exec behavior, and public/community campaign is frequently the only way to stop them.

Re:Accused of cheating, marathon runner Frank Meza's life fe... by Werewolf255 on Thursday March 10, 2022 @08:38AM (#30626733)
This is my big takeaway. I think running and biking can be really fun, but I've lost friends into the morass that is LetsRun. It almost always boils down to 'That person did something I think they can't do, they must be cheating, whose with me?' levels of mob justice... in the running community, no less???? It's enough to make you think that it's the sport itself that breeds the toxicity.
Re:Accused of cheating, marathon runner Frank Meza's life fe... by dspillett on Thursday March 10, 2022 @10:28AM (#30627956)
> If anything from reading this article it feels like the running and marathon communities are hugely self-righteous and have a colossally overblown sense of self-importance

In general that is far from the truth. Running communities tend to be very helpful and welcoming groups in my experience. Yes, there are a few alpha-cock types out there and one or two online forums where they manage to dominate (mainly because they leave other groups where being an arse is actively unappreciated), but that sort of prick appears in all walks of life and running seems to have fewer than its fair share.

A lot of the noise that you do hear comes from outside the running groups sometimes. For instance most people making jokes belittling joggers compared to runners neither run nor jog, they just like taking the mick out of a recognisable target. It is like the people who hardly ever leave their couch unless they need to go get another beer going on about how Cantona should have taken a particular shot differently (yeah, my football knowledge is that up-to-date!).

> if you run a marathon, it should be about your own sense of achievement

I would agree there. Though if there are awards for best-in-class or otherwise they should go to the people who genuinely earn them.

> why care so much about what some other person has done?

People don't generally like a cheat in any area, If someone else missed out on a best-in-class or other result because of a cheater they are perfectly justified in being irritated and many will be irritating on their behalf.

The man didn't deserve bullying by an online mob, he needed mental help not harassment and the ban from other events should be sufficient counter action, but that doesn't mean we should dismiss cheating as a victimless action that we shouldn't care about because it doesn't directly affect us.

Re:Accused of cheating, marathon runner Frank Meza's life fe... by emptyfile on Thursday March 10, 2022 @04:18AM (#30624904)
Right. People have had their lives and reputations blown up for all sorts of reasons, meanwhile this guy cheated to run

>the fastest marathon ever recorded for someone in his age group of 70 to 74

A bit ridiculous then to say people were attacking him for no reason, or his daughter not understanding why anyone cared. Dude was literally claiming to be the world marathon champion in his age group while cheating for years.

Re:Accused of cheating, marathon runner Frank Meza's life fe... by makomk on Thursday March 10, 2022 @05:11AM (#30625214)
I'm pretty sure only online cheating detectives pay much attention to unusually low marathon times for older age groups in amateur events, especially if the person doesn't actively seek to promote themself - not because there's a lot of people skipping the course, but because it tends to be dominated by younger people illicitly using their older relatives' race numbers after the original runner had to drop out (events tend to restrict refunds and transfers).
Re:Accused of cheating, marathon runner Frank Meza's life fe... by dspillett on Thursday March 10, 2022 @10:01AM (#30627635)
> because it tends to be dominated by younger people illicitly using their older relatives' race numbers

I can't say I've seen evidence of that being a massive problem specifically, though people running under other people's names is an issue more generally.

> (events tend to restrict refunds and transfers)

That isn't just to be difficult. It can affect their insurance, there can be genuine health & safety concerns, and is often enforced by running bodies that the events associate with. Not implementing such restrictions could mean the difference between an event being able to run or not.

Transfers are also an admin faf for the organisers, even ignoring that.

> I'm pretty sure only online cheating detectives pay much attention

I would suggest that this story is a reason to reconsider how sure you are about that?

If nothing else, consider that it being important enough for someone to cheat suggests it is important enough that other people don't want their achievements to be diminished by cheaters.

There are many things in life that only matter to a minority of people, that doesn't mean it is right for someone to stomp over that something for some perverse sense of self-satisfaction. While the trollish mob bullying is going too far by a massive margin, it is not wrong for people to care when someone cheats.

Re:Accused of cheating, marathon runner Frank Meza's life fe... by emptyfile on Thursday March 10, 2022 @05:44AM (#30625430)
Well I just don't get your comment. Did you read the article at all?

>I'm pretty sure only online cheating detectives pay much attention to unusually low marathon times

It would be a world record in his age group if the LA marathon was a proper IAAF course. When people started getting suspicious his name and picture came out on the cover of the Los Angeles Times.

>specially if the person doesn't actively seek to promote themself

maybe next time cheat a few minutes slower then the world record! ridiculous!

Re:Accused of cheating, marathon runner Frank Meza's life fe... by dc-programmer on Thursday March 10, 2022 @02:22PM (#30631249)
letsrun.com is a cesspool