News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by rendall on Monday March 07, 2022 @03:35AM (#30585468)
I want to remind everyone what happened, here.

By the beginning of 2010, it was clear that the App Store was likely to become a massive cash cow for Apple. Flash was direct competition, however. If one could play a game in a browser rather than buying it, Apple would lose out on that income. Everyone was clamoring for Apple to add Flash capability to its mobile iPhone browser. Adobe offered all help, yet Apple continued to drag its feet. It became obvious something was going on.

In April, Steve Jobs wrote an open letter, "Thoughts on Flash", stating, among other things, that HTML5 could deliver a superior experience to Flash and that Flash had such inherent security and performance problems that they could never be rectified.

These were lies, but Apple's henchmen in tech media, especially Wired and Gawker, repeated this lie endlessly, destroying a creative ecosystem and industry so that Apple could have its App Store.

The web is still to this day unable to deliver an experience like Flash could, and likely will never be able to.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by M4v3R on Monday March 07, 2022 @03:53AM (#30585592)
I strongly disagree that the only reason Flash died was Steve Jobs/Apple's personal vendetta against it. Sure, it might've played a part, but as other commenters already pointed out Flash was riddled with problems - it was a resource hog, the macOS implementation was buggy and slow and Adobe seemed to not care about fixing these problems, and it had a very bad record of security holes. Plus it was closed source and the format itself was undocumented.

I can see how all the aforementioned problems made it so Apple didn't want to include it on its mobile devices. And even if politics played some part in it, these problems made it easy for Apple to convince everyone else that retiring Flash is the right thing to do.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by rendall on Monday March 07, 2022 @04:12AM (#30585694)
> the macOS implementation was buggy and slow

This is actually another lie that has somehow been retconned into the collective narrative. Baffling.

I was a professional Flash developer at the time, working for brands like Nike and Johnson & Johnson. We as an industry used Apple almost exclusively. This was not a common observation until after "Thoughts on Flash"

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by dijit on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:47AM (#30586252)
Maybe you have a bias since you worked with flash.

As a flash consumer from 2001-2011 I must tell you that honestly; flash was fucking painful.

Run a very weird binary blob riddled with security holes and questionable browser integrations or suffer.

Yes, some things became possible (habbo hotel, flash games, video/audio before browsers supported it) but it wasn’t worth it. I very much wanted flash to die by 2006 and ran a lot of extensions to bypass flash on Linux such as the “HTML5 everywhere” browser add on that tried to force YouTube to use HTML5 video (with mixed results).

I think anyone looking at flash now is romanticising the past. It was the least enjoyable thing about web browsing in the 00-s

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by rendall on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:56AM (#30586313)
> "riddled with security holes"

There it is again! That specific phrasing. Curious. [1]

> "flash on Linux"

Yes, Flash on Linux sucked. We're talking about macOS, and it did not suck on macOS.

> Maybe you have a bias since you worked with flash.

Oh, absolutely. I chose to work with Flash because it was great! But that's not really germane. I would not have wanted to work with Flash if it sucked on Apple, since that was the platform I used at the time.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30585649

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by dijit on Monday March 07, 2022 @06:06AM (#30586359)
Riddled is pretty common verbiage for native English speakers when something is heavily afflicted with something which is probably why you’re seeing it everywhere.

“Riddled with holes” is the original phrase, usually when referring to worn out clothing or something which has been damaged with many punctures.

It’s not a conspiracy or a retcon. I think I have tweets from this period where I was extolling my frustration with YouTube specifically for requiring flash.

To be fair I didn’t use Apple computers in that era so you could be right; but I did use Windows and Linux and Linux was by far the least favoured by adobe, but it still wasn’t pleasant on Windows.

I bought my first MacBook in 2011 and flash was already dead by then.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by rendall on Monday March 07, 2022 @08:18AM (#30587367)
I disagree that it's a common phrase. It's used primarily when talking about cancer or infestations. It is almost never used in any engineering context. Except when people speak about Flash. You don't find that odd at all?
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by thfuran on Monday March 07, 2022 @08:43AM (#30587619)
That you don't use the word doesn't mean no one does. There's no grand conspiracy here.
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by rendall on Monday March 07, 2022 @08:56AM (#30587796)
It's not about my using that phrase. It's about how often it's used and in what context.

It's inevitable when talking about Flash, but not, say, Windows, or other contexts with security vulnerabilities. Always "Flash" specifically "riddled".

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by dijit on Monday March 07, 2022 @09:11AM (#30587980)
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by drawfloat on Monday March 07, 2022 @09:38AM (#30588317)
It's incredibly common.
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by Handytinge on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @06:40PM (#30608931)
I find your interpretation odd. I use the term "riddled with bugs" in software engineering regularly.

It might not be common vernacular in your neck of the woods, but it is where I'm from.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by pyuser583 on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @10:37PM (#30610636)
I’ve refused the phrase “riddled with security bugs” to describe XML parsers.
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by jcelerier on Monday March 07, 2022 @08:35AM (#30587521)
Who are you to decide if it was worth it or not ? Tons of humans had a really good time and memories on e.g. Habbo. That alone makes it entirely worth it.
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by dijit on Monday March 07, 2022 @09:07AM (#30587930)
Sorry. I should have clarified maybe.

When I say “was not worth it” I am implying that it was not worth it for me.

That I often didn’t enable flash even if I did enjoy some of the things flash provided.

I still firmly believe that we have much less energy consumptive software since flash died, I recently brought back some old /f/ content from 4chan and ran a flash emulator written in rust and it crippled my laptop, so it hasn’t improved a whole lot.

I hated it so much and it was so forced upon me that I am finding it extremely hard to have sympathy for you.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by hulitu on Monday March 07, 2022 @06:46AM (#30586642)
>I think anyone looking at flash now is romanticising the past. It was the least enjoyable thing about web browsing in the 00-s

The least enjoyable thing about web browsing in the 00-s was javascript. Pop-up windows, window resizing, stealing focus. Now javascript is still the reason web sucks. And security has not improved much.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by josephg on Monday March 07, 2022 @08:30AM (#30587485)
> And security has not improved much.

What?!

Modern browser security has gotten orders of magnitude better since Shockwave Flash was removed from web browsers. The sheer unending volume of security vulnerabilities flash introduced into browsers was staggering. Flash (until very near the end of its life) had no sandboxing, and had its own update mechanism. It was the norm for people to be running old versions of flash with unpatched security holes. And flash had so many vulnerabilities - if memory serves, flash generally fielded more CVEs in any given year than the entire rest of the browser!

Remember how revolutionary pwn2own was? "Wow, find a vulnerability and win $1000!". These days vulnerabilities of that magnitude are worth way more money, because of how secure the browser environment has become. ($100k-$1M on the black market as I understand it.)

The only reason it feels like security hasn't improved much is because crypto ransomware has made hacking so much more profitable. But even then, most randomware doesn't usually take advantage of security vulnerabilities in web browsers. Its really quite remarkable how secure the modern web has become; and that wouldn't have been possible if flash were still around.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by dwild on Monday March 07, 2022 @11:27AM (#30589734)
> Remember how revolutionary pwn2own was? "Wow, find a vulnerability and win $1000!". These days vulnerabilities of that magnitude are worth way more money, because of how secure the browser environment has become.

Theses amounts were low because there was no interest in rewarding white hat hackers sadly. Bug bounties at the time were extremely rare. It wasn't lower because it was easier (though it may have been easier, not arguing it wasn't, just that the amounts are not evidence of it).

> ($100k-$1M on the black market as I understand it.)

On the "white" market you means. Zerodium is paying theses amounts. I don't feel like it would be higher in the black market than what they are offering, but could be.

Speaking of which, in 2020 Zerodium stopped accepting "Apple iOS LPE, Safari RCE, or sandbox escapes" for a few months because there was too many of them... still no "Thought on iOS" yet... It's not like it's even a new thing, I remember a long time ago when you could jailbreak your iPhone using a website directly.

Didn't even need to go far either... check CVE-2022-22620, only a month ago.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by jbverschoor on Monday March 07, 2022 @04:28AM (#30585781)
(Most?) Flash apps didn't adjust for responsive web. It was also full of security issues. Most flash applications were running at a certain FPS, instead of reacting to UI changes/redrawing. Flash was nice for games, but for the rest is was a pain in the butt.

Also, look at how slow Adobe is in keeping things updated for newer platforms. I'm happy flash is dead, and I hope creative suite will follow.. Probably not though.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by hansworst on Monday March 07, 2022 @04:43AM (#30585866)
At the time, (most?) websites didn't adjust for responsive web either. There's nothing inherent about Flash that made it impossible to support responsive layouts with it. In fact, if anything, developing with Flash gave you more control over positioning than html/css did at the time.

Sure, there were downsides to Flash. It's true that many Flash-based apps/websites used more battery power than html/css stuff. But I'd argue that this is an indicator that there is a demand for rich content on the web. Since Flash was killed, we've seen a resurgence of all kinds of heavy JavaScript libraries, and forums like hackernews are full of people complaining about websites being sluggish and slow to load because of the amount of js that's being injected. Well guess what - now we've just replaced Flash with a fragmented open landscape.

Is it better? Maybe - to a degree the openness of html/css/js is good for obvious reasons. But to be honest, I think the web still hasn't recovered from the blow Apple gave to the creative ecosystem that had been built up around Flash, because there still isn't a similar tool that allows you to easily build web-based rich, interactive experiences, full of animation and rich graphics, the way Flash did about 15-20 (!) years ago

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by rendall on Monday March 07, 2022 @04:32AM (#30585805)
> Flash apps didn't adjust for responsive web

This was 2009. "Responsive layout" was barely a concept. Most HTML/CSS websites didn't have responsive layout. We were still figuring out all out.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by BadOakOx on Monday March 07, 2022 @08:03AM (#30587237)
Maybe it was not called "Responsive layout", but it was a thing since 2004: https://www.themaninblue.com/writing/perspective/2004/09/21/

Flash was as bad as Java Applets. They both tried to solve problems that couldn't be done with standard web technologies at the time. They both needed extra plugins so they could work... while everything else just works in the browsers. They have no place in web development.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by int_19h on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:31PM (#30594245)
If by "responsive layout" one means adapting to the size of the browser window, and not specifically adapting to mobile screens, then it was fairly common in 2009. And even earlier - we just did it with tables in late 90s and early 00s.

It is also true that the vast majority of web pages done in Flash did not do it.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by jbverschoor on Monday March 07, 2022 @09:01AM (#30587868)
Maybe not responsive, but definitely fluid design.
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by rendall on Monday March 07, 2022 @04:03AM (#30585649)
> Flash was riddled with problems - it was a resource hog, the macOS implementation was buggy and slow and Adobe seemed to not care about fixing these problems, and it had a very bad record of security holes

Yeah, see this? This "riddled" word? That's how I know you're just repeating what you read. It's a tell.

Jobs + Wired + Gawker + Apple made an incredibly strong conceptual gravity well that makes conversation about this difficult. They all use this "riddled with security holes" phrasing. It's like you just repeated "No, you don't understand. Brawndo is what plants crave."

What security holes? Specifically? Were they more serious than any browser?

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by MayeulC on Monday March 07, 2022 @04:14AM (#30585710)
Security issues? Yes, there were 0days after 0days. Adobe kept pushing updates, but users were often lagging behind. Researchers continually found new vulnerabilities.

Browsers weren't as sandboxed and hardened as they are today, and flash plugged directly into them.

Flash was one of the most used vectors for adware, all you had to do was visit some shady website.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by rendall on Monday March 07, 2022 @04:23AM (#30585762)
> 0days after 0days

[Citation needed]

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by Deukhoofd on Monday March 07, 2022 @07:18AM (#30586867)
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by rendall on Monday March 07, 2022 @08:25AM (#30587420)
100% of all zero-day vulnerabilities from 2008-2022 are due to Adobe?

Let's look at the entire context.

https://www.zero-day.cz/database/?set_filter=Y&arrFilter_pf%...

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by bydo on Monday March 07, 2022 @03:37PM (#30593015)
One in twelve of all security issues—in a period that begins when Flash was already on the decline and extends far beyond when Flash was at all relevant—were caused by a single web browser plugin and you're trying to handwave that off as not a big deal? Adobe has the highest percentage of exploits listed there for any company that is not an OS vendor, and Flash has the most of any single product that is not Windows (in an era when XP was still supported!) or IE (which it ties with).

And, yeah, Flash did suck as an end-user experience. For a few years it seemed like every restaurant in existence had an all-Flash web presence, and, no, waiting for endless animations while wading through some entirely non-standard "rich media" experience, while listening to my laptop fans kick into overdrive, did not "surprise and delight" when I was just trying to find their hours and a menu. It was absolutely infuriating.

This is ignoring that one of the major malware vectors that wasn't a zero-day at the time was to just put up a webpage claiming that Flash was out of date, and then linking a fake updater. Sure, that wasn't entirely Adobe's fault, but if they'd done a better job of keeping it up to date on their own it would have been an awful lot less believable to end users.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by Deukhoofd on Monday March 07, 2022 @09:32AM (#30588236)
No, I was filtering on Adobe so you could easily see all Flash zero days.
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by hluska on Monday March 07, 2022 @07:39AM (#30587042)
Good citation. :)
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by hluska on Monday March 07, 2022 @07:39AM (#30587034)
Riddled is a common word that native English speakers tend to use. It’s not a tell.

Your aggression, on the other hand, is uncommon. It is a tell.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by rendall on Monday March 07, 2022 @08:47AM (#30587669)
Sorry. Not intending to be aggressive. That's me being weirded out, not intentionally aggressive.

As a native English speaker, I can assure you it's not a common technical term at all. It's a poetic phrase, designed to elicit thoughts of illness and damage. A house can be riddled with termites, a body can be riddled with cancer, a bridge can be riddled with rust. But Flash, uniquely, is "riddled" with security holes. No one says that about Windows.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by warble on Monday March 07, 2022 @11:24AM (#30589692)
As an engineer, I hear it used all the time in contexts outside of Flash. It's extremely common.
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by hluska on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @09:22PM (#30610249)
Strange, I googled “windows riddled” (without quotes - try it). This was the first result:

https://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/forum/all/why-is...

“Why is Windows 10 riddled with so many bugs and the updates make matters worse?”

It’s likely time to admit that you’re wrong. Riddled is a word, the meaning fits and people use it to describe software.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by Ferrotin on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @06:52AM (#30598922)
Getting “riddled” specifically means to get holes put in you, as in with bullets. It’s a very fitting term for having lots of security holes.
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by andrewxdiamond on Monday March 07, 2022 @04:09AM (#30585685)
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by rendall on Monday March 07, 2022 @04:21AM (#30585753)
During this conversation, someone inevitably posts this without comment, as if it is a rhetorical slam-dunk.

Could you expand on this? Your point is the Flash had vulnerabilities?

What software doesn't? https://www.cvedetails.com/product-list/vendor_id-1224/Googl...

Remember, Jobs' contention was that Flash's problems were inherent. Can you support that?

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by gmueckl on Monday March 07, 2022 @04:40AM (#30585844)
Compare Flash to Safari then: Flash is a comparatively small VM runtime and vector graphics engine while Safari is a whole browser, which has a much larger attack surface. And Safari, despite its increased complexity, had about the same amount of reported vulnerabilities around 2010:

https://www.cvedetails.com/product/2935/Apple-Safari.html?ve...

So, objectively, Flash did have very persistent security issues.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by rendall on Monday March 07, 2022 @04:49AM (#30585910)
"Comparatively small" is doing a lot of lifting, there. What about Flash was "comparatively small" compared with Safari, and why does that let Safari of the hook for its vulnerabilities compared with Flash?
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by bjoli on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:13AM (#30586045)
I spelunked through the Firefox source code about 10 years ago.

A modern browser is an amazingly complex piece of software. A gazillion parsers with the ability to handle malformed content that should give anyone nightmares. Multiple JITs and interpreters. Layout handling with incremental grid calculation algorithms that gave me vertigo - before I understood that it was done asynchronously.

There is no way in hell flash is anywhere near as complex.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by rendall on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:42AM (#30586221)
Your "no way in hell" is not really an answer, and any response will just devolve into "Uh huh!" "Nuh uh!"

Browsers now are very complex. At the time, we were still dealing with IE6 and JavaScript 3.

Flash could do literally everything that browsers at the time did, and more. Load and display multimedia files, animate them, interpret ActionScript, and do it cross platform, cross browser, in a performant, relatively secure manner.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by gmueckl on Monday March 07, 2022 @03:12PM (#30592740)
"No well in hell" is a very good answer. Just the HTML DOM and layouting code in KHTML before it was forked into WebKit was an enormously complex piece of code. Then there is the JS implementation (including compiler - JS gets transferred as source code), the SVG DOM and renderer and other goodies that were integral parts of browsers already back then that I'm probably not thinking about.
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by bjoli on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @03:03AM (#30597629)
Just adding to this: the attack surface of a web browser is humongous compared to that of a relatively small runtime, even in 2008. In 2011 when I had a look through the FF codebase, there were already 2 JITs for JavaScript, one which had been in for years (but I don't remember if it was in use).
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by bjoli on Monday March 07, 2022 @07:27AM (#30586953)
You compiled to flash. Content served that were run by the flash runtime were valid or didn't work at all. The amount of code dealing with malformed content in browsers is staggering. A browser deals with everything that flash did, but in more complex ways, while also doing a LOT more.
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by shaky-carrousel on Monday March 07, 2022 @04:51AM (#30585923)
On the other hand, flash was being used by everyone, windows, mac, linux, mobile... Safari was just being used by mac users. Les users, less bugs found.
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by hulitu on Monday March 07, 2022 @06:50AM (#30586663)
Compare apples with oranges. Flash is a program, safari is an operating system.
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by hluska on Monday March 07, 2022 @07:42AM (#30587058)
So, you will ask for citations and then rip them apart because “every piece of software is vulnerable”?? If you don’t like what you get, why did you ask for it?

At first, you were merely overly aggressive. But this is turning into bullying.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by pverghese on Monday March 07, 2022 @04:18AM (#30585735)
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by arepublicadoceu on Monday March 07, 2022 @04:11PM (#30593374)
> Jobs + Wired + Gawker + Apple made an incredibly strong conceptual gravity well that makes conversation about this difficult.

I never, ever, read the Jobs manifesto against flash. Never cared to read any article about flash back in the day and I absolutely dreaded opening a website that used flash.

It was a guaranteed loading times on my bad internet, followed and/or preceded by a notice saying that I needed to install this crapware or update it. Not to mention my numerous crashes directly related to an unresponsive flash application.

But as you clearly wrote somewhere on this thread, this was probably due to me using windows and most flash devs using macOS.

As someone who just learned about jobs hate to flash and never touched on a MacBook in his life. I’m extremely happy this technology belongs to the past.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by cosmiccrisp on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @09:46AM (#30600435)
>it was a resource hog

Well, it had the ability to be one if a shade tree programmer didn't garbage collect their assets. Something that could easily be tested in an app platform. You could make amazing games that used only a few megs of RAM, or you could make a crappy app that hogs hundreds.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by gruturo on Monday March 07, 2022 @07:39AM (#30587040)
I have always had this terrible habit of opening oodles of tabs, and my (windows) pc used to become really sluggish after a while, usually leading up to an actual crash within a matter of days (never closing my browser, and suspending/hibernating the laptop but not rebooting or shutting it down).

I then noticed that restarting the browser (which was, back then, just one of many open apps) instantly removed this sluggishness, and no more crashes - unless I forgot to restart the browser (I say "the browser" here because this happened regardless of which one I was using, out of IE, Chrome or Firefox).

Some time later, I set up a really underpowered Atom netbook for a friend, and, horrified at the slowdown when visiting some heavier pages, I tried to help with noScript (which didn't really work for my non-tech friend) and a "Click-to-play Flash" extension, and I marvelled at the difference it made. I soon started using it on my own laptop and immediately noticed that slowdowns and crashes had stopped occurring even if I didn't restart the browser for weeks.

I decided to completely uninstall Flash from Firefox, and for the few sites which absolutely required it I'd use Chrome which shipped with it - and recommended the same to most people I know, receiving the same feedback.

Years later, the "thoughts on Flash" memo came out, and I though "hey, cool, I got there faster than Steve".

I have hated Flash ever since my realization, irrespective of the security issues it was riddled (sorry if the word triggers you) with, and ditto with Acrobat Reader. I've come to consider Adobe a producer of awful, bloated, insecure and shitty software, and my computers are better off without any of it. I do love the PDF standard, just not Adobe's software for producing/consuming PDF documents.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by josephg on Monday March 07, 2022 @08:19AM (#30587371)
Yeah I remember that. At the time, the web browsers were starting to aggressively throttle javascript on background tabs so badly behaved tabs wouldn't impact performance. But the throttling behaviour didn't work for flash. And flash banner ads were popular for some ridiculous reason.

I watch CPU usage closely, and for awhile there most of the time my CPU got pegged was because some random flash banner ("Click the monkey" crap) went out of control and started busy-looping in a background tab. I'd often came back to my computer to discover some random tab I had open was melting my computer. I hated flash for that.

But there was an easy solution. Pretty soon after that I installed a click-to-play flash extension; and the problem went away overnight. About 90% of the flash content my browser ever loaded was advertising, so it was like a lightweight ad blocker for the worst ads. Pretty soon Chrome built that behaviour into their web browser. And that was the beginning of the end for flash.

Steve Jobs did finish flash off when he blocked it on the iphone. But that didn't come out of nowhere. He first challenged Adobe to make Flash perform well on mobile devices. But Adobe couldn't meet his challenge. Flash never worked well enough on the low power smartphones of the day. People can blame Steve Jobs all they like, but flash would still be alive and well if Adobe had been able to ship a performant browser extension when it counted.

But they didn't. And now their product is dead. I pity the creators who made flash professionally, but I don't have a lot of sympathy for Adobe.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by mobilio on Monday March 07, 2022 @11:09AM (#30589475)
I remember this.

Then i have CPU C2Q 6600. And opening one site with 10 tabs i can see CPU spike up to 100% of all cores.

I found "click-to-flash" and some plugin for YT-to-HTML5 and this suddenly fix mine issues.

Mobile flash even didn't works good on high-end mobile devices because consume too much power. Since that devices are limited from their battery Flash was resource hog.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by MaxBarraclough on Monday March 07, 2022 @03:45AM (#30585537)
The point about security doesn't strike me as a lie. Flash had an atrocious security track-record, and it was a proprietary black-box, so no one else was able to build a stronger implementation.

> The web is unable to deliver an experience like Flash could, and likely will never be able to.

Plenty of Flash content can be converted over to HTML5. As an example, this old website: https://www.homestarrunner.com/

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by rendall on Monday March 07, 2022 @03:53AM (#30585594)
> The point about security doesn't strike me as a lie

Which part?

The lie was that these were inherent. "Thoughts on Flash" could have said "We have specific, actionable requirements, and if Adobe can meet them, Apple would be delighted to welcome Flash onto the iPhone". But, welcoming Flash was not the goal. Destroying a competitor was the goal.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by yonixw on Monday March 07, 2022 @04:58AM (#30585960)
I always understood the "inherit" part as "Who can find and patch the security vulnerabilities that affect his clients?". And since Flash was a closed source 3rd party plugin, it meant that the Safari team is dependent on them. Both for discovery and fixing bugs. Meanwhile, HTML5 and each Browser's Core (Webkit, Chromium etc.) is open source. This kind of closed-source vs open-source+open-spec is indeed inherit to the product.

I liked Flash too.. but the reason we don't have "HTML5 Flash" is only due to business decisions from Adobe headquarters. Since Steve Jobs prediction was correct (even if by chance) that power-wise, HTML5+JS=FLASH.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by rendall on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:19AM (#30586078)
> "I always understood the "inherent" part as ..."

This comes off as a just-so story to explain Apple's actions. That Apple would criticize Flash for being closed-source is absurd, but that people would repeat that as a valid criticism is baffling.

By the way, only the run-time was closed source. Build tools, language, was all open-source. You didn't even need Flash to compile a swf.

> power-wise, HTML5+JS=FLASH

I'm not sure what you're saying here. "power-wise"? What does that mean?

HTML5 has in over 12 years never been able to deliver the experience that Flash does. They are completely different things. Jobs' successfully conflating them in everyone's mind is a testament to his power as an influencer. Awesome, really.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by hulitu on Monday March 07, 2022 @06:39AM (#30586593)
>That Apple would criticize Flash for being closed-source is absurd, but that people would repeat that as a valid criticism is baffling.

That's how propaganda works. You need a lie and some newspapers to amplify it. Jobs was a "good" propagandist.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by yonixw on Monday March 07, 2022 @07:09AM (#30586795)
Can you both help us understand your stance, instead of throwing political words?

In his open letter [1], Steve Jobs specifies his open source contribution for HTML5 and the Webkit browsers. Meanwhile Adobe itself did not contribute any. All the available tools noted above were not officials. He was very correct at the time.

Also noted in the letter, the incentives in play are actually the opposite of what you have said, as how Apple and Adobe work together bringing Adobe software to Mac. Why would Steve Jobs hurt any Adobe product, isn't it hurting the MAC demographic at the time (artists)? As there was never any Apple software competing with Adobe.

IMHO, it's more likely that flash on mobile were to be a real problem holding the iPad\iPhone back if supported. So much so, Steve had to publish it and gain support from the outside world. Because I doubt any C-Level executive would be behind him destroying the mutual relationship with adobe.

[1] https://web.archive.org/web/20200430094807/https://www.apple...

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by shkkmo on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:12AM (#30586037)
FYI, "inherit" is not the right word, you want "inherent"
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by willis936 on Monday March 07, 2022 @06:12AM (#30586397)
Nothing was converted. Homestar Runner now runs an Flash emulator (ruffle) to play SWF files.
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by jasode on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:45AM (#30586242)
>I want to remind everyone what happened, here. [...] These were lies, but Apple's henchmen in tech media, especially Wired and Gawker, repeated this lie endlessly, [...]

>I was a professional Flash developer at the time,

I think your personal financial investment into the Flash development platform biases your history.

In contrast, I wasn't a Flash programmer and only a user and I disagree with your claim that it was an Apple-orchestrated conspiracy.

Even before 2009, I (and many others) dreaded the Flash plugin. Yes, the early Youtube used Flash but when a website like a restaurant displayed their menu using Flash, it was a terrible experience. Each time a website displayed the "Flash plugin required" , it was a hassle. And even after downloading the plugin and then visiting the same website a week later, you'd inevitably get "We're Sorry -- You need to update your Flash Player".

Adobe Flash was also one of the top reasons in early 2000s for desktop browsers to crash. Misbehaving plugins like FLash was one of the motivating reasons for Chrome to make a bold architectural decision to isolate each tab into its own process so Flash would not crash the entire browser. The Chrome release was 2008 which was before the 2010 Steve Jobs "Thoughts on Flash"

Based on countless developer testimonies (such as yours), I'm convinced that Flash was wonderful for the programmers & content creators -- but as a consumer of computers since the 1980s, it was one of the most user-hostile technologies. A lot of us didn't need Steve Jobs to tell us that Flash was suboptimal; we experienced it firsthand.

>The web is unable to deliver an experience like Flash could, and likely will never be able to.

Again, as a user, I see no website today and think to myself, "I wish this was using Flash because it would be so much better." Can you give a compelling example?

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by int_19h on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:36PM (#30594284)
My personal pet peeve with Flash websites was that all the text was usually non-selectable (and thus non-copyable) except for widgets such as text boxes. So e.g. in case of the menu, you couldn't copy the name of the dish to look it up. In other contexts, it could be a much bigger annoyance.
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by andai on Monday March 07, 2022 @03:40AM (#30585498)
>The web is unable to deliver an experience like Flash could

I think the browser has been on par with Flash Player for a while, but Flash-the-authoring-tool (to my knowledge) does not yet have an equal. (I'm told Adobe Animate, the rebranded Flash authoring tool, is somehow unsuitable for creating games, despite HTML5 export features.)

To put it another way, I think we've more or less replaced the Flash Player, but we haven't replaced Flash Professional. (As others have mentioned, Unity kind of covers the same ground, but not really.)

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by rendall on Monday March 07, 2022 @03:58AM (#30585623)
You cannot find Flash experiences on the web, nor even Flash-like experiences on the web. There has been no replacement.

This post seems to confuse capability with actuality. Sure, we have the technical capability for a Flash-like player and authoring tool, but it does not exist.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by shkkmo on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:50AM (#30586274)
You are the one confusing "player" and "authoring tool" as there absolutely are players with all the functionality of the flash player and more, they are just called browsers.

What's more there absolutely are "html5" experiences that rival the old flash experiences. In most ways these experiences are much better. Perhaps as an old commerical flash developer youbhave a rosy memory of flash in the naughts. Back in the day, the only time I wasn't pissed to see flash loading was when I played flash games, every other use of flash was generally awful and I would usually immediately close a page if it started loading flash. As much as I hate the bloat and SPAification of the web, it is still far better than what most sites did with flash.

The demise of flash is complicated and has a lot to do with the rise of mobile. Android did support flash but even on that platform, native games simply outperformed flash games and the market demand shifted. If Apple had supported flash on iOS, this shift would probably have been slower but flash would still have lost out.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by JoeyJoJoJr on Monday March 07, 2022 @06:15AM (#30586420)
Most of it comes down to an integrated and cohesive development/creative experience for the content author. The current tooling provides such a level of friction that people aren’t experimenting and pushing boundaries of web content like they did when Flash was popular.

I typically work for creative digital agencies, and every single project requires so much tool/framework/library exploration now. Back in the day, you would always just use Flash, and you got the project done really fast. Everything takes so much longer now, and it’s because of tool fragmentation, or just plain lack of tools.

If I ask the question, “what animation tool should I use for animated web content”, there just isn’t a good answer. Back in the day, you would just use Flash.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by shkkmo on Monday March 07, 2022 @12:16PM (#30590459)
> Back in the day, you would just use Flash.

And back in the day, I would close your site as soon as it opened if it started loading a flash animation. Using flash for a website animation was never a good choice, at least not for the end user.

I am perfectly happy to have a higher bar for rich web content if it means a less user hostile web than we had when flash was everywhere.

If we really need a more integrated and cohesive experience for content authors, then go out and make it. The fact that one doesn't exist may indicate that there isn't a cohesive demand for such a tool.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by rchaud on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @09:15AM (#30600088)
> Using flash for a website animation was never a good choice, at least not for the end user.

And yet Flash persisted across the web, until a giant like Apple decided to de-platform them in favor of its own lock-in solution.

Consumers for the most part have no idea what tech lies under the hood for the websites they visit.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by shkkmo on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @12:58PM (#30603206)
> And yet Flash persisted across the web, until a giant like Apple decided to de-platform them in favor of its own lock-in solution.

Flash was a proprietary technology that bootstrapped the early web but was doomed due to a combination of ongoing security issues (which pushed browsers to move it to a plugin and disable autoplay) and poor support for emerging platforms.

> Consumers for the most part have no idea what tech lies under the hood for the websites they visit.

The vast majority of of the tools and languages that lie under the hood for websites, especially on the frontend, is built on open source tech.

There are plenty of shady things that Apple has done, but it is ridiculous to blame Apple for single handedly taking down a doomed technology. This is an example of Apple's prescient side, not it's nefarious side.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by JoeyJoJoJr on Monday March 07, 2022 @06:26PM (#30594700)
Flash was used for a massive variety of use-cases: Digital signage, touch screen kiosks, eLearning experiences, games, web animation, etc. No one is just gonna go out and build a new Flash along with its ecosystem. I used web animation as one obvious example, but the reality is that there is an extreme lacking of cohesion when you look at just about any part of developing for the web. The ecosystem is currently such a slippery foundation that creation of an authoring tool with the scope of Flash is basically impossible to achieve.
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by shkkmo on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @01:05PM (#30603321)
> The ecosystem is currently such a slippery foundation that creation of an authoring tool with the scope of Flash is basically impossible to achieve.

I would say that the scale, scope and complexity of that ecosystem outgrew the ability of one or even a few tools to satisfy it.

The idea that flash was ever going to survive as the one tool for interactive content, videos, games, animation and more is simply silly.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by JoeyJoJoJr on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @06:59PM (#30609128)
It’s not silly at all. I’m not talking about Flash competing with Unity, Unreal, and every other web app. I’m saying there is a desperate need for something that just does what Flash did circa 2007. HTML5 was meant to do that (that was the promise) and still it doesn’t. The old Flash guys aren’t harping on about it just because of nostalgia, but because it has become much more difficult and expensive to produce the kinds of content that Flash excelled at in 2007.
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by shkkmo on Monday March 14, 2022 @11:07AM (#30673306)
If there's a market for tooling to go make that content, then go make that tooling.

I think that market is actually pretty small since most of the use cases that flash was filling are better served by the varieties of tech that exist today.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by somehnacct3757 on Monday March 07, 2022 @06:13AM (#30586408)
Adobe Air could target mobile platforms with negligible degradation and generated swfs for web, too. I and most other serious flash devs in this era had a toolchain where you built once in AS3 and published to web and mobile using frameworks like Starling.

Flash died not because it couldn't do mobile. Thinking this is part of the hit job orchestrated by Apple. Flash died because browser games can't be taxed by Apple.

The same thing is happening today with progressive web apps. Ask yourself what Apple could have against those, and now look backwards at their stance on Flash.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by shkkmo on Monday March 07, 2022 @12:49PM (#30590983)
> Flash died not because it couldn't do mobile.

I never said it couldn't do mobile. I said it couldn't do mobile as well as native.

Flash died faster because of apple, but was always going to die due to the combination of the rise of app stores, mobile battery issues, and the advancement of web standards.

Apple did the work to integrate flash into the iPhone before they rejected it.

I think it is interesting that Apple gets all the blame here since the decline of flash also coincides pretty directly with it's acquisition by Adobe. Youtube's early moves to offer non-flash video also had significant effects.

While I am a big critic to Apple's approach to called gardens, the decision against flash was as much prescient as it was causative of the decline of flash.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by somehnacct3757 on Monday March 07, 2022 @01:48PM (#30591705)
In my experience, having worked closely with these technologies in my day job during this era, the average person talking about it has an oversimplified view of the technologies and comes to the wrong conclusions.

Adobe did not want Flash to die, and their product manager was very involved in the community to figure out what needed to happen to prevent that. I don't think Adobe invested enough into those demands, but still there was steady investment made. If they had more time, and Apple wasn't such a bully, the tech could have evolved and survived.

Adobe built Stage3D so that one API could target GPUs across desktop and mobile. Think WebGL, which was released around the same time. But production-ready due to the distribution advantage the flash player had over browsers at the time.

Adobe funded open source projects such as Starling to create scenegraph-like APIs on top of Stage3D, providing an on-ramp for all existing AS3 devs to the new paradigm with their existing API knowledge and tool chain.

At this point in the timeline, any AS3 dev could write cross platform games and apps if they picked up a handful of mobile GPU concepts like draw calls, texture maps, and bitmap fonts. (You could take all these things for granted in the traditional Flash scenegraph.) Unity existed at this point but did not yet have dedicated 2D libraries. You'd be rendering your 2D game onto a face in a 3D world, with a fixed camera. Total overkill. They wouldn't be as performant as Stage3D for a couple years.

I disagree with the assessment that Adobe was a bad steward because I saw them trying with my own eyes.

I also disagree that Flash couldn't do native apps with native performance because I built them with my own fingers.

Lastly I disagree that web standards obsoleted Flash because where are the web games? Why aren't they playable on mobile safari? Why don't the web standards come with a dev environment and where are the dominant Flash monetization models?

Apple played hardball so that the only way to be on their platform was to use their tech in their way signed off on by their reviewers and monetized by their app store. They also wrote FUD pieces like the famous Jobs letter.

Who was the villain here? Is Apple justified robbing us of a Maker's renaissance era because it wasn't mobile ready at the literal dawn of mobile computing?

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by shkkmo on Monday March 07, 2022 @02:20PM (#30592150)
> because where are the web games?

All over the place. I see them regularly posted to HN. Did you miss the entire '.io' trend of web games? The market is smaller because it was partially eaten by native mobile games, but it is alive an well.

> Why aren't they playable on mobile safari?

Aren't they?

> Why don't the web standards come with a dev environment.

That's not what standards are. There are a plethora of web development tools and frameworks that target the web. All of these target different needs and visions.

> Is Apple justified robbing us of a Maker's renaissance era because it wasn't mobile ready at the literal dawn of mobile computing?

> I disagree with the assessment that Adobe was a bad steward because I saw them trying with my own eyes.

Adobe abandoned mobile flash development in 2011, when mobile was a fast growing, but still small part of the market. This is also when android more or less caught up with iOS in terms of adoption.

If adobe had continued investing in mobile development, would flash have survived? In retrospect, this is the decision that put the final nail in flash's coffin as mobile won the eyeballs.

If Apple had included flash in iOS, would that actually have saved flash?

Was a closed source, proprietary ecosystem that was late to mobile ever really going to stay the dominant media delivery platform or even survive?

We don't know the answer to these questions but placing all the blame on Steve Jobs is simply too simplistic to be true.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by somehnacct3757 on Monday March 07, 2022 @04:43PM (#30593687)
The market is smaller because the devs can't make money. Since portals were an advertising and profit share model, reach mattered. As more and more users switched to mobile browsers, the games can't run there, and browser gaming can't pay developers and it dies. Now who made it so that the mobile browsers can't play these games? I thought the letter said that open web standards had made Flash obsolete? Apple's ecosystem didn't naturally cannibalize flash gaming. It conquered it with violence.

Next: They weren't playable on mobile Safari, no. Safari finally supports WebGL 2 as of Sept 2021. A full 4 years after the other browser vendors supported it. Why drag their heels on this open web standard? Does their platform have something to lose from a little competition? You condemned Adobe for being 'late' to mobile (citation needed) but don't condemn Apple for being late to a web standard meant to replace Flash like they said in their original FUD letter?

Your retelling of Adobe's history is wrong. They were still very much invested in mobile development up until the end of Flash. In fact to this day you can still use AIR to target iOS and Android with native apps. They release updates regularly.

It's very clear that you don't have any idea what you're talking about, have not interacted with these companies professionally, and have not used the technologies in question or even followed along.

The only way to make sense of the facts is to accept that Apple lied in their letter because it was good for Apple's business and that goodness came at the expense of end-user choice.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by shkkmo on Monday March 14, 2022 @11:21AM (#30673469)
> As more and more users switched to mobile browsers, the games can't run there, and browser gaming can't pay developers and it dies.

As an android user with an embarsingly high level on Kongregate back in the day, I can tell you that almost no flash games worked well on mobile, even in browsers that did support flash. The mobile flash gaming experience was just bad, which is a big part of why it died.

> Your retelling of Adobe's history is wrong. They were still very much invested in mobile development up until the end of Flash. In fact to this day you can still use AIR to target iOS and Android with native apps. They release updates regularly.

Yes, Adobe abandoned mobile flash in favor of AIR targeting html5 and native apps in 2011. That is exactly my point, Adobe abandoned mobile flash which was another big part of why flash died. See: https://www.pcworld.com/article/478103/adobe_ends_mobile_fla...

> It's very clear that you don't have any idea what you're talking about, have not interacted with these companies professionally, and have not used the technologies in question or even followed along.

It's clear you don't have a real argument or facts to back it up if you resort to this kind of crap.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by hajile on Monday March 07, 2022 @01:17PM (#30591314)
I used Flash on my android devices back in the day (Firefox and others had support).

Flash sucked on mobile. The VM wasn't as fast as JS JITs in the browser by a long shot. By the time the processors could keep up, Flash had already been dead for years.

Adobe Air existed on mobile and it wasn't a good experience either.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by nicholsonpk on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:26AM (#30586115)
Maybe I misunderstand what experiences you are looking for, but if you go to itch.io and choose HTML5 do you not see the things that used to be made in Flash?
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by JoeyJoJoJr on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:59AM (#30586327)
There are more specialised tools that can export games for HTML5, but Flash was extremely general purpose. In my time as a Flash developer, I worked on web animations, games, websites (not a great use-case), digital signage, touch screen kiosks, eLearning products, tutorial animations, and I didn’t even touch any of the more enterprisey flex stuff.

You can do all that now with various tools but the ecosystem is so fragmented that you often need specialists for each of them. The Flash tools had so much reach that you could bounce between such wildly different projects with very little friction. As a consultant it was amazing, you just did it in Flash. Nowadays there are so many competing and fragmented solutions that you need to evaluate then glue together.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by andai on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:49AM (#30586269)
On that note, Flash games were basically web games (back in the day Java filled the same role to some degree, eg with SodaPlay (RIP)), and web games as a whole seem to have gone away to some degree, I'm wondering why that is. I guess they don't work very well on mobile (relative to mobile games that run fullscreen), and most (~50%) web traffic is mobile now?
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by JoeyJoJoJr on Monday March 07, 2022 @06:04AM (#30586347)
There has been a bit of a resurgence of browser games with Friday Night Funken. I feel as the app stores continue to stagnate, the open and creative nature of the web platform will foster a new market for easily distributable games.
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by perryizgr8 on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:48AM (#30586264)
I don't know if it's just a case of nostalgia but itch.io looks like a wasteland compared to newgrounds.
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by shkkmo on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:52AM (#30586290)
The market is smaller and there are fewer experiences (mostly due to native mobile gaming) but those experiences do rival (and exceed) what was done with flash back in the day.
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by JoeyJoJoJr on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:38AM (#30586192)
I still use Animate CC as an animation tool for web. I don’t like the HTML5 export feature. The “export texture atlas” feature is much more useful. I have built a runtime for this feature, designed to integrate into whatever renderer you use (Canvas2d, WebGl, DOM, Three.js). It’s kinda like Lottie I suppose, but allows for more dynamic behaviour.

https://github.com/jackwlee01/animate_cc_runtime

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by hansworst on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:07AM (#30586006)
I recently came across https://rive.app/ which seems to make some steps in the right direction as a replacement for Flash-the-authoring-tool.
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by andai on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:35AM (#30586174)
Interesting, thanks for sharing! I spent a few minutes playing around with it and it, it seems to target a different niche from Flash. You can't make games with it, only animations for games you'd make in something else.

There's no brush or pencil tool, only a very bezier-oriented Pen tool. You're supposed to take the results and integrate them into your game/app using one of their various cross-platform integration libraries. So you'd still have to use something else to make the game, this would just help you make animations (and maybe art, if you like bezier curves).

Still, in an era of "render your vector art to bitmaps and dump them in Unity" it's nice to see a tool that does realtime rendering of vector-art animation :)

It doesn't seem like it would be too hard to use this to make a HTML5 game (they provide a wasm module for playback of assets) but it's definitely a ways off from a fully integrated solution (and they don't currently seem interested in that aspect).

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by andai on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @01:02AM (#30596901)
Re: the player exists, but the creator is lacking: in that sense the Web, even today, is a "Turing tarpit, where everything is possible, but nothing of interest is easy."
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by dig1 on Monday March 07, 2022 @04:15AM (#30585720)
I'm not sure this is precisely the case. Any platform, except Windows, was pretty much alien for Adobe and Flash - I recall all the pains of running Flash on Linux, even when support on Firefox/Mozilla side was decent.

IMHO, Flash distribution and compatibility versioning was a mess. When you got a new version, you could not access the previous releases on the Adobe site, at least for Linux builds. Overall, I think Flash's demise was more up to how Adobe managed it.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by rendall on Monday March 07, 2022 @04:29AM (#30585786)
> was pretty much alien for Adobe and Flash

This is another weird collective retconn that is not true.

Apple was not alien to Adobe the creator of Photoshop and Premiere and After Effects. If anything, Adobe is less comfortable with Windows, which usually lagged a bit behind with versioning.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by throwmeariver1 on Monday March 07, 2022 @07:11AM (#30586819)
It was a PITA on linux in every way possible take of your rose tinted glasses.
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by slig on Monday March 07, 2022 @03:41AM (#30585513)
Another reminder: The Flash Player sucked pretty hard on macOS. It was slow, buggy, the fans would go nuts and Adobe didn't care. If they didn't care about Apple users, why would they care about a new thing?
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by rendall on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:24AM (#30586106)
> The Flash Player sucked pretty hard on macOS. It was slow, buggy, the fans would go nuts and Adobe didn't care.

This is a thing that literally never happened. No one said anything like this until after "Thoughts on Flash"

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by slig on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:43AM (#30586223)
I'm pretty sure that it happened. I had a white macbook in 2007, and I used to run a pretty popular flash game website back in the day. It sucked.
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by rendall on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:50AM (#30586280)
You used to run a Flash game website from your macbook? You loved Flash games so much, you built/ran a website where people could play Flash games, but it just sucked so bad that you remember it as sucking all these years later?

Not sure what you're saying, here.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by slig on Monday March 07, 2022 @06:09AM (#30586386)
I meant that I was, back in the day, a mac user, I tested a lot of Flash content and that it was very, very shitty.
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by ksec on Monday March 07, 2022 @09:27AM (#30588175)
I sort of disagree Steve was acting in bad faith. Flash was slow, security was a problem in the context of iPhone, and what Steve was saying, may be Web Site shouldn't have been done in Flash in the first place. And this is absolutely true, so many web site should not have been a flash site. And Video should be delivered as HTML5. Remember HTML5 Web Apps was suppose to be the second source of Apps for iOS. And Facebook even went all-in on HTML5 apps. I still remember how hard I cringe at their video when they said it was as good as Native Apps. ( Now come to think of it I think my hatred against Web Front End evangelist may have started then ) To this day, not a single Web App, including VSCode is as good as a well made native app.

And iPhone doesn't have the horsepower in 2010. Today's iPhone 13 is faster than 80% of the PC in single core performance. So I dont think it was a wrong decision at the time. May have been worth revisiting in 2015 or 2016, but Steve was gone. Adobe gave up. Despite Apple later changed the VM rules so you could ( correct me if I am wrong ) package Flash Games as App. By that time Adobe has stopped all development on Flash.

And it is sort of strange, because those flash website was essentially what we have for apps today. So may be it wasn't all wrong. It was the wrong place at the wrong time. Sigh.

>The web is still to this day unable to deliver an experience like Flash could, and likely will never be able to.

That is the sad part, but partly because no one wants it to. Google for the past 10 years wanted to make Web Apps and Javascript or whatever they deemed good and nearly completely ignore Web Page ( until fairly recently ). WebKit was moving very slowly for the first 5 years before pickup up some pace in the last 3-4. But both of them never intended to have Web Browser to deliver something Flash could. And frankly speaking they couldn’t care less.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by rock_artist on Monday March 07, 2022 @07:03AM (#30586755)
While I'm pretty sure business decisions was involved.

But, I had a Nexus One with all its glory of running flash. Mobile experience with flash was horrible. Maybe, if Apple did add Flash it was adjusted similar to adjusting website for "mobile". but still, it's much closed standard than HTML.

Part of the reason it's so important to have WebKit, Gecko and Chromium is to avoid a lock-in similar to IE where in the past, many websites performed horribly on macOS (and Linux of course).

So I wouldn't say it all lies.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by partido3619463 on Monday March 07, 2022 @07:23AM (#30586922)
Others have commented similarly, but as a user - Flash sucked. It meant you had to use a confusing “novel” UI, that the page would be slow or possibly not work. You might not be able to copy/paste text. Almost certainly not accessible.
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by nicoburns on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:37AM (#30586182)
My understanding is that Apple were actually working with Adobe to develop Flash for the iPhone during the iPhone's development, but that Adobe were unable to meet Apple's quality (bugginess, crashing, etc) and power budget (A major restriction on the first iPhone - competitors didn't even think it was possible with current technology) targets. It was only at that point that Apple cut ties and went a different route.
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by rendall on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:47AM (#30586259)
No. This is a misunderstanding. Adobe was trying to work with Apple, and Apple rebuffed them.

Your tale doesn't realistically explain why Apple would permanently close the door on Flash, and do it in such a public, reputation-damaging way. They didn't just want Flash to improve, but they wanted to destroy Flash. And did!

That Flash was a competitor to the App Store does explain their actions.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by darrenf on Monday March 07, 2022 @06:59AM (#30586728)
> Adobe was trying to work with Apple, and Apple rebuffed them.

The opposite was stated in a legal deposition by Scott Forstall (ex-SVP of iOS) just last year[0].

We did not ship Flash. We tried to make Flash work. We helped Adobe. We definitely were interested. Again, this is one where I thought if we could help make it work, this could be great. Flash has been such a problem because the way that it hooks into systems, it’s been a virus nightmare on Windows, even on the Mac. And when we got it running on iOS, the performance was just abysmal and embarrassing and it could never get to something which would be consumer value add.

[0] https://9to5mac.com/2021/04/27/apple-tried-to-help-adobe-bri... and many other places which reported it

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by FireBeyond on Monday March 07, 2022 @11:02AM (#30589381)
Apropos of anything else, there's pretty much zero substance to this. "We tried". "We helped". "We were interested".

It's entirely possible to say each of those things, under oath, be accurate, and still absolutely undercut things.

I wouldn't expect an SVP of Apple, in a lawsuit to say, "Yeah, we really didn't give a shit, and weren't sad that it failed."

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by hajile on Monday March 07, 2022 @01:36PM (#30591553)
If Apple had given nominal help to Adobe, that would have been brought up along with the observation that Apple didn't really help.

Flash was available on several Android phones of the time. These phones had faster processors than their iphone competitors and the experience still sucked. I liked having the option at the time, but it was a terrible experience every time I was forced to exercise that option.

The biggest contentions of the time would have been videos and games. Video caused issues because flash player only sites were everywhere. On the other hand, they released canvas support (necessary for performant games) in 2010 the month before Jobs released his letter.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by Mashimo on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:04AM (#30585987)
For me as a 64bit linux user the experience was horrible. The worst where flash only websites that did not have a HTML fallback.

I'm glad that both browser based flash and java applet died.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by rendall on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:26AM (#30586120)
I do think a valid criticism of web development at the time is that it was waaay too dependent on Flash, and I think the state of HTML/CSS/Javascript is a lot better for not having the Flash crutch.

Still, the reason that websites had Flash at all is that it was easy to create a beautiful experience - admittedly, only for those on macOS and Windows.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by dan1234 on Monday March 07, 2022 @03:41AM (#30585507)
If this is true, why didn’t flash takeoff on android devices?
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by rendall on Monday March 07, 2022 @04:43AM (#30585862)
I don't understand the question. What does takeoff mean in this context? What didn't happen that you would have expected?
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by bydo on Monday March 07, 2022 @04:04PM (#30593305)
Flash existed for Android. Ignoring the fact that it was slow, buggy, and power-hungry—the same arguments against it everywhere else—why didn't it thrive? Why couldn't it compete with the Google Play store, if it would have been such a keen competitor to the Apple App Store?

You're way too hung up on this idea that everyone loved Flash until Steve Jobs commanded them not to. My understanding was that it was pretty easy to create animations and rudimentary games in it, so, sure, maybe creators were pretty fond of it? Maybe even too easy, which is why we saw "look what I can do!" Flash websites in places where it was entirely unnecessary and unhelpful (restaurants were notorious for this). But end users never liked it. Or Java applets, for the record.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by oblio on Monday March 07, 2022 @04:09AM (#30585684)
Because developing for less than half the mobile market (back in the day) was a bad idea.
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by solarmist on Monday March 07, 2022 @02:13PM (#30592036)
I can only guess why your experience was so different from most people's. Still, I was a windows user up until around 2010, and it was an objectively terrible experience for me on the whole.

While there WERE flash and Silverlight websites that weren't terrible (in fact, I seem to remember a few that were great, was Strong Bad flash?), the majority of things people think of when they think "flash" is stuff that would show up on newgrounds.com or a random video stuffed into a flash container.

So, I think both can be true, but most users' primary exposure to flash was low-quality software created as people's first game or similar. If I were to diagnose the issue retroactively, it would be that adobe flash had way too many foot guns (around memory management, I'd guess) for non-professional software engineers, which also happened to be the most significant users of flash on the WWW at least on the sites I frequented.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by pier25 on Monday March 07, 2022 @09:55AM (#30588497)
> The web is still to this day unable to deliver an experience like Flash could, and likely will never be able to.

Not only that but the DX was so much better than anything today in the JS world.

We had a TS like language 15 years ago. IMO TC39 where really stupid to trash the ES4 spec (based on AS3).

The Flash standard library was really awesome. The only third party dependency I used regularly was a tween engine (Zigo first and then TweenLite) and a Signals implementation.

From what I've read the perf and security issues could have been improved but I'm not sure Adobe had that much interest in it. Honestly I think Adobe was more than happy to let Flash go. I don't think it brought that much revenue.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by rendall on Monday March 07, 2022 @10:08AM (#30588660)
> Honestly I think Adobe was more than happy to let Flash go. I don't think it brought that much revenue.

This explains a lot, too. Adobe did kinda just roll over, rather than address the fundamental concerns of the web community at large. Patches here and there, yes, but no deep restructuring.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by pier25 on Monday March 07, 2022 @10:30AM (#30588897)
> Patches here and there, yes, but no deep restructuring.

Exactly. I was heavily into Flash/Air dev from 2007 to 2014 and I always got the impression the team was heavily understaffed. Specially in the later years.

Adobe abandoned AS4 (ActionScript/Flash Player Next) which IIRC would have solved the perf issues.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by IshKebab on Monday March 07, 2022 @09:32AM (#30588243)
> These were lies

This is not "what happened here". It's your weird anti-Apple take on what happened.

Ask anyone that actually used Flash on Android. It was terrible. Far worse than the HTML5 video experience that iPhone users got (when it was supported anyway).

I agree the web is still catching up to where Flash was for game. But games weren't the issue. It was all about video.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by schnebbau on Monday March 07, 2022 @08:24AM (#30587415)
Lots of flash hate in this thread for some reason. As a heavy consumer of flash games (and dabbler in production, but mostly just HTML and PHP around this time), I never experienced "riddled with holes". I understand it had security problems, but I never encountered any myself or by extension.
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by pixl97 on Monday March 07, 2022 @08:28AM (#30587455)
How could you not encounter flash security problems? There was a time the flash extension for the OS/browser was being updated a few times a month due to security holes.
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by isitmadeofglass on Monday March 07, 2022 @12:19PM (#30590512)
> The web is still to this day unable to deliver an experience like Flash could, and likely will never be able to.

I think thats very far from true. You can do amazing things in the browser these days. But we don’t have the same ecosystem we had during the flash days. And the reason for that is certainly the App Store, well partly along with steam, but not because Apple or Valve were some evil actors trying to destroy creativity. The reason is simply that these store provided an avenue for all the people on new grounds to monetize their games, so they stopped releasing them for free. Then the monetization became competitive and everyone started optimizing for engagement and adoption instead of optimizing for “the crowd online will get a kick out of this”.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by Angostura on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:27AM (#30586125)
> These were lies

It would be helpful if you could point out specifically which of these two elements were lies. Because they look like truths.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by gspr on Monday March 07, 2022 @07:49AM (#30587132)
I dislike most things about the modern web – but seeing Flash gone is not one of them. Good riddance!
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by TomSwirly on Monday March 07, 2022 @06:35AM (#30586562)
I upvoted, I agree that Jobs was lying, but I disagree with your conclusions.

The browser's language is a natural monopoly.

Flash did one thing - animation - really well, and everything else badly.

Simply the inability to bookmark a location inside a Flash presentation meant that you could never use Flash to write your whole site - it was always going to be blobs of Flash on top of a fundamentally HTML structure.

Once we, the programming world at large, saw with Gmail what could be done with HTML/JS/CSS, the writing was on the wall for Flash.

(And also Flash was insecure; and there was no way to throttle poorly-written Flash applications running in the background on some random page, so very quickly the smart kids would only enable Flash on-click.)

Logically, there was no need for Flash to exist. Everyone saw pretty soon that all the facilities Flash had should be put into JS, which has the additional huge advantage of being able to manipulate the DOM.

Adobe didn't help it particularly with some fumbling, but they weren't ever going to win that battle, and they got out of it quite gracefully when it comes down to it.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by lopis on Monday March 07, 2022 @04:11AM (#30585689)
> Adobe offered all help

Perhaps too little too late and with a terrible track record.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by rendall on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:22AM (#30586096)
Adobe. The successful software company behind Photoshop and After Effects among many others, did not have a terrible track record for fixing Flash bugs. This is another lie.
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by srvmshr on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:41AM (#30586209)
Hate to differ in opinion but looking at Adobe products and they way they are memory hogs & spawn thousands of files on Mac/Windows, this does constitute poor quality SWE. They have a successful product and became market leaders - but the engineering quality isn't on par with several other cash cow products
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by cromulent on Monday March 07, 2022 @08:13AM (#30587314)
Yeah and Adobe weren't behind the creation of either Photoshop or After Effects - both were acquired.
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by lopis on Monday March 07, 2022 @02:30PM (#30592272)
At the time Flash player was deprecated, it was full of vulnerabilities. Adobe had every chance to improve its proprietary plugin, but never did in a timely fashion.
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by npteljes on Monday March 07, 2022 @08:40AM (#30587587)
One of the large beasts killed the other large beast. Flash was actively hostile to anything open, it undid any advancements of the internet that empowered people and put the control back in the content publishers' hands, so I'm not shedding tears. (Neither would I if Apple got bankrupt)
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by rendall on Monday March 07, 2022 @10:21AM (#30588803)
I can really get behind this sentiment, even as the upstream commenter.

Personally, I find the loss of Flash less interesting than the kind of consensus-reality-warp that happened.

An article like [1] raised no cranky, contrarian alarms in anyone. Just, repeating "riddled with security holes" at everyone.

[1] https://www.wired.com/2015/07/adobe-flash-player-die/

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by npteljes on Monday March 07, 2022 @02:14PM (#30592047)
Yeah I remember these, like with Internet Explorer, the popular sentiment was to cheer for Flash dying. At most some people were afraid that the creative treasure trove will fade into inaccessibility. Public opinion really is played as a fiddle, by interests with deep pockets.
Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by int_19h on Monday March 07, 2022 @06:20PM (#30594641)
The popular sentiment was shaped by gratuitous use of Flash for websites that weren't games or even apps, but that were done entirely in Flash just so they could have cute animated menus and whatnot. A typical website like that would be slow to load, have fixed-size layout, broken URL bar navigation, most text wouldn't be selectable, and accessibility tools would often be broken.

And yet that was the "Flash experience" for the majority of web users who were not into browser games...

Well, that, and animated ads.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by foxyv on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @11:57AM (#30602217)
To be honest, I was really happy when Flash died. I hated it so much. Proprietary, nonsensical, junk ware that had to be installed on every computer and updated regularly. It was a source of endless viruses and didn't support Linux very well at all. At the same time I hated Apple too because after the iPad-2 came out I couldn't make Skype calls on my iPad-1 because it didn't have a freaking camera.

There are still zany web browser games out there as well as crazy video sites. Although I will probably miss Homestar Runner.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by mattl on Monday March 07, 2022 @11:25AM (#30589714)
Flash wasn't a web standard and relied on a proprietary plugin. That's why I was against it at the time.

Adobe could have fixed that part.

Re:I can no longer compile my first Flash game by Aeolun on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:59AM (#30586325)
I remember that. I also remember agreeing 100%.