[1] https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PL-KKIb8rvtMQnKZOfxShrcAH5...
It's basically dry, though god only knows what the bottom of the silo itself looks like.
I imagine getting it operational again would take years of very obvious work.
First: Early nuclear missiles weren't very accurate - you don't have to be very accurate when your target is the size of Moscow. A missile silo is a much smaller target!
So AIUI missile silos were hardened to survive a nuclear bomb landing 500m away - but they wouldn't survive a direct hit.
Second: There was a theory, at one point in the cold war, that one side could launch a surprise attack that struck and disabled the other side's nuclear weapons. Or at least, disabled a large enough fraction that the counterattack was survivable.
This was seen as winning. Or as close to winning as you can get, in a nuclear war. And it was seen as relatively more ethical than targeting cities.
The jargon for this is "counterforce" or "disarming" strike [1] and it was part of the rationale for having a ridiculous number of bombs - if you have enough bombs to destroy the world 10 times over, you can destroy the world even if 90% of your bombs have been destroyed in a surprise attack.
Later in the cold war other technologies were developed - high precision guidance, submarine launched missiles, and missiles with multiple warheads. Between them they made a disarming strike seem unlikely to work. But on the other hand there are still an awful lot of missiles around and they gotta be targeted somewhere. If you'd already sent a dozen at the pentagon and a dozen at the white house, why not send some of the remainder at a few nuclear silos?
Of course, you might well say this all seems pretty unlikely. A nuclear war? In this day and age? But people who think that probably aren't in the market for a disused nuclear bunker, except as a historical curiosity.
1. I just read this term in Lessons of History (Durrant)
And so it goes.
Maybe. Sowing confusion about the whereabouts of your warheads can be useful, and that was extensively considered.
See for example https://www.princeton.edu/~ota/disk3/1981/8116/811604.pdf, discussing the never implemented “multiple protective shelters” concept.
That even discusses how that can be done when treaties require inspections to be able to count your missiles.
This was post cold war when the agreements to stand down ICBMs were rolling out and they were disarming and imploding silos (Russians came to observe even). So I think it was plausible that they were moving things. But yeah I have no way to know, a drill, real deal, it would look the same to me.
I ‘corrected’ that ugly .PDF part without checking whether it broke the URL.
I thought they were all pretty big complexes with people in a bunker connected to them 24/7
The older missiles were liquid fueled, unlike Minuteman. Which means kerosene added when placed on alert, LOX added just before launch. Probably much simpler to have people do that on-site than try to automate. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SM-65_Atlas#SM-65F_Atlas
And as to the (perhaps somewhat facetious) comment elsewhere in the thread that the Russkies might still have "2 nukes" pointed at this silo, there are currently 400 active Minuteman silos. I'm sure the Russians would rather target those than sites that were decommissioned in 1965.
I just read an OpEd in WSJ the author argued we need to build more weapons to keep up 1:1 with china. When we already have more than enough to be a deterrent.
You can read a bit about them here https://minutemanmissile.com/missilesecurity.html
I'd also worry (not much, but just enough to be creeped out and never want to buy one of these) that there may be some system that is still programmed with old silos as targets. If things heat up again, or if there is some error, that property might be a target.
At that point I think you'd also want to ask yourself whether surviving a nuclear war would really be the preferable outcome.
During the 80s I was fully aware that - if WW3 would have broken out, even in a limited way - it would have meant game over for me. You'll learn just not to worry about that.
Wait, were these ever actually deployed?! They were certainly studied, but I didn't think they ever made it into the ground.
Turns out that "success" involved "most of germany dead by NATO nukes" didn't bring positive attention.
Of course being 1960s technology, the missiles’ inaccuracy and lack of numbers, was offset by having nuclear warheads.
The plan was to set a nuke off above your own city, to try to destroy/deflect another nuke, or an entire bomber squadron. SMH
The house I grew up in was right next to a Nike base outside of Philadelphia.
For those in the Bay Area, there's a Nike base that offers tours a few days a week in Golden Gate Recreational Area.
Or the time we dropped nukes down a couple gas wells to experiment with Nuclear Fracking.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Day_After
Pretty incredible. Thanks for sharing!
Also, that's a great (audio) book on the general subject.
I really don't see the problem
I had a friend growing up who had a missile silo on the edge of their property.
Folks in the area never talked about them but everyone knew where they were. We would go look at it once in a while. Really eerie that out in this peaceful prairie was a horrific weapon just sleeping and waiting. Ready to go at all times. Pointed at folks on the other side of the planet nobody in the prairie knew or would likely ever meet.
After the Cold War they were decommissioning them. While driving out there I was waved down my an APC and some soldiers. I pulled over, they asked me to wait with them.
A couple convoys of more soldiers drove by, trucks, then a big convoy with a big white truck.
I asked “Was that the real thing?” The soldier said “They don’t bring us ALL out here unless it is.”
They thanked me for waiting and told me I could go after one more group when by.