Re:Decommissioned Atlas F missile silo complex for sale
by detritus on Monday January 31, 2022 @09:12AM
(#30148048)
Another bit of context - some responses on the internet weren't intended to be entirely literal in their nature.
Re:Decommissioned Atlas F missile silo complex for sale
by the-dude on Monday January 31, 2022 @07:42AM
(#30147308)
Isn't HN amazing. Last week I learned about Countervalue : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Countervalue
Re:Decommissioned Atlas F missile silo complex for sale
by jvanderbot on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:35AM
(#30149087)
I always forget that we're "Apes in trousers"[1] until I read comments like this.
1. I just read this term in Lessons of History (Durrant)
Re:Decommissioned Atlas F missile silo complex for sale
by LargoLasskhyfv on Monday January 31, 2022 @07:20AM
(#30147155)
Still better to point them at NZ, to get the capitalistic overlords hiding there :-)
First: Early nuclear missiles weren't very accurate - you don't have to be very accurate when your target is the size of Moscow. A missile silo is a much smaller target!
So AIUI missile silos were hardened to survive a nuclear bomb landing 500m away - but they wouldn't survive a direct hit.
Second: There was a theory, at one point in the cold war, that one side could launch a surprise attack that struck and disabled the other side's nuclear weapons. Or at least, disabled a large enough fraction that the counterattack was survivable.
This was seen as winning. Or as close to winning as you can get, in a nuclear war. And it was seen as relatively more ethical than targeting cities.
The jargon for this is "counterforce" or "disarming" strike [1] and it was part of the rationale for having a ridiculous number of bombs - if you have enough bombs to destroy the world 10 times over, you can destroy the world even if 90% of your bombs have been destroyed in a surprise attack.
Later in the cold war other technologies were developed - high precision guidance, submarine launched missiles, and missiles with multiple warheads. Between them they made a disarming strike seem unlikely to work. But on the other hand there are still an awful lot of missiles around and they gotta be targeted somewhere. If you'd already sent a dozen at the pentagon and a dozen at the white house, why not send some of the remainder at a few nuclear silos?
Of course, you might well say this all seems pretty unlikely. A nuclear war? In this day and age? But people who think that probably aren't in the market for a disused nuclear bunker, except as a historical curiosity.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Counterforce