News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by snowgrove on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:37AM (#30056309)
Why is the U.S. sending troops to Europe at all? It’s been 70 years since the end of World War 2, 30 years since the end of the Cold War. Let the wealthy democracies of Europe fund their own collective defense. They can easily afford it. France and the UK have credible nuclear deterrents. Young Americans from poor rural towns who enlist just for healthcare have no business in Ukraine or Bulgaria. Send the young Germans; maybe they’ll stop looking down their noses at countries with functioning armies.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by tzs on Monday January 24, 2022 @09:30AM (#30057984)
> Why is the U.S. sending troops to Europe at all?

Perhaps because in order to get Ukraine to give up the then third largest stockpile of nuclear weapons in the world the US in the Budapest Memorandum on Security Assurances in 1994 gave Ukraine security assurances against threats to its territorial integrity and political independence?

I assume I don't need to explain why the US wanted that stockpile to go away.

One might argue that now that Ukraine does not have that huge stockpile the US should just leave them to their fate. But the US still wants to convince various countries to get rid of their nukes or curtail their attempts to develop nukes, and letting Ukraine fall would not instill confidence that the US would hold up its end in any deal to make that happen.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by SauciestGNU on Monday January 24, 2022 @09:52AM (#30058278)
Not the person who asked originally, but I'm curious, because I think what happened with Libya is a clear enough warning for countries not to abandon their nuclear programs in exchange for Western assurances. I'm curious if you agree in that respect.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by Redoubts on Monday January 24, 2022 @09:36AM (#30058059)
Sure, but Western Europe has the same interests and can do the legwork itself.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by petre on Monday January 24, 2022 @11:03AM (#30059322)
The Germans are blocking Estonia from exporting Soviet age howitzers to Ukraine. So until this nonsense stops, I wouldn't say we have the same interests. They can probably remember the GDR. If it were for Western Europe they'd leave us to our own fates, after they invested piles of EU funds into Eastern EU states. Fortunately the US always steps in before it's too late.

Once an European security analyst one said that Russia and China are playing chess with the US and the EU, while the EU is playing backgammon.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by jopsen on Monday January 24, 2022 @05:38PM (#30065053)
I can't fault the Germans for not wanting to supply arms to conflict zones :)
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by datavirtue on Monday January 24, 2022 @11:14AM (#30059529)
Speaking of chess, this whole thing feels like some game that Putin is playing to satisfy the oligarchs and hurt Biden (long game to another Trump presidency), while giving himself a bit more leverage for future negotiations.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by petre on Monday January 24, 2022 @11:32AM (#30059887)
Not really. Putin's favourite game/sport is judo, not chess. Judo is a game of opportunity and technique: one takes advantage of their opponent's weakness or distraction to attack. The rest is continous defense and harassement to get your opponent distracted and create opportunities for attack.

He doesn't think in terms of Biden or Trump, but in terms of opportunity. You should really think of Russia as a modern feudal state where Putin shares the country's resources with the oligarchs. The only difference is that it isn't farmland, but oil and gas. He doesn't need to appease them. He can run a show trial, have them shot on a bridge, poison them, just like he did with Khodorkovsky, Litvinenko, Nemtsov, Skripal, Navalny and others.

Vladimir Sorokin once said that the basis of modern Russia was set by Ivan the Terrible.

https://www.publicbooks.org/dress-up-games-with-russian-hist...

One should read post/modern Russian literature in order to understand modern Russia. It's also very good. I love Russian literature.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by jopsen on Monday January 24, 2022 @05:53PM (#30065229)
As a European I agree... And to be fair there is a large number of Europeans in "Enhanced Forward Presence": https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natohq/topics_136388.htm

In practice, it's unclear if the presence actually does much. But at the very least it ensures that an attack against NATOs eastern Block would be an attack against troops from many countries -- thus, many NATO countries can claim to have been attacked.

5k troops isn't much, but it proves a commitment. All NATO really has to prove is that we stand together -- then Russia won't attack NATO members.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by dragonwriter on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:14PM (#30065480)
> Sure, but Western Europe has the same interests and can do the legwork itself.

No, it can't, conventionally in the short term; in part, that's low spending, and in part it is specialization within NATO, but neither of those are easily unwound in the short term.

Against Russia specifically, as opposed to a generic hypothetical major conventional regional threat, there is also the problem that UK + France probably have an insufficient nuclear deterrent force, which is a problem the US, even if we’d like them to increase domestic military spending, doesn't want addressed.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by dismantlethesun on Monday January 24, 2022 @10:30AM (#30058837)
Western Europe is also less unified since it’s about 10+ counties instead of just 1.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by Redoubts on Monday January 24, 2022 @01:49PM (#30062082)
Sounds like their problem.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by flexie on Monday January 24, 2022 @07:13AM (#30056697)
Young Europeans died in the US war in Afghanistan. So far, the only country to ever invoke article 5 of the NATO treaty is the US - on September 12, 2001.

Adjusted for size of population, as many Danes as Americans died in Afghanistan. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coalition_casualties_in_Afghan...

So, Europeans should come when the US calls, but not the other way around?

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by snowgrove on Monday January 24, 2022 @08:55AM (#30057578)
You’re assuming that I or most Americans agree that the war in Afghanistan was worthwhile. Probably true at first, certainly not true after the initial objective of getting Osama bin Laden was achieved.

In any case, no NATO country has been attacked or invoked Article 5, so your observation is irrelevant. Ukraine cannot invoke it because they aren’t a member of NATO. Bulgaria, Estonia, Latvia etc. haven’t invoked it because they haven’t been attacked or invaded, nor do I expect them to be.

In my view NATO should not have been expanded once the Cold War ended. The US should have reduced its financial commitments to the alliance when it became clear that rich countries like France and Germany were acting as free riders. These countries reap the benefits of American military spending while contributing less than their fair share, and criticizing America at the same time for the size of its military:

https://money.cnn.com/2016/07/08/news/nato-summit-spending-c...

>To make the principle work, all countries are expected to chip in. NATO's official guidelines say member states should spend at least 2% of their GDP on defense. Of the 28 countries in the alliance, only five -- the U.S., Greece, Poland, Estonia and the U.K. -- meet the target.

>The rest lag behind. Germany spent 1.19% of its GDP on defense last year, France forked out 1.78%.

>According to NATO statistics, the U.S. spent an estimated $650 billion on defense last year. That's more than double the amount all the other 27 NATO countries spent between them, even though their combined GDP tops that of the U.S.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by flexie on Monday January 24, 2022 @10:12AM (#30058575)
The US and the UK asked Ukraine to surrender its nuclear arsenal to Russia, pledging they would protect Ukraine.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budapest_Memorandum_on_Securit...

Now, when it's time to honor that pledge, the US and the UK should do so. And I think they are and that they will, to some extent.

I strongly doubt the US really wants Germany, France and other NATO members to spend 2 percent of their GDP on defense (in which case they would have combined military spending close to rivalling the US' 3.3 percent of GDP because their combined GDP is higher and because Canadian/Turkish/European public spending traditionally goes further). The US has a clear interest in having a military far superior to the next many powers combined. The US might like Europeans to spend a little more, but not anywhere close to 2 percent.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by hutzlibu on Monday January 24, 2022 @09:27AM (#30057942)
"certainly not true after the initial objective of getting Osama bin Laden was achieved."

Which is the ironie in this whole topic - he was caught in pakistan.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by wwtrv on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:47AM (#30056416)
Germans (or at least their politicians) would be happy to sell most of Eastern Europe to Russia one way or another. France doesn’t care that much. UK does, but their conventional military capacity is limited and them leaving the EU also complicated things (UK was the primary advocate of expanding EU into Eastern Europe.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by m000 on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:46AM (#30056406)
> Young Americans from poor rural towns who enlist just for healthcare have no business in Ukraine or Bulgaria.

Exactly the point. USA had no business in Iraq too. But they got some sweet multi-billion dollar reconstruction contracts after sending troops. And the troops will be entitled to a life-time veteran discount in diners across the US! What's not to like?

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by voisin on Monday January 24, 2022 @09:56AM (#30058327)
Who paid for the reconstruction? Was this just the US gov’t paying US contractors?
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by vegai_ on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:44AM (#30056382)
>Why is the U.S. sending troops to Europe at all?

Possibly because of a certain Atlantic defense treaty.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by guerrilla on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:49AM (#30056444)
Ukraine is not part of NATO amd no NATO country is under attack or has asked for assistance, quite the opposite actually. EU countries won't even be pulling their diplomats from Ukraine as talls continue.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by tpm on Monday January 24, 2022 @07:01AM (#30056572)
Certainly war in a neighboring country is a cause for concern for NATO members.

There aren't any meaningfull ongoing talks: the Russians are threatening full invasion of Ukraine and other countries are reacting. That's it really.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by guerrilla on Monday January 24, 2022 @08:18AM (#30057216)
There's no war in any neighboring countries that hasn't been there since 2014 so that doesn't explain or excuse anything.

> here aren't any meaningfull ongoing talks

Says you. The EU, who are a a part of said talks (unlike you), disagrees at this point.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by tpm on Monday January 24, 2022 @12:36PM (#30060957)
In what talks with whom is the EU engaging reagarding current buildup of Russian forces near Ukrainian borders (not only in Russia, but also in Belarus)?
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by guerrilla on Monday January 24, 2022 @01:45PM (#30062015)
> “I don’t think we had to dramatise as far as the negotiations are going on — and they are going on.”

As far as everything I've seen indicates, they're speaking continuously.[1]

[1] https://www.euractiv.com/section/global-europe/news/eu-says-...

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by tpm on Tuesday January 25, 2022 @09:39AM (#30072234)
He didn't say anything about ongoing negotiations led by the EU. Could be (and probably is) other parties.

I thing this is an important point - the Russians are trying to split the EU. Last year, there were efforts by German and French foreign ministers to talk with the Russia - Lavrov "leaked" their proposals which is not something you do when negotiating. Now the Russians are talking mostly to the US, but also not really talking to anyone, only repeating their tropes.

One of the reasons for their ignoring of EU is that Eastern European countries are part of the EU, but they do not want to talk with them, only about them - they think they are our rightful owners and obviously you are not going to discuss with the slave - that would elevate him to your status.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by guerrilla on Tuesday January 25, 2022 @04:54PM (#30078647)
> He didn't say anything about ongoing negotiations led by the EU. Could be (and probably is) other parties.

Seems naive to think the EU is not included.

> the Russians are trying to split the EU

They already are. A glance at F24 vs. DW will tell you that. With Germany importing half of their gas from Russia (or more now?) and France barely importing any, it's really not surprising. And there will be all kinds of small differences like that in relation to Russia.

> Lavrov "leaked" their proposals

Link?

> Now the Russians are talking mostly to the US, but also not really talking to anyone, only repeating their tropes.

That would makes sense, as US leads NATO and that's their concern, but also no they've been talking to Germany and will be with France on Friday. But realistically they're all talking all the time. That's how these things work. Anything else is just fantasy.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by tpm on Thursday February 03, 2022 @04:42AM (#30190559)
> Seems naive to think the EU is not included.

No it's not, seems naive to think the EU is included, that would be contrary to the longstanding Russian opposition to multilateralism. That goes back to the kicking the Soviets got from joining the OSCE in the 70's. Which was originally their idea, but didn't go so well.

> Link?

for example here: "In November, the ministry actually published its correspondence with France and Germany on Ukraine — 28 pages of diplomatic documents that were supposed to stay confidential (an echo of the famous Bolshevik move to reveal the secret diplomatic documents of the czarist government in 1917)."

https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/02/01/russia-fs...

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by ivan_gammel on Monday January 24, 2022 @05:15PM (#30064821)
German Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbok just returned from Moscow, for example, where they discussed Ukraine among other topics. There’s a lot of talks happening right now on different levels.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by tpm on Tuesday January 25, 2022 @09:30AM (#30072122)
German Foreign Minister is not a representative of the EU.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by ivan_gammel on Thursday January 27, 2022 @03:57AM (#30097980)
She cannot speak from the whole EU, but she represents one of the EU countries. As I said, there are talks going on on different level. If you want names of EU officials, simply check the schedule and public statements of Josep Borrell for example.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by soco on Monday January 24, 2022 @07:03AM (#30056597)
Russia has officially asked that NATO forces leave Romania and Bulgaria. Does that look like their interests stop at Ukraine?
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by xdennis on Monday January 24, 2022 @07:47AM (#30056959)
Not just them. Russia said NATO should revert to its 97 form, which effectively is the same form it had during the Cold War (except for the German reunification, which is telling).
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by throwoutway on Monday January 24, 2022 @09:19AM (#30057833)
Russia is demanding that NATO nations (ie Bulgaria) leave NATO. The alliance itself is being diplomatically attacked by threatening a real ground war
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by ivan_gammel on Monday January 24, 2022 @05:12PM (#30064794)
It’s a starting point for negotiation, to ask more than you need. Russia was concerned about NATO expansion to those countries, but was not willing to act on it when it happened. As long as there are arms controls treaties in place, it will not be a serious threat for them.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by wongarsu on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:49AM (#30056453)
Is there a credible threat of NATO members being attacked on their own soil? Does anyone believe that Russian troops will just march through Ukraine to attack Poland or Romania?
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by jopsen on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:22PM (#30065564)
If NATO doesn't do some posturing, yeah, Russia might not stop in Ukraine.

Ar-least I recall that being the analysis in 2014. Since then NATO has been posturing, by rotating troops through it's eastern member countries.

I'm guessing posturing is a lot cheaper than war. So I don't mind if smart people say that's a good idea.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by petre on Monday January 24, 2022 @11:15AM (#30059558)
Yes. See this map with Putin's plans to restore the USSR. Romania does not want a direct border with Russia and being reverted back to a Russian puppet state. Ukraine and Moldova do not want dissasembly. Most Black Sea states, including Turkey do not want the Black Sea transformed into a Russian lake. So yes, there is credible threat.

https://www.geopolitica.ru/sites/default/files/novor.png

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by tomjen3 on Monday January 24, 2022 @11:41AM (#30060062)
The Baltics seems to think so.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by unpopularopp on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:54AM (#30056498)
I mean Orbán is basically Putin's dog in the EU and NATO (they meet next week in Moscow! [0]). Russia don't have to attack, it's enough if you have someone like Orbán who will veto and sabotage everything in the EU and NATO

0, https://abcnews.go.com/International/wireStory/hungarys-orba...

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by tiborsaas on Monday January 24, 2022 @07:07AM (#30056627)
At least there's a small chance that Orban and his mafia will lose the 2022 election. Fingers crossed.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by wongarsu on Monday January 24, 2022 @07:55AM (#30057022)
No matter what happens, long term this will push the EU to become much more robust against interference. Short term it sucks, but often bitter medicine is the best
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by sccxy on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:43AM (#30056365)
German and French politicians have sold their soul to Gazprom.

Nato cannot rely on these countries against Russian threat.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by nivenkos on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:49AM (#30056441)
"Sold their soul" - have you seen European energy prices?

Up 300% in the last 2 months. We cannot afford a war, it'd make the COVID crisis seem trivial.

US interference (see the Burisma board, supporting gas tariffs and opposing Nord Stream 2) brings us to the brink of war - and, much like with the Middle Eastern refugees, Europe must pay the price for US imperialism yet again.

It's painful to read so many American comments treating it like a game, when they have nothing to lose - safe thousands of kilometres away, and won't be affected by the energy prices, etc. either.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by sccxy on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:51AM (#30056474)
I'm in Eastern European Nato country.

If you make your energy 100% dependant on Russian dictatator then you deserve those high energy prices.

For you it is high energy prices, but for Ukraine it is life or death.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by medo-bear on Monday January 24, 2022 @07:06AM (#30056621)
I find it ridiculous that there are very vocal people in Eastern Europe who are so willing to go to war, and with Russia of all countries. Mind you, they want to go to war but they DEMAND that other NATO countries help them. US and UK, on the other hand, also have obvious economic interests in screwing up Russia and will not hesitate to sacrifice Western Europe's well-being to drive their interests. Also US has been behaving more and more in an Anglo-centric (as opposed to NATO-centric) way, which also raises concerns
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by xdennis on Monday January 24, 2022 @07:52AM (#30057005)
People in eastern Europe aren't eager to go to war, we're just vocal about doing something because we know we're next after Ukraine.

If war starts, the sanctions need to be painful, whereas Germany is like "we're okay with sanctions so long as they don't affect us in any way whatsoever at all".

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by ivan_gammel on Monday January 24, 2022 @08:03AM (#30057073)
You are not going to be next after Ukraine, that’s just irrational fear. Russia has no capabilities for invasion beyond ex-USSR borders (according to the assessment of DoD-affiliated American think tanks) and no incentives to invade Baltics. Baltic states are already in NATO, it’s a done deal and Russia got used to it long time ago. In any case existing NATO members have Article 5. Ukraine has not access to it yet.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by jopsen on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:11PM (#30065443)
Posturing like gorillas beating their chests is the only mechanism for showing the Russian that we stand by article 5.

Things only really get very dangerous, if the Russians got the idea that NATO wouldn't stand together.

Deploying a few thousand troops from various NATO countries to eastern European NATO members is just posturing that serves to ensure that an attack on one is an attack on all.

Besides, increasing troops in eastern European NATO countries is allows negotiators to offer a joint de-escalation. It carries little risk, and small cost.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by medo-bear on Tuesday January 25, 2022 @12:30PM (#30074806)
> Posturing like gorillas beating their chests is the only mechanism for showing the Russian that we stand by article 5

or ... perhaps ... posturing like gorillas beating their chests in front of the home of a nuclear armed and scared ape can have catastrophic consequences

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by jopsen on Thursday January 27, 2022 @07:05AM (#30099500)
MAD was always a bit mad.

But not posturing could be worse. It's worse if Russia can't predict our response.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by medo-bear on Thursday January 27, 2022 @11:25AM (#30102432)
you see i can not make my mind up if russia wants to attack ukraine (why?) or if US wants russia to attack so that US gains the european gas market from russia
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by defaultprimate on Monday January 24, 2022 @08:32AM (#30057353)
This feels like something an Englishman that was pro appeasement would have stated to a Pole right before it was invaded.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by ivan_gammel on Monday January 24, 2022 @08:40AM (#30057432)
When you feel something like that, it is better to do a reality check. There’s no reason to assume current situation is the same as in 1939. Historical traumas are subject for therapy, not basis for political decisions.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by dragonwriter on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:25PM (#30065596)
> There’s no reason to assume current situation is the same as in 1939

A better example is that it's just like what lots of Americans were saying about Russia and Ukraine immediately before the invasions and occupations that are still ongoing began, but with “beyond Ukraine” replacing “Ukraine” now that facts on the ground have made the latter more obviously indefensible as a claim.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by defaultprimate on Monday January 24, 2022 @08:45AM (#30057483)
Sounds like something the Englishman would follow up with except about 1914s geopolitical state vs 1939s
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by medo-bear on Monday January 24, 2022 @09:28AM (#30057953)
i am from eastern europe eu nato country too, so please do not speak in my name. probably unlike most people i have seen what war looks like (as a child). it is definitely not something you want for people dearbto you. talking and taking into account everyone's concerns should definitely be the first approach. russia says that NATO encroaching on its borders is a huge security issue for them (remember that NATO promissed not to do this in the 90s). also stationing anti missile systems on its border is a security threat (it deminishes their deterrant). is it so hard to understand these are real concerns? it is hard to immagine US acting differently if a hostile alliance formed in South America
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by windock on Monday January 24, 2022 @02:07PM (#30062347)
No one promised that NATO will not expand, and it is not documented. It was discussed, but that’s it. It is Russia-propagated myth.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by dragonwriter on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:28PM (#30065643)
> No one promised that NATO will not expand, and it is not documented

Gorbachev, whose ambiguous statement about a feeling of betrayal when NATO did expand in the east beyond the reunited Germany is the source of the myth of the promise, later explicitly stated that no promise was made and the issue was never even brought up.

(And it's not as if the USSR and the USA didn’t understand the use of memorializing important agreements in writing to prevent later disputes about their scope and content.)

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by medo-bear on Monday January 24, 2022 @03:15PM (#30063376)
it is certainly not a myth and it is not propagated by only russia [0]. russia was only stupid not to demand a written agreement

[0] https://www.latimes.com/opinion/op-ed/la-oe-shifrinson-russi...

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by windock on Monday January 24, 2022 @05:58PM (#30065295)
Yes, it was discussed. But discussion and proposal is not an agreement, and not a promise. The article has no sources, and the most relevant part is “ U.S. could make “iron-clad guarantees” that NATO would not expand “one inch eastward.””

That just does not prove NATO agreed not to expand.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by medo-bear on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:35PM (#30065715)
the article does mention sources. read it. its an article not an essay. anyway i think it is very hard to argue that us and nato were honest. it is even harder to argue that nato is not a threat to russia. i find that in politics just as in life the simplest explanation is often the right one
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by windock on Monday January 24, 2022 @07:50PM (#30066411)
Every Eastern and Central European country joined NATO because of their fear of Russian aggression. Every former Pact country switched sides not to repeat history of being commandeered by Russia. That whole alliance was born to protect members from Russia. The simplest explanation is no one wants to be occupied by Russia so that Russia does not feel “threatened”.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by medo-bear on Tuesday January 25, 2022 @04:51AM (#30070094)
your argument works only if russia actually wanted to invade these countries, for which there is zero evidence, esspecially at the time those countries joined nato. if anything, if you take your argument of threat from russia seriously, their security decreased.

on the other hand, russia was attacked multiple times by western european countries and lost millions of its citizens. i think their unease at an alliamce which you yourself say is hostile, is justified

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by dragonwriter on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:35PM (#30065716)
While that op-ed spins a nice narrative, the actual facts it rely on point only to the US suggesting that a freeze on further expansion could be on the table as part of German reunification talks.

But whether or not it was open for discussion, no commitment was, in fact, made and Gorbachev has himself—after inspiring the myth by a vague statement about a feeling of betrayal at NATO expansion—acknowledged that and gone further and saying that a commitment on the issue was never even discussed as part of the negotiations.

Saying something could be part of a deal as an inducement to get someone to the negotiating table doesn't automatically insert it into the deal, or even guarantee it gets talked about in the negotiation.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by caskstrength on Monday January 24, 2022 @08:15AM (#30057181)
> I find it ridiculous that there are very vocal people in Eastern Europe who are so willing to go to war, and with Russia of all countries.

It is funny how all these warmongering Eastern Europeans always have war with Russia on their own territory. Really makes you think who starts those wars...

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by twelve40 on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:18PM (#30065517)
> Eastern Europeans always have war with Russia on their own territory

oh you mean when 250000 Romanians, 250000 Hungarians and some Croats decided it's a good idea to fight the battle on the Volga? (look at the map). That _is_ funny!

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by dragonwriter on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:20PM (#30065535)
> I find it ridiculous that there are very vocal people in Eastern Europe who are so willing to go to war, and with Russia of all countries.

Wait, who? Preparing to defend yourself in case Russia decides to go to war with you isn't the same thing as being willing to go to war with Russia.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by caskstrength on Monday January 24, 2022 @08:12AM (#30057144)
I wonder it there were similar considerations back in 1939 ("Just let them occupy Poland, war is dangerous and costly, etc."). Spoiler: at the end you will have both war and pay economical price.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by alkonaut on Monday January 24, 2022 @02:29PM (#30062678)
> We cannot afford a war, it'd make the COVID crisis seem trivial.

If Germans really want to avoid war they should start by clearly saying that the NordStream 2 pipeline project will be cancelled and the permits revoked the same day that Russia either realizes the threat of mass invasion.

The rest of Europe is pretty united in this matter. I worry mostly about Germany when it comes to things like sanction votes in the EU.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by ivan_gammel on Monday January 24, 2022 @05:01PM (#30064669)
Mrs Baerbock absolutely wants to weaponize Nord Stream 2 this way, but it is unlikely to happen if operator of the pipeline will fulfill the regulatory requirements. Anyway there are ways to create a lot of pain for Russia without touching gas topic.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by alkonaut on Monday January 24, 2022 @05:44PM (#30065143)
There are few good ones. Oil would be a much better one of course (because less painful for the west while more painful for russia). I don't believe any (further) economic sanctions like SWIFT would help much tbh. The thing about the Gas thing that it's not only economic, it's a sword that Russia has dangling over a part of continental Europe too. I think they fear losing that more than the income.

And the Gas dependency is going away. Perhaps it's worth ripping off the bandaid. It's only Germany and parts of eastern/central europe that still heats up with gas right (Asking from Northern Europe where I don't think we ever did ).

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by twelve40 on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:32PM (#30065679)
> sword that Russia has dangling over a part of continental Europe

Ah, those mean Russians, force-feeding the poor Europe their poisonous gas. Reminder: the Western European countries voluntarily entered into this relationship and have been buying the gas for many decades. They are absolutely free to buy their energy from anywhere else in the world. Case in point, that's how France currently gets 25% of their natgas and they have been happily living with this "dangling sword" for 45 years, why would they do that?

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by tpm on Monday January 24, 2022 @07:04AM (#30056600)
300% higher spot prices, yes. Most gas is bought on long term contracts. We will have to afford a war one way or another. Now the war will be further away, later it will be closer. If only there was some history which could be used to learn from.

US interference in the case of gas is trying to ensure alternative supplies for the EU, either American LNG or from Qatar.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by t0bia_s on Monday January 24, 2022 @10:16AM (#30058611)
800% higher gas price in my country. It is insane.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by deepsun on Monday January 24, 2022 @07:05AM (#30056610)
Ukrainians beg for help from US. No game. USA (and UK arms) are the only hope right now.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by mickotron on Monday January 24, 2022 @04:17PM (#30064175)
Also, didn't Hunter Biden work for Burisma?
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by ivan_gammel on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:46AM (#30056412)
Germany and France are the NATO. Without us the alliance does not make sense and should not exist.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by jopsen on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:49AM (#30056443)
I can't help think that it's a bit unfortunate that the US would be selling LNG, if sanctions result in the EU not buying Russian gas.

> Nato cannot rely on these countries against Russian threat.

I think that's a big stretch.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by egeozcan on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:47AM (#30056420)
> sold their soul to Gazprom

Everyone should be better than falling for the cliche narratives like that. Politics is complicated, and everyone has their own definition of what a soul is.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by rcMgD2BwE72F on Monday January 24, 2022 @07:03AM (#30056594)
Gerhard Schröder (Chancellor of Germany from 1998 to 2005) is chairman of the board of Nord Stream AG and of Rosneft, the largest energy Russian company.

François Fillon (Prime Minister of France from 2007 to 2012) is a board member of SIBUR, the largest petrochemical Russian company.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by tpm on Monday January 24, 2022 @07:07AM (#30056638)
And Matthias Warnig, CEO of Nordstream, was an Stasi officer (that's an undisputed fact) and allegedly recruited by Putin himself to work for the Soviets/Russians.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by caskstrength on Monday January 24, 2022 @08:17AM (#30057198)
Really makes me curious where will Angela Merkel end up.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by odiroot on Monday January 24, 2022 @10:21AM (#30058700)
Probably at her mountain "villa", gardening.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by gls2ro on Monday January 24, 2022 @08:40AM (#30057433)
Well, I really am not an expert in geopolitics, nor military strategies.

But here is why I think first US and then other Western EU countries are increasingly irritated by what is happening in Rusia near Ukraine borders:

1) First lets understand why EU does not have a proper army? Because a) EU started as an economic alliance and b) because countries in Europe did a lot of damage in the history by fighting each other. So after WW2, even if some countries have armies, in general US assumed the role and used (as entitled) as advantage the protector of Europe. US still has soldiers in Germany, Italy and UK. Please notice I wrote US and not NATO => thus EU cannot protect itself right now, cannot form a proper army so quick (in 1 year lets say) nor I am not sure we should want this. There is a reason why WW2 started in EU.

2) Second, lets understand why US is irritated by Russia's movements. Because allowing Russia to make a stand will just allow more daring moves in the future. This is the beginning of an escalation that we don't know where it will finish. Imagine just economically what does it mean for Europe to get into a recession because of this kind of treats in the future? US will not be shielded by this.

3) Third, if there is even a slight chance that a large scale war might happen then it is better to act quick early. I know that behind our computers we all think a war cannot happen. But it can and it will if we are not fighting against. War is irrational and can happen quickly, it is a devastating and irreversible event. It happened in the history multiple times. So I am all for a disproportionate response to anyone that flexes military muscles. These are muscles that should not be flexed.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by jopsen on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:17PM (#30065504)
Yeah, compared to a war it's a lot cheaper for NATO to do some posturing.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by kesor on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:41AM (#30056352)
France and the UK don't have an economic and political problem like the US has at the moment. Which is why they have no reason to "change the narrative" by distracting the public with useless wars.

There are zero US interests to protect in and around Ukraine, so all of this looks like unwarranted poking of a lion/shark/whatever.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by octopoc on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:52AM (#30056485)
1. Starting a war with Russia is not the goal here. Deterring Russia is the goal.

2. A war with Russia wouldn't be a proxy war and it wouldn't be anything like Afghanistan or Iraq. It could quickly become nuclear. It's not the same as America's wars in Afghanistan or Iraq.

3. You're implying that Russia is not a threat to Europe even if America stopped using its military to deter Russia from conquering Europe. I don't think that's correct. If Russia believed it could conquer parts of Europe tomorrow, they would probably try. They don't care about public opinion in western countries.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by deepsun on Monday January 24, 2022 @07:10AM (#30056659)
> could conquer parts of Europe tomorrow, they would probably try

And they do try (and succeed) all the time: Crimea, Eastern Ukraine, South Osetia, Abkhazia, Transnistria.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by jeswin on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:53AM (#30056495)
> There are zero US interests to protect in and around Ukraine, so all of this looks like unwarranted poking of a lion/shark/whatever.

Not everything is about self interest - free people have a moral obligation defend freedom. Inaction on Ukraine will be especially egregious after taking away Ukraine's nuclear weapons in exchange for security guarantees.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by iamstupidsimple on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:47AM (#30056424)
France and the UK aren't in political crisis? Did we forget about Brexit and COVID so quickly? Same deal with yellow vests in France.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by datavirtue on Monday January 24, 2022 @11:28AM (#30059815)
Tons of business/trade with Ukraine that will evaporate immediately. Trade promotes peace and unity. This alone is enough to raise this as a political issue in the US. The same thing with the other NATO countries right now.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by raverbashing on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:46AM (#30056396)
> Why is the U.S. sending troops to Europe at all?

Because of a thing called NATO, look it up

> Let the wealthy democracies of Europe fund their own collective defense.

They do and they're free to associate with defensive purposes, as opposed to what Russia wants them to think.

> Young Americans from poor rural towns who enlist just for healthcare have no business in Ukraine or Bulgaria.

And Young Russians that joined the army have no business invading Ukraine

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by azangru on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:51AM (#30056471)
> Because of a thing called NATO, look it up

That doesn't explain it. Is any of the NATO countries under threat?

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by soco on Monday January 24, 2022 @07:06AM (#30056622)
As mentioned in other comments, Russia has specifically asked for NATO forces to leave Romania and Bulgaria - both which are NATO (and EU) members.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by azangru on Monday January 24, 2022 @07:25AM (#30056790)
Sure; it asked, and got a resolute no in response. Does this mean that someone expects Russia to attack Romania or Bulgaria?
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by ceejayoz on Monday January 24, 2022 @09:09AM (#30057704)
It means this is absolutely about NATO, even if it's not yet directly involving one of the member nations. See also: Russia's current demands over Ukraine including "never let them join NATO".

If a bully stood next to someone they'd previously beat up, glared at me, and told me "I'll leave them alone if you promise not to be their friend, forever, no matter what", what would you interpret is going on?

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by raverbashing on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:54AM (#30056501)
I'm sure that marine and airspace incursions by russian craft are just happy accidents...

I'm sure Putin's veiled (or explicit) threats against NATO countries (and Google has plenty of these) are just him being humorous

Also the cyberattacks (some by Russian gov. APTs, some by entites tolerated by the gov) are just inoccent as well.

Not to forget the Internet Research Agency.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by ceejayoz on Monday January 24, 2022 @11:47AM (#30060167)
> I'm sure that marine and airspace incursions by russian craft are just happy accidents...

"Incursion" is a very misleading term for these and I wish the press would stop parroting it (including with regards to China/Taiwan). Russia's flying planes into the ADIZ, not the 12 mile limit as recognized by international treaties. It's international airspace; ADIZs don't exist in international law; the US made the first one up out of thin air and others followed.

We fly close to the Russian and Chinese coasts, well within their own air defense zones, on a daily basis. We also deliberately sail ships within China's declared territories; we just like to call them "freedom of navigation operations" when that happens instead of "incursions" when others do it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FONOPs_during_the_Obama_Admini...

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by guerrilla on Monday January 24, 2022 @07:03AM (#30056593)
> I'm sure that marine and airspace incursions by russian craft are just happy accidents...

These have been happening regularly (literally monthly) since World War 2 and has noyhing to do with what's going on now and explains absolutely nothing.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by jopsen on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:39PM (#30065749)
> That doesn't explain it. Is any of the NATO countries under threat?

The defense analysis in 2014 was that unless NATO did some posturing and demonstrated it's commitment to defense of Baltic member countries, then yes, Russia might one day try to attack one of them.

Afaik, what NATO is doing is largely the equivalent of a gorilla beating its chest. Compared to war, it's pretty cheap to rotate some troops throy Baltic member countries.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by alkonaut on Monday January 24, 2022 @02:39PM (#30062802)
Yes. Look at movement in Belarus (next to the Baltic states). This is the most threatening it’s been for 30 years.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by egeozcan on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:50AM (#30056464)
> Because of a thing called NATO, look it up

To be fair, Ukraine is not a part of NATO, nor are the many Eastern European countries, and further east, Turkey is on the edge of leaving.

This region is like a 7-D chess game.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by xdennis on Monday January 24, 2022 @08:03AM (#30057070)
> Ukraine is not a part of NATO, nor are the many Eastern European countries

Only Ukraine, Belarus, and the Republic of Moldova aren't part of NATO.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by caeril on Monday January 24, 2022 @08:52AM (#30057542)
The idea of countries going to war over rational self-interest or actual tangible threats is an outdated notion. We pick our enemies along ideological and secular-religionist lines, and the continued existence (and god forbid, even flourishing) of polities that conduct their way of life differently from our own cannot stand.

Neoliberalism/neoconservatism (n.b. they are effectively two sides of the same coin) is the world's most prominent religion, and the United States is its Holy See. Refusal to kiss the ring will be punished.

Of course, this is nothing new. Constantine put heretics to the sword, pagan temples were burned and desecrated all over Scandinavia, and the Crusades were definitely a thing.

Religion will always be a part of the human condition, and the nonbelievers will always be the enemy. Just don't make the mistake of assuming that religion requires a God or the supernatural. All you need is a non-falsifiable belief system of some form, whose tenets cannot be demonstrated with facts, and must instead be validated by violence and the threat thereof.

Russia, Iran, and Syria (previously Iraq, Lybia, and Yemen) reject the blank-slatism and other patently false doctrines of neoliberalism and neoconservatism. Their existence cannot be permitted, so we need to invent reasons to destroy them.

Such as it is, such as it has always been.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by dan-0 on Monday January 24, 2022 @07:33AM (#30056849)
> Americans from poor rural towns who enlist just for healthcare

The rest of the point aside, you're trying to tug a heartstring based on a stereotype. This is much more condescending and out of touch than it is accurate with regard to the modern US Military.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by snowgrove on Monday January 24, 2022 @08:24AM (#30057289)
You’re right, they also enlist for free college and the signing bonus.

My entire extended family has connections to the military. I grew up on Army bases. I know friends who enlisted and others who did ROTC. I nearly did Air Force ROTC myself for purely financial reasons (ended up going to a cheaper school, still paid for largely my father’s post-9/11 GI Bill benefits). I’m familiar with the subject matter. Access to Tricare and the VA hospital system is a big part of the military’s recruitment appeal.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by jopsen on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:28PM (#30065642)
I never thought of universal healthcare as a security risk... (Sorry, bad joke)

But historically NATO has been a pretty good deterrent against war. Should we stop that?

As for the troops from various NATO rotating through eastern NATO countries: I really hope nothing bad happens, and they experience some new culture.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by xdennis on Monday January 24, 2022 @07:41AM (#30056921)
Why should the USA send troops to Europe? I'll remind you that article 5 of NATO was only invoked once: when you called for help to invade one of the poorest nations on earth: Afghanistan. Could the wealthy American democracy not defend itself?
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by snowgrove on Monday January 24, 2022 @08:20AM (#30057241)
No NATO country has been invaded or attacked and Article 5 has not been invoked.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by jagrsw on Monday January 24, 2022 @05:25PM (#30064898)

  On the evening of 12 September 2001, less than 24 hours after the attacks,  the Allies invoked the principle of Article 5. Then NATO Secretary General Lord Robertson subsequently informed the Secretary-General of the United Nations of the Alliance's decision.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by jopsen on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:03PM (#30065355)
I think the idea is the same as why many European countries went into Afghanistan: To demonstrate a commitment to NATO.

Norway did actually achieve one of their goals in Afghanistan:

> ...the domestic goal of the mission, to prove Norway a trustworthy US and NATO ally, was fully achieved.

Sure, we can question the wisdom of going into Afghanistan. But that was kind of irrelevant to Norway given their domestic goal.

In any case, it seems pretty clear these troops would (if mobilized) be stationed in NATO countries -- not Ukraine!

Also note that many NATO besides the US has troops rotating through NATOs eastern members States.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by enigma20 on Monday January 24, 2022 @10:20AM (#30058681)
Why does/did US try to influence Nord Stream 2? Because that's what they always do. Pretend that they are friends doing things in others favour, but actually trying to affect things for their own interest, isn't it? But to have an influence, you have to show sometimes that you care, event if you actually don't.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by alkonaut on Monday January 24, 2022 @02:35PM (#30062761)
Nord Stream is one of few sanctions that could actually bite.

If one wants to hurt Russia then sanctions are better than war. And we are running out of sanctions.

It’s important to separate NATO, the US, the EU, the international community as a whole etc. These are overlapping actors with different interests and politics. They do have one thing in common and that is they want to avoid armed conflict and don’t accept Russia redrawing borders.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by odiroot on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:46AM (#30056414)
Let's say some of us trust US more in that regard.

Of course it's unfortunate even a single American has to be here.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by tomjen3 on Monday January 24, 2022 @11:39AM (#30060031)
If you are to rely on the Germans to protect Ukraine you are giving it to the Russians.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by 2-718-281-828 on Monday January 24, 2022 @09:41AM (#30058116)
your assessment would make sense if we had any reason that US is considering that for humanitarian or altruistic reasons. rest assured - the only reason ever for any country (especially US) sending troops anywhere is for own benefit.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by jopsen on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:31PM (#30065674)
A war in Europe would also hurt the American economy.

Lack of faith in article 5 would hurt American influence and interest across the globe.

Yes, the US stands to benefit.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by lostmsu on Monday January 24, 2022 @10:25AM (#30058767)
Is there oil in Ukraine we do not know about?
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by jopsen on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:34PM (#30065704)
If we wanted play the paranoid game of how this is all about oil, then one would argue the US wants sanctions against Russia. In particular closing NordStream2, so the US can sell LNG to Europe.

In practice, I think it's all about proving that NATO stands united, and that war is generally undesirable.

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by melomal on Monday January 24, 2022 @07:00AM (#30056555)
Because America has never missed a war. It's too profitable.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by rambojazz on Tuesday January 25, 2022 @06:46AM (#30070756)
You make it sound like a cost, maybe it's just business?
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by joeman1000 on Monday January 24, 2022 @02:39PM (#30062798)
Ukraine can’t afford anything you arrogant fool. It’s sandwiched between two superpowers who are both hostile. If the USA has set itself up as the world democracy squad in the last hundred years, it should honour that bloody title.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by twelve40 on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:45PM (#30065799)
If the USA cared at all about "democracy" in Ukraine, it would at least try to clean up that toxic dump that is run by Kolomoyskii, Poroshenko, Akhmetov and the same greedy oligarchs and thieves for many decades now, no matter who the front clown is. But it seems like the local democracy is not really a concern as long as Ukraine can be used for other purposes.
Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by snowgrove on Monday January 24, 2022 @03:01PM (#30063156)
I don’t see how not wanting my friends and family to die in someone else’s far-away ethnic conflict makes me an “arrogant fool.” Were you also a fan of the democracy squad’s 2003 Iraq invasion? South Vietnam couldn’t “afford anything” either, and Ukraine’s democracy is at least as corrupt:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corruption_in_Ukraine

Re:U.S. weighs sending 5k troops to Eastern Europe to counte... by thomond on Monday January 24, 2022 @07:12AM (#30056676)
> Send the young Germans

And I suppose you promise not to call them Nazis if they do?