News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by TulliusCicero on Sunday January 16, 2022 @05:42AM (#29954906)
This is basically what Strong Towns harps on: the infrastructure for super low density development is extremely costly relative to how much 'stuff' you're building the infrastructure for.

Initially it's not so bad, because it takes decades before you need to do replacement-level repairs/maintenance, but eventually it catches up with you. Some cities escape it (at least for a while) by building even more or by simply having a fantastic economy, but the ones that don't...it's not pretty.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by KennyBlanken on Sunday January 16, 2022 @08:47AM (#29955934)
The problem boils down to this: we've vastly over-paved and in general overbuilt our road network. We've paved all sorts of roads we should have left as dirt/gravel, but they got paved because it's a sign your neighborhood has "made it." It's a pretty high level problem a well; we built a ton of bridges starting around the 50's, without anyone thinking about how we were going to pay for them. Well, those bridges are starting to crumble because repairing or replacing them would mean massive hikes in taxes, and no politician wants to touch that.

Ironically, the vast majority of vehicles purchased are SUVs and trucks to the point that Ford will stop selling sedans entirely. At least everyone is prepared for the coming changes?

If we hadn't allowed the automotive industry to essentially dominate american society, we'd have neighborhoods with dirt/gravel roads or narrow paved paths for walking and bicycles, neighborhood parking lots for those who own cars, functioning bus services, lots of passenger rail, etc.

Instead we have a country where we're slaves to cars.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by acdha on Sunday January 16, 2022 @09:04AM (#29956042)
The other big thing was identifying the ideal as a detached single family house with a large lawn and dense housing as mostly for poor, likely brown, people with a few exceptions for rich people in desirable locations. Even things like condos have something of a “hasn’t made it” stigma for a lot of people, and that kind of thinking really locks in a lot of inefficient land use.

Awhile back I read an observation which really stuck with me questioning how much of the nostalgia many people have for college is due to that being the closest many Americans come to living in a walkable, high-density environment. Most people could do a lot better than 1-2 hours a day in solo car travel soaks up.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by rayiner on Sunday January 16, 2022 @01:34PM (#29958546)
"Brown" people love single family detached houses with large lawns. My Bangladeshi family members who immigrated to Queens moved to Long Island as soon as they were able to afford to do so. One of the major demographic shifts in this country is upwardly mobile Black people leaving cities to move to the suburbs: https://calmatters.org/projects/california-black-population-... https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2021/12/07/chicago-bl...

I like "walkable, high-density environments" myself, but most people who care about that are highly educated white people and white-adjacent minorities. Which is fine! Urbanism is compelling on its own merits. You don't have to "brown wash" it.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by acdha on Sunday January 16, 2022 @02:04PM (#29958814)
You’ll note that I was talking about how things are popularly portrayed, especially in the past — think about how “urban” became a popular euphemism when its literal meaning says nothing about about race. It’s not a coincidence that those images shifted notably after desegregation became the law of the land and that was enshrined as the way to know you’d made it for decades, and it’s certainly not a coincidence that almost everyone picked it up given how pervasive it was in mainstream discourse.

Once that became established, a lot of inefficiency was baked in: single-family rather than shared housing, driving yourself in a car rather than sharing a bus with strangers, not building things like sidewalks or favoring cul de sac designs to discourage non-residents traveling through a neighborhood, etc. You don’t need to know or care about the history half a century ago to think of those as the default when they’re what a lot of us were raised in and saw on TV/movies.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by rayiner on Sunday January 16, 2022 @03:49PM (#29959851)
I still don’t understand the point of the race angle. Insofar as “urban” is undesirable because it’s a euphemism for “brown,” why would “brown” people be striving to move out of urban areas themselves? Bangladeshi immigrants don’t mind that Queens is full of other Bangladeshis. They mind that it’s crowded, you don’t have a big back yard, you have to walk everywhere, etc. The things you mention—shared housing, non-residents traveling though, aren’t things that “brown” people like any more than white people.

I think you’ve got the causality reversed. Most people, regardless of race, find suburban living more pleasant and more convenient. Urban areas tend to be more “brown” because that’s often where immigrants start out, because “brown” people tend to be younger and lower income, etc. Thus, whites are more able to attain the goal of suburban living. But it’s misleading to make it sound like the suburban preference arises out of white dislike for “brown” people, because the preference seems pretty uniform between races. (If anything, affluent people who prefer urban living are more likely to be white, judging from the demographics of gentrification.)

Urbanists have a good point that the suburban preference might be different if people in the suburbs were forced to bear the externalities of their lifestyle. But that has nothing to do with race.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by relaxing on Sunday January 16, 2022 @04:29PM (#29960300)
The point is why there’s resistance to dense urban living. You seem intent on having a different argument entirely. It’s ok, no one’s saying people of color are supposed to inherently dislike the suburbs.

That some hipsters have found renewed value in density (mainly access to “culture”) is a separate, parallel development.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by rayiner on Sunday January 16, 2022 @11:55PM (#29963458)
> The point is why there’s resistance to dense urban living.

Right—and OP theorized it was driven by associating “urban” living with “brown people.” My point is that this isn’t the reason, because “brown people” resist dense urban living as well and avoid it when they can afford suburban living.

(Mostly white) hipsters finding renewed value in density is fine. My objection is them working the “brown people” angle to make their cause more politically sympathetic.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by rayiner on Monday January 17, 2022 @11:54AM (#29968534)
To follow-up in that: as affluent urban professionals have become more progressive, “brown washing” of political issues has become a real problem. I think they realize that mostly white upper middle class professionals aren’t politically sympathetic blocs. So they project issues they disproportionately care about (urbanism, student loan debt relief, climate change) onto “brown people.”

Elizabeth Warren’s campaign did this extensively. Her voters on Super Tuesday were almost 80% white, out of an electorate (mostly southern and southwestern) that’s majority minority. But Warren tried to insert a racial angle into every issue.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by relaxing on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @10:18AM (#29994657)
Of course it’s the reason. It doesn’t matter if brown people do or don’t want to be in urban areas, the fact is they are there in greater numbers, and that keeps white folks away.

So I get it now, your angle here is the unfair presumption that POC are politically liberal. Which is fine, but the issue is tangential to the conversation about suburban density and urban renewal.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by acdha on Sunday January 16, 2022 @05:44PM (#29961158)
Do you really think it’s a just a random coincidence that suburbanization dramatically accelerated after the key civil rights era cases prevented cities from segregating city services? A ton of the suburbs had racial covenants, there was explicit imagery around who your kids would be going to school with, realtors and mortgages tried hard to steer people into certain areas, police departments were famous for following black or Latino drivers around if they entered a white suburb, etc. That lasted for decades — Palm Beach police did ID checks on black motorists to learn which resident hired them into the 1980s! — and one of the big things keeping it alive was this constant narrative that there were lawless hordes ready to leave the inner city and rampage through your neighborhood.

I don’t think it’s the only factor but I find it very hard to believe that decades of that imagery, often openly embraced by the political candidates those neighborhoods voted for, was coming from nowhere. Absent that, I think there would have been a very different arc for American cities between WWII and the turn of the century.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by rayiner on Monday January 17, 2022 @08:05AM (#29966129)
Suburbanization happened all over the world around that time. E.g. Amsterdam: https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2015/may/05/amsterdam-bic.... It happened more in the US than Europe because we had big swaths of empty land while Europe was much more developed already. And it happened as well in American cities that had no segregation to begin with, or non-whites to flee from.

“White flight” happened, but I think urbanists misunderstand the causality. The 1960s economic and technological revolution allowed people to enjoy comfortable suburban lives. Black people were prevented from doing so by economic circumstances and discrimination. But the impulse to leave to city wasn’t caused by that.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by pastage on Thursday January 20, 2022 @02:06AM (#30005704)
Over here in Sweden there was a massive investment in public transport and I think it's called transportation driviven development. So we did not get the same amount of dettached housing. The view of suburbs as comfortable has always been away to exploit the commons of cities like Galesburg. It's not only Galesburg that pays for this, it's the surrounding towns. People live in the suburbs of Galesburg travel to another town making it impossible to use public transport unless everyone works in a star network topology.

We are seeing that develooment in Stockholm now work is much more organic so and the rays of the star are over burdened by suburb transportation (public true, but mostly private).

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by woah on Sunday January 16, 2022 @05:25PM (#29960925)
> Most people, regardless of race, find suburban living more pleasant and more convenient.

This is very easy to disprove: houses and apartments in urban areas cost more than in the suburbs.

Most people are not able to afford a large enough apartment downtown because there is not enough supply, and so they prefer to pay the same for a larger place in the suburbs, but this is not the same as preferring the suburbs.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by rayiner on Monday January 17, 2022 @12:03AM (#29963499)
> This is very easy to disprove: houses and apartments in urban areas cost more than in the suburbs.

No. Prices are a function of both supply and demand. Demand for housing in cities is high relative to the supply of housing in cities. That doesn’t mean that the demand for urban housing is more than the demand for suburban housing—because the supply of the latter is vastly larger.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by rdtwo on Sunday January 16, 2022 @10:09PM (#29962936)
It’s simply easier to manage problems in suburbia because smaller cities are more efficient and have lower overhead.

You can create semi private public schools through high property prices and zoning.

You can kick homeless people out.

You can mostly manage a 5-10 person police force

And really you can create zones where people are mostly like you what ever that likeness may be.

Some would say that shouldn’t be allowed but you can see the appeal.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by woodruffw on Sunday January 16, 2022 @01:48PM (#29958676)
I interpreted the parent's comment as a reference to post-war deurbanization and "white flight," further fueled by openly discriminatory lending and occupation policies (redlining, etc.) at all levels of government and business.

Reurbanization by wealthy whites (and deurbanization by some minority groups) are part and parcel with the earlier trend, and don't entirely subvert it.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by tptacek on Monday January 17, 2022 @11:18AM (#29968100)
Black folks, too, as you can see from the phenomenon of the South Side of Chicago hemorrhaging residents to south suburbs like Olympia Fields. It's also, as I understand it, the story of the ringed suburbs of St. Louis.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by dionidium on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @10:28AM (#29994830)
The highest rates of population decline in the City of St. Louis are indeed on the mostly-black Northside, as those residents move to the North St. Louis County suburbs. See here:

https://www.stlouis-mo.gov/government/departments/planning/r...

It's been like this for almost two decades now (north is to the right on this map):

https://nextcity.org/images/made/5529440117_600_350_80.jpeg

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by subroutine on Sunday January 16, 2022 @09:52AM (#29956406)
Galesburg Illinois has a total population of 30k people, so nobody in Galesburg is spending 2 hours in a car unless they're commuting to another state.

I grew up not far from Galesburg, in a town roughly the same size. Many of the rural subdivision roads outside of downtown are paved with chipseal [1] rather than asphalt concrete or portland cement. While chipseal is certainly not as nice as concrete to drive on, it is much cheaper to maintain. I remember the road in front of my house getting re-treated every few years. Meanwhile the paved blvd connecting all these subdivisions hasn't been maintenanced since the 1980s, and is turning to rubble. So I personally think the problem (at least for small-ish midwestern towns) is the bias of state DOTs towards creating new infrastructure (paving new roadways / bridges) over maintaining the infrastructure they've already built (there's no ribbon-cutting ceremony when you're just filling potholes). Of course, this mentality only exacerbates the problem.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Road_surface#Bituminous_surfac...

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by acdha on Sunday January 16, 2022 @11:19AM (#29957232)
> Galesburg Illinois has a total population of 30k people, so nobody in Galesburg is spending 2 hours in a car unless they're commuting to another state.

Yes, that's why that was the upper range. Note also that I did not restrict it to commuting — designing around car-only transportation means that almost every common activity becomes time spent immobile in a car, and people famously underestimate the amount of time they spend driving, looking for parking, etc. — usually “a 20 minute drive” means “25 minutes if you exceed the speed limit, hit every light, and there's minimal traffic and parking right in front”. If you start measuring that, you realize how much time people spend on things like unnecessary (we have relatives who'll spend an hour going shopping for like half a bag of groceries) or single purpose errands in addition to commuting.

> So I personally think the problem (at least for small-ish midwestern towns) is the bias of state DOTs towards creating new infrastructure (paving new roadways / bridges) over maintaining the infrastructure they've already built

Definitely — and one big factor for this is that single-occupancy vehicles are extremely inefficient so there's always this call to add more lanes or a bypass road to “defeat” traffic, but that reliably encourages more usage so conditions usually only improve for a few months after opening.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by kragen on Sunday January 16, 2022 @07:18PM (#29961912)
Commuting to Davenport is pretty common, isn't it?
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by subroutine on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @12:09AM (#29975367)
Perhaps, but stacking houses into condos in Galesburg isn't going to change that. It seems like OP is suggesting that traffic is a problem (causing 2 hours in a car) that can be remedied by building up instead of out. The point I am making is that traffic is not a problem in Galesburg.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by kragen on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @07:20PM (#30002468)
Yeah, you aren't going to take 2 hours to get to downtown Galesburg unless you're riding a tricycle.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by pandaman on Sunday January 16, 2022 @05:26PM (#29960943)
Do you mean there is some conspiracy that made people believe that not sharing walls and ceilings with others is somehow better than being always up to date on your neighbors business including their music preferences and substances they like to consume?

I find this very implausible. I grew up in Soviet block and all my friends and relatives grew in very dense small apartments yet all of them who could afford moved to houses as soon as they could.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by acdha on Sunday January 16, 2022 @05:32PM (#29960997)
Millions of people make that work and there are many advantages: it’s cheaper, more energy efficient, and if you drive less it’s healthier and safer for you and your neighbors. If you want to be social, like music, want a variety of healthy local businesses, etc. having considerably more people makes that work better.

My point was that when one style of living was picked as the goal and heavily promoted by policy it locked in a lot of negative outcomes like traffic jams and challenging local government finances.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by wkearney99 on Sunday January 16, 2022 @06:43PM (#29961653)
It sure seems like you're trying to force a perspective without taking some fundamental human nature factors into account. Or deliberately ignoring them. But I'll go with just not realizing one thing... there's a lot of things about close quarters residency that a great many people ACTIVELY F'ING DESPISE. Noise, smells, and just... well, meet enough people and you may develop slightly less positive opinions of them as a whole and choose to live with some degree of space/separation that's not "ideal" from an efficiency standpoint.

Sure, the numbers say living like a meat popsicle is absolutely more 'cost effective' but that's a hard-pass from me.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by acdha on Sunday January 16, 2022 @08:23PM (#29962338)
Great - if you read my comment more carefully, note that I’m not saying you shouldn’t be able to live in suburb, but that that lifestyle choice should not be subsidized by everyone else.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by pandaman on Sunday January 16, 2022 @05:47PM (#29961188)
This style existed since antiquity. Even Roman patricians lived in villas, which were standalone houses.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by acdha on Sunday January 16, 2022 @06:33PM (#29961576)
I’m aware. Note how I specifically highlighted the imbalance caused by pretending it was the best option which most of the country was told to aspire to.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by pandaman on Sunday January 16, 2022 @06:44PM (#29961664)
So who told Roman nobility to pretend they liked to live in their own houses and forced them out of lovely insulae with all the people living nearby and music and social life? I am guessing the "corporate media" is telling this to the people now, but who had been doing this all through the history before the printing press had been invented?
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by acdha on Sunday January 16, 2022 @08:20PM (#29962313)
Sure, lots of people want to live like nobility but that doesn’t make it practical. Consider that when I wrote “the ideal” I was referring to the practicality of having a single style pushed as the goal for everyone. I don’t think suburbs should be banned but I do think they should be sustainably self-funding and that cities should reverse course and favor their own residents over car commuters.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by pandaman on Sunday January 16, 2022 @08:41PM (#29962453)
I am not arguing practicality, I was just curious about the whole idea that people don't actually like to live separately and had been tricked into liking that by some unnamed forces. Obviously many people cannot afford the lifestyle they desire, I dare say nobody can. Even Elon Musk probably wants to live in a flying castle on Mars yet he has to make do with various mansions on Earth, such is life.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by talideon on Sunday January 16, 2022 @07:33PM (#29962010)
Yes, patricians. That's a hint this kind of thing isn't sustainable when everyone is doing it.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by pandaman on Sunday January 16, 2022 @07:46PM (#29962112)
This is also a hint that people were not told to pretend they like it, is not it? Rich and powerful all through the history do not shun low density living and personal transport yet the message that I've replied to asserts that people only want these things because they are told to pretend they are desirable but without external influence people would rather live in apartments and have no personal transport.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by talideon on Monday January 17, 2022 @08:21AM (#29966256)
At this point even out "patricians" shouldn't really be living in low density housing either.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by pandaman on Monday January 17, 2022 @11:25AM (#29968188)
So you are not even arguing practicality, it's just straight up class conflict for you? Color me unsurprised.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by talideon on Thursday January 20, 2022 @11:51AM (#30011380)
WTF are you even talking about?

You were contrasting a world that had about 150,000,000 people living it with today where we have about 7,800,000,000.

It's nothing to do with "class conflict", and all to do with load bearing. As things stand, we only just have the resources to support a fraction of those at Western living standards, and we damned well can't support the billions who haven't achieved them yet as things stand.

So yes, it's all about practicality.

And you and I are amongst the "patricians" already.

Also, don't pretend you know me at all.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by pandaman on Thursday January 20, 2022 @08:57PM (#30018241)
If it had nothing to do with the class conflict then you would not care how rich people live because rich accommodations do not create any noticeable load. And as for practicality - somebody living in a big house would not make your apartment any less practical yet you think everybody has to live like you.

I don't know if you are fooling yourself into thinking you are being rational and caring for environment and practicality but you are not fooling me.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by rexreed on Sunday January 16, 2022 @08:55AM (#29955994)
Many Roman roads have lasted a long while. Maybe we should move back to cobble stone? Certainly easier to patch and replace and open up for underground utilities.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by occz on Sunday January 16, 2022 @02:11PM (#29958873)
The roman roads didn't have to bear the load that modern roads do. Road wear is approximately (weight^4 ), meaning that the only vehicles that even matter in the calculation are trucks.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by mitigating on Sunday January 16, 2022 @10:27AM (#29956709)
Can you really drive on those at high speeds, is it dangerous? There's a few short blocks in NYC that are still cobblestone and even at 30mph it sucks.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by warning26 on Sunday January 16, 2022 @10:51AM (#29956934)
Honestly on some roads, I'd argue that's a feature.

It's ridiculous when there is a wide, flat, straight asphalt road surface with a speed limit of 25mph. Build it out of cobblestones, and 25mph suddenly feels a lot faster!

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by rexreed on Sunday January 16, 2022 @12:59PM (#29958225)
Indeed, that's the core of the argument made in this article here (from 2009) which is arguing for a return to cobbles / bricks for Georgetown: https://georgetownmetropolitan.com/2009/01/16/why-not-allow-...
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by mark-r on Sunday January 16, 2022 @02:08PM (#29958851)
The problem is that today's cobblestones are pale imitations of the old ones, and won't last nearly as long. There's a parking lot near me built about 5 years ago, and they tried to be decorative with part of it and made it from concrete shaped to look like cobblestones. Because of the grooves and surface treatment it is much weaker than standard concrete, and it's crumbling.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by prawn on Sunday January 16, 2022 @08:36PM (#29962424)
I'm with you on the speed reduction. An urban planner friend talks about how you're best motivating a speed limit by the environment (tighter road, bends, etc) rather than a literal limit and threat of fine.

But how would cyclists fare on cobblestones, especially if you were talking about suburban streets with kids playing, bikes going around, etc?

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by TulliusCicero on Sunday January 16, 2022 @09:57PM (#29962875)
It's not great, but if it gets cars to go slower I think it's still worth it.

Really painful and annoying to ride on with a kick scooter though.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by Naga on Sunday January 16, 2022 @11:40AM (#29957426)
I'm assuming you're speaking tongue in cheek, but I thought about why we have problems that the Romans didn't.

I don't know about ease of maintenance and access to utilities, but Romans did not have trucks that destroyed the roads (the ratio of weight of vehicles to the wear on the road is exponential, not linear), but I have no concept of how cobblestone is affected by trucks. Roman roads are also affected by survivorship bias (we see the roads that survived, not 90% of the roads that haven't) and they were not affected as much by freeze/thaw cycles as North American roads are.

My intutition says that they also probably were not generally as wide as North American roads. Drivers here have an expectation of being able to drive at high speeds without worrying about passing on coming traffic - Pictures I've seen of Roman highways were not two wagons wide. Less road width means less maintenance since there's physically less roads.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by rexreed on Sunday January 16, 2022 @12:58PM (#29958211)
Yes, somewhat tongue in cheek, but it's an interesting thought exercise. For the high traffic streets where there is high speed and also lots of heavy traffic, for sure, asphalt dominates for many good reasons.

But for the problems this article discusses for smaller cities where their population has moved to suburbs and exurbs and where the commercial centers have similarly moved out of city core, perhaps the more durable approach to cobbles (or brick) might be an interesting way to address ongoing maintenance challenges. It's mostly a thought exercise, but an interesting one.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by op00to on Sunday January 16, 2022 @10:06AM (#29956530)
The Roman roads that last a long time are outliers. Most Roman roads are long gone.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by m0llusk on Sunday January 16, 2022 @04:00PM (#29959983)
Roman roads were built with extremely robust foundations below which required very large amounts of labor to put in place.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by throwawayboise on Sunday January 16, 2022 @05:12PM (#29960782)
We have excavators, bulldozers, graders, etc, we don't need to use slaves to hand-dig road foundations.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by aperson_hello on Sunday January 16, 2022 @09:19AM (#29956165)
To be fair, the "SUVs" that are being sold are effectively the same as station wagons of the past (but smaller and with better gas mileage).

Hopefully self-driving cars will get us out of this pit of car-centric infrastructure, but that's a solution that's been a few years out for the past decade.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by plorg on Sunday January 16, 2022 @01:13PM (#29958358)
Can you outline how this is supposed to free us from car-centric infrastructure? Unless it's coupled with style kind of Uber-subscription dystopia we would still need room to park all of these vehicles. While downtown parking can be a problem, garages aren't, and neither of these problems is on there scale of the larger infrastructure problems.

The biggest problems with car-centric infrastructure are that they require a huge amount of ever-larger roads to funnel people (in cars) often tens of miles to do anything. Even in the rent-a-taxi scenario you would still need these roads, which would probably need more maintenance, not less. And all of that sprawl has knock-on effects as roads create divisions in communities, and low-density housing, enabled by car infrastructure, means you have and know fewer neighbors.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by mark-r on Sunday January 16, 2022 @02:03PM (#29958799)
At least the Uber-style infrastructure doesn't require oversizing everything. Even if my car is used 90% of the time for commuting by myself, it has to be big enough for the other 10% of the time when I'm taking the family and our luggage.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by TulliusCicero on Sunday January 16, 2022 @04:34PM (#29960352)
I think it's fine roads are paved. It's just that said roads are wider and effectively longer to service the same number of people, and this is due to zoning and the way property tax is handled.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by mitigating on Sunday January 16, 2022 @10:24AM (#29956682)
This might be ideal for side roads leading to a few houses but if it's major parts of a town aren't you just move the cost of roads somewhere else?

i.e. "I hope you can afford a truck, SUV, or constant repairs to your suspensions/tires"

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by mark-r on Sunday January 16, 2022 @01:53PM (#29958721)
I'm pretty sure that if a bridge collapses underneath you, you're just as likely to die in a SUV as in a sedan.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by mark-r on Sunday January 16, 2022 @11:03PM (#29963186)
For anyone who thinks I might be being facetious, I live in Minneapolis where there was an actual bridge collapse that killed people: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I-35W_Mississippi_River_bridge...
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by trinovantes on Sunday January 16, 2022 @01:57PM (#29958755)
Many suburban cities in Canada like Mississauga are also experiencing this. They've finally ran out of land to sell so they started raising property taxes and instituted levies

https://www.theglobeandmail.com/canada/article-mississauga-a...

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by defaultname on Sunday January 16, 2022 @02:17PM (#29958941)
Mississauga has a density of 2467 people per square kilometer. Mississauga neighbourhoods look like this-

https://www.google.ca/maps/@43.5675623,-79.740886,916m/data=...

That isn't apartment building density, but that's about as dense as single family homes can get.

Mississauga had to raise property taxes somewhat -- still extremely competitive -- as a revenue source dried up. But those new neighbourhoods all easily pay for themselves in property taxes. Nonetheless, loads of really silly narrative comes out of Toronto writers, still foreboding this dire scenario that they've been pitching for well over a decade. It's a bit farcical at this point.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by ricardobeat on Sunday January 16, 2022 @03:02PM (#29959392)
> about as dense as single family homes can get

These traditional north american houses are still not very space efficient at all (large unused garden + lawn + double parking spot + garage).

“Suburban” neighborhoods in Europe easily have double or triple the density of this. I also see zero townhouses or anything with 2+ floors in that area.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by toss1 on Sunday January 16, 2022 @05:01PM (#29960671)
>>(large unused garden + lawn + double parking spot + garage)

I don't know about you, but I actively use and enjoy every one of those things.

Perhaps you enjoy apartment living and consider anything not active indoors a waste.

If so, good for you, I wouldn't want to impose a garden or a parking spot on you. By the same token, calling these out as if they could possibly not be useful, simply because you do not think them useful, is at best, a fallacy.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by magikaram on Sunday January 16, 2022 @07:44PM (#29962095)
It's been well documented that the large set back front yards and loads of anti-pedestrian designed neighborhoods and towns have largely been the cause for issues relating to poor public transportation, heat island effects, and less affordable housing.

You can have nice gardens, double parking spots & a garage without the same designed towns and neighborhoods. Most often is done by limiting street parking, narrower streets, and using the rear-entrance drives and lots as done in many cities.

Those designs also enable more pedestrian friendliness vs. the suburban sprawl that is effectively carpeting the U.S. and Canada since the 40's.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by toss1 on Sunday January 16, 2022 @09:49PM (#29962830)
>>heat island effects are not caused by yards and vegetation, but by expanses of dark asphalt and dark roofs. More vegetation vs roads/lots, and roof area is the cure, not the cause.

>>Most often is done by limiting street parking, narrower streets, and using the rear-entrance drives and lots as done in many cities.

YES, limiting on-street parking is huge.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by citrin_ru on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @03:14AM (#29976449)
If there are trees on both sides of a residential street it will not be a heat island even with on-street parking. But it seems to me many Americans don’t like trees and prefer open spaces (which inevitably work as heat islands).
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by KptMarchewa on Sunday January 16, 2022 @06:57PM (#29961757)
You can enjoy active outdoors without wasting space on concrete car desert. It's called "parks".
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by toss1 on Sunday January 16, 2022 @09:45PM (#29962801)
Lawns and gardens are not concrete (at least not mine). Also,kind of hard to grow your lunch greens in a public park. Not much solitude there either. Nothing says that you need to even need to have concrete/asphalt driveways & parking; gravel drives can be quite nice.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by neilparikh on Monday January 17, 2022 @02:02AM (#29964078)
> I don't know about you, but I actively use and enjoy every one of those things.

That's fine, as long as you pay the costs associated with those things. However, in most cities suburbs are revenue negative, and subsidized by the dense downtown areas (that don't have these).

> I wouldn't want to impose a garden or a parking spot on you.

The entire problem is that this is exactly what is done though. Zoning forces a very specific type of housing in most of the city (single family house with large lot size, garage, driveway and backyard), even for those who would be okay with or prefer something else.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by toss1 on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @12:22PM (#29982401)
>>Zoning forces a very specific type of housing in most of the city (single family house with large lot size, garage, driveway and backyard), even for those who would be okay with or prefer something else.

Are you conflating city and suburbs here? While this is obviously dependent on each city/town which has their own zoning rules, most of the locales with which I'm familiar have quite the dense-pack throughout the city, and the suburbs are out in separate towns.

>>However, in most cities suburbs are revenue negative. Again, if the suburbs are separate towns, I don't see how this affects the city budget. If the suburbs are within the city and on the same budget, I'd look at the balance of costs and revenue, and if a particular zoning district is substantially more costly, i.e., being subsidized, then it seems a rate adjustment for that zoning type would be in order...

As it is, for where I live, the town is essentially all rural/residential, with 2-acre minimums (some exceptions), 35mi from the major city, and I can say that yes, we REALLY do pay for those associated things - one of the highest tax rates in the state, and increased ~50% since moving in 15 years ago. Yes, we occasionally grumble, but I am much more happy to pay for the zoning rules that maintain an healthy ecosystem where I can see over a dozen types of birds out the window at breakfast and many other healthy populations, than I'd be even slightly interested to see densepack developments reducing my rates (I can find densepack & lower rates elsewhere, and if I wanted it, I'd have gone there)

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by ricardobeat on Sunday January 16, 2022 @10:12PM (#29962952)
I didn’t say they are useless or not enjoyable (except for front lawns which are, in fact, useless). And no I don’t live in an apartment, or would like to, though some people do.

It’s just not really necessary for every single house to have these amenities. You can have parks, public parking, and a decent sized backyard in a townhouse / attached buildings. The space gained can then be used to sustain actual life in the neighborhood such as stores, restaurants, schools, libraries and small businesses. Once you have this, you don’t need two cars, or to drive everywhere, you don’t need a large private garden to enjoy the outdoors.

Of course I’d love to live in a huge house surrounded by green. But it’s not a sustainable model for urban development.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by TulliusCicero on Monday January 17, 2022 @09:01PM (#29974069)
> If so, good for you, I wouldn't want to impose a garden or a parking spot on you. By the same token, calling these out as if they could possibly not be useful, simply because you do not think them useful, is at best, a fallacy.

This is grossly out of touch with how most of these features end up existing. Most of the time, there's a minimum setback for the front yard, minimum parking, etc. specified by local zoning ordinances.

This isn't bottom-up market-driven demand, it's top-down requirements specified by the local government for that area. So they are, in fact, imposed on whoever wants to live there.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by toss1 on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @05:16PM (#29986829)
>>This is grossly out of touch with how most of these features end up existing ... this isn't bottom-up market-driven demand, it's top-down requirements specified by the local government for that area.

Wrong. Of course it is always implemented by a local govt, but it is very much a result of demand.

I very well understand how such regs end up existing, and changing. It is very much related to demand. People are generally against zoning until they realize what it is like to live without zoning, and then it is DEMANDED by the people, and of course implemented by the govt. I've lived in a locale where zoning was first brought in, then developers managed to build a coalition against it and it was abolished, then people realized that that was shi*y, and now it is zoned again.

I've also seen and helped organize opposition to new development that would trash both neighborhoods and wetlands and endangered species habitat - when 100 neighbors come out to oppose the proposed variance, that is not some govt imposing it, it is the residents supporting their own zoning.

It may be different in larger cities with heavier corporate development influence, but I doubt it, since e.g., I'm sure there are plenty of developers who'd love to develop in San Francisco, but all I hear about is NIMBY opposition to changing neighborhood zoning holding it back. Guess what? That's not some top-down govt, it's locals supporting their own zoning.

What is out of touch is your comment inaccurately characterizing it as some faceless govt imposition.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by randallsquared on Sunday January 16, 2022 @03:47PM (#29959831)
> I also see zero townhouses or anything with 2+ floors in that area.

Maybe you meant 2+ units? 'Cause almost all of them have 2+ floors, and many will have livable basements as well.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by jcranmer on Sunday January 16, 2022 @02:28PM (#29959071)
> That isn't apartment building density, but that's about as dense as single family homes can get.

You can get a little bit denser by going full street grid--Chicago's single family home districts look to mostly be rocking ~6-9k people/km².

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by idiotsecant on Sunday January 16, 2022 @02:52PM (#29959302)
I might be the only one but I strongly prefer grid-layout cities to these winding suburb road layouts anyhow. When your city is a grid you can make street names mean something and a person can navigate from place to place easily and have an intuitive idea of how far away something is, both without a cellphone.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by AlbertCory on Sunday January 16, 2022 @03:32PM (#29959669)
I think you are the only one.

I grew up in Chicago on a perfect grid. Now I live on a street that I picked precisely because you only drive down it if you live there. I don't like the sound of cars driving past. That's a personal preference that seems pretty generalized, even among people without kids.

And on a street like that, you don't need speed bumps, because people aren't speeding down the street.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by closeparen on Sunday January 16, 2022 @04:46PM (#29960483)
But that’s the thing. The street’s utility is exclusively to the houses that are on it. Those houses are very unlikely to be paying enough property tax to cover its existence. This luxury of yours is paid for by other people’s productive activity in the future. Great deal for you! But we the (net) taxpayers ought to think about how many more of these sweetheart deals we offer to cul de sac homeowners in the future, before we bankrupt ourselves.

I’m not a libertarian, I think it’s fine for government to tap rich people to provide nice things for everyone, but this particular nice thing (way more roadway than you pay for) has a pretty bad cost:benefit, and its beneficiaries are not exactly the neediest or most deserving of aid.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by TulliusCicero on Monday January 17, 2022 @09:15PM (#29974169)
I think having some residential that's offset is fine, the problem is that almost inevitably these places are designed to be impermeable to walk/bike traffic as well, and with the long distances required to go anywhere, you do have to drive everywhere.

A positive counter-example would be Houten. Winding street layout that's not good for through traffic, but very nice for walking and especially biking: https://www.google.com/maps/@52.033207,5.1474598,3a,75y,4.09...

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by halpert on Sunday January 16, 2022 @08:13PM (#29962275)
I find it hard to believe that building a road is so expensive. Some random website I found claims the cost of a two-lane undivided road costs $3 million per mile in an urban setting. Looking at the satellite imagery of Mississauga linked elsewhere, the frontage of each house is around 50 ft. So there are about 211 houses per mile. That comes out to $14,000 per house to build the road. The approximate lifespan of an asphalt road is 18 years, leading to a per year cost of ~800 dollars. Of course, this doesn't include maintenance of the road (fixing pot holes, plowing, etc.), but $800 per year seems like a pretty manageable sum of money.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by titanomachy on Sunday January 16, 2022 @08:38PM (#29962436)
In Galesburg (the town in the article), it wasn’t a manageable amount. That town has extremely low property values compared to any towns I’m familiar with, though. The author’s single-family home is worth about $60k. The median home in Mississauga is $900k (CAD), so I assume they can afford to maintain their roads.

We’re talking about pretty different things, though. Suburbs of ultra high-cost-of-living cities have their taxes buoyed up their proximity to the big economic engines, while small towns like Galesburg have to figure out how to be self-sufficient without that constant influx of wealth.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by tptacek on Monday January 17, 2022 @11:14AM (#29968052)
The median home price in Galesburg is $90k.

Makes sense for a declining city in far-out rural Illinois.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by titanomachy on Monday January 17, 2022 @03:46PM (#29971529)
It’s an interesting question to me what these towns will do going forward. If participation in the global economy is required to maintain a first-world standard of living, what will these towns produce that the rest of the world wants?

Some will farm or extract natural resources, but these operations require fewer people than they used to, so fewer towns. Some will be holiday destinations for city-dwellers. But we will probably sustain far fewer of these towns than we have historically.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by tptacek on Monday January 17, 2022 @06:49PM (#29973054)
What do towns full of software developers produce? There are developers that like living out in the country.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by halpert on Monday January 17, 2022 @09:52PM (#29974436)
> What do towns full of software developers produce?

Software? Sure there are software developers living out in small towns, but obviously not many in this town.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by halpert on Sunday January 16, 2022 @09:15PM (#29962652)
But would more density really solve the problem? An inability to produce $800 per household will make anything hard.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by titanomachy on Monday January 17, 2022 @03:16PM (#29971219)
I was thinking this as well. I wonder how much this is just a consequence of per capita city productivity being so many times greater than small towns.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by notfromhere on Monday January 17, 2022 @10:36PM (#29974757)
More density means more people per road and less road in general. Done right, and households are not the only entities paying into the coffers
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by closeparen on Sunday January 16, 2022 @09:43PM (#29962788)
The property tax bill in TFA is $1700, but roads are only one of the things property taxes buy.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by wkearney99 on Sunday January 16, 2022 @06:29PM (#29961541)
or if not 'tap the rich', better structure the payouts so there isn't such an imbalance. wage stagnation is a BIG problem.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by slyall on Sunday January 16, 2022 @05:52PM (#29961238)
A big problem is this sort of design makes it hard to walk between places. All travel involves going to the main road, going some distance down that and then following a new branch. Queue route map that requires 10 minute drive to get to the "next block".

Not too bad in you car but it means that you can't walk or bike anywhere unless they have put in paths between blocks. Means that if a 15-year-old kids wants an ice-cream their parent has to drive them to the corner store.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by BirdieNZ on Sunday January 16, 2022 @06:07PM (#29961358)
You can have both, if you have a grid of main through-roads for transporting people around and then inside each "square" of the grid you have a continued fractal of sub-grids which aren't for through-traffic (slower speed limits, narrower streets, traffic calming measures, difference in material to make clear the difference from through-roads and local streets etc.). People traveling past won't use the inner streets because they aren't efficient for that, but people living in the neighbourhood will use the inner streets.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by fiter on Sunday January 16, 2022 @08:49PM (#29962503)
In Berkeley, CA they purposefully break up the grid for cars. So a street will be passable to pedestrians and bikes but blocked by bollards for cars. This gives the cul-de-sac effect without causing terrible walkability. Of course, traditional winding suburbs can accomplish something similar by adding pedestrian walkways through cul-de-sacs.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by asdfasgasdgasdg on Sunday January 16, 2022 @03:37PM (#29959721)
He's definitely not the only person who prefers cities to suburbs. What?

Now, I think almost everyone would prefer if their one street were not integrated into the grid. That would be the ideal. You live in a grid, but with none of the downsides. But failing that, many people opt to live in denser areas rather than the burbs, even if the cost is that folks sometimes drive down their street who are going someplace else..

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by nayuki on Sunday January 16, 2022 @06:12PM (#29961401)
There's a good video explaining how urban and suburban residents alike want less traffic in their neighborhoods: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dqQw05Mr63E
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by TulliusCicero on Monday January 17, 2022 @09:13PM (#29974154)
> I grew up in Chicago on a perfect grid. Now I live on a street that I picked precisely because you only drive down it if you live there. I don't like the sound of cars driving past. That's a personal preference that seems pretty generalized, even among people without kids.

Well, you could still get this, more or less, with a grid, like Barcelona's superblocks.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by tptacek on Monday January 17, 2022 @11:13AM (#29968040)
Most of Chicago has adapted against that problem: streets are now artificially cul-de-sac'd to cap them near arteries, so neighborhoods have explicitly designed traffic flows. It works reasonably well (I'm in Oak Park, not Chicago, but same deal). Obviously, you'd get less traffic in Glenview or whatever.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by KptMarchewa on Sunday January 16, 2022 @06:59PM (#29961776)
Are American cardboard walls and windows actually that bad that you can hear cars through them?
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by titanomachy on Sunday January 16, 2022 @08:42PM (#29962457)
As someone who lives in a recently built American house in a dense urban area: yes, definitely. It’s quiet enough that I can tune them out, mostly.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by pxeboot on Sunday January 16, 2022 @07:25PM (#29961959)
Cars? Probably not. Loud trucks/motorcycles? Absolutely.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by mech422 on Sunday January 16, 2022 @07:02PM (#29961804)
Yeah - Phoenix has a basically 1 mile grid, with lil side streets in-between the major intersections.

I hate it, because if you miss a turn, you basically have to go another full mile to hit another 'cross street'.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by toofy on Sunday January 16, 2022 @03:27PM (#29959620)
you’re definitely not the only one. grids make much more sense. and not only for ease of navigation.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by TulliusCicero on Sunday January 16, 2022 @03:17PM (#29959530)
> That isn't apartment building density, but that's about as dense as single family homes can get.

Roughly the equivalent of pointing to IBM as the most high paying and prestigious tech companies can get.

It would be trivial to increase the density there by reducing setback requirements, narrowing the roads, removing minimum parking requirements.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by Retric on Sunday January 16, 2022 @09:14AM (#29956117)
> Initially it’s not so bad

This assumes it’s significantly cheaper to build new roads than to rebuild them which seems false on the surface. It could be that replacing more roads at the same time would drive down costs. If replacing ~600’ of roads is 600$/foot how about replacing 10 miles of roads?

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by burlesona on Sunday January 16, 2022 @11:11AM (#29957125)
Actually the cost of initial construction and future reconstruction is about the same. The problem is the initial construction is heavily subsidized either by State or Federal "growth" grants, or by developers who financialize the whole thing through the sale of federally subsidized development loans.

In theory what should happen is the resulting development pays enough taxes to pay for all the infrastructure it depends on to be rebuilt as needed (typically every 15-30 years depending on which kind of infra we're talking about). But in practice the taxes are not actually linked to the cost of infrastructure (they are much too low) and not enough funds are collected to maintain the infra.

This is managed by a shell game where fees from new developments (who just financialized their new infra) are used to pay the maintenance on old projects that are losing money, and where federal subsidies for growth and expansion are contorted to uses like widening a scarcely used road that is falling part (bc. the feds will pay to expand but not to maintain) - which solves the problem for now by making it even worse for the next generation.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by xyzzyz on Sunday January 16, 2022 @01:55PM (#29958744)
> The problem is the initial construction is heavily subsidized either by State or Federal "growth" grants, or by developers who financialize the whole thing through the sale of federally subsidized development loans.

Cities also "financialize" the whole thing by selling bonds. The real difference is that when the developers originally build roads at their own expense (recouping it by the sale of the properties they developed), they pay much less than what the city then pays later to repave them. If you frame the question instead "why does the government pay so much more than private companies for the same products and services", it pretty much answers itself.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by wkearney99 on Sunday January 16, 2022 @06:31PM (#29961557)
this also exposes the fantasy of the private sector doing all the work at a lesser rate, versus having many infrastructure things like this done at a governmental level.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by pixl97 on Sunday January 16, 2022 @11:34AM (#29957367)
Roads aren't just roads. They are sewer pipes, water pipes, gas pipes, telecommunication lines, and power lines. These items age and also need replaced. Not sure how much remodeling you've ever done, but refits are more expensive than having something built in a new structure. It gets even more expensive when this infrastructure is in use while you're upgrading it.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by matkoniecz on Sunday January 16, 2022 @09:21AM (#29956176)
Maybe it is caused by rising standards and rising human labor costs?

There are many stories where rebuilding or just renovation of a bridge was vastly more expensive than constructing it 50 or 100 years ago (yes, obviously after adjusting for inflation).

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by KptMarchewa on Sunday January 16, 2022 @07:02PM (#29961798)
Construction is the only sector where real productivity decreased.

https://www.curt.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/Productivity...

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by trhway on Sunday January 16, 2022 @04:23PM (#29960234)
Also include the "management/administrative tax" - these days mid-management is much thicker and consumes and wastes tremendously more resources.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by acdha on Sunday January 16, 2022 @07:16PM (#29961898)
Not just “mid-management” but subcontracting. This is especially bad in government projects because you have challenges around selecting bidders fairly and if you don’t have enough civil servants doing the same jobs at similar pay it can be hard to have people on the government side who are capable of adequately overseeing a project of that scale. If you end up hiring multiple contractors, you’re guaranteeing a lot of overhead even if it goes well and plenty of chances for a 3+ way blame-shifting exercise if it doesn’t.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by m0llusk on Sunday January 16, 2022 @03:55PM (#29959926)
No, that is only true when focusing on large infrastructure items like bridges and the really scary numbers only show up when bizarre outliers like the NYC Second Avenue subway are included.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by rout39574 on Sunday January 16, 2022 @10:51AM (#29956941)
Roads are initially built with the promise of future returns in mind. These estimates of future returns tend to be affected by developers, who are acting to encourage the approval of development projects.

Rebuilding projects are contemplated in the shadow of actual returns, which are harder to lie about.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by pstoll on Sunday January 16, 2022 @11:00AM (#29957006)
> Roads are initially built with the promise of future returns in mind.

Roads are like startups! We should get VCs in on the action.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by iratewizard on Sunday January 16, 2022 @02:15PM (#29958916)
If a road could get a cut of all attached business's revenue, and revenues shifted back towards small businesses (i.e. away from mega corps), I could see private roads being a boon and lawsuits forcing regular, quality maintenance. In practice, though, I'm sure it would get muddy quick.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by kbenson on Sunday January 16, 2022 @03:11PM (#29959482)
> I'm sure it would get muddy quick.

I see what you did there...

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by silvestrov on Sunday January 16, 2022 @11:00AM (#29957017)
You get money from the initial sale of the lot. This convers the cost of initial construction.

After the sale, the town only gets tax revenue which is a lot less.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by throwawayboise on Sunday January 16, 2022 @05:03PM (#29960685)
Why not do a traffic study and determine what percentage of the traffic on a road is using the road to get to adjacent properties, and what percentage is transiting through the area. Tax those adjacent properties that percentage of maintenance costs of the road. So a large mall presumably would be taxed for a fairly large share of the costs of maintaing roads that feed customers into the mall. In cases where there are roads that don't really go anywhere else, they would pay 100% of the costs of maintaining those roads. If 50% of the traffic enters the mall, they pay 50% of the costs of those roads and the city is responsible for the other 50%.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by acdha on Sunday January 16, 2022 @07:22PM (#29961941)
It’s a good idea but tricky to do at scale: the catchment area of a mall is measured in miles, some people would scream about big brother, and places like the mall would argue that their jobs and tax revenue mean they shouldn’t get taxed at the same rate.

If I had to do this, I’d try to figure out a privacy-preserving way to record Bluetooth IDs since most cars have Bluetooth beacons those now and try to do it regionally so you could address questions of fairness (e.g. I go to 4 places doing errands. How much does each one get assessed?). You’d also need to do this regularly to avoid sampling skew (how much does peak holiday demand at the mall count for?) and that really means you’d need to have a robust privacy policy with teeth.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by dantheman on Sunday January 16, 2022 @09:19AM (#29956162)
Most of the time the roads are built with grants from the state or federal government.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by Retric on Sunday January 16, 2022 @09:33AM (#29956259)
I was assuming based on the age of the town they where continuously paying for roads, grants make this much easier.

If they didn’t have to pay for the roads to begin with they have 30 years to set aside money for the replacement. Even minimal interest would drastically reduce their out of pocket costs. Grants turn this into a question of bad fiscal management, which is definitely an issue but says little about how much infrastructure they have.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by yellowbeard on Sunday January 16, 2022 @09:29AM (#29956233)
Or by developers
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by acdha on Sunday January 16, 2022 @10:06AM (#29956529)
This is also a problem if they don’t have good oversight: the developers often cut corners or build something which will look good when they’re selling units but costs more to maintain.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by ashtonkem on Sunday January 16, 2022 @06:57PM (#29961756)
The issue isn’t that the developers cut corners though. The best designed roads just aren’t going to last long enough to change the math.

It’s also not the developers job to consider the long term maintenance and tax implications of these developments. That’s the responsibility of the city itself through plan approval and zoning.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by tomohawk on Sunday January 16, 2022 @11:50AM (#29957522)
What Strong Towns hasn't figured out, but which is obvious to everyone else, is that cities have really bad failure modes. Unfixable failure modes.

The people running the cities run them into the ground by applying more and more gold plating to the services they provide, making sure to lard the contracts for their friends who keep them elected, and pursuing their luxury beliefs through unworkable policies. Eventually it all collapses and is irretrievable. Then they whine about being underfunded. If only they had more money, they could make their luxury beliefs work.

People move out of cities because they do not feel safe, and the services suck.

It's really the only option they have, since the people running the cities are completely unaccountable.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by eldavido on Sunday January 16, 2022 @02:44PM (#29959229)
I think this is an insightful comment and I'm sorry to see it get downvoted.

I live in a large condo building. It has its pros and cons. It's great, in theory--750-1000 people pooling their expertise and funds to tackle infrastructure issues. Great recent example: we fixed a sewer lateral (the pipe that connects to the sewer under the building). Three of them, total cost 200k. Sounds a lot until you realize we spread it across ~350 units (600/unit), which is roughly 1/10th what a typical suburban homeowner would pay for the same thing.

The other side of the coin is that, in larger political structures, governance REALLY matters. You can end up with a relatively well-run condo like mine, or a large, wasteful organization that squanders obscene sums on pet projects and outright corruption.

Many people don't even know this, but SF has been under federal investigation for high-level corruption in the public works department for over a year [1]. The thrust of your comment is correct. Large cities attract large amounts of money, much of which gets wasted, or ends up lining pockets in hard, or even "soft" corruption, with jobs and contracts steered to friends (qualified or not) via patronage networks.

What I think you miss though, is that there's a middle ground. You don't have to be either extreme drive-everywhere suburbia, or a giant mega-city like Beijing or New York. My home town, Homewood, IL, is a nice, walkable city of about 20,000, with a nice downtown, plenty to do, and relatively honest (if not always saintly) government.

The mid-size towns and suburbs can do a lot more to encourage the kind of urbanism the author calls for. Getting explicit about cultivating nice, walkable downtowns is a start. Many, including Homewood, don't, because "development" and "jobs" are seen as unqualified goods, without thinking about the cost side of the equation (roads, plumbing, etc required to service this stuff).

I've written for Strong Towns. What they get most right is that (1) LAND is the scare resource in a town, and (2) cities should explicitly encourage uses that lead to the highest taxable value of that land. Big box retail isn't this. Denser housing and retail districts (I own one of these buildings), is. The numbers on this are simple and don't lie.

[1] https://www.sfchronicle.com/sf/article/Mohammed-Nuru-to-sett...

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by tomohawk on Sunday January 16, 2022 @08:49PM (#29962504)
I agree that it would be great if we could get to that, but I've lived near cities that are in aggressive decline for more than 30 years as an adult. Prior to that, they were in decline for 20 or more years. One nearby city lost an average of 20k people a year for decades.

I once talked to a guy who had been a 3 star general in the army. He was a logistics guy. He had gone to a school in that city that had been prestigious back when he was a kid. He wanted to give back and maybe bring back what had been there, so went through Gate's program, and became the superintendant of schools there. He left after a year. Said it was the hardest job he ever did, and didn't think he made one bit of difference.

He wasn't hopeful that anything would make any difference. Money was not the problem. Per pupil spending was high. Assistance from the state was high. The elites in control of the politics were the problem. Probably too much money was the problem.

If you don't have the ability to make your schools perform basic functions and keep kids safe while they're doing it, then who will live there?

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by TulliusCicero on Monday January 17, 2022 @09:19PM (#29974197)
> I think this is an insightful comment and I'm sorry to see it get downvoted.

The comment was written with clearly flamebait-level phrasing: "lard", "gold plating", "luxury beliefs", "whine about being underfunded", etc. so it's actually good if it got downvoted.

Additionally, it's flatly wrong about the facts: people have been moving into cities, out of rural areas, for decades now. There's little to recommend in a comment that's grossly incorrect and also written in a way seemingly intended to rile people up.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by prawn on Sunday January 16, 2022 @08:51PM (#29962516)
I'm guessing governance is an issue at almost any scale. You hear of painful HOAs, of strata corporations (our equivalent), councils/towns, cities, etc. Where I live (in Australia) there are constant issues with council staff running up legal bills (at taxpayer expense) over petty personality squabbles (e.g., someone said something abuse at a meeting and started a multi-year drama). It's idiotic, and seems to happen in more councils than not.

My argument against the GP comment would be that regional areas would surely have the same problems of maintenance, just without the efficiencies of density. Maintaining longer roads, pipes and cables, still dealing with bridges, etc.

Surely part of the solution is working out what level of 'polish' you want in your area (paved road vs gravel, as one example) and deciding honestly what scale of funding will pay for it now and in the future?

The quality of roads, footpaths and services in my suburb are generally very good. My council rates (AU$2900/yr) scale with the valuation of my property. Concessions for pensioners, but no rate pausing or whatever some parts of the US have.

Separately, we have a fuel excise (40-50c per litre of fuel) which is used to fund federal road projects. Obviously that has a limited shelf life with a shift to EVs and has already been in decline through the fuel efficiency of modern cars.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by TulliusCicero on Sunday January 16, 2022 @03:27PM (#29959623)
What even are you talking about? The trend for the past several decades is people moving out of rural areas, into urban ones.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by dang on Monday January 17, 2022 @04:51PM (#29972094)
Please don't break the site guidelines like this. It's enough to respectfully provide correct information.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by TulliusCicero on Monday January 17, 2022 @09:08PM (#29974121)
"What even are you talking about?" is too aggro? Okay. I guess I responded that way because of the clearly flamebait/trolling phrasing in the comment I responded to, but I'll try to do better.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by ashtonkem on Sunday January 16, 2022 @06:30PM (#29961543)
Critically the initial cost is born by developers and higher levels of government, either out of profits or general tax receipts. It’s when the maintenance comes due that the problems start, as the local municipalities have less ability to levy the taxes needed to maintain this infrastructure. This is particularly rough because money is extremely moveable at the local level as people move to nearby towns for lower taxes, and big box stores pit municipalities against each other for tax breaks.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by xyzzyz on Sunday January 16, 2022 @01:52PM (#29958708)
Can you name one city that did not escape it, and was drowned in infrastructure costs? Galesburg is certainly not one of them, given how roads constitute a small fraction of its spending.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by TulliusCicero on Sunday January 16, 2022 @03:22PM (#29959579)
That's not really how this works. If you don't have enough money to adequately maintain your infrastructure, you'll just inadequately maintain it instead. You won't plow ahead and spend the ideal amount of money anyway, you just let things kind of go to crap.

So the failure state to look for isn't a city going into massive debt as it drastically outspends its revenues year after year, it's a city with infrastructure that's decaying and falling apart because they don't have enough money to take care of it. Then that's the thing that can have ripple effects on the local economy and population.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by refurb on Sunday January 16, 2022 @09:10AM (#29956094)
Strongtowns is an internet phenomenon (ask a normal person if they’ve heard of Strongtowns).

Small towns are shrinking (and large ones, see Detroit). No surprise here.

It’s a trend that started 20 years ago and seems to be reversing due to housing prices and WFH. Strongtowns is a day late and a dollar short.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by jackcosgrove on Sunday January 16, 2022 @09:37AM (#29956290)
Downstate Illinois has been in decline for fifty years. The climate is harsh, agriculture requires far fewer workers, light industry departed, and like upstate New York the region is given short shrift by a metro-dominated state government.

Urban planning may be a factor but smart planning could not have overcome the headwinds.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by stickfigure on Sunday January 16, 2022 @10:39AM (#29956817)
> The climate is harsh

Doesn't this seem like a fatal issue right there? Given that Americans are free to move anywhere in the US, I would expect a general trend towards places that are more comfortable to live. Population growth can cover up a lot emigration, but the era of large families is over. Cities can still draw people with cultural significance, but what is the draw of Galesburg IL? Even for people that like small towns, there are plenty of small towns farther south with better weather.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by Kon-Peki on Sunday January 16, 2022 @12:00PM (#29957631)
> what is the draw of Galesburg IL?

There are two liberal arts colleges in the Galesburg “metro” area that draw both students and faculty from elsewhere (ps - the big one has a special 5-year 2-campus 2-diploma engineering program gives you a BA from them as well as, for example, a CS degree from UIUC [1]). The student population and their locations support a “downtown” that no city of that size and location would otherwise be able to support and therefore likely draws a lot of the rural population for entertainment.

We pass through there a few times a year on the way to our favorite camping spot. I’d say their biggest problem and much of the cause of the sprawl-style development is that there is a bypass road on the north side of the city built nearly to interstate standards, complete with on-ramps and off-ramps. But it is flagged as both a US highway and a state highway so the chance that Galesburg has any control over it at all is pretty close to 0.

[1] https://www.knox.edu/academics/majors-and-minors/engineering

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by analog31 on Sunday January 16, 2022 @11:22AM (#29957251)
And farther north. Greetings from wisconsin.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by TulliusCicero on Sunday January 16, 2022 @10:00PM (#29962892)
> like upstate New York the region is given short shrift by a metro-dominated state government.

My reading has usually indicated that if anything the more rural counties get more from the state government than they pay in. It's usually the major metros subsidizing the others.

Then when you look at how the feds treat highway spending, things become even more lopsided in favor of rural counties. There's just an inherent disadvantage against specialization in small metros by virtue of a smaller population, and the way they're laid out in the states makes this difference even larger (young educated professionals don't want to live in a super low density suburban environment that demands they drive everywhere).

> Urban planning may be a factor but smart planning could not have overcome the headwinds.

The German engineering firm that Tesla bought is in a town of just a few thousand (or it was just a few thousand at the time anyway). A cutting edge engineering firm being in such a small town is basically unthinkable to me in the states. Clearly there's some difference, and I do think better urban design plays some part, though yeah it's not the only factor.