News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by defaultname on Sunday January 16, 2022 @02:17PM (#29958941)
Mississauga has a density of 2467 people per square kilometer. Mississauga neighbourhoods look like this-

https://www.google.ca/maps/@43.5675623,-79.740886,916m/data=...

That isn't apartment building density, but that's about as dense as single family homes can get.

Mississauga had to raise property taxes somewhat -- still extremely competitive -- as a revenue source dried up. But those new neighbourhoods all easily pay for themselves in property taxes. Nonetheless, loads of really silly narrative comes out of Toronto writers, still foreboding this dire scenario that they've been pitching for well over a decade. It's a bit farcical at this point.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by ricardobeat on Sunday January 16, 2022 @03:02PM (#29959392)
> about as dense as single family homes can get

These traditional north american houses are still not very space efficient at all (large unused garden + lawn + double parking spot + garage).

“Suburban” neighborhoods in Europe easily have double or triple the density of this. I also see zero townhouses or anything with 2+ floors in that area.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by toss1 on Sunday January 16, 2022 @05:01PM (#29960671)
>>(large unused garden + lawn + double parking spot + garage)

I don't know about you, but I actively use and enjoy every one of those things.

Perhaps you enjoy apartment living and consider anything not active indoors a waste.

If so, good for you, I wouldn't want to impose a garden or a parking spot on you. By the same token, calling these out as if they could possibly not be useful, simply because you do not think them useful, is at best, a fallacy.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by magikaram on Sunday January 16, 2022 @07:44PM (#29962095)
It's been well documented that the large set back front yards and loads of anti-pedestrian designed neighborhoods and towns have largely been the cause for issues relating to poor public transportation, heat island effects, and less affordable housing.

You can have nice gardens, double parking spots & a garage without the same designed towns and neighborhoods. Most often is done by limiting street parking, narrower streets, and using the rear-entrance drives and lots as done in many cities.

Those designs also enable more pedestrian friendliness vs. the suburban sprawl that is effectively carpeting the U.S. and Canada since the 40's.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by toss1 on Sunday January 16, 2022 @09:49PM (#29962830)
>>heat island effects are not caused by yards and vegetation, but by expanses of dark asphalt and dark roofs. More vegetation vs roads/lots, and roof area is the cure, not the cause.

>>Most often is done by limiting street parking, narrower streets, and using the rear-entrance drives and lots as done in many cities.

YES, limiting on-street parking is huge.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by citrin_ru on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @03:14AM (#29976449)
If there are trees on both sides of a residential street it will not be a heat island even with on-street parking. But it seems to me many Americans don’t like trees and prefer open spaces (which inevitably work as heat islands).
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by KptMarchewa on Sunday January 16, 2022 @06:57PM (#29961757)
You can enjoy active outdoors without wasting space on concrete car desert. It's called "parks".
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by toss1 on Sunday January 16, 2022 @09:45PM (#29962801)
Lawns and gardens are not concrete (at least not mine). Also,kind of hard to grow your lunch greens in a public park. Not much solitude there either. Nothing says that you need to even need to have concrete/asphalt driveways & parking; gravel drives can be quite nice.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by neilparikh on Monday January 17, 2022 @02:02AM (#29964078)
> I don't know about you, but I actively use and enjoy every one of those things.

That's fine, as long as you pay the costs associated with those things. However, in most cities suburbs are revenue negative, and subsidized by the dense downtown areas (that don't have these).

> I wouldn't want to impose a garden or a parking spot on you.

The entire problem is that this is exactly what is done though. Zoning forces a very specific type of housing in most of the city (single family house with large lot size, garage, driveway and backyard), even for those who would be okay with or prefer something else.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by toss1 on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @12:22PM (#29982401)
>>Zoning forces a very specific type of housing in most of the city (single family house with large lot size, garage, driveway and backyard), even for those who would be okay with or prefer something else.

Are you conflating city and suburbs here? While this is obviously dependent on each city/town which has their own zoning rules, most of the locales with which I'm familiar have quite the dense-pack throughout the city, and the suburbs are out in separate towns.

>>However, in most cities suburbs are revenue negative. Again, if the suburbs are separate towns, I don't see how this affects the city budget. If the suburbs are within the city and on the same budget, I'd look at the balance of costs and revenue, and if a particular zoning district is substantially more costly, i.e., being subsidized, then it seems a rate adjustment for that zoning type would be in order...

As it is, for where I live, the town is essentially all rural/residential, with 2-acre minimums (some exceptions), 35mi from the major city, and I can say that yes, we REALLY do pay for those associated things - one of the highest tax rates in the state, and increased ~50% since moving in 15 years ago. Yes, we occasionally grumble, but I am much more happy to pay for the zoning rules that maintain an healthy ecosystem where I can see over a dozen types of birds out the window at breakfast and many other healthy populations, than I'd be even slightly interested to see densepack developments reducing my rates (I can find densepack & lower rates elsewhere, and if I wanted it, I'd have gone there)

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by ricardobeat on Sunday January 16, 2022 @10:12PM (#29962952)
I didn’t say they are useless or not enjoyable (except for front lawns which are, in fact, useless). And no I don’t live in an apartment, or would like to, though some people do.

It’s just not really necessary for every single house to have these amenities. You can have parks, public parking, and a decent sized backyard in a townhouse / attached buildings. The space gained can then be used to sustain actual life in the neighborhood such as stores, restaurants, schools, libraries and small businesses. Once you have this, you don’t need two cars, or to drive everywhere, you don’t need a large private garden to enjoy the outdoors.

Of course I’d love to live in a huge house surrounded by green. But it’s not a sustainable model for urban development.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by TulliusCicero on Monday January 17, 2022 @09:01PM (#29974069)
> If so, good for you, I wouldn't want to impose a garden or a parking spot on you. By the same token, calling these out as if they could possibly not be useful, simply because you do not think them useful, is at best, a fallacy.

This is grossly out of touch with how most of these features end up existing. Most of the time, there's a minimum setback for the front yard, minimum parking, etc. specified by local zoning ordinances.

This isn't bottom-up market-driven demand, it's top-down requirements specified by the local government for that area. So they are, in fact, imposed on whoever wants to live there.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by toss1 on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @05:16PM (#29986829)
>>This is grossly out of touch with how most of these features end up existing ... this isn't bottom-up market-driven demand, it's top-down requirements specified by the local government for that area.

Wrong. Of course it is always implemented by a local govt, but it is very much a result of demand.

I very well understand how such regs end up existing, and changing. It is very much related to demand. People are generally against zoning until they realize what it is like to live without zoning, and then it is DEMANDED by the people, and of course implemented by the govt. I've lived in a locale where zoning was first brought in, then developers managed to build a coalition against it and it was abolished, then people realized that that was shi*y, and now it is zoned again.

I've also seen and helped organize opposition to new development that would trash both neighborhoods and wetlands and endangered species habitat - when 100 neighbors come out to oppose the proposed variance, that is not some govt imposing it, it is the residents supporting their own zoning.

It may be different in larger cities with heavier corporate development influence, but I doubt it, since e.g., I'm sure there are plenty of developers who'd love to develop in San Francisco, but all I hear about is NIMBY opposition to changing neighborhood zoning holding it back. Guess what? That's not some top-down govt, it's locals supporting their own zoning.

What is out of touch is your comment inaccurately characterizing it as some faceless govt imposition.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by randallsquared on Sunday January 16, 2022 @03:47PM (#29959831)
> I also see zero townhouses or anything with 2+ floors in that area.

Maybe you meant 2+ units? 'Cause almost all of them have 2+ floors, and many will have livable basements as well.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by jcranmer on Sunday January 16, 2022 @02:28PM (#29959071)
> That isn't apartment building density, but that's about as dense as single family homes can get.

You can get a little bit denser by going full street grid--Chicago's single family home districts look to mostly be rocking ~6-9k people/km².

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by idiotsecant on Sunday January 16, 2022 @02:52PM (#29959302)
I might be the only one but I strongly prefer grid-layout cities to these winding suburb road layouts anyhow. When your city is a grid you can make street names mean something and a person can navigate from place to place easily and have an intuitive idea of how far away something is, both without a cellphone.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by AlbertCory on Sunday January 16, 2022 @03:32PM (#29959669)
I think you are the only one.

I grew up in Chicago on a perfect grid. Now I live on a street that I picked precisely because you only drive down it if you live there. I don't like the sound of cars driving past. That's a personal preference that seems pretty generalized, even among people without kids.

And on a street like that, you don't need speed bumps, because people aren't speeding down the street.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by closeparen on Sunday January 16, 2022 @04:46PM (#29960483)
But that’s the thing. The street’s utility is exclusively to the houses that are on it. Those houses are very unlikely to be paying enough property tax to cover its existence. This luxury of yours is paid for by other people’s productive activity in the future. Great deal for you! But we the (net) taxpayers ought to think about how many more of these sweetheart deals we offer to cul de sac homeowners in the future, before we bankrupt ourselves.

I’m not a libertarian, I think it’s fine for government to tap rich people to provide nice things for everyone, but this particular nice thing (way more roadway than you pay for) has a pretty bad cost:benefit, and its beneficiaries are not exactly the neediest or most deserving of aid.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by TulliusCicero on Monday January 17, 2022 @09:15PM (#29974169)
I think having some residential that's offset is fine, the problem is that almost inevitably these places are designed to be impermeable to walk/bike traffic as well, and with the long distances required to go anywhere, you do have to drive everywhere.

A positive counter-example would be Houten. Winding street layout that's not good for through traffic, but very nice for walking and especially biking: https://www.google.com/maps/@52.033207,5.1474598,3a,75y,4.09...

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by halpert on Sunday January 16, 2022 @08:13PM (#29962275)
I find it hard to believe that building a road is so expensive. Some random website I found claims the cost of a two-lane undivided road costs $3 million per mile in an urban setting. Looking at the satellite imagery of Mississauga linked elsewhere, the frontage of each house is around 50 ft. So there are about 211 houses per mile. That comes out to $14,000 per house to build the road. The approximate lifespan of an asphalt road is 18 years, leading to a per year cost of ~800 dollars. Of course, this doesn't include maintenance of the road (fixing pot holes, plowing, etc.), but $800 per year seems like a pretty manageable sum of money.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by titanomachy on Sunday January 16, 2022 @08:38PM (#29962436)
In Galesburg (the town in the article), it wasn’t a manageable amount. That town has extremely low property values compared to any towns I’m familiar with, though. The author’s single-family home is worth about $60k. The median home in Mississauga is $900k (CAD), so I assume they can afford to maintain their roads.

We’re talking about pretty different things, though. Suburbs of ultra high-cost-of-living cities have their taxes buoyed up their proximity to the big economic engines, while small towns like Galesburg have to figure out how to be self-sufficient without that constant influx of wealth.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by tptacek on Monday January 17, 2022 @11:14AM (#29968052)
The median home price in Galesburg is $90k.

Makes sense for a declining city in far-out rural Illinois.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by titanomachy on Monday January 17, 2022 @03:46PM (#29971529)
It’s an interesting question to me what these towns will do going forward. If participation in the global economy is required to maintain a first-world standard of living, what will these towns produce that the rest of the world wants?

Some will farm or extract natural resources, but these operations require fewer people than they used to, so fewer towns. Some will be holiday destinations for city-dwellers. But we will probably sustain far fewer of these towns than we have historically.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by tptacek on Monday January 17, 2022 @06:49PM (#29973054)
What do towns full of software developers produce? There are developers that like living out in the country.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by halpert on Monday January 17, 2022 @09:52PM (#29974436)
> What do towns full of software developers produce?

Software? Sure there are software developers living out in small towns, but obviously not many in this town.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by halpert on Sunday January 16, 2022 @09:15PM (#29962652)
But would more density really solve the problem? An inability to produce $800 per household will make anything hard.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by titanomachy on Monday January 17, 2022 @03:16PM (#29971219)
I was thinking this as well. I wonder how much this is just a consequence of per capita city productivity being so many times greater than small towns.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by notfromhere on Monday January 17, 2022 @10:36PM (#29974757)
More density means more people per road and less road in general. Done right, and households are not the only entities paying into the coffers
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by closeparen on Sunday January 16, 2022 @09:43PM (#29962788)
The property tax bill in TFA is $1700, but roads are only one of the things property taxes buy.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by wkearney99 on Sunday January 16, 2022 @06:29PM (#29961541)
or if not 'tap the rich', better structure the payouts so there isn't such an imbalance. wage stagnation is a BIG problem.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by slyall on Sunday January 16, 2022 @05:52PM (#29961238)
A big problem is this sort of design makes it hard to walk between places. All travel involves going to the main road, going some distance down that and then following a new branch. Queue route map that requires 10 minute drive to get to the "next block".

Not too bad in you car but it means that you can't walk or bike anywhere unless they have put in paths between blocks. Means that if a 15-year-old kids wants an ice-cream their parent has to drive them to the corner store.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by BirdieNZ on Sunday January 16, 2022 @06:07PM (#29961358)
You can have both, if you have a grid of main through-roads for transporting people around and then inside each "square" of the grid you have a continued fractal of sub-grids which aren't for through-traffic (slower speed limits, narrower streets, traffic calming measures, difference in material to make clear the difference from through-roads and local streets etc.). People traveling past won't use the inner streets because they aren't efficient for that, but people living in the neighbourhood will use the inner streets.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by fiter on Sunday January 16, 2022 @08:49PM (#29962503)
In Berkeley, CA they purposefully break up the grid for cars. So a street will be passable to pedestrians and bikes but blocked by bollards for cars. This gives the cul-de-sac effect without causing terrible walkability. Of course, traditional winding suburbs can accomplish something similar by adding pedestrian walkways through cul-de-sacs.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by asdfasgasdgasdg on Sunday January 16, 2022 @03:37PM (#29959721)
He's definitely not the only person who prefers cities to suburbs. What?

Now, I think almost everyone would prefer if their one street were not integrated into the grid. That would be the ideal. You live in a grid, but with none of the downsides. But failing that, many people opt to live in denser areas rather than the burbs, even if the cost is that folks sometimes drive down their street who are going someplace else..

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by nayuki on Sunday January 16, 2022 @06:12PM (#29961401)
There's a good video explaining how urban and suburban residents alike want less traffic in their neighborhoods: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dqQw05Mr63E
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by TulliusCicero on Monday January 17, 2022 @09:13PM (#29974154)
> I grew up in Chicago on a perfect grid. Now I live on a street that I picked precisely because you only drive down it if you live there. I don't like the sound of cars driving past. That's a personal preference that seems pretty generalized, even among people without kids.

Well, you could still get this, more or less, with a grid, like Barcelona's superblocks.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by tptacek on Monday January 17, 2022 @11:13AM (#29968040)
Most of Chicago has adapted against that problem: streets are now artificially cul-de-sac'd to cap them near arteries, so neighborhoods have explicitly designed traffic flows. It works reasonably well (I'm in Oak Park, not Chicago, but same deal). Obviously, you'd get less traffic in Glenview or whatever.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by KptMarchewa on Sunday January 16, 2022 @06:59PM (#29961776)
Are American cardboard walls and windows actually that bad that you can hear cars through them?
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by titanomachy on Sunday January 16, 2022 @08:42PM (#29962457)
As someone who lives in a recently built American house in a dense urban area: yes, definitely. It’s quiet enough that I can tune them out, mostly.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by pxeboot on Sunday January 16, 2022 @07:25PM (#29961959)
Cars? Probably not. Loud trucks/motorcycles? Absolutely.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by mech422 on Sunday January 16, 2022 @07:02PM (#29961804)
Yeah - Phoenix has a basically 1 mile grid, with lil side streets in-between the major intersections.

I hate it, because if you miss a turn, you basically have to go another full mile to hit another 'cross street'.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by toofy on Sunday January 16, 2022 @03:27PM (#29959620)
you’re definitely not the only one. grids make much more sense. and not only for ease of navigation.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by TulliusCicero on Sunday January 16, 2022 @03:17PM (#29959530)
> That isn't apartment building density, but that's about as dense as single family homes can get.

Roughly the equivalent of pointing to IBM as the most high paying and prestigious tech companies can get.

It would be trivial to increase the density there by reducing setback requirements, narrowing the roads, removing minimum parking requirements.