News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by Retric on Sunday January 16, 2022 @09:14AM (#29956117)
> Initially it’s not so bad

This assumes it’s significantly cheaper to build new roads than to rebuild them which seems false on the surface. It could be that replacing more roads at the same time would drive down costs. If replacing ~600’ of roads is 600$/foot how about replacing 10 miles of roads?

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by burlesona on Sunday January 16, 2022 @11:11AM (#29957125)
Actually the cost of initial construction and future reconstruction is about the same. The problem is the initial construction is heavily subsidized either by State or Federal "growth" grants, or by developers who financialize the whole thing through the sale of federally subsidized development loans.

In theory what should happen is the resulting development pays enough taxes to pay for all the infrastructure it depends on to be rebuilt as needed (typically every 15-30 years depending on which kind of infra we're talking about). But in practice the taxes are not actually linked to the cost of infrastructure (they are much too low) and not enough funds are collected to maintain the infra.

This is managed by a shell game where fees from new developments (who just financialized their new infra) are used to pay the maintenance on old projects that are losing money, and where federal subsidies for growth and expansion are contorted to uses like widening a scarcely used road that is falling part (bc. the feds will pay to expand but not to maintain) - which solves the problem for now by making it even worse for the next generation.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by xyzzyz on Sunday January 16, 2022 @01:55PM (#29958744)
> The problem is the initial construction is heavily subsidized either by State or Federal "growth" grants, or by developers who financialize the whole thing through the sale of federally subsidized development loans.

Cities also "financialize" the whole thing by selling bonds. The real difference is that when the developers originally build roads at their own expense (recouping it by the sale of the properties they developed), they pay much less than what the city then pays later to repave them. If you frame the question instead "why does the government pay so much more than private companies for the same products and services", it pretty much answers itself.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by wkearney99 on Sunday January 16, 2022 @06:31PM (#29961557)
this also exposes the fantasy of the private sector doing all the work at a lesser rate, versus having many infrastructure things like this done at a governmental level.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by pixl97 on Sunday January 16, 2022 @11:34AM (#29957367)
Roads aren't just roads. They are sewer pipes, water pipes, gas pipes, telecommunication lines, and power lines. These items age and also need replaced. Not sure how much remodeling you've ever done, but refits are more expensive than having something built in a new structure. It gets even more expensive when this infrastructure is in use while you're upgrading it.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by matkoniecz on Sunday January 16, 2022 @09:21AM (#29956176)
Maybe it is caused by rising standards and rising human labor costs?

There are many stories where rebuilding or just renovation of a bridge was vastly more expensive than constructing it 50 or 100 years ago (yes, obviously after adjusting for inflation).

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by KptMarchewa on Sunday January 16, 2022 @07:02PM (#29961798)
Construction is the only sector where real productivity decreased.

https://www.curt.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/Productivity...

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by trhway on Sunday January 16, 2022 @04:23PM (#29960234)
Also include the "management/administrative tax" - these days mid-management is much thicker and consumes and wastes tremendously more resources.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by acdha on Sunday January 16, 2022 @07:16PM (#29961898)
Not just “mid-management” but subcontracting. This is especially bad in government projects because you have challenges around selecting bidders fairly and if you don’t have enough civil servants doing the same jobs at similar pay it can be hard to have people on the government side who are capable of adequately overseeing a project of that scale. If you end up hiring multiple contractors, you’re guaranteeing a lot of overhead even if it goes well and plenty of chances for a 3+ way blame-shifting exercise if it doesn’t.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by m0llusk on Sunday January 16, 2022 @03:55PM (#29959926)
No, that is only true when focusing on large infrastructure items like bridges and the really scary numbers only show up when bizarre outliers like the NYC Second Avenue subway are included.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by rout39574 on Sunday January 16, 2022 @10:51AM (#29956941)
Roads are initially built with the promise of future returns in mind. These estimates of future returns tend to be affected by developers, who are acting to encourage the approval of development projects.

Rebuilding projects are contemplated in the shadow of actual returns, which are harder to lie about.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by pstoll on Sunday January 16, 2022 @11:00AM (#29957006)
> Roads are initially built with the promise of future returns in mind.

Roads are like startups! We should get VCs in on the action.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by iratewizard on Sunday January 16, 2022 @02:15PM (#29958916)
If a road could get a cut of all attached business's revenue, and revenues shifted back towards small businesses (i.e. away from mega corps), I could see private roads being a boon and lawsuits forcing regular, quality maintenance. In practice, though, I'm sure it would get muddy quick.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by kbenson on Sunday January 16, 2022 @03:11PM (#29959482)
> I'm sure it would get muddy quick.

I see what you did there...

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by silvestrov on Sunday January 16, 2022 @11:00AM (#29957017)
You get money from the initial sale of the lot. This convers the cost of initial construction.

After the sale, the town only gets tax revenue which is a lot less.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by throwawayboise on Sunday January 16, 2022 @05:03PM (#29960685)
Why not do a traffic study and determine what percentage of the traffic on a road is using the road to get to adjacent properties, and what percentage is transiting through the area. Tax those adjacent properties that percentage of maintenance costs of the road. So a large mall presumably would be taxed for a fairly large share of the costs of maintaing roads that feed customers into the mall. In cases where there are roads that don't really go anywhere else, they would pay 100% of the costs of maintaining those roads. If 50% of the traffic enters the mall, they pay 50% of the costs of those roads and the city is responsible for the other 50%.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by acdha on Sunday January 16, 2022 @07:22PM (#29961941)
It’s a good idea but tricky to do at scale: the catchment area of a mall is measured in miles, some people would scream about big brother, and places like the mall would argue that their jobs and tax revenue mean they shouldn’t get taxed at the same rate.

If I had to do this, I’d try to figure out a privacy-preserving way to record Bluetooth IDs since most cars have Bluetooth beacons those now and try to do it regionally so you could address questions of fairness (e.g. I go to 4 places doing errands. How much does each one get assessed?). You’d also need to do this regularly to avoid sampling skew (how much does peak holiday demand at the mall count for?) and that really means you’d need to have a robust privacy policy with teeth.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by dantheman on Sunday January 16, 2022 @09:19AM (#29956162)
Most of the time the roads are built with grants from the state or federal government.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by Retric on Sunday January 16, 2022 @09:33AM (#29956259)
I was assuming based on the age of the town they where continuously paying for roads, grants make this much easier.

If they didn’t have to pay for the roads to begin with they have 30 years to set aside money for the replacement. Even minimal interest would drastically reduce their out of pocket costs. Grants turn this into a question of bad fiscal management, which is definitely an issue but says little about how much infrastructure they have.

Re:Why Galesburg has no money by yellowbeard on Sunday January 16, 2022 @09:29AM (#29956233)
Or by developers
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by acdha on Sunday January 16, 2022 @10:06AM (#29956529)
This is also a problem if they don’t have good oversight: the developers often cut corners or build something which will look good when they’re selling units but costs more to maintain.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money by ashtonkem on Sunday January 16, 2022 @06:57PM (#29961756)
The issue isn’t that the developers cut corners though. The best designed roads just aren’t going to last long enough to change the math.

It’s also not the developers job to consider the long term maintenance and tax implications of these developments. That’s the responsibility of the city itself through plan approval and zoning.