I see a number of surgical masks over 95%. I don't think that would be possible in practice, because of leaks at the sides and top. I'd expect more like 50%. But, you don't appear to have the equipment to do a fit test.
Refer to the 3M video on how to fit test an N95.
I realize that N95 and surgical masks have different standards, but you are making them look comparable, when they are not.
We are just solving for the filtration and letting people figure out the fit.
But, you make a good point, in the videos I try to point this out but we could do better. Where could I add this to make this more clear?
For example an ASTM 2 or 3 surgical mask fabric has a filtration of 98%+
On my face I have a leakage of about 21% or PFE of 79% when worn normally.
With an ear saver, it jumps to 91%.
With a mask brace, it jumps to 98%.
So it really is about the fit.
If I put leakage % it would vary from person to person and many people would be mislead by this.
> With an ear saver, it jumps to 91%.
> With a mask brace, it jumps to 98%.
I had no idea it could vary so much for surgical masks. I’d be curious what range of leakage people could typically expect for other designs such boat-shaped KF94 or flat-fold KN95 masks.
Fit seems important enough to deserve a mention in the intro paragraph at the top of the home page. A more detailed explanation, including the example you gave of how much it can vary for even one person, could go in the “Click here” link to the full testing methodology.
Thank you for doing this, by the way, rare to see a manufacturer test so far beyond their own masks. It clearly takes resources to do this and is a great service to all of us who have been relying on guesswork.
For example I found this study on beard length which made me reconfigure my facial hair: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41370-021-00337-1
The charts in that paper also make it seem that n95 *typically* has a much better seal on the face which is worth noting.
I also wonder if the breathability you're measuring affects filtration, given imperfect fit. I would imagine that worse breathability would cause more air to flow around the mask rather than through it.
It measures the air outside the mask verses inside the mask.
https://tsi.com/products/respirator-fit-testers/portacount-r...
I get as low as 80% and as high as 99% on my face.
Fit is a big deal because it's personal and hard to communicate. I think it was Amazon that found when scanning their workforce that they discovered 29 different face shapes!
Hard to argue against that, but on HN I'm sure someone's gonna try :-)
Change title to "Comprehensive Mask Material Testing" or "Comprehensive Mask Fabric Testing" or similar.
Similarly; "...that's why we're testing the filtration capabilities of every mask in our laboratory"
At some point (on the front page, above the fold) there could be a small notice box explaining the difference, or ?-link or tooltip to read more.
I think a lot of the suspicion you're facing in this thread wouldn't have been there if it weren't for that ambiguity, and the need to go into deep content to resolve it.
For someone who just browses to your site and spends 5 min finding "the best mask", they would never realize as it is today.
https://www.armbrustusa.com/blogs/news/mask-fit-vs-filtratio...
Oh, excellent update!
(It might be a good idea to break your database into two sections: one for N/KN/KF respirators and one for other masks.)
I also notice that you have a "collections" page
https://www.armbrustusa.com/collections/
That page has a very helpful section, "USA made N95 masks and KN95 respirators".
https://www.armbrustusa.com/collections/usa-made-n95-masks-r...
Exactly what we need. Two questions:
1. Aren't all N95 "masks" actually respirators? 2. Why do you offer "made in USA" KN95 (Chinese standard) instead of an Armbrust branded N95?
Thank you for doing this!
I am very curious about country stats and have 2 questions.
First, I found this one randomly: https://www.armbrustusa.com/blogs/mask-review/kf94-try-mask-...
The country of origin on your page says China, but the photo's box says Korea. Is this a mask repackaged and exported from Korea that is actually from China?
Second, does "China" also include Taiwan? If so, I would be interested in separating them for statistics.
for those interested, here's a first level breakdown of pass/fail by country
| country | # pass | # fail | pass rate |
|-----------+--------+--------+-----------|
| USA | 39 | 27 | 59 |
| China | 48 | 186 | 21 |
| Korea | 31 | 13 | 70 |
| Thailand | 0 | 2 | 0 |
| India | 2 | 12 | 14 |
| Mexico | 1 | 0 | 100 |
| Germany | 0 | 1 | 0 |
| Singapore | 1 | 0 | 100 |
| Vietnam | 1 | 0 | 100 |
also, in this dataset it looks like adult masks have a 66% pass rate as a whole, while kids masks have a 73% FAILURE rate!So a third question is, are you using adult mask testing methods for testing kid masks as well (which would explain the failure; on the other hand, the kid masks that passed must be quite some mask!), or do kid masks just suck in general?
That said, I have also noticed this... if a manufacturer in China makes a great adult masks, their kids mask is likely to fail standards for filtration AND be harder to breath.
Having made both adult and kids masks I can tell you that there is way less of a demand for kids masks and because of that less attention gets paid to them on the manufacturing floor. Theory: People are just lazy and make worse masks for the kids I think because kids are not paying attention.
Furthermore, kids don't care that it passes standards, they care if there's a dinosaur on the mask or not. Even my own kids tell me my kids masks are boring! So manufacturers put their time on making it fun and not on protection.
We test both kids and adults to the same standards, use the same fabric, etc. Boring but effective :)
China and Taiwan are separate (they make very different masks) but I haven't been able to find any from Taiwan to test.
(apologies, I edited my original message with a third question, which I would love to get an answer to, but now I don't want to mess with this thread anymore)
I guess maybe you explain the failure in the video, and maybe there's a good reason that it failed, but you're asking me to waste a bunch of time watching videos to understand information that could have been provided in print. It doesn't make me trust you.
> A good example of this is in the text written on the front of N95 and KN95 masks. The standards for each of these masks demand that very specific information be printed on the device. If a KN95 mask does not have the manufacturer name and the standard number they are meeting (GB 2828-2019 or GB2828-2006), then they cannot be considered KN95 masks
Such masks are marked failed. My guess is thats what happened here.
Would be good to see what the update notes say for this one. It might be because the product listing still claims it's approved from emergency use; the FDA rescinded the EUA for all non-N95 masks back in July [1].
0: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zeYlKgOI8-w&t=210s
1: https://www.fda.gov/medical-devices/emergency-use-authorizat...
If it's a filtration test and it filters correctly give it a pass with an asterisk.
Notes should be live in about 275 of them hopefully today.
Still kind of unimpressed by the high weighting of labeling formalities for pass/fail (I live in the realm of EN149 anyways) and I'd certainly prefer a few notes over video. Feature request for the next pandemic: I'm sure people wearing glasses would love being able to filter for masks with that spongy cell foam flow blocker strip on the underside of the nose stripe?
But I really love the inclusion of breathability: I'm convinced that in the day to day realities of living through a pandemic, a mask with better breathability won't just be more comfortable than one less breathable, but also provide more protection, because it's worn better and more. And a list like that would have been very helpful earlier in the pandemic not only for buying guidance, but also for instructing people that if they really can't stand wearing a mask, maybe that's in large part because they simply haven't encountered a good one yet. Seeing a range from <50 to >200 and how little it correlates with filtering (it does, but much less than one would expect) is worth more than words. I didn't realize the breathability factor myself until I found myself in a hospital abroad (injury, not infection) where they supplied me with proper FFP2 for going to x-ray and the like. So much better than the emergency use 3-ply crap I used before and almost decadent indulgence compared to the emergency textile contraptions that preceded them.
https://www.armbrustusa.com/blogs/mask-review/surgical-medte...
The accompanying video is informative and I can add that the way the earloops are attached is wide-spread in Germany. Also confirmation from my side that the strings rip right off with this type of attachment regardless of the actual manufacturer.
On an iPhone, the value for color in the details is slightly too far to the left and in this case wrong because it reads Black. I’d like to be able to tap on the color and see a list of matching masks and also have a top level filter for color.
As a parent I’d love to have a top level filter to see masks for kids.
Finally, German quality engineering exists but it’s really not found that often in the wild as the myth would lead someone to believe. So thanks for helping to debunk that in the video.
I don't think you should base anything on N=1, either for or against.
Thank you!!
As a consumer, when I land on that site, “what’s the best mask I should buy” (protection level, budget, comfort, local/globally made). If it’s not clear on mobile, it’ll be pretty hard to get non-tech people to stay on page for more then 10s or funnel them to the page you want.
1. For masks that fail on marking issues but not filtering efficiency, could they get a third category that’s not pass or fail (something like ‘non-compliant’)?
2. I wish you could filter on pass/fail
3. I wish you included/could filter on price per box and price per mask.
I wish I could filter for "valve" because valved masks are not allowed where I live.
It'd be nice if you had pop-up dialogs upon hover over each of the fields. For example, if I hover over breathability, explain what it is and how you measure it.
Some color codes/gradient would be nice to help with the visual effect (Green for Pass, Red for Fail etc.) But please do include a toggle for color-blind mode if you do add color.
Good call on the color coding... I'm color blind so didn't think of this :)
Initially, I was seeing the sort return 1, 10, 100, 2, 20, 200.. so sorting by the first numeral instead of the number. But now it seems to be sorting ok-ish except if you jump to the bottom and the row for "Staples / Beixikang Face Mask" shows a % symbol for some reason. So possibly some data entry issues.
Below the Beixikang, there are then about 12 entries in 80-168 range so the entry for the Beixikang may be throwing the sort off.
I'm seeing this too; I think the single entry [0] that includes a percent sign in its breathability score is screwing up the sort.
0: https://www.armbrustusa.com/blogs/mask-review/surgical-beixi...
> Some color codes/gradient would be nice to help with the visual effect (Green for Pass, Red for Fail etc.) But please do include a toggle for color-blind mode if you do add color.
If the green and red shades are chosen to have enough contrast to look different when convert into black and white (e.g. when printed), it should be usable even for most colorblind people, while also being easier to read for everyone.
It would be great if you also sold the stuff you use for testing masks. I spent a while looking into testing masks myself, but then the shortage eased up so it seemed less important.
I think it would be great to have easily reproduceable, low cost test equipment available at shops and clinics because the quality of masks (even of a specific make and model) is likely to vary between units. You might find a good mask with your tests, and then find that your next order of the exact same mask is crap. So you have to keep testing. Maybe it is less bad now. I was interested in this more when masks were in very short supply, but then I managed to get a few boxes of them, and set the testing idea aside.
All test results disappear when the browser window isn't wide enough (eg. on mobile, or narrow PC windows).
How could I possibly trust one company to do both?
Eg by type (surgical,duckbill,n95,kn95), by budget (budget, price/performance, premium), ships now on amazon, doesn't ship now but better in some way if you're willing to wait, etc.
Also I was looking at the 3m 9210 that you have 2 entries for in your table. The breathability is quite different between the two samples (98 vs 242). Is this expected? That seems a lot of variability for the same mask.
Good N95 style masks are difficult to get hold of in Australia. A few places are either charging absurd prices (like $10+ per disposable mask), but most pharmacies just don't stock them.
The one above has some fancy photos of certs in its listing, so it would be interesting to see if it's genuinely good. Happy to send some to you if it's helpful (you can dm me on twitter listed in my profile).
More importantly, it greatly reduces their effectiveness. Fogging up glasses is, by far, the lesser issue of the two.
From the comments here it seems others have got to the right content, so I'm not saying 'avoid this spam nothing here' or whatever, just not sure what's going on. Accessing from Europe (UK) if that's something to do with it.
https://www.armbrustusa.com/blogs/mask-review/n95-gerson-duc...
https://www.armbrustusa.com/blogs/mask-review/n95-gerson-duc...
https://www.armbrustusa.com/blogs/mask-review/kf94-dr-puri-b...
https://www.armbrustusa.com/blogs/mask-review/n95-honeywell-...
https://www.armbrustusa.com/blogs/mask-review/n95-indiana-fa...
Buy this mask button should be green :)
Thank you.
9205 is US made, the 9210 is made in Singapore.
The heavy lift we are doing here is around our particulate filtration efficiency test in which we do either the NIOSH N95 NaCL (0.3 micron) test or the ASTM 0.1 micron latex particle test.
I'd love HN feedback on how we improve the interface and make this a true resource for people.
Disclaimer: Yes, I'm a mask manufacturer and that's how I justify keeping all of this equipment up to spec, but I'm not big enough to make all of the masks for the world so I'd rather people find a good mask than just use my mask.
Any feedback is appreciated.