News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by walterbell on Monday December 20, 2021 @09:57PM (#29633285)
785 Omicron cases in Denmark, Dec 16 report for Nov 22 to Dec 7, Table 2, https://www.eurosurveillance.org/content/10.2807/1560-7917.E...

  0% fatal, 0.13% ICU, 1.2% hospital
  4.3% Covid-recovered 
  76% double vax, 7% booster
  14% unvax, 2% single vax
  77% no travel history
Edit: https://www.cnn.com/2021/12/18/politics/white-house-omicron-...

> Some of Biden's advisers are encouraging the administration to begin discussing publicly how to live alongside a virus that shows no signs of disappearing ... Steering public attention away from the total number of infections and toward serious cases only -- as some Biden advisers have encouraged -- could prove a challenge after nearly two years of intense focus on the pandemic's every up and down.

Edit2: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29633899

> The CDC’s Nowcast algorithm has some kind of bug, and the prevalence of Omicron nationwide wasn’t really 73% in the week ending December 18. Take that to the bank ... You will see this walked back. The CDC will explain what happened. The Twitter experts will have to walk back their initial tweets. The press will have to publish a new round of articles clarifying their prior wave of headlines. It might happen tomorrow, later this week, or some time next week, but it will happen. This result won’t stand.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by 6tZAfJuXT2LL on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @02:44AM (#29634996)
Here are more up to date numbers from Denmark in English and Danish: https://www.ssi.dk/-/media/cdn/files/covid19/omikron/statusr...

23038 Omicron cases in total. On December 15 44.1% of confirmed cases were Omicron.

The last page has a comparison with Delta on hospitalizations. It finds 1.4% of Delta infections led to hospitalizations compared to 0.5% for Omicron. However, this could be due to the fact that most of the Omicron cases were reported in the last week, and haven't yet 'had the time' to lead to hospitalizations.

There's also a lot more infected who has received two or three doses compared to Delta.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by hef19898 on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @03:08AM (#29635113)
> There's also a lot more infected who has received two or three doses compared to Delta.

Might be. At this point I am not motivated to dig into the numbers any more. The important questions, in that regard, for those that are interested is: How many of these of confirmed Omicron cases are double, how many are triple vaccinated? How many people overall are vaccinated? How many confirmed Omicron cases are unvaccinated? Followed by looking at the timeline between positive test / Omicron confirmation and hospitalization and ultimately death.

I said it in 2020, in early 2021 and will say it until the day it changes: That nobody in charge is able to give weekly briefings based on hard numbers, properly explaining those I have close to zero confidence the people in charge have this thing under control. And this lack of explanation is one, IMHO the, root cause of the confusion and frustration out there.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by elzbardico on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @05:23AM (#29635900)
What is more depressing was finding out that we simply don’t have simple, widely accepted and used standards for collecting and reporting data on infectious disease pandemics. The criteria and the metrics change from country to country and even from state to state or even by city in larger countries like the US, India and Brazil. You don’t even have a single, universally agreed upon criteria of what constitutes a death by COVID. And because of that some countries like Sweden probably over-counted deaths while lots of African countries probably under-counted them. It is all an unmitigated mess, compound by widely spread politicization and rent seeking behaviors. It will probably be decades of research before we know what actually happened those last two years.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by monopoledance on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @12:17PM (#29639535)
> What is more depressing...

Is how nothing really improved in two fucking years. I am completely at loss how this winter is the same or worse than the last one - which itself was going down exactly like predicted a month into the pandemic...

I am growing bitter, misanthropic and hateful.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by elzbardico on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @07:59AM (#29648697)
At this moment we are probably seeing second order effects were people that should survive the virus are instead dying because the known effects of chronic stress on immune competency.

On the other side, I believe that as with masks, lots of people become complacent after vaccination, because they had no idea their efficiency would diminish over time. This false-safety make them more reckless.

Making things mandatory, and manipulating people through fear instead of relying on personal responsibility and the natural instinct of self-preservation also made lots of people rebellious and distrustful, making mitigation behaviors an all-or-nothing affair among the population.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by monopoledance on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @01:59PM (#29653545)
I disagree with this general sentiment.

Nobody gets manipulated through fear. It's incompetent policies, which always try to maximize economic impact in certain sectors and re-electability in certain demographics... instead of clear and continuous leadership, risking prevention-paradox disapproval in the population.

Lock-downs too late, too arbitrary; selective economic and social relief; corruption; ...

Fucking "personal responsibility" and "freedom(tm)" are the worst ideas in a pandemic, where the way out is inherently a collective endeavor. That thinking is exactly why we can't have nice things, now. 80% are for mandatory vaccinations here - bring it! Bodily autonomy gets limited by far lower approval numbers all the time (see e.g. abortion).

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by roenxi on Monday December 20, 2021 @10:17PM (#29633418)
Yeah, but it is really too early to tell. The cases in that update are largely in young people (age <= 65) and it takes about a week from symptom onset to end up in hospital. That data seems to be as at 9 Dec, even if the hospitalisations were high the data would not necessarily show them.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by walterbell on Monday December 20, 2021 @10:27PM (#29633489)
South Africa, https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-12-17/s-africa-...

> Only 1.7% of identified Covid-19 cases were admitted to hospital in the second week of infections in the fourth wave, compared with 19% in the same week of the third delta-driven wave ... Health officials presented evidence that the strain may be milder, and that infections may already be peaking in the country’s most populous province, Gauteng.

Hong Kong, https://www.med.hku.hk/en/news/press/20211215-omicron-sars-c...

> The researchers found that Omicron SARS-CoV-2 infects and multiplies 70 times faster than the Delta variant and original SARS-CoV-2 in human bronchus, which may explain why Omicron may transmit faster between humans than previous variants. Their study also showed that the Omicron infection in the lung is significantly lower than the original SARS-CoV-2, which may be an indicator of lower disease severity.

If the Hong Kong report is accurate, could regular nasal washing slow viral replication, e.g. in early stages of infection? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29620312

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by nyolfen on Monday December 20, 2021 @10:35PM (#29633538)
80% of SA has already been infected and thus has some measure of immunity and prior culling, as well as an average age 1-2 decades younger than most developed nations

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-08-18/deaths-da...

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by walterbell on Monday December 20, 2021 @10:37PM (#29633546)
Nice to see natural immunity being recognized as a talking point, although the Danish sample shows prior infection is much more protective against Delta than Omicron.

What percentage of US and UK have already been infected?

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by ericmay on Monday December 20, 2021 @11:25PM (#29633860)
We know that natural immunity (don’t forget it’s not forever - it doesn’t protect against sufficient mutations) is going to happen so the idea that it isn’t recognize or wasn’t recognized is incorrect. What we are concerned about is how many people have to die from a preventable disease while this herd immunity naturally comes to bear.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by WillPostForFood on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @12:08AM (#29634110)
It isn’t recognized in the sense that you can show a vax card to get in a restaurant or on a flight, but not proof of previous infection.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by rossdavidh on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @02:37AM (#29634960)
As far as I know the US is the only country that for some reason doesn't think it matters if you are recovered. Israel, EU, others all seem to recognize it. Why the US does not, is not clear to me.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by elzbardico on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @05:26AM (#29635929)
The problem in the US is that it became a political issue and both sides don’t want to lose face by ceding even an inch
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by bmeski on Saturday December 25, 2021 @01:22PM (#29685558)
Other nations aren’t owned by pharmaceutical companies.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by rossdavidh on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @12:10PM (#29639457)
True, about so many issues.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by staticassertion on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @02:17AM (#29634862)
Perhaps to discourage 'covid parties' or other purposeful contractions of the virus.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by HWR_14 on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @06:36AM (#29636371)
Which makes sense for a lot of reasons.

1) Allowing a prior infection will lead to idiots having COVID parties to get tested.

2) Natural immunity is more variant-specific.

3) Tests are binary, but viral load determines natural response. The amount of viral load and natural response you need to fight off future infections and the amount to trigger a positive result are almost certainly not the same concentration.

4) Tests, unlike needles in the arm, have false positives.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by jdhn on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @09:12AM (#29637519)
>2) Natural immunity is more variant-specific.

How is it more variant specific? The gene therapy shots only expose you to the spike protein, whereas natural infection gives you exposure to the whole virus. As we see with omnicron, this variant has evolved so that the spike protein is the most changed aspect about it.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by HWR_14 on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @04:27PM (#29642327)
The spike protein, even through Omicron, is the most stable part. Your stupid body can pick up on any feature of the virus, and any other identifier is worse than the spike protein against the natural waves of different variants. Even if Omicron is worse than against natural immunity (something I would not concede, but will for the sake of this sentence) you're likely to have gotten COVID more times naturally than someone who was vaccinated over the past year.

Since there is literally no downside, get the fucking vaccine.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by walterbell on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @05:33PM (#29642922)
> Since there is literally no downside

There are downsides for recipients of bad batches.

Public VAERS data is reporting inter-batch variances where 90+% of adverse side effects are happening in 5% of batches. VAERS data is noisy, see site videos for more discussion, but extreme inter-batch variances across all three vendors is not expected. EU regulators have previously expressed concern about inter-batch manufacturing variance.

http://howbad.info

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by asveikau on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @01:37PM (#29653282)
> http://howbad.info

Wow. People die and get seriously ill but it seems stupidly irresponsible to assume some correlation between that outcome and a vaccine batch absent other sorts of analysis.

I entered mine and i see: the longer ago i got the shot, the higher number of deaths and serious illness. I.e. The correlation seems to be higher number of deaths as time increases.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by jdhn on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @08:17PM (#29644368)
Tried to access that site, and my internet provider (AT&T Fiber) marked it as a spam site and wouldn’t let me proceed unless I added it to a whitelist in my router. Very odd.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by jdhn on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @08:11PM (#29644315)
What makes you think I didn't get it?

>any other identifier is worse than the spike protein against the natural waves of different variants

Source?

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by orwin on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @04:24AM (#29635570)
In my country it is if the infection is less than 6 month ago. And count as a first vaccination, so you can only take half a moderna after a prior infection.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by monopoledance on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @12:22PM (#29639608)
In Germany you can. I am sure that's true for many regions. However, the granted protection status doesn't last as long as full vaccination.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by lovecg on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @12:44AM (#29634351)
I believe some countries do recognize it (Germany maybe?)
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by ulric260 on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @01:19AM (#29634566)
Yes, in EU people who have recovered from Covid get the EU digital certificate.

https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/policies/coronavirus/eu-d...

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by laurent92 on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @02:16AM (#29634855)
But France revoked the Passe Sanitaire and mutated it into a Vaccinal Pass, meaning you can’t get it using a PCR test or a previous infection, only the vaccine will be accepted.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by WastingMyTime89 on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @03:54AM (#29635416)
You need to get one booster shot after your infection in France to get a pass (instead of two shots for the usual vaccination course). That has always been the case.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by ulric260 on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @04:37AM (#29635656)
In France you get a pass for ~6 months after covid recovery, then one booster shot is indeed required.

But with vaccination, you get a pass for ~7 months, then (from Jan 2022) you also need a booster shot...

https://www.gouvernement.fr/info-coronavirus/pass-sanitaire

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by laurent92 on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @05:11PM (#29642740)
The prime minister announced 2 days ago that the Passe Sanitaire will be changed into a Passe Vaccinal, meaning PCR tests won’t be able to get it.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by brazzy on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @01:11AM (#29634526)
Yes, definitely the case in Germany.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by zorpner on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @12:28AM (#29634250)
First, this is not totally accurate -- you can board flights with literally no proof of anything, and international travel often does permit an affidavit of prior infection.

Second, just get a vaccine, jfc. Been infected? Great, now you're even more immune. Do one easy thing for your fellow humans. Can't? Plenty of documentable, obtainable exceptions. Won't? Fine. Don't avail yourself of the luxuries which are the result of humans working together to build something. Easy.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by colordrops on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @03:38AM (#29635296)
Why not base policy on science and data rather than an apeal to "unity"
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by nradov on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @12:23AM (#29634218)
The virus is so contagious that there will be no significant herd immunity effect. Pretty much everyone will eventually be infected (if they don't die from something else first).

https://www.sciencealert.com/delta-variant-means-we-can-rule...

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by rich_sasha on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @02:29AM (#29634918)
Measles is way more infectious and does achieve herd immunity at around 95% vaccinated.

Question is, can we get 95% immunity to Covid, as opposed to “benign but still infectious”.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by raxxorrax on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @05:36AM (#29635996)
The measles vaccine more or less protects you for the rest of your life, although a single refreshment might be sensible. Flu and covid vaccines would need constant adaptation and you will never reach that in a globalized world.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by rich_sasha on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @02:19PM (#29640974)
Yes, plus the Covid vaccine doesn’t seem to give much immunity against infection and spreading, so the whole game is off.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by pbreit on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @01:10AM (#29634514)
What can prevent it? Certainly not the current vaccines.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by kube-system on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @01:14AM (#29634543)
Current mRNA vaccines are highly effective at preventing severe disease and death of all widely circulating variants, including omicron
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by walterbell on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @01:26AM (#29634599)
> highly effective

Varies by # of months since last dose, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TSZMtSPX3iE

Dec 20, https://www.euronews.com/next/2021/12/20/omicron-3-vaccine-d...

> COVID-19 vaccines will not be enough to withstand the Omicron variant, warned the CEO of BioNTech, the German company behind the mRNA vaccine produced with Pfizer. "We must be aware that even triple-vaccinated are likely to transmit the disease…It is obvious we are far from 95 per cent effectiveness that we obtained against the initial virus."

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by kube-system on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @01:36AM (#29634658)
I was responding to the above question about preventing death not infection.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by zerocount on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @03:14AM (#29635147)
He's talking about preventing infection.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by kube-system on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @09:11AM (#29637513)
>> What we are concerned about is how many people have to die from a preventable disease

> What can prevent it?

Thus my answer.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by nradov on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @12:21AM (#29634205)
The CDC estimated that 45% of Americans had been infected as of September 2021, so probably closer to 50% by now.

https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/cases-updates/burd...

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by cmrdporcupine on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @12:42AM (#29634341)
That's insane. The # here in Ontario, Canada is just over 4%.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by refurb on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @01:58AM (#29634757)
There is a lot of variability in numbers due to testing rates.

Singapore and British Colombia have the same number of people (~5M). Singapore tested every suspected case and only recently stopped that. They have strict measures to enter the country and have had quite strict covid restrictions (and still do!) such as no dining in, masks in all public spaces, etc.

BC had some restrictions, but no where near Singapore. Mask adoption was good but not consistent. Currently very few restrictions.

Yet Singapore reports 280,000 total cases and BC 225,000.

I’d suggest BC’s number is likely double what’s reported, if not 3x.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by hef19898 on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @03:20AM (#29635187)
Can we have the numbers in cases per 100,000? And maybe an explanation why BC's numbers are supposed to 3x higher than what is reported?
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by refurb on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @04:04AM (#29635466)
Populations are comparable. And just what I said - BC had less testing, that’s why they had fewer total cases. Either that or restrictions and masks don’t work because Singapore was better than BC on both counts. They had a “circuit breaker” for a while where you couldn’t leave your house in 2020.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by cmrdporcupine on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @06:41PM (#29643513)
It's easy to plot test positivity vs known cases and see how they co-relate over time. Apart from the first wave in March 2020, test positivity has tracked fairly well with case numbers here in Ontario. There's been enough testing capacity since at least Sept 2020 to track at least 4000 cases a day.

And if there's significant cases being missed in testing, they'd show up in hospitalization and ICU statistics. And there's been no anomalies there.

There is a group of people who really want to consider "natural immunity" as equivalent to vaccinated. But here in Canada at least the previously infected are a very small percentage of the population, at least in a way we can confirm with test results.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by hef19898 on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @04:46AM (#29635708)
Wouldn't you need percentage of positive test to draw any conclusions of the impact the number of tests has on reported cases? And the testing strategy?
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by refurb on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @06:49AM (#29636456)
Yes you would. I don’t have the energy to dig that data up or even know if it’s available, but suffice to say that Singapore would quarantine and test entire housing blocks, I’m going to guess Singapore had much more extensive testing.

Singapore had effective contact tracing and at least in the beginning would do mass testing to trace each and every case.

That wasn’t the case in BC.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by hef19898 on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @07:29AM (#29636736)
Good, so it is reasonable to assume the BC underreported more then Singapore. Still quite a stretch to claim it is by a factor of three, don't you think?
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by refurb on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @08:05AM (#29636969)
Well the 3x was entirely pulled out of my ass, so yes, it’s a stretch.

But just based off the entirely different approaches I’d think BC is at least 2x it’s reported numbers?

But you’re right, you could dig into number of tests, how tests were triggered, etc and come up with a much better estimate.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by geerlingguy on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @01:10AM (#29634513)
To the coronavirus, that sounds like an opportunity.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by jacquesm on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @01:17AM (#29634560)
To a suitably changed virus any population of a certain size and density is an opportunity.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by kube-system on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @01:17AM (#29634559)
4% is the estimate or known cases?
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by cmrdporcupine on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @08:41AM (#29637263)
Known cases, positive test results only. But even if you doubled or tripled you'd be nowhere near 45%.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by kube-system on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @01:13PM (#29640270)
Assuming 2x or 3x is a reasonable factor between reported cases and total infections. US current official CDC estimates are 4x, and Canada has a lower testing rate (almost half) than the US. Earlier on, US estimated infections were 10x the reported count. Some studies for other developed countries have estimates that approach 30x. IMO, 8x doesn't seem like an unreasonable WAG given this.

I searched Canada's official resources, but I couldn't find anywhere that they publish their own estimates.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by cmrdporcupine on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @06:43PM (#29643535)
2x-3x anomaly would show up as distortions and fluctuations in both test positivity rates and in ICU/hospital rates. There's no such anomalies in the Ontario data, not since the first wave in March/April 2020 when testing was extremely limited. I pull the data daily from Ontario's public data API and graph and track it in a spreadsheet, I'm pretty familiar with what's there.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by nyolfen on Monday December 20, 2021 @10:38PM (#29633551)
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by runako on Monday December 20, 2021 @11:50PM (#29634020)
That's as of end of 2020, before the big waves this year (IIRC more people have died of Covid in the US in 2021 than in 2020).

More recent CDC estimate suggests the total number of infections is closer to 146 million[1]. I'm not sure how they are handling repeat infections, but nonetheless it sounds like their model has the US population at higher than 1/3 infected.

1 - https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/cases-updates/burd...

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by onlyrealcuzzo on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @12:36AM (#29634301)
Also in Guateng, ~75% of adults are vaccinated. That's better than most parts of the US and even a lot of places in Europe. There's just more <18 year olds in SA.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by wesleywt on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @01:18AM (#29634562)
You are making an assumption that is dubious . Please link to the study or statistic by a reputable source that we, South African have had 80% infection rates.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by nyolfen on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @08:10AM (#29637007)
i literally linked a citation at the bottom of the post
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by graeme on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @12:19AM (#29634189)
That first quote makes the same error as your initial comment! The Omicron wave grew faster, and with faster growth, a greater proportion of your cases are too recent to have been hospitalized
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by divbzero on Monday December 20, 2021 @11:36PM (#29633931)
> If the Hong Kong report is accurate, could regular nasal washing slow viral replication, e.g. in early stages of infection? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29620312

There is also evidence that certain mouth rinses reduce infectivity of SARS-CoV-2 in the lab [1] though without a trial it’s hard to know how that translates to real world transmission.

[1]: https://www.mdpi.com/2076-0817/10/3/272

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by systemvoltage on Monday December 20, 2021 @10:33PM (#29633526)
The Spectator Covid Tracker for Omicron is interesting: https://data.spectator.co.uk/category/south-africa
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by pbreit on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @01:09AM (#29634501)
No it's not. All indications are that omicron is much milder.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by Gene_Parmesan on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @04:11AM (#29635494)
I really am not sure why you got downvoted. Here is a NYMag article that supports what you're saying: https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2021/12/and-now-for-the-good...
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by roenxi on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @06:09AM (#29636222)
It hasn't been a month since the Omicron variant was reported to the WHO. All the indications could point any way and we wouldn't have solid evidence yet - it takes time for the disease to play out. NYMag can't magic solid evidence into existence when it doesn't really exist, especially from a week ago. This is the same sort of thing as got the "its just a flu" type mutterings while the pandemic was ramping up.

It might be a lot milder, and that would be nice. But if it turns out to be about the same then the speed of its spread is scary.

[dead]
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by jhgb on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @07:28AM (#29636728)
> It's time to get back to our lives and put Covid on the back burner. There seems to be no end in sight if we don't. There's no talk about people having natural immunity, you don't hear about studies on what makes people asymptomatic, it's nothing but 'get vaxxed', 'get boosted', 'the unvaccinated are going to die.'

Well I'm no Pasteur but it sure sounds to me like the latter is a proven means to achieve the former.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by ars on Monday December 20, 2021 @10:15PM (#29633402)
These numbers are very difficult to interpret without knowing the base - how much of the population is in each category.

Also booster vs double vax - is that just that the shot is more recent, or does 3 shots make a qualitative difference?

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by seoaeu on Monday December 20, 2021 @11:34PM (#29633915)
Against delta, the early research showed 2 doses + boosters to be more effective than the original 2 dose series ever were. For instance, [0] shows them being 20x more effective compared to the control group with two vaccine doses (which corresponds to something like 60x better than someone completely unvaccinated)

[0]: https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/acip/meetings/downloads/slides-...

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by walterbell on Monday December 20, 2021 @10:25PM (#29633467)
> how much of the population is in each category

Denmark population is 5.8 million people, https://www.worldometers.info/world-population/denmark-popul...

> booster vs double vax - is that just that the shot is more recent, or does 3 shots make a qualitative difference?

Probably the former. There are many papers which show declining efficacy each month. Mass-vaccination campaigns in each country probably means that # of shots can be used to determine recency.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by foolfoolz on Monday December 20, 2021 @10:53PM (#29633648)
does it really matter? you have a choice to get the vaccine.

i think these numbers should end the pandemic completely. we have a virus that’s contagious. if you take available medicine it won’t kill you. that’s baseline where we were 2 years ago

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by ars on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @01:11AM (#29634522)
Of course it matters - if you had the second vaccination recently you should wait till around 5 or 6 months to get the booster, but if the booster makes a qualitative difference then you should get it right away.

If the booster fades after a few months then that's important to know as well.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by omginternets on Monday December 20, 2021 @11:17PM (#29633808)
Unless your employer mandates it …
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by dude187 on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @12:51AM (#29634395)
Hopefully those get thrown out in court
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by walterbell on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @01:21AM (#29634578)
One scenario is that Tuesday's winter solstice speech will make a case for "grave danger" which could provide justification for U.S. courts to uphold OSHA mandate, domestic travel bans of unvax, and other unprecedented NPIs. Meanwhile, reality will continue to provide data on actual vs. narrative danger.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by dude187 on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @01:51AM (#29634712)
I think there's a good possibility you're correct, but I'm also holding out hope he instead says we need to stop looking at cases as a focus of concern.

Given his recent message of doom and gloom, chances are you're correct. I just hope people start actually start following the science and work to eliminate all of these people

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by landemva on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @12:39AM (#29634322)
Get some shoes and walk away.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by lovecg on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @12:53AM (#29634405)
Unless you’re 50 with a mortgage, then it’s not much of a “choice”.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by omginternets on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @01:30AM (#29634622)
Yeah, I just might. Others aren’t as lucky.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by make_it_sure on Monday December 20, 2021 @10:11PM (#29633367)
14 deaths in UK so far, ICU and deaths are a lagging indicator.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by listless on Monday December 20, 2021 @11:13PM (#29633777)
Because of COVID or with COVID when they died?

Why is it so damn difficult to figure out what’s really happening? I’ve read about 10 stories today all telling me I should be very worried about Omicron and not a single one has any data.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by VBprogrammer on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @01:38AM (#29634663)
I suspect you are being downvoted because of your question about what it means to have died from COVID.

I agree this is a trope which is trotted out by vaccine deniers and even those who said that COVID itself was a hoax before that.

However, 1500 people in the UK die on an average day. Remember back in the days we were able to point to the number of excess deaths in the UK? 14 people dead in 2 weeks is very near the noise floor. Unfortunately what we would like to know is how much longer these people would have lived without COVID. I suspect this is not knowable.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by zerocount on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @04:03AM (#29635457)
He merely asked for the number of deaths directly caused by Covid. Where do you get the idea that anyone is questioning what it means to die from Covid?
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by VBprogrammer on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @09:08AM (#29637487)
Directly caused is a very tricky question to answer on both the positive and negative sides. For example is someone who has terminal cancer who dies of COVID counted? Even though they are on a cocktail of drugs to treat the cancer they may well have lived for months or years later.

Similarly, someone with well managed diabetes, do we write them off as having a comortality even though they may have lived for decades longer by all available indications.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by brigandish on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @05:12AM (#29635845)
> I agree this is a trope which is trotted out by vaccine deniers and even those who said that COVID itself was a hoax before that.

As you can see from this[1] Freedom of Information (FOI) request, the ONS makes a distinction between "Involving COVID-19" and "Due to COVID-19".

> Unfortunately what we would like to know is how much longer these people would have lived without COVID. I suspect this is not knowable.

It's also interesting to see in that FOI answer the average age of death is higher than the average life expectancy in the UK. It might give an indication of whether people are being taken to meet their maker early.

[1] https://www.ons.gov.uk/aboutus/transparencyandgovernance/fre...

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by lobocinza on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @10:17AM (#29638146)
Anti-vaxxers exploit methodological deficiencies to push their agenda. People that should be improving their methodology exploit anti-vaxxers absurdity to maintain status quo.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by benjaminwootton on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @04:51AM (#29635741)
People on the “anti side” of the debate have been asking this for 2 years. It was a valid question then and a more important one now.

It is likely that a significant percentage of people are dying with incidental Covid infections. Depending on how significant, that completely changes the dynamics.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by Paradigma11 on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @11:42AM (#29639103)
Well, you can estimate the probability of someone randomly selected in the population testing positive for covid at a certain point in time. The probability of "dying with Covid" should be similar unless there is evidence of a bias.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by Paradigma11 on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @02:00PM (#29640743)
Sloppy formulation of mine, its an upper limit i think.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by lobocinza on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @10:15AM (#29638122)
Excess mortality is an useful metric. It's flaw being that our habits completely changed due to social distancing and lock down and has to be addressed somehow.

> Because of COVID or with COVID when they died?

I'm afraid this question is impossible to answer due to uncertainty but...

I - Outliers like immunodeficient and morbid obese could be excluded.

II - If you want to know the probability of someone dying due to having COVID you can use the Bayesian theorem to find it giving that you have (1) the incidence of people dying that have Covid (2) the incidence of any kind of death, (3) the incidence of Covid (lack of testing is an issue).

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by Barrin92 on Monday December 20, 2021 @11:16PM (#29633796)
because it's a relatively new strain and it's hard to figure out to what degree previous infection plays a role. A lot of people may have had covid without ever knowing it.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by landemva on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @12:35AM (#29634296)
'A lot of people may have had covid without ever knowing it.'

If a lot of people had it and were ok, why the continued mask hysteria? It is beginning to seem like people don't want to move on.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by dragontamer on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @01:40AM (#29634671)
My local clinic is so overbooked with work, that I had to come in before they opened and stand in line. Even though I was in line before they even opened, it took me 2 hours to get some basic care (just a TDAP booster, wooping cough, for reasons completely unrelated to COVID19). Yeah, there was a line long before I got there.

This is a major story because all across the country, our health care system has been stretched to its limits. We had a nursing shortage before COVID19 started, but this pandemic has only made our nurses and doctors even _MORE_ overworked than expected, as they deal with case-after-case of COVID19.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by argiopetech on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @11:00AM (#29638615)
How much of that is due to changes in procedure (additional cleaning, more involved check-in, etc.?) How much of that is due to healthcare workers leaving the local area (e.g., for incredibly lucrative travel nursing positions) or the industry generally (due to burnout, unemployment incentives, vaccine refusal, etc.?) Finally, how much of the current situation is due to the "catch-up" effect of people who were unable or unwilling to have sub-optimal diagnosed in the midst of the 2020 hysteria and are now seeking treatment for more and more serious conditions?

There is much more at play here than the disease itself. Government, media, and institutions should be held to account for their role in exacerbating the situation.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by dragontamer on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @11:14AM (#29638781)
A month ago, I had no problem getting a flu shot. Walk in, got the shot and left. Like 5 minutes.

This past week, COVID-19 cases are triple what they used to be and flu cases are doubled in my county.

It doesn't take a genius to figure out the problem. Same clinic, same staff, just one month apart with a sudden COVID and Flu surge.

It was even the same nurse who administered the two shots.

-----

And the receptionist said, sorry for the wait, we've had an explosion of COVID-19 cases. EDIT: "Overrun" was the receptionist's word actually. But you get the gist.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by argiopetech on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @11:38AM (#29639055)
Fair enough. Out of curiosity, do you live in one of the areas the CDC lists as having a high COVID-related ICU bed occupancy?

https://www.cdc.gov/nhsn/covid19/report-patient-impact.html

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by dragontamer on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @11:39AM (#29639068)
Category D (60% to 69%) area.

There's no ICU at this facility I go to. Just a neighborhood clinic. But enough people are taking COVID19 tests that they're having issues keeping up.

-------

Everyone around me was in for non-COVID19 reasons. We all came in on maybe Thursday/Friday/Saturday, saw the 4-hour wait, and decided to come back on Sunday to stand in line before the clinic opened.

But the number of COVID19 walk-in patients was clearly big enough to cause all of us in line to postpone our health care (again, mine was pretty whatever, just a TDAP/Wooping Cough booster, the person in front of me had mysterious pains and the person behind me had a mysterious blister). So nothing "serious" mind you, but... there's a lot of self-selection bias here since we all came back another day.

----

Furthermore, the clinic has temporarily suspended its giveout of flu shots. Its really overrun right now and quite evident. I drive past it every day to work and I can see that its parking lot is completely packed.

The sign-in line took 45 minutes to clear after the clinic opened. That's just walk in, type in your name + problem into the computer, and sit down. A lot of us standing outside in the cold waiting just to get to the damn computer screen to sign in.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by argiopetech on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @12:00PM (#29639338)
Thanks! I'm trying to build a mental model of how well that data corresponds to the "on the ground" situation. Evey datum helps.

It's likely unknowable, but I'd be curious to know how many of those coming in for COVID tests are being required to test.

We all know at this point the symptoms of COVID. It's a generally good idea (as well as the most comfortable option) to avoid the public when ill. Exercising a sick day or call-out option to rest and recoup seems more sensible and causes less risk to the public and the capacity of healthcare institutions than sending every case of the sniffles for a test.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by dragontamer on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @12:07PM (#29639419)
> It's likely unknowable, but I'd be curious to know how many of those coming in for COVID tests are being required to test.

The data that's important is "percent positive".

When the covid19 cases are 5% positive or less, you've got accurate statistics. When its above 5%, then things get less-and-less accurate. That is to say: you want roughly 95% of people getting COVID19 tests to be negative, to ensure you're "counting" as many people as possible.

We're at 10%+ positive now. Which means our county is no longer with accurate covid19 counts.

---------

Its a local goal that's been emphasized. Test as many cases as possible so that we get as accurate a picture as possible. I'm not sure if this is applicable to the rest of the country. But we really do strive for 5% positive around here, and its kinda bad that we're failing that now... and is highly indicative that we're undercounting cases severely.

I mean... 4-hour wait times, amirite? If you've got (maybe) COVID19, and the receptionist says "4-hour wait before your test", will you really sit there? Or will you go home and just take off of work for a few days?

Its a natural behavior, but that's the sort of thing that leads to dramatic undercounts of COVID19 during these times.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by brazzy on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @01:16AM (#29634555)
Because even if a lot of people are OK and only a few die, those "few" still add up to hundreds of thousands dead people, when the entire population gets infected. Which sure sounds like a good reason to get hysterical. To say nothing of the issue of a catastrophically overtaxed health system and what side effects that will have.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by argiopetech on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @11:17AM (#29638808)
From the top-down, metrics focused perspective, I agree.

From an individual, bottom-up perspective, most people don't have a high risk of death from COVID. The majority will avoid spreading any disease to others, usually by self-enforced quarantine. Some individuals will die, but all of us will die of something some day and we should come up peace with that.

The only top-down mitigation to death of a specific cause is legislation. For an endemic disease, legislation to avoid the spread of that disease must necessarily approach tyranny.

I've addressed the overtaxing if the health system I'm reply to a sibling. It is unclear to me that any overtax if the health system (which is, from what I can glean from the CDC limited, in the US, to a few states) is due to COVID directly rather than institutional responses to COVID.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by spookthesunset on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @03:35PM (#29641789)
> rather than institutional responses to COVID

I bet you a lot of fake internet money that when the fire is out and cooler heads prevail, most of the overtax was institutional responses to COVID.

We won't be able to know how true this actually is until years (perhaps decades) after this all calms down. There is simply too much pressure to maintain the current narrative and do true root cause analysis.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by taurath on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @03:44AM (#29635347)
Masks help slow it and keep it more manageable. If everyone in a country attended a giant “get covid” rally in their neighborhood many hundreds of thousand or maybe millions would die as the hospital system would be overwhelmed despite omicron appearing to be less likely to require hospitalization.

Right now the hospitalization number is already too high, and is putting massive strain on nurses. When Ventilators and ICU beds run out people die that normally wouldn’t.

It’s not so much mask hysteria as hysteria of a large number of people refusing to protect themselves or their communities from the virus or spreading it.

It would not be a problem if unvaccinated people simply agreed to not be treated by a hospital when they get covid. That will never happen. So wear a mask to slow the spread.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by zerocount on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @04:28AM (#29635594)
The whole 'hospitals are overwhelmed' thing is getting old now. A few do get overwhelmed, but everything seems to work out and you don't hear any more about it.

So enough with the fear mongering, if you're not high risk, go get Covid and be done with it.

Oh, and we're not refusing to protect ourselves. Our bodies already do that, it's called an immune system and when I caught Covid all the little immune workers showed up and took care of business. You don't need the vaccine unless you're high risk.

And another thing, before vaccines the hospitals and their staff were doing just fine without the vaccine, yet some were fired later for not taking it. It's insanity and it's profit and politically driven hysteria.

Masks keep us from spitting on eachother. They help.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by mattzito on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @07:27AM (#29636713)
A healthy-as-a-horse family friend caught Covid (unvaccinated because he didn’t believe Covid was a real thing), no risk factors other than being in his 50s, and died on a ventilator. Probably would have died anyway, but in his case he died because the ICU staff was overworked during a local wave and his vent tube clogged and no one noticed. Now his (also anti-vaccine) widow is considering suing the hospital for malpractice.

Now, obviously the above is anecdata, but there’s a real chain of causality from the standpoint that if my friend had been vaccinated, this probably wouldn’t have happened. If the people within his immediate social circle were vaccinated, this might not have happened. If his community at large was vaccinated, not only would he be less likely to catch it, he would be less likely to end up in the hospital, and even in the hospital, he would have received more attentive care.

You can’t just hand wave away the societal impact of having a novel virus circulating through the community. And even if you want to shoulder the risk yourself, what about the impact your contribution to spread has on other people? Where’s your obligation to your community at large?

I met another person, friend of a friend, last week, who can barely speak above a whisper. She caught Covid (runner, vaccinated), and ended up with lung damage. It was two months before she could walk around without being winded. She did everything right, and still ended up severely harmed by Covid.

Now, one can turn around and say, “well, look, the vaccines were pointless!”, but obviously that’s ridiculous- it’s just the law of large numbers. The data clearly shows that if you are vaccinated, you are less likely to get sick, end up in the hospital , and die of Covid. If everyone around you is vaccinated, it’s less likely you’ll need to depend on the vaccine to make the odds work out in your favor.

There’s all kinds of aspects of life where we collectively decide to look out for each other for the benefit of all. It’s frankly shocking that so much death and pain is handwaved away as “getting old now”, and even more so that it’s political.

Edit: I realize there’s no changing anyones mind here, so I could have saved my breath. But I think it’s worth calling out that the arguments put forth in the parent post are just ridiculous, and if we applied the same logic to drunk driving, or smallpox, or personal property rights, people would think the argument was ludicrous.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by zerocount on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @03:52PM (#29655021)
You and I stand on opposite sides of the fence. Neither one of us will change the other's mind. I also will respect your view points, but I won't back down on personal choice. That's the main issue with the pandemic right now.

My ex-wife knows two people who've died after taking the vaccine. One at the 2 week mark and the other the day after. She also knows a body builder, in excellent condition, who ended up on a ventilator from Covid. He was in that condition for months and has less than half of his lung capacity now. Those two would be alive if not pressured or forced to take the vaccine. And that is one category of people (dead from vaccine) that gets hand waived by the numbers, as if those people meant nothing. We all have stories...

I had Covid and recovered nicely at 51 years old, as did my ex-wife at 50. So there's another counter story. And I never said or advocated that vaccines are pointless. They absolutely work for the purposes of reducing severe illness and chance of death. I encourage people who think they're in a high risk category to get vaccinated, but not everyone needs it. But that's what's being pushed right now because if we can just vaccinate everyone, it will effectively go away. No, it won't. The vaccinated get Covid and spread it to one another because they don't get sick enough to stay home. I didn't have the energy to go any where. I had to get in bed and nap every two hours.

Why can't you show the data and allow everyone to make a choice? If you want to talk numbers, it's very rare that you'll end up on a ventilator or in the hospital from Covid. And don't talk to me about the collective good. People don't give a shit about me or you. I get one chance at life and I'm making choices for me, not for strangers. And I won't blame anyone else for doing the same thing.

My condolences to the loved ones of all who've died from Covid and the vaccine. I encourage all to make their choices without consideration of outside influence. It is your one life and you must do what you think is best. It's better to die free than live in collective chains.

Good luck and godspeed.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by mattzito on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @07:40PM (#29657372)
I eagerly await our world where my personal choice allows me to drive drunk down your street, because people don’t give a shit about me or you, and I get one chance at life and I’m making choices for me, not for strangers.

Likewise, I’m going to stop allowing minorities to live in my apartment building - I’m making choices for me, after all, not for strangers.

Let’s get rid of ALL vaccine mandates for the same reason, I’m sure you’d agree that we would be better off if everyone got to decide whether they got a measles shot or not (btw, measles deaths are on the rise for this exact reason). Maybe we shouldn’t have mandated polio vaccines?

I eagerly await the removal of consumer protection laws, because I can make the decision for myself about what is safe for me.

No more hand washing for restaurant staff - that’s an infringement on their personal choices. Ditto with food storage guidelines - refrigeration is expensive. Gotta do what I think is best

“Better to die free than live in collective chains.”

Ridiculous argument, and one that AGAIN if we made about basically any other societal rule that is for the collective good, we would be laughed out of the room. After 800k deaths in America alone, for sure, personal “freedom” stands above everyone else’s welfare.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by listless on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @01:45PM (#29640564)
The important point you make is that he was 50s and in good health. That should alarm everyone. People who are 50s and in good health should NOT be dying on vents. Why anyone over 40 would refuse vaccination is a pure tragedy and nothing but. It breaks my heart to hear these stories.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by zerocount on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @04:05AM (#29635470)
That's exactly what we need to be questioning. Keep asking questions and pressing for answers that make sense. We need to move on.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by tonyedgecombe on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @06:53AM (#29636485)
>why the continued mask hysteria

Is that pro-mask hysteria or anti-mask hysteria?

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by argiopetech on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @11:31AM (#29638960)
I'm not sure it matters. Hysterical people do not make good choices. When the hysterical people who run the system do nothing to calm their hysteria or the public's, the result is chronic unreasoned decision making, rapid flip-flopping, and the overall appearance of bad faith.

The knee-jerk reaction to bad faith interaction (from all people) is "I don't know what, but not that." The knee-jerk response of the powers that be to mutiny is to exercise more power. The feedback worsens the situation.

If we would stop trying to manage rapidly-evolving situations with to-down legislation, returned individual freedoms, and all took a deep breath, I'm sure the populace (who certainly don't desire the death of their friends and loved ones) could find a reasoned solution that is at least as effective as what we have now.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by mbg721 on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @11:34AM (#29639001)
Or the response to anti-human policy is just "Not that", and the policymakers are scrambling for another way to shove it in.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by argiopetech on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @11:43AM (#29639117)
There are, of course, people who are not hysterical on all sides. That some of those are capitalizing on the situation to enact long-desired changes (legislative or otherwise) comes as no surprise.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by walterbell on Monday December 20, 2021 @10:13PM (#29633388)
Would be good to see category percentages for UK cases.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by thehappypm on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @11:52AM (#29639238)
14 total is very low, the UK was averaging over 100 deaths per day in October.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by dmitryminkovsky on Monday December 20, 2021 @11:04PM (#29633714)
Why is the unvaccinated number so much lower? Is the population highly vaccinated?
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by orforforof on Monday December 20, 2021 @11:39PM (#29633954)
According to Table 2 their sample had 8,199 unvaccinated and 9,269 vaccinated. It seems odd that more cases were found in the vaccinated people, can anyone suggest why? Statistical anomaly?

Edit: I misread the table, I thought column 1 was number of subjects. The replies explain well why the # of cases would be larger for the (larger) vaccinated population.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by akrito on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @12:22AM (#29634211)
It's because many more people are vaccinated. Assume 100,000 people are vaccinated and 10,000 aren't. If the infection rate in vaccinated population is 5%, and in the unvaccinated population is 50%, then out of 10,000 infected people, 5,000 will be vaccinated and 5,000 won't.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by landemva on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @12:37AM (#29634305)
A couple years ago vaccines prevented almost all people from getting sick. Not anymore.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by walterbell on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @01:28AM (#29634608)
CDC changed their definition in Sept. 2021, https://www.miamiherald.com/news/coronavirus/article25411126...

> Before the change, the definition for “vaccination” read, “the act of introducing a vaccine into the body to produce immunity to a specific disease.” Now, the word “immunity” has been switched to “protection.” The term “vaccine” also got a makeover. The CDC’s definition changed from “a product that stimulates a person’s immune system to produce immunity to a specific disease” to the current “a preparation that is used to stimulate the body’s immune response against diseases.”

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by _djo_ on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @03:44AM (#29635351)
The CDC's definition has been out of date for years. It turns out that to a large degree sterilising immunity was a myth with only a tiny, tiny fractions of vaccines actually achieving it. [0]

Most just achieve enough reduction in transmission to end or prevent outbreaks by bringing the r0 well below 1.

[0]https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2021/09/steriliz...

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by zerocount on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @05:30AM (#29635958)
How convenient that the article, in effect, supports the current agenda of pushing vaccines on everyone. It does this through the angle of sterilizing immunity being unachievable.

It starts off with some Danish guy observing a measels outbreak in Scotland and how the people that had the measels 65 years earlier were not affected by the current outbreak. You can stop reading at that point because it totally ignores that critical part of the story. It then uses this observation as the catalyst for the 'myth' of sterilizing immunity of the measels vaccine. Then it goes into testimony from experts on how we can't prove an infection took place, blah, blah, blah... Right.

So here we go with the wiggle room that eventually justifies the Covid vaccine being given to everyone on earth. Never mind that 65 years later the old people didn't get infected with the measels. Their bodies must have had some seasoned immunity workers who remembered how they handled it last time.

It's never ending. "We don't have proof." "There's not enough evidence." "We can't quantify what defines that." But just to be safe, give this to everyone and punish those that refuse. I can't believe people actually suggest that unvaccinated people not be allowed in the hospital or should just suffer their 'bad decisions.' Really? Is that what it's come to?

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by _djo_ on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @05:55AM (#29636127)
‘Convenient’, or unsurprising because it’s just recording the current scientific consensus around vaccines and that’s the same thing driving current policy? Not everything is a conspiracy with malevolent intent.

For all the damage that COVID has wreaked, it’s providing a huge increase in the amount of attention, effort, and investment going into studying the immune system, vaccination, and infectious diseases in general. It’s not surprising that some older ideas and theories are being overturned or modified.

You’re also wrongly treating the vaccines’ effect on transmission as binary, either being fully sterilising or not. In truth they’re all able to reduce transmission somewhat from 20-50%, and that alone might be a good enough benefit to mandate full vaccination across the population.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by brazzy on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @01:18AM (#29634563)
Most vaccines never had 100% effectiveness, especially the flu vaccine.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by zerocount on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @04:34AM (#29635639)
Yep. That wasn't the goal for the Covid vaccine. It was to keep people from getting severe cases and preventing deaths. It works, but it should be targeted to high-risk individuals and not a blanket strategy that's not needed for the majority of the world's population.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by tomjen3 on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @02:04AM (#29634793)
I don't think the flu one ever did, and smallpox, rabies and Measels probably still do, though I wouldn't recommend testing it.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by ramesh31 on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @12:45AM (#29634360)
You need 90%+ vaccination rates to start seeing herd immunity, which is what we have for things like MMR.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by hcurtiss on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @01:46AM (#29634697)
It wasn’t that long ago that the scientists were suggesting 70% was sufficient. Is it that >90% is required when the vaccines don’t effectively impede transmission? Is it possible 100% would not be sufficient?
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by usrusr on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @03:49AM (#29635381)
It's been clear for a long time that even 100% won't make the virus disappear. Yes, back in the early days when we didn't use the greek alphabet yet eradication was a reasonably possible best case outcome (though not really likely, given the transmissibility across species.

Look at how prevalent pre-delta variants are now: no, they have not disappeared because almost everybody had delta, they have disappeared because of vaccine shots combined with moderate (compared to 2020) NPI. A virus strain does not simply disappear because there's a new one in town, it keeps replicating until it runs out of hosts. And virions are certainly not defecting to a newer, more glorious flag (like humans might do)

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by beberlei on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @02:35AM (#29634949)
The 70% number was often mentioned when the original variant was still predominant end of last year. Alpha and Delta are just so much more transmissible. The vaccine was never said to prevent all infections by serious scientists
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by _djo_ on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @03:45AM (#29635359)
70% would have been workable for the original or 'wild type' strain. Delta and Omicron are many times more transmissible.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by lukevdp on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @02:06AM (#29634807)
Yes it is, it depends on the efficacy of the vaccine and the transmissibility of the virus.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by landemva on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @01:01AM (#29634459)
Does a prior infected person count toward herd immunity? I have Dr. letter of my recovery.

I heard those who had it and recovered have sterilizing immunity. Is that better or worse than the vaccine non-sterilizing immunity for getting us to herd immunity?

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by usrusr on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @03:55AM (#29635418)
Herd immunity counts nothing against delta or omicron. The endemic state, a permanent balance between immunity vaning and reinfection, that's not herd immunity. Natural immunity is just as temporary as vaccine immunity, give or take a few months.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by joshuahughes on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @05:13AM (#29635851)
"Natural immunity is just as temporary as vaccine immunity, give or take a few months."

Citations needed for that claim. Based on the articles below, natural immunity seems to be vastly longer lasting...

Lasting immunity found after recovery from COVID-19 https://www.nih.gov/news-events/nih-research-matters/lasting...

Had COVID? You’ll probably make antibodies for a lifetime https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-01442-9

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by ripe on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @07:01AM (#29636537)
The concluding para from your Nature article says the opposite of what you're claiming, and supports the person you're replying to:

"the persistence of antibody production, whether elicited by vaccination or by infection, does not ensure long-lasting immunity to COVID-19. The ability of some emerging SARS-CoV-2 variants to blunt the protective effects of antibodies means that additional immunizations may be needed to restore levels, says Ellebedy. “My presumption is, we will need a booster.”"

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by peteradio on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @09:06AM (#29637478)
Its a confusing conversation because theres different levels of immunity.

I think the bone marrow cells are indicative of long-term protection from severe illness. They have long ramp up time from the point of latest exposure.

Blood boosted antibodies will be there to thwart an infection and continue to be there to prevent reinfection but the body turns off the pump because it becomes a waste of resource without an active enemy.

So the lifecycle of a (non-boosted) person going through endemic sars-cov2 will be slow activation followed by an afterburner which will tend to get you through a wave. Or you can try to time a booster to get you through a wave without getting triggered by the actual virus.

So in a sense, there is evidence long term "slow" immunity which is less effective at preventing transmissions and so allows for waves which indicates a certain lack of immunity by another defintion. I think that leads to conflict because of fuzzy definition on either side of the conversation.

Anyway that's my mental model of this whole thing. Any glaring holes?

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by usrusr on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @07:27AM (#29636716)
There is plenty of evidence of natural immunity decaying. It will likely never (not in a lifetime) fall to a level equal to an entirely unprepared immune system, but the same holds for vaccine effect: immune system responses are a log decay, with various nonlinear effects applied (thresholds, saturation, the occasional rare ADE and so on) to different aspects that are of different importance for different viruses so that the observed curves look a bit different in each case. Yes, for some viruses, even what's left after a century is enough.

But those details are completely besides the point for endemic state, endemic state is endemic state wether reinfection, on average happens every quarter or wether it happens every five years. The only difference is that anything larger than a few months will lead to massive seasonality, and longer cycles will lead to a larger severity spread. This severity spread will be the decisive factor in the question of revaccination thresholds (maybe higher than current flu shot habits, maybe lower, maybe about the same), but there are far too many uncertainties to bother with concrete predictions.

What we do know: a year or two from now there won't be any vaccine-only immunities left, everybody will either be vacc+infection or infection only.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by ifyoubuildit on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @08:59AM (#29637404)
> There is plenty of evidence of natural immunity decaying

You said something like this in another thread, but I've yet to see sources for this. Can you provide some?

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by walterbell on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @01:30AM (#29634619)
In the Denmark numbers above, only 4.3% of Omicron infections were Covid-recovered, compared to 77% being double-vax, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29633285
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by meheleventyone on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @02:17AM (#29634865)
For that to be meaningful you need to compare the per capita rate of vaccinated and prior covid infected. That’ll show you very roughly how much protection each provides in a way that’s comparable.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by usrusr on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @04:14AM (#29635515)
With hardly more than 10% recovered, total, vs almost everybody vaccinated that's not much of a difference. Very well within the range of methodical difference like in which group those recovered and vaccinated are counted and so on.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by garmaine on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @03:13AM (#29635144)
Why don’t you get the jab? It would be strictly better to have both.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by rabuse on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @01:30AM (#29634616)
Anecdotal, but I got my first bought of covid in Feb. 2020, and it was very flu-like for me. I've had 2 more infections after that (one, didn't even know, and the next was like a mild cold). In South Florida, we barely had a lockdown.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by beberlei on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @02:39AM (#29634968)
How do you even know it was COVID? It could have been any number of flu/cold? In feb 20 there was no way to get tested for it
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by rabuse on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @08:29AM (#29637154)
The complete loss of smell and taste, was never a flu symptom to me before.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by avereveard on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @02:06AM (#29634812)
It's not a sustainable business, once polio was eradicated from territory, you lost all sales. New vaccines are more of what we'd call a subscription model.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by sdenton4 on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @12:19AM (#29634184)
Consider the extremal point: If 100% of people are vaccinated, then all cases are breakthrough cases, and 0% of cases will be in unvaccinated people. At some point, the raw count of breakthrough cases crosses over and exceeds the raw count of unvaccinated cases. This doesn't mean the vaccine is ineffective, of course!
[dead]
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by shawabawa3 on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @05:27AM (#29635933)
What? If you think for 5 seconds it's extremely easy to see how effective the vaccine is

Compare the % of population that is vaxxed Vs unvaxxed, compare the % of cases in vaxxed Vs unvaxxed people, see how the percentage compares

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by Xylakant on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @02:58AM (#29635057)
No, that’s not what it means. It means that comparing the absolute numbers of people infected in both groups - vaccinated people and unvaccinated people - or even the percentage of the total number of infections is not valid. You need to take the ratio of people infected relative to the group size.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by ip26 on Monday December 20, 2021 @11:18PM (#29633809)
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by walterbell on Monday December 20, 2021 @11:11PM (#29633757)
Unclear why unvax Omicron infection is 14%, when unvax Delta infection is 44%, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29633440
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by vermilingua on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @12:25AM (#29634231)
These numbers stack up, if the vaccine is effective against Delta but not against Omicron. The bulk of people being infected with Delta would then be unvax, while anyone is fair game for Omicron infection, backed up by the 14%unvax/77%dvax correlating with 80%+ dvax population in Denmark.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by mahkeiro on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @12:30AM (#29634264)
Because vaccine effect on Omicron transmission is very weak.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by dataflow on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @08:34PM (#29720676)
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by awhitby on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @12:53AM (#29634407)
It's obviously possible that this is a bad nowcast (as argued in Edit2 of the parent), but there are other possibilities.

I suspect the % of tests that are of asymptomatic people is much higher than a few weeks ago, because of travel plans and publicity around omicron. If omicron does produce milder symptoms (either inherently or because more omicron cases are breakthrough and mitigated by vaccination) then it could be that a higher proportion of omicron cases are now being tested (and some fraction sequenced), relative to delta, compared with a few weeks ago.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by littlestymaar on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @02:31AM (#29634926)
> The press will have to publish a new round of articles clarifying their prior wave of headlines. It might happen tomorrow, later this week, or some time next week, but it will happen. This result won’t stand.

Well since the doubling time of the omicron incidence seams to be below 2 days (worldwide result estimates between 1.4 and 2.2), even if it wasn't the case last Friday, Omicron has probably passed the 73% threshold since then so I don't think anyone would bother retracting their writings.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by pelasaco on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @04:10AM (#29635490)
So looks like - as expected - the Virus is getting "weaker" i.e adapting itself better to your host, without killing it, or is it to early to come up too a conclusion? I read the same report from different countries too...
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by taurath on Monday December 20, 2021 @10:12PM (#29633378)
Know any comparisons vs delta??
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by walterbell on Monday December 20, 2021 @10:20PM (#29633440)
19,137 Delta cases in Denmark, also from Table 2 in same doc.

  0.07% fatal, 0.11% ICU, 1.5% hospital
  0.9% Covid-recovered 
  50% double vax, 3% booster
  44% unvax, 3% single vax
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by zzleeper on Monday December 20, 2021 @10:34PM (#29633530)
That table is extremely useful b/c it tells us it's still too early to tell. Had just a single of the 785 omicron cases died (like maybe they got an unrelated stroke while in the hospital), then that would change the numbers from 0% IFR to 0.12% IFR (i.e. above Delta).

Also, noticed that ICU rate is 3x higher with Omicron (which might also be related to the lack of enough observations).

That said, I really hope IFR is much lower, given all the vaccines, boosters, and previous infections.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by walterbell on Monday December 20, 2021 @10:41PM (#29633563)
> ICU rate is 3x higher with Omicron

Sorry, that was a typo on my part, Omicron ICU should have been 0.13% not 0.3%, fixed now after double checking the source doc, thanks.

The Delta-Omicron ICU rates are similar in this Denmark sample.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by mahkeiro on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @02:01AM (#29634784)
What may be of interest is that the proportion of vaccinated people is more important with Omicron cases. It may mean that the vaccine is less protecting against ICU as the rate are similar, and that would be worrying. But we are going to have to wait at least 2 more weeks to get a better picture.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by usaphp on Monday December 20, 2021 @10:39PM (#29633557)
Compared that to flu data from 2018-19 season [1]:

28,908,721 flu cases:

0.09% fatal, 1.3% hospital

[1] - https://www.cdc.gov/flu/about/burden/2018-2019.html

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by Gene_Parmesan on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @04:10AM (#29635483)
> Steering public attention away from the total number of infections and toward serious cases only -- as some Biden advisers have encouraged -- could prove a challenge after nearly two years of intense focus on the pandemic's every up and down.

At some point this definitely needs to happen. I don't know whether now is that time. But at some point, this thing is going endemic. Reporting purely on case numbers ad infinitum is just going to cause warning fatigue, and people are going to stop listening. Again, I'm not saying I think now is the time to make this transition. But I recall watching a nightly news report over Thanksgiving saying that in vaccinated adults, the rate of hospitalization with Delta-variant breakthrough infections at that point was... 0.0 in 10,000. That's not to say no one is going to the hospital; obviously that's not true.

But we run the very real risk of making people stop listening to the warnings. It's like those who live in hurricane regions; after years of hearing "better put your SSN on your arm so we can identify your body," and then evacuating - and coming back with nothing amiss because the storm missed you by 100 miles - they stop listening. And when the big storm does hit, they don't evac because they just roll their eyes and think "Oh, not this again."

Obviously you can't stop warning people about incoming hurricanes. And just like in COVID, there are serious complications with hurricane forecasting that cause overwarning to be necessary to some extent. But if there's a serious COVID variant that is actually a ruthless killer that arises, we will need people to listen.

I was reading yesterday that the Omicron wave appears to have already peaked in South Africa, just 3 weeks after its identification, and they expect it to peak here by end of January. That is significantly shorter than Delta. On top of that, they are finding the Omicron cases much milder than Delta. They seem to believe that Omicron has migrated out of the lungs and into the upper respiratory tract, where it is less dangerous but better able to spread. A researcher quoted in the article called it a "best-case scenario."

Yet we are still having warnings as if the apocalypse is about to come.

Again, I don't know what the right timing is for this, and until we figure it out I'm 100% on board with listening to the CDC. But - we don't report on the daily number of cold cases because the cold is part of life. And if/when COVID becomes something that is a mild upper respiratory infection for the near-entirety of non-immuno-compromised people, I think continuing to report daily on how many thousands of new cases we have serves no purpose other than continuing to stoke fear.*

And because this is important context for some sorts of people, I am an extremely progressive liberal who is steadfastly continuing to wear masks in public, and have been booster-ed for 2 weeks now.

*(This is a concern of mine because, as we know from 9/11 and the terror alert warning system that we now know was totally bogus, but had to deal with on the nightly news for years, there are elements in this country who are happy to take advantage of tragedies to stoke fear.)

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by rsfern on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @08:04AM (#29636949)
Somewhat of a counterpoint: the CDC has tracked the flu through the flusurv network for almost 20 years now (starting 2003/4 season). Popular reporting on how the flu season was going has been pretty common, though obviously with much less intensity and ubiquity.

Especially in severe outbreaks it’s been normal to have this kind of warning publication, see https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2018/01/12/5776320...

Anyway I agree that we collectively at some point have to stop over-reporting on Covid, but I don’t think it makes sense to drop it back to zero. At this point even with vaccines and developing therapeutics it doesn’t seem likely to become less of a health concern than the flu any time soon

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by ryathal on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @09:43AM (#29637783)
It's likely to get phased out with the midterm elections. Covid panic is no longer politically expedient.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by Animats on Monday December 20, 2021 @10:56PM (#29633670)
Those are good numbers. Early, yes, but good.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by smnrchrds on Monday December 20, 2021 @11:18PM (#29633811)
Not great, not terrible.
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by W-Stool on Monday December 20, 2021 @11:37PM (#29633945)
3.6?
[dead]
Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by belltaco on Monday December 20, 2021 @10:20PM (#29633441)
>Scientists have continued to say from the start that each strain will become weaker but more contagious.

Explain Delta then.

Re:Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week by eyelidlessness on Monday December 20, 2021 @10:43PM (#29633577)
And scientists generally haven’t said this. Mostly people overgeneralizing science on the internet. And frequently (in my experience) with a lot of well justified question marks.