If everyone is driving the 'recommended' speed of 130kmh on a German motorway then it is a severe risk if you drive slower. Road users need to be predictable. Trucks or motorhomes are slower, but you expect them to be slower. You see them from the distance and plan ahead. But a normal car that drives 60 when all others drive 130-140 is a massive danger as other drivers do not expect it to do so, so will lose precious seconds to react. You can get fined for driving unnecessarily slow.
In Germany you also cannot merge onto the motorway unless you have a certain speed already, and you cannot enter the motorway at all if your car can't do an appropriate minimum speed (or you have special transport papers and warning lights).
Do you happen to know the speed? I drive an Aygo (tiny, 3 cylinders) and I’d love to know how close I can get.
So every truck on the roads is a severe risk?
If you are doing 40mph but everyone else is doing 65-70 then you cause a hazard for people as they have to take evasive action to go around you, then others have to brake to avoid hitting the people going around you, then a ripple braking wave starts behind you, then a BMW driver rear-ends someone half a mile behind you and suddenly you've caused a multiple pile-up where someone died today, because you were going too slow for the conditions.
But I seriously doubt that driving below the speed limit has a measurable increase in risk.
I would bet the opposite: That driving below the speed limit decreases risk of serious accidents.
One reason for that is that rear end accidents where both cars are going in the same direction are typically much less serious than head on collisions. So even if slow drivers increase the risk of rear end accidents (which I doubt is significant), they reduce the impact of head on collisions much more leading to a net positive.
People should drive slower, it's always safer. (Apart from dumb maneuvers like brake checking...)
Some subsequent research affirms this curve, others call it into question. My own, informal read is that the stronger research generally affirms it.
Reducing the rate of harmless crashes is no good if the rate of severe crashes increases.
Also, all crashes are relevant. Fatalities can’t happen when there aren’t crashes.
The speeding crisis is mostly a moral panic.
"Would this person have died if the cars were driving slower?"
And simple physics tells us that almost always the answer is "No".
If you try to argue that driving faster is safer, you need to provide strong evidence. Statistical correlation over a time frame where cars and roads have been made much safer doesn't really convince me. Even a correlation between driver speed and collision risk is meaningless -- eg. people with poor vision generally drive slower, but are still more dangerous than drivers with good vision.
(I'm not saying that driving fast is unsafe in general. On a well maintained road with good visibility you can drive pretty fast with minimal risk. All I'm saying is that, all other things being equal, driving slower is almost always going to be safer)
It is not simply the case that anti-speed crusades result in safer roads. The USA’s 55 mph experiment a was a failure in that regard, and Vision Zero campaigns aren’t delivering on promises.
We really need to focus on crash elimination, which is not a hyper focus on speed. Crashes that don’t happen can’t injure or kill.
But I really doubt that slow drivers are inherently dangerous. Especially since a lot of road users are slow and can't drive fast (big trucks, tractors, mopeds, bicycles, RVs, cars with trailers, etc). So the focus must be on making sure that drivers are attentive and have good visibility, not telling slow drivers to step on the gas.
Sometimes, the right thing is for slow drivers to speed up and go with the flow.
If someone drives very slow, there's probably a reason why they are going so slow. It could be:
- they are distracted
- they are tired
- they are lost and don't know where to go
- they are intoxicated
- they don't see well at night or because of glare
- they are inexperienced
I don't think telling these people to go faster is going to make anyone safer.
An inability to read an argument without imputing your biases onto the person making it makes what you say a bit useless.
What reasons other than speed are there for keeping bicycles off fast roads? Motorcycle can be very nearly just as small and vulnerable as bicycles, but they can keep pace with cars and consequently they're allowed on every road.
Same reasons why you cannot drive small motorcycles on highways here in Italy, even if they can easily reach 110km/h they are not allowed on even second tier highways.
Maybe it's different in Italy, but in America the restrictions on bicycles really seem to be about top speed, not acceleration.
Overall the reasons why you cannot drive bicycles on highways are many, but when you put them all together it mostly fall under one term: safety.
What I wanted to say on my original comment is that trying to put an autonomous driving car in a urban situation is not about checking the speed limit from a road sign, looking at a ground stop or other road signals. If you want a safe autonomous car in an urban center it must be aware of the context much more than “this is a stop sign” or “speed limit is 50km/h”, that’s why I praise Mercedes for trying to solve the solvable problems first and then move to more complex ones.
My only source on this is a drivers training handbook.
In the UK you’ll fail you driving test if you drive below the speed limit, eg 60mph in a 70mph zone.
Hard to find an authoritative source, but this seems to break it down pretty well: https://www.drivejohnsons.co.uk/learning-centre/faq/driving-...
'Appropriate speed' is definitely a potential minor (or major) error on your driving test (and you are marked as failing for either a single major or three or more minors in the same category).
Generally, it's up to the examiner's discretion whether speed is 'appropriate', but often lenience will not be more than 10% of the speed limit (unless there are other factors, such as weather, road surface, visibility, etc. which would make it unsafe to travel at the posted speed limit).
That being said, driving laws, as far as I know, always say that you need to adapt your speed to the local conditions in order to drive safely, but you can never exceed the speed limit. Many (most?) jurisdictions have laws against dangerous and reckless driving and I expect it is possible to be found to be driving dangerously even when staying under the speed limit.
Where there is a minimum speed, which is also of course conditioned to current road conditions, it is also for safety. For instance, on a motorway where the traffic moves at 70mph it is dangerous for everyone if a vehicle decides to move at 30mph...
Ignoring everything that is happening around you, even if you are under the speed limit, is an incredibly unsafe way to drive.
Sounds incredible until you witness it yourself.
I'd say that most cars drive at around 130-140 km/h in the center lane, and 170 km/h isn't unusual. This requires people to keep the left lane free, something I yet have to witness in North America.
But beyond that, the Autobahn is really boring to drive on. It's just like any other highway: almost straight, and completely isolated from the world around it.
Different traffic laws. In Germany, there's only a lower limit on the Autobahn, and there's an advisory speed limit that in precedent cases you must be able to maintain if your vehicle and road (and weather) conditions permit but in practice is somewhat overrun, which is legal.
Most states in the US penalize overspeeding, but also penalizes underspeeding on state and interstate highways if car, road and weather conditions otherwise permit. While counterintuitive, in highways (especially interstate ones) there's an expectation of a "belt" of vehicles that maintain more-or-less the same speed: different speeds of vehicles should be on different lanes (the innermost being the fastest lane otherwise posted in signage).
Many of our highways are posted at 55 mph or 65 mph. Car traffic is typically 70-80 mph on those highways.
People are driving contextually, it's the limits that are not keeping up.
They're not blindly targeting the "speed limit" and throwing all caution to the wind.
(of course, they're ALSO often throwing all caution to the wind, but that's another story).
That could be by design, or the factory fitted alloys having a different circumference to the factory steel wheels.
I peg my cruise control at 76.5 and overtake all day long because other road users are oblivious to their actual speed.
What? Where is the legislation that says that?
Some roads (at least here in Italy) also have a minimum speed requirement when there is no traffic, which goes higher the more you go to the left lanes, but that’s another story.
Anyway I think that reading speed limits from road signs is quite stupid and frankly useless, most of the time the speed you need to be driving is contextual and the same applies to a lot of other dynamics of driving.
Well done Mercedes, one step at a time raising the bar once you manage to do “simple” things right.