Some subsequent research affirms this curve, others call it into question. My own, informal read is that the stronger research generally affirms it.
Reducing the rate of harmless crashes is no good if the rate of severe crashes increases.
Also, all crashes are relevant. Fatalities can’t happen when there aren’t crashes.
The speeding crisis is mostly a moral panic.
"Would this person have died if the cars were driving slower?"
And simple physics tells us that almost always the answer is "No".
If you try to argue that driving faster is safer, you need to provide strong evidence. Statistical correlation over a time frame where cars and roads have been made much safer doesn't really convince me. Even a correlation between driver speed and collision risk is meaningless -- eg. people with poor vision generally drive slower, but are still more dangerous than drivers with good vision.
(I'm not saying that driving fast is unsafe in general. On a well maintained road with good visibility you can drive pretty fast with minimal risk. All I'm saying is that, all other things being equal, driving slower is almost always going to be safer)
It is not simply the case that anti-speed crusades result in safer roads. The USA’s 55 mph experiment a was a failure in that regard, and Vision Zero campaigns aren’t delivering on promises.
We really need to focus on crash elimination, which is not a hyper focus on speed. Crashes that don’t happen can’t injure or kill.
But I really doubt that slow drivers are inherently dangerous. Especially since a lot of road users are slow and can't drive fast (big trucks, tractors, mopeds, bicycles, RVs, cars with trailers, etc). So the focus must be on making sure that drivers are attentive and have good visibility, not telling slow drivers to step on the gas.
Sometimes, the right thing is for slow drivers to speed up and go with the flow.
If someone drives very slow, there's probably a reason why they are going so slow. It could be:
- they are distracted
- they are tired
- they are lost and don't know where to go
- they are intoxicated
- they don't see well at night or because of glare
- they are inexperienced
I don't think telling these people to go faster is going to make anyone safer.
An inability to read an argument without imputing your biases onto the person making it makes what you say a bit useless.
But I seriously doubt that driving below the speed limit has a measurable increase in risk.
I would bet the opposite: That driving below the speed limit decreases risk of serious accidents.
One reason for that is that rear end accidents where both cars are going in the same direction are typically much less serious than head on collisions. So even if slow drivers increase the risk of rear end accidents (which I doubt is significant), they reduce the impact of head on collisions much more leading to a net positive.
People should drive slower, it's always safer. (Apart from dumb maneuvers like brake checking...)